coolstar mac I think she meant that Alison as a character was acting/lying about what really happened that night, still. There are a lot of theories out there that Alison was the one who killed Bethany and that her mom was really burrying Bethany and telling Alison "What have you done?" while doing so.
Peek At Chu But in all offense Ali did LIE about dying . So tbh those girls spent bout 7 years of there life’s being tortured for something they didn’t do
WORLDWIDE DD well she had no other choice and she constantly risked her life to save them even when she was in hiding. And the liars aren't innocent. If they didn't have such terrible secrets in the first place they wouldn't have been easy targets for blackmail.
Peek At Chu most of the lies the liars had to keep secrets were for their parents. And if the liars aren’t innocent, Alison is worse. Let’s be honest, they didn’t hurt or torture anyone. Alison did tho.
This family is messed up... -Jessica ended up having a twin who apparently no one knew about and she kept it a secret. -Jessica was buried alive. -Charlotte/Charles basically tortured his own sister and friends for years. -Jessica made her husband thinks Charles was dead. -No one knew or remembered Charles. -Mary Drake is somehow Spencer's mother. -Spencer had an evil twin all along, who eventually tried to kill her -Jason hooked up with his own brother without even knowing. -Charlotte somehow ended up being trans (not saying being trans is bad, just that it was messed up how it was kept a secret) -Idk how many times Jessica has cheated on Kenneth. -Ali was buried alive by her own mother. AND THE WORST ONE OF ALL: -Jason kissed Hanna's mom and they literally went on a date
Wow, I just saw this scene while in the midst of marathon-ing the series and this was some seriously stellar acting by Sasha Pieterse! Up until this point, Allison seemed like a cold-blooded, heartless human being. But this scene humanized her character. She's so different from the mean girl in the flashbacks.
@Daniella Georgiou-Norman how is it harder to play a gay woman? Are you insane? You basically just have to kiss girls instead of boys. How is that harder than playing any other role? Her job is literally to act, meaning PRETENDING. She’s just pretending with girls the same way she would pretend with boys... This being said, Shay’s the worst actress of them all lmao. She’s okay, she’s fine, I’m not saying she’s bad. But she’s not THAT convincing.
@Daniella Georgiou-Norman i actually liked Shay the most out of the cast, but acting-wisez she just had a worried expression most if the time... I personally prefer the other actor's acting over hers. And I don't see why it's so hard to play a gay character...? I'm gay myself and it's not like we are a different breed or something lol it's not that difficult to portray a gay person
Unbelievable that it was Ali's own brother who did this to her. Shame on Mrs. DiLaurentis for letting him get away with that and shame on Mr. Hastings for not telling anyone about Jasons psycho twin. I feel so bad for Ali and Spencer. :'(
Ninja master there was no such episode!!! We still don't know for sure it was Charles who hit Ali! Although its more than likely, we are still trying to figure out whether or not he was that person. Plus he ain't Jason's twin. There will be an episode, 6×10 which is supposed to reveal a lot of things and answer a few quetions, but, you know, its Pretty little LIARS so, you never know whats right, whats wrong :):):) lol
KaylaSwEet06 what about... Jason? I mean, i know he was drunk but... nevermind. How about Bethany then? I know she is supposed to be dead, but its either that she isnt dead or she hit Ali before she was murdered. This would actually make sense because Mrs D would not want to reveal anything about Bethany, plus it would make no sense to report her when she is dead (because she died that night, after that.) Thats just a theory.Plus, i didnt say Charles NEVER hit her. I just said we dont know that for sure
Georgia Evan Who in that town has that much power over a Delarentis (or however you spell it). Her face looked shocked like she knew that person and couldn't believe what that person had done.
***** Yeah but in the books, Ali had a twin, (she was in the mental hospital, Courtney,) and one day when Ali was visiting her she made Ali look like Courtney, aka her, and Ali stay in the hospital. That's probably the person the police found and thought was Ali, when it was her twin, and Ali killed Courtney, for revenge for keeping her in the mental hospital for years, and Ali HATED all of those girls, Spencer, Hanna, Aria, and Emily. But since it was the first people Courtney saw, she made a group. Sooo..
It has to be someone who has dirt on Mrs D. Something so big that she wasn't willing to go to jail for. Perhaps the person who tried to kill Ali had this dirt on Mrs D and was/is blackmailing her.
It is probably Jason. Think about it! Jason was in the N.A.T club and they basically had dirt on everybody. plus that would explain why Mrs D buried Ali because she thought Ali was dead and didnt want a dead kid and a kid in prison
Bek Grace thats so true! Just the only thing is idk if its a little to easy for pll you know? Maybe its someone we have no idea she is connected to even so then it comes as a shock when we finally learn about it :)
Mrs.Marin also said that the flash drive had videos of adults as well, who they assumed was Mona (now we know it wasn't) maybe it had Mrs.D too, and Jason was in the N.A.T
Watching this in July 2017. Of all the scenes of this show, this clip is something I will always remember. Sasha's delivery between 1:45 - 2:06 and 2:25 - 2:33 is so unbelievably captivating. Chills me to the bone every. single. time.
Rewatching this I'm actually starting to appreciate the fact that CeCe is -A. Now that we saw the full scene in 6x10 and seeing CeCe's reaction to Mrs. D saying "What have you done?!" There is no one else that I can picture in that role. Vanessa Ray was fantastic in that episode
This scene makes sense when u find out who the real and original A is, that’s why Alison’s mum was pointing the finger at Spenser- this comment on makes sense to the people that have watch all episodes of PLL x
0:24 we all assume that's Alison but i'm not convinced. We think it's Ali falling to her knees and then on her stomach but if you look closely, Ali fell sidways to the right at 0:23. My theory, Melissa buried Bethany, Ali went back to the barn to wait for a text (in that time ,someone pulled Bethany out), Ali went home and Bethany hit her with the rock. 0:24 , thats Bethany dropping the rock with her left hand (that's why Ali fell to the right when she was hit), the blood that fell on the rock is Bethany's from when she was hit by the shovel, and then she falls to her knees in exhaustion wearing the exact same outfit as Ali.
Shedde i have the same exact theory , but who hit Bethany ? could it be Spencer ? because Ali told her that she went back to sleep however when the girls woke up she wasn't in the barn and she was saying she thought she heard Ali screaming ( maybe screaming because Spencer was after her with the shovel ), but the girl that Melissa buried had an A- written on her head with blood and Mona was A at the time .
What confuses me is that Charles is dead and has died long ago and that means it's not Charles. In the recent episode the liars said that A is pretending to be Charles after the real Charles died? So that leaves us back to where we started. I think that The A team has spencer Hanna and ezra because spencer is the girl in the coffin in the song secret and when they look at aria they are all actually looking at Hanna then at aria but it only lasts for a millisecond so u have to pay close attention. And Ezra because he was pretending to be into aria then he was pretending to be a teacher so he can get close to her, but when she finds out he tells her he is in love with her but how do we no he isn't lying? So he must be helping them in a way
With all the writers and producers claiming they are staying away from the “Ali has a twin” plot line, I still believe SOMEONE has to have a twin because of all the twin references and hidden images they’ve included in the show. So…I think that Jason has a twin. A twin SISTER, one who has been in Radley. Jason’s twin would therefore be a Hastings, explaining Mrs. D’s comment about “You can never turn your back on a Hastings.” It would also explain Peter Hastings’ involvement with Radley and Mrs. D. I think the twin escaped the night that Ali was fake-murdered and that’s why Mrs. D was on the phone asking for an update…”Please send someone. I’m worried.” AKA send someone from the hospital to pick up my crazy daughter. If Jason’s twin sister was the one who bashed Ali on the head, that would explain why Mrs. D was protecting the murderer by stashing Ali’s body in the ground. Maybe she knew she was still alive-she knew Ali could hold her breath for a long time-so maybe she wanted the twin to BELIEVE Ali was dead so she wouldn’t keep coming after her. Then Ali escaped and ran away before Mrs. D could get back to her. Mrs. D was not at all surprised when Det. Holbrook told her that he didn’t think the body in the grave was Ali’s-because she already knew that Ali wasn’t dead. However, Ali may not have realized what her mother was doing (remember, she didn’t see who hit her, so she wouldn’t necessarily know that her mom was trying to protect another one of her offspring) which is why she seemed hesitant to let her mom know that she was alive. If her mom was trying to find her, this would also explain why Ezra thought she might be A. So now the twin believes that she’s killed Ali, and she disappears again/goes back to Radley. Mona continues her A game with the Liars, but all of “Mona/A“‘s threats are related to the girls’ secrets, NOT to finding Ali. At some point “the game was stolen” from Mona, and A began to give the Liars hints and clues, trying to help them find Ali-because *A* wanted to find Ali and needed the girls to help. This would fit perfectly with the timeline because Mona said that the game was taken from her when she went to Radley. Well, if she was at Radley with the twin, then maybe she confided in her or otherwise let it slip that Ali was alive, and THAT’S when the twin took on the role of A, so she could find her half-sister and kill her for real this time. (I don’t have a solid motive for the twin wanting Ali dead, except that there isn’t anyone in Rosewood who didn’t want Ali dead at some point so I think motive might be kind of moot.) In the finale it was revealed that Ali hadn’t slept with Ezra OR Ian, so who was her pregnancy scare? Could it have been Wilden or someone else? We know that Wren has privileges at Radley, so perhaps he was the twin’s doctor and knew the family that way. Maybe Ali slept with him, the twin found out, and went bonkers because she loved him, or something. If Wren knew there was another sibling, maybe he told Melissa at some point-they were close enough that they got engaged so I don’t think it would be improbable that he told her. Melissa has always seemed to know more about what’s going on than Spencer, so this would make sense. Melissa was also involved with the NAT club-maybe she knew there was another sibling already through that, or her friendship with Jason. Maybe that’s why Melissa said she knew that Spencer didn’t kill “that girl”. The question still remains, who is in Ali’s grave? There were very few people who knew that Ali wasn’t actually dead, so one of them had to have had a motive for making sure that everyone believed Ali was dead. Mainly, Mrs. D-she wouldn’t have wanted the twin to find out that Ali was still out there, so somehow she was able to replace the body in her backyard and put Ali’s clothes on it. She also would have been the one making the ID of the body and she could have lied to police (everyone else does!).
I like your theory/thinking the best because you address many of the unanswered questions like "who's was in the grave?"; "who got Ali pregnant?"; etc. Also, Wren stated on the phone to someone when Spence was asking too many questions, "We have a problem. I'll take care of my end and you take care of yours" (paraphrase). I had a thought that IF Courtney was in "play" (as I'm understanding is a character in the books, which I have not read), then she would have been the one that was pulled out of the grave--maybe Courtney was the twin that could hold her breath. And, if it was Courtney that was pulled out of the grave, then she would be the "Ali" that the girls think they were helping in Philly or the twin that came home--meaning that the real Ali is "A" and the one that Courtney fears more than anyone else--her twin sister, Ali, who knows what she did. BUT if Ali OR Courtney were pulled out of the grave by Mrs. Grenwald, that would leave an EMPTY grave and we are back to (no matter which theory of twin you choose), WHOSE BODY IS IN THE GRAVE. I'm new to PLL series and have the same juicy questions. :)
i like your theory too but i think Ali was pulled out of the grave because when she got mad at her mom she would hold her breaths for minutes at a time _thanks for the feed back -A
But if Courtney was hit in the head (when Courtney was pretending to be Ali), then I was thinking that Mrs. D saw the twins together, and knew that it was one of the twins that killed the other twin. And that Mrs. D thought that it was Courtney who killed Ali. But what if it was Ali who killed Courtney because she knew Courtney was pretending to be her. Hence, Courtney was pulled out of the grave and feared Ali, who she knew was there. But this theory is weaken in that it leaves the grave empty. Even if it was Ali out of the grave, it still leaves the grave empty. No matter what the writers spin up, they MUST put a body in the grave. Spoiler Alert for Season 5 - STOP if you are not caught up. I'll still speak code in case someone didn't get that warning. There is a NEW body buried. Question: the grave was NOT a shallow grave. So, how did the evidence surface to the top??? LOL!
April Reyes, like you, looking forward to what the writers/producers do with the story line. I hope they don't leave too many holes and weaken the great pot twists. :) Keep the good theories coming!
Spencer was NOT sleeping, in the very first episode (1x01) the girls are sleeping then they wake up as Spencer is coming back to the barn wide awake, that's when they asked her what happened to Ali and Spencer says "she's gone I think I heard her scream"
Maybe she did go back to sleep, but then she woke up first before everyone else. And went out to look for Alison. It's not just black and white all the time.
I think it was Bethany who hit Alison, remember that in a chapter of the 5 season it is revealed that Alison's mother was related to Bethany. My theory is that mrs D the night she disappeared was talking to Radley, she was worried because Bethany had escaped. And when Alison is coming to his house is hit by Bethany and mrs D does nothing because it has some important connection with her and so, she buries Alison's body. Maybe A didnt like that and kill Bethany.
I love this show but I hate how they don't Give us answers to some things.I comment on another post about this but I don't remember seeing maya`s body.why was Ian killed and who did it.where is Noel khan I don't remember seeing him again.I'm so confused with this show.I hope in the next season we see A face and learn how that person is connected to the girls
tequila simmons Yeah, they have a lot of plot holes...But I think maybe "A" is related to Ali and Jason, making him related to Spencer. Maybe when A saw Ian trying to hurt Spencer in the bell tower, he killed him to protect his half-sister? (Even though he decides to torture her later...)
tequila simmons in the same episode, 4×24 I haven't watched the episodes in season 5 and season 6 yet because i can't, but i read recaps and watch clips on youtube and thats the way i catch up with what has happened :):)
I think they want us to think it was Jason because Mrs. D is obviously covering for someone. I mean, who would bury their own daughter? But. I don't think its Jason.
![Pretty Little Liars - Melissa Kills Bethany Young- "No One Here Can Love or Understand Me" [5x11]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Qf9yk_CeoFk/mqdefault.jpg)
This scene made me LOVE Alison. What a character-building episode for her. She deserves all the awards! I bawled like a baby.
AngelAtTwilight Especially when she bursts out crying😫😫😫
AngelAtTwilight gsd
Me too
GiGiShrum she was 12 years old in season 1
Angela Shrum no she doesnt
"what have you done! what have you done!" omg i was crying GOD BLESS YOU SASHA
seriously! since when did she get so talented? I mean she was always perfect for the role of Alison, but this performance was really excellent
I think its an act
Sarah B yeah it is an act thats what shes supposed to do.
coolstar mac I think she meant that Alison as a character was acting/lying about what really happened that night, still. There are a lot of theories out there that Alison was the one who killed Bethany and that her mom was really burrying Bethany and telling Alison "What have you done?" while doing so.
Alison Lauren Dilaurentis Well technically Melissa could be lying. You never know with this show :)
Sasha needs an Oscar
Włos sasha
+Aleks ali
YEAH
I am crying I can't believe it.........
+Sophia Baker Worlds best frigging actress
And I thought my family was messed up
Ikr!? Haha
Me too
yeah this video put me in my place
fucking same 😂
lol
I just spoiled it for myself im only on season 3
Why would you do that :P
Mylifeaslilyc I'm on season 2 😂
i'm in the season 1 😭
I'm on season 1 😭
sameeee
aria: " we're all here for you"
*acuses her of being A*
*acuses her of 2 murders she didn't commit*
*gets her in jail*
the liars: :))
Nora Sprooten ikr
That's why I hate the liars they're way too stupid and easy to manipulate
Well I kinda don't blame them for thinking ali was a. She used to be very evil.
Peek At Chu But in all offense Ali did LIE about dying . So tbh those girls spent bout 7 years of there life’s being tortured for something they didn’t do
WORLDWIDE DD well she had no other choice and she constantly risked her life to save them even when she was in hiding. And the liars aren't innocent. If they didn't have such terrible secrets in the first place they wouldn't have been easy targets for blackmail.
Peek At Chu most of the lies the liars had to keep secrets were for their parents. And if the liars aren’t innocent, Alison is worse. Let’s be honest, they didn’t hurt or torture anyone. Alison did tho.
I think she is the best pll actress
Agreed
yup!
Stiles Stillinski She got the role when she was 12 or 13 years old believe it or not
Stiles Stillinski. I agree
She was the youngest. To pull that off is incredible
"Can't u c me breathing" made me cry 😢😢😢😢
I thought she said "I was screaming". Well that changes stuff
She said both.
WHYAREALLTHEGOODNAMESTAKENOMG!!! she said "I was screaming. Can't you see me breathing?!"
wooow they can act. that part where ali says cant you see me look at me is just...
They're really great!! Troian(Spencer) went to school just for acting!
is just...im crying !
i think sasha and troian are the best on the show. also sasha is the youngest by far of the women
roter13 Sasha is horrible
Etch En She's one of the best actresses on the show..
This family is messed up...
-Jessica ended up having a twin who apparently no one knew about and she kept it a secret.
-Jessica was buried alive.
-Charlotte/Charles basically tortured his own sister and friends for years.
-Jessica made her husband thinks Charles was dead.
-No one knew or remembered Charles.
-Mary Drake is somehow Spencer's mother.
-Spencer had an evil twin all along, who eventually tried to kill her
-Jason hooked up with his own brother without even knowing.
-Charlotte somehow ended up being trans (not saying being trans is bad, just that it was messed up how it was kept a secret)
-Idk how many times Jessica has cheated on Kenneth.
-Ali was buried alive by her own mother.
AND THE WORST ONE OF ALL:
-Jason kissed Hanna's mom and they literally went on a date
Andrea14 how is being trans messed up? With the rest I agree but being transgender is okay 👌
JASON SLEPT WITH HANNA'S MOM.
Grabiela Arenas Wait hold up.
DoodleGirl28 woah... Alison is adopted?💀💀
Jason also dated his sister
This will always be my favourite scene 😓
Kitty Rose mine too
+Space samee im on that ep now photoshop rally??😂😂
Sasha is just such a Great actress! Love her 😘
All this time we think Ali is a cold-hearted bitch. But she changed. Poor girl. I would hate having that done to me. The way she cries is just so sad.
ѕωєєтмαяιиєттє Soon she becomes one ull see but I still love her
I know. Paige brings her inner bitch back
ѕωєєтмαяιиєттє Then she changes and she's rlly nice then but I kinda miss bitchy Ali but I do like her being nice 😂
ѕωєєтмαяιиєттє I can't believe it might be the last season 😫😫😫
Ikr. At the end of season 7 pll will end :(
Sasha is such an amazing actress
i spoiled it for myself still on season 1
Anuscha Gilani 😂
Anuscha Gilani I'm on season 4 I look for spoilers
Anuscha Gilani me too hahaha
Same
Same I just started season 4 when they started to suspect Alison is red coat!
Wow, I just saw this scene while in the midst of marathon-ing the series and this was some seriously stellar acting by Sasha Pieterse! Up until this point, Allison seemed like a cold-blooded, heartless human being. But this scene humanized her character. She's so different from the mean girl in the flashbacks.
drlee2 because she changed over the last 4-5 years
shining moment for sasha when it comes to acting
I agree! she has really grown into a talented actress through the course of this show
omg sasha is such a good actress :)
“We always have been”
Next season: “Alison is A”
Me: some friends you are
“ i was screaming , god can’t you see me ? cant you see me breathing ? lOOK AT ME “ that broke me😭
Sasha Pieterse is the best actress of the show omg she is so amazing !
Stop joke alison
@Daniella Georgiou-Norman how is it harder to play a gay woman? Are you insane? You basically just have to kiss girls instead of boys. How is that harder than playing any other role? Her job is literally to act, meaning PRETENDING. She’s just pretending with girls the same way she would pretend with boys...
This being said, Shay’s the worst actress of them all lmao. She’s okay, she’s fine, I’m not saying she’s bad. But she’s not THAT convincing.
@Daniella Georgiou-Norman i actually liked Shay the most out of the cast, but acting-wisez she just had a worried expression most if the time... I personally prefer the other actor's acting over hers. And I don't see why it's so hard to play a gay character...? I'm gay myself and it's not like we are a different breed or something lol it's not that difficult to portray a gay person
@Daniella Georgiou-Norman I personally think it was Troian
Unbelievable that it was Ali's own brother who did this to her. Shame on Mrs. DiLaurentis for letting him get away with that and shame on Mr. Hastings for not telling anyone about Jasons psycho twin. I feel so bad for Ali and Spencer. :'(
So i've never watched this before, think you could give me a synopsis? don't worry about spoilers
You don't know that yet! Stop assuming shit lol
Ninja master there was no such episode!!! We still don't know for sure it was Charles who hit Ali! Although its more than likely, we are still trying to figure out whether or not he was that person. Plus he ain't Jason's twin. There will be an episode, 6×10 which is supposed to reveal a lot of things and answer a few quetions, but, you know, its Pretty little LIARS so, you never know whats right, whats wrong :):):) lol
Elly _ S
Charles did hit Ali, otherwise her Mom wouldn't have protected her attacker. He's the only one who can make sense.
KaylaSwEet06 what about... Jason? I mean, i know he was drunk but... nevermind. How about Bethany then? I know she is supposed to be dead, but its either that she isnt dead or she hit Ali before she was murdered. This would actually make sense because Mrs D would not want to reveal anything about Bethany, plus it would make no sense to report her when she is dead (because she died that night, after that.) Thats just a theory.Plus, i didnt say Charles NEVER hit her. I just said we dont know that for sure
Perfect execution by Sasha Pieterse....so freaking good
sasha deserves an oscar. Jesus Christ.
ikr
Agreed
leila middleton it’s an Emmy
Heart breaking! She deserves an Oscar shes my fav
Wow!!! sasha is such a good actress!
Ms. D IS WAS PROTECTING HER SON CHARLES WHO IS ALSO A !
Triston Baptiste yes
YOU ARE CORRECT😭😭
+Triston Baptiste yep yep and yep :)
Well actually it is her daughter, CeCe
+Triston Baptiste well, daughter
Alison can really act, and she has a great voice Gosh!!
I have the feeling her mom didn't tell the police because its Jason.
Georgia Evan
She probably panicked and just assumed Ali was dead.
Georgia Evan
Who in that town has that much power over a Delarentis (or however you spell it). Her face looked shocked like she knew that person and couldn't believe what that person had done.
Georgia Evan
I can see that also happening.
***** Yeah but in the books, Ali had a twin, (she was in the mental hospital, Courtney,) and one day when Ali was visiting her she made Ali look like Courtney, aka her, and Ali stay in the hospital. That's probably the person the police found and thought was Ali, when it was her twin, and Ali killed Courtney, for revenge for keeping her in the mental hospital for years, and Ali HATED all of those girls, Spencer, Hanna, Aria, and Emily. But since it was the first people Courtney saw, she made a group. Sooo..
Ally Taylors
It's been said that they aren't following the book.
I love Sasha Piterse she's an amazing actress and my favourite character from pll she is awesome
2014 nope
2015 nope
2016 nope
2017 nope
2018 nope
2019 nope
2020 on my recomending
exactly 😂 !!
They way she said "I was screaming" gave me chills
Sasha was only 12 when she started filming this
She has some real talent😱😱
14
@@corinnedrake4668 12
@@ninaa.aa_ really what age was she filming this
@@corinnedrake3628 she was 12 in the pilot the rest she was 13
@@lordefan9800 Bruh she looks way older than her age filming this she looked like a highschooler or a person in college
Sasha Pieterse is a very good actress! °0°
Sasha is such a good actress this scene always makes me cry
Sasha did such a good job in this scene, i was a mess
It has to be someone who has dirt on Mrs D. Something so big that she wasn't willing to go to jail for. Perhaps the person who tried to kill Ali had this dirt on Mrs D and was/is blackmailing her.
It is probably Jason. Think about it! Jason was in the N.A.T club and they basically had dirt on everybody. plus that would explain why Mrs D buried Ali because she thought Ali was dead and didnt want a dead kid and a kid in prison
Yeah Jason is looking a whole lot more suspicious as the seasons go on! Plus, they're blood so it would make sense!
Bek Grace thats so true! Just the only thing is idk if its a little to easy for pll you know? Maybe its someone we have no idea she is connected to even so then it comes as a shock when we finally learn about it :)
Bek Grace makes since sense their always fighting in some flashbacks
think about it...
Mrs.Marin also said that the flash drive had videos of adults as well, who they assumed was Mona (now we know it wasn't) maybe it had Mrs.D too, and Jason was in the N.A.T
The actress who played Alison had done an amazing job I could feel the characters pain 🥺
She was like "oh my daughter is laying on the ground so let's berry her"
Ali's still alive?! Yes!😊
I loved this scene. Sasha was amazing in it
Sasha and Troian’s acting skills are simply incredible ❤️
OMG She needs a Oscar right now she’s amazing
I love how I haven’t even finished the first episode of season 1 and I’m searching this up
Spencer looks like a frog when she cries 😂😂🐸🐸
Watching this in July 2017. Of all the scenes of this show, this clip is something I will always remember. Sasha's delivery between 1:45 - 2:06 and 2:25 - 2:33 is so unbelievably captivating. Chills me to the bone every. single. time.
This scene made me crying 🥺
-why u bury me alive?
-just : ) Typical dilaurentis's family :D
She literally deserves an Oscar and how old is she in this clip? in the first episode they shot she was actually 12 years old ! 😊
She was 15 i think
+DUD ! She was 12 actually she is only 19 this year
+Meghan Keightley oh i found out like a couple weeks ago that she was 12 when they was shooting season 1
My fault😅😅
She was around 18 or 19 in this clip
She had just turned 16 in this clip
“She was hysterical, what have you done! What have you done!” She said that AMAZINGLY.
Rewatching this I'm actually starting to appreciate the fact that CeCe is -A. Now that we saw the full scene in 6x10 and seeing CeCe's reaction to Mrs. D saying "What have you done?!" There is no one else that I can picture in that role. Vanessa Ray was fantastic in that episode
+Daniel Graham ikr and pll has given us clues about her/she the whole we just missed them
My thoughts exactly!
I can't believe that Alison's mom buried her alive
Sasha is an amazing amazing Actress she needs an oscar. When she was crying in the video she is Amazing I can't believe it
Wow Sasha is such a great actor
This scene was probably the best scene in Pll. Sasha is amazing!!
Her voice crack at the end makes this more realistic 💯💯💯😥
She is the best actress ever! I want to cry 😰 It is so well acted !
I love Sasha Pieterse💕
Alison/Sasha her face is perfect us her voice omg !!
Every time I see this I cry
the best show ever 👏🏻
I cried my eyes out when Ali was bawling her eyes out
This scene makes sense when u find out who the real and original A is, that’s why Alison’s mum was pointing the finger at Spenser- this comment on makes sense to the people that have watch all episodes of PLL x
So there is me through the whole of pll thinking "Oh geez, Ali is such a dick" and now this happens and I'm like "WTF??? Ali is so sweet!"
Alison was strong and she need an award 👍
God, can't you see me? Can't you see me, really look at me...
Alison my baby😭❤️
Omg,Cece thought she was BETHANY
Am I the only one who thinks Spencer looks so cute when she cries😂
Yes
1:56 Lucy's like "wow she needs an Emmy or a Golden Globe"
0:24 we all assume that's Alison but i'm not convinced. We think it's Ali falling to her knees and then on her stomach but if you look closely, Ali fell sidways to the right at 0:23. My theory, Melissa buried Bethany, Ali went back to the barn to wait for a text (in that time ,someone pulled Bethany out), Ali went home and Bethany hit her with the rock. 0:24 , thats Bethany dropping the rock with her left hand (that's why Ali fell to the right when she was hit), the blood that fell on the rock is Bethany's from when she was hit by the shovel, and then she falls to her knees in exhaustion wearing the exact same outfit as Ali.
Shedde i have the same exact theory , but who hit Bethany ? could it be Spencer ? because Ali told her that she went back to sleep however when the girls woke up she wasn't in the barn and she was saying she thought she heard Ali screaming ( maybe screaming because Spencer was after her with the shovel ), but the girl that Melissa buried had an A- written on her head with blood and Mona was A at the time .
Emily started crying Than I fucking cried because maya left than Alison in season 2-3 I was sad and I'm so happy but still crying
maria benzaoual I think it was alison and noel.
maria benzaoual Mona became A after that .
if u watched last nights last summer finale u would have known why
I miss this show so much and I’ll never forget it😭💔
Is it just me who thought Ali was the one who had a twin? Look closely on Ali's "missing" poster ;)
+LoveRoryandJess Ikr? I read the books and the books are so different from the show!
I cried so hard in this scene, Shasa is awesome!
0:26 anyone else saw a smiley face here?
Gives me chills every time...
She was covering for Charles
What confuses me is that Charles is dead and has died long ago and that means it's not Charles. In the recent episode the liars said that A is pretending to be Charles after the real Charles died? So that leaves us back to where we started. I think that The A team has spencer Hanna and ezra because spencer is the girl in the coffin in the song secret and when they look at aria they are all actually looking at Hanna then at aria but it only lasts for a millisecond so u have to pay close attention. And Ezra because he was pretending to be into aria then he was pretending to be a teacher so he can get close to her, but when she finds out he tells her he is in love with her but how do we no he isn't lying? So he must be helping them in a way
Hanna and spencer clues I found them in the opening song thingie
What really needs to happen is there needs to be a pretty little liars movie
this was the saddest scene
Give Sasha an Oscar already
Mrs D was talking to Charlotte and she was protecting her
I remember this sooo vividly this show was my entire teenage years😭
I thought I was messed up damn Ali
I love pretty little liars so much
With all the writers and producers claiming they are staying away from the “Ali has a twin” plot line, I still believe SOMEONE has to have a twin because of all the twin references and hidden images they’ve included in the show. So…I think that Jason has a twin. A twin SISTER, one who has been in Radley.
Jason’s twin would therefore be a Hastings, explaining Mrs. D’s comment about “You can never turn your back on a Hastings.” It would also explain Peter Hastings’ involvement with Radley and Mrs. D. I think the twin escaped the night that Ali was fake-murdered and that’s why Mrs. D was on the phone asking for an update…”Please send someone. I’m worried.” AKA send someone from the hospital to pick up my crazy daughter.
If Jason’s twin sister was the one who bashed Ali on the head, that would explain why Mrs. D was protecting the murderer by stashing Ali’s body in the ground. Maybe she knew she was still alive-she knew Ali could hold her breath for a long time-so maybe she wanted the twin to BELIEVE Ali was dead so she wouldn’t keep coming after her. Then Ali escaped and ran away before Mrs. D could get back to her. Mrs. D was not at all surprised when Det. Holbrook told her that he didn’t think the body in the grave was Ali’s-because she already knew that Ali wasn’t dead. However, Ali may not have realized what her mother was doing (remember, she didn’t see who hit her, so she wouldn’t necessarily know that her mom was trying to protect another one of her offspring) which is why she seemed hesitant to let her mom know that she was alive. If her mom was trying to find her, this would also explain why Ezra thought she might be A.
So now the twin believes that she’s killed Ali, and she disappears again/goes back to Radley. Mona continues her A game with the Liars, but all of “Mona/A“‘s threats are related to the girls’ secrets, NOT to finding Ali. At some point “the game was stolen” from Mona, and A began to give the Liars hints and clues, trying to help them find Ali-because *A* wanted to find Ali and needed the girls to help. This would fit perfectly with the timeline because Mona said that the game was taken from her when she went to Radley. Well, if she was at Radley with the twin, then maybe she confided in her or otherwise let it slip that Ali was alive, and THAT’S when the twin took on the role of A, so she could find her half-sister and kill her for real this time. (I don’t have a solid motive for the twin wanting Ali dead, except that there isn’t anyone in Rosewood who didn’t want Ali dead at some point so I think motive might be kind of moot.)
In the finale it was revealed that Ali hadn’t slept with Ezra OR Ian, so who was her pregnancy scare? Could it have been Wilden or someone else? We know that Wren has privileges at Radley, so perhaps he was the twin’s doctor and knew the family that way. Maybe Ali slept with him, the twin found out, and went bonkers because she loved him, or something. If Wren knew there was another sibling, maybe he told Melissa at some point-they were close enough that they got engaged so I don’t think it would be improbable that he told her. Melissa has always seemed to know more about what’s going on than Spencer, so this would make sense. Melissa was also involved with the NAT club-maybe she knew there was another sibling already through that, or her friendship with Jason. Maybe that’s why Melissa said she knew that Spencer didn’t kill “that girl”.
The question still remains, who is in Ali’s grave? There were very few people who knew that Ali wasn’t actually dead, so one of them had to have had a motive for making sure that everyone believed Ali was dead. Mainly, Mrs. D-she wouldn’t have wanted the twin to find out that Ali was still out there, so somehow she was able to replace the body in her backyard and put Ali’s clothes on it. She also would have been the one making the ID of the body and she could have lied to police (everyone else does!).
I like your theory/thinking the best because you address many of the unanswered questions like "who's was in the grave?"; "who got Ali pregnant?"; etc. Also, Wren stated on the phone to someone when Spence was asking too many questions, "We have a problem. I'll take care of my end and you take care of yours" (paraphrase).
I had a thought that IF Courtney was in "play" (as I'm understanding is a character in the books, which I have not read), then she would have been the one that was pulled out of the grave--maybe Courtney was the twin that could hold her breath. And, if it was Courtney that was pulled out of the grave, then she would be the "Ali" that the girls think they were helping in Philly or the twin that came home--meaning that the real Ali is "A" and the one that Courtney fears more than anyone else--her twin sister, Ali, who knows what she did.
BUT if Ali OR Courtney were pulled out of the grave by Mrs. Grenwald, that would leave an EMPTY grave and we are back to (no matter which theory of twin you choose), WHOSE BODY IS IN THE GRAVE.
I'm new to PLL series and have the same juicy questions. :)
i like your theory too but i think Ali was pulled out of the grave because when she got mad at her mom she would hold her breaths for minutes at a time _thanks for the feed back -A
you have very great theories keep me posted
But if Courtney was hit in the head (when Courtney was pretending to be Ali), then I was thinking that Mrs. D saw the twins together, and knew that it was one of the twins that killed the other twin. And that Mrs. D thought that it was Courtney who killed Ali. But what if it was Ali who killed Courtney because she knew Courtney was pretending to be her. Hence, Courtney was pulled out of the grave and feared Ali, who she knew was there. But this theory is weaken in that it leaves the grave empty. Even if it was Ali out of the grave, it still leaves the grave empty. No matter what the writers spin up, they MUST put a body in the grave.
Spoiler Alert for Season 5 - STOP if you are not caught up. I'll still speak code in case someone didn't get that warning.
There is a NEW body buried. Question: the grave was NOT a shallow grave. So, how did the evidence surface to the top??? LOL!
April Reyes, like you, looking forward to what the writers/producers do with the story line. I hope they don't leave too many holes and weaken the great pot twists. :) Keep the good theories coming!
This part broke my heart so much I was sobbing😭😭
why am i watching this? i’m on season 3😂
same lmao
My biggest fear is being buried alive
What an actress at such a young age to. IMPRESSIVE
Spencer was NOT sleeping, in the very first episode (1x01) the girls are sleeping then they wake up as Spencer is coming back to the barn wide awake, that's when they asked her what happened to Ali and Spencer says "she's gone I think I heard her scream"
Maybe she did go back to sleep, but then she woke up first before everyone else. And went out to look for Alison. It's not just black and white all the time.
She did go back to sleep after ali saw her, then she woke up and went to look for ali
when did Spencer hear Ali (or Bethany) scream? always confused me.
Sashas acting is on POOIIINNNTT
I think it was Bethany who hit Alison, remember that in a chapter of the 5 season it is revealed that Alison's mother was related to Bethany. My theory is that mrs D the night she disappeared was talking to Radley, she was worried because Bethany had escaped. And when Alison is coming to his house is hit by Bethany and mrs D does nothing because it has some important connection with her and so, she buries Alison's body. Maybe A didnt like that and kill Bethany.
Sasha needs an award for her performance in this episode
I love this show but I hate how they don't Give us answers to some things.I comment on another post about this but I don't remember seeing maya`s body.why was Ian killed and who did it.where is Noel khan I don't remember seeing him again.I'm so confused with this show.I hope in the next season we see A face and learn how that person is connected to the girls
At least we'll get all the answers to all our questions since season 2 this summer when season 6 airs :)
tequila simmons Yeah, they have a lot of plot holes...But I think maybe "A" is related to Ali and Jason, making him related to Spencer. Maybe when A saw Ian trying to hurt Spencer in the bell tower, he killed him to protect his half-sister? (Even though he decides to torture her later...)
Ali said she is the one who pushed ian off the bell tower. We didn't see Maya body but we assumed it was her body found in the season 2 finale.
sose g when did she say that.I don't remember that.Imma need to watch all the seasons over cause I'm so confused.
tequila simmons in the same episode, 4×24
I haven't watched the episodes in season 5 and season 6 yet because i can't, but i read recaps and watch clips on youtube and thats the way i catch up with what has happened :):)
My heart cracks when spence crys
In season 5 I want fucking answers for FOR EVERYTHING!!!
So talented
I think they want us to think it was Jason because Mrs. D is obviously covering for someone. I mean, who would bury their own daughter? But. I don't think its Jason.
I loved how much change she had
jessica is mary drake in season 4 i swear
she is