Quick Fix -- Bracing A Sagging Garage Beam

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 126

  • @chrishapp4742
    @chrishapp4742 7 років тому +49

    Overkill is underrated. Remember that. Nice work.

  • @rm42749
    @rm42749 10 років тому +6

    I had the same problem but in my house. I had to cut and drill the sheet-metal all by hand though. I jacked the broken joist as far past level as I could get it and then bolted the support up just like you did. That was 20 years ago and it is still there doing the job.

  • @jamisan
    @jamisan 7 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for this excellent solution. I have the same problem and have been puzzling for several months over a way to level this beam and have it be stable and strong enough. Thank you again

  • @rossmerchant1832
    @rossmerchant1832 6 років тому +8

    Good work! I have the same issue at my house and was thinking of exactly the same solution. Your fix is complete over kill but better over done than under done!

  • @SC-hk6ui
    @SC-hk6ui Рік тому +1

    spot on professional job, you should be rightly proud.

  • @temia7944
    @temia7944 3 роки тому +10

    From a Structural Engineer's perspective, additional ply introduced at the underside of the beam would better control the deflection. Nice one.

    • @garethmeansgentle
      @garethmeansgentle Місяць тому

      Plywood on the underside would be better? I'm in this same situation

  • @josephbriceno2799
    @josephbriceno2799 4 роки тому +9

    Well done. I just wonder if the outer holes are not creating a new weakness where cracking can occur. I would have preferred an outer 'Simpson tie' type of wrap that doesn't take away from the structural integrity of the beam itself. But I have no way of knowing what type of structural significance you are dealing with.

  • @freedom-money
    @freedom-money 9 років тому +2

    Nice work! Its never overkill when it could be 200 years.....

  • @DukeLaCrosse20
    @DukeLaCrosse20 10 років тому +9

    Did you consider putting channel iron under the beam? It would seem to me that you could use a standard piece of channel iron (and some long wood screws) underneath and it would perform similarly, perhaps with less hardware since the moment of inertia of the channel iron would be added at a distance from the centroid of your beam.

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  10 років тому

      No, thought didn't even cross my mind. I was just using material I had on hand, which is plate steel. I don't keep channel iron on hand.

    • @Josh-gb6mv
      @Josh-gb6mv 6 років тому +5

      This is actually pretty common, called fledge plates, I work in a steel and welding shop most of the times contractors get two plates anywhere from 1/4 to 1/2 inch with staggered holes and run lag bolts into the floor joists after they have jacked them up.

  • @telosfd
    @telosfd 9 років тому +3

    I have a ridge beam placed between to brick walls in my roof, so the one edge is already rotten and iam thinking to cut the rotten part and doing the same thing or join a piece of wood trush. I like your video, very informative.

  • @bahramatashkar6616
    @bahramatashkar6616 10 років тому +3

    I love the job you have done, well done.

  • @buzzkill2739
    @buzzkill2739 10 місяців тому +1

    That would be crazy work in a crawl space..

    • @Dr-ow9jr
      @Dr-ow9jr 3 місяці тому +1

      In a crawl space it would be a pier

  • @bojielopez2005
    @bojielopez2005 3 роки тому +1

    Nice idea, can you please let me know the thickness of the metal plate and the appropriate distance of the screws. Thanks.

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  3 роки тому

      1/4" plate, 1/2" bolts, not sure on the distance apart. Probably should stagger the top and bottom rows unlike I did here.

  • @RichDavey
    @RichDavey Рік тому

    Superb job
    Gonna be doing this too
    Well done 👍

  • @amberschlegel7153
    @amberschlegel7153 8 років тому +2

    This looks like a good idea for rafter repair too. Thanks for the awesome idea😁

  • @dminky1126
    @dminky1126 2 роки тому

    This is exactly what I need. Where can I order the those metal brackets?

  • @rickmiller1257
    @rickmiller1257 Місяць тому

    I have to do this same thing to my son's floor joist. Question....is it necessary to use plates on both sides of the joist?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  Місяць тому

      probably not, but in this case I felt I could clamp the bolts harder without compromising the boards

  • @md20120
    @md20120 4 місяці тому

    So this is essentially a flitch plate but instead of the timber on either side of the metal flitch plate, the flitch plates are on either side of the timber?

  • @blinzy7282
    @blinzy7282 4 роки тому

    It needed it! It isn't overkill if it is actually necessary. From what I can see the original beam looks like it was extremely under designed and was spliced in the WORST spot! The splice is right where the beam has the most bending moment. This is what happens when people don't know how to frame buildings, usually seen in old buildings or un-permitted structures. It looks like the splice location should have been a column location, but this works.

  • @frankphoto2
    @frankphoto2 5 років тому +2

    Thanks now i know how to fix my sagging beams

  • @Bryanicus
    @Bryanicus 9 років тому +6

    What would the ballpark cost be to have something like this fabricated?

    • @thisdj83
      @thisdj83 5 років тому +1

      $60.00

    • @thisdj83
      @thisdj83 5 років тому +1

      I actually did a repair like this a couple weeks ago. Home depot sells different styles, sizes and gauges at reasonable prices. I spent about $25 on a repair

    • @thisdj83
      @thisdj83 5 років тому +1

      There is a small rack near lumber. It has all varied sizes, design and gauges. I think if you describe what you need and what for, someone there might point you in the right direction.

  • @bababa39
    @bababa39 5 років тому

    Awesome video. I bought a house with a bedroom and bathroom above the double garage. The previous owner had telescopic posts initially...but then took them out (car doors hitting them) and put some kinda adjustable steel girdle around the support beam (3 - 2x8s) and I'm noticing some ceiling drop in my bedroom/bathroom. Problem is....I don't know how to adjust this thing lol

  • @DRJMF1
    @DRJMF1 3 роки тому

    Thanks. I need to make a purlin to a length of 6.5 metres but wood only comes in 4.8m lengths. What is the best way to join the two timbers to make a 6.5 m long purlin beam ? The purlin will be composed of two 6x2 inch beams sandwiched together face to face And then maybe a 4x2 inch beam underneath the two 6x2 beams. The purlin would be a 8x4 inch beam but needs to be 6.5m in length. Thanks.

  • @nole8923
    @nole8923 2 роки тому

    Best video I’ve seen that relates to my situation. I made a loft in my storage shed that is 16 ft wide on 2x6 joists about 22 inches apart. It’s not saggy but I’m thinking about doing something similar as opposed to a lally column for support. I have a question for everybody. For 16 ft joist support how long does the flitch plate need to be in the middle?

  • @ferrencebeeb
    @ferrencebeeb 5 років тому

    Hi, that looks very useful, but I couldn't quite get what the splices were for on either side.
    Is the central beam just one beam or two? I guessed it was one but the splices on either side made me second guess.
    How far through do the splices go through the wood?
    Is it to introduce a gap on either side so that when it's bent back there's some room for give in the beam?

  • @mtgentry
    @mtgentry 4 роки тому

    Did you considered staggering the bolts? This still looks great tho.

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  4 роки тому +1

      Didn't think about it, but that would have been better

  • @terryoconnor1744
    @terryoconnor1744 6 років тому +1

    Great video! I'm planning on doing this, and have the steel with synched holes, but am wondering how you attached it. Was it difficult to get the holes to match up on the other side?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  6 років тому +1

      I drilled the holes after I had the first plate up. They weren't 100% perpendicular though. I ran through a couple of bolts and mounted the opposite plate, then corrected the out-of-aligned holes from the other side. Hammered through the bolts and it went together well.

    • @terryoconnor1744
      @terryoconnor1744 6 років тому

      Thanks!

  • @MrAllie-bf6zt
    @MrAllie-bf6zt 6 днів тому

    Can this be done for a main roof joist?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  6 днів тому +1

      I would recommend getting an structural engineer to give you a response to this question.

  • @LisaBartlettREALTOR
    @LisaBartlettREALTOR 3 роки тому

    Where can I buy the steel brace you picture? I've searched the internet and can only find decorative pieces

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  3 роки тому +1

      There should be local steel suppliers near you. They can typically sheer it to the size you need too.

    • @LisaBartlettREALTOR
      @LisaBartlettREALTOR 3 роки тому

      @@JohnHarmon Thank you !!

  • @kurtzimmerman1637
    @kurtzimmerman1637 5 років тому +1

    Hey john. Where would I go to have something like this made? I have the same problem in my garage.

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  5 років тому +3

      any steel shop should be able to slice some plate for you. You can drill the holes or have them do it.

    • @kurtzimmerman1637
      @kurtzimmerman1637 5 років тому

      @@JohnHarmon thank you

  • @GXRG00
    @GXRG00 9 років тому +1

    Nice work!!👍🏼👍🏼

  • @modelformodels
    @modelformodels 2 роки тому

    After 8yrs . Is it still holding strong?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  2 роки тому

      My brother no longer lives there, so I haven't checked on it, but I believe that it is.

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  2 роки тому

      I stacked the bolts on top of each other. That might make it weaker. I would stagger them if I were to do it again.

  • @joevlasek5158
    @joevlasek5158 4 роки тому

    Nice Job: On a different note, do you think this would work for installing a 16" door instead of my two existing 2 8' garage doors with a support beam in the center? (W/O) a second story. This would seem like a much more cost effective approach than rebuilding my garage? I would appreciate any help you can give?

    • @JordanHaisley
      @JordanHaisley Рік тому

      Yes, but have an architectural or structural engineer sign off on the design.

  • @AR12-AQUIL
    @AR12-AQUIL 4 роки тому

    Nice job. Why didn't you weld a bottom plate to make a u channel to overkill the overkill. I believe in overkill when dealing with that type of weight above living space.

  • @ironwill4706
    @ironwill4706 2 роки тому

    Nice job😎

  • @mattthroup7437
    @mattthroup7437 5 років тому

    Hi John, great video mate - is this similar to a flitch plate ?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  5 років тому

      Never heard of a flitch plate before, but I suppose so. :)

  • @matijazg5455
    @matijazg5455 3 роки тому

    People comment that this is overkill, but my first thought was that using metal brace is inferior to using wooden one because it decreases flexibility of a wooden beam. Of course, this is just a garage so it probably doesn't matter, and I might be wrong, I'm no professional, I ended up here looking for ideas how to reinforce old wooden beams in my house :)

  • @jroar123
    @jroar123 3 роки тому

    Where did you get your music?

  • @jbarsness5514
    @jbarsness5514 Рік тому

    How long is the span? Thanks

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  Рік тому

      My metal brace is just shy of 4'. Not sure on the span of the 2x4s. This was many years ago and my brother no longer lives there.

  • @jamessilverman4887
    @jamessilverman4887 6 років тому

    I need to do an identical repair. I do not have equipment for cutting metal plate. Where would you suggest I go to get the plate fabricated?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  6 років тому +1

      Most places that sell steel will slice it up for you. With a drill and an angle grinder you can have the same thing. It will just take longer.

  • @iananderson8035
    @iananderson8035 4 роки тому +1

    Great idea! Do you know of any online calculators to figure out the dimensions of steel needed and hole spacing/bolt size??

    • @bryanstock281
      @bryanstock281 4 роки тому

      Did you find a resource for this?

    • @iananderson8035
      @iananderson8035 4 роки тому

      @@bryanstock281 not exactly but for a small fee there is a website service I found where you can connect with an engineer to discuss specifics about any project. www.justanswer.com

  • @PeterPan-kz2si
    @PeterPan-kz2si 8 років тому +2

    Is it still in place? It hasn't degraded

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  8 років тому +3

      Holding up fine. Still in place.

    • @PeterPan-kz2si
      @PeterPan-kz2si 8 років тому +4

      John Harmon - Cold Creek This method could potentially save me a couple grand at least. So hats off to you sir! If it pans out I owe you a couple jars of unfiltered honey

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  8 років тому

      :)

  • @stevensolis6507
    @stevensolis6507 7 років тому

    Where did you have that 1/4 inch plate made? Did you have it taken to a metal fabricating shop to have it done? I may have to do something like that on my tool since the roof is starting to sag.

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  7 років тому +1

      My garage. I have a small CNC plasma table.

  • @newbie54
    @newbie54 9 років тому

    What size bolts did you use? What size holes?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  9 років тому

      newbie I don't remember. 1/2" I think

  • @marcalva2030
    @marcalva2030 5 років тому

    Why not replacing the beam for a new one and healthy wood?

    • @iceteakilla
      @iceteakilla 5 років тому

      That would be a lot of work lol. He would have to have everything supported and then to remove that one beam and replace it with another beam. All the preparation and extra material to support the structure while he swaps out the old would take and cost a lot longer than just jacking up that current beam and adding in those plates as support.

  • @gergemall
    @gergemall 3 роки тому

    Thank you… great job

  • @SterlingCobb
    @SterlingCobb 3 роки тому

    How did you get the plate done?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  3 роки тому

      Not sure what you are asking, but I cut it out on my CNC table. You could have it sheared at a metal supplier and drill holes in it.

  • @franciscogonzalez-pp4kd
    @franciscogonzalez-pp4kd 4 роки тому

    How long were your plates?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  4 роки тому

      Just under 4 feet as that is as big as my plasma table can cut.

  • @MexSider
    @MexSider 4 роки тому

    After 6 years, we still watching this video,
    My question is, How wide is that? My garage is 30 wide and is sagging, Im thinking to put a support in the center

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  4 роки тому

      How wide is the brace? Just under 4'

  • @henrydu9982
    @henrydu9982 6 років тому

    Why not double the beam with a new one? Just curious.

    • @papergatorzfedducca7998
      @papergatorzfedducca7998 6 років тому

      Where would u put the second beam? Right beside it? Length?

    • @jackboltsvolts8986
      @jackboltsvolts8986 6 років тому

      @@papergatorzfedducca7998 ... under it! The depth is the strength. I-beam principle.

  • @justtisha
    @justtisha 3 роки тому

    Where would I look to have someone fabricate this for me?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  3 роки тому

      A steel shop, or post something in your local adds

  • @rjc1945
    @rjc1945 8 років тому

    What size steel plates? Looks like about 4' long, maybe 1/2" thick? Bolts 6" apart?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  8 років тому

      +rjc1945 1/4" plate if I remember correctly... maybe 3/16. Unsure on how far apart I put them... It was almost a couple of years ago. I would pull up the CNC file and tell you, but I lost the hard drive that had them all.... and I didn't have them backed up like I thought

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  8 років тому

      +rjc1945 Yup, 4' long.... roughly 6" apart I think based on the number of holes I counted

  • @vladimirlimansky2081
    @vladimirlimansky2081 3 роки тому

    Where did you buy/order this metal brace from?

  • @mathteacher2651
    @mathteacher2651 7 років тому +1

    Great Job!

  • @chrisdutton9200
    @chrisdutton9200 5 років тому

    Who’s the artist/track please?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  5 років тому +1

      www.melodyloops.com/tracks/summer-break/

  • @SpicyAl3000
    @SpicyAl3000 7 років тому

    Hello all o/ Do you think it'd be possible to diy engineer an 8m (26 ft) beam to support a SIPS panel roof?

    • @alabastardmasterson
      @alabastardmasterson 6 років тому

      Not knowing all the load requirements, 26'x14" lam beams are under $200. Stack however many you need together. Glue and screw to add strength. TrussLok or structural screws. Having one milled might be cheaper

  • @terencesmith9004
    @terencesmith9004 7 років тому

    Hi John, greetings from Ireland. I am looking to do something similar to this on my bedroom ceilings which is sagging after converting my attic space without using steel. It's not sagging much, more of a settling in phase however as I am renovating my bedroom now and I want to add additional support. Can you tell me if your solution might weaken the timber by drilling so many holes in it or does the steel mitigate that?Also, the span of the joists is 14ft, dependent on wires /pipes going through the joists wouldi need to add steel anywhere I can or is the middle area sufficient to a 5-6ft piece of steel on each joist? Many thanks in advance of your expertise knowledge. RegardsTS.

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  7 років тому

      I would recommend calling a structural engineer for your specific situation. Many of them will give you some basic advise over the phone. In this situation I don't think it has weakened the wood at all, and is still holding up. I sandwiched it pretty hard though with those bolts. The friction of the plates alone should really help compensate for any weakness in the wood created by the holes. Hope that helps.

    • @terencesmith9004
      @terencesmith9004 7 років тому

      Much appreciated John. Keep up the good work.

  • @domesticbraila
    @domesticbraila 7 років тому

    At 0:58 ... you keep the mouse in your hand, on screen is an arrow called the promter

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  7 років тому

      Usually just called a pointer, or mouse pointer.

    • @bryanleigh6497
      @bryanleigh6497 6 років тому +1

      @@JohnHarmon Ignore armchair Grammar Nazis whose roofs are OK!

  • @mrs1975brown
    @mrs1975brown 7 років тому

    That's great , can you make me some plates for a 8 by 8 beam my splits are 8 feet apart where beam splices together 28 foot span ! I'm trying to find plates , willing to pay for 2 custome or 1 long single ????? Any advice

  • @AnthonyWebb7
    @AnthonyWebb7 10 років тому

    Miss the old intro!

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  10 років тому

      Which one? I still have them all :)

  • @t436
    @t436 8 років тому

    is there a way to buy the brace or it has to be made custom?

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  8 років тому

      Unknown. I guess it just depends where you live, but for this size I am leaning toward custom.

  • @mattyfreshification
    @mattyfreshification 7 років тому +1

    Love this

  • @ezekielteklaking
    @ezekielteklaking 3 роки тому +1

    yeah real quick fix let me just get out my metal press and cut the the sheet metal and press some holes into it. I can do this no problem

    • @dreamingcode
      @dreamingcode 3 роки тому

      I agree these videos of useless without showing us how it was done where do you get the metal Etc

  • @guadalupecovarrubias3487
    @guadalupecovarrubias3487 6 років тому

    Solid👍🏻

  • @istantch
    @istantch 10 років тому

    Nice!

  • @punchymuffin6402
    @punchymuffin6402 Рік тому

  • @terryfarrelly6411
    @terryfarrelly6411 6 років тому +1

    Great video. But wow you sound like the joker why so serious "

    • @JohnHarmon
      @JohnHarmon  6 років тому +1

      I was sick when I made this video

  • @beanstyx2732
    @beanstyx2732 6 років тому

    👍