Can You Tell the Difference between AI and Human Composers?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
- Practice Merch!: www.twosetappa...
Follow TwoSet Apparel: / twosetapparel
Submit your music memes: / lingling40hrs
***Passionate about Classical Music? Join our team! Go to this link: www.twosetviol...
_______________________________________
S H O P: www.twosetappa...
W E B S I T E: www.twosetvioli...
F A C E B O O K: / twosetviolin
I N S T A G R A M: / twosetviolin
W E I B O: www.weibo.com/...
T W I T T E R: / twosetviolin
S N A P C H A T: Brettybang | Eddy.Chen
Petition for Twoset playing for their old teachers
⬇️
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
totally dude! It would certainly be very INTERESTING
@
honestly, the best commercial ever
@@ManiacMemes when u link ur own video
It’s impressive that they got Batman feels just by listening to Hans Zimmer’s score, shows how well he composed The Dark Knight
Zimmer's work.. you can really hear how he stay truth to the tempo. like REAAALLY hear it. or Feel it i guess. plus the Shepard tone that he loves to use
I literally ran around my house because i was correct with the composer, film, and piece 😂😂😂😂
@Danny R.Z I love the apple apple video
I think because he listened to it earlier, you can hear unwanted music from everywhere in modern life
well, the batman movie was one of the coolest movies. but i think they probably just saw the movie and then heard it and recognized it
The weirder one is usually going to be the human. The AI learns what's normal and makes normal music. The human learns what's normal and tries to make music that sounds new and interesting.
You're quite optimistic about humans :-)
Agree. Also, what seems interesting is that AIs don't seem to be that good at build ups; this was the clearest in the dark cinematic compositions in which tension and build up play a big role.
Ai can only compose short phrases won't be able to develop without human assistance
For me it's too easy to pick ai composers they r just not as good. Plus all the compositions here by ai we're just 'ai' assisted so it's basically fraudulent video
That was how I was able to tell them apart. The human compositions were too weird and eccentric for a computer to have come up with them, no AI would make those choices, and like you could imagine all the human compositions conveying a specific actual mood/emotion/story in a dynamic plot beat rather than just existing for the sake of sounding how you expect something to sound. The only category that threw me off a bit was the last one where the human compositions were pretty conventional sounding (but good) film music and the AI did things that arguably didn't fit the category they had been put into.
Child prodigy: Destroy musician's self esteem.
AI: Destroy composer's self esteem.
@gJb 1 The name is literaly "artificial inteligence"
@@sora5127 but it still only develops compositions by been feed with sheet music. It can create out of nothing. At least yet (and possibly never, for security reasons).
@@sora5127 So what? That's historical artifact in the name :) Do you say "AI of coopas" in Mario games are intelligent being? So yes, there is no intelligence in Neural Networks.
@@mapron1 That's false, the Koopas in the Mario Brothers franchise have pre-programmed behavior, Artificial intelligence, or more precisely a neural network comes to make its own decisions similar to the machinations of a human brain. At its core, human intelligence consists merely of a massive amount of neurons in the brain similar to booleans, which hold a positive/negative or true/false state. It is with enough of these neurons that humans can learn. While Neural networks have nowhere near the same amount of "neurons" as the human brain does, it doesn't need as many since neural networks are made only to specialize in a single topic, and at their core, operate and learn based on experience and the effects of previous decisions, psychologically the same way a human being does. If humans have intelligence, then a neural network should as well.
@@8LyJu8 Isn't that the same for people. A person cannot create things out of nothing, if a human was born in an empty blank white world with nothing, it wouldn't be able to compose music either. If you gave that human sheet music, only then would it be possible for it to learn to compose.
TwoSetViolin in 20 years:
*"Can we tell human composers from our superior AI composers?"*
Why are you everywhere? good to see you back
Two set in twenty years:
"This is very impressive if it's composed by a human"
Welcome back!
please don't forget to do a break before you're forced to by the internet mass :)
Isn't that what this video is?
I like how Hans Zimmer stands out so much that without question you can decide it was composed by a person.
That’s Zimmer for you! He’s (along with Williams) the Ling Ling of film scores
@@jenkinsfamily2229 Ennio Morricone bro
@@dinospumoni5611 dead
@@lordpersius0322 so? he was still one of the absolute best film composers of all time
Ikr I felt the human hints in the cinematic parts because of listening to Zimmer
Last video they got self esteem -10000000, now they're back at it again.
Yes?
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
idk why it's funny but it is
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
don't click the blue letters
Nah they said they learned.
I noticed that the subscriber count has dropped dramatically. What happened?
Eddy: "it sounds like Batman"
Me: Hans Zimmer did his job well then.
Also, who else recognised it straight away...
I did! I was on a concert with him in november, and this took me right back.
I love Zimmers music! I did long before I knew who he is. I watched all the pirates of carribean-films over and over just because of the music 🤩🤩🤩
I did too
I did
Two set doesn’t listen to soundtracks 😢😭
“This sounds like what you’d hear in a movie!”
Yes that’s why it’s *cinematic* eddy
Sometimes they’re like 8 year old kids, but sometimes they’re just so talented
True
8 year old kids + talent = prodigy
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
Prodigies
@@ManiacMemes Stop advertising your own videos in the UA-cam comment section. It's very annoying and you're begging for subs and views.
AI worker here: "AI Compositions" are actually super guided, and generally only provide the motif
Moreover, the Ai will probably generate 20 of them, and a human will pick the nicest
Musicians still have a couple of decades of employment ^^
Do you know any good resources on this? I would be really interested in learning more about what about an "AI composition" is actually done by the AI. The whole melody of the first AI composition, for example, was basically the same as an actual Christian hymn from 1641. That makes me wonder what the AI actually did.
I'm obligated to explain that ia will take composers jobs, but musicians still have an advantage place because ia still play musical instruments like shit
Theophilus check out The Video from Nvidia about Aiva, they explain
I'd like to add to that, common techniques make AI by immitating humans, meaning the result will lean towards a more normal sounding music, maintaining a musical idea and smoothly developing on it without major changes.
6:43 "It doesn't know where it's going", exactly, an AI would know where it was going, because it would go pretty much nowhere (this is made more clear with longer pieces). The weird transitions at 6:20 - 6:40 are made by a human experimenting with wild transitions and not by AI trying to replicate what most humans would usually do, because "weird" isn't usually done.
Take the piece at 6:00 that confused Eddy, it is really good and it sounds like "love", but the thing is.. love is a *very* common theme so an AI would be able to replicate somewhat accurately, also the piece mantains the same musical idea all the way through, which is very consistent with an AI that doesn't take risks. Btw, about the weirdly bright part of the AI piece at 9:10, an AI doesn't know why we do stuff, so it may misplace musical ideas it's seen before but doesn't quite understand, nice catch on twoset's side.
PS: I know there are methods to develop AI that attempt to be creative and to intentionally do things humans usually don't and a dataset with wild experimental pieces would result in an unconventional AI, but in this case it was obvious that they tried to make the AI imitate and not innovate.
I feel some sense of relief then. whew... I guess.
10:30 I’m so relieved they recognized Hans Zimmer’s skills
When twoset doesn't care that it will be copystriked as long as they'll give us some content 🥺🙏🏻
𝕐𝕖𝕒 ᗩᒪᔕO I ᒪIKᗴ ᑌᖇ ᑌᔕᗴᖇᑎᗩᗰᗴ ᗩᑎᗪ ᑌᖇ ᑭᖴᑭ ▼・ᴥ・▼
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
so underrated
TWOSETTER- LUV UR EDITS OAHDIEU U DO AMAZING WITH VIDEO STAR-
And indeed they do, so check out twoset apparel 👌😉
Maniac Memes can you please stop self promoting?
Eddy: if this is not human, I will...
Me: prac-
Eddy: I will become batman
Me: ...well that’s new.
It's because that piece of music was literally from the Batman soundtrack.
@@JW-ws4op i think u missed the joke...
The more it sounds familiar, the more likely it is to be AI. As it learns from us and has no creativity, it can only interpret its results based on already existing works.
Thats definetly True for now, but just seeing how fast ai is improving already, its only a matter of time until they will be able to create original masterpieces. Who knows, perhaps in 100 years, AI will be so good, Beethoven sounds boring. We dont know where technology brings us
To be honest isn't that how modern composers make music? They take inspiration from other pieces of music and make their own version?
That was literally soo apparent through all I really dont get how they didn't guess right.
Not yet it doesn't.
oh that sounds exactly how human makes music
*Baroque 1:* AI
*Baroque 2:* BWV 721 · J.S. Bach
*Romantic 1:* AI
*Romantic 2:* Blanik (Má Vlast) · Boston Symphony Orchestra · Rafael Kubelik
*Cinematic 1:* Pursuit (From "Epic" OST) · Danny Elfman · Pete Anthony
*Cinematic 2:* AI
*Cinematic 3:* AI (A common humanity · AIVA Technologies)
*Cinematic 4:* Alarms (From "Epic" OST) · Danny Elfman · Pete Anthony
*Dark Cinematic 1:* Night Mission in Venice (From Assassin's Creed II OST) · Jesper Kyd
*Dark Cinematic 2:* AI (A call to arms · AIVA Technologies)
*Dark Cinematic 3:* A Dark Knight · Hans Zimmer & James Newton Howard
*Dark Cinematic 4:* AI (Midnight Sun · Aiva · Aiva Sinfonietta Orchestra · Brad Frey)
Help complete the list :) (Thanks to sebasgverde, Tigershortfoot and Deepanshi Matai)
Dark Cinematic 1 is Night Mission in Venice by Jesper Kyd from Assassin's Creed II OST
Dark Cinematic 1: Assassin's Creed II OST - Night Mission In Venice - Jesper Kyd ua-cam.com/video/YuyAdaMCmYk/v-deo.html
Cinematic 3 is AI
Baroque is BWV 721. Great piece.
@@deepanshimatai2926 how come i didnt see your reply ??? when i wrote?? UA-cam is pretty slow. sorry
"There is 1 imposter among us"
Eddy : first piece
"The first piece is not The Imposter"
Among us gang.
A.I music is like expressing a Beethoven Symphony as variation of wave pressure . It's meaningless
1 impasta?
*laughing uglyly*
You fool.
THERE MORE IMPASTAS AMONG US!!!!!!!!!!
*terminator genysis theme starts playing*
*O Fortuna lyrics start vibing*
AMOGUS
"if this is ai i will..."
famous last words
Can i have that cinematic 3 piece name?
Can i have that cinematic 3 piece name?
Gonna be honest, they should’ve put bretts lofi for the last dark cinematic
when the fear of prodigies aren't still over, but the AI composers are already coming
Okay.......I'VE HAD IT WITH THOSE ROBOTS!
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
@@charmaine7781 and also the bots clogging up UA-cam comments
@@justicewasserved17 Yes I've noticed that too
Just wait for the AI prodigies.
I replayed Eddy's, "Nah nah nah" at least 8 different times.
I think the ‘Is it composed by AI?’ Could be the Twoset community’s version of the ‘Is it cake?’ Meme.
Omg yes
Interesting
now i know what real what fake👁👄👁
“Which composer is secretly cake? The human or the ai?”
At this point im jus enjoying the music. I gave up differentiating between ai and human😂
Imagine being a human, writing a film score, then having that score described as "convincing"
Long ago the musicians lived together in harmony, then everything changed when the AI attacked. Only ling ling, master of all instruments could stop them, but when the world needed them most, they were practicing 40 hours.
My grandmother used to tell me stories about the old days, a time of peace when Ling Ling maintained balance between the musicians and the AI. But that all changed when the AI attacked.
A 100 years past and my brother and I discovered the new Ling ling, a violinist named Ling ling althout his violin skills are great he has a lot to practice before he's ready to save anyone. But I believe he can save the world!
Wow, that's would be a very insteresting backstory for a video game
Read this in the dark cinematic part
@@PurpleAuri its the Avatar the Last Airbender opening
You know whats funny?
At 9:34 they say it's sounded like batman but in fact it really is the batman theme from the dark knight from Hans Zimmer
What was more funny? After 5-6 sec. my first thought was "Hey! It's Hans Zimmer Batman or The last samurai" - And I was immeditely checking comments for answers :D damn, i'm so good at this (joke) :D
That's what I was thinking
Exactly! Not hating at all but I was so shocked when they couldn't tell this was from Dark Knight and written by Hans Zimmer
@Satu Lehto Hans Zimmer is a legend, both are great scores
yea, i recognized it instantly and got so mad on the inside that they didnt xD the piece is so fking good!
I think something that gave away that the cinematic one (the one eddy called love) is that it sounds like it took Harry Potter bits and it feels like it has been fed Harry Potter and Lord Of the Rings scores to produce this piece idk why
Eddy: *mentions Lord of the Rings*
Me: “[…] there’s some good in this world, Mr. Frodo… and it’s worth fighting for.”
Happy Belated Hobbit Day!!!
I feel so related.... :)
RINGERS!!!
I LITERALLY SAID TH SAME THING-
I am glad you are here with me. Here at the end of all things, Shur‘tugal Vodr.
"If an AI can make love...."-Eddy Chen 2020
It seems the trailer of a science fiction
shoot i read that wrong
watch Her (you might cry)
Don't worry Eddy. Human made AI, so basically that was composed by a human.
UNDERRATED COMMENT!!!
smart
Good comment Wise Girl ;)
You get that so well!!!
Ai suppose to ...beventualy no longer need human
"I wanna believe in love" -Eddy Chen, 2020, moments before destruction
the last time I was this early lamentable wasn't even a thing yet
the last time I was this early ling ling wasn't even a thing yet
ฅ^•ﻌ•^ฅ
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
so underrated
i read that as “last time i was this early i wasn’t lamentable yet” at first sight
I found it very easy to differentiate, particularly for the cinematic. The AI ones didn't have the same range of emotions, and the third one sounded too much like John Williams, making me think the AI was given Williams' scores to study.
agreed 👌🏼
The cinematic ones were easier for me, got them all right. For me it was easy because the human compositions feel like a story, something is happening and you can sense it. The ones I thought were AI are really good at reproducing the music of cinema but there isn’t a story flow I can sense; they’re either stagnant or the flow doesn’t fit.
That said, I also got the non cinematic ones right too even though I can’t say why.
You mean, was the AI given Korngold's scores to study
brett and eddy: diss cinematic music
also brett and eddy to all of the pieces: wow this is really good
"I feel confident but I'm doubting myself." - Eddy
Never felt so conflicted as Eddy is.
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
That was straight up Hans Zimmer's Batman score for Dark Cinematic #3
Dear Brett.
Please don’t make me question my existence while I’m in the middle of my exam week.
Thanks.
Sincerely,
One girl who is studying for the solfege exam she has in some minutes.
Good luck! Hope it went well!
Hey!! I also have a solfège exam today. Good luck.
Good luck to both of you then!
Gl!
Thanks to everyone!
Kieran Kauffman Good luck!
Ok guys, it's official. Eddy doesn't believe in love anymore
Breddy shippers be like 👁️👄👁️
@@ipsharoy7398 Except for Brett's
@@ajchandra7735 ???
@@ipsharoy7398 sorry for the confusion I meant to reply to OP, not you
@@ajchandra7735 ohok
The thing about music is that it's based on emotion, soul, feelings, senses, nature, beauty, and so many other things an AI will never replicate perfectly. Robots can beat us in math, in sports, in stamina, in endurance, in accuracy, but they will never (At least not anytime soon) take over the musical spirit which makes us human.
Edit: I watched the video, now I wanna die
I mean replicating the general style of whats already there in a genre really isn't that hard i'd guess... lots of training data to be had^^
I welcome our new AI overlords
Mmm that statement is more something you would like to belive than something factually true.
God I feel this as an artist as well. The only thing that makes me feel even remotely better is the simple face that *we* made it. The composition of an AI is a form of art in and of itself. When an AI creates with all the combined knowledge and skill that's been poured into our art and music it is little more than humanity writing a love letter to its history through a new medium.
Hard copium... I know lol.
are AI robots real or fake
Eddy: "4 is Human. AI cannot compose something so beautiful."
AI: Let's see about that.
He was talking about #3...
Twoset: "Accent the like button and legato the subscribe button."
Me, a rebellious teenager who needs to practice: *sforzandos the like button and slurrs the subscribe button*
Kendal Morrison *in presto agitato*
Is- is that moonstar🤭🤭
@@pastthepointofnoreturn6412 Yup 😁 Moomoo forever
Kendal Morrison same❤️
@@marilyndsouza9713 Aren't we all in presto agitato?
...Says me, who hasn't done anything for the past 6 months xD
Twoset: This sounds like batman
Me: Thats because it is batman
am I the only one that notices?
Naa i noticed it to
A masterpiece
I had to play batman in highschool so I def noticed
Its Hans Zimmer
Roasts today: Damn bro your intonation is off
Roasts in the future: Bro you sound like a human
Ooooof
true
Hans Zimmer.. even tho he is "just" a cinematic composer he is sooo good and recognisable. Love his scores 🖤
Btw the "romantic - human" one was Blaník by Bedřich Smetana
The fact that they got Batman feels from just hearing the music shows just how well Hans Zimmer scored for The Dark Knight Trilogy. Love his work.
@@davidbrussard-composer7372 indeed it's absolutely amazing!
Hans Zimmer is definitely one of my favourite "cinematic" composers. Oof. I love every single ost of his.
Wait..his last name is "sour cream"?... I mean the music is wonderful but his last name made me laugh
@@mara_mori In which language? Btw it just means room in German.
Alternative title: Among Us: Classical Music Edition
Now they've done that for real😂
"Our jobs are being taken away," -- Eddy, a UA-cam Music Comedian
Well.......
I Guess 😂😂
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
Maniac Memes is this a bot
Yes, I’m reporting it continuously!
Anything you can do, a computer can.
Composers in 2010: pfff
Composers now: * sweats*
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
honestly, the best commercial ever
@@HhHh-ev2zz It is funny for some reason I don't know why.
Not sure if anyone has mentioned this but if u guys ever do a show reaction again, could you do “Do you like Brahms?” It’s a very recent kdrama written by a writer who went to music university so I heard that they put in a lot of factors they’ve went through in school so I think it would be interesting to see your thoughts on it. :)
Omg yes yes yes i want to watch that kdrama bc of trailer (they put rach 2 😭🥺 ) but romance-genre drama is not a cup of my tea sooooo idk 😶
illumillu killuallu Oh yes it does have romance but what I like about it is that it’s not like in your face romance but more of relatable romance? So it doesn’t stick out too much? (If that makes sense 😂) And there’s many other stories too about the competitions, professors, and orchestras so it’s definitely interesting.
@@jpark8323 wow thats interesting story, thanks for your review ❤ i think i'm gonna watch it 👀👀
@@Greeeenmoss ommmgggggg
"I'm not a musician anymore"
Midroll
"I'm a Verizon wireless engineer"
As an composer and an ai learner, this was pretty clear which is human and which is computer (expect cinematic 4 that had a few unpredictable note, i think it a little bit of randomised algorithm when the ai didn't knew who to continue)
The ai had a number simple motivs and he transposed them to fit the chosen continues chord, he had basically shafled the motives together, and it was easy enough to separate them into a melody mixed together.
The humans has less melodys and they managed to make out of each one of them a lot more.
Also the ai had a few Voice leading rules that made it clear that it is an ai, he could not made a single doubling of the third in the chord or parallel fifth melodic line, something that the humans was not afraid to do.
I understood practically nothing of your analysis, but if you really could tell the human and the ai compositions apart, that's impressive.
@@johannah4770 Basically AI mash together different patterns that go well together while humans tend to use less patterns and build upon them. I was able to guess all right with a cheat: Try to ignore the melody altogether and listen for the "left hand", the bassline, the supprting and accompanying part of the music. You will notice all AI tracks lack a feeling of intention, depth, or forward motion, like there's always something more to be desired. Perhaps with more time given AI will eventually learn to compose the bassline too.
@@yumpatMEOW I don't think that's cheating. That's just using your knowledge of typical AI's.
I'm a programmer who works with AI and is interested in music and I also got them all right except for the last one. Basically the music that sounds the most predictable, standard, and formulaic is the AI and the music with more risks and surprises is human. Eddy kept trying to pick the one that he found more beautiful but that's not really a good strategy because obviously the only compositions that will be played by the orchestra are the beautiful ones, whether they're composed by humans or AI.
You need to create AEI ( artificial emotional intelligence it will feel pain when loss and ecstasy when win and all other bits and nibbles ) but this will happen in 2034.
somewhere in an alternate universe where the billboard charts has songs like "AI Marry - 203" and "AI Tom - 596"
Friend: I'm calling, I have some tea to spill.
Me: Give me about 12 minutes, something important I have to do.
Friend: Okay take your time. Call me when ur done.
*30 mins later*
Friend: 12 minutes huh?
Me: Sorry I didn't know I was gonna take such a tricky exam
The baroque human piece is BWV721. It sounded "weird" to them because that note right before they stopped the clip the first time is a semitone higher than it should be, I believe (at least based on the recording I am familiar with, as well as another one I just found on UA-cam.)
theowoo they actually preferred an AI piece over a Bach piece, humanity is losing ground
@@AlejandroGonzalez-rw9kt they did. But what I'm saying is I believe that Bach piece wasn't represented in the best light. Maybe that threw them off. :)
@@theowoo true. and anyway, that is not one of the greatest Bach pieces
@@AlejandroGonzalez-rw9kt I personally like that piece. I guess one aspect of it is that the chorale tune it is based on seems to be in Phrygian mode.
@@AlejandroGonzalez-rw9kt They didn't prefer the AI piece, they were guessing which piece sounded more baroque
Editor-san: "Let's see how many mood-setting special effects we can fit into a single video"
Brett hasn't slept well again ! He needs to sleep .
*Petition for Brett to sleep 8 hours a day .*
Look at his hair and eyes too 👀
He would still practice 32 hours a day, just enough to don't fall behind the peers
He is a bit off.
Alternative title: Two classical musicians watch their jobs getting taken in 12 minutes and 42 seconds
10:30 - TwoSetViolin also approves Hans Zimmer... This made my day!!
“I’m not gay. I just like Brett, there’s a difference.”
where is this from?? lmaooo
Ward
Did Eddy say that?
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
don't click the blue letters
*screams in Breddy
"I'm batman and I'm gonna join the dark side. "
star war fans: ................excuse ME??
Chill. He meant Darkseid ;-)
Hey guys! I'm from Brazil and I'm turning 25 next week.. just bought a violin and started practicing! Found out about your channel by searching for ways to learn... You guys are awesome! I can already tell it's really really hard to play, but you make it look worth it! Thanks for your videos, I have so much fun watching them! 😘
How's your violin-playing now, a year later?
@@sebastiano728 how about now?
"and remember to keep practicing because that's what being human is all about"
I really wanna see their faces when they discover that AI's actually practice way more than 40 hours a day
We don’t know what’s real anymore. 2020 is officially cancelled.
Honestly, 2020 being cancelled would be a good thing
@@vanadium8865 yeah but we don't know what 2021 will be like; it may be even worse, so maybe we'd stick to 2020 till it lasts.
Let the AI try to make more then 35 seconds of interesting music - nothing than BS comes out.
I feel like a good judge for this is how “quirky” the piece is. An AI will follow its programming and therefore won’t deviate too far from the normal, whereas a human has real creativity and will go outside of the box to make a creative piece
Necrocommenting, but it's not following a programming, depending on the algorithm is creating variation and recognizing patterns (much like we do), it won't have the intent to create something (don't have an objective outside creating the music) but it some algorithm you can recognize the pieces and composition patterns that arises, leaving to the user the intent that was mean per section/whole piece.
It will follow references, and the more data (and the approach of teaching you use) the better or worse will be (Like us)
Case in point being Brett's take on Mozart's Requiem's Lacrimosa
Last time I was this early, Guiness still counted the Fastest Violinist Record to be viable
The 3rd cinematic one sounds like the Harry Potter theme if you change the notes little. Im sure that the AI took it from there
I agree. Sounds like they fed the AI a lot of John Williams for that one.
That’s what I made me think it was AI, it sounded like Harry Potter cut short.
Exactly my thought. I was like, it sounds Harry Potter but it is WRONG.
the fact that twoset just joked around about the 3rd dark cinematic piece sounding like batman....and it was LITERALLY from a batman movie...... meaning the piece so fully embodies the movie even when you dont remember it...... hans zimmer genius methinks
Just the magic of regular old Leitmotiv.
I could tell Cinematic 3 was AI because it was like an excerpt of every cinematics combined into one
8:02 As an Assassin's Creed Fan I was happy that I recognized Dark Cinematic 1 instantly :D
Right, from such a genius like Jesper Kyd
I knew Brett would get the dark cinematic one right. He has a weird talent for horror film music xD
wait.... they didn't noticed Hans Zimmer's music. that's sacrilegious.
Lamentable.
No, it's not.
Hans Zimmer bribes his students to make the music for him, so its understandable
Koifish production I’m not sure that’s how bribery works 😂
@@KFishproductionII teaching isnt bribing
Musicians: Work for years and years to get good at playing their instrument and more
AI technology: Time to take the musicians job...
I remember when computers couldn't beat humans in chess. Those days are around 30 years behind us. In another 30 years, computers will be capable of so much... So exciting in many ways, but also a bit worrisome.
Me: aight time for some Bach.
*Terminator theme starts playing*
The Terminator Theme is fantastic! I would totally put that theme in a playlist alongside Bach.
Imagine in the future where everyone will appreciate classical music but they only appreciate the ones composed by A.I....
That's kinda scary
Baybayinnn
That sounds similar to a book called "Us" by a Russian author Zamyatin. Thy actually listen to human-made music, but they made it based off of perfect mathematical algorithms. So.... Basically like AI.
I see baybayin right there. 💖
ano basa sa baybayin ng name mo?
Second baroque is a famous organ Chorale "Erbarm dich" BWV 721 by JS Bach, but played so slowly....
People prefer hand-baked desserts over autonomously made ones even though they might be more perfect and are able to follow a recipe on the exact. Even in a few years when an AI will both be able to compose songs and play all the instruments for it better than any person could people will most likely pick the man-made one not because of the taste, but because it "feels" better. I could definitely see people going to concerts with humans playing instead of just listening to a generated one on their phone
being so racist twards the ai's
No these pieces were all played by people, it's just that music was composed by AI.
@@nitishsreeram3002 yeah I'm aware, but it won't stay that way for long
I personally don’t see the difference with a computer playing it vs a person playing it, all it matters to me is that it sounds good and doesn’t have mistakes
Nah, I do prefer the autonomously made desserts, they are more reliable. And if you listen to the AI pieces, they sound like if they are just doing the job, while a lot of the human pieces sounded like trying harder. Not saying they sounded better, but mainly like if they had something to prove, if that makes sense.
The think is AI's are learning from a human, so technically it is copying "humanstyle".
It occurs to me, that's what *all* AI is though right? Copying humanstyle. It's not just artificial intelligence, it's artificial *human* intelligence. If it were artificial alien intelligence or artificial insect intelligence it might sound very strange. But I don't really know.
That's true, but to be fair that's kinda what humans do themselves. Every art is developed on what came before. So I guess the question is can the AI actually creatively develop something further, or just compose based on what it derives from hundreds of pieces of human composed music. I think it's also an interesting point that this was all played by humans, if it were 'played' by a computer using samples or even electronic tones would the compositions stand out differently?
@@UnbeltedSundew If the recordings were all computer mockups instead of humans playing, I think it would have been even more difficult to tell the difference because it would have all sounded a bit artificial. Having humans playing the AI composed music actually adds a human element to the AI.
@@toronado455 It's interesting to think about, I suppose a test could be set up in which each piece is played both by humans, and then computer, although I think at that point it would be too difficult for a layman like me to remember all pieces well enough for comparison. I suppose it could be set up to break up such a scenario to test the pieces first as played by human and then after the same pieces played by computer.
T455 there’s different types of AI. For example with music it’d be impossible for an AI to start from scratch without any understanding of what’s musically appealing because it’s not objective. But in something objective like chess, with this new AI alpha zero that wasn’t given any knowledge beforehand like all the other chess AIs, played against itself for 4 hours without knowing any strategy except for the rules and it taught itself good enough to completely trash the best other computer without losing a single game out of 100
The second cinematic was definitely made from John Williams compositions.
"Either its John Williams Star Wars and I just dont know the star wars soundtrack well enough, or it sound like star wars because an AI learned from star wars."
2:25
Eddy: What's the purpose of existence
A new Ted Ed video: Is life meaningless ?
Me when Hans Zimmer's "The Dark Knight" starts playing and TwoSet like it: My two loves together in one! *tear slides*
The 3rd piece on that last one WAS Batman. It was from Hans Zimmer's score for The Dark Knight (last track on the Album).
Imagine ppl mistaking your piece for some AI-made arrangement 🔥🔥🔥
That's what Ling Ling Insurance is for
Eddy: mentions The Lord of the Rings
Me: Welp, guess what I'm doing this weekend..
Yea lol
Lotr and two set awesome combination
Yeah!!
Baroque 2 sounds like bretts lofi
The melody of the first AI piece is an actual human-composed melody ("Wer nur den lieben Gott lässt walten") from 1641. Maybe the arrangement is done by an AI, but the whole composition is certainly not done by an AI.
second piece against that was J.S. Bach - Erbarm' dich mein, oh Herre Gott, BWV 721
THANK you, I knew I've heard this melody before! I was doubting my entire existence for a minute there 😂
@@itisflat1356 they are both from J.S. Bach, the first one is BMV 690
The first one is not by Bach. Bach used the hymn for his own compositions (like BMV 690) but the melody that is used here is by Georg Neumark.
Yes, that can definitely happen, in AL-ML, we call this "Overfitting", think of it as the AI inadvertently has "memorized" what it being trained on rather than "learning".
I think any person who has ever watched LoTR, at all, can instantly relate that AI piece to any of the scenes in that movie. it's so enchanting and calm and instantly makes you think of the hobbits village.
Sameeeeeee
ua-cam.com/video/fvNV_2D1Az4/v-deo.html
don't click the blue letters
Yes Im a huge LOTR fan
Any of the scenes? Imagining it during the Battle for Helm's Deep now
@@yesdcotchin xD perfect!!! ..
lmao the one they said sounded like batman was actually from Batman Begins by Hans Zimmer
But AI also needs someone who can understand music to make the program to make the music. Does that mean the piece that AI created is also created by human
Hmmmmm InTrEsTiNg
Probably because they have to be programmed to compose... I think
@@Mainni12 yea, right? They were programmed to compose like this or those styles, right? And also when they release the piece they need to check it first. Like, does this piece perfect enough to fit in bach style, or in cinematic, etc. Does that means the piece was composed by AI is also composed by human??
The modern AI are just fed lots of examples of music in the style that they are meant to compose in. Then they learn from the examples
@@qtheplatypus oooo..... I see...
But instead of having a whole orchestra you need someone to code it and to at least know or be a competent musician.
Still less than a whole orchestra.
In the future child prodigies will be playing AI composed music
Why not?
In the future there will be robot prodigies
Yes. The writing's on the wall. And I'm looking forward to being able to listen to new Bach cantatas, Haydn symphonies, Schubert string quartets, and a lot of new music!
Plot twist: Their "friend" was an AI
Plot twist: That very first one was composed by Bach
ua-cam.com/video/sFw6IDdmm9s/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/DTpVFx2hsmo/v-deo.html
TwoSet: "Cinematic music already uses AI"
*John Williams and Hans Zimmer would like to know your location*
Well.. if you actually listen to Williams you can hear copied parts from Korngold, Dvořák, Holst, Mahler.. he's good at compilations I can give him that.
" if AI can make love..."
- Eddy Chen
the way everyones trying to be first and im just tryna see whos first
I was Haha just checking now XD
you should do a 'composers or our followers' edition
edit: I realise that the followers are composers but you know what I mean
Got them all right except for one (Cinematic 3). But some of those AI examples are scarily good.
I'm so proud of myself because it didn't even take me that long to figure out that "Romantic 2" was human and even who and what it was! XD
(It's "Blaník" by Smetana, the melody at the beggining is based on a Hussite war song that when sung by the Hussites sometimes allegedly scared the opposing army into fleeing before the battle even began. The song also features in another one of Smetana's symphonic poems called "Tábor".) Now that I've showed off, go listen to Má Vlast!
Yes! I was like "oooh easy, that's a famous one" and I realised what it was and then I got so surprised when Brett thought it was AI 😱
But well it's famous in Czech Republic
Here it is: music.ua-cam.com/play/OLAK5uy_lLDr1qf7kWGfF-EJQYd_JQLiww32fIM90.html
ok now i feel super bad that i don't know this piece bc i'm czech lmao. BUt it's fine i only started listening to classical music recently, and as someone who hasn't had any connection to classical music until recently it's almost impossible for me to recognize anything. At least i know where to go next.¨haha i still feel stupid tho.
@@cheeseontoast3434 it's okay! I've been somewhat always in touch with classical music but I still recognized only like five to ten famous pieces 😅 these past three months (not only thanks to TwoSet) my knowledge has grown so much
Do u know what cinematic#3 was
Genre: *Dark Cinematic*
My Brain: *Brett's LoFi*
dude when it turned out the 3rd one was the ai i was in genuine shock it sounds exact,y how the most genuine and pure form of love feels
AI: has started replacing musicians
Twoset: hold up a minute... ( I mean 40 hours )
girlfriend reviews fan here?