Roll For Crit's Top 20 Games of All Time | Part 2: #10-#1

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 34

  • @blakejackson5340
    @blakejackson5340 4 роки тому +8

    I know you mentioned it, but I LOVE Aeon’s End. Definitely my fav deck builder!

  • @piyushathawale
    @piyushathawale 4 роки тому +2

    Such a great and diverse list! Im going to get some of these you mentioned. Its so good to see that you guys have a list which is so personal and close to you.

  • @Table.Fables
    @Table.Fables 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the list I enjoyed this! Mage Knight and Arkham Horror LCG are my two faves!

  • @kobusbrits3523
    @kobusbrits3523 4 роки тому +3

    Arkham Horror: The Card Game is such a gem. That and Aeon's End are my favourite games.

  • @sigepohio
    @sigepohio 4 роки тому +6

    7th Continent Average rating … 7
    Will - #9
    Jonathan - #5

  • @foodini666
    @foodini666 4 роки тому +4

    nice video. was fun to watch. battlestar galactica a game store by me has used for $100.00. not sure if they are open at the moment but i'm tempted to get it more than I was before watching this. I love that show too.

  • @AX5Terminator
    @AX5Terminator 4 роки тому +1

    Have you guys played Marvel Champions? If yes, how does it compare to Legendary? Where do you rank it?

    • @RollforCrit
      @RollforCrit  4 роки тому +1

      It made it to my top 10 of 2019, so I'm a big fan! Very different game from Legendary though. We've got a full review elsewhere on the channel. Maybe it will move into our top 20 somewhere after some more expansions come out... - Jonathan

  • @DaletheCasualGamer
    @DaletheCasualGamer 4 роки тому +1

    BSG is the game that pulled me into this hobby, and to me is still the best a game has done to match theme to mechanics. Thanks for sharing your lists!

  • @falconashek8913
    @falconashek8913 4 роки тому +1

    One of my favorite Deck builders is High Command (Hordes and WarMachine combined). Lord of the Rings the deckbuilder (Cryptozoic), Clank! original, Star Realms and Legendary: Big Trouble in Little China is next. I did add some other Legendary expansions in that box, until it was full, yes fully sleeved too.

  • @wbeytel
    @wbeytel 4 роки тому +3

    Good lists, I like or love most of your choices 👍

  • @arcubal
    @arcubal 4 роки тому +2

    Thanks guys! Again, solid lists all round. I think my tastes usually gravitate more towards Will's side, if only because I'm really (like REALLY) bad at social deduction games so I tend to not enjoy them as much. I really like story-heavy, thematic experiences, so yeah 7th Continent, Arkham Horror TCG, Robinson Crusoe, Chronicles of Crime and Sherlock Holmes definitely fit in my wheelhouse. On top of that, I have to add Legacy games (Pandemic, SeaFall, Clank! and Betrayal) as they create these beautifully personal narratives. Tainted Grail, Near and Far, Stuffed Fables represent solid examples of my favorite publishers (Awaken Realms, Red Raven and Plaid Hat) whereas FFG's Descent and Mansions of Madness (both 2nd editions) are still the Kings of dungeon crawls for me. Finally, the less strategic and more role-play-like Folklore: the Affliction and HEXploreIt deserve an honorable mention. One thing is for sure...we have enough great games to keep expanding those Top Games lists!

    • @Fatpie42
      @Fatpie42 4 роки тому

      I'm terrible at Avalon because I'm bad at lying, so I love it all the more for this. Not keen on traitor mechanics in other games though, with the exception of Betrayal at the House on the Hill where the traitor isn't a secret a player has to keep to themselves.

  • @JohnnyMcNabb63
    @JohnnyMcNabb63 4 роки тому +11

    Bought 7th continent because of all the reviews.. I HATED the game.. it felt like I was a kid at the library and stuck at the card Catalog. It just wasn’t for me.

  • @goodsound4756
    @goodsound4756 4 роки тому +3

    Robinson Crusoe suffers from the same issues many cooperative games do: no interesting decisions to take. It's thematic yes. But actually you try to get some cubes and you roll some dice for it. Repeat. As each character has some advantage in its domain, it's obvious that the soldier will hunt, that the worker tries to get tools and the explorer explores the island. It felt way too scripted. The game captures the story well but mechanically the game is boring to me as it drags too long. Just my 2 cents.

  • @adamras2002
    @adamras2002 4 роки тому +1

    I really don't understand the draw of cosmic encounters. I might be missing somethign but by far one of my least favorite games, but the poeple who love it seem to REALLY love it.

    • @Fatpie42
      @Fatpie42 4 роки тому

      I have mixed feelings on Cosmic Encounter. I like the way people are encouraged to double cross each other, but the cards feel very "take that" to me and the alien variations chosen at the beginning don't really seem to balance very well with each other. It's definitely unique though. And it really gets people pushed into a corner.

  • @benlauson555
    @benlauson555 4 роки тому

    Nice list, we definitely have different tastes in games! No lacerda in your lists!!!

  • @stefansibbes2548
    @stefansibbes2548 4 роки тому

    Social deduction, Deckbuilding and Adventure style coop, got it!

  • @Iamwrongbut
    @Iamwrongbut 4 роки тому

    What is crit? I have always been confused about this channel’s name haha

    • @calvintrane
      @calvintrane 4 роки тому

      critical...the critical hit in test dice xD

  • @therunandgunshooter3129
    @therunandgunshooter3129 4 роки тому

    Kingdom death monster

  • @RedBird77
    @RedBird77 4 роки тому +11

    However you identify. (Rolls eyes)

    • @PablowingUrMind
      @PablowingUrMind 4 роки тому +3

      * *Ben-Shapiro Triggering intensefies* *

    • @classicalteacher
      @classicalteacher 4 роки тому

      Fact is fiction and T.V. reality. I wonder if these guys are flat-earthers too?

    • @Slobst
      @Slobst 4 роки тому +3

      Person triggered over a greeting (rolls eyes)

    • @classicalteacher
      @classicalteacher 4 роки тому

      @@Slobst Not triggered. That's something a liberal gets when confronted with logic. They can't comprehend logic so they go into defense mode.

    • @Iamwrongbut
      @Iamwrongbut 4 роки тому +1

      Jon Visser *defense

  • @Avtomatik
    @Avtomatik 4 роки тому

    geez, there are about half a million games on the market and you guys have what 4 same games in your top 10? :/

  • @Son0fAggression
    @Son0fAggression 4 роки тому

    Wow, dc deck builder... never seen anyone who's ever played any other deck builder put it on a top list. It's just such a generic game.

  • @diamondmeeple
    @diamondmeeple 4 роки тому

    Two loss aversion fanatics bring us into their world. The fear of feeling inferior is like an aura around the two.

  • @chrismichael9556
    @chrismichael9556 4 роки тому

    However you identify?? 👌 since we're playing this game , I identify as a black gay unicorn thats fluid on Fridays as a walrus. 😃 i appreciate you taking time out of your intro to include me .

  • @jamesdavid7782
    @jamesdavid7782 4 роки тому

    Booooo for including a pay to win game. smh