both version are great, everyone is entitled to like what they like.. I just think it's dumb how anyone can say either version sucks, because S.H.E are obviously good singers, as is Jade..
GEO, as a part of sweetbox (wich was formed by Jade Valerie Villalon and GEO) has given some songs composed by himself to them, but this song is NOT a cover, since GEO composed it and Jade wrote the lyrics, and as they were the band, is their song. But also, I couldn't say I consider SHE's version a cover, as it was released first and although the songs share the same instrumental, the lyrics have been written by different people P.S: Hope you understand me, my english isn't very good...
Fortunately music is international and open to interpretations. No doubt both versions have their qualities - no reason to debate about the best one. Personally, I like this one better - but its just my opinion.
Just to get the record straight. S.H.E. sang it first and it was Jade who sang a cover for it - google it if you don't believe me. Jay Chou composed the song for Ella.
i know you dreams i know you cries each breath i memorized and i would do anything to help you win your fight but it's not enough to make you smile it's never enough woo more can i give more than love more than this more than what's in these two hands more than love more than me but i can't give more than i am more than i am i've seen the searching in your eyes and i feel helpless by your side so many spaces i can't fill oh God knows how hard i tried it saying no more, and i dying inside you always be more no matter what i do it's never good enough for you i'm trying to be everything that you need and not every breathing and you are still not happy after all these have gone oh i gonna be cold it's never good enough for you for what's fall in love ah more than love tell me what's more than love tell me what’s more than this well it's actually that i can never give and what's more than love that i can never give
i know this one is original ~ but SHE got three Different voice ~ they more powerful ~ and they make this song got a sadly story~ the boy wait the girl 40 years ~ so SHE is BETTER~
MV wise i think S.H.E want give me more images. Anyway this is a great song. Somehow i think the last chorus shld repeat like what's on S.H.E version. It shoudl come back to hook back the audience the chorus.
I didn't say sweetbox's version was bad,just that she re-sang it as More Than Love please tell me where did you get your source from, I am so eager to see it
The Chinese version is the original one, by S.H.E. And, I must say that the Chinese version is MUCH better... same goes for Superstar by S.H.E. that Sweetbox also sang in english...
obvious you did... but i don't want to take this as a kids game, okay? what bout you, if you can tell me which source you get it that Sweetbox covered this from SHE? I would like to end this here too...
actually im waiting for someone other than she or sweetbox to do this song. i love the melody, but both bands seem too forced in their performances of this song. when i first heard the song, it was she's version (i was in china) but i immediately recognised the melody. i later heared sweetbox, but i wonder still where the original melody came from. anyone know???
i have no idea how you find this as a kid's game, this is just merely a discussion...go wiki and find it out yourself,then hopefully i don't need to correct you anymore
lcutie36: S.H.E copied the song from Sweetbox. That's from what I know, and I believe they had to have permission to do so. But I like S.H.E.'s version better.
sorry but wo ai ni and superstar both sound a lot better than sweetbox's chyna girl and more than love. they just sound more like asian songs and wo ai ni is esp sung with more feeling and emotion as the song seems to be written for. i don't know why they have to do covers of each other even if they are under the same producer. original versions usually do sound better so they should just keep it that way. and isn't it more refreshing if they were always originals?
sorry I disagree with your opinion that Jade sang this song after S.H.E did. Its the other way around!! Wo ai ni of SHE is really a cover of More Than Love of Sweetbox.. I dont argue whos better becuz it depends on each person's preference, but that doesnt mean the truth should be twisted like that.
excuse me, but S.H.E does not suck!! they do not lack originality and their version of all the songs sound better! fyi, S.H.E first sang wo ai ni and superstar before sweet box sang it as more than love and chyna girl. so the songs were originally written for S.H.E get your info straight if you're going to diss somebody
@MissR00s They are 3 girls from China (Taiwan). They copied the song in Chinese. Personally, I think their version (just the song, not MV) is not good. They lack the power. I heard their version first, but when it is when I heard this version, I realized it is a greate song.
You said this version is better than S.H.E !! oh!! I think diffirent from you!! sweetbox has a bad voice, I know S.H.E is copy this song, but S.H.E have a good voice, and all of version from sweetbox, S.H.E is the best, I don't know where's sweetbox come from!! but I very like S.H.E and don't want to hear someone said S.H.E is not good than other !!! ok, the end, I still say as LoveDonghaeLeeteuk that "YOU'RE WRONG !!!!"
wiki is not reliable, i think it is the basic thing everyone knows... anyway its fine, i dont even bother to "discuss" with you anymore. Its pointless.
Why are you always picking up the band S.H.E.? It's not cool, and I don't know how you pull out all these COPIED songs. I never heard about S.H.E and I'm looking forward to listen they're song, but stop to saying these things because you're wasting time.
both version are great, everyone is entitled to like what they like.. I just think it's dumb how anyone can say either version sucks, because S.H.E are obviously good singers, as is Jade..
i do really love this song,feeling like she is a deep love inside,ya!
I love the song too
GEO, as a part of sweetbox (wich was formed by Jade Valerie Villalon and GEO) has given some songs composed by himself to them, but this song is NOT a cover, since GEO composed it and Jade wrote the lyrics, and as they were the band, is their song. But also, I couldn't say I consider SHE's version a cover, as it was released first and although the songs share the same instrumental, the lyrics have been written by different people
P.S: Hope you understand me, my english isn't very good...
i love it!
nice song makes me cry
Fortunately music is international and open to interpretations. No doubt both versions have their qualities - no reason to debate about the best one.
Personally, I like this one better - but its just my opinion.
Just to get the record straight. S.H.E. sang it first and it was Jade who sang a cover for it - google it if you don't believe me. Jay Chou composed the song for Ella.
guys stop fighting s.h.e rules PERIOD.
jade's not bad for creating such good songs :D
i think S.H.E's version has this love story feel to it. i like S.H.E's version better. but the melody in general is so beautiful.
THANKS!!!!
S.H.E !!!! From Taiwan
i know you dreams
i know you cries
each breath i memorized
and i would do anything to help you win your fight
but it's not enough to make you smile
it's never enough
woo more can i give
more than love
more than this
more than what's in these two hands
more than love
more than me
but i can't give more than i am
more than i am
i've seen the searching in your eyes
and i feel helpless by your side
so many spaces i can't fill
oh God knows how hard i tried
it saying no more, and i dying inside
you always be more
no matter what i do it's never good enough for you
i'm trying to be everything that you need
and not every breathing
and you are still not happy
after all these have gone
oh i gonna be cold
it's never good enough for you
for what's fall in love
ah
more than love
tell me what's more than love
tell me what’s more than this
well it's actually that i can never give
and what's more than love
that i can never give
SHE - 我愛你
S.H.E and Sweetbox rules stop to figth bitches they are really cool and enjoy of the music
i know this one is original ~
but SHE got three Different voice ~ they more powerful ~
and they make this song got a sadly story~
the boy wait the girl 40 years ~
so SHE is BETTER~
Jade❤
does it matter who sang it first?
well i dont care wat u say, kaytee05........i like sweetbox and her songs and she sings the way she feels....*-*
MV wise i think S.H.E want give me more images. Anyway this is a great song. Somehow i think the last chorus shld repeat like what's on S.H.E version. It shoudl come back to hook back the audience the chorus.
I didn't say sweetbox's version was bad,just that she re-sang it as More Than Love
please tell me where did you get your source from, I am so eager to see it
雖然S. H. E早期很多歌曲翻唱sweet box的歌 但我沒記錯這一首和super star都是特別先製作給S. H. E 糖果盒子才拿回去重唱的吧?
這一首不是翻唱
S.H.E 我愛你
2016 ..
i'm like lost,
so who had the song 1st? s.h.e or sweetbox? who copied who?
thanks
The Chinese version is the original one, by S.H.E.
And, I must say that the Chinese version is MUCH better... same goes for Superstar by S.H.E. that Sweetbox also sang in english...
#1 song aside from Human Sacrfice!
@hsbd007 S.H.E's version is the original
obvious you did... but i don't want to take this as a kids game, okay? what bout you, if you can tell me which source you get it that Sweetbox covered this from SHE? I would like to end this here too...
actually im waiting for someone other than she or sweetbox to do this song. i love the melody, but both bands seem too forced in their performances of this song. when i first heard the song, it was she's version (i was in china) but i immediately recognised the melody. i later heared sweetbox, but i wonder still where the original melody came from. anyone know???
i must say, their version of i love you is so much better than their version of superstar..
Did I reply you ? Kiddo
S.H.E 's version is the best!!!!!!!
i have no idea how you find this as a kid's game, this is just merely a discussion...go wiki and find it out yourself,then hopefully i don't need to correct you anymore
yeah S.H.E is the best!
facts lmao, its all media presented, no one knows the truth ;]
lcutie36:
S.H.E copied the song from Sweetbox. That's from what I know, and I believe they had to have permission to do so. But I like S.H.E.'s version better.
Ur missing the point, it dont matter whos first, it matter whos better, and if both r good, then deal with it ppl!
sorry but wo ai ni and superstar both sound a lot better than sweetbox's chyna girl and more than love. they just sound more like asian songs and wo ai ni is esp sung with more feeling and emotion as the song seems to be written for. i don't know why they have to do covers of each other even if they are under the same producer. original versions usually do sound better so they should just keep it that way. and isn't it more refreshing if they were always originals?
sorry I disagree with your opinion that Jade sang this song after S.H.E did. Its the other way around!! Wo ai ni of SHE is really a cover of More Than Love of Sweetbox.. I dont argue whos better becuz it depends on each person's preference, but that doesnt mean the truth should be twisted like that.
i felt that S.H.E 's version sound much better
( personal opinion) No offence..
excuse me, but S.H.E does not suck!! they do not lack originality and their version of all the songs sound better!
fyi, S.H.E first sang wo ai ni and superstar before sweet box sang it as more than love and chyna girl. so the songs were originally written for S.H.E
get your info straight if you're going to diss somebody
@MissR00s They are 3 girls from China (Taiwan). They copied the song in Chinese. Personally, I think their version (just the song, not MV) is not good. They lack the power. I heard their version first, but when it is when I heard this version, I realized it is a greate song.
You said this version is better than S.H.E !!
oh!! I think diffirent from you!!
sweetbox has a bad voice, I know S.H.E is copy this song, but S.H.E have a good voice, and all of version from sweetbox, S.H.E is the best, I don't know where's sweetbox come from!! but I very like S.H.E and don't want to hear someone said S.H.E is not good than other !!!
ok, the end, I still say as LoveDonghaeLeeteuk that "YOU'RE WRONG !!!!"
this song is jade made for s.h.e
wiki is not reliable, i think it is the basic thing everyone knows... anyway its fine, i dont even bother to "discuss" with you anymore. Its pointless.
Why are you always picking up the band S.H.E.? It's not cool, and I don't know how you pull out all these COPIED songs. I never heard about S.H.E and I'm looking forward to listen they're song, but stop to saying these things because you're wasting time.
you may prefer S.H.E. I dont care. kid.
S.H.E sang the songs first, OKAY? please do your homework
omg really?!?!
anyways i like S.H.E.s version better
chinese version better
Jade❤
Jade❤
Jade❤