Mahsa Amini: A year on from death - did protests change Iran?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- It's a year since 22-year-old Mahsa Amini was arrested by Iran's morality police on the streets of Iran.
Within days she was dead - her family said she'd been beaten in custody.
Her death ignited a wave of women-led protests that shook Iran, posing the biggest threat the regime has faced in almost half a century.
A year later, after a brutal crackdown, what lasting impact have the protests had?
We Iranians are not a divided country! We are a highly secular society that has fallen captive to an theocratic regime that has the support of only 10 percent of population! If there is division it is with a small minority who still support this brutal regime! We want change and we will get it. It's only a matter of time! And not a long one!
Iraq Libya Syria Yemen ??? Still believing western propoganda help you .
You nailed it! That's totally true!
10%? Where is the source?
If they only have 10% then protests should skyrocket into 1979 style revolution as you only need to get 25% or more, let alone with 90%
yet only less than 0.1% of the population protest
The last time was in 2009 when there almost a million went on for 15 months over election fraud and in the end, they were all but crushed. let alone with just mere 100k in almost 12 month
Shah son would be better
@@karimtabrizi376shah killed 60 thousand Iranians .when people died for hunger he spend billions in party he didn't care about country.
”You killed her for two strands of hair!”
- Father of Mahsa Amini
your id should say ; i am not a troll, lol
When this regime falls, there will be singing, dancing and fireworks.
@@syncopatedfeb4770 your id id should say: I'm not a religious fascist that calls troll to anyone who questions my religion
@@masterchuck8772 my id says i don't have a religion, and i always wondered what you homeless chmps do on krak, now i know, time to go back to your tent, low iq kraky, lol
این حرفا رو از کجای باسنت در آوردی ؟ دروغگو!
People need to realize that religion is a choice. It should NOT be a political ideology.
Many govs use it to push their ideology, including Iran.
Religion is part of politic, that's what religion is about:teach us manners of healthy life
The religion dictates the rules of the nation. If you dont like the rules, leave ... just as you say that to those that dont like the British laws.
the question why you became a troll? there must be a job where you don't meddle in other people's business for $12, what a f disaster, lol
@@jagoman85 you're not very intelligent are you?
Just say you are a religious fascist.
Where do expect Iranian women to go? 😒
So Very Impressed and in Awe of the bravery of these men and women!!!…Sending THeE Best of All Wishes in Love & Solidarity from Maine in the USA…🌟💫⚡️💕❤️💕
So am i!! Brave brave people!! Love from 🇸🇪
Thank you Melissa for your kind message I am Iranian and I love your country and your people not sure about the government though but I’m sure it’s better than the Persian government they’re wronguns too
@@dk8198 love and light and gratitude…
👉Hijab is not only that we are fighting for. We are fighting for freedom and democracy and secular law, and equality of rights for men and women.
How is the west doing with that then?
@@ShirinAyhanfairly good I would say
The problem with this clash of culture is in our country:
On the one hand, we have this [Absolute individual Rights] of our women in society which must be protected at all costs.
On the other hand, there is also, this hellish war being waged by the Zionist enemy in the West, against our country - Whose ultimate goal, there is to uproot [Our] society's traditional [Shi'it-Iranian] values & to destroy the country's hard earned - [Political-Independence]!
In that - Iran can [Not] afford to lose this war!
Long Live Greater 🇮🇷 Independence!
Iranians are Zoroastrian not Muslims
@@dk8198sorry you are late about 14 centuries
I hope that masha amini hadn’t died for nothing! A revolution is needed! FREE IRAN
She died of a heart attack
@@isscaibnzehra8717due to strikes
This religion-based law is clearly ridiculously oppressive.
@@user-yg1rk6fs5z us has similar laws but he's probably a troll living in israel or something, lol
@@syncopatedfeb4770 I'm in the UK & am not a troll.
and i'm god, lol@@RobertTaylor-gz2fu
its only oppressive towards those that want a liberal laws. if they dont like the laws, they can leave the country.
@@jagoman85 Life isn't always that straightforward.
Killed for not covering enough of her head.
Masha was not killed for not wearing idiot
it's your fault, not iran's. even during shah, you've constantly been trying to cause civil wars to plunder like iraq and syria. so these countries have to use religion, communism or other censorship to prevent you from getting in, causing civil wars, killing and stealing, like you've done thru 160 wars, under the criminal name of democracy.
a 12 year old can watch the video where she was sitting there just fine and then suddenly collapsed, low iq troll
so let's cover up west's homeless, crime, 1 out of 5 on benefits, 1 out of 4 asrap before age of 18, with a head covering. all you do is expose your failed society, lol
Crazy right 😂😂
@LionSeries
You'll never be executed for polygamy in the west
Barbaric Islamic regime must go.
Shout out to brave Iranian women ✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️
Do you remember shireen abu akleh
This came just in time for the Isreal-Palestine conflict. People need to realize just how "free" the Islamic states are and see what they are defending
It’s not just about hejab. we don’t want Daee islamic republic government in Iran. 0:03 0:03
Iranian people love their democratic gvt
@@MrMalmirهر چقدر بهت پول میدن اینو بدی دو برابرشو به ازای مادرت میدم
You can kill people but not what they stand for.
The women are now stronger!
RIP Mahsa Amini🌹
the toilet cleaner muchacho has pooped, lol
@@syncopatedfeb4770 oh, your mother?
it's not my problem us took your land and you have to clean toilets for persians in beverly hills, lol
@@syncopatedfeb4770you do realize not all Latinas are maids right
WOMENS RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS!! PROTECT EVERY WOMEN'S RIGHTS!! 💪🏻
Stay strong girls
I hope that one day Iran is free from this terrorist regime WOMAN LIFE FREEDOM
What is a woman?
Keep dreaming..
Long live the Islamic Republic of Iran.
🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷
Do you remember shireen abu akleh
@@hanazuki333a woman is LIFE!
@@hanazuki333 Nice
There is such thing like Revolution in Iran and the people should exercise that option soon
There is such a thing as google and you putting "iranian revolution" into the search bar on it and then maybe pressing enter is an option you should maybe look into when you get five minutes spare from being a full time fucking cretin.
Iranians are Zoroastrian not Muslims
ما ملت کبیریم
ایران رو پس می گیریم
We are a great nation
We will redeem Iran❤❤❤
Never
@@Hakuoo8never say never
@@Hakuoo8why never?
Hats off to these ladies, proud all off you. Every one has own freedom and rights
Hello
Noble and great people of Iran and the world
September 25 wherever you are in the world
Be on the streets for women, life, & freedom
Thank You
RIP Mahsa. I am profoundly proud of all the women fighting for their freedom. Freedom for one is freedom for all. Hold the line ladies!!!!
At least spell it correctly
The thing is to not let them pick you off one by one in your cars. That is how they operate. Use other means to rebel which are difficult for them to target not driving alone in a car. Together you are strong.
These lasses have got a lot of courage.
The entitlement and ignorance of religious people is what holds humanity back. I don't care what religion anyone subscribes to. It's always the same story, some people think they're special and turn into animalistic little fascists because other people want to do their thing.
Whilst France forces women to remove their clothing is leading the way?
@@aafiaturkey6748 The rule was applied only for school students to wear the exact uniform, not applied in the whole country. And France doesn't arrest and kill those who wear hijab. So please inform yourself first, before spitting like a crazy person.
@@aafiaturkey6748what a irrelevance. France is not right but iran isnt too.
@@infinity-r8fexactly the point you made about ignorance
You are brainwashed by sacular freemasonry system i inviting you to look at army of Satan serials in rational beliver channel to open your mind about Religion. Religion will free you from enslave of people who control world(Satanists,illuminati,zionism) and turn you to your creator God
Wow, in Iran these brave women want to ditch the scarves/head cover and in UK/Europe, western born/raised Muslim women want to go full ninja. Crazy world we live in.
I kindly ask you to be mindful about your choice of words " full ninja " . It is the choice of some people and it should not excuse any racist comments.
@@kelanitweir4994 erm it’s not a racist comment, people use this word far too easily these days. My word of “ninja” is purely observational. If you take offense, that’s your problem, I’m not going to change my choice of words to not offend you or anyone else. Get over it!
@@liveitlarge68 take offense? Bro it's not about that. I'm saying your choice of words is wrong and it is not justified by it's frequent usage. It is just an advice! But let me ask you something, do you consider the headscarf oppressive?
@@kelanitweir4994 I consider it a choice in the west, maybe I’m being naive thinking that, I hope not. I do believe some women wear it or started wearing it for political statement making reasons. Again, that’s the freedom of choice we have in the west, just like my choice of words.
Overall, my opinion is the whole outfit is related to religion, but I think like the Old Testament, Islam is vile and not suited for current times and western society. Again, that’s me exercising my freedom of speech.
@@liveitlarge68 I see were you're coming from. I respect that you consider the Vail as a choice but why Islam is not compatible with the western modern lifestyle? You have in the west the biggest number of deaths related to Alcohol and suicides, whereas Islam prohibited both . Also, the beauty industry sexualize women to an extent that a lot of young women feel insecure about their look, making women a sexual object, which is one of the justification of the hijab. Finally, small actions as taking care of the neighbors regardless of their religion or political ideology is one of the beliefs in Islam, not to mention all the civil laws that guarantee people's rights are mandatory in Islam. So, why you consider Islam been incompatible with the modern societies?
I'm sure God has much more important things to do than worry about hats & scarves.
and so do people, so why t f are you trolling, lol
The problem that people fail to realize is the headscarf is a command of God and people have the free-will to either follow God's command or ignore it . However, no one should kill anybody on the basis of wearing a headscarf or not.
@@syncopatedfeb4770 Why have a law mandating head coverings?!
@@kelanitweir4994 The Quran doesn't mandate it.
@@davidz3879 ok look at this verse ( 59) O Prophet, tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to bring down over themselves [part] of their outer garments. That is more suitable that they will be known and not be abused. And ever is Allāh Forgiving and Merciful.) Chapter 33 verse 59. And also this verse in chapter 24 ( And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and guard their chastity, and not to reveal their adornments1 except what normally appears.2 Let them draw their veils over their chests) these are clear proof, explain by the prophet and understood by all the companions. Have a nice day.
I am an unstoppable force, ready to take on the morality police and defend my beliefs like a burning inferno.
Expected so much from feminist in the west to form an army and fight for Iranians women's rights!!!.
Uh, what?
Glory to free Iran 🇮🇷💚🤍❤️
As someone who just lost his family to the Abrahamic Cult, never accept subjugation.
Very poorly prepared report !
No mention of the desire for regime change , Kurdish and other ethnic movements .
This is not about mandatory dressing , people want change of regime.
Women , Life , Freedom !
That protest song is a certified bop
There's no compultion in religion
- Quran, Al Baqarah 245
Islam is a proposition. It must not be forced.
Islam is scary religion
Smiling from heaven 🤍
She was a hijabi, so shes probly in heaven
@@isscaibnzehra8717how if she didn’t follow allahs will
@@HuHWhatOk what didn’t she follow?
@@isscaibnzehra8717 she didn’t cover like Quran command to
People should wear hijabs if they want to
In fact, I recommend that all the clerics in government wear a full burkha.
We'd rather not see them.
Shame to say but I don’t think they will ever change
Change is a rule of nature but for better or worse is depended on us Iranians
@@StormbringerI Good luck to you brother/sister. I hope thinks change for the better 🤝
@@StormbringerIGood luck with that , it took millions of US soldiers to hold against the Iranian soldiers , what are unarmed women gonna do !
freedom for Iran, Molla out of Iran.
ua-cam.com/video/CbnvoMnlM8k/v-deo.htmlsi=fSlx3TUoU1_Nt30-✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️
These old, arrogant and evil lawmakers will be seen enjoying belly dancing and not saying a word.
France taking lessons, telling women what they can and cant wear
Kurdish people never forget ; Mss. MAHSA JİNA AMİNİ..
Greetings from San Francisco..
Pl protest fr us
Free iran Kurdistan
@@solotrue45 / Thanks a lot for sharing..
Zan, Zindagi, Azadi!
ua-cam.com/video/CbnvoMnlM8k/v-deo.htmlsi=fSlx3TUoU1_Nt30-✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️
Mard! Zindagi azadi
AZADI!!!!
Zan, Zindagi, Aazzadi, Mahsa Amini.
Lanaath Bar Khomeini !
Do the Iranian people love the Israeli people?
I think they don’t
It depends on the individual. They're not nearly as anti-Israel as the Iranian government.
There are two groups of people in Iran - the moronic islamist extremists who bootlick the government - and the seculars who hate everything the government stands for. So yes, some Iranians love Israel.
@@bryanrey4024as an Iranian, the majority of the population love Israel, only some people support Palestine.
@@sinabarzyar5766 people should know that the situation of Israel and hamas conflict is started by hamas lol they just forgot what happened in October ber 7th and citizens celebrated the deaths of Israel people and now they pull the victim card and kill themselves on purpose on warzone instead of hiding underground with their fellow hamas 😂
In America, women have all the rights.
Some more than these but they still have limits (e.g. prohibition of abortion in some states right?)
@@capriccio3092 I can see that as a protection instead of oppression, even at the smallest degree. Like, we can't be 100% without rules
SAY HER NAME MAHSA AMINI✌️✌️
Politicians and Rulers have been the bane of world peace and freedom all over the world
(Jews) shaving your beard is a death sentence !!
(Cristians) not having a cross over your bed is a death sentence !!!
Whahaha who told you that another Muslim delulu world and fantasy
😢😢😢😢God help iranian woman
Us in the Is dont even know what a woman is
No, life goes on as usual some wannabe Europeans remain.
Sounds depreciating
Why double stand again million of people who died and suffer to this day in only one part i recalled about human in iraq
Hey, nice opinion on national customs😊😊😊
What is immoral about hair? Men have hair as well. There is nothing particularly sexual about a woman's hair especially if the woman is not pretty nor young. It is completely illogical especially in this day and age making a big deal over hair.
Biji Kurdistan ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
ua-cam.com/video/CbnvoMnlM8k/v-deo.htmlsi=fSlx3TUoU1_Nt30-✌️✌️✌️
Go girls 💪
This just shows Islam shia or Sunni is a problem, sad but true
Pls say it correctly is Mahsa Amini
You're saying the narrator pronounces her name incorrectly?
its good see freedom for woman.
What are the empoyerment in female decorum across global laws?❤❤❤😊😊😊😊😊
So sad
Why Raising regime will force it self in power has nothing to do with religion.
The fact behind fear and brutality is to remain in power as an empire using faith to control nation wealth as a culture.
Its illogical the Iranian regime is unstable under Islamic culture but UAE has advanced. this much.
Why are imams rejected!
Iran carry unwanted baggage of religion which is not them o e. Just discard that...
all my support for the Iranian woman, really what a bad religion
No.
Regime change. And the sooner the better.
در مقابله با زورمندان ناتوانیم . روی اوریم به خدای بینیاز . تا سزاواران صاحب اعمالی ناشایسته خود .
The Iranian government will not last guaranteed and alcohol will be allowed next
Party on When you can Iran
she would have been 23 :(
Yes, it's sad...she became a strong icon, just tragic that she had to die for that.
@ seanrm i think it’s not nice and you and respect less of you to Sau that because people are getting killed and what would you do if you would get killed for 2 strains of hair
women for freedom: 1 The regime: 0
The small protest didnt do anything
If you are a Muslim after all the nonsense the mullahs have done and still remain in that religion, I do not know what to say to you.
Great salute and well done to Iranian girls who are very brave to stand for women right and freedom and shame to idiot men and women who aren't supporting the women's movement.
shes becoming a martyr
been one.
All women may covert to christain for their safty by joao
What happened in Iran it’s not English business :)
من ایرانی هستم
Adam Family 4
💔🩸⚡️
Protests don't change anything!
It's a revolution. Ppl are fighting the regime in the street 💪🏼
@@Vashryn same people in power, try revolting in saudi
Hair is evil
You people are influenced by the so called western culture, Iran has it's own tradition and cunture and we respect Iran for their tradition, but the western trying to demolished Iran, that's why some people protesting against the present culture, but as a Muslim you should follow the Islamic tradition. ❤
You mean deleting people who doesn't practice it?
We only have the 🇺🇸 and 🇬🇧 to thank for this nasty regime. And we learned nothing….
ua-cam.com/video/C4gD7GAdM-U/v-deo.htmlsi=hwS1BfMCLxpw-FKU. 🇺🇲🇪🇺🤮🤮
Huh???
The US & UK didn't bring the current Iranian gov to power. Iran is an enemy of them.
No, the British nor the Americans didn't destroy our country, we ourselves did.
@@sinabarzyar5766 then shame on you
Funny how if you say that head scarfs and burkas should be banned in the UK the likes of Channel 4 would be the first to call you racist 😂
This is a SLANDEROUS story, against AYATOLLAH KHAMENEI and the government of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Mahsa Amini died of natural causes following her arrest in September 2022. Perhaps she should not have been arrested for failure to wear the hijab correctly. But she died of natural causes , likely to have been brought on by severe stress. It’s a fact that she had serious underlying health conditions.
The Islamic Republic of Iran DEMOCRATICALLY VOTED to become an ISLAMIC REPUBLIC, back in 1979. And that means the obligatory wearing of the hijab. We all have a right to be either an Islamic Republic or a KINGDOM, or a communist country, free liberal democratic country etc.
I am a UK citizen, born and raised in this country, from a non- religious background. I converted to Islam, mostly due to MALE MYSOGYNISM in the UK, back in the nineties ! I experienced such degrading treatment by British men towards women , that I ran to ISLAM!
The UK has committed SEVERE HUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES AGAINST ME , by locking me up for a total of FIFTY FOUR DAYS, stating that I was mentally unwell, based on SLANDEROUS COMMENTS about ME! I almost DIED OF FRIGHT! Just like Mahsa Amini. This country is HYPOCRITICAL. I am going to make a GIGANTIC COMPLAINT. Insha’Allah.
I smell a lot of bull**** here
@@moreplease998 NO! Are you telling me that MEN IN THE UK RESPECT WOMEN!?… I think you are suffering from DELUSIONAL BELIEFS.
@@annabanna8852 you're projecting now
@@moreplease998 I’m currently in Roseberry Park Hospital, Middlesbrough . This is my second stint locked up. I am currently on my 30 th day of this locking up! I had just come off my section 2, only to now be put on a section 3, pending. I could go on a section 3 on 18/09/23. This all began in December 2022, when I sectioned within 24 hours of making allegations that I could have possibly been sexually abused as a child. I’m calling out to this country , asking everybody band anybody to hear my voice, and help me to get released ! I am not mentally unwell, and was forced to take 10 mg of Olanzapine, a very high dose of an antipsychotic, that destroys the brain ! If I didn’t take it , I would have been injected. I pretended to take it. But never did. They now know this, and am terrified what they may do next.
Andy McDonald , MP for Middlesbrough has been begging the government for an Inquiry into this NHS Trust- TEES, ESK, WEAR VALLEYS MENTAL HEALTH NHS NHS TRUST, and its hospitals , ROSEBERRY PARK and WEST LANE hospital. Too many suicides have happened in them. Do your own research , and help this woman out…Me, Judith. Thank you.
@@moreplease998 I sent you a request to help me! What a total hypocrite ! Shame on you !
Hijob is the command of Allah (Azzawajal). Anti Hitjob demonstration is Blasphemy and according to the laws of old and new testament and Islam the violators should be subject to Death.
Maybe the world would be better off if Islam was wiped out
Oh please
Long live the Islamic Republic of Iran.
Proud to be Muslim and Iranian.
🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷🇮🇷
Get off the UA-cam
Iran 🇮🇷 is Shia 🤔
Shia & Sunni can both be oppressive.
go clean toilets muchacho, lol
@@davidz3879 oh no, homeless are here, lol
🇮🇷💩
@@syncopatedfeb4770 bro I am not Indian i am Somali Muslim I was asking if Iran is Shia or Sunni
💩💩
What about the Israeli protest no one talks even in Iran protest is very small in some cities and very less people in Israel there 30 percent population on roads . From last 1 years Iran protest coll down 6 months ago. Why propoganda against Iran always.
Because it suit them well
BS
you chaps tried to encourage a revolution in Iran and you failed. You are not good at this thing anymore because people are waking up to your shennanighans
religion is like scarlet rot.
Why is that? If you want objectively to evaluate a religion then read it's scripture and history instead of focusing on what some people presumably "following this religion " are doing. The you can get to a conclusion.
@@kelanitweir4994 Men created gods, men created religions, men wrote books , scripts for their religions, men do what they wrote in their own books or scripts.
So yes, I agree with you. It's not the religion, it's those men who created all these and still following it and forcing it on others too. They are responsible for everything that has been done yet, in the name of their own religions.
@@infinity-r8f ok how about I prove to you that what you've said is completely false , then afterwards you make your own decision.
First the idea of religion is not man made. If it was , then how a new research conducted by a psychologist called Justin Barrett on babies demonstrated an inclination for believing in God? ( read his books born believers and Cognetive science religion and thiology) .
Secondly, the world didn't came out from nothing. Science today claim that the universe is 13.8 billion years, so it is not eternal, which clearly raise a question, how and what made us ? The answer is a powerful and knowledgeable entity that have a will decided to make something from nothing, and all the universe is dependent on him and he is independent of anything.
Such powerful entity must have created us for a purpose don't you think? And in order to give us guidance, he sent messengers and prophets. That is why we muslims believe that all the prophets were sent by God with a message but only the Quran remains unchanged by the wicked people.
Then comes the challenge of the Quran, the Quran refers to some scientific facts that are known known for mankind till very recently; like the expantion of the universe in chapter 51 verse 47 . Also it clearly points that the sky is protective for mankind in chapter 21 verse 32 . Today, not only the Ozone layer protect us from solar waves but also the electromagnetic field of the earth has a protective effect against solar winds.
Another one is the origin of iron which is extra terrestrial, and the Quran clearly mention it in chapter 57 verse 25( We have sent down iron in which there is great might and diverse benefit for people) .
The question is how the Quran, which was revealed 1400 years ago knows about these facts? And there is plenty more but I don't want to make this comment longer than it should be. What is your opinion?
oh no, the homeless is back, lol@@infinity-r8f
They should shave their heads bald too the cool breeze feels good on the head with no hair on it.
Good for you lady's sum rules and laws are just in the past.
Allah is dishonouring them like He's doing with the west. Good.
i live in iran and i just know we feel death everyday with this leader and Government 😪
ok
bot, lol
Who cares
No one
wHO caRESSESW
Goofy
🥲🥲
Thank you channel 4 for covering this. You're raising awareness!!
그대의 영혼,
이 나라에 오십시오.
그 더러운 나라에 계시지 말고.
Only Iran & Afghanistan have this law.
You're right, but if you look at the other side of the spectrum, france has banned the hijab and the abaya , too.
@@kelanitweir4994 France applied that rule only for students in schools and colleges, to wear the exact uniform, they didn't applied that law in the whole country. And they don't arrest and kill them for wearing a hijab.
what about Saudi Arabia? I agree about Afghanistan which is worst than Saudi Arabia.
You left out Saudi Arabia
@@infinity-r8f It doesn't mandate head-coverings, though they're commonplace.