Those that were snapped in the blip didn’t die though; they were erased from existence, and if they didn’t exist, they couldn’t die. They weren’t in an afterlife
if they just disappeared and didnt die, why people still remember them. If they just disappeared from existence, they will just disappear and be treated like peter parker.
@@SuperZippocollector I don't think so. When people die in the MCU their soul get into an afterlife, but if they stop existing their soul also won't exist anymore. At least that's how I interpret.
Honestly it wouldn't make sense if they went to an afterlife, you would think all of them would have some recollection of being there. I think it's pretty obvious they just stopped existing which also meant their souls didn't exist either.
@@SuperZippocollectornot existing is not the same as dying, to die you have to exist first. If you are erased from existence you can’t die, you were never born.
Yeah crazy that a channel dedicated to analyzing details in popular media, actually thinks deep about details in popular media… like that’s the whole point dude. Why did you click on the video?
Did the snap kill people? I've never once seen it like that. They were all transported into the soul stone, right? Into that weird orange void that Thanos temporarily travels to to have his chat with Gamora.. They were all still alive, just trapped unconscious within the Soul Stone.. Not dead at all.
16 днів тому+6
they were erased from existence, they didn't technically die
14:00 I’m pretty sure Tony said: “kid”, he was trying to talk to Peter. Stark did entrust Peter to be the next him and probably wanted to say a few last words before going
Well I was quite chirpy when I came here but I’ve just watched endless deaths in the MCU……seeing Gamora and Nat side by side broke me again. 😢 Excuse me whilst I take myself off to swear a lot about Thanos! 🤬🤬🤬🤬
Definitely a great video but we all know what Logan meant when he said so this is what it feels like. This is what it feels like to love, be loved, and fully accept that you are part of a family.
quick question: I'm not really good at lore but weren't all the souls of the blip kept by the soul stone instead of brought into the afterlife and that's why they could return 5 years later?
The dusted didn't die. They simply ceased to exist. If they died, then it wouldn't have been a seamless transition for them. They would have recalled being ferried into the afterlife.
11:20 Technically Coulson came back through TAHITI protocol and then again and again till final resting after Season 5, Or is it ? 👀 Also 14:45 i thought it was a Reference to Yukio from The Wolverine
In various religions there is a "standby" place between "dimensions", so I'd guess that the snapped people went to the soul dimension so they didn't really die. They were just in limbo. But the rest of it, like Tony Stark it's nice fan theory but it's likely just the acting. All these asterisk are adding up.
Okay.. Just the way people got blipped.. same way God's beloved will be TAKEN in a blink of an eye 👁️ in RAPTURE. That's before the second coming of Christ. You can see that very well picturised in the movie "GATHERING". MUST WATCH IT.
The blip didnt kill people it made them vanish out of existence, if im remembering rightly never in the MCU since have they said the blip was people dying, its always that people vanished or was taken
thanos didnt kill half of life from my perspective, he said "half of life just cease to exist" i think he just snapped everyone out of existence, not dead, in limbo...
As long as you can have an escape to "Jesus is the only way", people will be ok with it. It's kind of scary to see how much evil just find a way, anyway, as long as you don't accept Jesus as your savior.
This whole take went off the rails when you ignored the fact the snapped did not pass over they were erased.. too reachy as a result and hard to humour the rest of the video sorry
I doubt they thought this far ahead
They used to, back in the day. Now they just see what's working and build up on it.
They didn’t. NR just need something to talk about
❤❤@@maverickmurphy
Exactly
NR reaching for theories 24/7 😂
Those that were snapped in the blip didn’t die though; they were erased from existence, and if they didn’t exist, they couldn’t die. They weren’t in an afterlife
Thank you
Exactly. I don't get why so many people assumed they died unless some Disney writer, exec claims this.
if they just disappeared and didnt die, why people still remember them. If they just disappeared from existence, they will just disappear and be treated like peter parker.
@@JayyLoremas erased from existence, not from history, just ceased to be, not never came to be.
Really think about it guys
Marvel definitely didn't look this far ahead but it still makes for an interesting video.
I don’t think the dusted died. I think they just stopped existing.
That is basically the same thing
@@SuperZippocollector I don't think so. When people die in the MCU their soul get into an afterlife, but if they stop existing their soul also won't exist anymore. At least that's how I interpret.
@
No, if they don’t exist, they don’t have a soul to ferry to the afterlife.
Honestly it wouldn't make sense if they went to an afterlife, you would think all of them would have some recollection of being there. I think it's pretty obvious they just stopped existing which also meant their souls didn't exist either.
@@SuperZippocollectornot existing is not the same as dying, to die you have to exist first. If you are erased from existence you can’t die, you were never born.
Yall must have some really good weed to be thinking this deep .
Needs that fasho 😂
And i need some to tolerate these wilder theories... lol.
No they just don't have an video ideas to keep pushing out. Haha
Yeah crazy that a channel dedicated to analyzing details in popular media, actually thinks deep about details in popular media… like that’s the whole point dude. Why did you click on the video?
Nah, his memory recall is too good for him to be blasted.
I dont think this counts for the snap as they disappear from existence as if they didnt exist.
if they didnt exist, why bring them back
@@kingnasirthesecondThey didn't erase everyone's memories of them.
Rocket didn't die though, well he didn't reach the afterlife. He was right at the door, but never crossed.
Just like Víctor Sueiro
Did the snap kill people? I've never once seen it like that. They were all transported into the soul stone, right? Into that weird orange void that Thanos temporarily travels to to have his chat with Gamora.. They were all still alive, just trapped unconscious within the Soul Stone.. Not dead at all.
they were erased from existence, they didn't technically die
This is a cool theory and I never contemplated it. I DEFINITELY thought maybe they were trapped in some alternate reality(cause of the stone)
Yup
The snap didn’t kill people.
The amount of work that you guys do, that never crossed Marvels mind once, is commendable. They should have yall on payroll
UA-camrs are really now advertising Viagra 🤦♂️
Most of them have been advertising with blue chew for years.Don't know where you've been
They’ve been doing that for years lol
Listen. Use that promo code. I know I will😉
Ahh, the first day! Welcome to the wonderful world of UA-cam!
LMAO💀
14:00 I’m pretty sure Tony said: “kid”, he was trying to talk to Peter. Stark did entrust Peter to be the next him and probably wanted to say a few last words before going
Loki and professor Xavier died a million times 😂😂
😂😂 fr tho
That bluechew thing came out of nowhere 😂
Right poor grandma
14:05 Thank me later
😂😂
Thank you kindly
🙏
THANK YOU
You need to wear a cape!
Thought I was on another channel for a second with this theory time reach lol
Yeah, you're thinking about things too much ..
You can also hear Tony say "ok" while he was looking off into the distance last Pepper, it could be nothing but it could also be something
It sounds like Tony is listening to someone, and he whispers o.k. before he looks back at Pepper.
Imagine Marvel's producers and screenwriters watching this and saying: "We never thought of that LOL"
Those snapped didn't die. They were stuck in the soul stone.
Now this is a fun theory!
The snap didn’t kill them. They ceased to exist.
I swear marvel executives are probably watching every one of y’all’s videos
here comes the filler videos with stupid theories until the next Marvel project
Stop watching
The good news is that you don’t have to watch it.
Then why even click on the video
EXACTLY
The Mind Stone imbued him with a mind... Not a soul... That would be the soul stone
I just so happend to just finished re watching endgame still making me cry years later
The exact moment? I’m pretty sure it was when he died. Shouldn’t take 16 minutes for that
Really trying to make us cry with 14:00
Not an episode LEGITIMATELY sponsored by bluechew
How many cakes did that blue promo take? That’s hilarious.
Well I was quite chirpy when I came here but I’ve just watched endless deaths in the MCU……seeing Gamora and Nat side by side broke me again. 😢
Excuse me whilst I take myself off to swear a lot about Thanos! 🤬🤬🤬🤬
You are so right for that, I will also swear at Billy even thouh i love him but why WHY DID THEY HAVE TO KILL OFF LILLIA😭😭
How is a extra 13.4 out of 106.6 vs 120 per minute apocalyptically higher?
I am gettig flashbacks to the "Exact moment Kang killed..series"
Definitely a great video but we all know what Logan meant when he said so this is what it feels like. This is what it feels like to love, be loved, and fully accept that you are part of a family.
10:08 now this is what we need in "WHAT IF"?!
NewRockStars became Taker’s podcast lol!
I love all NR videos, the research they do and the passion they have…. But this one feels like a bit of a stretch
Omfg i was just thinking wtf was he looking at a few hours ago duuudeee
7:46. Shows Marc Spector, says Steven Grant being in the Field of Reeds.
I love your channel and I think you’re one of the coolest guys in the world but, with all respect, how could you know this for a fact
love this!
heres another really big question and possible plot hole. Would infinity war loki be in valhalla or Hel?
I’ve been wondering that too
Logan was talking about the feeling of being a parent.
Natasha & Gamora didn't make it to an afterlife, their souls were traded for the soul stone.
9:33 That is exactly what I was thinking…
And quite frankly, I would pay to see that scene filmed by Marvel!
quick question: I'm not really good at lore but weren't all the souls of the blip kept by the soul stone instead of brought into the afterlife and that's why they could return 5 years later?
The dusted didn't die. They simply ceased to exist. If they died, then it wouldn't have been a seamless transition for them. They would have recalled being ferried into the afterlife.
Eon was replaced by Epoch.
u are the best!
11:20 Technically Coulson came back through TAHITI protocol and then again and again till final resting after Season 5, Or is it ? 👀
Also 14:45 i thought it was a Reference to Yukio from The Wolverine
In various religions there is a "standby" place between "dimensions", so I'd guess that the snapped people went to the soul dimension so they didn't really die. They were just in limbo. But the rest of it, like Tony Stark it's nice fan theory but it's likely just the acting. All these asterisk are adding up.
u milking that tony stark looking over LMAO
This was AMAZING!! 😍😍😍
Please do tenet
Do what.? And why.?
They did, back when it came out.
oh great here comes deadpool
You have to round up on the numbers of deaths per minute cause maybe 105 is all we know about…
oh phoque... westview was Visions afterlife.... damn.... 💥
Is anyone going to talk about the blue chew part of the video 🤨🤫🧏♀️
But I thought that the people who got dusted didn’t actually “die” but more so “erased” and placed some where else.
So you’re telling me doing well she’s doing the exact same job as the messenger God Hermes
REACHING AS ALWAYS
Lol this is such a reach... gotta get the clicks though I guess
Okay..
Just the way people got blipped.. same way God's beloved will be TAKEN in a blink of an eye 👁️ in RAPTURE.
That's before the second coming of Christ.
You can see that very well picturised in the movie "GATHERING".
MUST WATCH IT.
Nah, , moonknighr characters were not and so was asgardians
The blip didnt kill people it made them vanish out of existence, if im remembering rightly never in the MCU since have they said the blip was people dying, its always that people vanished or was taken
In the medical field, we call that the “1000 mile stare”
Thanx for the Blue Chew Discount Code 😜
None of the people snapped out of existence, died. They just ceased to exist.
A lot of these theories are feeling very desperate.
Can we truly conclude that the snap was a moment where everyone died?
Is this confirmed or?? Like???
Not confirmed, just a theory
this is a next level of overthinking
I think, in the MCU, Thanos' snap didn't kill anyone; they were erased from existence.
*Samwise holding Frodo* REEEEEEEEEAAAAACHHHHHH
So where did those who were “blipped” go then? if they didn’t die? another void somewhere?
I feel like the snap was half the people "simply cease to exist" so i wouldn't say they actually died
I don't think the people that were dusted died. I think they just stopped existing.
Reaching as usual
He was fried, that’s what he was looking at lmao, It’s not that deep.
thanos didnt kill half of life from my perspective, he said "half of life just cease to exist" i think he just snapped everyone out of existence, not dead, in limbo...
Personally i feel like being erased from existance and actually dying should be to separate things
Why would you say Nicholas scratch isn't a witch? Cause he is in the comics
what about wong he died and was brought back by the time stone
Okay, y'all just out of real ideas now😂
Your not doing Superman and Lois s4????
this is such a stretch but we stan
Does getting dusted by The Snap count as dying?
As long as you can have an escape to "Jesus is the only way", people will be ok with it. It's kind of scary to see how much evil just find a way, anyway, as long as you don't accept Jesus as your savior.
I wonder what Alice's afterlife looked like
I respect your channel and all, but this is taking it too far dude, dial it down a notch
Just let Tony rest bruh🙏🏻😭
This whole take went off the rails when you ignored the fact the snapped did not pass over they were erased.. too reachy as a result and hard to humour the rest of the video sorry
Dusted people arent dead, thats my theory, they just ceased to exist, and no, its not the same as dying.
Maybe the scars/burns on Tony's face in Endgame from snapping the gauntlet are the disfigurement Dr Doom wants to hide
I just today learnt about Maria Hill dying I stopped watching secret invasion after the first episode because it was so baf
I am just flat not going to watch this one.
Hello there
What’s death’s role with zombies?
I think getting dusted doesn't count as dying