That's why their vocals stand out so much! The lack of unanimity in their voices is what makes them shine. Every single one of them has a special charm, while Seulgi, Joy and Wendy cover the high notes, Irene and Yeri put a lot of effort on the lower register. Their harmonization always sounds so good because it's a mix of very different colors. It's similar to what happens with Little Mix, for example
Damn Wendy! Do not hurt 'em!! She slayed this from Korea to Japan to America to The Phiilippines and back to Korea! LOL! She's definitely the main vocal! WOW!
I would usually agree about it being angelic, but the devil came out and slapped every damn angel in this performance! Wendy SNAPPED! Give her 50 to life because she killed them all!!
still can't believe they can sing shit like this live, i wasn't as into k-pop as i am now because of them, but the sole reason for that is because i was legitimately shook when i listened to their live vocals. there are many talented idols in the industry, but very few can pull off the kinds of songs Red Velvet sings. they're on a different tier vocally. so much respect.
웬디라는 친구의 존재가 그룹 전체의 퀄리티를 끌어올려준다. 웬디가 없었으면, 굳이 완벽한 노래를 위해 sm이 집착에 가까운 고난이도 프로듀싱을 하지도 않았을꺼고, 어려운 노래를 멋지게 소화하는 웬디가 없었다면 나머지 멤버가 음악을 대하는 태도를 이렇게 진지하고 프로답게 가져오지 못했을거다. 웬디의 하이라이트 끝나고 코러스 부르는 표정봐라. 눈빛에서 이미 가수로서의 이 노래를 완벽하게 끝내겠다는 사명감이 느껴진다.
OMG They are so amazing! This sounds just as good as the official version! They look so comfortable like they are really enjoying themselves, and every member got to shine. They aren't my favorite group, but they are definitely one of the most talented groups ever, and definitely the most talented of the new generation in my opinion. They 100% deserve all their success and I hope they will be legends one day like SNSD. This also happens to be my favorite song at the moment, and all Reveluvs (and people in general) who have not heard this song yet are missing out big time!!! Red Velvet Hwaiting!!!!
Can't believe this song was too early in their discography... This song is one of the most difficult to pull off... And our girls just did it in style....hats off to them...
1:40 that small failure in seulgi's part was the only proof that this live asf. They sound exactly the same in the studio version. Wtf. I really stand the best vocal queens...
and there’s also no way this was edited, they sang this while the camera was rolling, they were live, and i doubt it’s possible to add autotune in a live performance.
No but this song is a solid title track material and it's so much better than most of the title tracks from the other groups 😭 Red Velvet always does that tho. They should be known and appreciated more in worldwide.
omg, why haven't I discovered Wendy earlier? I LOOVE HER SOO MUCH AS A NEW FAN/ LUVIE. So ready for OT5 comeback. me and my bestie's are saving already 😅 gotta have that latest rv album 😉 red velvet fighting!
One of my favourite songs of RV😊 I wish they do more songs like this! They have many great songs! Don’t consider myself a fan but I adore RV entire discography and Wendy voice gave me goosebumps
wendy really loves singing and is clearly seen in this video how much she enjoys doing it and the rest of the girls 💗 OT5 FOREVER, not leaving one member out !!!
It’s been years since they debuted and I still can’t pick a bias omg Joy is too perfect to be real Irene is too beautiful for this world Seulgi is literally goals Wendy’s voice melts me everytime i hear it And Yeri’s bubbly personality is too much for this world, someone protect her pls 😭😂 EDIT : IT'S BEEN BASICALLY A MONTH (or more) SINCE I POSTED THIS COMMENT AND I STILL HAVEN'T PICKED A BIAS...but then i thought "why should you pick just one bias if you can pick all of them?" lol
웬디 진짜......sm은 메인 보컬을 진짜 제대로 된 사람 데리고 온다
진짜 목소리합은 원탑이다 몇년이지나도 이정도로 목소리합좋은 그룹 안나올듯
그니까요 이렇게 예쁜 느낌 진ㅁ자....
ㄹㅇ 뭔가 결이비슷한거같네
진짜 나만 레드벨벳 수록곡중에 이게 제일좋은것같냐
훈이죄 진짜 개좋아요 ㅠㅠ
저도요! 이거랑 쿨월드 썸카크가 젤 ㅠㅠ
그냥 ㄹㅇ 다좋음 고를수가없음
@우짤래미 ㄹㅇ 가사 너무이뻐요ㅠㅠ 시인이 오보이 가사 작사해줬다 하더라구요
이거랑 봐 투톱
이노래는 타이틀급 노래 레베럽들만 듣기 아까운 수록곡 역시 레드벨벳 가창력 최고
웬디진짜예술이다.. 노래부를때 표정이랑 액션이 너무 멋있음 ㅠㅜ몇년전에 첨보고 주기적으로 보러옴
너무 공감
와.....손승완 그냥 보컬 그냥 날아다니는데.....미쳤다
1:17 조이목소리 진짜 보물이다 보물... 어쩜 저리 청아할까... ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 인스턴트 한번도 안먹어본 목소리같아... 진짜 옥구슬같음... 인어공주가 말하게 된다면 저런 목소리일거같음
인정.. 아이돌 하는 사람은 정해져있나봐요 .......
Wendy! That powerful voice and how much she feels the moment. I can't handle it sometimes.
2:13 여기부터 웬디 성대 컨트롤 스킬 레전드
The way Wendy drags those notes wow
Yep this is cool
it's amazing that their ranges are not all similar as well as their timbres but their harmonization is still on point
jisoo's lost rice cooker never thought I'd be hearing/seeing word 'timbre' 😂😂
That's why their vocals stand out so much! The lack of unanimity in their voices is what makes them shine. Every single one of them has a special charm, while Seulgi, Joy and Wendy cover the high notes, Irene and Yeri put a lot of effort on the lower register. Their harmonization always sounds so good because it's a mix of very different colors. It's similar to what happens with Little Mix, for example
@@kaatsu1264 OMGGG YAAAS THAT'S WHY I STAN RED VELVET, BECAUSE I GOT A VIBES OF HARMONIZATION JUST LIKE LITTLE MIX.
내생각이지만 레드벨벳은 보컬그룹쪽임 대중들의 생각보다 훨씬더 보컬적으로 탄탄하고 그걸 바탕으로 굉장히 견고한 디스코그래피를 쌓아왔음
Wendy is so powerful, emotional, and got perfect technique
일주일에 한번씩. 마음 지칠때마다 들으러옴. 기부니가 확 좋아짐ㅠㅠㅠ 이곡 명곡ㅠㅠㅠ
요즘도 들으시나용?
요즘도?
이노래 진짜 안질림....ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 레드벨벳은 진짜 다들 목소리 넘 예뻐 레벨도 그냥 앉아서 노래하는 방송도 많이 했었으면 하는게 항상 아쉬움...사람들이 좀 알았으면 좋겠음 다들 잘하는데
진짜...웬디 라이브 개쩔어 언니 이거 욕이 아니라 진짜 미치셨어요...? 진짜 어디계세요 그쪽 방향으로 절하겠습니다 언니 사랑해 나 칠순이야
Wendy, Seulgi e Joy are so fantastic, their voices is perfect
I agree, but Wendy's on another atmosphere in this performance!!
웬디가 미쳐날뛰었다는..전설의 레전드
ㅌㅋㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ완디보고싶어 ㅠㅠ
@@김상조-i5c 오늘 돌아왔잖아요!!!!너무 좋고
@@Gqurjsnhd 미띤 당근 봤죠 전 이제 성불합니다
@@김상조-i5c ㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋㅎ죽어도 여한이 없어욬ㅎㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋㅎ
전설의 라이브
진짜 웬만한걸그룹노래중에 oh boy보다 음역대높은 곡들 얼마없을듯
음역대가 이렇게 높은데 all파트가 존재,,,, 레드벨벳은 진짜 보컬그룹인 거 같아요
트와이스 more & more 있어요~
@@TheKim5975 oh boy가 테크닉도 그렇고 더 높아요 그리고 그곡은 딱히 가창력을 요구하지도않고 가장 중요한건 그 그룹이 그노래 라이브를 못하잖아요...
Giannis Antetokounmpo 그 분들은 소화를 못 하시는데
넝넝넝넝 트와이스 무시하나요? 얼마나성장햇는데
요즘 걸그룹들 앉아서도 립싱크하는거 보면 데뷔초부터 이렇게 퀄리티 좋게 노래한 레벨이 얼마나 대단한지 알수 있음…
웬디 라이브 오지네..;;
여돌 수록곡중 단연 탑임
2:14 woah Wendy's vocal is not joke, I got goosebumps lol
슬기랑 웬디는 라이브 넘사벽‥
oh boy는 웬디파트가 너무기다려진다
저 파워풀한 보컬!
다시는 없을 완벽한 그룹이자 완벽한 곡이다 레벨말고 이 곡을 이렇게나 완벽하게 표현할 수 있는 그룹이 있을까? 진짜 존나 자랑스럽다
레드벨벳 수록곡중에 젤 좋아하는 노래 가사도 존예고 멜로디도 신비롭고 이노래 듣고있으면 뭔가 환상속의 판타지세계에 있는것같음 그리고 노래분위가 레드벨벳하고 ㄹㅇ 찰떡임
Damn Wendy! Do not hurt 'em!! She slayed this from Korea to Japan to America to The Phiilippines and back to Korea! LOL!
She's definitely the main vocal! WOW!
Eyebrowstj - Multifandom4Life ikr 😂😂
what's with the places? did she sang it on those countries? hehe i cannot relate
@@maikom8693 it’s just an exaggeration to express how good Wendy is lol.
@@wendy9481 oh, xd i didnt get it at first. thanks lol 🤣
웬디 스킬 진짜 장난아니다..ㄷㄷ 고음 안정적으로 뽑아내는거 어쩔겨
omygod wendy's voice is angelic!
I would usually agree about it being angelic, but the devil came out and slapped every damn angel in this performance! Wendy SNAPPED! Give her 50 to life because she killed them all!!
Wendy is enjoying so much as if she is holding no bar like she's I am gonna blow you away.
아니 진짜 손웬디♡ 표정봐 노래 진짜 대박♡ 수록중에 최애♡
다 잘하는데 웬디 진짜 소름돋게 잘한다 짜릿하다
wendy and seulgi omg i love them
which one are they? i'm a new fan i'm struggling to know which one is who
still can't believe they can sing shit like this live, i wasn't as into k-pop as i am now because of them, but the sole reason for that is because i was legitimately shook when i listened to their live vocals. there are many talented idols in the industry, but very few can pull off the kinds of songs Red Velvet sings. they're on a different tier vocally. so much respect.
Im here for Red Velvet. But somehow, i can't handle Wendy. That is the power of main vocal.
#ForeverWendy
이 노래 처음 들었을때 진짜 귀가 축복받은 느낌이었음 덤덤때 입덕해서 아직까지 레드벨벳 팬인데 여전히 수록곡 넘버원임 특히 웬디 고음과 멤버들 화음이 진짜 환상적임 귀가 녹아내리는거같음ㅜㅜ💖💜💚💙💛
웬디라는 친구의 존재가 그룹 전체의 퀄리티를 끌어올려준다. 웬디가 없었으면, 굳이 완벽한 노래를 위해 sm이 집착에 가까운 고난이도 프로듀싱을 하지도 않았을꺼고, 어려운 노래를 멋지게 소화하는 웬디가 없었다면 나머지 멤버가 음악을 대하는 태도를 이렇게 진지하고 프로답게 가져오지 못했을거다. 웬디의 하이라이트 끝나고 코러스 부르는 표정봐라. 눈빛에서 이미 가수로서의 이 노래를 완벽하게 끝내겠다는 사명감이 느껴진다.
맞아요 웬디 능력자에요ㅎㅎ👍
👏👏👏👏
멋진 코멘트
说得太好了❤
개인적으로 레드벨벳 수록곡 중에서 가장 좋음..처음 들었을 때 거부감도 안들고 ost 느낌도 들어서 너무 좋아ㅠㅠㅠ
ㅠㅠㅠ난 웬디 oh boy 부를 때가 제일 좋음ㅠㅠ♥
손승완 그녀는 꾀꼬리인가천사인가
전설의 오보이완 사랑함다
둘 다 하는 걸로 하죠 ㅎ ......
OMG They are so amazing! This sounds just as good as the official version! They look so comfortable like they are really enjoying themselves, and every member got to shine. They aren't my favorite group, but they are definitely one of the most talented groups ever, and definitely the most talented of the new generation in my opinion. They 100% deserve all their success and I hope they will be legends one day like SNSD. This also happens to be my favorite song at the moment, and all Reveluvs (and people in general) who have not heard this song yet are missing out big time!!! Red Velvet Hwaiting!!!!
Can't believe this song was too early in their discography... This song is one of the most difficult to pull off... And our girls just did it in style....hats off to them...
Wendy's voice is GOLD!!!
멤버들 눈 마주치고 화음 쌓는거 넘 좋아ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 그리고 오보이완은 언제나... 놀라게 한다💙
Wendy is so powerful oh my 💙
이때 데뷔한지 얼마 안됐을때 아닌가 이렇게 잘했는데 지금 부르면 더 잘하겠네 다시 라이브 해줬으면... 너무 좋아
와씨 조이 음색어쩔꺼임... 미쳐버려 ㅠㅠ
I literally think every RV fan should watch this! What a performance! Big applause for Wendy!
Hope Irene can sing more. She has a sweet voice.
I love how Wendy love singing
at that time red velvet was only 1 year rookie... wendy is truly THEE main vocalist
웬디 왤케 신났어ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 귀여워ㅜ흑흑 아니 근데 이 노래는 진짜 조이 목소리가 보물이다 진짜 조이 목소리... 슬기 웬디 가창력
또 들어도 이 가슴 벅차오름은 어쩔 수가 없구나....진짜 우리 레벨 너네가 최고야 정말....
smol bean is feeling the song too much 😭 i love you tiny wendy 😭
1:40 that small failure in seulgi's part was the only proof that this live asf.
They sound exactly the same in the studio version. Wtf.
I really stand the best vocal queens...
and there’s also no way this was edited, they sang this while the camera was rolling, they were live, and i doubt it’s possible to add autotune in a live performance.
wendy voice is really amazing❤❤
웬디 그루브 타는 거 리얼 힙합이다 보컬은 알앤비고
승완이 빵긋빵긋 웃으면서 고음 갈기는 게 진짜 ㅜㅜ
I just love how much wendy is feeling herself when she sings❤️❤️❤️ such excitement in her eyes
almost 2 years after and yet i'm still smitten to wendy's voice
Maria Frances Quito
Same.
It's been 4 years now and I still am amazed by Wendy's Vocals!
Still in 2020
Now, i want to hear Wendy sing the whole The Red album alone. I think she can nail it
개개인으로는 몰라도 목소리합은 케이팝 보컬원탑이다… 향수 지리네
Their voices and harmonies?! Like hello?! Why are they not the most popular group in the world?!
People these day just like to girl crush concept maybe
I love my girls!!!! Aaaaahhh..
Vocal legends only.
PS. WENDY. THAT'S ALL I CAN SAY. WENDY. JUST WOW
blackvelvet
Wendy has a way of leaving one speechless when she opens her mouth!
wendy's voice is no joke
와 레드벨벳 라이브 장난없다..
Wendy slayed all of things in earth, and my underpants...... by this song.
HAHAHAHAA
Wendy snapped!
Katrina Stevenson
She snapped, went insane, and committed a crime! Give her a life sentence for killing me with her voice!
2:12 and 2:37. wendy did THAT while sitting. wig found in mars.
LMAO
코러스 화음 진짜 하나도 안 빼놓고 다 완벽하게 해버리네 ㅠㅠ
Sooyoung's voice is so pure!
웬디 이때 접신함? 개잘부르네
No but this song is a solid title track material and it's so much better than most of the title tracks from the other groups 😭 Red Velvet always does that tho. They should be known and appreciated more in worldwide.
가사도 이쁘고 노래도 좋고 음색도 넘 좋은 개띵곡 ㅠㅠㅠ
승완이도 승완이지만 진짜 우리 현,슬기,완,수영,림 5명 목소리 합이 그냥 기적같애 막 벅차올라
And that’s why Wendy is my bias LMAO
I love Joy's "Oh boy~"
And Wendy @ 2:13..Gosh that voice 😍💙
omg, why haven't I discovered Wendy earlier? I LOOVE HER SOO MUCH AS A NEW FAN/ LUVIE. So ready for OT5 comeback. me and my bestie's are saving already 😅 gotta have that latest rv album 😉 red velvet fighting!
joy voice are killing me 🔥🔥🔥 joy voice not are joke , beautiful voice 💚💚💚❤️
웬디 진짜 잘한다 ㄷㄷ
진짜 레전드 명곡이다… 가사 너무 좋아
가사 진짜 ㅇㅈ
when wendy starts singing 2:14 i was just shookt huhu😭 her voice❤️ love that part so much.
One of my favourite songs of RV😊 I wish they do more songs like this! They have many great songs! Don’t consider myself a fan but I adore RV entire discography and Wendy voice gave me goosebumps
와 이 노래 왜 이제 알았지....... 개좋다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ라이브 개짱 ㅠㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅠㅠ
oh boy, i can't get this song out of my head!
기억 안 나는 몇 년 전에 내게 이런 감정이 찾아 온 적 있던 것같다 노래 진짜 잘하고 가사도 너무 좋다
Wendy's is an excellent vocalist..
Wendy ahh 💙
이때 웬디 창법 너무 그립다… 지금은 힘을 좀 빼면서 부르는? 그리고 알앤비를 좋아해서 그런가 알앤비 창법에 가까워진 느낌임 ㅜㅜ
저 창법이 웬디 목에 무리가 가는 창법이여서 바꿨대요ㅎㅠ
레드벨벳 보컬라인 칭찬해
wendy really loves singing and is clearly seen in this video how much she enjoys doing it and the rest of the girls 💗 OT5 FOREVER, not leaving one member out !!!
웬디 언냐,,, 라이브 오졌고요,,,
Vocals and harmonies on point 😍
It's 2021 and I bet if Wendy sing this solo, she might've change the oh boy to Oh Girl.
Oh Girl come and light me up 🙊
Desember 2020, come here because I miss red velvet so much :')) ♥️
아니 승완이 보컬 미쳤냐구ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ♥♥
웬디 매력쩔. 물건이여
내 기준 이쁜 가사 투 탑
이거랑 샤이니 뷰 ㅠㅠ
It’s been years since they debuted and I still can’t pick a bias omg
Joy is too perfect to be real
Irene is too beautiful for this world
Seulgi is literally goals
Wendy’s voice melts me everytime i hear it
And Yeri’s bubbly personality is too much for this world, someone protect her pls
😭😂
EDIT : IT'S BEEN BASICALLY A MONTH (or more) SINCE I POSTED THIS COMMENT AND I STILL HAVEN'T PICKED A BIAS...but then i thought "why should you pick just one bias if you can pick all of them?" lol
The struggle's not the same for me! It's WENDY all the way!! Seulgi is my bias wrecker, but I do love them all!!!
There's no such thing as bias in red velvet. Maybe there is actually. All of them are my biases.
Ikr! Barely 6 months in red velvet and my bias has already changed thrice 😂😂
Just randomly pick one and let the other 4 bias wreck you. Hahahaha
@Lipstick Chateau Wine Color welcome to another episode of "nobody says that"