The reaction was great. Nothing wrong with any of the criticisms, good or bad. Lisa is an amazing dancer obviously but I think she'll appreciate any pointers from different perspectives. Lisa is always immaculate in my eyes but it's great to see other dancers reactions.
I don't think looking down every now and then indicates lack of confidence or anything at all. Even when Lisa momentarily looks away from the camera, she still has that presence that directs your attention towards her. She is very confident in her dancing abilities since she's been dancing since 4 years old. Lisa is also known for her facial expressions while dancing. So, every move she does, whether it's looking straight at you or away, trust her it's intentional.
I always thought looking away was intentional, like giving off cool/indifferent vibes, I've seen other dancers do that like bts jimin. Also michael jackson literally poses while staring sideways for the same effect.
I liked that reaction. I really enjoyed the technical advice and small things like the eyes. I’ve seen a lot of reactions but most seem to only say great things and while I love idolizing someone I love learning how to be better more? It was small things like that, things I didn’t even notice until mentioned but then realized it had in fact changed the feeling. It was refreshing to take a step back and watch Lisa grow into an amazing dancer through this comp rather then just screaming about how amazing she is from the start, and that; I believe at least, allows us appreciate how far she’s come.
loved this reaction!! people say they want honesty but when they get it… it’s totally fair to say that lisa has evolved and improved over the years and has a style that suits some songs better than others. doesn’t change the fact that’s she’s of the best dancers in the industry!
this reaction is GREAT in my opinion it’s nice to see other dancers perspective lisa is an amazing and established dancer but doesn’t mean she can’t get criticism and the best part about this dancer is that she saw the progression of each lili film like even tho she didn’t love the hip hop side she still pointed out how they eventually got better with each new one. she’s amazing and lisa would definitely appreciate it that someone is saying she improved
I wanted to mention that in salsa dancing when dancing with a partner, the passive dancer role does look down at certain times, in certain moves. It makes the dancer look more feminine.
Her criticisms are very interesting and show that sometimes dance is a difference in opinions all together. Almost everyone I watch (myself as well) tend to think she does the hip hop/masculine type dance very well while she thinks (or thought before the movie) the opposite. And she perceives looking down as showing less confidence. While I do agree with that at times, in Lisa’s case she was definitely not coming off as unsure of herself. Her choice of when and where to make eye contact seems very intentional and an artistic choice. But I respect her opinion of course. Just fun to see different perspectives. I also love how she pointed out how much Lisa has evolved. Lilifilm the movie is definitely the best for me as well. I
Lisa is amazing..she is a pro...she is fast learner too ..easy choreo she can just learn by watching it once ....she has been tested at a show too..that's why they call dance machine... doesn't take more than 2 hours to learn the toughest of toughest choreography
when you look down it doesn't make you look unconfident, it's such an old-school dance thing like in europena dances they tell you not to look down but when you do its a certain feeling like sensual so i really hate that concept of you're not supposed to look down
These kinds of artistic choices are always subjective. It can be a problem when someone trained a certain way becomes dogmatic about the "rules" and in a largely unconscious mental process called "confirmation bias" actually will have a negative response to something that other people (not trained in the same way) will see as being beautiful and aesthetically excellent. It's like the dogma ("rule") is so ingrained that seeing it "broken" automatically triggers a "this is not good" response...because for years they were indoctrinated to associate it with not being correct.
@@TEAM__POSEID0N yes I agree I’ve had this experience after taking dance classes in different studios. I just don’t like when people project that onto others as if it’s the standard. Dance should be liberating and an artistic experience.
Lisa is my fave artist and each lilidance was better and better, I get why you say the lilidance one was not as confident as she is right now but thats because it was her first video and probably was nervous and also she didn't know how her fans will react but look at her now!! everyone loves the last lilidilm because here it shows the best of her and also the choreographer put more effort in the choreography!! anyways I did like your point of view since everyone has different opinion but also like your appreciation as a dancer!! anyways I love Lisa and I love her dance videos!!
I’m a dancer as well and Lisa definitely has the sauce. That cravin performance was fly af. The thing that probably seems “off” is that she’s really skinny which you or even myself at first probably wasn’t used to seeing with that type of movement. That’s why the tomboy choreo performance looked better with the baggy suit. The swag is definitely there though. Side note something I’ve noticed from videos is that Lisa performs these choreos better than Cheshir herself imo. Other note that floor move in tomboy where she’s doing those hops with her legs while simultaneously doing a broken down wave with her right arm is FLAMESS. One of the sickest moves out of all the choreos
Loved this reaction! Seriously enjoyed every comment and criticism you had to offer! I know the chances are slim, but I hope Lisa comes across this video some day. She's always been extremely passionate about dancing, so I feel like she'd really appreciate what you had to say considering your own expertise in the field. :-)
that;s so interesting about the hip hop stuff but because for me, I think lisa executes it so well that when i see other female idols in kpop dance, i compare them all to her and how i find that they're not as sharp and controlled as lisa.
@@iamguava lol how do you know how much experience Jenna has? I’m explaining her perspective, how other professionals feel is also valid but isn’t my concern, only hers.
@@Koko3op "seeing" versus "watching". I'm not sure what that means in this context. Does she train/teach dancers? If so, that would just mean that she sees hundreds of aspiring dancers and dance students, many likely being novices. Or is she dancing with hundreds of professional dancers every week? Either way, I don't think we can infer that such situation automatically elevates her into an unquestionable judgment-seat position above a person who has been dancing and winning awards for dancing since early childhood, as well as in recent years dancing for global audiences that number in the millions. Jenna has a point of view and an opinion. It's interesting. I just file it along with the various other points of views and opinions. I appreciate her taking the time to watch and offer her opinion. I will definitely be interested in seeing her dancing and I'm sure she's very good. I just can't really join in with some of those commenters who are trying to make her opinions out to be the pronouncement of an "expert" that can't be questioned or disagreed with by anyone who is not an "expert".
lol the comments saying they didn't like her reaction - lisa may be considered one of the best dancers in kpop but she's grown into that over the years, which is what jenna was pointing out, lisa wasn't as confident when she started and she worked on it... everyone has room to grow and perhaps the other dancers you watched reacting to lisa were focusing on different things to what jenna focuses on criticizing lisa (and so politely lmao) is not a crime
The world of UA-cam 😍. I even contemporaries not uploading this cos I had to re-do the screen recording cos I knew they’ll be some nonsense lol. Thanks for getting it tho!
@@Koko3op thank you for uploading it anyway - i really love that everyone you bring on isn't willing to fake a reaction, and your hard work even when something goes wrong!! i guess the intentional ignorance comes with the territory of being a super protective stan 👀
@@mrs_rover Well, just because someone loves what they see in Lisa's dancing doesn't mean that it's a "fake reaction" and being hyper-critical with comments like "this isn't her bag" and joking about her slender figure doesn't mean that the reaction is more genuine. People come into these things with different mindsets. Most of the reactions are great. I really like this channel. And if someone is making a genuinely well-informed critique, they will provide details of how improvements could be made and you'll find yourself thinking, "yes as cool as this performance was, I can see how those improvements would have made it even better." But there have been a couple of reactors here where it actually looks like their ego is getting in the way of being able to appreciate what they're seeing. One of the tell-tale signs is the snarky "small booty" comment. It's also like they have to find ways to put down the performances in order to cast themselves in a superior, judging position. But when there is no solid objective critique to be made, you get ambiguous put-down comments like "this just ain't her bag". Like literally millions of people, including haters, have watched the #2 video. But even the haters didn't think of using "not her bag" as an angle of attack (probably because it has no definable meaning that can even be argued about).
@@TEAM__POSEID0N perhaps you're also viewing this from a biased lens - a bunch of people in the comments liked this video and saw actual critiques and not snarky comments ... personally i didn't find her tone any worse or better than any reactor, so i think you're reading a bit much into a few general observations also i didn't mean a positive reaction to lisa would've been a fake one, i just meant that if she had a criticism to share, it would've been a shame if she wasn't comfortable to share it and gave a fake reaction instead
I've seen plenty of other dancers reactions to lisa (like some i just want to know from different style dancers point of view), and this chick is the most non-valid. Not because she is criticizing but because of her specific comments. I've seen others critic her with valid opinions (and yes, they're not necessarily praising her, or say this could be better) that actually make sense but when this woman critic her it seem really of base. It doesn't help she says almost nothing to actually back up her thoughts. The only thing i can think of she talks about in depth is lisa looking down but (even to an untrained eye) it clearly something lisa does intentionally to add to the sensuality. Also to say hip-hop dance isn't her bag is WILD lmfao. She been practicing and performing hip-hop dance syle since like 10 or 11. Last comment that i found really of base (even tho there's a few more) is the growth comment between lili film 4 and movie. Not saying someone cant get better in the amount of time but logically it wasn't really that far apart and considering how she started of (again hip-hop) dancing around 10 then became a k-pop trainee for 5yrs at 14 safe to say confidence, or hip-hop (which is what got her noticed in the first place) isn't really an issue with her. This woman's criticism just doesn't feel (or complements cuz some of them seem kinda back handed) genuine. I tried to be natural like with the other dance react videos but this woman just aint valid here
Jenna must have a good eye to notice what was “missing” in the earlier pieces but so much improved in the last piece. I have only read like 3 comments, and already someone was defending Lisa like everything Lisa does in every dance is intentional and perfect. But let’s be real, Lisa’s dance skills have continued to improve. She gets better all the time, and it takes away from the credit she deserves if you don’t recognize or acknowledge her progress. Jenna even mentioned how she herself struggled with something (arms?), so I assume that as a dancer Jenna can recognize and understand the struggle LOL. Anyway, I really enjoyed the reaction. I actually hadn’t seen these videos before, and I totally understood where Jenna was coming from. Lisa was da bomb in the movie. (On a related note, isn’t it crazy how amazing an idol looks until you see them dancing next to the choreographer? 🤣 It makes me want to defend the idol (cough cough Taemin), even though the choreographer obviously interprets the piece on a whole other level.)
The looking down may be a flirtatious move, seductive if you will, in keeping with the dance and music? Might be an idea to have this lady, and the other dancers, reactions to the BLACKPINK dance practices - or Lisa's solo M/Vs or practices?
I'm used to watching reactions from this channel and other ones that come from choreographers and dancers like Jenna and it's always fun to see the technical points of it in comparison to what I've learned over the years on a personal level but idk, some comments feel a bit back-handed and some others feel a bit rigid. Maybe it was from this channel or another but there was a contemporary dancer (I think) that was also very focused on the critical part and I really loved her reaction because you could see her objectivity was above her subjectivity. Even her way of explaining things and technicalities was so on point. Gotta appreciate that more. But those are just my two cents
Oooohhh. Nice reaction.. would want to watch you dancing tho, it's seems that you're very professional. Let me share this video to other Blinks and Lilies.🙂
I appreciate an honest opinion as much as anyone and in my eyes that’s what was given. Does this mean I agree with everything this young lady said? No. First, one of the first things noted by those that picked her out of 3,999 other audition hopefuls was her confidence. It stood out to them. Lisa is humble but she’ll be the first to tell you she’s the best dancer around so, imho, I don’t think her looking down from time to time is a confidence issue. I don’t agree with the “this isn’t her bag” quote either cuz the thing is, dancing…is her bag. Now is every form her strongest? Probably not but what I do know is that every type of dance she performs she puts 100%+ into it and she has more than proven herself capable of taking on any genre. Everyone is subject to criticism, especially celebrities and Lisa has certainly dealt with her fair share. She is a member of the biggest girl group in the world and is arguably one of the biggest Kpop artists on her own.She’s a brand ambassador for Celine and Bulgari. She’s known as a prolific dancer amongst her peers and she just won a VMA for best Kpop. I don’t think a little criticism is gonna tarnish her career or her continuing rise in popularity. Just sayin…
Not sure if Lisa picked the song Tomboy or if the Choreo and song were picked together. But when Destiny was on a lunch date with a friend, they got to talking about this clip, LiliFilm the Movie. and the story was told, the song was about 2 years old now and not getting views. Destiny was months from being broke, then Lisa used the song in her clip and kick started Destiny's career all over again. people started to stream the song and follow Destiny getting her recognition. ua-cam.com/video/XGjdQIaPA5s/v-deo.html This is a link to an interview of Destiny telling the story in her words
Cheshir Ha (Lisa's friend and choreographer) initially picked the song and asked Lisa if she liked the idea of dancing to it. Lisa loved the song and they proceeded to make "Lili's Film The Movie." Destiny has expressed gratitude multiple times. The views on Tomboy tripled in just a week or so after Lisa's dance video came out.
@@TEAM__POSEID0N Lisa has so much pull with her followers, she is like the Asian Oprah, lol You get a million views, and you get a million views. lol The minute Lisa drops a clip, oops, it has a million views.
Although I loveeee how Lisa dances and other people absolutely loving everything she puts out in so glad to come across some criticism ! Especially from someone who knows what’s up and I’m sure Lisa would too
@@melanimonje99 because the criticism makes no sense. And why does this girl "know's what's up"? Who is she? Some random nobody lol. There are many, many internationally renowned dancers that have a different opinion; I will go with them, thanks.
@@iamguava ….i still don’t get why your upset . Idk what to tell you dude I just write how I talk and it’s just a comment to a commentary video so please🥲I’m tired
@@melanimonje99 ok, have a good night. Oh, and I'm not upset, just as I am absolutely certain that Lisa won't ever see these ridiculous so called "experts"
She said “SOMETIMES when she’s looking down it seems like she isn’t as confident”. That’s a different comment and her own fair observation. Please pay attention closely lol
I'm subscribed here because I know i'll get THE BEST REACTION from pros. I don't want to hear another "waaah" "woo" "naaah". I want to know objective opinion. Lalisa is my artist and I support her but i'd like to know more about her skills. Loved this reaction. Love her. Lots of love. I hope to see more reaction videos from her and Ceecee.
@@dskrip24 I dunno maybe you're projecting lol. Everyone expresses themselves in their own way. There's no need for them to be backhanded, she's just reviewing her dance, she doesn't know anything about Lisa it's not that deep.
I really did not like her reaction at all compared to every other dancer that has reacted to Lisa. She has very strange opinions, but I guess that's what they are - just her opinions.
I think she was fair and pretty spot on, especially as her opinion evolved towards the end with The Movie; by then Lisa had realllllly developed as a dancer and performer
Jenna is an extensionist. Her dance training is very professional to the point that they can be proficient towards ANY song. What Jenna probably missed is that her choreo AND movement is proportional and according to the vibe of the song. No OVER EXTENSIONS, no over Emoting, no untimed random EXTENDED Eyecontact. She's articulating the feel of the song. When the hard beats comes she goes hard, when its soft, its soft. Dynamics was the word often used. You dont go aggressive on a non aggressive songs.
@@abramrexjoaquin7513 she said that Lisa eye contact should be improved when that is one thing that other professional dancers and choreographers praise Lisa for. She said she is not confident in hip hop when Lisa started dance lessons age 4 and won many awards, she was in a dance crew until being the only person picked by YG from 4,000 people in Thailand age 14 (they stated that it was Lisa's confidence that made her stand out). As I said, Jenna has her opinion, it just seems to differ from other professionals opinions. I like the channel and respect Jenna's opinion, just that I don't happen to agree with her.
@@abramrexjoaquin7513 Lisa’s greatest strength outside of her actual dance skills is her perfect control over her entire body. Plus you can’t say Lisa developed massively from Lilifilm 1 through the The Movie since it was only a little over a year time span for all five Lilifilm dances. She has mastered her craft at a young age, and she does still continue to train because she never wants to stop learning. But her facials, her eye contact, and her confidence are some of her strongest attributes that all of the other dancers and choreographers have praised her for. Jenna does have unusual ideas and opinions. They are her personal opinions but I happen to strongly disagree with her.
Reaction to aespa girl group please.aespa is the first metaverse kpop group.They have their own Universe just like marvel. To understand their lore watch aespa smcu episode 1 and 2.It’s so amazing and meaningful.Also reaction to their songs next level, black mamba, dreams come true, savage, illusion and their savage mini album. You will definitely like them and their all songs especially B-sides.
Dude you were way more out of the bag with your reasons about Hip hop not In Lisa's bag than the actual statement. Every girl can dance feminine but seeing a girl can dance in other genres which is less feminine and doing it very professionaly makes it much cooler. I feel like you don't like hip hop dance from your words rather than not liking Lisa dancing hip hop
She clearly said she liked her hip hop execution in the movie. Did you finish her reaction? Also she’s allowed to dislike Lisa dancing hip hop if that’s how she feels as a dancer loool
@@Koko3op Finished and she still felt the same about her hip hop. Yes you are allowed to dislike anything, but it doesn't feel honest if you dislike something from someone who has reputation on those elements. Lisa is famous for her facial expressions and contact with viewers. And also her hip hop dance. It felt weird when i heard her explaining lisa looked down at the beginning of the 2nd dance. The dance doesn't even start then, she was looking at the sky or building or something
![Reacting To LILI’s FILM [The Movie]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gSw8815KMlo/mqdefault.jpg)
LIKE & WATCH In full before commenting please!!
Hey love your vids, but I would love to see a reaction video from CEECEE about the seventeen world choreography. THANK YOU.😁😁
Intro song plz ❤️
When she's looking down, it is intentional, to look sultry. Lisa does everything to convey the vibe!
The reaction was great. Nothing wrong with any of the criticisms, good or bad. Lisa is an amazing dancer obviously but I think she'll appreciate any pointers from different perspectives. Lisa is always immaculate in my eyes but it's great to see other dancers reactions.
Thank you!
I don't think looking down every now and then indicates lack of confidence or anything at all. Even when Lisa momentarily looks away from the camera, she still has that presence that directs your attention towards her. She is very confident in her dancing abilities since she's been dancing since 4 years old. Lisa is also known for her facial expressions while dancing. So, every move she does, whether it's looking straight at you or away, trust her it's intentional.
I always thought looking away was intentional, like giving off cool/indifferent vibes, I've seen other dancers do that like bts jimin. Also michael jackson literally poses while staring sideways for the same effect.
totally agree
You promote Lisa better than YG! Thank you! :)
Hahaha thank you
above all Lisa's personality is humble, cheerful, funny and sincere. She is charming, Lisa is my vitamin,thank you for loving Lisa.🙏🏻🤍
I liked that reaction. I really enjoyed the technical advice and small things like the eyes. I’ve seen a lot of reactions but most seem to only say great things and while I love idolizing someone I love learning how to be better more? It was small things like that, things I didn’t even notice until mentioned but then realized it had in fact changed the feeling. It was refreshing to take a step back and watch Lisa grow into an amazing dancer through this comp rather then just screaming about how amazing she is from the start, and that; I believe at least, allows us appreciate how far she’s come.
Ahhh thank you for understanding the intention behind reactions like this. I appreciate people like you a LOT!!
I'm a Lilie (Lisa's fan) and this is so great. I love to watch honest reaction from non kpop fan. Thank you jena!
I’m the opposite I think Lisa does the more masculine/ hip hop dances best. I like her girly too, but tomboy Lisa is the best Lisa to me!
loved this reaction!! people say they want honesty but when they get it…
it’s totally fair to say that lisa has evolved and improved over the years and has a style that suits some songs better than others. doesn’t change the fact that’s she’s of the best dancers in the industry!
What is this girl talking about? Looking down doesn’t just mean being uncomfortable 😅 who taught her that? 😂
Exactly
this reaction is GREAT in my opinion it’s nice to see other dancers perspective lisa is an amazing and established dancer but doesn’t mean she can’t get criticism and the best part about this dancer is that she saw the progression of each lili film like even tho she didn’t love the hip hop side she still pointed out how they eventually got better with each new one. she’s amazing and lisa would definitely appreciate it that someone is saying she improved
I wanted to mention that in salsa dancing when dancing with a partner, the passive dancer role does look down at certain times, in certain moves. It makes the dancer look more feminine.
Her criticisms are very interesting and show that sometimes dance is a difference in opinions all together. Almost everyone I watch (myself as well) tend to think she does the hip hop/masculine type dance very well while she thinks (or thought before the movie) the opposite. And she perceives looking down as showing less confidence. While I do agree with that at times, in Lisa’s case she was definitely not coming off as unsure of herself. Her choice of when and where to make eye contact seems very intentional and an artistic choice. But I respect her opinion of course. Just fun to see different perspectives.
I also love how she pointed out how much Lisa has evolved. Lilifilm the movie is definitely the best for me as well. I
Yea I was confused abt the criticisms because those are usually her strong points esp from other dancers But interesting perspective indeed
Lisa is amazing..she is a pro...she is fast learner too ..easy choreo she can just learn by watching it once ....she has been tested at a show too..that's why they call dance machine... doesn't take more than 2 hours to learn the toughest of toughest choreography
when you look down it doesn't make you look unconfident, it's such an old-school dance thing like in europena dances they tell you not to look down but when you do its a certain feeling like sensual so i really hate that concept of you're not supposed to look down
Depends on perspective I guess. She explained why she sees it that way, which is fair.
I agree it is artistic choice by Lisa, she knows exactly what she is doing.
These kinds of artistic choices are always subjective. It can be a problem when someone trained a certain way becomes dogmatic about the "rules" and in a largely unconscious mental process called "confirmation bias" actually will have a negative response to something that other people (not trained in the same way) will see as being beautiful and aesthetically excellent. It's like the dogma ("rule") is so ingrained that seeing it "broken" automatically triggers a "this is not good" response...because for years they were indoctrinated to associate it with not being correct.
@@TEAM__POSEID0N yes I agree I’ve had this experience after taking dance classes in different studios. I just don’t like when people project that onto others as if it’s the standard. Dance should be liberating and an artistic experience.
Lisa is my fave artist and each lilidance was better and better, I get why you say the lilidance one was not as confident as she is right now but thats because it was her first video and probably was nervous and also she didn't know how her fans will react but look at her now!! everyone loves the last lilidilm because here it shows the best of her and also the choreographer put more effort in the choreography!! anyways I did like your point of view since everyone has different opinion but also like your appreciation as a dancer!! anyways I love Lisa and I love her dance videos!!
this is the equivalent of my helper critiqueing me (a Master Electrician) on how I wire a house.
I’m a dancer as well and Lisa definitely has the sauce. That cravin performance was fly af. The thing that probably seems “off” is that she’s really skinny which you or even myself at first probably wasn’t used to seeing with that type of movement. That’s why the tomboy choreo performance looked better with the baggy suit. The swag is definitely there though. Side note something I’ve noticed from videos is that Lisa performs these choreos better than Cheshir herself imo. Other note that floor move in tomboy where she’s doing those hops with her legs while simultaneously doing a broken down wave with her right arm is FLAMESS. One of the sickest moves out of all the choreos
thankS TO YOU I CAME HERE FOR YOUR COMMENT and ofc LIsa
MY QUEEN FOREVER LISA💖❤👸⭐💫👑
LISA IS AMAZING ARTIST♥💟♥💟♥💟
Loved this reaction! Seriously enjoyed every comment and criticism you had to offer! I know the chances are slim, but I hope Lisa comes across this video some day. She's always been extremely passionate about dancing, so I feel like she'd really appreciate what you had to say considering your own expertise in the field. :-)
You gotta comment like is bad could have been done better, there should be details to back it up why it was bad who it could have been better.
Lisa is the queen of dance
My queen LALISA 👑❤️❤️❤️
Lisa is the best Multitalent of the World 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍
that;s so interesting about the hip hop stuff but because for me, I think lisa executes it so well that when i see other female idols in kpop dance, i compare them all to her and how i find that they're not as sharp and controlled as lisa.
I guess it’s because she’s seeing it from an angle of seeing and between around hundreds of dancers every week as opposed to watching.
@@Koko3op but other professionals with more experience think differently, that's all we're saying.
@@iamguava lol how do you know how much experience Jenna has? I’m explaining her perspective, how other professionals feel is also valid but isn’t my concern, only hers.
@@Koko3op you can defend her, it's your video. I notice that you haven't addressed her body shaming comment that others have pointed out though.
@@Koko3op "seeing" versus "watching". I'm not sure what that means in this context. Does she train/teach dancers? If so, that would just mean that she sees hundreds of aspiring dancers and dance students, many likely being novices. Or is she dancing with hundreds of professional dancers every week? Either way, I don't think we can infer that such situation automatically elevates her into an unquestionable judgment-seat position above a person who has been dancing and winning awards for dancing since early childhood, as well as in recent years dancing for global audiences that number in the millions. Jenna has a point of view and an opinion. It's interesting. I just file it along with the various other points of views and opinions. I appreciate her taking the time to watch and offer her opinion. I will definitely be interested in seeing her dancing and I'm sure she's very good. I just can't really join in with some of those commenters who are trying to make her opinions out to be the pronouncement of an "expert" that can't be questioned or disagreed with by anyone who is not an "expert".
lol the comments saying they didn't like her reaction - lisa may be considered one of the best dancers in kpop but she's grown into that over the years, which is what jenna was pointing out, lisa wasn't as confident when she started and she worked on it... everyone has room to grow and perhaps the other dancers you watched reacting to lisa were focusing on different things to what jenna focuses on
criticizing lisa (and so politely lmao) is not a crime
The world of UA-cam 😍. I even contemporaries not uploading this cos I had to re-do the screen recording cos I knew they’ll be some nonsense lol. Thanks for getting it tho!
@@Koko3op thank you for uploading it anyway - i really love that everyone you bring on isn't willing to fake a reaction, and your hard work even when something goes wrong!!
i guess the intentional ignorance comes with the territory of being a super protective stan 👀
@@mrs_rover awww thanks. It means a lot being appreciated!
@@mrs_rover Well, just because someone loves what they see in Lisa's dancing doesn't mean that it's a "fake reaction" and being hyper-critical with comments like "this isn't her bag" and joking about her slender figure doesn't mean that the reaction is more genuine. People come into these things with different mindsets. Most of the reactions are great. I really like this channel. And if someone is making a genuinely well-informed critique, they will provide details of how improvements could be made and you'll find yourself thinking, "yes as cool as this performance was, I can see how those improvements would have made it even better." But there have been a couple of reactors here where it actually looks like their ego is getting in the way of being able to appreciate what they're seeing. One of the tell-tale signs is the snarky "small booty" comment. It's also like they have to find ways to put down the performances in order to cast themselves in a superior, judging position. But when there is no solid objective critique to be made, you get ambiguous put-down comments like "this just ain't her bag". Like literally millions of people, including haters, have watched the #2 video. But even the haters didn't think of using "not her bag" as an angle of attack (probably because it has no definable meaning that can even be argued about).
@@TEAM__POSEID0N perhaps you're also viewing this from a biased lens - a bunch of people in the comments liked this video and saw actual critiques and not snarky comments ... personally i didn't find her tone any worse or better than any reactor, so i think you're reading a bit much into a few general observations
also i didn't mean a positive reaction to lisa would've been a fake one, i just meant that if she had a criticism to share, it would've been a shame if she wasn't comfortable to share it and gave a fake reaction instead
wow thats some great points! i never noticed that before
Thank you for saying Lisa is great...
i like lisa's masculine side more 😁
It may not be Lisa's "bag" but Lisa's bag is way bigger LMAO
*Chidlish stan spotted in the comments*
Don't miss to react "TAKE ME, SWALLA, SENORETA - LISA" This is one of the best Lisa's dance solo stage that you really don't miss
She is so cute. Thank u
AMAZING LISA
I love Lisa dance she amazing
I've seen plenty of other dancers reactions to lisa (like some i just want to know from different style dancers point of view), and this chick is the most non-valid. Not because she is criticizing but because of her specific comments. I've seen others critic her with valid opinions (and yes, they're not necessarily praising her, or say this could be better) that actually make sense but when this woman critic her it seem really of base. It doesn't help she says almost nothing to actually back up her thoughts. The only thing i can think of she talks about in depth is lisa looking down but (even to an untrained eye) it clearly something lisa does intentionally to add to the sensuality. Also to say hip-hop dance isn't her bag is WILD lmfao. She been practicing and performing hip-hop dance syle since like 10 or 11. Last comment that i found really of base (even tho there's a few more) is the growth comment between lili film 4 and movie. Not saying someone cant get better in the amount of time but logically it wasn't really that far apart and considering how she started of (again hip-hop) dancing around 10 then became a k-pop trainee for 5yrs at 14 safe to say confidence, or hip-hop (which is what got her noticed in the first place) isn't really an issue with her. This woman's criticism just doesn't feel (or complements cuz some of them seem kinda back handed) genuine. I tried to be natural like with the other dance react videos but this woman just aint valid here
💯 fact!!!
Thank you for your reaction #lisa #Lalisa #blackpinklisa
I love and appreciate your criticism!
Jenna must have a good eye to notice what was “missing” in the earlier pieces but so much improved in the last piece. I have only read like 3 comments, and already someone was defending Lisa like everything Lisa does in every dance is intentional and perfect. But let’s be real, Lisa’s dance skills have continued to improve. She gets better all the time, and it takes away from the credit she deserves if you don’t recognize or acknowledge her progress. Jenna even mentioned how she herself struggled with something (arms?), so I assume that as a dancer Jenna can recognize and understand the struggle LOL. Anyway, I really enjoyed the reaction. I actually hadn’t seen these videos before, and I totally understood where Jenna was coming from. Lisa was da bomb in the movie. (On a related note, isn’t it crazy how amazing an idol looks until you see them dancing next to the choreographer? 🤣 It makes me want to defend the idol (cough cough Taemin), even though the choreographer obviously interprets the piece on a whole other level.)
The looking down may be a flirtatious move, seductive if you will, in keeping with the dance and music?
Might be an idea to have this lady, and the other dancers, reactions to the BLACKPINK dance practices - or Lisa's solo M/Vs or practices?
I'm used to watching reactions from this channel and other ones that come from choreographers and dancers like Jenna and it's always fun to see the technical points of it in comparison to what I've learned over the years on a personal level but idk, some comments feel a bit back-handed and some others feel a bit rigid. Maybe it was from this channel or another but there was a contemporary dancer (I think) that was also very focused on the critical part and I really loved her reaction because you could see her objectivity was above her subjectivity. Even her way of explaining things and technicalities was so on point. Gotta appreciate that more. But those are just my two cents
I love reaction LISA
Oooohhh. Nice reaction.. would want to watch you dancing tho, it's seems that you're very professional. Let me share this video to other Blinks and Lilies.🙂
I appreciate an honest opinion as much as anyone and in my eyes that’s what was given. Does this mean I agree with everything this young lady said? No. First, one of the first things noted by those that picked her out of 3,999 other audition hopefuls was her confidence. It stood out to them. Lisa is humble but she’ll be the first to tell you she’s the best dancer around so, imho, I don’t think her looking down from time to time is a confidence issue. I don’t agree with the “this isn’t her bag” quote either cuz the thing is, dancing…is her bag. Now is every form her strongest? Probably not but what I do know is that every type of dance she performs she puts 100%+ into it and she has more than proven herself capable of taking on any genre. Everyone is subject to criticism, especially celebrities and Lisa has certainly dealt with her fair share. She is a member of the biggest girl group in the world and is arguably one of the biggest Kpop artists on her own.She’s a brand ambassador for Celine and Bulgari. She’s known as a prolific dancer amongst her peers and she just won a VMA for best Kpop. I don’t think a little criticism is gonna tarnish her career or her continuing rise in popularity. Just sayin…
Thanks for reaction
This is a good review, very raw ...
I think they said that the floor when they shoot the 3rd video was very slippery.
Not sure if Lisa picked the song Tomboy or if the Choreo and song were picked together. But when Destiny was on a lunch date with a friend, they got to talking about this clip, LiliFilm the Movie. and the story was told, the song was about 2 years old now and not getting views. Destiny was months from being broke, then Lisa used the song in her clip and kick started Destiny's career all over again. people started to stream the song and follow Destiny getting her recognition. ua-cam.com/video/XGjdQIaPA5s/v-deo.html This is a link to an interview of Destiny telling the story in her words
Cheshir Ha (Lisa's friend and choreographer) initially picked the song and asked Lisa if she liked the idea of dancing to it. Lisa loved the song and they proceeded to make "Lili's Film The Movie." Destiny has expressed gratitude multiple times. The views on Tomboy tripled in just a week or so after Lisa's dance video came out.
@@TEAM__POSEID0N Lisa has so much pull with her followers, she is like the Asian Oprah, lol You get a million views, and you get a million views. lol The minute Lisa drops a clip, oops, it has a million views.
Although I loveeee how Lisa dances and other people absolutely loving everything she puts out in so glad to come across some criticism ! Especially from someone who knows what’s up and I’m sure Lisa would too
Knows what's up? Really? Just how do you come to that conclusion?
@@iamguava bruh what do you mean? Why does it matter
@@melanimonje99 because the criticism makes no sense. And why does this girl "know's what's up"? Who is she? Some random nobody lol. There are many, many internationally renowned dancers that have a different opinion; I will go with them, thanks.
@@iamguava ….i still don’t get why your upset . Idk what to tell you dude I just write how I talk and it’s just a comment to a commentary video so please🥲I’m tired
@@melanimonje99 ok, have a good night. Oh, and I'm not upset, just as I am absolutely certain that Lisa won't ever see these ridiculous so called "experts"
Lisa💜💛
Queen Lisa
Lisa ❣️
how about... lisa solo stage lemon dance cover and swalla 2.0 😉
react to lisa solo stage, i like it, faded and attention
you out here telling she couldve done this and that but at the end of the day shes an awsome dancer and youre the one watching her
And here you are watching my friend LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL why did you watch this ??
@@Koko3op you think i came to watch u? Bro i came to watch lisa not u
LISA didn't secured her spot at 13 against thousands of trainees for nothing
Lisa has lack of confidence when dancing? Really? 😂 I strongly disagree with her opinion.
She said “SOMETIMES when she’s looking down it seems like she isn’t as confident”. That’s a different comment and her own fair observation. Please pay attention closely lol
@@Koko3op Like I said, I disagree with her opinion and I think it’s disrespectful the “she ain’t got no bootty” part.
@@Koko3op you consistently refuse to address the body shaming, could that be because you think that your wonderful "expert" was wrong?
Everything's fine but saying she's not confident...nah
I don't like ur reaction..really can u even dance 1% of her...
เธอดุจเทพธิดาจากฟ้าลงมาบนโลกสวยงามสง่า ลิซ่า แบล็คพิ้งค๋
I want to see your dances tho! If you are good as Lisa.
But not every dancers are have the same opinions or liking the same things.
ขอบคุณนะคุะที่ดูสาวๆๆๆๆ Black Pink ของเรา หวังว่าคุณคงจะชอบทั้ง 4 สาวนะคะ Love Love Love Love
I’d love to see her reacting blackpink
ลิซ่าคือหัวใจของฉัน❤️
Im curious if she know the songs before or after lili film...
Lillies loves you
Finally a good critical reaction
❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉😊🥰
Completely agree. I love Lisa and don’t deny that she’s an amazing dancer but her “swaggy” hip hop is not the best.
I'm subscribed here because I know i'll get THE BEST REACTION from pros. I don't want to hear another "waaah" "woo" "naaah". I want to know objective opinion. Lalisa is my artist and I support her but i'd like to know more about her skills. Loved this reaction. Love her. Lots of love. I hope to see more reaction videos from her and Ceecee.
Where do I find Jenna?
♥️♥️❤️❤️💓💓💘💘💞💗♥️❤️💓♥️❤️❤️💓💘💞💞💞
😍🔥🔥
Nicee reaction.
Why do I feel like this dancer is insecure or something lol
She praised Lisa a lot so I dunno where you got that impression from.
@@Koko3op They seemed to be backhanded compliments though lol🙄
@@dskrip24 I dunno maybe you're projecting lol. Everyone expresses themselves in their own way. There's no need for them to be backhanded, she's just reviewing her dance, she doesn't know anything about Lisa it's not that deep.
Everything lalisa do is intentional....
Please reaction blackpink Lisa solo stage at youth with you season 2 and 3
Some no name commenting on Lisa what a joke
Doesn't matter if you can sing, your super hot! Wheres your dance video Jenna!?
Haha check her insta @jennaabrandon
right! like the entire time I was staring at her
I think she is choreographer but lisa ‘s dances feel like an idol not same dancer instructor. Btw I love lisa dances ,very satisfied to watching ☺️☺️
React to señorita please
I really did not like her reaction at all compared to every other dancer that has reacted to Lisa. She has very strange opinions, but I guess that's what they are - just her opinions.
I think she was fair and pretty spot on, especially as her opinion evolved towards the end with The Movie; by then Lisa had realllllly developed as a dancer and performer
Jenna is an extensionist.
Her dance training is very professional to the point that they can be proficient towards ANY song.
What Jenna probably missed is that her choreo AND movement is proportional and according to the vibe of the song.
No OVER EXTENSIONS, no over Emoting, no untimed random EXTENDED Eyecontact.
She's articulating the feel of the song.
When the hard beats comes she goes hard, when its soft, its soft.
Dynamics was the word often used.
You dont go aggressive on a non aggressive songs.
@@abramrexjoaquin7513 she said that Lisa eye contact should be improved when that is one thing that other professional dancers and choreographers praise Lisa for. She said she is not confident in hip hop when Lisa started dance lessons age 4 and won many awards, she was in a dance crew until being the only person picked by YG from 4,000 people in Thailand age 14 (they stated that it was Lisa's confidence that made her stand out). As I said, Jenna has her opinion, it just seems to differ from other professionals opinions. I like the channel and respect Jenna's opinion, just that I don't happen to agree with her.
@@abramrexjoaquin7513
Lisa’s greatest strength outside of her actual dance skills is her perfect control over her entire body. Plus you can’t say Lisa developed massively from Lilifilm 1 through the The Movie since it was only a little over a year time span for all five Lilifilm dances. She has mastered her craft at a young age, and she does still continue to train because she never wants to stop learning. But her facials, her eye contact, and her confidence are some of her strongest attributes that all of the other dancers and choreographers have praised her for. Jenna does have unusual ideas and opinions. They are her personal opinions but I happen to strongly disagree with her.
She’s a bodyshamer too, idk how people just ignored her commenr ‘She aint got no booty’ dafuq!
Smh🙄
Bitter.
Can't even pronounce her name after so many reaction. Guess you ain't interested.
Hahaha
You are watching Lalisa and saying silly things.....And who are you ? lol
A professional dancer outside these casual UA-cam appearances. Who are you?
@@Koko3op ohhh well I haven't seen ya anywhere lol
Reaction to aespa girl group please.aespa is the first metaverse kpop group.They have their own Universe just like marvel. To understand their lore watch aespa smcu episode 1 and 2.It’s so amazing and meaningful.Also reaction to their songs next level, black mamba, dreams come true, savage, illusion and their savage mini album. You will definitely like them and their all songs especially B-sides.
We did film savage and black mamba!
@@Koko3op Then reaction to next level,dreams come true,illusion and lucid dream songs. You definitely like this songs.
@@Koko3op Also they have a short movie ep 1 and ep 2.It's their metaverse concept storyline.It’s so amazing.
Dude you were way more out of the bag with your reasons about Hip hop not In Lisa's bag than the actual statement. Every girl can dance feminine but seeing a girl can dance in other genres which is less feminine and doing it very professionaly makes it much cooler. I feel like you don't like hip hop dance from your words rather than not liking Lisa dancing hip hop
She clearly said she liked her hip hop execution in the movie. Did you finish her reaction? Also she’s allowed to dislike Lisa dancing hip hop if that’s how she feels as a dancer loool
@@Koko3op Finished and she still felt the same about her hip hop.
Yes you are allowed to dislike anything, but it doesn't feel honest if you dislike something from someone who has reputation on those elements. Lisa is famous for her facial expressions and contact with viewers. And also her hip hop dance. It felt weird when i heard her explaining lisa looked down at the beginning of the 2nd dance. The dance doesn't even start then, she was looking at the sky or building or something