Same here. This song is beautiful when Brandi sings it; but, as a duet with the woman she wrote it for who just so happens to have an amazing voice herself? Whoa, absolutely gorgeous!
I’ve only discovered Brandi in the last year or so! Where have I been! She’s way high up on my favorites list! The crystal, pure tone mixed with the grit, gravel & breaks make the perfect voice! ❤
Relationship goals... find yourself someone who looks at you how Brandi and Catherine look at each other throughout this video 😍 Been following you since my teens 15ish years ago. In 2009 2 of my friends from school killed themselves then a few years later another 3 in one year. It was absolutely brutal but your music and particularly your song That Year, weirdly also released in 2009, really helped me through it all. Thank you for all of the amazing music you have shared with us all over the years ❤
I have stage 4 cancer. Sometimes I have sever anxiety attacks and my go to music that will bring me back off the ledge is Brandi Carlile. It could be 1 song or 10. However long it takes for her exquisitely beautiful voice to calm me. From one woman in Seattle to another - Thank you Brandi!
Bless you...what you wrote, touched my heart...i will say prayers for your peace and comfort. Your story isnt over until Jesus calls you home. No man can determine that. ❤
I would so love to listen to a whole album with the two of you singing together!! Your voices are so smooth and beautiful together, and your chemistry is so sweet to watch!! What do you think? ❤❤
I live on the island of Newfoundland in Canada, and our province is also called "The Rock". I know your song isnt about us, but wow, it captures the island. We even have/had a band called Great Big Sea with Alan Doyle as the lead singer. I love this song. I love your eclectic music and that you dont stick to one genre of music. The mark of a true & talented artist. And your wife voice is WOW! Ive added this to my youtube music list along with many other songs by you. Thank you for the music!
You will never know how your music has ministered to my entire family, dear, dear Brandi! I'm telling the entire universe. Some people's truth expressed so beautifully and artistically is more powerful than anything! Though I'm crying, I feel like I am part of a very big and beautiful network!
Bush hall, London, 2011 🙌 almost blew off the blooming roof, nevermind the doors. With that voice. You could see her happiness about something bouncing through. Guess that was Catherine. 🥰😊
This Minnesotan was so happy to see you guys for the second time recently, this time in Fargo❤ Last summer in St. Paul, I learned of the power of Brandi Carlile & Co's live performance, when I unexpectedly burst into tears during "Creep"😭 Never stop!!🤘🏼🎸
Breathtaking. I'm crying. This is a beautiful beautiful performance of a masterful piece of songwriting. I'm going to play this for my partner. I'm floored.
I adore you MissBrandi! The first time I heard you sing was on SNL and it was Right on Time. I was gobsmacked! I'm a retired professional singer. COPD robbed me of my ability to sing in public but I still sing in private, because that makes me feel human. Your voice and your personality and your marriage is an inspiration. Every time I hear you I get goosebumps! This song and your lovely wife with you totally made my day today! Thank you, you magnificent woman for sharing your angelic and inspirational voice with us! I am your number 1 fan in 🇨🇦 💖🫂
Every bit of the In the Canyon Haze IMAX prrformance was exquisite. The sound and video production, the visuals, the vibe and, of course, the music was perfection! 💕
Hi, I'm in Ireland. My understanding of IMAX is that it's a cinema type service? Was this concert played at IMAX theatres in the States or did IMAX sponsor the event? We screen ballet, royal Shakespeare performances, international opera in our cinemas here - just in case this is a weird question, that's the context! 😊 love from Ireland ☘️
I've only recently discovered Brandi Carlisle and BOOM I just love your voice and music. Thank you so much. This song I could listen to on repeat all day. Honest and genuine. Love the harmonies
Made my day today watching and listening to you all sing and entertain your fans. Thank you both, for showing your love, and giving us your talent. You grace our hearts. thank you. Saw you at Freeman Stage this summer in the falling rain, and we loved it even in the rain! Thank you all.
Last year when I was going through such bad health issues I considered ending my life, this song reminded me I could sing. This song reminded me there was beauty in this world and this life, even through pain. This song helped keep me alive.
My day is not complete until I here you lovely ladles sing this song ❤ 💕 It's so beautiful 😍 Love you both. Catherine had no idea you were sucj a beautiful singer. Your a good match 👏
Thanks for sharing such a great video. I really wanted to watch this live stream in real time. But, since I am in Japan, I couldn't. In the future, I need to fly back to the USA to see you guys.
Watched this video 5:00 I could listen to this all day! Catherine has a beautiful voice we need to hear more songs from her maybe a solo? Your both truly amazing artists keep sharing your gift with us we appreciated you! ❤😊
For Rockstar there's no another best thing with out rock,and for the music lover everything they heard is music,for mrs.brandi you're the new old Rockstar I love you❤❤❤❤❤
Amazing, thank you for showing me which direction you have always showed me. From the time I saw you at Kent Stage years ago to now. Your stories with your book have been my stories.. Thank you for being my out let💖
For years, I didn’t know Catherine could even sing, let alone so beautifully❤
Same! I watched a video of them messing about singing and heard her voice recently and thought wow, great set of pipes on her!
Same here. This song is beautiful when Brandi sings it; but, as a duet with the woman she wrote it for who just so happens to have an amazing voice herself? Whoa, absolutely gorgeous!
I’m just jealous of her guitar…. Very jealous
You know it's good when it makes you bawl but you still, REPEATEDLY, listen.
I’ve only discovered Brandi in the last year or so! Where have I been! She’s way high up on my favorites list!
The crystal, pure tone mixed with the grit, gravel & breaks make the perfect voice! ❤
Relationship goals... find yourself someone who looks at you how Brandi and Catherine look at each other throughout this video 😍 Been following you since my teens 15ish years ago. In 2009 2 of my friends from school killed themselves then a few years later another 3 in one year. It was absolutely brutal but your music and particularly your song That Year, weirdly also released in 2009, really helped me through it all. Thank you for all of the amazing music you have shared with us all over the years ❤
Hope the music helps you get through everything you have been through. All the best.
🖤
💞
🤢🤢🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
Charles you simp, back in the basement😂 feeding time at the zoo.
So beautiful the way they look at each other.
We really need an album for all the songs these two covered.
I have stage 4 cancer. Sometimes I have sever anxiety attacks and my go to music that will bring me back off the ledge is Brandi Carlile. It could be 1 song or 10. However long it takes for her exquisitely beautiful voice to calm me. From one woman in Seattle to another - Thank you Brandi!
Bless you...what you wrote, touched my heart...i will say prayers for your peace and comfort. Your story isnt over until Jesus calls you home. No man can determine that. ❤
I am so sorry for your illness. Music has always saved me. I don’t usually comment on this but you are in my prayers!
TRY cannibis oil
I'm sorry to hear this.
Music does help soothe the soul. Peace to you
Health and healing to you. Thank you for sharing. ❤️❤️
Brandi has one of the best voices in the history of recorded music, but I'm really impressed by Catherine's crystal clear harmony!
I think so too!
I have loved Brandi for many years but their voices together are heavenly. Ahhhhh
I would so love to listen to a whole album with the two of you singing together!! Your voices are so smooth and beautiful together, and your chemistry is so sweet to watch!! What do you think? ❤❤
I live on the island of Newfoundland in Canada, and our province is also called "The Rock". I know your song isnt about us, but wow, it captures the island. We even have/had a band called Great Big Sea with Alan Doyle as the lead singer. I love this song. I love your eclectic music and that you dont stick to one genre of music. The mark of a true & talented artist. And your wife voice is WOW! Ive added this to my youtube music list along with many other songs by you. Thank you for the music!
Newfies FTW!!! My dad’s bio mom was from St John’s! ❤
Wow! I love your comment! Big big hugs 🫂 🤗 and love from your neighbor in CB NS 🇨🇦
Beautiful couple beautiful song. ❤
There's no way I could express how much I love this song. Even more after watching you two sing it together. Thanks.
You will never know how your music has ministered to my entire family, dear, dear Brandi! I'm telling the entire universe. Some people's truth expressed so beautifully and artistically is more powerful than anything! Though I'm crying, I feel like I am part of a very big and beautiful network!
I wish they'd do an entire album together.
This is so dang adorable. 🥰
Bush hall, London, 2011 🙌 almost blew off the blooming roof, nevermind the doors. With that voice. You could see her happiness about something bouncing through. Guess that was Catherine. 🥰😊
I thought you “meowed” in your garden, and I preferred it, but I still absolutely love this and anything with you two in it
How good do these two beautiful people sound together 😊 Amazing to see Katherine coming into her own musicianship - shes goot skills y'all !! ❤
I get to see her in a week at Interlochen. Man, I'm so happy to finally get to see her.
Such a beautiful performance and totally joyous to see them sing and play together. ❤️
Absolutely breathtaking vocals and performance, couldn’t agree more.
So beautiful ❤️
So sweet performance and what a beautiful love and smiles :) Thank you both for this song and for this video!
My favorite version of this song
Please make a whole album together!
this song makes me cry EVERY TIME! Catherine's voice is so sweet, love you two singing together.
Love how you are SO ‘in tune’ with each other! 💜💜
This Minnesotan was so happy to see you guys for the second time recently, this time in Fargo❤ Last summer in St. Paul, I learned of the power of Brandi Carlile & Co's live performance, when I unexpectedly burst into tears during "Creep"😭 Never stop!!🤘🏼🎸
I love hearing you sing Brandi
True love always has the most beautiful harmony, doesn’t it?
Beautiful humans
Beautiful song
Beautiful melody
Love in action ❤
Breathtaking. I'm crying. This is a beautiful beautiful performance of a masterful piece of songwriting. I'm going to play this for my partner. I'm floored.
Sound so good together! love it!
The bridge floored me… gorgeous!
I could watch you two together any time!
Thank you, for sharing. I've followed you since the time you left your guitar on stage and the joyful crowd asked you to sing "Hallelujah."
I can't tell you how many times I have listened to you both singing this song. Just love it and will learn to play it.
I adore you MissBrandi! The first time I heard you sing was on SNL and it was Right on Time. I was gobsmacked! I'm a retired professional singer. COPD robbed me of my ability to sing in public but I still sing in private, because that makes me feel human. Your voice and your personality and your marriage is an inspiration. Every time I hear you I get goosebumps! This song and your lovely wife with you totally made my day today! Thank you, you magnificent woman for sharing your angelic and inspirational voice with us! I am your number 1 fan in 🇨🇦 💖🫂
Couple goals
I could listen to this song all day - thank you!!
Every bit of the In the Canyon Haze IMAX prrformance was exquisite. The sound and video production, the visuals, the vibe and, of course, the music was perfection! 💕
Hi, I'm in Ireland. My understanding of IMAX is that it's a cinema type service? Was this concert played at IMAX theatres in the States or did IMAX sponsor the event? We screen ballet, royal Shakespeare performances, international opera in our cinemas here - just in case this is a weird question, that's the context! 😊 love from Ireland ☘️
How fricken sweet!
❤ Que maravilloso es apreciar la música y disfrutar de esta, aún sin entender el idioma.
I've only recently discovered Brandi Carlisle and BOOM I just love your voice and music. Thank you so much. This song I could listen to on repeat all day. Honest and genuine. Love the harmonies
Such a beautiful couple sing a beautiful song. Thank you💜💜
WOW. STUNNED. AMAZING. Had no clue about Brandi's abilities until today. New fan right here.
Made my day today watching and listening to you all sing and entertain your fans. Thank you both, for showing your love, and giving us your talent. You grace our hearts. thank you. Saw you at Freeman Stage this summer in the falling rain, and we loved it even in the rain! Thank you all.
Last year when I was going through such bad health issues I considered ending my life, this song reminded me I could sing. This song reminded me there was beauty in this world and this life, even through pain. This song helped keep me alive.
I absolutely second every word of this. Thank you for sharing this. And… This song, the harmonies, the love-there really are no words.
Simply beautiful...
💞🌸💞🌸💞
What a beautiful song❤
I love this song so much. And perfect pairing of gentle voices❤❤
Love Love Love this song more than words💘
This is a masterpiece!
Brings a tear, and at the same time a big smile!
Beautiful 💕
this song saved my life
PS. How perfect that they dound each other ❤❤
Everything you do 8s gold because i can feel the love ❤❤ thank you
Such incredibly soulful talent.
I love this Brandi!❤
Love these beautiful ladies sing forever ❤❤
I'm working so hard to learn the lyrics and sing with you girls. This song is a beauty! I love singing the harmonies. God bless you both 😘
Sweet song 🎵 😊
So beautiful together, so natural, so in love!
Wonderful surprise to come home to this magical performance 🥰
Absolutely beautiful.
Awesome song. Great performance.
I think this is the first time ive seen Catherine. Nice duet👏
My day is not complete until I here you lovely ladles sing this song ❤ 💕 It's so beautiful 😍 Love you both. Catherine had no idea you were sucj a beautiful singer. Your a good match 👏
Thanks for sharing such a great video. I really wanted to watch this live stream in real time. But, since I am in Japan, I couldn't. In the future, I need to fly back to the USA to see you guys.
Wow. Love this!
Love is so wonderful.
Thanks for sharing with us this shiny gem. Honestly it's really heartwarming and a true comfort song for me.
Watched this video 5:00 I could listen to this all day! Catherine has a beautiful voice we need to hear more songs from her maybe a solo? Your both truly amazing artists keep sharing your gift with us we appreciated you! ❤😊
Gosh love this song. Wish I could sing but can’t hear all the words wish I knew all the words thank u for a great song.
Looove you girls 💖💖 I love the harmonies!
tiny tears with joy and eager antisipation. . . . . !!!!!!!! 🔥🔥🔥
Blessings to Your Family.
This is Beautiful Love...❤😊🌎✌❤ 🙏
Beautiful.
BEAUTIFOUL!!!👏👏👏👏👏👏
My GAWD! Whenever I see a notification from you I know it's just going to make me feel better. Your voices are so beautiful❤❤❤
Wow!
#BrandiCarlile #CatherineCarlile Your harmony is beautiful. You sound wonderful together 😊❤😊❤🎸
Wow. What a song. Can't get enuff. 🌹
This must be the best music video clip available on UA-cam... :-) LOVE IT!
Thank you so much for sharing this ❤️
Excelentes composiciones. Brandi tu vida es un ejemplo de amor.
amazing
*LOVELY* *!!*
A wonderful song and wonderful voices!!!❤
J’adoooore ☄️🎸🎼🪩❤❤
Saw Brandi last year in Ohio for our daughters’ first concert. Best vocal performance of any concert I’ve ever seen.
Ellas son maravillosas. La canción es tan hermosa.
Someone to harmonise with... a treasure*
Couple goals❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Absolutely exquisite.
Nice to meet you both.
Beautiful song 🫶
Holy moly! Let me grab my composure 😊 That's was breathing! Brought me to tears the harmonies were so tight. True love 💘 Awesome backup boys!
For Rockstar there's no another best thing with out rock,and for the music lover everything they heard is music,for mrs.brandi you're the new old Rockstar I love you❤❤❤❤❤
💞Beautiful! 💞
so wonderful ❤
You have a beautiful voice it's nice to meet you.
Amazing, thank you for showing me which direction you have always showed me. From the time I saw you at Kent Stage years ago to now. Your stories with your book have been my stories.. Thank you for being my out let💖
Beautiful!!