What Is The Biggest Faultline Of Pakistan I Pashtuns of Pakistan Afghanistan I Tilak Devasher I Aadi

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 67

  • @berghoff2593
    @berghoff2593 Рік тому +10

    Pashtun nation should be recognized by UNO.

  • @rohan12395
    @rohan12395 Рік тому +3

    Gandhis betrayal with gaffar khan should be taught in schools

  • @RashadMunawar-q8u
    @RashadMunawar-q8u 8 місяців тому +1

    Most of the Pashtun live in Islamabad, Karachi, Lahore, Faisalabad, Multan, Peshawar and other parts of Pakistan. We Pashtun love 💕😘 the Land wherever we live and defend our homeland with our blood.

  • @RashadMunawar-q8u
    @RashadMunawar-q8u 8 місяців тому +1

    I am Pashtun by caste and Love 💕😘💕 Afghanistan and Pakistan both with the core of my heart ❤️. Pashtun living in Pakistan are almost double Pashtun as compared to Afghanistan. Pashtun can never forget that India equipped Northern Alliance against Pashtun of Pakistan and Afghanistan.

  • @deenamitrataduri8731
    @deenamitrataduri8731 Рік тому +4

    Great learning session. Thank you both of you for bringing this up. Looking for to more information on the topic. Good work!!

  • @tajnawab
    @tajnawab Рік тому +2

    Respect salaam namaste to host guest and viewers and especially Sir Tilak Devasher.

  • @surendrabarsode8959
    @surendrabarsode8959 Рік тому +2

    Wonderful session!! However, a few doubts 1- When Pak Army has many Pashtuns and in general Pakistan has Pashtun population, how is that Pashtun psyche and traditions are not known to Pak Army? Tilak mentions Pak Punjabi officers messing up with Afghans but they could always rely on their Pashtun members. 2- What is it that will resolve the Durand Line issue? Pak is not going to up NWFP under any circumstances!! 3- Can India fish into troubled waters (or mountains!) and offer a deal to Taliban under which India helps it secure NWFP and Taliban recognizes J&K as integral part of India? Is this deal worth it? We may not want POK but we certain need to have physical possession of GB for obvious strategic reasons! Otherwise, knowing Pashtun history and traditions by itself has no strategic relevance for us.

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 Рік тому +1

    There r more books in urdu .
    He has not been on ground to research .
    Tell him to go.

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 Рік тому

    Pl listen to Mr. Ghani (?) IN CONVERSATION WITH Mr. Imtiaz Gul .He was the Head of intelligence.

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 Рік тому

    V v ordinary opinions .
    Lots of people in Pakistan know it.At least his target audience.
    What great to learn.
    It's all in muslim history in Indo Pak .
    He should promote friendship between India and Pakistan.
    V v wrong .so many Afghan sources.
    I will post it on Twitter.
    Lot lots of books translated into urdu from Afghani ot Pushto or Persian sources.
    Sorry.No great.
    What remarks at the end by host .
    Laughable. It's like .........world.

  • @sanjeevnayyar7063
    @sanjeevnayyar7063 Рік тому +7

    Raj kapoor family were hindu pastlhtuns

    • @TheGuruNetOn
      @TheGuruNetOn Рік тому +2

      As per Wikipedia :
      "Raj Kapoor was born as Shrishti Nath Kapoor on 14 December 1924 at Kapoor Haveli, a large house then owned by his grandfather in the Qissa Khwani Bazaar neighborhood of Peshawar, British India into a Punjabi Hindu family of the Kapoor clan, who belonged to the Dhai Ghar Khatri community."
      en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raj_Kapoor

    • @Vivansha_Kshatriya
      @Vivansha_Kshatriya Рік тому

      @@TheGuruNetOn Wikipedia is not to be believed 100%

    • @Striker-jg9kv
      @Striker-jg9kv Рік тому +1

      There is nothing like hindu pashtuns. The begairat behaya Kapoors of dalla karachiwood can start claiming to be hindu or Mongolian if they can make money out of it . They are simply begairat dalla converted mulla pigjabi who pimp there begairat behaya ghasti mughaliya khwateens for HALALA to further there cause . That's it

    • @Vivansha_Kshatriya
      @Vivansha_Kshatriya Рік тому

      @@Striker-jg9kv ✅️absolutely ✅️ 💯 %

    • @Unknown___5
      @Unknown___5 Рік тому

      Kapoor are punjabi
      Pashtuns are iranic people

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 Рік тому

    Let me remind u .
    When we were young the elder generation used to go to Aghanistan (lundi kotal , was the biggest stop over,shopping) for pleasure .
    Perhaps u missed that era.
    V v cordial relations.
    Listen to EX P.M's Imran on present situation in Afghanistan yesterday.
    Labeled by opponents as Taliban khan ,Tilak follows them because he is bookish and has never been on the ground to really grasp the situation.

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 Рік тому

    U know he referred to a book review by Friday Times .People know the opptunist Najam Sethi.

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 Рік тому

    Marketing vigorously for his book.
    Nothing new .
    So many good books in Urdu, which I am sure he never looked at them.

  • @vivekanandadas2463
    @vivekanandadas2463 Рік тому

    A known and overt enemy is less of a danger than a covert one. I do believe Bangladesh and Bangladeshis with their demographic invasion of the Northeast pose a much greater threat to India of which very little is discussed both in national media - print and electronic and social media. The vast numbers of illegal Bangladeshis primarily in NE, WB but now spreading to every nook of the country pose threats to national security that must be addressed urgently.

  • @asadabbasmirza9519
    @asadabbasmirza9519 Рік тому

    One has to be in Pushtuns area to understand.
    V v comfortable intermingling between Afghans and Paki Pushtuns

  • @arvindnandu9580
    @arvindnandu9580 Рік тому +1

    Many of the conclusions san any logic or rational or basis..sometimes felt like the author had an understanding or theory and he looked at every possible way to join the dots to show that picture in his head..

  • @AM-SD
    @AM-SD Рік тому +1

    Good to see guests who were part of the establishment, happy to see your channel grow.

  • @prakashanvsg5784
    @prakashanvsg5784 Рік тому +1

    Bring Thilak Devasherji very often.Quite interesting. It is going to be a sharp weapon against pakis.

  • @sanjeevnayyar7063
    @sanjeevnayyar7063 Рік тому +1

    Vg topic. Also do on baluchistan n how China captured Xinjiang n Mongolia

  • @v-jayt652
    @v-jayt652 Рік тому

    This is Sanatani Lands and Pashtons are a Tribal society so they aren’t original people of these lands.
    Presumably they came from Iraq escaping Islamic onslaught.

    • @Unknown___5
      @Unknown___5 Рік тому

      No they are iranic people
      Indio-aryan land started from indus vally (punjab kashmir and sindhi) to bangal

  • @nitinbhandari220
    @nitinbhandari220 Рік тому

    How come oil well in Middle East be important when it was discovered in 60s and 70s in the formation of Indian and keeping the soviet out of equation?

    • @DEFTALKSbyAadi
      @DEFTALKSbyAadi  Рік тому

      Do watch the show on Oil done recently for context

  • @dilkaraja8743
    @dilkaraja8743 Рік тому +2

    Can this book available in hindi ?

    • @AS_7419
      @AS_7419 Рік тому

      No it's not available in Hindi

  • @apexprecitech
    @apexprecitech Рік тому +1

    I am amazed by the fluency and coherence of this narration. Not even a noticeable fumble . Great .

    • @KingKong-lb3vh
      @KingKong-lb3vh Рік тому

      you mean the typical Indian fumbles of 'anddddddddddddddd anddddddddddddduhhhhhhhhhhh' or mispronunciation of development (DEVVEL..instead of DIV-ELL....)?

  • @nitinparanjpay8130
    @nitinparanjpay8130 Рік тому

    What about STATUS OF WOMEN TILL LATE 1970 s ? So it's about TALIBANIZATION not to do with PASHTUN CULTURE.

  • @MyKarur
    @MyKarur Рік тому +1

    Brilliant Tilak. A true intellectual! Learnt a lot!

  • @jamesb9499
    @jamesb9499 Рік тому +1

    Excellent discussion. TY

  • @SandeepKumar-jj1yl
    @SandeepKumar-jj1yl Рік тому

    Happy New Year Sir to you your family and friends......
    ✨✨✨✨✨
    🎆🎆🎆🎆🎆🎆
    🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

  • @shambhuprasad8434
    @shambhuprasad8434 Рік тому

    Most educative and revealing dialogues about the pasthun ethnicity

  • @alaypatel6050
    @alaypatel6050 Рік тому

    All these analysis have no meaning when u r discussing an entity like Pak. Its not a natural entity so the prociples of a normal state dont apply to it. When an entity is created on the basis of chaos and to create chaos, how can chaos harm it. Only reason for its existance is as a hedge against india. And it will never lose its relevance as long india is there. Only way out was for india to become a strong state( financially and most importantly to industrialize ) but since its not gonna happen, dont day dream. Forces that created it, will never let it go out of existnace.

  • @navinbhatia9936
    @navinbhatia9936 Рік тому +1

    Brilliant

  • @MOHIT836
    @MOHIT836 Рік тому +3

    Sir,that was really good session. Since I had read the book a long ago and asked doubts pertaining to it in several forums,I didn't have anything to ask today,but it was a really good session. That titbit on KAG Khan wasn't known to me

  • @v-jayt652
    @v-jayt652 Рік тому

    What were Pashtuns before Islam?

    • @DEFTALKSbyAadi
      @DEFTALKSbyAadi  Рік тому

      Pashtuns only. !!

    • @Unknown___5
      @Unknown___5 Рік тому

      @M A before budism they were Zoroastrian and befor Zoroastrianism they were pagan

  • @SharadaAttili
    @SharadaAttili Рік тому +3

    What a session Aadi. I bow down to Tilak sir's work. Looking forward to the next session and how it is soon. Binge worthy.

  • @petechau6314
    @petechau6314 Рік тому +1

    Sir Pl send message to Afghanistan with request to demand two things: 1. Pakistan must pay $40 billion collected from USA; for the destruction of Afghanistan. Afghanistan wants 40 billion for reconstruction. 2. Hand over KP up to Atak.
    3. Start fragmentation of Pakistan with freedom of Baluchistan and KP .

    • @mazam2014
      @mazam2014 Рік тому

      Dreaming is good for h🥰😊😁😆ealth - when you try to get it u go to next world it.

  • @ajittripathi7353
    @ajittripathi7353 Рік тому

    ❤️🤝💯😃👍🎉🌹

  • @subhashjain4688
    @subhashjain4688 Рік тому

    Happy new year aadi.

  • @daus8436
    @daus8436 Рік тому

    👍👍

  • @saurabhdel1
    @saurabhdel1 Рік тому

    Happy new to all 🎉🎉🎉

  • @rajupayel
    @rajupayel Рік тому

    jai hind..........

  • @abba3629
    @abba3629 Рік тому +1

    2:14 "....Yearning for Peace, and Ready to Defend..." Well! Isn't that's exactly what Ukraine is doing now??

    • @apexprecitech
      @apexprecitech Рік тому

      Rather it should be " Ready to offend, waiting for the moment"

  • @Kafkaesque786
    @Kafkaesque786 Рік тому

    A great example of the problem with armchair analysts. I can guess with a fair amount of certainty that he hasnt been to suburbs of Delhi let alone Afghanistan.
    Forgot to mention Sikhs and Kashmiris as significant nations without a state.

    • @1525boy
      @1525boy Рік тому

      Sikhs and Kashmiris have in India 🇮🇳, retard.

    • @1525boy
      @1525boy Рік тому

      Sikhs and Kashmiris have India 🇮🇳.
      Troll 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰.

  • @RajIndia31415
    @RajIndia31415 Рік тому +1

    It's strange but your recent videos, including this one don't show up in your channel when one navigates to the videos section. Don't know if this channel is a target of limiting visibility.

    • @mohit-514
      @mohit-514 Рік тому +1

      Raj
      Live session shows up in live option
      While the recorded video in videos section