Still to this day thinking about Longtail makes my stomach churn... its so cruel that they stuck him in the elders den. He could have learned to do things without sight, had they given him a chance.
Exactly. He's still very young if you think about it. He's only a month older than graystripe (and maybe firestar depending on his age. Presumably the same though.) Edit in 2024- it took me years of rereading to realize... he isn't a month older. More like 7 months older. When we meet Longtail, graypaw mentioned he had only been a warrior for a moon. (maybe 2.)
Thank you for bringing this up! Because we never knew if Longtail got another apprentice after swiftpaw (Swiftpaw was actually beyond the age of an apprentice when he died from the dogs) And even though we didn't get to see it Longtail had to change a lot to accept Firestar as leader, so seeing him get treated like this in between the arcs is so.. 😞
@shyscorpio5463 I'm just hoping Longtail made the decision himself and wasn't forced into the elders den... it's really sad, though. I think Longtail deserved more. He could have ended up deputy eventually, honestly.
Starting this after finishing the first 3 arcs - kicking myself for not reading this right after i finished the first, but now i’m crying at Brightheart being pregnant when i just finished Whitewing giving birth and i’m EMOTIONAL
@@pikathemimikyu6655I liked him in Power of Three, ignoring Outcast when he's trying so hard to push clan customs onto the Tribe. He was such a supportive and caring dad.
1:05:55 - Even when he had lost his last life, the great oaks would still be here. One for each clan, until his name had been long forgotten. Why was that so sad, They wont be there. They were cut down.
This is the first warriors book I read 😅 now that I've read most of the first 4 arcs (I finished 1-3 but now I'm on the end of book 4 of omen of the stars. I did finish arc 5 completely but it doesn't really need any of the previous books to make sense since it's an origin arc.) Everything in it makes sense.
My favorite book in the entire series. 🔥Firestar is amazing in this. So glad to have read this before starting on a New Prophecy back then because it fits perfectly in between.
"could there be another place for cold-hearted cats who had been ready to use the warrior code for their own dark ambitions?" *YES* spoilers!!!! It's called the place of no stars or the dark forest
Reading this straight after darkest hour. Not sure if that's better than going to midnight but idk hope it's ok 🤷♀️ehhhh idk what's going on 😭😭 what boon should I dooo!!??
Only 210 likes and 1.29k subscribers??? You are so underrated! You work so hard on each video, literally reading for a hour and risking losing your voice!
My thoughts/theories/musings throughout the book! ^w^ (Spoilers for this and previous books in publishing order! So up to the first book of power of three potentially ^^) 0:00 (7/9/23 19.51) -i have no clue what to expect XD -i think i heard it's set before TNP 2:25 -skyclan? -ok ok I've heard of it before, spoilers -_- -i thought it'd only appear later though XD -That's why the names are so confoosing 10:30 -oh wow -rip skyclan 17:30 -lol bramblewclaw will have to struggle with tigerstar yet XD -actually i wonder why firestar also gave him the -claw name ending 21:08 -skyclan ghost? 45:18 (11/9/23) -firestar, bro, you always had prophetic dreams, seriously buddy 47:18 -nooo that's the longtail backstory! :( -i was so confused in TNP because they never explained it properly until a friend told me lol -but like that's sad :( 1:00:17 -so nice seeing all the older (dead) cats :3 -and I still don't understand why firestar gave brambleclaw the -claw suffix -like ??? Won't that just remind everyone of tigerclaw? -and it's so weird having firestar pov again XD 1:22:32 -DUN DUN DUN -yeah actually i hope starclan apologises to skyclan -that might be the main plot? Idk -also skyclan probably turned into bloodclan, riiight? 1:48:49 -smudge :DDD -tbh all i can imagine smudge as now is smudge from warrior cats animated XD -if you haven't watched it, WATCH IT, it's a masterpiece 1:57:30 -cool stuff -wonder why smudge also is haunted -don't have much to say, I'll move onto the next part! ^w^
Still to this day thinking about Longtail makes my stomach churn... its so cruel that they stuck him in the elders den. He could have learned to do things without sight, had they given him a chance.
Exactly. He's still very young if you think about it. He's only a month older than graystripe (and maybe firestar depending on his age. Presumably the same though.)
Edit in 2024- it took me years of rereading to realize... he isn't a month older. More like 7 months older. When we meet Longtail, graypaw mentioned he had only been a warrior for a moon. (maybe 2.)
Thank you for bringing this up!
Because we never knew if Longtail got another apprentice after swiftpaw (Swiftpaw was actually beyond the age of an apprentice when he died from the dogs)
And even though we didn't get to see it Longtail had to change a lot to accept Firestar as leader, so seeing him get treated like this in between the arcs is so.. 😞
@shyscorpio5463 I'm just hoping Longtail made the decision himself and wasn't forced into the elders den... it's really sad, though. I think Longtail deserved more. He could have ended up deputy eventually, honestly.
@@pikathemimikyu6655 Either him, Dustpelt, or Brackenfur would've been better deupty's
@shyscorpio5463 yeah, than Graystripe 😭 let's be honest, he was not deputy material. Firestar was so biased.
“Are you mouse brained?!!? You’re telling me sky clan had to leave because there weren’t enough trees!!!?? 😂😂
Time stamp?
I love how Graystripe has a lisp
Starting this after finishing the first 3 arcs - kicking myself for not reading this right after i finished the first, but now i’m crying at Brightheart being pregnant when i just finished Whitewing giving birth and i’m EMOTIONAL
At 1:03:30 Leopard star said boat but in arc two they don’t know where the boat is until Daisy tells them they just called them water monsters.
What are you talking about about? I don't remember boats or Daisy being involved in this super edition
@@JosiahFickinger Exactly. It happens after. So they should have no idea they're really called boats.
Mousefur on dawn potrol? I miss it 😭
So refreshing to remember when brambleclaw was once an enjoyable character
The Prophecies Begin Brambleclaw was a cool guy. It all went down hill during The New Prophecy and beyond.
@@pikathemimikyu6655I liked him in Power of Three, ignoring Outcast when he's trying so hard to push clan customs onto the Tribe. He was such a supportive and caring dad.
So annoying how people stuff brambleclaw into literally everything
So true
1:05:55 - Even when he had lost his last life, the great oaks would still be here. One for each clan, until his name had been long forgotten.
Why was that so sad, They wont be there. They were cut down.
THANK YOUUU FOR UPLOADING THIS I COULDNT FIND IT
This is the first warriors book I read 😅 now that I've read most of the first 4 arcs (I finished 1-3 but now I'm on the end of book 4 of omen of the stars. I did finish arc 5 completely but it doesn't really need any of the previous books to make sense since it's an origin arc.) Everything in it makes sense.
THEY LITTERLY SAID OK LONG TAIL YOUR DONE ELDERS DEN FOR U
59:30 "you are?" "So am i!"
My favorite book in the entire series. 🔥Firestar is amazing in this. So glad to have read this before starting on a New Prophecy back then because it fits perfectly in between.
"could there be another place for cold-hearted cats who had been ready to use the warrior code for their own dark ambitions?"
*YES*
spoilers!!!!
It's called the place of no stars or the dark forest
bookmark for me!!
37:05
btw if you see this remember me to come back here!!
Do you remember the rainnnnnnnnn
@@alvinmitchell7468rainnnn~~~~~
I was looking for hours and after I finish the book myslef I found this😢😢
nice profile
Sorry to hear you didn't find it before 🙁or was it not uploaded yet?🤔 Hopefully the others will be avilable for you when you need them.
Reading this straight after darkest hour. Not sure if that's better than going to midnight but idk hope it's ok 🤷♀️ehhhh idk what's going on 😭😭 what boon should I dooo!!??
You can look at wekapipidi for info but you actually should be on fire stars quest wich is good
Only 210 likes and 1.29k subscribers??? You are so underrated! You work so hard on each video, literally reading for a hour and risking losing your voice!
These are just reuploads of the official audio readings
I got a commercial for this about this kid singing and she’s like my talent is singing it’s not it’s really not…
Bookmark one:44:44
Sameeeeeee
I had a oc called swift star I didn’t know a cat had that name until now
Bookmark one: 46:00. also Firestar being hunted by starclan/skyclan lol
😢:
10:03 Idk who these two are but
First series and this one are the only ones worth reading
My thoughts/theories/musings throughout the book! ^w^
(Spoilers for this and previous books in publishing order! So up to the first book of power of three potentially ^^)
0:00 (7/9/23 19.51)
-i have no clue what to expect XD
-i think i heard it's set before TNP
2:25
-skyclan?
-ok ok I've heard of it before, spoilers -_-
-i thought it'd only appear later though XD
-That's why the names are so confoosing
10:30
-oh wow
-rip skyclan
17:30
-lol bramblewclaw will have to struggle with tigerstar yet XD
-actually i wonder why firestar also gave him the -claw name ending
21:08
-skyclan ghost?
45:18 (11/9/23)
-firestar, bro, you always had prophetic dreams, seriously buddy
47:18
-nooo that's the longtail backstory! :(
-i was so confused in TNP because they never explained it properly until a friend told me lol
-but like that's sad :(
1:00:17
-so nice seeing all the older (dead) cats :3
-and I still don't understand why firestar gave brambleclaw the -claw suffix
-like ??? Won't that just remind everyone of tigerclaw?
-and it's so weird having firestar pov again XD
1:22:32
-DUN DUN DUN
-yeah actually i hope starclan apologises to skyclan
-that might be the main plot? Idk
-also skyclan probably turned into bloodclan, riiight?
1:48:49
-smudge :DDD
-tbh all i can imagine smudge as now is smudge from warrior cats animated XD
-if you haven't watched it, WATCH IT, it's a masterpiece
1:57:30
-cool stuff
-wonder why smudge also is haunted
-don't have much to say, I'll move onto the next part! ^w^
for 17:30
firestar explained that it was so bramble wouild be accepted by the clan, kinda bad try
1:17:15 third book mark
Did sand storm had kits in this book?
BOOK MARKSSSS
27:45
1:44:01
1:07:16 Second Bookmark
1:05:48 liked this quote :)
12:47 bookmark
B00kmark 7:58
13:12
You only got 13 minutes into it?
1:15:14 bookmark
18:37
Bookmarks: 1:00:03
1:01:16 saving where I was
Book mark: 1:36:13.
Bookmark: 1:39:36
1:03:36 how do they know what boats r tho
1:48:46 smudge noo
1:14:14
27:13
26:19
30:31
8:00
Sucks brambles voice style is the exact same as graystripe
random comment because I’m bored.
1:22:27
54:59
28:05
1:38:01
45:15
1:13:29
1:04:01
1:12:48
18:07