Thank you for sharing your perspective of the Meet outfits for the historical dolls! I prefer the quality and accuracy of Pleasant Company (1986-1999) and early American Girl (2000-2010). I understand the intention of renaming the category and brightening up the clothes for the Beforever line to up the sales. The brighter colors and cheaper fabrics are not my thing. I do like Beforever Addy’s blue dress, Rebecca’s purple outfit and Nanea’s Meet Outfit.
I do like Beforever Molly’s outfit. It would probably go in my middle row of outfits I like but don’t pay a lot of attention to. I have 3 mini Mollys in the original Meet outfits. If I buy another one, it would be in the Beforever outfit.
I spent my childhood in the 1970’s and have always lived in the Southwest. Ivy’s dropped turtleneck shirt was a popular style It is a cowl neckline. There is a photo of me around 10 years old with a cowl neck shirt and gauchos! Josefina’s camisa (long top) and skirts were the fashion influence of the Spaniards claiming the northern territories of the Southwest. Josefina’s empire waisted dresses would have been the fashion influence of the Americans coming to Santa Fe for trade after 1821 and the Santa Fe Trail.
@@courtneysokal6590 The Beforever historical outfits on the earlier historical dolls that were updated leave an impression of the time period they are from but are not historically accurate. The quality for dolls like Josefina went downhill as they retired the majority of her collection. I agree that Julie’s Beforever Meet outfit is not representative of the time period. Her earlier Meet outfit was a better representation without using some stereotyped idea of the 70’s. Kit’s Beforever Meet outfit also falls in the category of leaving an impression of the 1930’s while not being historically accurate as her original Meet outfit was. A child in the 1930’s would not have had the fabric in that pattern while the design is another generalization of the 1930’s. These colorful changes were meant to create a renewed interest in these dolls and increase sales. They were not based on educational accuracy. They did do a better job with Maryellen and Nanea as new dolls released during the Beforever time period. And as I stated, I like Addy’s Beforever dress. It maintained some quality and detail. Molly was discontinued and then brought back in her new Meet outfit (I believe it was originally through Costco). Courtney, Claudie, and the Hoffman twins are post-Beforever. With the post 1980’s dolls they are also targeting sales for the people with the money who were alive to remember these time periods.
I enjoyed this video! I was waiting for Emily to be in your top list because she has such a cute meet outfit, but I think you missed her! I also love Molly's BeForever meet outfit (except for the thick glasses). I was lucky enough to grab it while they were selling it briefly as a separate outfit in the sale section. I think Felicity's BF meet would have been better if they had actually made it into separate pieces so it could look like proper layers, but that yellow is ghastly. Marie-Grace's meet is my least favorite because not only is it hideous looking, but the fabric is like the material from a parachute! I hate it! I also obsess over Rebecca's purple shoes. I'm like, do I need to buy her or do I just want the purple shoes?
OMG, I can't believe I overlooked Emily. Poor Emily! I even like the thick brown glasses in Molly's meet outfit. I feel you about Rebecca's purple shoes. I hope you find them all by themselves and at a great price.
You know I love my Felicity and Caroline... but yes, Caroline's is "too pink", but her higher dress is appropriate for younger girls and it would get longer and even have a train for fancy occasions. Her collection I drool over though and have gotten a dress made for her that I love too. Regency/Jane Austen id my favorite era to wear personally. Maryellen I just am obsessed with. Rebecca I love too, but not my top tier like Felicity and Caroline.
Caroline's work dress and birthday dress are really nice. We used to have them both but parted with them when we weren't really using them. I've mildly regretted it a few times but mostly I'm glad someone who loves them is probably getting much more wear out of them than we were.
Kit does have sooo many outfits, which makes sense from a selling stuff perspective- and I love and want basically every outfit they made for her- but in-universe it certainly doesn’t track. And thank you, Molly beforever meet defense club! It’s such a cute outfit. I think a lot of people who are really into Molly just don’t like that it’s a different outfit, but I’m a bit of a Molly hater so it doesn’t bother me, and it looks adorable on Emily who I do love 😂.
This was a very interesting topic. And got me thinking about how I would rank them. I am a huge Samantha fan, agree that her Beforever meet is not accurate. The style of her historical meet is accurate to her time, I like it but wonder if a solid color would have been better. Kit and Samantha I think have the largest wardrobes possibly because they were both very popular and sold well. A girl in Kit's time may have had a fair amount of clothes, but she likely would not have gotten much that was new. And as time progressed during the depression those dresses would have tended to get shorter as she grew and new clothes weren't in the budget. I haven't seen Molly's Beforever outfit that much and I do like it better than her historical. I am with you about that sweater, it is so cute. As for Julie, being in my teens in the 70's I thought the styles were cool then but I shake my head now and cringe Lol. Addy's historical meet is in a color that was very common at the time, it's called a double pink. There are a lot of Civil War reproduction fabrics out now that use that color. I love it.
i Like Molly Be forever outfit also. I plan to purchase it. Well you know I love Addy original meet outfit. Thanks for another fun video. I have never really thought about the meet outfits.
wow i wish i knew that i had the chance to purchase a molly wearing the outfit but i passed because i have three molly dolls already. This year i am trying to decide what my collection will look like. I was inspired by your New Years video and I am running out of space. @@agtakesover
I think my absolute favorite outfits out of these (equal, not ranked) are Josefina (meet), Maryellen, and Kaya. I think I agree with 2/3 of your worst choices! I know Julie's beforever outfit is very costume-y and not historically very accurate... but I still kind of love it. Addy's meet dress and Mollie's Beforever dress are in my top 10. My other top 10's are Josefina's beforever, Rebecca's meet, Claudie's, Melody's, and Nikki's... I think. I love a lot of them. 😅
I'm never gonna *love* Julie's BeForever meet, but I will say that with the exception of her jeans, I could use all the elements of it in other outfits. So not bad mix and match potential.
My Addy, Rebecca and Julie came in the BeforeEver outfits I love Addy's and Rebeccas but Julie's not so much. i hope to have the original meets someday.
I really enjoyed this video. I agree re: Marie-Grace's outfit, Julie's BeForever and Felicity's BeForever. I also agree re: Molly's BeForever (LOVE the shoes and the skirt!), but I'm not crazy about Courtney's and I like Addy's BeForever better than her Historical dress. I would probably swap out Claudie for Courtney. Thanks for sharing!
My top three are easily 1) Historical Julie, 2)nicki and 3)Caroline Bottom 3 are 1)beforever Samantha, 2)Cecile (I hate how the satin fabric looks after it’s been played with, it’s so easily ruined) and 3) beforever kit. I actually don’t mind beforever felicity, I think the shape is not too wild for a panier era gown. Samantha’s is just such a down grade history wise, so it bums me out to see it. I love the turn of the century fashion especially children’s wear. It’s like you took Nellie’s outfit and made it pink and modern 😭
For a second I just saw "Julie" under your top three instead of "historical Julie" and I was so tickled at the idea of BeForever Julie's meet being in someone's top three ;)
Thank you for sharing your perspective of the Meet outfits for the historical dolls! I prefer the quality and accuracy of Pleasant Company (1986-1999) and early American Girl (2000-2010). I understand the intention of renaming the category and brightening up the clothes for the Beforever line to up the sales. The brighter colors and cheaper fabrics are not my thing. I do like Beforever Addy’s blue dress, Rebecca’s purple outfit and Nanea’s Meet Outfit.
No to Molly's beforever meet? It wasn't that much brighter than her original one.
I do like Beforever Molly’s outfit. It would probably go in my middle row of outfits I like but don’t pay a lot of attention to. I have 3 mini Mollys in the original Meet outfits. If I buy another one, it would be in the Beforever outfit.
I spent my childhood in the 1970’s and have always lived in the Southwest.
Ivy’s dropped turtleneck shirt was a popular style It is a cowl neckline. There is a photo of me around 10 years old with a cowl neck shirt and gauchos!
Josefina’s camisa (long top) and skirts were the fashion influence of the Spaniards claiming the northern territories of the Southwest.
Josefina’s empire waisted dresses would have been the fashion influence of the Americans coming to Santa Fe for trade after 1821 and the Santa Fe Trail.
The Beforever outfits are largely historically accurate though
@@courtneysokal6590 The Beforever historical outfits on the earlier historical dolls that were updated leave an impression of the time period they are from but are not historically accurate. The quality for dolls like Josefina went downhill as they retired the majority of her collection.
I agree that Julie’s Beforever Meet outfit is not representative of the time period. Her earlier Meet outfit was a better representation without using some stereotyped idea of the 70’s.
Kit’s Beforever Meet outfit also falls in the category of leaving an impression of the 1930’s while not being historically accurate as her original Meet outfit was. A child in the 1930’s would not have had the fabric in that pattern while the design is another generalization of the 1930’s.
These colorful changes were meant to create a renewed interest in these dolls and increase sales. They were not based on educational accuracy.
They did do a better job with Maryellen and Nanea as new dolls released during the Beforever time period. And as I stated, I like Addy’s Beforever dress. It maintained some quality and detail. Molly was discontinued and then brought back in her new Meet outfit (I believe it was originally through Costco).
Courtney, Claudie, and the Hoffman twins are post-Beforever. With the post 1980’s dolls they are also targeting sales for the people with the money who were alive to remember these time periods.
I enjoyed this video! I was waiting for Emily to be in your top list because she has such a cute meet outfit, but I think you missed her! I also love Molly's BeForever meet outfit (except for the thick glasses). I was lucky enough to grab it while they were selling it briefly as a separate outfit in the sale section. I think Felicity's BF meet would have been better if they had actually made it into separate pieces so it could look like proper layers, but that yellow is ghastly. Marie-Grace's meet is my least favorite because not only is it hideous looking, but the fabric is like the material from a parachute! I hate it! I also obsess over Rebecca's purple shoes. I'm like, do I need to buy her or do I just want the purple shoes?
OMG, I can't believe I overlooked Emily. Poor Emily! I even like the thick brown glasses in Molly's meet outfit. I feel you about Rebecca's purple shoes. I hope you find them all by themselves and at a great price.
I love Joesafina BeforeEver skirt and belt so colorful,bright and beautiful I need to get it for my joesafina someday
It's not my favorite of her outfits, but I don't think she has any *bad* outfits.
You know I love my Felicity and Caroline... but yes, Caroline's is "too pink", but her higher dress is appropriate for younger girls and it would get longer and even have a train for fancy occasions. Her collection I drool over though and have gotten a dress made for her that I love too. Regency/Jane Austen id my favorite era to wear personally. Maryellen I just am obsessed with. Rebecca I love too, but not my top tier like Felicity and Caroline.
Caroline's work dress and birthday dress are really nice. We used to have them both but parted with them when we weren't really using them. I've mildly regretted it a few times but mostly I'm glad someone who loves them is probably getting much more wear out of them than we were.
Kit does have sooo many outfits, which makes sense from a selling stuff perspective- and I love and want basically every outfit they made for her- but in-universe it certainly doesn’t track. And thank you, Molly beforever meet defense club! It’s such a cute outfit. I think a lot of people who are really into Molly just don’t like that it’s a different outfit, but I’m a bit of a Molly hater so it doesn’t bother me, and it looks adorable on Emily who I do love 😂.
I would get an offical membership card to ther Molly BeForever Meet Defense Club!!!
This was a very interesting topic. And got me thinking about how I would rank them. I am a huge Samantha fan, agree that her Beforever meet is not accurate. The style of her historical meet is accurate to her time, I like it but wonder if a solid color would have been better. Kit and Samantha I think have the largest wardrobes possibly because they were both very popular and sold well. A girl in Kit's time may have had a fair amount of clothes, but she likely would not have gotten much that was new. And as time progressed during the depression those dresses would have tended to get shorter as she grew and new clothes weren't in the budget. I haven't seen Molly's Beforever outfit that much and I do like it better than her historical. I am with you about that sweater, it is so cute. As for Julie, being in my teens in the 70's I thought the styles were cool then but I shake my head now and cringe Lol. Addy's historical meet is in a color that was very common at the time, it's called a double pink. There are a lot of Civil War reproduction fabrics out now that use that color. I love it.
I enjoyed this entire comment, but the coolest new thing I learned was the "double pink". Thank you so much for sharing that!
i Like Molly Be forever outfit also. I plan to purchase it. Well you know I love Addy original meet outfit. Thanks for another fun video. I have never really thought about the meet outfits.
Molly's BeForever outfit is kind of hard to come by at a good price because she was sold for such a limited time in that outfit.
wow i wish i knew that i had the chance to purchase a molly wearing the outfit but i passed because i have three molly dolls already. This year i am trying to decide what my collection will look like. I was inspired by your New Years video and I am running out of space. @@agtakesover
Yay! We're both holding ourselves accountable and I'm here for it!
Nellie is my favorite but you’re so right about the wrinkles… the pink spring dress is also terrible for that
Agreed about the spring dress!
Where would you put Emily’s outfit? Maybe I missed her in the video. 🙃 I think it’s adorable.
Someone else pointed out I overlooked Emily. Poor Emily! I'd put her in the middle - solidly so (not lowwww mid like Ivy or high mid like Claudie)
I think my absolute favorite outfits out of these (equal, not ranked) are Josefina (meet), Maryellen, and Kaya.
I think I agree with 2/3 of your worst choices! I know Julie's beforever outfit is very costume-y and not historically very accurate... but I still kind of love it.
Addy's meet dress and Mollie's Beforever dress are in my top 10. My other top 10's are Josefina's beforever, Rebecca's meet, Claudie's, Melody's, and Nikki's...
I think. I love a lot of them. 😅
I'm never gonna *love* Julie's BeForever meet, but I will say that with the exception of her jeans, I could use all the elements of it in other outfits. So not bad mix and match potential.
I love Molly's BF outfit! I am always on the lookout for it. The thing I love the most is the shoes.
I got it not too long ago and it was definitely a bit of a splurge. But definitely worth it for me.
Tie,it's gonna sound like a cop out however i do agree w/ you and your choices ,go figure ☺. Thankyou Kristie
Lisa
Similar tastes :)
Diddo😂
With Marie-Grace dress I don't like that the dark pink vest looking thing isn't separate. Is it supposed to be a vest? Cause it kinda looks like one n
I don't understand it at all and am waiting for someone to explain in the comments what they're called and why they existed.
I totally agree with everything!Aside from the historical accuracy, I do like most of the outfits!! ❤
Yay!!
I need Claudie to complete my Histocal collection. I love her dress with the sweater and the mint green bow to match
Yeah, her outfit is adorable and SHE is gorgeous!!
My Addy, Rebecca and Julie came in the BeforeEver outfits
I love Addy's and Rebeccas but Julie's not so much.
i hope to have the original meets someday.
Yep...Julie's BeForever meet outfit is *not* where it's at.
I have both of kitts dresses and I like them both but I do like the before ever better
Yep...outliers unite!!
I really enjoyed this video. I agree re: Marie-Grace's outfit, Julie's BeForever and Felicity's BeForever. I also agree re: Molly's BeForever (LOVE the shoes and the skirt!), but I'm not crazy about Courtney's and I like Addy's BeForever better than her Historical dress. I would probably swap out Claudie for Courtney. Thanks for sharing!
Thanks!
Whoever did the bad Felicity dress didn't read the Felicity books or did their research
I've literally met no one who loves that dress.
My top three are easily 1) Historical Julie, 2)nicki and 3)Caroline
Bottom 3 are 1)beforever Samantha, 2)Cecile (I hate how the satin fabric looks after it’s been played with, it’s so easily ruined) and 3) beforever kit.
I actually don’t mind beforever felicity, I think the shape is not too wild for a panier era gown. Samantha’s is just such a down grade history wise, so it bums me out to see it. I love the turn of the century fashion especially children’s wear. It’s like you took Nellie’s outfit and made it pink and modern 😭
For a second I just saw "Julie" under your top three instead of "historical Julie" and I was so tickled at the idea of BeForever Julie's meet being in someone's top three ;)
YASSSSS MY GIRL COURTNEY GETS SOME LOVE!!!
I don't LOVE her, but I don't hate her or anything. I *DO* love her collection.
Fun fact with Ruthie
In the kit books her dress was yellow
I've read Kit's books but not Ruthie's and I don't remember that. I'll have to pay attention when I read Ruthie's book.
I think a lot of people don't like Ivy's meet outfit the shirt is definitely the big deal breaker of her outfit
Yes. It might have a fighting chance if not for that shirt!
I like Kit’s BeForever as well
Of the beforever outfits, I like Molly's best, but Kit's, Addy's, and Rebecca's are all also pretty.
I would say Claudies is my favourite meet outfit!
Solid choice. I love her meet!
Any prototypes send them my way AG
Right?!
I need Felicity's orginal Rose meet dress
I hope you find it, and at a fantastic price :)
PLEASE! NOW WITH GIRL OF THE YEAR! PLEASE! ❤
You can actually find AG Takes Over's GOTY outfit ranking video in the 11 months ago videos! It's really entertaining, would recommend! 😁
Thank you so much, @therobotdevil2284!
@hello.kitty.2000 On my channel, you can also use the search feature and if you type "Best & Worst" that should bring it up. Enjoy!
You forgot Emily?
I sure did. Someone else pointed it out afterward and I felt bad for poor Emily! I'd put her in upper mid range, if that helps.
@@agtakesover it happens it’s okay lol thanks for letting me know where it goes!
I never liked Felicity nor her outfits. Molly is #1 in my book.
I just can't get into Felicity.