Producing is way different that doing revamps! YG Producers are working so hard you cant even compare! I agree Mando has some nice works, but it's far different than producing!
You know the revamped is gonna be better than the original if Mandø does it-* Edit: I know Mandø said that is kinda disrespectful to compare, and I'm gonna be more respectful to the original producers and their songs. I'm sorry if I ofended* someone. I actually commented* this joking. Sorry!
@Karen Ariana is the writer, along with a few others, but Ariana isn't the one who distributes the lines. I think the girls do it, but the producers have the power to change it. I think the producer, tommybrown, is the one responsible for the distribution. Whoever it is, I doubt it was YG or the girls, cause up until now they had fair line distribution under its management
I like this better because it's less monotonous (repetitious, lacking in variation in tone, pitch or sound). It's more energetic and it sounds more 'K-Pop'.
I think the original sounded like that because Selena and more of her producers did the beats and stuff and this sounds like something the western fans and Selena’s fans would like
Very unpopular opinion: I kind of understand why there wasn't much from jisoo in this collab(although they could've looped her part or idk). From what I've notice in this revamped version and the original, jisoo's husky voice in this version feels like it belongs here and is pleasant to listen, but in the original it would've sounded a little off. Like idk if you'd get me, but for me *personally* jisoo's deep husky voice compliments more with lofi beats and dreamy aesthetics or calming songs, or even soft songs with badass lyrics(eg. bibibi by IU without the og instrumental and somethingmuch softer to highlight her strong yet calming aura that she radiates), whereas the original "Ice cream" was more of an up beat "pink" song with kinky lyrics (which I'm not complaining about, there isn't many "girly" kinky songs in kpop. Most of them are badass hoe anthems, which are fire.). Also, selena's voice complimented the most with jennie, so they made her sing(rosé, if she sung with a deeper voice could've too comolimented selena's voice but that isn't a very YGE thing to do. And i don't wanna jinx her solo debut.). There isn't a YGE song without a rap, so there, lisa got the rap. Jisoo having a very unique tone to her voice got the least lines, and probably because this was a *collab* they decided to not having any parts highlight her since then her voice would've changed the whole vibe and this song would've been known as "jisoo's era/song" and not a collab. Jisoo should've gotten more screen time tho, her visuals fit the description or vibe of the song more than anybody, and she's the main visual(what happened? Yg why? This I can't understand. But I don't wanna jinx her first lead role in a drama. So do what you want but don't take away actress chu from us.)
I agree with everything you say, apart from the problem at the core: if Jisoo is part of Blackpink, then Blackpink should make songs that fit with all the members. The fact that they had her and pushed her aside for the sake of making a PiNk PopPY sOnG with SeLeNA (sorry if I sound petty but I really don't like her) is straight up stupid. If they want to change artistic direction with the group and Jisoo doesn't fit anymore, then they should just take her out of the group. At least they would be coherent. Having her and not using her is pointless and dumb (that's why it doesn't even surprise me anymore at this point). If Blackpink has a concept built around 4 members (not 12, FOUR, and they still manage to live one out!!), and a song would be fit only for 3 members, then the song isn't fit for Blackpink. I wouldn't be so harsh if every now and then they'd just give more space to a different member, but I think so far everyone who is not blind knows who are the favourites and who is left behind (and it's not an attack to the girls, it's a problem of artistic directors/production etc. I know nothing about the girls behind the scenes and so does everybody despite what they want us to see)
@@myssangela4872 I agree, they could've given her more than 14 seconds, at least 30secs or even just backtracked her vocals. But when you said, they should just taken her out if they think she doesn't fit the group anymore, you kind of missed the point of it being a collab. Jisoo fits blackpink, she's the line between the black and pink concept and can adhere to both, *but* for this collab, her and selena had similar vibes, both of them have similar voice textures, and vocal limitations. It still wasn't fair, but we don't know what happens backstage. And we can't simply imply it was favouritism, because it doesn't work like that. The people in charge, if did favour one member, they would lost their jobs. It might even have been jisoo's choice to not sing as much because she wasn't comfortable singing in english(honestly who knows, they could've had korean lines for her, like they did with some of Lisa's rap parts). And this was a collab, well, more like, selena ft.blackpink, but that was kind of the whole point, thought of by yge to target the western media. I mean, if people won't watch it for blackpink they'll watch it for selena, and more than half of it was selena, then lisa, because she's the most popular member in the west, then jennie, then rosé, and jisoo isn't as popular in the western media as she is in korea, so maybe that's why(this is honestly the only explanation i can think of as to why they went with the line distributions they did). Let's just wait till their main cb to really conclude the favouritism of the company.
@@myssangela4872 and it wasn't, "they changed the whole theme for selena, but rather they chose selena for this theme", because they mentioned "we knew she'd fit right away". As they've been preparing for this since late 2019, also around the time when rosé was still working on her solo debut(they said it would be like an album, and not just a song, so kind of explains why she's been the buisiest, and probably why her vocals were highlighted in both hylt and ice cream while still not giving much away), jisoo's also working on a drama and I can't imagine how hectic her schedule must've been, preparing for hylt, ice cream, the other songs *and* their upcoming cb(there's no explanation to the screentime, but I think I've mentioned enough points as to why it's the way it is). Jennie worked behind the screens, did cfs and was probably the least active compared to her members, due to her injuries(which I'm glad she did, i wouldn't want her overwork herself), lisa mentored in ywy2 and promoted brands and all. So, they themselves knew that this isn't a music centred song but rather a song for fun and benefit for both the parties, since it would be really helpful for selena to have more fans in the east and maybe just even to regain her confidence after her big break, since she would've been more comfortable in an enviornment that's not as toxic for her and calm, and for blackpink to promote and be more popular in the west, because, like, have you seen selena's following?
@@myssangela4872 and yes. Jisoo being the lead vocal doesn't have many line which is unfair but the songs in which she has more lines aren't as hyped as the one's where people spam jisoo not having enough lines. Plus, the songs in which she shines are more calming ballads rather than a strong concept, which people just sleep on.
Thank you for your answers. It's kind of uncommon to find someone to entertain an actual conversation/discussion in the fandom in a nice way. I hope I'll be able to actually reply to you during the day but you brought up so many points hahaha maybe I'll reply tomorrow we'll see
This is by far the most superior revamp I’ve ever heard. That small outro for our baby jisoo, wow mando didn’t really come to play, you’re indeed the cherry on top to this song💅🏼
Well... Just as I thought... *TALENTED BRILLIANT INCREDIBLE AMAZING SHOWSTOPPING SPECTACULAR NEVER THE SAME K-TOTALLY UNIQUE COMPLETELY NOT EVER DONE BEFORE UNAFRAID REFERENCE OR NOT REFERENCE PUT IT IN A BLENDER SHIT ON IT VOMIT ON IT EAT IT GIVE BIRTH TO IT* Stan talent, stan mandø fka ab mashups aka YG Entertainment future producer
What do y'all expect? Mando will always outdo those producers in YG 😂 thank you so much for adding those extra beats in the chorus, it felt more complete! The ending though 😭 +seconds for Jisoo's line distribution xD And also this song screams ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) energy
The fact that you managed to give Jisoo justice using the super small amount of lines she got is at the same time wholesome and disheartening because it exposes even more how much shit YG intentionally gives her.
the extra beat added into the "look so good look so sweet" part really brings it all together, the original sounds so empty. Mando really filled in the empty space in this song, imo this is way better than the original. And it was so satisfying hearing lisa's rap and then continued by the end part.
i absolutely forgot i was watching ur revamp version and was gettin confused being like i didnt catch this instrumental the first fifty times i listened to this song
THIS IS SO GOOOOOD. I really love that you fill the emptiness in "look so good yeah look so sweet". Also i REALLLLYYYYY love the last part T-T This is sounds so good and more happy(?)
Now this sounds so good!!! Best revamp ever. Kept the singing and tone but added some more flare! I loved this. And the ending with the girls in the darker how you like that concept was so good!
This is what I expected from what the song would sound like... Excellent Mando! Another masterpiece and might listen to this instead of the original one lol
Guys so hear me out, if y'all gonna give some vocal parts of Jennie/Selena to Chaesoo, which ones are you gonna give? Because imo they perfectly fit those lines and I don't see Chaesoo doing better (no offense please ik they are good vocals and they will slay the line but Jennie and Selena would pull it off better).. or is it just me? Although for me, it would have been better just them making the song longer for more lines then those lines will be Chaesoo's... idk man, I find 3mins songs too short. Can't they do a little more effort in producing BP's songs?
I understand where you coming from but it shouldn’t be a matter of which lines would we give to Chaesoo as fans, the producer should have factored in all 5 of them and made the song where they can all have a a decent amount of lines. Whether they make the song longer as you suggested, or just making sure the song suits all 5.
To be honest here,i cant clearly hear the different except for jennie's part,jisoo's uce cream chillin part and the last part...im serious.. Shiuld i check my ear??
I was wondering too, so I looked over the comments and checked the original. Basically what’s different here is that there’s a bit more happening in the instrumental too add interest to the song and make it feel a little less repetitive.
Zsunder = LOONA PRODUCER Mandø. = BLACKPINK PRODUCER Dylon Marcel = Twice producer Mashup people should be able to make the intros in live stages my opinion
Will you please review my revamps and rearranged versions, also I am also premiering a revamped version of this song tomorrow...coincidence.I have been a fan of yours since a long time.....Love this just like your other masterpieces
I forgot what the original sounds like 😂 I shall just listen to this one. Btw, if it’s not a burden, can you make a mashup for ICE CREAM X AIIYL please? It’d be cool!
For me, the original sounds empty, like something is missing out, but at the same time it's so repetitive and I feel while listening to it like I already listened the song for hours! Meanwhile this version feels fresh and like a true summer banger. I really like that the second part of Lisa's rap is put almost at the end(?), it feels better to listen. You just gave more life to this song and put the missing puzzle. Overall, in this comeback(?) I like how stylists put their effort into it and made girls look stunning! I really missed vibes like this since AIIYL. This concept really suits girls and I wish I could personally thank the stylists. :) Girls vocals always on point, even tho I'm still sad that Rosé and Jisoo didn't have a chance to show off their talents like Lisa and Jennie. But I understand that it's not their fault, but producer's and that even tho I can be mad forever, it still won't do anything. :// I think their producer's should start look up to you and learn how to make good songs and how to fairly distribute with lines. :)
Let's be real for a second, though. Lisa's lines make ABSOLUTELY no sense. Like nothing she said had anything to do with the song. Mona Lisa kinda Lisa, get a visa??? Who wrote this song? Lyrically, it's a flop, for sure. But it is catchy, though. 🥺
They did Lisa super dirty this time, Mona Lisa has nothing to do with Lisa herself, they're both from different time periods but fr who the heck wrote her rap 😭
if this wasn’t a blackpink song i doubt anyone would say that this is a good song. it’s like the friday song. it’s a really bad song. the mv is nice though. but if you just listen to the song, it’s pretty bad
Basically I love your work mando. Sometimes I feel like the original one is masterpiece, but still love your work. But today I agree with you. This revamped is better better better than the original one. Sorry yg:(
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #30 ДВА В ОДНОМ [Один человек]• Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nrXy15orKhY/mqdefault.jpg)
*At this point mando should be producing some of blackpink's songs and songs in general*
100%~
And janny
YES
Producing is way different that doing revamps! YG Producers are working so hard you cant even compare! I agree Mando has some nice works, but it's far different than producing!
Yep
Legend says that YG is not chilling chilling after hearing this masterpiece.
omgg I see you everywhere iconic
I dont think you can watch youtube in jail 🤭
😂😂😂
Speaking *facts* right there
I am, I'm Legend
When Mandø revamps you know Jisoo’s gonna get lines
Yesss
As she should, as she should.
Kim k: its what she deserves
we love mandø for that!!!
@@boss1boy lmao
I swear if Mando, ZSunder, and Janny all had a collaboration they could overthrow YG easily
yes 😌✨
the powerful trio
Too powerful to handle for us
Facts
Periodt y'all, the three of them could literally take over the Big 3 if they made their own companies
You know the revamped is gonna be better than the original if Mandø does it-*
Edit: I know Mandø said that is kinda disrespectful to compare, and I'm gonna be more respectful to the original producers and their songs. I'm sorry if I ofended* someone. I actually commented* this joking. Sorry!
PRDT.
I am the 1K likeeerer
I Agree
I agree
Yeah adding unnecessary sounds
THE EXTENDED ENDING YES
IKR
IKR
I LITERALLY HAD THE CHILLS-
Jisso’s “You’re the cherry on top” was precious 💜✨
I wish yg gave her more line
Jisoo actually have lines here tho, yge learn it how to do
And her being Thumbnail is PERFECTION
@Karen Ariana is the writer, along with a few others, but Ariana isn't the one who distributes the lines. I think the girls do it, but the producers have the power to change it. I think the producer, tommybrown, is the one responsible for the distribution. Whoever it is, I doubt it was YG or the girls, cause up until now they had fair line distribution under its management
@@6maria94 as far as I know Ariana only wrote 6 seconds (Jennie's part)
stop saying “this is better than the original”
this is the original
Stop saying the “this is the original” comments
Because those comments aren’t even original
@@Lilyjem39 he meant the song (?)
XxBlOOdy ScREamxX yeah i’m, aware I’m saying that I see this same comment literally everywhere
@@Lilyjem39 oof-
SilveryMarsh ✨u need to calm down, you’re being too loud✨
I got irritated with every "look SO sweet" in the original one, this one sounds amazing
I hate the ice cream chillen chillen Ice cream chillen chillen .... like cmon teddy
@Sadecebirinsan u mean 8, 6 graders with hormones
@Sadecebirinsan EIGHT?!?!? BITCH WAT-
@@mochiquizbear6168 you literally said that to Ariana Grande, Selena Gomez, Victoria Monet and many others ☠ oof
@@geehna they better count they mf days and YGent.
i LOVE how you made the chorus sound less empty and how you gave jisoo more lines
I know this will be better than the og for sureee
Edit after the premiere: Guess o was right this is a whole bop!
This should be ori version...
Ori Ice Cream is like an incomplete homework...
for real
Its always been an incomplete homework
Ice cream is genuinely a rushed clusterfuck of English lyrics 😔 it’s so sad to me tbh bc I was so excited for this shit
The original was kind of a let down :(
Well yeah! I expected for some we can hear in repeat but nah
2:36 Dont know why, but only what impressed me that musch was that "lil drop" after HIT THE BAG
This is better than original, is more energetic.
Agree, the original song sounds too empty
@@lilacbp3908 the original's chorus was very underwhelming; that's why it sounds empty
(┛✧Д✧))┛彡┻━┻
read the recent post community😀
Jisoo ending the song.. I mean...
YES THANK U😭😭💗
Not to mention she is also a thumbnail🥺
I like this better because it's less monotonous (repetitious, lacking in variation in tone, pitch or sound). It's more energetic and it sounds more 'K-Pop'.
I think so too, the original sounded so empty and overwhelming.
I think the original sounded like that because Selena and more of her producers did the beats and stuff and this sounds like something the western fans and Selena’s fans would like
why the hell is this better than the original???? I love this shit, dude.
Very unpopular opinion:
I kind of understand why there wasn't much from jisoo in this collab(although they could've looped her part or idk). From what I've notice in this revamped version and the original, jisoo's husky voice in this version feels like it belongs here and is pleasant to listen, but in the original it would've sounded a little off. Like idk if you'd get me, but for me *personally* jisoo's deep husky voice compliments more with lofi beats and dreamy aesthetics or calming songs, or even soft songs with badass lyrics(eg. bibibi by IU without the og instrumental and somethingmuch softer to highlight her strong yet calming aura that she radiates), whereas the original "Ice cream" was more of an up beat "pink" song with kinky lyrics (which I'm not complaining about, there isn't many "girly" kinky songs in kpop. Most of them are badass hoe anthems, which are fire.). Also, selena's voice complimented the most with jennie, so they made her sing(rosé, if she sung with a deeper voice could've too comolimented selena's voice but that isn't a very YGE thing to do. And i don't wanna jinx her solo debut.). There isn't a YGE song without a rap, so there, lisa got the rap. Jisoo having a very unique tone to her voice got the least lines, and probably because this was a *collab* they decided to not having any parts highlight her since then her voice would've changed the whole vibe and this song would've been known as "jisoo's era/song" and not a collab. Jisoo should've gotten more screen time tho, her visuals fit the description or vibe of the song more than anybody, and she's the main visual(what happened? Yg why? This I can't understand. But I don't wanna jinx her first lead role in a drama. So do what you want but don't take away actress chu from us.)
I agree with everything you say, apart from the problem at the core: if Jisoo is part of Blackpink, then Blackpink should make songs that fit with all the members. The fact that they had her and pushed her aside for the sake of making a PiNk PopPY sOnG with SeLeNA (sorry if I sound petty but I really don't like her) is straight up stupid. If they want to change artistic direction with the group and Jisoo doesn't fit anymore, then they should just take her out of the group. At least they would be coherent. Having her and not using her is pointless and dumb (that's why it doesn't even surprise me anymore at this point).
If Blackpink has a concept built around 4 members (not 12, FOUR, and they still manage to live one out!!), and a song would be fit only for 3 members, then the song isn't fit for Blackpink.
I wouldn't be so harsh if every now and then they'd just give more space to a different member, but I think so far everyone who is not blind knows who are the favourites and who is left behind (and it's not an attack to the girls, it's a problem of artistic directors/production etc. I know nothing about the girls behind the scenes and so does everybody despite what they want us to see)
@@myssangela4872 I agree, they could've given her more than 14 seconds, at least 30secs or even just backtracked her vocals. But when you said, they should just taken her out if they think she doesn't fit the group anymore, you kind of missed the point of it being a collab. Jisoo fits blackpink, she's the line between the black and pink concept and can adhere to both, *but* for this collab, her and selena had similar vibes, both of them have similar voice textures, and vocal limitations. It still wasn't fair, but we don't know what happens backstage. And we can't simply imply it was favouritism, because it doesn't work like that. The people in charge, if did favour one member, they would lost their jobs. It might even have been jisoo's choice to not sing as much because she wasn't comfortable singing in english(honestly who knows, they could've had korean lines for her, like they did with some of Lisa's rap parts).
And this was a collab, well, more like, selena ft.blackpink, but that was kind of the whole point, thought of by yge to target the western media. I mean, if people won't watch it for blackpink they'll watch it for selena, and more than half of it was selena, then lisa, because she's the most popular member in the west, then jennie, then rosé, and jisoo isn't as popular in the western media as she is in korea, so maybe that's why(this is honestly the only explanation i can think of as to why they went with the line distributions they did). Let's just wait till their main cb to really conclude the favouritism of the company.
@@myssangela4872 and it wasn't, "they changed the whole theme for selena, but rather they chose selena for this theme", because they mentioned "we knew she'd fit right away". As they've been preparing for this since late 2019, also around the time when rosé was still working on her solo debut(they said it would be like an album, and not just a song, so kind of explains why she's been the buisiest, and probably why her vocals were highlighted in both hylt and ice cream while still not giving much away), jisoo's also working on a drama and I can't imagine how hectic her schedule must've been, preparing for hylt, ice cream, the other songs *and* their upcoming cb(there's no explanation to the screentime, but I think I've mentioned enough points as to why it's the way it is). Jennie worked behind the screens, did cfs and was probably the least active compared to her members, due to her injuries(which I'm glad she did, i wouldn't want her overwork herself), lisa mentored in ywy2 and promoted brands and all. So, they themselves knew that this isn't a music centred song but rather a song for fun and benefit for both the parties, since it would be really helpful for selena to have more fans in the east and maybe just even to regain her confidence after her big break, since she would've been more comfortable in an enviornment that's not as toxic for her and calm, and for blackpink to promote and be more popular in the west, because, like, have you seen selena's following?
@@myssangela4872 and yes. Jisoo being the lead vocal doesn't have many line which is unfair but the songs in which she has more lines aren't as hyped as the one's where people spam jisoo not having enough lines. Plus, the songs in which she shines are more calming ballads rather than a strong concept, which people just sleep on.
Thank you for your answers. It's kind of uncommon to find someone to entertain an actual conversation/discussion in the fandom in a nice way. I hope I'll be able to actually reply to you during the day but you brought up so many points hahaha maybe I'll reply tomorrow we'll see
this ending slapped!! the original one felt very unfinished. as if they just got bored and decided to cut the song like this lol
the outro is ✨m a s t e r p i e c e✨
this 1000% better than the original, mandø did it again
Jisoo has more lines?!? yAY!
STAN MANDO FOR BETTER LIFEE!!!
tysm for making the chorus actually feel like a chorus. i NEED this on spotify..
This is by far the most superior revamp I’ve ever heard. That small outro for our baby jisoo, wow mando didn’t really come to play, you’re indeed the cherry on top to this song💅🏼
It didn't even start and I already like it💗
Edit: I watched it AND I LIKE IT SOOO MUCH THANK U MANDO!💗
Finally this song is longer than three minutes.
Well... Just as I thought...
*TALENTED BRILLIANT INCREDIBLE AMAZING SHOWSTOPPING SPECTACULAR NEVER THE SAME K-TOTALLY UNIQUE COMPLETELY NOT EVER DONE BEFORE UNAFRAID REFERENCE OR NOT REFERENCE PUT IT IN A BLENDER SHIT ON IT VOMIT ON IT EAT IT GIVE BIRTH TO IT*
Stan talent, stan mandø fka ab mashups aka YG Entertainment future producer
blackpink producers are shaking
What do y'all expect? Mando will always outdo those producers in YG 😂 thank you so much for adding those extra beats in the chorus, it felt more complete!
The ending though 😭 +seconds for Jisoo's line distribution xD
And also this song screams ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) energy
I love the fact jichu is on the thumbnail ❤
Everybody ganster till Mandø drops a revamped Music Video.
The fact that you managed to give Jisoo justice using the super small amount of lines she got is at the same time wholesome and disheartening because it exposes even more how much shit YG intentionally gives her.
Rosé have less?
The ending is lit
That's my favorite part
the extra beat added into the "look so good look so sweet" part really brings it all together, the original sounds so empty. Mando really filled in the empty space in this song, imo this is way better than the original. And it was so satisfying hearing lisa's rap and then continued by the end part.
As if I didn’t expect this to be better when it ALWAYS IS
you definitely made the ending way smoother and better!
one of the best revamped
i absolutely forgot i was watching ur revamp version and was gettin confused being like i didnt catch this instrumental the first fifty times i listened to this song
thank you so much for adding bass to the chorus, it sounded empty, you made the whole song so much better
i prefer this more than origial because of Jisoo line! this is so great work!!! you are amazing!!!
THIS IS SO GOOOOOD.
I really love that you fill the emptiness in "look so good yeah look so sweet". Also i REALLLLYYYYY love the last part T-T
This is sounds so good and more happy(?)
I prefer the original, that revamped hit to hard for a cute concept but whatever, that's a good job ^^
Yo I just realise those “You're the cherry on top” at the end!! Amazing
Every time bp releases a new song,I always wait for your revamped versions❤️
You never disappoint❤️
Now this sounds so good!!! Best revamp ever. Kept the singing and tone but added some more flare! I loved this. And the ending with the girls in the darker how you like that concept was so good!
This is what I expected from what the song would sound like... Excellent Mando! Another masterpiece and might listen to this instead of the original one lol
I loved the line distribution💗💗💗💗🖤🖤🖤🖤
When i heard the original i was sitting there like “whens the mando version coming out?”
omg YG NEEDS to add that ending right now it feels so complete
Guys so hear me out, if y'all gonna give some vocal parts of Jennie/Selena to Chaesoo, which ones are you gonna give? Because imo they perfectly fit those lines and I don't see Chaesoo doing better (no offense please ik they are good vocals and they will slay the line but Jennie and Selena would pull it off better).. or is it just me?
Although for me, it would have been better just them making the song longer for more lines then those lines will be Chaesoo's... idk man, I find 3mins songs too short. Can't they do a little more effort in producing BP's songs?
I understand where you coming from but it shouldn’t be a matter of which lines would we give to Chaesoo as fans, the producer should have factored in all 5 of them and made the song where they can all have a a decent amount of lines. Whether they make the song longer as you suggested, or just making sure the song suits all 5.
I think Jisoo could’ve gotten Jennie’s lines from the second chorus. I can see her singing it
I CANT STOP LISTENING TO THE ENDING ISTG, ITS SO GOOD
Teddy x Mando YG 2020 Petition??
That base line and synth is lit bruh
Teddy: *exists*
Mandø: *I'm about to end this man's whole career*
Thank you for this masterpiece and lots of love for this video.
Baby you deserve a treat
ngl the original has always felt like there’s something off with it but this sounds so good i’m-
Yay! I've been waiting for your version ❤️🧡💛
To be honest here,i cant clearly hear the different except for jennie's part,jisoo's uce cream chillin part and the last part...im serious..
Shiuld i check my ear??
I was wondering too, so I looked over the comments and checked the original. Basically what’s different here is that there’s a bit more happening in the instrumental too add interest to the song and make it feel a little less repetitive.
the original instrumental was too bland and sounded like a nursery rhyme--this one sounded like an actual song
@@akira.592 they should hve given this song to yg alledged new girl group
If I'm being honest, I didn't really hear a difference either until like half way. But omg that extended ending was so good
There are added beats before the chorus, in the chorus, some rap parts, extended Jisoo parts as well.
YG should literally hire you
Zsunder = LOONA PRODUCER
Mandø. = BLACKPINK PRODUCER
Dylon Marcel = Twice producer
Mashup people should be able to make the intros in live stages my opinion
I know ur revamped will be better than the original ones. Thank u for making this ^^
the end gave me chills what
0:32 the laugh is just so perfect there . I think Lisa should try this during the performance 👍❤
istg brass really makes everything sound good
Look so good look so sweet lyrics for this person who made song better than orignal
I can suffer to this in my sleep and let it haunt me😔✨💜
Will you please review my revamps and rearranged versions, also I am also premiering a revamped version of this song tomorrow...coincidence.I have been a fan of yours since a long time.....Love this just like your other masterpieces
you're so talented!!!!!!
I forgot what the original sounds like 😂 I shall just listen to this one. Btw, if it’s not a burden, can you make a mashup for ICE CREAM X AIIYL please? It’d be cool!
Love the last part.❤
For me, the original sounds empty, like something is missing out, but at the same time it's so repetitive and I feel while listening to it like I already listened the song for hours!
Meanwhile this version feels fresh and like a true summer banger. I really like that the second part of Lisa's rap is put almost at the end(?), it feels better to listen. You just gave more life to this song and put the missing puzzle.
Overall, in this comeback(?) I like how stylists put their effort into it and made girls look stunning! I really missed vibes like this since AIIYL. This concept really suits girls and I wish I could personally thank the stylists. :)
Girls vocals always on point, even tho I'm still sad that Rosé and Jisoo didn't have a chance to show off their talents like Lisa and Jennie. But I understand that it's not their fault, but producer's and that even tho I can be mad forever, it still won't do anything. ://
I think their producer's should start look up to you and learn how to make good songs and how to fairly distribute with lines. :)
Ok but like idk why but this version seems more clean and easy to listen🖤thank u for making these🤧❤️🖤❤️
I actually really like this on a lot more than the original
I was waiting for this
I just realized that nooooooooooooo one in the group or even selena saying "BLACKPINK IN YOUR AREA" or "SELPINK IN YOUR AREA"😧
omg your pfp 🥺 HARUTOOOO
also this is amazing uwu
this is 1000X better than the original, like im sorry like im sorry lmaoo
i really like this revamp!! the ending especially, it's less abrupt than the original which i personally think sounds better. thank you for this!
Let's be real for a second, though. Lisa's lines make ABSOLUTELY no sense. Like nothing she said had anything to do with the song. Mona Lisa kinda Lisa, get a visa??? Who wrote this song? Lyrically, it's a flop, for sure. But it is catchy, though. 🥺
They did Lisa super dirty this time, Mona Lisa has nothing to do with Lisa herself, they're both from different time periods but fr who the heck wrote her rap 😭
The things you added was so minimal but it made the song so much better
Isn't this the original cuz I suddenly don't remember any other version now
finally!!!! I've been waiting for you!!!! You saved the song gahd. This sound so much better than the original for real. YG SHOULD HIRE YOU
this is better than the original
im not sorry no hate
I love this! I wish I would’ve thought of these additions when I was making my own revamp. hihi love you!
Actually, the actual song is arleady perfect but our ears missing something in the song.
the end part is so good
i'm sorry to say this but the only thing that you did was turn up the bass a bit. It is like the original...
I was waiting for this! 😍😍😍😍 Love this version so much better!❤️❤️❤️❤️
if this wasn’t a blackpink song i doubt anyone would say that this is a good song. it’s like the friday song. it’s a really bad song. the mv is nice though. but if you just listen to the song, it’s pretty bad
Finally 😔 I felt like the song was random and empty but anyways those who like it good for them
yes
Exactly. It's hard to vibe to 😐
It’s not Friday level bad 😂 but yes it’s not that good and is overrated
but if it was a horror movie I meannnn Ice Cream only wins cuz the mixing and vocals are good, except for the unnecessary autotune 😂😂😭
This is MORE BETTER than the original, this is more energetic!
I swear if mandø is a producer!
when you get excited for mando's version of the comeback song more than the actual comeback
What I love about this version is the trumpet-sound on the Chorus and on the Outro of the song, it just gives a little bit of spice.
I actually didn't like the og song. This version is so good and I haven't even finished listening to the full song yet😍
The lines added at the end are **chef’s kiss**
Fans: Jisoo, I dreamed that you sang in Ice Cream
Jisoo: So wake up
:')
brasileira vei
@@fxlipx4587 eae man
Basically I love your work mando. Sometimes I feel like the original one is masterpiece, but still love your work. But today I agree with you. This revamped is better better better than the original one. Sorry yg:(
this sound more like a girl crush song when this is the pink song everyone wants. i like the original more but i appreciate the hard work done on this
Mandø you need to be in yg
I don't know why you are not in yg💕