And this does make a pretty cool domino effect, he wouldn't bribe people to rejoining, that means he's not blah blah vigintillion dollars in debt, which means Team Ice Cube picks him in BFB, and in TPOT 2 Pen doesn't know how to block the blocks from being attacked, so they might just get sucked up by BH, that could go anywhere tbh
I have an idea on how the ending plays out. So to recap: The ones Pencil banned are: Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy, David, Flower and Leafy Pencil would then rant to Leafy about how Leafy literally threw away the Alliance's trust in the final contest. What do I mean by that? Well, Since Leafy suddenly became mean to Bubble and Pencil stood up for Bubble, Leafy basically showed her true colors. I can imagine how distraught Pencil was, seeing Leafy suddenly blow her argument with Bubble out of proportion. Here's how the dialogue goes. Pencil: "Okay. First off, Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy, David, Flower and ESPECIALLY Leafy are banned from Dream Island; so Firey, Ice Cube, Woody, Needle, Teardrop, Pen, Eraser, Tennis Ball, Coiny, Match and Bubble can all pass." Leafy: "What?! But Bubble is a mean person!" Pencil: "No she is not. Remember the fallout? Well I do, and seeing one of my friends gets taken advantage of really hurts me. All of you weren't even thankful when Bubble tried to help you win, and YOU Pin, are no better, and so are you, Golf Ball, I saw your bossiness towards your own team!" Leafy would then devise a plan to get revenge on the Alliance. So Leafy convinces Pin and Golf Ball and Snowball and Rocky and Blocky and Spongy and David and Flower to steal Dream Island. Later on, Pencil was confused to why Dream Island is gone, and when she found out... Pencil: "Leafy?! It was you?!" Leafy: "Yes I did! I was meant to win! Had I won, I would let us ALL on Dream Island!" Bubble: "Noit with that attitude! Y'all could have woited for the noixt season!" Match: "Wait, HOLD ON A SECOND! Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy, David and Flower?! Don't tell me you all are in on this too!" Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy and David start to stutter, trying to make an excuse, but before they could save face... Flower: "Yeah they did!" Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy and David gasped in horror. Pencil: "You.... WHAT?!" Pin: "So what if we DID?! Yeah, we all deserve to be part of Dream Island, and about me popping Bubble, well sometimes she just has to deal with it!" Then Rocky starts speaking... Rocky: "Enough! Pencil's right! We're all wrong! We should have just waited for the next season! And for the record, I did NOT agree to this! Pencil, please, hear me out, they threatened to kill ME if I refused!" Firey: "Leafy... how could you..." Ice Cube: "Leafy I TRUSTED you! And then there's this!" Golf Ball: "Forget next season, if we can't have Dream Island, NO ONE CAN! Besides, Islands that were sold would be destroyed in 2 hours anyway." A major fight ensues with all recovery centers destroyed as usual, and Flower and Leafy did the unthinkable: an assassination attempt on Match! Bubble and Pencil: "MATCH! NO!" Pencil and Bubble rush in to save Match, but then all of a sudden, an enraged Bubble puts Leafy and Flower up for execution HER WAY, and all three of them died. Meanwhile, Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Blocky, Spongy and David run away while Pencil and the others are busy mourning the death of Bubble. Pen and Eraser would cut ties with Blocky. Also, I can see a SIGNIFICANT parallel to Pencil and Firey's reasoning to why Leafy shouldn't be allowed on Dream Island. Firey banned Leafy simply because Leafy rejected the Ferris Wheel, which paints both Firey AND Leafy in the wrong. But Pencil banning Leafy because of the fallout with Bubble, boy will that change the course of the story. Yup, this is just my opinion, maybe I'll elaborate on my next reply for BFDIA (Even though it's different from yours obviously.)
Honestly in this scenario, I could totally see pin stealing the island instead, which would be really interesting to see as a continuation to this, and perhaps she'd even work with some of the other rejected contestants, most likely golf ball, and possibly snowball interestingly enough
I could actually see Bubble or Ice cube trying to steal the island if Pencil does not let one or the other one which I can see happening as she does abuse both of them despite being in the alliance, idk just what I think
Idea: what if bfdi didnt have bias? This might be a bad suggestion but you know how things like jacknjellify doing all these biased things to get specific characters out (most notable ice cube, tennis ball, and pencil) well what if the show came out like you do it, with jacknjellify not being a factor and its just the contestants? This either will be interesting or not interesting Edit: like at 13:34, the creators would never do that in canon because they wanted tennis ball out and kept putting him up for elimination at merge
Honestly, for BFDI 22, I feel like Tennis Ball, considering that he's kinda good at gadgets, could've been the one to build a speaker box instead of Firey. Just a feeling however
As you remember the BFDI point phase removed the triple digits due to budget cuts so that what if senario where the points phase didn’t remove the triple digits will have to dismiss the budget cuts
Idea:what if tennis ball won What happens: Tennis ball wins the fake round and he votes for golf ball to join his and you pick the others in round 1 his team loses the Rocky will be the first one out the next round his team loses the grapes are up for elimination the one out is gonna be pen and pin the cherrys pick to save pin on after that his team loses the one out is pin and coiny they chose to save pin so Firey is free from him but before pin was picked she used her win token then pencil was up for elimination but then they picked to save coiny so pencil was out the next round tbs team loses again the out was tb and spongey Spongey was out cause no one likes him then the grapes lose again the one out is golf ball and match they agreed to save golfball the cherrys was finally up for elimination and the rest you can do (don’t mind my user)
My top 8 for this in my version 8th david 7th firey 6th flower 5th leafy 4th tb 3rd pencil due to pen probably becoming more popular with development 2nd pen 1st bubble Doesnt let in blocky pin gb flower david profily yf Bomby Pin steals dream island with top 24 joining Leafy is in instead of pin with pen getting 14th most votes overall 4 people not there stays same So top 21 with pin gone leafy pen tv in
Firey's elimination would probably be like: Snowball: i vote firey because it get's pretty cold in the tlc and i need to warm it up Match: omg like, yeah. And then all the recommended characters come in and firey is eliminated
Isn’t he terrible at challenges? He only survived because there were other people that were more disliked than him, plus, it’s proven that he never was really good at challenges and nobody saw him as this much of a threat, considering that he only got at the top because of the lack of votes and for getting first in BFDI 12, but it is shown that he did horrible in BFDI 13 and 14.
1:37 this is just plain wrong. Rocky would've easily been the first one safe, or the 2nd safe at worst. Back around when the original BFDI was still ongoing, most People liked Rocky, and he had a bit of a Cult following, since at the time he was seen more as a comedic Relief Character than a Character with no Character, not to mention that Characters like Rocky were generally well-received at the time, and the Fact that People mostly didn't care if a Character had any interesting Arcs going on, since there weren't really any to begin with besides like Bubble and Leafy's Frienemy Arc. So because of that I'd say Rocky's larger Fanbase would overwhelm Bubble/Icy's smaller ones, causing one of them to be eliminated instead.
Nah. Rocky had always been seen as quite polarizing. If you compare the times when either character was up with Rocky, they were always safe before Rocky, there’s no way Rocky would be safe before them.
What if the murder trout won the crying contest in total firey island instead of the yelling beavers Note that total firey island is the series of books They happened right before BFDI Here’s a video showcasing the total firey island story ua-cam.com/video/bOuKRMhLkHg/v-deo.htmlsi=ybZbFPhSQ_pWL3ca
I have a feeling that if this timeline was real, then Pen could make it into BFDIA!
Definitely possible, he’d be more popular if he made it further
And this does make a pretty cool domino effect, he wouldn't bribe people to rejoining, that means he's not blah blah vigintillion dollars in debt, which means Team Ice Cube picks him in BFB, and in TPOT 2 Pen doesn't know how to block the blocks from being attacked, so they might just get sucked up by BH, that could go anywhere tbh
Wow@@Squirtle_Squad_Supremacy
Pen would get in over Yellow Face, which likely wouldn't change much
@@slyarWouldn’t Pen get in over Puffball instead of Yellow Face, since Yellow Face got more votes than Puffball
Pencil: wins TFI
Also Pencil in an alternate universe: Wins BFDI
the lore of how the first winner is eliminated first and last comes first is not real
I have an idea on how the ending plays out. So to recap: The ones Pencil banned are:
Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy, David, Flower and Leafy
Pencil would then rant to Leafy about how Leafy literally threw away the Alliance's trust in the final contest. What do I mean by that? Well, Since Leafy suddenly became mean to Bubble and Pencil stood up for Bubble, Leafy basically showed her true colors. I can imagine how distraught Pencil was, seeing Leafy suddenly blow her argument with Bubble out of proportion.
Here's how the dialogue goes.
Pencil: "Okay. First off, Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy, David, Flower and ESPECIALLY Leafy are banned from Dream Island; so Firey, Ice Cube, Woody, Needle, Teardrop, Pen, Eraser, Tennis Ball, Coiny, Match and Bubble can all pass."
Leafy: "What?! But Bubble is a mean person!"
Pencil: "No she is not. Remember the fallout? Well I do, and seeing one of my friends gets taken advantage of really hurts me. All of you weren't even thankful when Bubble tried to help you win, and YOU Pin, are no better, and so are you, Golf Ball, I saw your bossiness towards your own team!"
Leafy would then devise a plan to get revenge on the Alliance. So Leafy convinces Pin and Golf Ball and Snowball and Rocky and Blocky and Spongy and David and Flower to steal Dream Island. Later on, Pencil was confused to why Dream Island is gone, and when she found out...
Pencil: "Leafy?! It was you?!"
Leafy: "Yes I did! I was meant to win! Had I won, I would let us ALL on Dream Island!"
Bubble: "Noit with that attitude! Y'all could have woited for the noixt season!"
Match: "Wait, HOLD ON A SECOND! Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy, David and Flower?! Don't tell me you all are in on this too!"
Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy and David start to stutter, trying to make an excuse, but before they could save face...
Flower: "Yeah they did!"
Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Rocky, Blocky, Spongy and David gasped in horror.
Pencil: "You.... WHAT?!"
Pin: "So what if we DID?! Yeah, we all deserve to be part of Dream Island, and about me popping Bubble, well sometimes she just has to deal with it!"
Then Rocky starts speaking...
Rocky: "Enough! Pencil's right! We're all wrong! We should have just waited for the next season! And for the record, I did NOT agree to this! Pencil, please, hear me out, they threatened to kill ME if I refused!"
Firey: "Leafy... how could you..."
Ice Cube: "Leafy I TRUSTED you! And then there's this!"
Golf Ball: "Forget next season, if we can't have Dream Island, NO ONE CAN! Besides, Islands that were sold would be destroyed in 2 hours anyway."
A major fight ensues with all recovery centers destroyed as usual, and Flower and Leafy did the unthinkable: an assassination attempt on Match!
Bubble and Pencil: "MATCH! NO!"
Pencil and Bubble rush in to save Match, but then all of a sudden, an enraged Bubble puts Leafy and Flower up for execution HER WAY, and all three of them died. Meanwhile, Pin, Golf Ball, Snowball, Blocky, Spongy and David run away while Pencil and the others are busy mourning the death of Bubble. Pen and Eraser would cut ties with Blocky.
Also, I can see a SIGNIFICANT parallel to Pencil and Firey's reasoning to why Leafy shouldn't be allowed on Dream Island. Firey banned Leafy simply because Leafy rejected the Ferris Wheel, which paints both Firey AND Leafy in the wrong. But Pencil banning Leafy because of the fallout with Bubble, boy will that change the course of the story.
Yup, this is just my opinion, maybe I'll elaborate on my next reply for BFDIA (Even though it's different from yours obviously.)
I love this idea.
So this makes Pencil way better than Firey.
8:25 if pen got 1 more point
UH OH
Fr
Idea: What if the COINY and Firey slap arc never existed?
then Coiny would win
@@diaryofanasdkid9752 nah
@@diaryofanasdkid9752Or at least make it further
6:57 i imagine most of her shards would get to the other side of the ravine though. tennis ball would still get out
Would that even count as getting to the other side?
alternative title: bfdi in the right dimension
Yes ❤
Honestly in this scenario, I could totally see pin stealing the island instead, which would be really interesting to see as a continuation to this, and perhaps she'd even work with some of the other rejected contestants, most likely golf ball, and possibly snowball interestingly enough
True
I could actually see Bubble or Ice cube trying to steal the island if Pencil does not let one or the other one which I can see happening as she does abuse both of them despite being in the alliance, idk just what I think
No bubble will not do that even if she’s in the alliance, she will get a lot of hate from that. She’s too nice to do that.
I wish that happened in real Bfdi 15 because pen is my favourite character
That whole Pencil-Leafy thing was so creative! Keep up the good work!
Imagine if pencil won dream Island
8:11 wOw, FiReAfY mOmEnT, tHeY aRe HoLdInG hAnDs
BEST TIMELINE EVER
Nahhhh they about to make total pencil island and make firey the winner now
Bfdi good ending Rocky is eliminated earlier
Real and pen wins
These are super entertaining to watch! New sub!
Video: Hasn't even premiered yet
UA-cam: This uses "Cipher"
Idea: what if rocky stayed over flower in bfdi
Alternative title: how can Pencil win bfdi? Also match wouldn’t vote bubble to win, unless she gets slapped
2:57 Did no one notice this error??? Firey can subtract 300 points not 100
You should do a what if on if Yellow Face’s votes weren’t counted for BFDIA. Pen would be there instead.
He doesnt like to do BFDIA what ifs
Idea: what if bfdi didnt have bias? This might be a bad suggestion but you know how things like jacknjellify doing all these biased things to get specific characters out (most notable ice cube, tennis ball, and pencil) well what if the show came out like you do it, with jacknjellify not being a factor and its just the contestants? This either will be interesting or not interesting
Edit: like at 13:34, the creators would never do that in canon because they wanted tennis ball out and kept putting him up for elimination at merge
Why do I feel like they’d do something like “ice cube wins” with her dead body on the other side lol, but it does make sense to keep tb in
That amazing 😲! ❤ she (pencil) is the winner in this video ❤😊 and good new is pen and pencil makes it so far ❤😊😊😊
Idea: If Strongest Team OnEarth losed first in TPOT
What does losed mean?
@@JustANormalChochko they are ufe
VIDEO SUGGESTION:
What if the entire first season was with points only
That's actually a really interesting one
I'll write that down
Finally Pencil gets to win BFDI!
Also I find it funny how Firey got a lower placement than Flower of all people lol
Great what if. Much better final 3 than the one that we got in cannon imo.
Honestly, for BFDI 22, I feel like Tennis Ball, considering that he's kinda good at gadgets, could've been the one to build a speaker box instead of Firey. Just a feeling however
As you remember the BFDI point phase removed the triple digits due to budget cuts so that what if senario where the points phase didn’t remove the triple digits will have to dismiss the budget cuts
i just realized the finale is the same as the alliance from needle winning bfdi
Idea:what if tennis ball won
What happens:
Tennis ball wins the fake round and he votes for golf ball to join his and you pick the others in round 1 his team loses the Rocky will be the first one out the next round his team loses the grapes are up for elimination the one out is gonna be pen and pin the cherrys pick to save pin on after that his team loses the one out is pin and coiny they chose to save pin so Firey is free from him but before pin was picked she used her win token then pencil was up for elimination but then they picked to save coiny so pencil was out the next round tbs team loses again the out was tb and spongey
Spongey was out cause no one likes him then the grapes lose again the one out is golf ball and match they agreed to save golfball the cherrys was finally up for elimination and the rest you can do (don’t mind my user)
If pencil did win Bfdi pencil will never been 1st boot in bfb
Currently working on how this would work out in BFB, its quite interesting.
Cool that one thing happening to a character can change the entire order
Idea: what if firey was in the danger zone instead of pen in bfdi 15
That’s a VERY specific what if. But Firey would still survive over rocky
Oh wait I just realize this video is literally it
My top 8 for this in my version
8th david
7th firey
6th flower
5th leafy
4th tb
3rd pencil due to pen probably becoming more popular with development
2nd pen
1st bubble
Doesnt let in blocky pin gb flower david profily yf Bomby
Pin steals dream island with top 24 joining
Leafy is in instead of pin with pen getting 14th most votes overall
4 people not there stays same
So top 21 with pin gone leafy pen tv in
Another idea: what if everyone had their modern personality
Firey's elimination would probably be like:
Snowball: i vote firey because it get's pretty cold in the tlc and i need to warm it up
Match: omg like, yeah.
And then all the recommended characters come in and firey is eliminated
You should do one where rocky was eliminated instead of gb in bfdi 11
Idea: what if the *BLEH* arc didn't ever happen?
It might have some changes to the audience-
Arc?
@@Payt0nR its littrally the whole point of $%^& existing
1:06 Pen gets launched from 9th to 3rd
1:54 pErFeCt SyNc
What if BFDI’s point phase didn’t remove triple digits?
11:44 needle would vote leafy due to her calling needle needy way more times
What if Golf ball didn’t thrown Rocky during the relay race of BFDI season 1
you deserve to be on the hot 100
idea: what if Golf Ball was stuck in a jawbreaker in BFB 2 instead of Taco
During BFDI 21 in this au, I can imagine Golf Ball voting for Pen due to him being sexist against her in BFDI 11.
Can't wait for the winner of this supposed season to not let Leafy on for various reasons causing her to buy dream island from the announcer!
Not a What-If without Firey getting screwed over by the contestant vote
y'know... i actually perfer that final 4 than the real one
13:51 I bet that the voting gap would be so huge that even if Flower had a Win Token, it probably wouldn't save her from elimination
It would be cool if BFDIA in this would be the people not allowed in dream island plus a couple of the BFDI 18 debuters.
I always wonder how do you make your videos?
I use PowerPoint to make the actual visuals
Then I use Filmora to edit
@@NeverButterthanks for telling me!
Here’s the best idea ever: BFDI but voting is on the spanish channel
Idea:what if needle rejoin instead of blocky in BFDI 9
I think a video about if every contestant won dream island then who would they let in and not let it would be cool
Also I noticed something, Pen gets the Maximum amount of Teddy Bears!!
Heres an idea: What of armless people could participate in the bowling ball challenge
Wow tennis ball clumsyness come in handy
What if the recommended character debuting period of bfdi happened during the teams phase?
What if pen didn’t cheat?🚫 what is pen had plot armor✅
I feel like Pencil wouldn't let Match in for some reason and she'd nuke dream island, so BFDIA would still exist
I want bubble to win
Idea: what if blocky didnt steal the test answers in bfdi 3
No His Name Is Ben
actually, its 🅱️en.
I thought that in the eliminated contestant vote rocky would vote leafy for the same reason as spongey
I have an idea for a what if: what if the squashy grapes won the 1st contest?
She probably would only not let David and Spongy
I don't think that Pen actually cheated, as Leafy wanted to offer to help him in the challenge in Vomitaco.
its a shame that pen, TB, and pencil all get really far in these scenarios because they were robbed
Leafy would TOTTALY steal dream island she really never made any connections with pencil mostly
This video was made for me (Pen is my fav)
He would’ve gotten eliminated regardless because he was at the top of the scoreboard for a long time so he would be seen as a threat
Isn’t he terrible at challenges? He only survived because there were other people that were more disliked than him, plus, it’s proven that he never was really good at challenges and nobody saw him as this much of a threat, considering that he only got at the top because of the lack of votes and for getting first in BFDI 12, but it is shown that he did horrible in BFDI 13 and 14.
It is a must that rocky must be out immediately and tennis ball must make it past points in these (seriously why does he keep on getting so far)
Idea: what if stapy didin't make beep lose in bfb 5
1:37 this is just plain wrong. Rocky would've easily been the first one safe, or the 2nd safe at worst. Back around when the original BFDI was still ongoing, most People liked Rocky, and he had a bit of a Cult following, since at the time he was seen more as a comedic Relief Character than a Character with no Character, not to mention that Characters like Rocky were generally well-received at the time, and the Fact that People mostly didn't care if a Character had any interesting Arcs going on, since there weren't really any to begin with besides like Bubble and Leafy's Frienemy Arc. So because of that I'd say Rocky's larger Fanbase would overwhelm Bubble/Icy's smaller ones, causing one of them to be eliminated instead.
Nah. Rocky had always been seen as quite polarizing. If you compare the times when either character was up with Rocky, they were always safe before Rocky, there’s no way Rocky would be safe before them.
I agree with you on this one, compared to Rocky, ice cube barely did anything this season
bottom 2 bfdi 14 btw
What if rocky didn’t forget how to talk in bfdi 4
« Even Leafy agree «
What if the teams never broke up in bfdi
8:14 pen is soon going down
hold up why would firey want pencil to win bfdi, just asking
What if in episode 18 tennis ball won the tiebreaker with leafy?
Idea:What if flower wins in bfdi
What if Spongy lost the bread loaf contest
He'd probably be gone
Erm, actually, Pencil started with 81 points. 🤓☝️
I know one what if David didn’t die by firey in bfdi 19
Spoilers:
In this scenario, that would mean Pencil wins two seasons in a row (She won TFI)
TFI was more of an alternative series
@@CarneiroDaNeve Or more alternatively of a pilot episode turned into a series
@@jayswithjam8754 Yeah because TFI had sequels
Does anyone know the music’s name in 5:06?
Yoylecake - Places
It’s called “Places” from the Yoyle Cake album, you’re welcome.
W WINNER
I ❤ Pencil
Bro pencil won season 0💀
Yum
My dreams:
Firey would rejoinn
Oh wait nvm
What if the murder trout won the crying contest in total firey island instead of the yelling beavers
Note that total firey island is the series of books
They happened right before BFDI
Here’s a video showcasing the total firey island story ua-cam.com/video/bOuKRMhLkHg/v-deo.htmlsi=ybZbFPhSQ_pWL3ca
How aboit a scenario where bubble wins? )i need this so bad pls bubble always gets 2nd in these)
I think u made a mistake here 2:57?
Yeah I missed that, can't believe I did