NATO agrees to bolster Ukraine's air defenses | DW News
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 тра 2024
- Defense ministers of NATO countries have promised Ukraine early support for its air defense. This was stated by NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg after the consultations held via videoconference in Brussels. The Norwegian did not say who made the promises after the meeting of the so-called NATO-Ukraine Council. Concrete announcements will be made by individual member states in the coming days. According to Stoltenberg, countries that do not have their own air defense systems have pledged to provide financial support for the purchase of systems for Ukraine.
Chapters
00:00 Russia's Strategy Helps Achieve Limited Success in Ukraine
04:03 Katarzyna Zysk, Norwegian Institute for Defense Studies
07:19 Olesya Vinhas de Souza, NATO Defense College
#ukrainerussiawar #airdefencesystem #nato
Subscribe: ua-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
The slower the aid the greater the chance for Russian to win the war
Our chances are now about.. 100%. Ukraine was forbidden to surrender until November, when Biden is re-elected
Nato are just dead slow in sending any aid to ukraine a snail could do it faster even!
No matter how much aid or money the UrkNazi regime gets, the Urks are running out of season cannon fodders
Why rely on aid? Why don't they buy military hardware from abroad like russia does? Would negate any political risk.
Russia has won already.
The Russian army facing equipment and weapons shortages? Are these guys serious?
Why are the Russians using such antiquated equipment?
Please provide a plausible explanation why, for the last month or two, the Russians have begun to carry their assault troops across extremely muddy terrain with ATVs, motorcycles, and 'softskin' trucks, in order to attack Ukrainian fortifications. This is not a rare scenario! If the Russians had plenty of tanks, IFVs and APCs, they would be using them to carry their troops into battle, just as they did for two years.
@@andyhurrell This is simple. When you have old stock and you are building new ones, which one do you expel first?
Logic dictates that you use your old equipment and replace them with newer stockpiles. This is also what the US says it's doing in it's inventory when trying to appease the people why it needs to continue providing equipment to Ukraine.
😂😂😂 They recycle the same lie every month. Next is Russia is running out of missiles, then the next day 404 get 100.😂😂😂
@@andyhurrell Same reason US asked other countries to send old Soviet eqmt to Ukr in 2022. Best to lose old stock while building up new stockpiles for a bigger fight (Nato v Rus)
Why has it taken this long???
Cause the government officials are too busy fighting amongst themselves like usual
Stop whining about it. It will take it will take as much as that as well but you don't have to say it. Why is it? Why has it taken this long?
😢
They won't take Ukraine
Waiting for the USA to spend the money and weapons
Why Have You ALL Made Them Beg For Help. They’re The Most Innocent And NO ONE DOES A FN THING??
wtf?
There is absolutely no doubt that many 'western' nations have had their governments & economies seriously compromised because they have been infiltrated by/entangled with Russian oligarchs, pro-Russian operatives & propagandists, and pro-Russian politicians (..who serve the needs of rich/powerful individuals/corporations closely connected with Russian oligarchs..). The Russian influence in the policies & decision-making in some 'western' nations has resulted in 'roadblocks' & great pressure on well-intentioned 'western' leaders/governments to do as little as possible to enrage Putin or (supposedly) escalate the conflict. Fortunately, some leaders/governments have prevented Russian influence on their decision-making, and, consequently, they have shown focus & strength by supporting Ukraine as much as they can, regardless of what Putin says. These nations include all the Baltic states, all Scandinavian nations, France, Belgium, the Czech Republic, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, the U.K., and some others. It seems to me that the U.S.A., and Germany are the most problematic nations, and IMHO, only severe public pressure will push their leaders/goverments/Ruling Classes to do more, do it faster, and do it with the aim of total defeat of Russian forces in Ukraine.
Apart from the contributions of our respective governments we can all be saviours of freedom and contribute to containing Russia. For example, by donating to Ukraine24 which funds drone programmes.
@@TauNomm
How do one do that?
Asking for a friend.
Because of the republican party who opposed Ukraine entirely.
2:30 "The Russian Army facing equipment and weapon shortages ..." We've heard that lie over and over. In reality Russian war machine fires up to 10 times more shells then their opponent.
I guess they are out of showels and washing machine chips
North Korea has really come thru
If North Korea came through, what happened to 27 countries combined weapons when they came through?
They need F-16's, tons of ammunition, etc. They should have been given everything they needed 2 years ago.
That’s all well and fine. But until they secure new, trained soldiers all that stuff is meaningless if you don’t have the personnel trained to use it. Not too mention these soldiers will have to gain some experience in combat. Many of the more experienced soldiers are either KIA, wounded or exhausted. Weapons mean nothing without the human factor. This ain’t call of duty where you can just over again if you get lit up.
@MikeDarr61 they had them 2 years ago. The advantage was squandered because the West didn't supply the ammunition that they promised
@@MikeDarr61 Yeah, this isn't COD. Their soldiers were fully trained and they had enough of them 2 years ago. That's why I said they should have been given EVERYTHING they needed 2 years ago.
Most important they need trained personal but they don’t have many left
The f16s are not being provided in an amount that will make much of a difference, almost certainly will have no impact on the eventual outcome. Furthermore, why should they be given anything? Why do you so vehemently support one autocratic regime over another?
Even they dont believe what they are saying
Even you don't believe what you're saying
Too little too late?
not enough too late.
legends say the meat grinders are still grinding. to this day.
Shame to cowards. How long time do You need to understand situation in Ukraine?
It is Ukraine that doesn't understand it is being played just to help NATO bleed Russia out, until the last Ukrainian. Sure, it's Russia who is the actual invader here, but without NATO Ukraine would have lost only 10k soldiers and and Russia 15k. With NATO there will be 500k Ukrainians and 750k Russians gone.
They do understand the situation, that’s why they don’t wanna keep wasting money and taking a loss
The situation in Ukraine was very well known from day one: no way for them to win a war against the Mother country!
Slava 🇹🇼
@@HEMI345Syes I heard they had 3 days to live.
Weird how the biggest armed forces in the world with just 7 patriot missiles.
Look trollski, learn some English. 😂😂😂
@@TheTwangKingsspeak only when spoken to…Zelensky said now you have to go serve in the East on the front somewhere like Ivanivske or chasing yar!
What are you on about? Nothing you wrote makes one iota of sense.
@@TheTwangKingsUkrobot is triggered 😂
@@Mr.Clownensky trolski is drunk on shoe polish.
Thanks NATO countries but Ukraine needs them fast please. 🙏🇺🇦💙💛💕❤️🇨🇦
I don’t know if they lying so much or they just ignorant.
They lie and choose to be ignorant. That's their way of life.
They agreed? Wow! Somehow they managed to be slower than the Ents talking among themselves in LOTR.
They?
The losing side talking about the weakness of the winning side😂😂😂
About time they stepped up!!
Way too late
Apart from the contributions of our respective governments we can all be saviours of freedom and contribute to containing Russia. For example, by donating to Ukraine24 which funds drone programmes.
The west almost entirely bankrolls every facet of the ukranian government.
This was has given the Russian military the best training they could ask for.
It's rather hard to gain experience when the people who are supposed to be learning are dropping like flies.
who are the Russians planning to fight? if it's NATO then nobody in Europe is trembling. LOL
Again you are telling us Russia is struggling 😂😂😂😂
But they are struggling. Russia is supposed to be the second strongest nation in human history and they have failed to take 1/10 of Ukraine in a war that's lasted around 2 years
In other news Northern Europe fails to explain why it took a month & a half to unseat themselves from their hands.
Well said
Last year, the EU approved 12 sanction packages against Russia and the Russian economy grew 3%. Meanwhile, the German economy is in "tatters". The EU sanctioned itself.
Russia has implemente fuel export restrictions for 6 months starting March 1 to avoid fuel shortages at home. War has helped Russian economy though - for sure
@@icu17siberia WW2 brought the US economy out of the depression. but the sting in the tail for Russia is the hyper-inflation that is just around the corner.
We cannot let Ukraine lose
And what YOU are going to do?
Hieee@@amalia_ag
Why not?
Then send in the troops from US and NATO. Otherwise ... Ukraine already lost.
@@amalia_ag what he's doing.
About time they are finally stepping up.
The clown 🤡
Same lies like Russia suffered heavy losses but Ukraine has no soldiers.
Wagner alone claimed to have lost 40,000 more than a year ago
The war on screens looks sweet with imaginative ideas. It looks like no one wants this special operation/war to stop.
0:30 Never doubt the Russians. Where is the political will to support the Ukrainians.
Perhaps you need to spend the next month reading & watching news reports from February 2022 (...from non-Russian sources of course...). The fact is that, while 'western' democracies have been slow to provide everything the Ukrainians need, there are over 50 allied nations involved in providing humanitarian & military aid to Ukraine.
I never doubt ruZZia, putins circus is so funny
The big Euro countries have committed a lot of money, but are lightly armed, and afraid to send too many of their weapons to Ukraine and then be short themselves. This is exacerbated by the Euros' bureaucracy.
@@SpringIsBACKthey have nuclear weapons. Even if they are short on regular weapons they can use their nukes.
@@derekbaker3279 I don't consume Russia sources. It's obvious that the Ukrainians are losing ground. Russia historic does poorly in the early phase of a war, then recover, see Great Northern War, the Patriotic War, the Winter War, and World War II.
😂 Himars game changer, leopards, etc etc now the Patriots the game changer😂 lets see what Russia has up its sleeve.😂
US and UK rush to protect Israel against Iran but cant do the same for Ukraine
Israel is an ally and Ukraine is a proxy.
Beacuse Iran is not a Nuclear superpower. Russia is a nuclear superpower.
@Aaronsmith-cu8ii and Israel is not Ukraine..
@@andreiapostu Israel is an ally, Ukraine is an investment.
That's what Zelenskiy said in front of the UN and I think he has a point.
BTW Iran, North Korea, Russia ... all best friends of China.
l guess you’ve perfected the art of mixing lies, truth and wishful thinking and present it as news. Its an amazing skill.
*When you have women who hardly go to the warfornt as analyst, then know nothing good is coming out of that!*
Western aid to Ukraine is pathetic and pathetic. Ukraine needs munitions and air defense against Russia's massive military industry. Ukraine is not capable of producing a similar arms industry as Russia. Russia, the USA and the UK promised in the Budapest memorandum to protect Ukraine when it handed over its nuclear weapons to Russia. Russia did not keep this promise and illegally attacked the independent state of Ukraine in violation of international agreements. The West must secure Ukraine's independence.
well, Russia didnt do much on trump presidency....
Ukraine could delay its loses by playing the long game but choose to suic6
@@skarhabekgreyrukh8601 You speak as if Ukraine had any choice in this. Russia attacked. There was no long game to play.
@@TheOriginalJphyper they have, notice why Russia never attack Ukraine? Putin is man of pride, pretend to be buddy buddy and you done.... like what trump did
Whatever happened to the F-16s?
They are coming (being said for at least 18-months) and the pilots need training (being said for at least a year). Delay long enough and Ukraine will lose, then everyone can stand around bragging about how much they did to help Ukraine, but, gee guess Ukraine wasn't good enough to win -so sorry!
@@WarHawk-it will face the same fate as those indestructible leopards and abrams lol
Ukraine didnt need F16 lol... they need more mobile arty and anti air
@@Mr.Clownensky - No one ever said Leopards or Abrams were 'indestructible'. What they allow is for the better survival of the crew, unlike Russian tanks that burst into flame from the inside-out killing the crew.
@@WarHawk- Ukrainians really thought that Abrams and Leopards would greatly help them, but it turned out that cheap Russian drones burn these tanks like matches.
And yeah, all media called these tanks gamechangers
😂😂 if Russia was using human wave like Ukraine, then you would see Russia kidnapping people off the streets like Ukraine
Very true...its only the western media don't speak truth
God bless Ukraine 🇺🇦 🇺🇦🇺🇦❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏
Slava 🇹🇼
God already blessed Ukraine with a J president and a patronage from US and NATO. What do you want more?
Apart from the contributions of our respective governments we can all be saviours of freedom and contribute to containing Russia. For example, by donating to Ukraine24 which funds drone programmes.
I pray for Ukraine and the rest of Europe . Putin must be stoped
What religion are you by the way? Please exclude me from your prayers.
@@amalia_ag whos side are u on may i ask??????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Others see US and NATO should be stopped. And Russia has done it.
Where do you get these analysts? They seem ignorant compared to UA-camr analysts.
Something people should know. Europe is short on Patriots themselve.Also each Patriot battery cost about 1.3 billion usd. Also numbers to be given are never mentionned . This sounds like typical European BS . How can one tell its BS ? It has that particular odour
You can smell the stench. The idea is weakening the russians. You wont give enough weapons to the ukranians to win the war, you want to keep the russians to allocate quite a lot of their resources to this war. That should slow China, the main dish on the plate of the US. Its all politics.
Noted
Why are we not helping Ukraine?
The goal was never to "help" Ukraine. The goal was to convince the taxpayer to accept that their elected reps. would hand over their tax money to the western military industrial complex...so the shareholders that own the armaments businesses could rake in massive profits and the politicians could say they were "helping" Ukraine. Those are the only people being "helped". That's why even though Ukraine is being badly beaten, the war MUST continue...because the flow of money MUST continue. And you can tell that the western elites already know that the war is lost in Ukraine, because they are already whipping up their citizens about the next conflict between China and Taiwan...and then we will agree to "help" Taiwan. Not that I'm a fan of rock'n'roll or Creedence Clearwater Revival , but John Fogerty nailed it when he wrote in a line from "Fortunate Son", "And when we ask them , "How much should we give ?" they only answer more, More, MORE !"
Who stops you to go to Ukraine and help? Here on DW they brought an "expert" and she said "you are allowed".
Sanctions and the 2023 offensive were supposed to "win" the war
USA is on to their next atrocity
you werent helping because trump was blocking the aid, using his puppet mike johnson. now trump agreed to help because his popularity started to plummet and he is afraid it may make him lose the elections
because we are not loud enough!
When there is a hypersonic missile that changes direction and speed and is launched from Russia, visits Poland for 20 seconds, flies over Moldova from the north and hits a target object in Ukraine from the south, then we really have nothing to talk about. Air defense does not help here. Only negotiations!!!
lots of words but no deeds, that is what we see. Lets vote our politicians out of office.
i mean, what would you do? wait until ukraine fortifies its positions even more before attacking? so they can lose even more troops?
Not true, Russia's advance has stalled. Ukraine is holding the front line. Russia spent all it had to take Advika
hahahaha
Comedian in cargo pants is this you?
You have a "deep understanding" of the situation. DW/RFE would be proud of you.
@@stevewake6614 Well look at it this way. ruZZia occupied 30% of Ukraine in 2022, now they only infest 19%...
That’s great but why is it so slow!
Slava ukraine
😂😂😂
Slava 🇹🇼 Heroyam TAIWANese 🦾
You sound like Nancy Pelosi. Now, that's an achievement.
@@amalia_ag I think you are projecting... A 2 word slogan of support spoken by millions could not possibly have so narrow minded an interpretation
The EU should go up and beyond to let Ukraine win !
well ..ukraine is done ...the biggest loser !!!!
Why? EU loves to let USA defend it. EU money goes for students to party in Erasmus scholarships.
@@joeschmoe21 what's your point ?
@@joeschmoe21 Education is important, but you are right. The money needs to be found somewhere.
@@Thomas-us4wq My point is EU will never fight Russia or anyone else, because they don't want to, nor does Russia want to fight EU. Germany is full of mosques now. Russia does not need that. And EU folks are into partying and drinking, particularly young people. So... EU neither can nor needs to get involved with Ukraine.
A just cause
War is never justified, but it can be necessary in order to stop an attacker like Russia.
"nato" will NEVER "agree". They MUST and have to do everything that is requested. The entire "union" is basically to please the demands of USA by restricting the growth of Russia.
Yeah, boy, that mechanical difficulty was a patriot enema
Bots here on Masse
American bots
Your mom? How dare you...
@@africa...foodandlifestyle5511 Amasende Iyakho ya sala mva fana ingundaan. Spelling and gramma may be wrong , but you get the message
@@africa...foodandlifestyle5511 The usual suspects... Russian, Serbian, Belorussian, Hungarian, Slovakian.... and yes... reactionaries in America, reactionaries in Britain, reactionaries in Australia, and elsewhere.
You r out of touch mate
The proxy war in Ukraine is the first time NATO has tried to pick on someone their own size and NATO is getting humiliated.
Very funny how they speak for themselves but never alow Russia to speak, instead they speak on behalf of Russia 😂😂😂
Hey sillyzally, afraid no understand wat u speak.
Do you ask a criminal what he thinks when he invades your place?
@@alhambrabiker1476 we will see who will win the conflict thank God me and family are far from Europe, war hunger....
@@zallyzally2698 war hunger is Putin who started the war.
@@alhambrabiker1476and are you a man of peace when you put American missile on you lands to attack the Russians in the future. What do your expect that Putin will do. The question is so simple. Put the NATO is too far and the people of the world 🌎 will be happy.
what they do??
Who could fight with out Air
Well, it's been 10 days...any deliveries from Europe yet? maybe 1 per country?
Video footage shows the bomber falling out of the sky. Any crash that occurred did so when the bomber hit the ground. Is "the malfunction during the combat mission" Russian secret code for "shot done " ?
Russia is the most accident-prone nation the world has ever known.
lol
добре
now we are talking.
They will last 1 month or 2.😂
@@timmy-wj2hc ...one year old account. A bot emoticon at the end. lol.
@@80-80. If you believe everything that this channel is saying , I have a slightly used bridge to sell you ,dear.
@@edvsilas8281 that comment is meant for THE SUN, read you script.
‘spring offensive’ ... ‘a real game changer’
‘summer offensive’ ... ‘a real game changer’
‘autumn offensive’ ... ‘a real game changer‘
..... rinse/repeat as the M.I.C. shekels flow ever faster.
‘$lava ! $lava !’
'3 day SMO'
'2 year war'...
Talk only , will DW have chance to follow up report Youkrain receive them ??
so in two years from now, Ukraine can expect 2 new Patriot systems?
Toooooooo few , too late,
Toooo few, toooo late
Today (saturday) in the early evening (washington time) U.S. will have a vote for (finally) releasing 60Bn $ going to UA war effort after being delayed for months . Its the single most important decision for Ukraine in over two years. Lets hope the bill will pass
Everybody agrees and promises, but does anyone DELIVER according to promises?
The answer is NO!
Any words from Putin and Russia council mean nothing the world.
Putin lies, he always lies.
Definitely not to that puny fairytale worldlet in yer head created by media, bot. 🙈🙉🙊
Not to the 🇺🇸 and its Europawns.😂
But to the rest, 90% of the population, it does.
You're wrong. During Putin’s broadcasts on Ru channels, I see hundreds of Ukrainians. They are waiting for what he will tell them and how he will determine their fate.
@@timmy-wj2hchaha the Chyna poo Han using a VPN to give his 1 cent
Ukraine will win they will
No one wins a war
😅😅
Russia wins
@@northernlights9637 Russia has won
@@northernlights9637 tell that to Germany then they seem to have lost 2 thats why today there Navy and Air force is weaker than Australia but 80 years ago it would of been 10 times stronger and a super power
Ukraine is winning and winning bigly on TV and media.
So tell me what's the difference between these Patriots and the ones that got blown up 🤔
Why they allow to lie on the air so easy
DW reads the comments below..you can't fool us
past 2 years so much air defence sent by western countries. Where have these gone ?😂😂😂
Ukraine is a large country, you clever smart... put some patriot air defense systems around Mumbay and then wonder, what "happened to All the other Patriot air defense systems" 🙄😂
Here's what I don't "get". It's good the US is going to plug in another $61 billion in support. (Even tho' I can't afford my taxes already!)
But, dang it, if the Euro weapons manufacturers can't produce enough weapons, fast enough, there are several categories where the US still has VERY deep stocks - some a bit old, but still better than most Russian gear. The S. Koreans can build good stuff to NATO spec too.
Buy from the US and S. Korea. Kick in some tech or mutual aid for the S. Koreans as incentive if need be. (The S. Koreans are a bit reluctant to supply Ukraine directly, but obviously have no problem selling to the Poles.)
🤦🏾♀️
Excuse me, but why do you have Russians as commentators? Doesn't it seem strange to you? Why don't you have Ukrainian experts as commentators?
Apparently there are no such crazy people left anymore
You must be new, they always have pro Ukraine and western commentators.
Ukrainian war experts are needed in frontline.😂
Who? "de Souza"? She is "Ukrainian" or "from Ukraine".
I think Norwegians are skimping on personell, that Polish lady is quoting 2 years old estimates. According to IMF Russian economy is growing much faster than all western ones. She deserves living wage, poor thing have not seen TV news or checked news on internet in a long time.
An issue the western world needs to address with air defense is cost efficiency. We are good at dealing with modern aircraft and ballistic missiles, but we are way to reliant on these same systems to handle cheap cruise missiles and drones. Doing like Israel and using 1.5 million dollar missiles to shoot down 20 thousand dollar drones is not a viable way of winning a war of attrition. We really need to up our game in laser defense and electronic warfare capabilities if we insist on keep dominating the world militarily.
Patriot missile system they now call batteries is over 1 b $ each. It also protects the USA White house.
according to google, Prof. Zysk was born in 1960, making her 64 years of age.
Twelve minutes of crazy.
Thank you, EU!
FEU Victoria Nuland . . . :)
@@markojuric4954 GFY. ruzki !!
Israel vs rusia, mungkin solusi dari ketengangan ukraine, salah satu membantu ukraine
There is no cure for hypersonic, though 😂
Bs hypersonic already knocked out like 6 times
I’m thinking of getting half of a NATO tattoo. Why? Because it’s aspirational.
Either way the bomber is down..
This people should research of the meaning Meat Grinder and look at the past world wars , Japanese, Chinese wars
About time someone besides the US funds Ukraine
Ukraine needs more support
Most likely too late
Be a shame if we need them ourselves
Zelensky admitted that Ukraine had no intention to honor the Minsk agreements. Who didn't want peace? Who advised against the 2022 peace talks in April?
Hint: someone visited Zelensky in Kiev at that time.
What if Russia capture this defence system??🌚🌚
how ? with the mobic cube tent ?? we all know what goes on in there....
Isn’t their bs s-400 way more advanced?
It is almost impossible, this system operates 10’s of miles behind front lines.
@@dennisestradda9746 Yet it still gets shot down easily.
They can't 'borrow' fast enough, so in reality, they cant afford to😅
its a pretend loan.
So we give to a country that didn't want nato but refuse one that needs nato
To become NATO member state = a country has to fulfill the needed criteria for joining...
Ukraine didn't fulfill the needed criteria before the war...same goes for EU membership...
But still NATO and EU27 member states are supporting Ukraine...
@@saba1030 exactly sooooo if they didn't fulfill the requirements why are these countries sending trillions to them.... there's ppl in each country that need help instead we seems aid to countries while letting our own ppl go w out
@@victoriad8515 >why are these countries sending trillions to them
cos they (Ukraine) dumb enough to die just to irritate Russia for these countries.
Taiwan not even a country. Even US don't recognize it. If US didn't want to irritate China nothing had happened.
"Meat Grinder" strategy. How long is not only about bodies, but finances to pay for the acts, and at current RUS cannot afford more than 6 more months like this, but if we allow UKR to fail based on financing (not lives) within the 6 months then RUS will recoup it's economic losses (Putin does not care about the lives lost -- they will 'encourage' births again) in the territory gained.
Slava Ukraini!
Slava Donbas 🤡…Ukraine is part of the Russian Empire
Estimados alemanes, franceses, ingleses y europeos en general. Debido a la increible inteligencia que han mostrado sus lideres para con su gente, le hice esta compocisión:
Europa va a la guerra do re mi, fa so la
Europa va a la guerra y USA se reirá
do re mi, fa so la, y USA se reirá
Europa va a la guerra do re mi, fa so la,
Europa va a la guerra y no la pararán
do re mi, fa so la, y no la pararán
Europa va a la guerra do re mi, fa so la
Europa va a la guerra y nadie quedará
do re mi, fa so la, y nadie quedará
Europa va a la guerra do re mi, fa so la
Europa va a la guerra y todos morirán
do re mi, fa so la, y todos morirán.
About time too
Bot 🤣
Allowing the Azov to fly, this should be interesting!