She should have won!!!! I am old enough to be her grandmother and I believe she was the most talented person in this competition. Kellie is always in my prayers.
She has since become the biggest star of the 6 people with her music,tv show & talk show. Daughtry has sold more records but she is loved by more people. She has been a guest on much more shows. Won DWTS Kathrine has had a good career in acting tv series with two hit shows. Kellie is a very special type of person.
It worked out perfectly. Kellie is definitely a star, but Daughtry is really admired and respected for his music. They are both beautiful authentic people who have heart. :)
@@phsycosloan She said something here that still remains the same. She has not changed but has learned a lot. She is still the same sweet girl she was but only now a real sweet woman & to me the most genuine person in show business.
This was the season of Idol when I started thinking this show was fixed~~How that guy won will always be a mystery~~I can't believe what the judges said to Katherine~~She was awesome and I think I actually cried~~There's still a part of me that these singing shows are somewhat fixed~~When Kelly Clarkson won first season I knew every week who was going and I knew Kelly was gonna win~~Best Idol contestant and winner on any other singing show~~Kelly Clarkson 4 ever~~She'll always be my Idol~~
The show is still fixed there have been a number of great singers over looked just because they would not bow down to producers. When Simon left the show nosed dived
I seen her live when she opened for Rascal Flats in Hershey Pa in around 2010. She is a very nice person. We had vip tickets and met them all backstage.
She might have not been crowned American Idol, but she is more successful than the winner, in my opinion. When it comes down to the last 6 or 12, it's just a popularity contest, I like all kinds of music and don't like pigeon holing anyone, because they all are talented and got a boost from being on American Idol. You should be happy for her, because that girl can sing.
I love Kellie! Season 5 has always been my favorite for some reason. I must add that I don’t remember Lisa Tucker being on the OC. This is cheesy, but my husband and I own all four seasons, and when Ryan Seacrest said that I pulled up google and she plays “as herself” on an episode I remember very well, “The Party Favor” (where they play that American Girls song over and over and it’s prom), but we don’t remember her. I’ll have to go back and watch it. 😝☺️
While she was not the best contestant that season in terms of pure vocal talent, she was certainly a great singer and had the great looks and likable personality to make up for it. She was definitely the best of the bunch as far as having the whole package, and that’s why she continues to do so well!!
First time seeing this part. I don't no a damn one of them but Kelly. Love Kelly. She should have won it all. She is the one that was a star and made a name for herself. And made it big. But others have no clue who they are or if they even doing anything. I watch her on Dancing with the stars and I watch it again a lot......Kelly and Kyle u look so so happy. Hope one day they have a show of only Champions of past shows of dancing with the stars and your in it.. called Champions of the stars and you win it and Kyle sing..God bless you both.
I didn't want Kellie Pickler to go but I had a feeling that she wasn't going to win, love her personality and her voice and she had some success in country music, and I wanted to meet her in person and I got to meet her after the show at a private concert, definitely a great moment for me, love Kellie Pickler regardless!
By far the best in her season. Loving her. Wish I knew she had her own show with her husband. Called I love Kellie Pickler. Now I'm trying to find it. It was on CMT
The week before this i swear i saved Kellie from elimination by staying up for hours voting for her, this week i fell asleep early and only got a few votes in. I know its silly now but i was so mad at myself back then
Catherine McPhee and Kellie Pickler should've been the top two that season, they were the best. Both have still done well in the entertainment industry. Both are still loved and have had TV shows. Daughtry who?
Never could understand the judges remarks to Katharine McPhee. She has a gorgeous voice. Just heard her with great opera singer (sorry-can't think of his name at the moment) Pachelle---? Something like that.
In case you all don't know, despite her being eliminated, Kellie Pickler managed to win Dancing with the Stars, which means she avenged her opponent unfair Idol defeat.
Being a dad has really changed Simon for the better. I remember the "asshole" Simon as seen here...and fast forward to after the birth of his son Eric...day and night !!!!!
Kellie Pickler has become a much bogger star than Taylor Hicks, the winner that season. Has Taylor Hicks ever had a hit? I read once the judges were agaibst Kellie because they thought she was too similar to Carrie Underwood.
I get the comparison but fr tho how in the world she needed to change herself just to be so called original when to achieve an originality itself is not an easy thing to figure? 😪
Yeah, TAYLOR HICKS winning pretty much wounded the show so it was never the same after that, although the original judges leaving was what killed it mostly. T.H. was just a 'good ole southern boy charming the gals in the south'.
I remember Kelly from this season and she came in 6th?....what was that gray haired guys name....the one who won? Crazy right?. This whole thing still feels like some popularity contest instead of choosing the best voice for the job.
It has always been that way in any singing competitions but some winners got the whole packages for instance Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. You can be like one of the worst contestants but if you're popular and like among the popular throughout the whole competition, you'll probably stay till the end and snatch the top prize 😕
I'm beginning to think that winning idol is a curse, the ones that should've won it are successful artist, there's a number of them and Kelly is one of the many. They all are AI people towards the end before they pick the winner, it's all a popularity contest towards the end. This season they were all very special and loveable, in my opinion.
carrie underwood is also successful. and in most seasons the winner is the most successful from that season like season 6 jordin sparks is most successful from her season, season 7 David cook is most successful, season 10 scotty mccrerry is most successful, and in season 11 Phillip Phillips is most succesful.
Back then the contestants dressed like they would normally, the jeans etc. Which I love! But now they're all crazy with outfits & makeovers to where it's ridiculous.
I think my man Taylor rolled his eyes a little bit when he realized hat he didn’t get the highest vote, Crazy because he was never in the bottom two or three!
Watching this in 2019. So i know who wins and also the two that went on to have bigger careers than the winner. Guess judges dont know everything do they? LMAO
I rewatched season 5 and I realized.. Yea Kellie was too weak compared to the top 5. She shouldve been in the bottom a few times but ends up safe and her last song was pitchy.. But good for her for going far in the industry. But no, Idol did not make a mistake. it is what it is.
Brianna Blakey holy shoot, that has to be her. I love OTH! I saw your comment at first, but scrolled past it. Then, I came back and was shocked to see that she was Taylor’s friend. I expected her to be a friend of Katherine or Kellie.
Why not? There is a lot more to this than just the voice. If that were the case, then Katherine McPhee or Clay Aiken would be billionaires, and Michael Jackson would have been a blip on the radar, like Donny Osmond. Great art moves the audience and great artists do. That's why Kellie with her admittedly good, but not great singing became a star. Bob Dylan would not have gotten to round one of this show. Carol King MIGHT have made it this far.
She done much better than winning idol..she became americas country sweetheart!! She is infectious..i just luv her..
She still went on to greatness!:)
She should have won!!!! I am old enough to be her grandmother and I believe she was the most talented person in this competition. Kellie is always in my prayers.
-so heartbreaking to hear-
-of her husbands suicide-
Kellie Pickler still avenged her defeat by winning Dancing with the Stars in 2013.
Go Kellie! Proving them all wrong.
She has since become the biggest star of the 6 people with her music,tv show & talk show. Daughtry has sold more records but she is loved by more people. She has been a guest on much more shows. Won DWTS Kathrine has had a good career in acting tv series with two hit shows. Kellie is a very special type of person.
It worked out perfectly. Kellie is definitely a star, but Daughtry is really admired and respected for his music. They are both beautiful authentic people who have heart. :)
@@phsycosloan She said something here that still remains the same. She has not changed but has learned a lot. She is still the same sweet girl she was but only now a real sweet woman & to me the most genuine person in show business.
With Idol, everyone is a winner.
She is very nice and "down to earth". Yes, she did very well after AI, now she even has her own show "Picker and Ben" on Fox every day.
They did her a favor. No American Idol contract.
YASSS THAT'S THE SILVER LINING HERE
Soooo true!
Yes, Nashville wisely signed her.
This was the season of Idol when I started thinking this show was fixed~~How that guy won will always be a mystery~~I can't believe what the judges said to Katherine~~She was awesome and I think I actually cried~~There's still a part of me that these singing shows are somewhat fixed~~When Kelly Clarkson won first season I knew every week who was going and I knew Kelly was gonna win~~Best Idol contestant and winner on any other singing show~~Kelly Clarkson 4 ever~~She'll always be my Idol~~
The show is still fixed there have been a number of great singers over looked just because they would not bow down to producers. When Simon left the show nosed dived
I seen her live when she opened for Rascal Flats in Hershey Pa in around 2010. She is a very nice person. We had vip tickets and met them all backstage.
I cried when she lost I loved her as a little girl
She might have not been crowned American Idol, but she is more successful than the winner, in my opinion. When it comes down to the last 6 or 12, it's just a popularity contest, I like all kinds of music and don't like pigeon holing anyone, because they all are talented and got a boost from being on American Idol. You should be happy for her, because that girl can sing.
She has the best personality! Idk why taylor was voted for his personality but not Kellie plus Kellie has a better voice too
Kelly you got the last laugh!!!
♤picker
Cajunmexican Luna Kellie
kELLY STILL GOT A singing career with number one hits and now has a TV show called Pickler & Ben...not bad for a "reject" by Idol.
I agree, she reminds me of a younger Dolly Parton with her magnetic personality, it would be cute if she had a Picklerworld.
I remember watching this live and I was literally devastated she got sent home.
Love Kelly never a available bad song and the girl is so down to earth
I love this girl so much. Best personality ever...
Boy did the country get THAT ONE wrong!!
She is a nice person. I love you Kellie. ❤❤🎶🎤
Keep going Kellie! Look for the silver linings!
This was the BEST thing that could happen to Kelly NOT being under Simons label.
American Idol truly became they biggest step into the industry. Even if they got eliminate.
I love Kellie! Season 5 has always been my favorite for some reason. I must add that I don’t remember Lisa Tucker being on the OC. This is cheesy, but my husband and I own all four seasons, and when Ryan Seacrest said that I pulled up google and she plays “as herself” on an episode I remember very well, “The Party Favor” (where they play that American Girls song over and over and it’s prom), but we don’t remember her. I’ll have to go back and watch it. 😝☺️
Same I can't remember her.. only her name but I don't recall what season she was included. I need to use google
While she was not the best contestant that season in terms of pure vocal talent, she was certainly a great singer and had the great looks and likable personality to make up for it. She was definitely the best of the bunch as far as having the whole package, and that’s why she continues to do so well!!
First time seeing this part. I don't no a damn one of them but Kelly. Love Kelly. She should have won it all. She is the one that was a star and made a name for herself. And made it big. But others have no clue who they are or if they even doing anything. I watch her on Dancing with the stars and I watch it again a lot......Kelly and Kyle u look so so happy. Hope one day they have a show of only Champions of past shows of dancing with the stars and your in it.. called Champions of the stars and you win it and Kyle sing..God bless you both.
Lol the other contestants started tearing up.
I didn't want Kellie Pickler to go but I had a feeling that she wasn't going to win, love her personality and her voice and she had some success in country music, and I wanted to meet her in person and I got to meet her after the show at a private concert, definitely a great moment for me, love Kellie Pickler regardless!
That’s so awesome. I had such a crush on her when she was on the show when I was 10. Would be a dream to meet her.
By far the best in her season. Loving her. Wish I knew she had her own show with her husband. Called I love Kellie Pickler. Now I'm trying to find it. It was on CMT
I love you kellie pickler and whose laughing now. . . .
The week before this i swear i saved Kellie from elimination by staying up for hours voting for her, this week i fell asleep early and only got a few votes in. I know its silly now but i was so mad at myself back then
You are great love to hear you sing and so dam cute love the country in you stay your self love you Kelly your fans love you ..
Kellie was awesome. Crazy that Chris and Katherine were in the bottom two two weeks later.
All six were awesome!
I love her so much! She’s a sweetheart!
How freaking rude we’re these judges my god these are people ... Good and talented people. Kelley has gotten the last laugh.
Catherine McPhee and Kellie Pickler should've been the top two that season, they were the best. Both have still done well in the entertainment industry. Both are still loved and have had TV shows. Daughtry who?
Kellie, Katherine and Daughtry went on to better things for sure. I think Taylor is a lounge singer now LOL
They got it wrong but she is a winner all the way.
Never could understand the judges remarks to Katharine McPhee. She has a gorgeous voice. Just heard her with great opera singer (sorry-can't think of his name at the moment) Pachelle---? Something like that.
Screw Paula Kellie is the bomb u should have won it all
Was it strange he called everyone but Pickler by their first name when he lined them up. I loved Kelly the best. It was all fixed
They all dug her name and thought it was funny, so they kept using it. They should have called Taylor 'HICK's, though.
Kellie is making more money than any of them I’d guess.I did one show with her and she’s AMAZING.👍🎙🎙🎙
Chris Doughtry was in this group?? That guy is huge now!
Why didn't she give a final performance?
She did sing though. But was not shown on tv.. They needed to cut..
Anyone else notice when showed Taylor's friend was actress who was on one tree hill who played character Quinn look at 6:05
I remember coming across that scene past year. Lol, Shantel Vansanten!
Funny that Katharine McPhee first met her future husband David Foster in this episode for the first time! haha
I know it's completely disgusting too
In case you all don't know, despite her being eliminated, Kellie Pickler managed to win Dancing with the Stars, which means she avenged her opponent unfair Idol defeat.
Being a dad has really changed Simon for the better. I remember the "asshole" Simon as seen here...and fast forward to after the birth of his son Eric...day and night !!!!!
So sad it cut off at the end before she got to sing for the last time. At least she was very successful
It’s crazy how Chris & Kat were the top 2 during the top 6 & neither of them won.
And Kat's husband was on this episode lol
That is crazy lol tho. Both were the bottom two in two weeks.
Kelly proved them all wrong.
She got eliminated here and the rest as they say was history! :-) Thank you for uploading my request @domeju. Love your vids as always! :-)
Kellie Pickler has become a much bogger star than Taylor Hicks, the winner that season. Has Taylor Hicks ever had a hit? I read once the judges were agaibst Kellie because they thought she was too similar to Carrie Underwood.
I get the comparison but fr tho how in the world she needed to change herself just to be so called original when to achieve an originality itself is not an easy thing to figure? 😪
Chris Daughtry, too!
Yeah, TAYLOR HICKS winning pretty much wounded the show so it was never the same after that, although the original judges leaving was what killed it mostly. T.H. was just a 'good ole southern boy charming the gals in the south'.
Simon Cowell has stated Kellie was one of his all-time favorite contestants.
Why did she have to get ugly breast implants?
Elliott was my favorite that season... Wow, many moons ago!
I know. He was my fav. I remember it like it was yesterday...
Taylor should have went home that night!!
As soon as Taylor found out he wasn't in the top 2 votes that week..he stopped smiling.
shwonsh he was very smart
Haha, facts!😂
What year was it? Poster should give proper info about their posts.
Katheryn is married to Foster now. Was this competition fair? Kelly should have won America Idol. All were great singers.
That was the best season ever!!!😎😍
I remember Kelly from this season and she came in 6th?....what was that gray haired guys name....the one who won?
Crazy right?. This whole thing still feels like some popularity contest instead of choosing the best voice for the job.
It has always been that way in any singing competitions but some winners got the whole packages for instance Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. You can be like one of the worst contestants but if you're popular and like among the popular throughout the whole competition, you'll probably stay till the end and snatch the top prize 😕
+firdaus mat *most
Taylor Hicks was the worst winner of Idol. He barely sold any albums. Daughtry, Kellie, Mandisa, even Bucky sold more and were more successful.
BPA1985 lol, I love Bucky. Phillip Phillips was the worst winner ever.
Gos to show you what the judges really know, she went on and sold more records then anyone of those people beside Chris d. she shot , still hot ,
I'm beginning to think that winning idol is a curse, the ones that should've won it are successful artist, there's a number of them and Kelly is one of the many. They all are AI people towards the end before they pick the winner, it's all a popularity contest towards the end. This season they were all very special and loveable, in my opinion.
carrie underwood is also successful. and in most seasons the winner is the most successful from that season like season 6 jordin sparks is most successful from her season, season 7 David cook is most successful, season 10 scotty mccrerry is most successful, and in season 11 Phillip Phillips is most succesful.
Back then the contestants dressed like they would normally, the jeans etc. Which I love! But now they're all crazy with outfits & makeovers to where it's ridiculous.
Angela Magic Salveson oh shoot, that’s true. I didn’t realize this, but I wish it was still like this.
I think my man Taylor rolled his eyes a little bit when he realized hat he didn’t get the highest vote, Crazy because he was never in the bottom two or three!
Watching this in 2019. So i know who wins and also the two that went on to have bigger careers than the winner. Guess judges dont know everything do they? LMAO
But look at her now ! go Kelly
To think that Katherine would end up getting engaged to the piano player guy (can never remember his name)
David Foster the writer of some of Whitney Houston's songs. ☺
I always liked Kellie , I stopped watching the show after she was eliminated.
Love Kellie.
This was the epi her closing song wasn't aired haha
6:58 Taylor is mad that they had the highest number of votes LOL 😅😅😅😅
I know you've got lots of requests, but could you upload Lisa Tucker's elimination if you get a chance?
someone had requested that already. I'll get it as soon as I can.
ua-cam.com/video/bAXeq_Udl5M/v-deo.html
Other than Daughtry on here, who is even heard of any of those other ones? Kelly did all right
Katherine and her future husband!
Katherine McPhee too.😉
**If Kelly could spend 6 months with Stevie Wonder it would be a miracle result!**
These two shouldn't have been in the bottom no way. 👎
elimination of Constantine? thank u
Kathrine ended up married to David foster 😂
Funny thing is, Katharine sang the song that was co-written by her now boyfriend. Hahahahaha
who did win this season??
Taylor Hicks. IE the clown. Its sad really.
I thought it was Daughty lol
Cristin Clark we all wish
I rewatched season 5 and I realized.. Yea Kellie was too weak compared to the top 5. She shouldve been in the bottom a few times but ends up safe and her last song was pitchy.. But good for her for going far in the industry. But no, Idol did not make a mistake. it is what it is.
Anyone know if that’s Shantel VanSanten in Taylor’s friend group?! @ 6:05
Brianna Blakey holy shoot, that has to be her. I love OTH! I saw your comment at first, but scrolled past it. Then, I came back and was shocked to see that she was Taylor’s friend. I expected her to be a friend of Katherine or Kellie.
It's no wonder no one likes Simon! He NEVER shuts up. 🙊
Ew where is Paris now?????? lol
E limin ati on // you think I just made myself
I thought this was going to be about Kellie Pickler going #2.
Instead of go home singing like regular contestants/singers, she went home doing what she does best...
Videos Banheira okay we get it you dont like her!
Guess what? This is called comment section for a reason.
Videos Banheira and this is called a reply for a reason! ;-) thanks for the info! 😂😂😂
First!
Kelly is watch
she did not deserve top 6 tbh
Why not? There is a lot more to this than just the voice. If that were the case, then Katherine McPhee or Clay Aiken would be billionaires, and Michael Jackson would have been a blip on the radar, like Donny Osmond. Great art moves the audience and great artists do. That's why Kellie with her admittedly good, but not great singing became a star. Bob Dylan would not have gotten to round one of this show. Carol King MIGHT have made it this far.
the blon dumb, country and her family stories keep her week after week
BeardedMcCartney sounds like someone's a little jealous.
+BeardedMcCartney Well it's not like she gets through for her sad stories. She's a real talent and she proved just that, matter of fact even better
Yeah! Cuz she deserves top 3 atleast! 😊
Yeah the old and her got married desperate
**If Kelly could spend 6 months with Stevie Wonder it would be a miracle result!**