A red velvet video after a long time! Do you like their comeback too? ✧ EDIT: After watching the recording video of COSMIC, Joy's final adlibs were actually done by Seulgi. Even though I listened to the stems before making the line distribution, I was still not able to recognize that it was Seulgi as she sounds so much like Joy in that part, making it the reason why I gave it to Joy as it sounds so much like Joy. However, the recording video confirms that it was Seulgi. Therefore, the final results would be like this: WENDY - 42.4 secs. (=) *SEULGI - 32.5 secs. (=)* *YERI - 19.8 secs. (🔼1)* *IRENE - 17.5 secs. (🔼1)* *JOY - 17.0 secs. (🔽2)* For Paid Requests: 『 ko-fi.com/bunn1x 』
I agree! I was suppose to use her as a thumbnail as well since she has good shots in the M/V but I realized that people might like to see other members as well (As I've used Yeri on the main video already)
I always want more Joy (vocally and visually!), but I feel like she was the standout in Chill Kill, so it’s not like she’s always overlooked. And she shines on the rest of this album. The only thing I’m bummed about in this video is that I wanted more solo dancing shots like Seulgi’s - would’ve been so cool to see each of them doing the choreography (we get a little bit of Irene, but I would’ve loved the other three, too). Overall, amazing comeback and maybe one of my fav RV songs, which is saying something.
@@chilllllllllll she gets most lines? mind you, SEULGI wasnt treated as a lead vocalist and main dancer since Queendom era. Joy got more lines than her even in bsides. seulgi getting the most screentime as she should coz she's literally the member who express the red and velvet concept the most. stop spreading fake news my ass.
@@iyah-ng1jvDumbmates always stay dumb. Have you even checked the mvs and lines of seulgi or are you going to defend her without checking them? She is literally SM's princess and not even once she got the least lines. It has always been Yeri, Wendy and Joy getting mistreated but you always have to play the victim card. Aseul fans making everything about themselves is just so stupid.Then you have the audacity to call out others subfandoms who are just complaining about their favs not getting treated right. Asslickers of SM.
Wendy yaa!!! our lovely main vocal ! even she get flu while recording, she could stand out from the other as always !! ah, hope she getting better too !!
Everyone is beautiful, but I think this is Seulgi’s era. I expected Irene to be the main character in the MV since she’s the next one to release a song, but Seulgi portrayed her part well (all of them did, actually). Anyway, the MV and the songs are all good.
@@dairynehyun2122well...by having 20+ and 30+ secs of screentime while the other members only got 10+ something of course they will own the MV. I wouldnt say they own the whole era.
Yes, as I've said on the other comment, I was surprised that it wasn't Joy as I listened to it on its stems (meaning on a clearer version of the adlibs), and Seulgi sounds so much like Joy in those parts 😭
I've seen you active in the past few days, I really waited for your line distribution to the point that I didn't watch the other ones that are posted..💗
Red velvet is in such a wierd predicament. For eg wendy gets lots kf line in group but noone even bothered about her solo. They have fans for ot5 but not for solos. Probably only seulgi and joy have potential. This group and members deserves so much better
Joy is the gp darling, seulgi fandom darling, wendy critics/producers darling. 99% of their korean fans love them as a group, not individuals, and that's the demography SM caters to the most no matter how loud twitter stans are or how royal chinese bars are.
@@abjolute 2017 snsd had the renewing members renewed together and the leaving members left together. Not even taeyeon or yoona did anything ahead of the rest. That, and snsd could stick to each other enough to not let sm pressure them to the point their blatant favoritism was visible on holiday or all night mv. In those two senses, rv doesn't even hold half of snsd's weight.
Most Reveluvs are solo stans and the gg stans are just seulrene stans. But Wendy may not be as popular as the others but she definitely has her small dedicated fanbase and she's very talented so it won't be hard for her at all.
Those are backing vocals. I filtered the song first before creating this video. However, I do not count backing vocals on my line distribution videos as I think that it could change the ranking in a way that it shouldn't be (since most of the backing vocals could be either done by specific members only or by other people outside the group).
@@hisannnilyan4170 yes you are right . Therefore BTS positions are not fair Inwhich Jk is the center and has more lines and in the first row since he is in dance line which is completely unfair
@@wise5746 wdgaf about bts here...like this is red velvet and irene is in a group with full of vocalist who can sing so ofc they had to give more singing part to wendy seulgi and joy
Pretty sure they uploaded her teaser image late bc they forgot and she got like 10 secs of screentime here, it's just crazy considered how she called the company out for not posting their comeback and then promoting it a lot. They also cut some of her screen time parts out and when she was shown, it didn't even line up to her lines
@@Asunnixe All very valid issues, but I’m referring specifically to the people complaining about this line distribution. She’s like 5 seconds off Seulgi, and it’s not like she’s been desperate for lines in previous cbs so I just don’t get where the issue is in that department
@@DuskLizares She's third in line and usually is always in so yea I don't understand that part but I think if she did have screen time matching her lines, there would be less complaints. Such as Irene is last but got a good amount of screen time (Ik she's center) and Yeri also got her fair share of screentime but Joy didn't. I saw a tweet that Joy's screentime was cut off which also doesn't help. Overall she's being mistreated this comeback but she should be fine during the live stages and promoting it bc she has lines
@@Asunnixe That is a problem if true. I think a lot of people are just annoyed and getting mad at things they normally wouldn’t because they know Joy got screwed over in other areas during this cb.
@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211 what do you expect, wendy is the main vocalist, she deserves a lot of lines, even this Fair Distribution Line almost similar to FMR Distribution Line 😄
Joy got third bro. Calm down. The line distribution is fair this time around. It’s been getting better before Irene and Yeri were literally left with little to nothing. If you were a true ot5 you’d be happy. Now if you’re talking about the actual screen time then yes she was done wrong. But song wise it’s fair
@mysopeworld I really hope RV don't disband but I am seeing fx and snsd effect after aespa became popular they are not caring about RV as much. Such a bad habit of sm. They should treasure their artists. I think yeri, Wendy, Joy and irene will leave the company and seulgi is the only who might continue but they stay together forever
@@abjolute I really hope not, they’re my ult gg, I’ve been listening to them since zimzalabim. I really pray that they do not disband. Together they’re unstoppable no other group does harmonies like them. Each of their voices blend so beautifully it’s impossible to replicate. I love Aespa but RV is such a gem and SM need to take them more seriously like they used to RV is still popular yk?
@@wise5746 I love Seulgi till this comeback.But when I watch yesterday's live through group leader is Irene Seulgi doesn't let her talk.She can't communicate with fans😥
wendy as a main vocal shouldnt just have “more lines” when they’re insanely simple, she gets the most cause she has all the hard adlibs. why would it be different with joy?
It's crazy 😭😭😭😭 us YERI Stan's are so used to her having close to no lines so we don't even say anything but suddenly these Irene and joy Stan's are crying about mistreatment 😭😭 it's funny and painful to watch
@@onlytheflowerknowMaybe because it is real go and check how less of lines and screentime Joy has.Always acting like this when it comes to Joy. 16s of screentime when the whole video is almost 4 minutes long? Even the other people who are in the back had more screentime than Joy .
heavy editing in her teasers, messing up the audio, delaying her teaser, and now giving her a very short screentime and cutting her parts in the mv lol we have every right to get mad cause sm is obviously sabotaging her. if you don't know anything just shut up lol
Yeri getting the initial part of the bridge didnt make sense, I'm irene biased, but that part was suiting for joy, wich is something that generally happens, it demanded a more emotional vocal work and yeri was bland.
No yeri was a pleasant surprise, and she sounded great. Not everything needs to be predictable, and Yeri deserves to be noticed for her vocals for once.
You joy Stan's seem to have turned pretty toxic..the juxtaposition of Sooyoung and her "Stan's" is truly disgusting cuz wdym a sweet, caring, funny, supportive and always cheerful and positive joy has a fandom this toxic???? Stop it.
![[4K] Red Velvet - “Cosmic” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](/img/n.gif)
A red velvet video after a long time! Do you like their comeback too?
✧ EDIT:
After watching the recording video of COSMIC, Joy's final adlibs were actually done by Seulgi. Even though I listened to the stems before making the line distribution, I was still not able to recognize that it was Seulgi as she sounds so much like Joy in that part, making it the reason why I gave it to Joy as it sounds so much like Joy. However, the recording video confirms that it was Seulgi. Therefore, the final results would be like this:
WENDY - 42.4 secs. (=)
*SEULGI - 32.5 secs. (=)*
*YERI - 19.8 secs. (🔼1)*
*IRENE - 17.5 secs. (🔼1)*
*JOY - 17.0 secs. (🔽2)*
For Paid Requests:
『 ko-fi.com/bunn1x 』
Heyy I’d like to contact you to ask something but can’t get t your discord
Wendy main vocalist doing her thing. The bridge with Yeri and Wendy is chefs kiss!
Love Yeri‘s voice in this, especially in the bridge. Happy for her lines.
So exciting and refreshing to have Yeri in the bridge -- she sounds amazing.
"It's electric" is sung by Yeri
Yeri’s smile is all to this mv!❤❤ Edit: TYSM FOR 18 LIKES I HAVE NEVER GOTTEN THAT MANY OMG!
I agree! I was suppose to use her as a thumbnail as well since she has good shots in the M/V but I realized that people might like to see other members as well (As I've used Yeri on the main video already)
@@BUNN1X_Official IKR she is so cute
Yeriiiii, I love that bridge ❤❤❤
I hate SM so much, they uploaded the mv 44 minutes later
yeah, they even posted a statement about it 😭
They don't even care anymore and red velvet is treasure of kpop. They did the same with snsd. Why do they screw their own iconic groups
@abjolute because new they have aespa and rizze so they abandon their old groups + a lot of agencies do the same like YG and it s so sad
@@abjolute Snsd is fine.f(x) should be added.
@@BUNN1X_Official where can i see the statement?
My favorite song on this June. The bridge makes me feel so emotional
I always want more Joy (vocally and visually!), but I feel like she was the standout in Chill Kill, so it’s not like she’s always overlooked. And she shines on the rest of this album.
The only thing I’m bummed about in this video is that I wanted more solo dancing shots like Seulgi’s - would’ve been so cool to see each of them doing the choreography (we get a little bit of Irene, but I would’ve loved the other three, too). Overall, amazing comeback and maybe one of my fav RV songs, which is saying something.
Because seulgi main dancer irene Lead dancer
@@keserutimealmao stfu, seulgi literally has been put on the side in their choreo since queendom era for a MAIN DANCER
@@iyah-ng1jvcheck all the mvs she is literally no. 1 in all of them. She gets the most lines and screentime.
Don't give fake news to everyone.
@@chilllllllllll she gets most lines? mind you, SEULGI wasnt treated as a lead vocalist and main dancer since Queendom era. Joy got more lines than her even in bsides. seulgi getting the most screentime as she should coz she's literally the member who express the red and velvet concept the most. stop spreading fake news my ass.
@@iyah-ng1jvDumbmates always stay dumb. Have you even checked the mvs and lines of seulgi or are you going to defend her without checking them? She is literally SM's princess and not even once she got the least lines. It has always been Yeri, Wendy and Joy getting mistreated but you always have to play the victim card. Aseul fans making everything about themselves is just so stupid.Then you have the audacity to call out others subfandoms who are just complaining about their favs not getting treated right. Asslickers of SM.
Wendy yaa!!! our lovely main vocal !
even she get flu while recording, she could stand out from the other as always !!
ah, hope she getting better too !!
Irene might not have the most lines im this song but she really shined so much to the point that she owned this ERA tho all of them did.
So true
Always the eyes on Irene even if the others sing more
@@wise5746 she's very captivating the fact that RV is a visual group.
Everyone is beautiful, but I think this is Seulgi’s era. I expected Irene to be the main character in the MV since she’s the next one to release a song, but Seulgi portrayed her part well (all of them did, actually). Anyway, the MV and the songs are all good.
@@enchantixx Actually it's Aseul's era.
@@dairynehyun2122well...by having 20+ and 30+ secs of screentime while the other members only got 10+ something of course they will own the MV. I wouldnt say they own the whole era.
joy's vocals was soooooooooo amazing in cosmic like i fell in love with her belts and high notes like omggggg she shined so much
at least the line distribution is decent, unlike the screen time distribution.
3:36
I think these are Seulgi's adlibs (She sang them in the recording video)
Yes, as I've said on the other comment, I was surprised that it wasn't Joy as I listened to it on its stems (meaning on a clearer version of the adlibs), and Seulgi sounds so much like Joy in those parts 😭
This group is always ALWAYS fresh 😉✌❤
Red Velvet FIGHTING ♥
They are the definition of a perfect group ❤
I started floating in the bridge
After watching them recording the song the adlibs you gave to joy from 3:32 is Seulgi actually
It was seulgi all along i was shocked too after watching the recording like i thought it was joy cause it sounds just like her
And gosh, that puts her as the least distribution. Which almost never happened before? 😢
I agree! I even listened to it on its stems, Seulgi sounds so much like Joy in that part 😭
3:35 all adlibs you put to Joy after 17 sec. part is SEULGI according to their recording video, go and watch it.
I've seen you active in the past few days, I really waited for your line distribution to the point that I didn't watch the other ones that are posted..💗
RENEEEE! I MISSED YOU! THANK YOU FOR WAITING!
MOTHER WENDY💙💙
The best !!
Soloist wendy maim vocal wendy 🔥
Monopoly wendy
@@zolbayr480 As she should, lol. What, you're also gonna ask Taeyeon to sing less in snsd?
@@alltheprettygirls9 yea
@@zolbayr480dumb
@@zolbayr480 as she should! Actually she should get 60% line distribution like red flavor. That song is a HIT!
This MV is lacking of Joy if I feel like that, she deserves better
I’m so happy you’re back, I hope we can collab soon 🫣🤍
hoping that our schedules would match soon so that we can do it!
Y'all are so fast the mv just released yesterday
there are others who are even faster than me. but realistically speaking, I almost didn't sleep while making this 😥
3:36 aren't these adlibs Seulgi??
Joy
@@Byulboombyul Oh, I thought they were Seulgi!
Nope that's Joy.
it's in fact seulgi according to their recording
@@RiswjyVlols it's seulgi
Hiii i love ur line distribution videosss❤❤
So can i ask u smth??
Wendy gets the most line, as she should as the main vocalist!
Loving the pre chorus and bridge by main vocalist wendy. Her voice hard carried this song fr
SEULGI MAIN VICALISTA Y MAIN DANCER
Red velvet is in such a wierd predicament. For eg wendy gets lots kf line in group but noone even bothered about her solo. They have fans for ot5 but not for solos. Probably only seulgi and joy have potential. This group and members deserves so much better
Joy is the gp darling, seulgi fandom darling, wendy critics/producers darling. 99% of their korean fans love them as a group, not individuals, and that's the demography SM caters to the most no matter how loud twitter stans are or how royal chinese bars are.
@alltheprettygirls9 I thought the same thing what happened about snsd and see what happened. I hope they Stay together forever❤️❤️
Because reveluv mostly aseul bias.
@@abjolute 2017 snsd had the renewing members renewed together and the leaving members left together. Not even taeyeon or yoona did anything ahead of the rest. That, and snsd could stick to each other enough to not let sm pressure them to the point their blatant favoritism was visible on holiday or all night mv. In those two senses, rv doesn't even hold half of snsd's weight.
Most Reveluvs are solo stans and the gg stans are just seulrene stans. But Wendy may not be as popular as the others but she definitely has her small dedicated fanbase and she's very talented so it won't be hard for her at all.
Can you do pink punk ot9 sing blackpink songs to boombayah up to the girls long ver and ready for love extentend ver
Irene should have more lines
isn't 0:50 to 0:53 an Irene adlib?
Those are backing vocals. I filtered the song first before creating this video. However, I do not count backing vocals on my line distribution videos as I think that it could change the ranking in a way that it shouldn't be (since most of the backing vocals could be either done by specific members only or by other people outside the group).
@@BUNN1X_Official oh ic makes sense
I give they position:
1.Eunbi=Leader?,Main Vocalist
2.Euna=Main Rapper,Sub-Vocalist
3.Jisoo=Lead Vocalist,Sub-Rapper,Visual
4.Hannah=Vocalist,Rapper
5.Jennie=Leader?,Lead Vocalist,Lead Rapper,Face Of The Group,Center
6.Miyeon=Main Vocalist,Visual
7.Rose=Lead Vocalist,Lead Dancer
8.Lisa=Main Dancer,Sub-Vocalist,Rapper
9.Jinny=Lead Rapper,Sub-Vocalist,Dancer,Maknae
10 years of insane line distribution lmao
I think you wrong at bridge, isnt that yeri-joy-wendy ?
it's only yeri and wendy, joy has no part in the bridge this time.
No, it's only yeri & wendy part
it's just joy face in mv
but actually is wendy's voice
Irene should have more lines !!!
it is the center, if it has many lines, besides being in the center of almost the entire song, the others will not appear
@@hisannnilyan4170 yes you are right . Therefore BTS positions are not fair Inwhich Jk is the center and has more lines and in the first row since he is in dance line which is completely unfair
@@wise5746 wdgaf about bts here...like this is red velvet and irene is in a group with full of vocalist who can sing so ofc they had to give more singing part to wendy seulgi and joy
@@siarmn because it is same example as BTS!! However also Joy doesn’t get lines!!
@@wise5746 tf is wrong with armys and their obsession of bringing bts into every other thing? This has nothing to do with bts plz.
pretty sure that 3:36 to 3:40 is seulgi, sounds like her typical adlibs and voice
it's Joy
I actually filtered the song first, and then listened to both the lead and backing vocals, so I found out that it was Joy.
@@BUNN1X_Official news update, it's seulgi's adlib, go watch their recording video
@@mmateusz_xthat's seulgi
Joy stans really are fighting imaginary ghosts trying to claim she got mistreated here, huh?
her screen time was terrible as well tbf
Pretty sure they uploaded her teaser image late bc they forgot and she got like 10 secs of screentime here, it's just crazy considered how she called the company out for not posting their comeback and then promoting it a lot. They also cut some of her screen time parts out and when she was shown, it didn't even line up to her lines
@@Asunnixe All very valid issues, but I’m referring specifically to the people complaining about this line distribution. She’s like 5 seconds off Seulgi, and it’s not like she’s been desperate for lines in previous cbs so I just don’t get where the issue is in that department
@@DuskLizares She's third in line and usually is always in so yea I don't understand that part but I think if she did have screen time matching her lines, there would be less complaints. Such as Irene is last but got a good amount of screen time (Ik she's center) and Yeri also got her fair share of screentime but Joy didn't. I saw a tweet that Joy's screentime was cut off which also doesn't help. Overall she's being mistreated this comeback but she should be fine during the live stages and promoting it bc she has lines
@@Asunnixe That is a problem if true. I think a lot of people are just annoyed and getting mad at things they normally wouldn’t because they know Joy got screwed over in other areas during this cb.
Fair Distribution Line
lol not fair at all
Lol not fair at all
@@wise5746it is very fair 💀 like what's wrong with you
@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211 what do you expect, wendy is the main vocalist, she deserves a lot of lines, even this Fair Distribution Line almost similar to FMR Distribution Line 😄
@@FlowerEvil77 ik? 😭
Line distribution is fair, screen time distribution is not.
I hope joy leaves SM so I can support her and get rid of that rotten company 🙏🏻🙏🏻
She only has 10s screen time
I don't think she will leave sm not sure but she is going mostly into acting like crystal
Joy got third bro. Calm down. The line distribution is fair this time around. It’s been getting better before Irene and Yeri were literally left with little to nothing. If you were a true ot5 you’d be happy. Now if you’re talking about the actual screen time then yes she was done wrong. But song wise it’s fair
@mysopeworld I really hope RV don't disband but I am seeing fx and snsd effect after aespa became popular they are not caring about RV as much. Such a bad habit of sm. They should treasure their artists. I think yeri, Wendy, Joy and irene will leave the company and seulgi is the only who might continue but they stay together forever
@@abjolute I really hope not, they’re my ult gg, I’ve been listening to them since zimzalabim. I really pray that they do not disband. Together they’re unstoppable no other group does harmonies like them. Each of their voices blend so beautifully it’s impossible to replicate. I love Aespa but RV is such a gem and SM need to take them more seriously like they used to RV is still popular yk?
Why always Irene get the less lines
is she main vocalist?????
@@viclusiv is seulgi main vocalist?
@@viclusiv She is main rapper and visual but all screen time is for seulgi
Exactly
Me too I feel it is unfair
@@wise5746 I love Seulgi till this comeback.But when I watch yesterday's live through group leader is Irene Seulgi doesn't let her talk.She can't communicate with fans😥
They really did Joy so wrong
you can’t expect her to have the most lines all the time, the line distribution was fair and all their voice colors were utilized well
This is quite a normal distribution for Red Velvet tho? Wendy 1st, Seulgi 2nd, Joy 3rd, then Irene or Yeri is either 4th or 5th.
@@gorgeousspears971 well she is 3rd but it was more bc of adlibs than actually lines
@@camillamelissamoraes6647same as Wendy and Seulgi, they have morebadlibs than Sing line, what do you mean
wendy as a main vocal shouldnt just have “more lines” when they’re insanely simple, she gets the most cause she has all the hard adlibs. why would it be different with joy?
Red Velvet fans mad at Seulgi for getting most screentime but when other members got the most its okay. So they only hate it when Its Seulgi. Noted
nobody is mad at seulgi, people are mad this entire mv was joys idea and she has 5 seconds of screen time. ur arguing with a wall kevin
Don’t victimize Seulgi, no one is mad at her, whoever edited the video erased Joy from it even when singing her lines or being the center
@@abyrea1453btch stfu, the hate seulgi is getting twitter from so called OT5 is ridiculous
Not even a single soul said anything about Seulgi but her akgaes themselves got into this argument and then start playing the victim cards.
the akgaes in these comments💀💀 reveland is truly ruined because of you all
It's crazy 😭😭😭😭 us YERI Stan's are so used to her having close to no lines so we don't even say anything but suddenly these Irene and joy Stan's are crying about mistreatment 😭😭 it's funny and painful to watch
@@onlytheflowerknowMaybe because it is real go and check how less of lines and screentime Joy has.Always acting like this when it comes to Joy. 16s of screentime when the whole video is almost 4 minutes long?
Even the other people who are in the back had more screentime than Joy .
Damn Joy fans are getting as bad as Blackpink's solo fans, stop being so damn negative.
heavy editing in her teasers, messing up the audio, delaying her teaser, and now giving her a very short screentime and cutting her parts in the mv lol we have every right to get mad cause sm is obviously sabotaging her. if you don't know anything just shut up lol
Yeri getting the initial part of the bridge didnt make sense, I'm irene biased, but that part was suiting for joy, wich is something that generally happens, it demanded a more emotional vocal work and yeri was bland.
No yeri was a pleasant surprise, and she sounded great. Not everything needs to be predictable, and Yeri deserves to be noticed for her vocals for once.
keep yapping, joy doesn't need a bridge every single time
You joy Stan's seem to have turned pretty toxic..the juxtaposition of Sooyoung and her "Stan's" is truly disgusting cuz wdym a sweet, caring, funny, supportive and always cheerful and positive joy has a fandom this toxic???? Stop it.
The solo stans are definitely the biggest RV antis. 🤦
Yeri sounds great let her have her turn to shine