Understanding Arnab Goswami’s arrest: Politics, policing, law & journalistic principle
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лют 2025
- #CutTheClutter
Republic TV owner Arnab Goswami was arrested by the Maharashtra Police in a 2018 alleged abetment to suicide case. How this case, unlike the previous ones against him, is not a directly linked to his journalism. Why this is a State vs Centre, Shiv Sena-BJP fight, and whether Arnab is a victim or a perpetrator, a crusader or willing political pawn, would depend on your political view. Shekhar Gupta lifts the layers in episode 610 of #CutTheClutter.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch Cut The Clutter, ep 599 here: • Law, politics & TRPs w...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Brought to by Tata Motors
/ @tata.evofficial
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/Subscrib...
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
Please support good journalism by paying for it. Subscribe to ThePrint. Links for both domestic & overseas subscribers are provided here: theprint.in/subscribe/
I don't support Arnab by any means. But you can imagine, what police, Politicians, powerful people can do
Why we should support? To promote left ideologies who does not speak anything against Pak and so on.............. Always criticize Indian army in one way or another
@@vijaykumarthakur366 true.
Inko jail ke andhar daalna chahiye.
May future may power may aayunga tho communist liberals, intolerence gang ka ilaaj pehle karunga.
Baadmay 100% swacch India banega.
1947 may division religion basis pe hua tha,tho ye secularism ki necessity nahi hai.
Secularism nahi hogi tho urban naxals ko nahi rehne doonga.
Chinese propaganda ke liye true Indian nationals support nahi karenge.
Remember a journalist was arrested for breaking story of namak salt with roti in UP
Not arrested. The local police was argued with him.
@@pravinmeher2036 No
He as arrested. You don't need encounter specialist in UP. Every cop is already an encounter specialist.
This comment is dipped in whataboutery. One wrong doesn't make another wrong right.
@@pravinmeher2036 you saying no he wasn't arrested doesn't make sense. Where do you get your information?
"Only when the shoe pinches you, you realise what injustice is - else injustice is rationalised"
sorry nationalized :P
Lol have the same high spirits when this happen with other biggies and done by communist and bhp hahaha
Well said
🤫🤫🤫🤫Sequence :
Arnab knew about this case reopening. Hence, he used his media face and exploited SSR case to gain sympathy. This is why he maligned Maha Saba to take advantage of this situation when it comes so that he can call it a revenge due to SSR case. Fact is, it's the reverse as is mentioned above.
BJP pressurised the Judge to close the case unlawfully. And as favor, Modi used Arnab to fullfil his agenda through Media. Agenda we see on the Republic Channel of Hate red, social disharmony and religious bias.
@@mrjohny2993 wow you should stand for elections
How conveniently Shekhu?
SSR case is a "simple" suicide case. But Naik's is abetment of suicide.
SSR Did not leave a suicide note
His wife & daughter are having a gala time posing with sharad pawar
Shekhu is darling of about to be extinct party.
Well, that is what the AIIMS panel says, not Shekhar. Now, unless u are a better doctor than no point placing useless allegations.
@MR Noob use brain of logical not that of puncturewala, first of all AIIMS panel did second review and that too 2 months later & Abetment to suicide cannot be ruled out by AIIMS panel!
He is saying "poor Ria". It seems a joke. She broke the law dealing with drugs.
See jailing Arnab is wrong period
No justifications for that but Rhea was indeed harassed to no end.
Journalists aren't the judiciary we have courts for that...
So do all the babas and pujaris you see around.There are even govt. licenced bhang shops. If you want to tackle of problem then do it evenly on everyone.. we need to rise above individual persecution.
"If we don't demand justice for those we disagree with, then we are being dishonest to ourselves" - The crux of this CTC👍👍
This not the crux of CTC. This is just a line in the end (after discrediting him in the whole video) to infuence innocent souls like you to think "Kitna honest aadmi hai aur kya badhiya baat bola". This is just PunchLine journalism. The real cut the clutter of this episode is some othet message which I have shared in the comment
@@paddymaddy1934 innocent soul !!! Police investigation seems completely botched.
How can a man have accidental death by hanging? Give it a try if you may. Come back and let us know if you succeed
Totally agree...
Sorry babu
Very well said
Now, I am trying to imagine what will happen to journalists in BJP states coz they will now have precedents for their justification.
Exactly. Don't cry when BJP do the same. Rules will always backfire.
BJP is the one who started all theee things
It's already happening but nobody is as famous as arnab so
Less noise
@@weaksupremacy3799 And now we are looking for who to blame for all this instead of actually being worried that this is something that's been happening and continue to happen?
A few months ago, a journalist was charged with sedition when he reported that CM could change in Guj. He was jailed too.
Just see how SG spins his words...(17:24 onwards)......in Mumbai its Shivsena govt (no mention of Congress and NCP because smaller ally) and in Bihar its BJP and it's ally govt (No mention of JDU though the CM is from JDU). Learn from him about how to put forward his thoughts into the minds of viewers. Bravo SG...🤔🤔
Yeah he masters the Art of placing Trojan Horses
That's in your indoctrinated head. Do you also spin up conspiracy theories in all the free time you got.
@@classScribbler insults are the lowest form of argument .
@@vahsirartapaham4578 oh yeah? How about I cover my ears and scream "blah blah blah"... Frankly people are very tired of hearing all the bullshit from the right wing. No gain in using reason with them. Besides they are mostly paid - why waste time in educating a troll whose only purpose is to alter like /dislike ratio and keep people distracted.
@@vahsirartapaham4578 well replied on the comment. Also very well observed on this piece. The hypocrisy of claiming neutrality and yet taking sides is indeed worth acknowledging. If it is about decluttering the origin to the present, then the inconspicuous absence of the other two parties itself indicates how half hearted decluttering it is.
Appreciate SG for giving his personal opinion at the same time defending Arnab's journalistic freedom. This motto of "I disagree with you, but I'll defend your right to disagree with me" is what is needed to protect individual and civil liberties.
People who are on either extreme fail to see the bigger picture.
Arnab is himself on the other extreme, prepared to frame people without proof.
@@manthansharma9838 agreed, but unless he breaks the law, his freedom of speech and thought should be protected. Because if they can come after him with little to no evidence, tomorrow they can come after you and me.
@@qui-gone Fair point. Basically protect Arnab for exactly that thing he has supported to deny to a lot of other people. Freedom of speech and opinion.
Its clear cut case of revenge by maharashtra govt and police. Shamelessly ur,not saying that. Ur shamelessly partial
Case is not reopened suddenly! Case reopened on May 2020. You can check MH home minister tweets of may month. In may 2020 SSR was alive. So how this can be personal vendetta?
Very True, but revenge of what ? clarify that also (Godi Media)..🤮
@@makarandshinde6491 Ever heard about Palghar lynching?
Arnab was already against the wrong acts committed under the Maharashtra government.
Arnab is no saint. But what happening now is disaster in manifestation.
See it through broader perspective.
@@urvishbhavsar2826 ohh palghar lynching?
There was misunderstanding between local people (all were hindu) as sandhus were fake and they were child traffikers. From some days there were cases of robbery and child traffiking. So villagers were patrolling in night. Due to lockdown travelling was banned so sadhus took inner route avoiding main road. That crowd was wild and ferocious and uneduacted. Police men were less(only 2)and unarmed compares to crowd,so crowd overpowered them and killed that sadhus. All people(more than 100) who was in that brutal crime are under arrest and we wish all should get life punishment. If you dont trust me you can read any article other than godi media. Some channels gave it communal turn to fulfill political agenda
@@makarandshinde6491
Palghar case video where there are obviously more than 2 policemen and how they were left vulnerable to the murderers there : twitter.com/i/status/1321783930811547648
Shekar Gupta is so happy inside😁
Every true human who is for humanity is happy today...only communal, liar & bjp supporters are not happy
@Sanjay Nair then where is the freedom of speech issue here...he has been arrested for a crime not like BJP governed states where journalist charged with sedition ....BJP is just a communal political party ..in every election they talk only on caste , religion , Pakistan and now NADDA introduced Trump in bihar election...
@@amigosworld6554 Are you going to decide whether a person is human or not. Giving Medallion of yourself I see.
@@grenade-xf7cq yes...for me Arnab Goswami is not a human...he is devil in suit..and why you are giving him certificate that he is innocent...he earned money on people's dead body...and your behavioural pattern must be same as him..that's why you support him
@Sanjay Nair yes but you must know on whose direction the case was closed?? ...that time who govern maharastra??..in abetment of suicide case the suicide note is primary evidence...
Mamata Banerjee started doing this stuff before Yogi Adityanath. Be fair, Mr Gupta.
What Bengal thinks today, India will think tomorrow. - G.K. Gokle
@@yourballsinmyfisticansquee5374 BALATKARI JANTA PARTY KA DALAL SPOTTED POSTING SAME COMMENT FOR EVERY REBUTTAL
@@kareemkhan-hv1yp Which Janata Party are you talking about brother? Don't use unnecessary idioms.
Weren't these atrocities against journalists started by Congress with the act of emergency. I am not trying to defend anyone but it seems that the view is no longer unbiased but rather leaning towards anti-BJP
Yes, every political party abuses their power for their own benefit.
You forgot Bengal.. Very nicely passed the buck to UP and not even mentioned Bengal for once 🙏
@kazi rahman lol what do you expect bjp to say ? “Your welcome!”
Sena is doing what congress did for decades, and bjp been doing wherever they are in power.
And bjp is crying just like congress or left, when it comes to their political stooges.
Regardless-THATS A F*%#!£* CRAZY TYPOGRAPHY . Try turning off caps lock
@Rahul gupta 💯, but you can’t deny ,hatharas case and burning the body by state police at 2o clock ,with petrol/kerosene was and will remain big black blotch on hindutva politics of bjp for long . Just saying 🤷
@kazi rahman Bro my point is that SG failed to mention Bengal. I am not saying BJP/ Congress didn't do it. How UP deserves to be mentioned in this topic so is Bengal. Now don't get offended again!
It's started from cpm govt in bengal. In kerala cpm does all the time. Few times he talks about few good things abt modi but most of the time he praises cong and other parties. He is just wolf in sheep clothes
Ya...I was thinking..
SG just reply one thing honestly.,if it had happened to Ravish or Rajdeep by BJP govt, would you say any thing other than bashing the govt and using words like emergency and death of democracy.
It proves only one thing in Maha, people in govt don't deserve to be ministers as they act like MAWALIS n Gang of mafias
But SG did say that Arnab's arrest was wrong. And you're asking "what if BJP did the same thing", but the fact is that they are already have arrested so many journalists on trumped-up cases.
Your comparison is great. You seem to be deaf and dumb
Head master of mawali politics is Modi & Amit Shah.
Sir ji UP jhak lo Zara
😂
Everyone,
Please watch this 5 min video, show it to your family doctor & ask an explanation. & yes Its important !!!
ua-cam.com/video/bPdTSS_l0gY/v-deo.html
And hope Shekhar Gupta, you don’t have any old closed case against you which can be opened for vendetta against you. Watch out!!
He has had a free reign being the Congress stooge for years!!
Must be thousands cases like this in Maharashtra, but only Anvay Naik's wife got the chance to see the HM.
It is obvious why
Just like SSR's father had the privilege of meeting the CM of Haryana , IT minister even though many people farmers in Haryana succumb to suicide. You create the Frankenstein and the Frankenstein tries to destroys you.
What about ssr case? This police was unable to register a single FIR ,why? Becoz they fear 🐧
I feel Arnab will get out of this situation. But if he doesn't, he is going to drag down some very powerful people with him.
I don't like his way of journalism, but many know that someone is trying to shut him up. They knew they couldn't book his for his words, so opened a cold case.
Oh, everyone knows this is political. But Arnab needs to choose if he is a journalist or a politician or a hijra. B/c by being overtly political in his tone and tenor, he claims to be a journalist. This makes him worst than a hijra, who does not hide their embarrassment.
@Ruemann Yeah and if its true then why was shivsena (Allied with BJP then) silent or at least provide proof now, that it was Fadanvis who shut down the case?
Everyone,
Please watch this 5 min video, show it to your family doctor & ask an explanation. Its important !!!
ua-cam.com/video/bPdTSS_l0gY/v-deo.html
@@man_named_nobody calling someone hijra won't make u look better
The same SS was an ally. If it was truth they were seeking. There are more heinous things they are covering up with Arnabs arrest. Opening a cold case is legal but circumstances of this arrest cannot be ignored.
Not liking Arnabs journalism doesn't qualify him for injustice. Grow spines to call out injustice
I personally feel his journalism was bad on SSR case but he pointed the hypocrisy of state government on Palghar case.
his 'journalism' in SSR. That was not journalism, that is called supari work
@@KiranKumar-nb4nx
Haa
@Shekhar Sansanwal
He is Arrested for Involvement in A Suicide Case.... Not for his Journalism or his Reporting on SSR.
@Mr K it was never a journalism, it was clearly fakt propaganda for bihar election... How many times & with how much intensity he questioned CBI? Just watch out his prime time show's topics when india is in a state of emergency with every major index falling like never before in past 20-30 yrs...
@Mr K Andhbakth Pro Max
Also a AndhiPaid Journalist Fan🤣🤣
Your facts were FLAWED!
Police had NO court order and pushing is manhandling too - even the magistrate took cognisance of the same.
@@sojanjos Let's see when the same thing happens to you
@@sojanjos rice bag spotted
@@kiranhiremath3408 keep crying 😂😂
Wonder if an old man could take such pushing & shoving ????
@@sunitasurendran2001 Well said, not just old, it's a rusted old man. A stooge of the mino
CBI investigated SSR case and found drugs involvement. Is this something that must be overlooked?
When a person decides to join politics that person must be open to take critical criticism, if not they should not join politics.
Imagine arresting journalist like Ravish kumar, Rajdip sardesai etc.
Up government can arrest them anytime.
@@balluwarasi1883 why will UP Govt. Arrest them they live in Delhi if I'm not wrong, the Central Government can arrest provided they have a abatement to suicide case against either of them.
Coupta will cry louder if that happens.
they are are far more influential tha AG. Targeting Ravish Kumar would be suicide.
@Sumit Verma Prashant Kanojia! Rings a bell? There are many more in UP. All you need to do is look it up. Instead of blindly being swept by Propaganda.
Question for guptaji, how do you, as a journalist, & The Print in general, protect yourself from state/central law and other bureaucracies?
he just de clutter the news, govt elected by people like you, so asl questions to your beloved politicians
By not questing the government in power as hard as Arnab did to to Uddhav. Print does soft journalism, it just give its views. Doesn’t pressurise government hard to answer questions. And I am happy that both media houses like print and republic exist. They both do different kind of journalism and it good to have an option to watch anyone we feel like
@@kumarankit053 please do the same thing in up and ask questions to modi, you bot
@@AbhiSingh-eb3hq as per people like you, anyone with a opposing point of view is a bot. I do question Modi govt on his policies but no point explaining to an Andhbhakt like you
@@AbhiSingh-eb3hq bots are always better than paid bots
Whatsoever Mr.Shekhar gupta , you always sound like an anti BJP .
While describing Arnab, you are maligning SSR case and Disha Salian case....
thats what he wants perhaps
India is a strange country where change of ruler changes governance rules and standard operating procedures. Is it democratic?
I guess the only thing democratic is change of power. Everything else is I authoritarian.
Only procedural democracy 😂
@Edward Elric why do you think he needed to get paid by bjp. He was just taking side. We know why this action now after case was closed by same police. Perhaps if they had shown same alacrity in the sadhu lynching case while police were mere spectators as vedios showed, criminals would have been behind bars now.
@Edward Elric God and science don't match.
You are absolutely right brother. This is not democracy.
Sir you maybe one of the few left who still do journalism, presenting both side of the story.. Such a balanced presentation..
Comman people :- *Ye sare milke humko pagal bana rahe*
🤫🤫🤫🤫Sequence :
Arnab knew about this case reopening. Hence, he used his media face and exploited SSR case to gain sympathy. This is why he maligned Maha Saba to take advantage of this situation when it comes so that he can call it a revenge due to SSR case. Fact is, it's the reverse as is mentioned above.
BJP pressurised the Judge to close the case unlawfully. And as favor, Modi used Arnab to fullfil his agenda through Media. Agenda we see on the Republic Channel of Hate red, social disharmony and religious bias.
@Edward Elric and u have a Christian name
@@mrjohny2993 Exactly i was thinking about it but maybe this is also the tip of a ice berg.
@Edward Elric you are fullmetal alchemist fan?!!
@Edward Elric what i meant to say was why should being hindu be related to having justice tho i fully support you i n the fact that the mother and son duo should hve justice
That man’s wife and daughter were seen with Sharad Pawar very fishy
Agree..he looks fishy
Arnab Goswami is seen with Prime Minister, home minister & entire BJP Party..very fishy ...🤔
@@terminator9176 He is pro BJP but what does that have to do with this case, liberandu?
@@AR-xi2sq he is pro bjp and this has nothing to do with it. But when sushant's family was seeking justice rw was with them but now when Anvay's family is seeking justice the right wingers are against them. A case of Double standards.
@@blzKrg Everyone knows that he has been put behind the bars for what reason. Anvay Naik's case is just a reason
"Evidence free targeted journalism" is something which all media houses in India practise. We have seen that in Rohit Vemula's case where an attempt was made to give it a caste angle without any evidence that caste played any role in his suicide.
Why was he ans his friends forced to vacate their hostel
@@mesinjana were they asked to vacate because of caste?
@@mesinjana I think the reason was his opposition to yakub memon hanging
Have you read Vemula's suicide note? He clearly mentioned about humiliations he had faced due to caste.
@@arkamukherjee4027 in his letter did he say that he was committing suicide because he was being targeted for being from lower caste? Can you quote the sentence? contents of Rohit Vemula's suicide note is available in the internet.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_of_Rohith_Vemula
"Politics is the art of the possible"
-Otto Von Bismarck
ua-cam.com/video/a1IPYmxAVic/v-deo.html bhai please dekho maine arnab par meme video banaya hai...!
Bahut mehnat lagi hai bhai😓😕
Koi dekh hi nahi raha😓😭😭
von not Van
Congress and allies have opened the pandora's box. Congratulations to the Journalists community. BJP now has the licence to take out any journalist. So far they had avoided targeting journalist. NOW EVERYONE IS ON RADAR.
Yes, this sets a very dangerous precedent..
Assuming the ruling dispensation isn’t already vindictive against hostile journalists / press .......
Did u know what happened to people like gauri lankesh, kalburgi? They are all killed by RSS for critisicing them.
BJP was already arresting small journos. Not that you care.
@@khabibnurmagamadov29-03 she was not critsizing she was abusing hinduism and nationalists.
You said arnob is paying for his crime. Even a cub reporter would say “alleged crime”. Rightly so. Your intend is clear. There are two others named in the alleged suicide note. While RS 85 lakhs was due from republic, 4cr was due from Abdul or firoze. You conveniently avoided mention of this. While you trace the origin of the problem to UP, why hold back and begin fm the days of emergency ? As much you try mr Gupta, you are clearly a modi and Bjp baiter and your smooth talk doesn’t sell.
So why r u expecting everyone in country to support bjp and its allies.?
What is it that pulls u towards bjp?
Well it is ur right to hold any belief.i have mine.
And as far as arnob is concerned he is ass licking prop of bjp.
NOT A JOURNALIST.
Mr Gupta you have sort of mastered the art of "running with the hare and hunting with the hound " ... The point is - The clock is ticking !
@YourBallsInMyFist ICanSqueezeOutMoreThan50Cents paid looser .
People are so divided. Everyone has chosen sides. My hero, my victim.
My nothing, neither seen his debate nor hated him
@Edward Elric you don't like don't watch, who forces you.
unfortunately true☹️
@Edward Elric Damn right
That's my policy too
arnab is most definately not my hero, but he seemsto be a victim
Shekhar...its a political case...u know as much as anyone does. Why then badgering Arnab?....i wish you had conducted these detailed episodes on Sonia's or Rahul's antics....but again they gave u the padam awards...
SHEKAR, YOU NEED TO FACE YOUR CHILDREN, LISTEN TO YOUR CONSIOUS , TRUTH WILL PREVAIL, SATYAMEVA JAYETE
He loves to spread fake propaganda but..🤡
Arrest Mahesh Bhatt, not this good journalist guy India is so corrupt
So u feel.. It started from UP.. I thought u had left hypocrisy long ago... And u were born before Indhira Gandhi emergency.... Quite convenient
He's a Congress kiss-ass ; what do you expect!
He has said that it wasn't invented by UP.
Quite agree here, this journalist seems to be doing the work for congress. I can only smell hypocrisy.
Everyone,
Please watch this 5 min video, show it to your family doctor & ask an explanation. Its important !
ua-cam.com/video/bPdTSS_l0gY/v-deo.html
Shut up idiot
MY FAVOURITE JOURNALIST IS ASHOK SRIVASTAVA FROM DD NEWS💕💕
Frank Rusen Periera - Rajya Sabha TV
@@anirudhmurali88 only Real OG would say this👍👍👍
Perfect
Today, DD news is the best channel
At this age don’t give wrong information Judge observed that case is opened without
Court permission.
For God sake stop giving false information
Lolz poor knowledge... 😂 😂 Keep crying
Lol keep talking crap... The case was reopened in May 2020... It was a headline in our newspapers too... Go get ur facts checked
@@atharvaw.9973 he said that some judge observed that the case was opened without court's permission
@@rajashashankgutta4334 bhai case open krne ke liya new evidence chaiye hote hn wo mil gai hn jo arnab ko suicide se connect krte hn.
Yes His narrative of Arnav illegal arrest is totally exposed himself of falsehood. . He is misleading the innocent viewers. .fuck you Old man you bloody joker I know you very well as Congress bootlegger shame on you old pimp
His master's voice, not that of Shekar's. How many lies and half information.
Agree
Unfair to compare him the scumbags like Serdesai and Dutt. Always enjoyed his narratives till recently, Now he is shallow and does not speak the truth. Looks like you are also protecting the baby penguin. You now seem to be compromised and mellowed down with age.
Out of all the family members why did he choose to kill his mother and not his wife or child????? Why???
Here comes Sherlock Holmes. Remember in India political power decides how investigations proceed. BJP ruled then and now SS.
Exactly..!!👍
There are so many questions, doubts are there in Anvey's case..!!
How did his mother died..?
Postmortem report says, by strangulation..!
Who did that..?!
I believe his mother was a director of his company.
And for all u know maybe he and his mother also must have been killed by some family member.for personal benefits any thing is possible in this world of ghor kalyug .But u cannot buy Arnav goswami he is too honest
@@ayushgarg8609 so he will kill his mother.. Huh.. Analyse the suicide note...
I purposely decided to see how modest you would try to do this episode. I am impressed with your attempt to convenience the viewers. Btw - if central govt had done a 1 day ban of NDTV or did similar way of arrest of JP Roy then the CTC would be of same tone?
The law of the land is the same for everyone
@@manigopal92 Great to know this information! Thanks.
@The Maker Channel I know that you take it as a joke. But I don't have time to elaborate until now out of pure necessity to clarify. My name is Dr.Mani Gopal Madala. I am from Andhra Pradesh and I always was a massive supporter of Modi. What I meant was, Shekhar is not biased towards the BJP or Congress ANYMORE. Everyone is personally biased towards BJP or Congress but that's their PERSONAL preference. He's doing a good job as an UNBIASED JOURNALIST (profession is different from personal preference). And I don't think our Modi govt is dumb as this post in the first place saying "if central govt had done a 1 day ban of NDTV or did similar way of arrest of JP Roy". This so called adult can't even type a sentence in English and he thinks he's making a point. You and him are the kind of RETARDS giving bad name to the right wing !
@The Maker Channel And it's not "A valuable info" dumbass
@@ravikumarchivukula2166 And you can't even correct your goddamn rubbish grammar after editing your own comments ? What a fckng Loser. Instead of begging for likes on UA-cam, why don't you go beg on the streets ? Atleast you can earn some money that way!
As an architect, I am just worried about the poor man and his mother who died. Mighty clients not paying up is routine.
Dear he was not poor man ..his mother was killed by him then he committed sucide..
@@jabarnews7476 But the suicide note is the key here..
Arnab was not arrested due to his journalism, rather for fraud against an Interior designer who owe him RS 84lakh, who later suicide naming Arnab Goswami in his letter.
Journalists arrested by BJP Govts:
Pawan Kumar Jaiswal who reported scam in MID-Day Meal in UP.
Andrew Sam Reported about shortage of PPE kit in TN.
Siddique Kaplan was arrested for Hathras Reporting.
55 Journalist got arrested for reporting on Corona cases.
Dhaval Patel arrested for reporting merely on Speculative CM of Gujarat
Masrat Zahra of JnK was arrested under UAPA for his FB post.
Kishore Chandra of Manipur was arrested under NSA for making Video against BJP government
Vinod Dua was charged with Sedation that he COULD lead to public Mischief.
Dozens of Journalist protested in Fatehpur for harassment by UP government
Ratan Singh in Ballia was killed
Vikram Singh was killed in Ghaziabad
Chandan Tiwari was killed in Jharkhand by couple of people
Honarable Mentions-
Sidhart Varadrajan
Prashant Kanojia
Ashwani Saini
Om Sharma
Vishal Anand
Neha Dixit
Zubair Ahmed
Subhas Rai
Pawan Chaudhary
Vijay Vineet
Manish P
Last but not least Kalburgi, Gauri Lankesh, Govind Pansare, Narendra Dabholkar etc were murdered.
In Press freedom Index we fell to 142 among 180 countries
We all know how IT/ED/etc are being misused by Government against Journalist
@@kavisiddu no sir it should also match with circumstancial evidence s merely a letter doesn't have much evidentiary value
@@kavisiddu sir you can check suicide note is not a enough proof
Just watch the words he uses. He calls Rhea Chakraborty "poor Rhea Chakraborty". He terms the death of SSR a suicide while CBI is still seized with investigating. I have a list of choicest Hindi or Urdu abuses for this man masquerading as a journalist.
It's just his views..no one is bound to buy it...
Imagine the outrage if similar treatment was given to Sardesai or Prannoy Roy by police in a BJP state.
But people would also burst firecrackers on streets.
Haan bhai, tumko aur kitna outrage chaiye?
Prashant Kanojia was arrested in UP just because they didn't like what he wrote.
Atleast MH police has a valid case against Arnab. Why didn't Arnab not pay the dues he owed Anvay Naik forcing him to commit suicide?
INTOLERENCE GROUP WILL GET ACTIVATED
Mother was strangled , thats something strange here.. police should have solved it long ago..
The then BJP govt suppressed this case in late 2018
@@TheOppositionthat might be but again then courts could have done something for the disclosure for the families
That was politics then and Arnab was saved during that time.
Now politics has changed in the state and he is getting the taste of his own medicine.
BTW, Arnab is anything but journalist.
@@praveentripathi6009foresnsic report has more credibility than that of note
@@hrushikesh90 let law take it's own course.
Intro of arnab was hilarious, i couldnt stop laughing..😂😂
He is famous in some.
He is doing something not journalism.
And iam not going to argue about it..
This is true journalism...👏👏
What abt rabish kumar , rapjeeep sardesai , rana landyubb ?
@@darshankhandelwal7290
They are other side of a same coin, where one side is Arnab😑
Well said. SG and Print is left oriented people so hypocripsy and biasedness is first step of there journalism and mindset . They think they can speak anything and people are idiots those have nothing to verify on there distorted facts and figures.
@Alu Pyaz bhai tu pyaz kareed jake, idhar BJP IT cell ka msg copy paste matkar..
@@saimanoor7149 you misunderstood my comment. This is not hypocritic statement, media should help opposition, keep flaws of govt. infront of people and ask question to ruling party.. left/right oriented mind set is harmfull only if it makes you think illogical.. like arnab...
So Saima people are not idiots most of them illiterate, ask BJP to provide good education so that atleast future generations will have developed country instead developing country.
Actually shekar gupta must be feeling within himself "it serves arnab well" ... But he is appearing as though he is the most balanced and noble journalist out there...
That is true but better than the lot that has no morality and pursues anti-BJP, anti-Hindu, pro-Jihadi, pro-Communist bias.
Noble!?🙄🧐
🤣🤣🤣🤣
The beginning of your comments , you hv already shown your bias!
Still much better than cow swami..
Everybody has their bias.only the honest own up.
BJP leaders and fake news channels are badly affected.
ARE TUM LOG KITNA BHI CHATI PITO, PITO CHATI , LIBERANDUO , USE BAIL MILEGA HI.
Rhea Chakraborty must be happiest person right now
she might be high on maal and making a nude video
Raid in NDTV was also on charges of money laundering - a non journalistic crime. Why that was considered as the blackest day of democracy... You were also part of the group crying foul. Why different standard now. Or you should have the courage to speak in same tone against NDTV at that time
He is a bjp inclined journalist, you are a Congress inclined journalist. He has his share of followers you have your own.
Truth dies a slow death.
One does evidence-based journalism. Another blames Pakistan for locusts that came and destroyed crops in India.............
@@anonymous_4276 Well said.
It's not about journalism but about the personal crime....the aggrieved party who are ordinary citizens deserve just and impartial inquiry....
Very true!
Your personal ethnics reflects work ethnic.
Didnt SSR and Disha deserve it...
You are not supporting him Full heartedly he earned this situation for himself
Shame on you, you don't remember mamta, and left do in bengal.
Reporting mid meals deserves arrest in UP?
A speculation of change of CM in gujarat deserves arrest?
There's a long list... was Smriti, Ravishankar sleeping?
@@yourballsinmyfisticansquee5374 BALATKARI JANTA PARTY KA DALAL SPOTTED POSTING SAME COMMENT ON EVERY REBUTTAL
@Shinji Ikari www.thehindu.com/news/national/manipur-journalist-kishorechandra-wangkhemcha-jailed-for-12-months-under-nsa-for-criticising-bjp-government/article25782130.ece
I like your unbiased style of journalism Shekhar ji... India is really deprived of journalists like you at the moment!!
Sir, Don't be very excited because you will be next, A local cop will drag you out of your house and bundle you in a police van. #JUSTLIKETHAT.
Yes. I agreed.
Eager to see Shekhar Gupta behind bars. But these guys will lick the feet of any payer
Irony: When justice is being done legally, everybody has a problem; then for what reason is journalism true?
Sorry babu ❤️
There is trust dificiency in the Maha police plus its corrupt police force currently headedby Udav Thakarey and Parambir Singh respectively.
@@premtiwari3161 as a Maharashtrian we are proud of our police. They treat citizens like their family... So you north Indians can keep your shitty police to you... We are happy with our police_/_
@@omchattar1426 lol i like how you people are unapologetically racist towards south indian and then speak things like these
@@kartikaytiwari7387 if you don't know this but Maharashtra is part of South India. And yet feeds north india... So maybe if you don't have any better argument than calling us racist maybe read more
Never spoke a word about atrocities in WB . Shame !! Shame!!!
Whats was your business mode " SOURCE" " SUTRA"
Nobody should get immunity...not press, not politician, not police, Not judges...
But our country is shamelessly allowing the bad politicians, bad press, Goons in khaki and Corrupt judges to rein free....but people who raise voice against attrocity and people who are right have no way to save themself.
Exactly. All this mullah maulana class as well running their mouths inciting violence, but still given that they have power in their community, nobody can touch them
Mr. Gupta talks like a scared journalist. One of the basic qualities that a journalist should have is the ability to call a spade a spade without fear.
The sad thing is that every politician wants to control journalist and everybody pick there side according to their ideology. But nobody wants to support unbaised and serious journalism.
He is not a journlist at all. He is just a pawn in the hands of a party....
Who is?
Everyone is a pawn
@swetab singh He is because of BJP not other way around. The Day he start criticizing BJP viewership will be lowest
What about ndtv?
@Akash Akash Exactly, they are sold to their Political MAsters... Be it Arnab or Ravish.
@@seventhuser904 people these days have become increasingly retarded they think that those that align with their thought process are unbiased whereas their opponents are the worst people to have walked on this planet.
Nicely said Sir. When Arnab was harassed by a person in flight, that person was banned to fly for 60 days by civil aviation minister. Now when Arnab was arrested, there are hartals in Karnataka BJP members. It clearly shows Arnab had BJP following.
Mamtha started it first.. Ohh sorry i forgot u know mamtha (a nice lady) since long long time..
"Evidence free journalism"! Was the VK Singh coup attempt a case of journalism full of evidence.
ua-cam.com/video/a1IPYmxAVic/v-deo.html bhai please dekho maine arnab par meme video banaya hai...!
Bahut mehnat lagi hai bhai😓😕
Koi dekh hi nahi raha😓😭😭
Don't try to trap people in this whataboutism. Almost every claim that he has made has contradicted himself.I'm not against the central govt. as such but the way it polarises media.
@@awhig2474 well said!👍🏼
Ru talking about SG?
By him, I meant Arnab not Shekhar
John 8:1-11 "let him who is without sin cast the first stone"
Ofcourse with your monologue you want to convey "jo hua accha nahi hua" but at the same time "he deserved it". What will you do when they come for you? You and your cronies in lutyens have been subverting the psyche of a nation for an entire generation and more.
The lutyens is finished.
So right
Wow . Fucking spot on brother. SG is, but a mere pawn of Lutyens. A sell out who , under the garb of civilised journalism is conducting a propaganda on behalf of the Lutyens
It's a clear cut vendetta against ARNABJI.
Every body understands it
Hey Shekhar so much qualification & roundabout in your support almost nullified it. We got your point basically.
Ecactly my feeling
Exactly! My god
Everyone,
Please watch this 5 min video, show it to your family doctor & ask an explanation. & yes Its important !!!
ua-cam.com/video/bPdTSS_l0gY/v-deo.html
Yaaarnnn... we had journalists who allocated cabinet ministers to govt and fixed their portfolios... good night!
Sekhar Gupta justifying Arnab treatment, shame on you hypocrite , have you even in cut the cutter criticized Mamata & Naveen for their action against journos , only jogi is bad ,than why your friends following Yogi , why not making examples of tolerance, you pl apologize for your act of making us fool
Ya Guptaji on a earlier episode said it so himself
It was started by Congress during emergency!!!
@@ezazable well he is correct by stating it but he forgets to mention the legacy of congress has been forwarded by the BJP
Nowadays this type of situation happens people like you mentioned “congress “ “emergency”but nobody point out the reason why congress ruled 30years after emergency
So, you are admitting that we are under emergency rule
Why u r declaring it is suicide for SSR and Disha .. as a journalist u must use the right words .. don’t misguide
Looks like you are justifying and putting all blames on yogi. Then why not neheru or indira?
Nehuru is gone baby gone.🤣💜
He did say that Arnab's arrest is wrong, but he is also pointing out that arrests or journalists also happen in other states, predominantly in UP
Y not blame Mughals and British?
Is this a serious question? LMAO. Yogi is the one who has been destroying democracy in UP in recent days. India and Nehru are long dead.
I am the first viewer today. I feel quite good actually about it..
Ramuuu chai lao bhai k lea first aya hai
Thali peeto phir
@@yourballsinmyfisticansquee5374 You can't hear adverse opinion my friend. He was putting his views on the issue. He is way beyond jealousy. He has achieved all he wanted in his life. Some Bhakts dont like their govt being criticised and now, some even dont like Arnav being criticised.
*Old man too smart to take a side* _ Wants to remain relevant to both the sides : )
right... old man is lost his mind
That is journalism. No biasness
That’s true journalism whose definition is lost in the era of Tabloid journalism!
Too smart to call this a Shivsena Govt when we know who is really pulling the strings or say squeezing the balls of SS
Argument is baseless. It is a case which is closed, opened at the behest of the state. Everybody knows.
So by that logic all closed cases should never be reopened??
UP started it? Dude.... you forgot Emergency?? What rubbish.
I would say the British Started it
You would again say, Mughals started it...
😂😂😂 Nonsense finger-pointing game Bhakth
@@jagajeetkuppala yeah so let me just say what suits me. Also SG doesnt even mention that there was no summons issued to him and he was simply picked up by police. What rubbish lol.
I would say a Mad Dog suffering from Rabies is taken by Municipal authorities.🤣
I think it's u
@@cpatil-vh5bw
Looks like your Drugs supplier is gone, So u are desperate.
Yeahh! this is free speech none of that barking by...
Arnab is second one,first one is roaming in Bihar now.
@@samrudhik8757 😁
What's the new evidence in this suicide case that the police came running to arrest him. This case was closed a year ago. If cases was closed by the court then u are questioning the judiciary as well. It's all about politics.
This sounds like a case of poetic justice. Without much proof, Arnab went behind Rhea Chakrabarty and many others with vengeance without caring about what happened to the other person. I’m hoping when he gets out of this, he will reflect on his situation and be kind on his victims that he tries in his kangaroo court. That being said I agree with your comments that an eye for an eye will leave the whole country blind. So I hope he is released soon.
I really don't think he will change. He makes crores out of his horrible and divisive "journalism".
*इस देश मे न्याय मिलना भूसे के ढेर में सुई ढूंढने जैसा है।*
Why? Just because Arnab is the one at the wrong enf this time? If someone had said the same stuff in front of arnab earlier, arnab would hv asked the guy to go to Pakistan.
Meanwhile Kangana and her sister: Deep Breathes🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐🤐
Kangana ab thode din ke liye underground hogi..
Why is Rhea and her brother are called "poor".... they were arrested because of evidence and Rhea herself admitted to the proof, in what way do they become poor guys? And how can you conclude that Shushant's case is suicide as the case is not closed yet?
Aiims report
You keep waiting for the CBI report. The aims report already confirmed it was a suicide. Shouting at the top of one's voice in news studio can not make up evidence. Nobody wants to understand depression or bipolar or anything related to mental health. Bas sabko drama chahiye
@@lullaby205 Some guys ACTUALLY take Arnab's conspiracy theories seriously. That's what surprises me. His theories might be good entertainment but it's surprising that some guys think his conspiracy theories are the Gospel truth.
If he feared kidnapping , harrasment and insult then why naik chose only himself and his mother to be dead and left his wife and daughter untouched.
So you want to take a call on that as well? He would not have been emotionally able to kill his wife and daughter, after seeing his mother dead. Anyways, how does that absolve the people responsible for his death?
So you wanted his wife and daughter to be dead to justify the atrocity?
Why don't we send you to him to ask him personally?
It is nice to know the political side of this arrest. However, do not agree with your narrative of two murders of Disha Salian and Sushant Singh Rajput. If Udhav Thakrey son is innocent then why does Thakrey and parambir Singh threaten and shut up everyone who wants justice for SSR and Disha. Kangana Renaut was threatened and her office was destroyed. SSR friends have threats on their life. Disha parents are too scared to adk for justice. There are many illegal activities go on in Mumbai politics police Bollywood. Anyone who raises voice to stop these underworld drug mafia are either killed or sent to jail. Your narrative was very diplomatic. Arnab stands by truth and that is why he is liked by common people. One needs to be fearless to raise voice against these people. Can you imagine if Gandhi did not fight for freedom India would be still under British.
👌👌
Sahi
I'm glad I'm following the true journalism from #ThePrint, thanks to shekhar sir, Who had created this beautiful free-spirited channel, No stress, No story, No Exclamation ...
Most important No irrelevant Question Marks ❤️
Center Back Arnab?? what you are talking Mr Gupta
U r telling lie. His out standing was 83lakh . He paid 90% of outstanding as per the agreement. Don't spread fake newss. Look at court case
You sound like partialling among television journalism. He asked for SSR case CIB investigation and also for Palghar incident. Other News channels are not going on such political issues where arnab has put his legs.. He also get arrested for 8 days. You find logic of arrest of goshwami in a 1.5 year old case after 3-4 debates which is directly against congress and shivsena government.
whether Arnab was doing journalism or not is not matter of discussion.
The answer we need to ask how come democratic government function work like that.
would Bjp has done this this would have termed as emergency .
Bjp is already doing it chasma hata chutiye
@@ret007able West Bengal me Jo ho raha us level kahi kuch nahi ho raha.
I don't know everybody is ignoring that.
Voters were lathi charged at polling booth in 2019 election. Series of organised murder.
How come Bharat Teri tukde honge, and celebrating afzal guru death ceremony is freedom of speech and Jai shree Ram was not .
Just becoz somebody support rss ideology doesn't mean he is idiot or less valued. Dozens of RSS workers were killed Bengal and Kerala not a single investigation on that
Just becoz u support this party that party does not make u educated intellectual. so better judge your words before judging others.
Jaha tak chasme ki baat hai chasma aap tutariye. 2g spectrum scam,coal scam , Commonwealth scam .
Sab bhul gae ho Kya. Itne bade scams hai ki harshad Mehta bhi Sharma jae.
@@raj-nz4bj teri ideology ke wajah se chutiya nai bola teri rhetorics ki Bengal mein dekho , sirf bengal kyun UP bhi dekh le sab jagah politicians power ka misuse krte hain ..isliye party ka chasma hata aur dekh kahan kya ho rha hai
Wow Sekhar ji so conveniently left out our dear Mamata ji
I expected the comment section to be fiery.
And it exceeded my expectations 💥
I am really having trouble understanding all of this controversy surrounding this video. He is just standing up for another person of his field. Is it just Arnab hate that is fuelling this hate or is it something else?
I'm here Just with popcorn.
Sir - please check the dictionary meaning of manhandle - "handle (someone) roughly by dragging or pushing". You agree he was pushed around but you disagree he was manhandled. Great stuff until 01:30 - don't think i need to watch this narrative further.
SG is sounding like JAI of SHOLEY when he goes to MAUSI regarding VERU'S marriage with BASANTI
ua-cam.com/video/UZVhl9m8FrQ/v-deo.html
He is d new godi
For a very long time I had the idea that The print and The Wire are identical twins and that the two survive essentially by validating the skewed and often misinfomed understandings of national issues that the educated and left leaning population of the country harbours. However, ever since I have started watching Shekhar Gupta's videos, I have realized that I was terribly wrong ( and I have no problem in acknowledging this). The Print is doing a remarkable job and the reason why i have turned into this huge fan of Shekhar Gupta lately is his ability to call a spade a spade. I have not seen him shying away from taking the tough, unpopular and more importantly a non partisan position in most of the issues. His journalism is for a better country and for a better world. It is not against a party, an ideology, a religion or against an individual. Keep up the good work sir. We need more people like you.
His facts are not correct in when he says “Palghar was communalised”
When you have evidence for it being a communal incident, how can you brush it off by saying it was being communalised? It’s a congress ruled state. Law and order is a state responsibility. There is a clear category to which the persons lynched belonged to. How is it so obvious that this was not communal in the first place and bjp had to go out others way to sensationalise and communalise this incident????
Look at yourself before raising finger at everyone...its not print..its your own bias.
@@amanabegam2422 no look at yourself.
Anyone who stands for the right thing does not look down on Arnab. Yes , his manner may not be always palatable but you cannot deny his courage and commitment to justice - qualities which are far better than those of Lutyens journalists.
Arnab may be loud and rude but he wears his patriotism on his sleeves. He takes on issue which journalists like you dont dare to take up. Do some self introspection rather than demeaning AG in a very subtle way
Journalist's job is to do the news
Mate, so what if he is patriotic, unfortunately though arnab is no longer a journalist and takes up issues that others don't take up, coz that's not truth, he's just a businessman, sooner u realize what he's doing to journalism, better for Indians and u, if u are true Indian, that is 😅
@@UMI.EAT.TRAVEL i think u r living in a bubble of utopia all media owners like Pranoy Roy or Arnab or Rajat Sharma etc are business man. They have come to do business not charity so your arguement is weak. Itsvery intolerant to say if i dont agree with your view i am not a true Indian. May be you are a Pakistani posing as an Indian :) Learn to live with a different view if u r a true indian
@@indranilchakraborty33 of course it is business for all, but still the job of journalism needs to be done as true as possible. Please tell me u also do ur job to the best of your ability. And I never said you are NOT true Indian, I disagree with you calling arnab patriotic, coz the lies he's spreading under the garb of journalism is harming my country India more than his patriotism, and u fail to see it, unless again I repeat, u are true Indian, u will condemn the disharmony he's trying to spread. Either u are brainwashed or u can't see it, hope this debate changes your mind about your so called patriotic journalist (both of which he's not 😂)
@@UMI.EAT.TRAVEL hey its not your country also its my country too. Arnab is speaking the truth in a crude and loud way. I diagree with Arnabs mannerism and rudeness but i fully agree with the content. I think u have been part of the elite brainwashed circle who tries to teach who is a true Indian or not. For you its my way or highway. Anyone who agree with your narrative is a true Indian lol You are speaking the voice of 1975 Emergency. I think u also have that mindset .Arnab is a patriot and a journalist and that too a fine one. You are comfortable with the Lutyens gang spreading a false narrative for years. I dont need any sermon from someone to prove my Indianness. I have a doubt whether you are a Pakistani troll lol So dont go down the slippery slope of mud slinging. Lets agree to disagree . I stick to my view and you stick to yours without mud slinging on each other
I feel you have made a lazy talk on the issue. Would have been appreciative if you have said black is black and white is white.
Centre has got too much power, we need to make opposition stronger
Till 2035 no chance of congress I bet u bcz of Congress anti India stand, pro Muslim,anti hindu ,pro pakistan. E.g. pulwama, love jihad ,wahabism, Art 370 etc
Never understood this anti hindu thing. Being a Hindu it always amuses me how 22% people can hurt 78% Majority
@Ashwini Desai Justice for Anvay Naik 🙏🙏🙏 🙏
@@akashkumarsingh1331 what will happen after 2035?
Yes SG sir you are right some of us like him. Rather, I would say he may get out of hand sometimes in delivery, sure. But his heart is in the right place. I cant say the same for many others in in the business.