What Dushyanth says is right. No one is telling don't learn or I will not teach you classical music if you are not a Brahmin. What about Yesudas Sir who learned and performed karnatic music with immense appreciation. Vinayam is necessery where there is Vidya. I didn't know TMK until this controversy. So. TMK pl work hard for the betterment of Karnatic music and any sort of music especially.
Why are you taking Yesudas example... How many kacheris has done alongside so called bragmins..... You should only ask him what discrimination he faced ... So. Shut up
TMK's achievements are corrupting Carnatic style music and bringing discredit to many doyens and Vaaggeyakaras. He must be having his own larger political ambitions and hopes to achieve them in his own style ably supported by such awards.
I fully agree with the sentiments expressed by Dushyanth Sridhar. I am an atheist and not his fan/follower. I am of the firm view that Ramaswamy Naicker was a third rate person who thought that the only way to destroy Sanatana Dharma was by destroying the Brahmin community. Nobody has the right to INSULT the Religious beliefs of others.
Carnatic fraternity has been insulted. It is not Music Academy anymore. It is Periyar Thidal. Let all Carnatic vidwans and rasikas boycott events in the Music Academy.
Well expressed, Vid. Dushyanth Sridhar🙏🏼 There was a time TMK was my favorite, listening over and over for instance to his rendering of the Simhendramadhyamam composition 'Ninne Nammithi' by Vid. Mys. Vasudevacharya. But over time, TMK seems to have mysteriously turned full circle, from being a Bhakta once, now to mud slinging Carnatic Sahityas of great composers. In Kaliyuga, it's said devotional singing is the route to reach God Himself. The music academy would do well to know one cannot reward Peter for robbing to pay Paul!
What reforms did he accomplish just like a typical leftist just talking about and do nothing he just demonise Brahmins and call Brahmins all kinds of names is not justified. I totally agree with you Dushyant ji.
What intelligence.. what clarity… what a grounded stance. This is what real Bhakti and knowledge brings… that’s who we term a Brahmin. Padavandanas sir!!🙏🙏🙏🙏
As a true reforner, not just boasting of reformity or inclusiveness in words, i am.asking if TMK in these 10.years of such mere talking, has brought onto his stage atleast 2 tambura artists from oorrur kuppam???? Leave alone accompaniments . When he has not even done that successfully , doesnt it show that he is speaking with political ahenda and not true to his conscience?
I really appreciate Dushyanth Shridhar for taking this bold, responsible and sensible stand. Iam sure if more and more people come together for the noble cause of boycotting T M Krishna, he will soon be erased from public memory. Getting fame through the great vagyekarakas of carnatic music and conveniently villifying them to get a magsaysay and playing to the gallery and N Ram is what he is all about. A person with hardly any integrity or dignity should be shown the door.
That guy was /is against the construction of Ram mandir at Ayodhya. Most pathetic part some /few / Brahmins with a political bias supporting him. It is hard to understand the logic. Is everything boils down to money?
One doubt. Do they announce the Sangita Kalanidhi Award so early every year. Or the "secular" "The Hindu" group wants to create a nuisance before elections. Giving an opprtunity to TN govt to interfere
I wish he should be respected with Chappal Garland. He deserves only thst as honour. TMK sold out to DMK. Shame on him to to shamelessly receive award. In fact he should decently withdraw or will be put to shame. Our Hinduism cumture heritage, it's discipline us utmost important.
As a matter of fact he himself looks like a perfect villen as he has proved it several times. But in kaliyuga all these things are bound to happen. persons who don't deserve will adorn the chairs & people who don't deserve will get the awards & rewards. Parodox of life....! What to do....shame,.,.
100 % it is political pressure for this , a institution,,,built on righteous,,ethic,,principle,, decency,,decorum,,,has buckled,,by political power. Come on M/s Murali & co ,,answer ,,logically ethically,,,consciously ( if U have) for cranky,,lunatic half baked,,with the attributes of ‘ mental ‘ not performed for @ 8 years in season,,, how he is selected .????? Is there some competent ,,strong good Advocate to move a appropriate case against this controversy ????
Many comments are made without fully listening to the points being made by the speaker. Music has various genres. Classical CARNATIC MUSIC is about DIVINITY . It's sacred to Indians just like compositions of Vach, Beethoven...in Western classical. BTW: Why no one dare attempt reforms on various practices of Abhamic faiths.
Oh! I made the same point too, trying to explain carnatic music's nature and hertiage value. We are being called names for the same. Who stopped anyone from protecting villu pattu, nagaswaram and so forth? These so called TMK and EVR supporters, just find an opportunity to hurt Brahmins, hindu sentiments, its cultural value in any form and paint caste to the issue to politicize it. But I'm glad that atleast now, we don't sit back and look for someone else to speak for us. Its time we RAISE.
Why is Krishna awarded now. It is evident. Such singers if they want to sing Periyars song let them but not on a stage where the singers praise the Gods.
@@sandeep15299nobody is asking him to sing in another way..but just the place where he sings matters ..nobody wants to hear about a person who insulted their sentiments..u may not be believing Hinduism or it’s gods,but u have no rights to insult others beliefs
@@nandhinin9263 So you all powerful people will decide what, where and how he sings? Can you show me where there is no God? Just because someone does not agree with such conceited and arrogant behavior does not mean they don't believe in Hinduism. The fact that you are all so obsessed with Gods shows that you do not know much about Hinduism. Your behavior is more in line with Abrahamic thinking.
@@sandeep15299 ha ha..here the powerful ppl r the ones who are affiliated to some party ..just like how TMK who had disrespected the whole meaning of Carnatic music got through his influence..and it’s high time he s shown the right place..he insulted lord Rama and that’s hurting the sentiments of ppl who follow ..not the seculars like you who dt even know what it means when ur beliefs are mocked …u always connect everything with Brahmins..tats how u r all trained ..if u talk the same way abt Islam or Christianity everyone will oppose together,unfortunately tat unity is not there as among Hindus there is secular ones who r brainwashed
You have every right to peacefully protest. TMK is a stupid hater of Dharma, that's why Vidhya should be given to Eligible people. otherwise this would happen,
The award has already been tarnished when they do not consider whoever has a raised a voice against their decision. There is a lot of favoritism and lacks objectivity . Now it is all the more evident that they are political. Personally I don't wish to listen to anyone singing or performing on their stage
To all those who are witch hunting one particular community :I would request you to remember that what they have achieved in the realm of classical arts is the result of a lot of sacrifice, dedication and endless hard work. Nowhere has anybody from any other community, who is willing to put in the hard work required to gain such acumen ,been barred from doing so. By the way, I am a non- Brahmin!😊 People, be fair! Use your good sense. It is so easy to get carried away by mob fury!
MMA is Hindu Ram’s coterie. Sane music lovers should boycott MMA with immediate effect. There are umpteen honest and orthodox sabhas to perform at and get recognised by. Don’t need MMA at all.
Everyone has a right to music and sing what they want. Would be super interesting to see these ppl tolerate TM singing in other places while insulting their religion. When water gets under their own butts - then they become victims! Same crappy drama since 75 yrs. kudos to ppl who are now voicing their displeasure.
TMK earned money and fame by singing mummoorthigal keerthana, all Brahmins, and the people who have patronised his concerts in India, USA, other countries are mostly Brahmins
TMKrishna is a compassionate person. His compassion is evident... he reached out to so many under privileged people to understand their views. All those speaking against him need to think a little. The privileged people are so hurt because of TMKrishna's views. Think of the underprivileged who could not enter the temples they labored to build. TMK's views hurt you so much; but the people he's referring to were hurt physically, mentally, subconsciously for centuries and the effect that created in them is still impacting their life.
TMK is a reformer in the musical field as Aadi Sankarar and Ramanajur were in the realm of religion, who were equally despised by similar retrograde crowd that existed then and feels uneasy now. TMK will also be respected in the future for reforming this form of music that has become, in their own words, brahmin music, only to be learnt, sung by this crowd which is hopelessly lost in their backwardness of thought and existence, change and adapt if you want to survive. You have everything to lose, choice is yours. This problem is prevalent only amongst the the tamil brahmin community, not so with the brahmin community of other languages who encourage others also to take up carnatic and classical music.
This guy harps about TMK boycotting the December music season for the past several years. I only have one simple question - is there a written rule somewhere in the rulebook that says that participating in the December season is a mandatory requirement for the artiste to be considered for the award? If that is not an eligibility requirement, this guy should just shut up. There is no need to lecture us about sanatana dharma etc. Whoever this character is, he just comes across as a bitter and angry young man. God bless him. This is about an award. If the candidate meets the eligibility criteria, he/she will be considered. If the person wins, he/she wins. Plain and simple. We may disagree with a person's views/opinions. That is irrelevant. We should be able to hold our emotions in check.
TMK boycotted every December past 10 years by villainizing the whole Brahmin community as door keepers of k music which is not true. And his hatred is coming from so called periyar who put cheppal on lord Srirams Murthi. That expains his sick secular mind. Period.
It is a very shameful act by the academy for awarding this rogue, indecent, anti Hindu and anti sanatani with academy award. If music academy doesn't rescind its decision, the music lovers will not only boycott it but we will look for establishing a new academy.
Fully agree. TMK should dedicate himself to music than to cheap politics based On Religion😂 we have great vocalist , Legend Yesudas👏 who was always devoted to music. Ppl love to listen music than focusing on religion. I hate TMK😂
He is working towards democratising the beautiful art form we have towards non Brahmins. Ruikang Devi Arundale brought about similar changes making Bharatnatyam not just accessible for the Devadasi but for the Brahmins and other castes as well. Somehow when it’s done the other way there’s something wrong with it.
Finally, one person to understand what the controversy is about. The moment they take periyar's name or Rama's name they associate that this because of brahmins and caste and sanatana.
Very bad. Academy award lost its dignity after conferring accademy award to TM Krishna who is aligned with enemies of Sanathana Dharma. Dushyant and other are doing good thing by boycotting future program.
There is one rule followed accross the globe and more so visibly in Bharat , if any one resorts to Brahmin Bashing and Hindu bashing, they generally are showered with awards and Schalarships. Its sad that Academy also joined the same vagan. As such , the standards are any way coming down. If academy did not confer to the Great MDR, where do the contemporary musians stand?
What kind of cinema oriented concerts have sprung up? As such diminishing this rich culture is not enough on the screens it is now taken towards concerts!
TM Krishan stated his opinion that Carnatic music is dominated by Brahmins. I don't think he should be vilified and cancelled for stating his opinion. According to this gentleman reform needs to be done in a subtle manner so as not to offend his sensibilities. Most reform movements are only successful because some one calls out as loudly as possible about the injustices. Why are these people not being subtle about their boycott and instead shouting all over the social media. ng And who are these people do decide how and what songs he can sing or not? This boycott, cancelling, vilifying is exactly what dominant groups do and actually makes TM Krishna's point. A mature and empathetic community will actually start a dialogue to self examine and see if there is something that can be improved.
@@nandhinin9263I guess you expect complete obeisance and compliance to your dogma. Fortunately, those days are long gone. I gather he does not respect them because of their arrogance and their domineering, casteist behavior. Good for him.
We can say the same about EVR followers as they want to dominate with EVR theories which are extremely disgusting and devastating. We simply say, Shri. TMK can have his ideologies but presenting it in the carnatic music platform is not the one, for it. End of the day, it is the choice of audience as what they want to listen to but imagine a baby consuming poison served with payasam. As an adult, we just want one to be responsible because babies will never willingly consume poison. Hope you understand the metaphors.
@@sandeep15299 have U even seen them??so why shd he be respected..how much respect has evr given ??did u even know MS amma dominated anyone?If so share the proof..do you even know anybody was denied musical knowledge as they were not Brahmins?the days u had told stories and bashed Brahmins are gone..
Of course, whoever has talent will dominate and it’s obvious Brahmins dominate this field- don’t need TMK to tell that. The reasons he gives and vilifying the whole community are absurd. Non Brahmin musicians know how they got their art and are not supporting TMK. Caste prejudices are there in every community and they are slowly going away in their own due to changing times. No need to link art to caste. This fellow is just enjoying the attention of anti Brahmin hate mongering toolkit gang and feeling morally superior. An arrogant but useful idiot for the leftists.
@@vedavallirajagopalan9652My sincere submission to you is that, he is atleast voicing the unjust that others consider not worthy due to various reasons.
this is one of the “” tell tale indicators “ that Dravidian,,political,,,quid pro quo “ anti “” freedom for India “ group. Irony is when whole…nation was fighting for freedom,,even at the cost of their life.. irrespective,,of cast creed,,religion. Following the foot steps of the so called reformer,,but after learning from great “” Semmangudi “ this lunatic ,,with all unethical,,traits,,makes exceptions as “ head lines” out of arrogance,,imbibed by ignorance. ,,wants to be in “ lime light” by hurting humiliating,,,even the Guru & others,,including his parents,,perhaps repenting for such a cranky ,,crack pot. Let all have their full from of ,,,their opinion bla bla but why so called institutions,,,built by ethics,,principles,,values,,laid down by guidances,,bye - laws ,,etc be vitiated & award a wrong ,,person embodiment of Negative,,Pessimistic,,,attitude to the fine art of Carnatic music,,which is breathed,,,worshipped as “ Divine by millions of Music lovers. More for their ultimate,,surrender,,mental solace…l The so called select,,expert committee even now take a recourse,,correct the wrongs. n
Hari Om. Music Academy has gone out of its principle of flourishing music. Now it has gone into the hands of DMK . Music Academy can now change its name as DMK Stage and start engaging for DMK meeting only and not to Indian Arts and Culture.
Right from the 2000 season onwards, these awards have been issued based on popularizing the carnatic music abroad, which was used as a trump card for gaining that title. Everyone knows that this is a big lobby, partly uncovered by mee too movement. I have witnessed the musicians from the days of chembai vaidyanatha bhavatar etc., and now a days honestly the award is not even worth its paper weight. This fellow shouldn't even be allowed sing carnatic song in the first place, let alone him receiving an award. This just reinforces only one point , the dilution of standards. Nothing else.
Stalin says don't bring politics into Music in the TM Krishna matter. But let Stalin think who is bringing politics into Music by this accolade to a Periyar follower. Boycott Music Academy.
TMK is from famous family of first corrupted politician of india ttk. TTk Was charged by non other than Feros and he is joining hands with feros grandson great combination
TMKrishna is a shame on to himself. Learned luminary like Dushyant screaming about him Is a victory for TMKrishna who is a spoilt bored rich kid. My heart goes out for Dushyant. May his harbinger ring like a death knell on the adversaries.
Bhakthi is the essence of carnatic music. Carnatic music is not like rock and roll thingie with just beats. So not just Brahmins, even the conservative or god loving non Brahmins Hindus are upset with the act of MA..
It appears TMK was awarded to ridicule carnatic music's great composers and carnatic music lovers by academy members. When award is proposed it is necessary to look for voting from carnatic music lovers too and not just the academy committee.
சரியே.ஆனால் பக்க வாத்தியக் காரர்கள் இவருக்கு வாசிக்க க்கூடாது.அப்படி இருந்தால் தான் சரியான பாடம் கற்பிக்க முடியும் இந்த மாதிரி பேர்வழி களுக்கு.அழிவு ஆரம்பம்.
None of mummurthis or saint composers sang for us they only sang for theit beloved lord to show their bhakti through their spontaneous compositions. All the musicians who are making a career in this field had to study this music for years practising and come to platform level once you get fame and name they are lost in it and become egoist. These days even carnatic musicans have fallen with values and it has become glamourised. Need to see which direction it goes
The problem with TMK is that he wants to have the cake and eat it too. I am shocked to hear that he has accepted this award. He should know that the title Sangita Kalanidhi will never collocation with him.
Super. Arumi. Music academy thinks they are coming from heaven. The same murali do for in paper Hindu paper for several years for academy this time. What We boygott paper, not going academy. It's my humble request to music lovers
Support DS whole heartedly - I like TM Krishna's rendition but I cannot fathom any servings or rendition from a ill hearted person. sorry - Bhakthi and purity within one's soul is prime. then comes bhavam and Shruti.
It is self defeating when artists demonise other artists just because they are Brahmins. Rather, they should learn the dedication and devoutness of Brahmins. Its dividing musicians based on cast lines, when eveeyone is free to learn music from anybody. Please be professional not parichial, Mr. Krishna. Very sad.
In today's world anyone who is interested in a particular vocal or instrument can learn it and master it. Music has no language, no religion, no country or boundaries. It is universal. It is like AIR.
DMK might have used influence for TMK to bring down the fame of Music Academy and music standards. Shame to the jury for recommending the award to the so called rebel of karnatik music
TMKrishna has not taught carnatic music to Lower class people and produced a good stage performer. All his students are brahmins and foeigioner. If he wished. I the last ten years he must have produced ten scheduled cast stage performers.
We must ask, what happened to the beautiful Nagaswaram that will precide every auspicious ceremonies and temple festivals. Why never fight for those artistes and help them retain their lineage. Its very saddening to see temple festivals or the temples per se not having our divine nagaswara vidwans.
And in continuation... It would be a good idea for all the top Carnatic music artists to boycott the much corrupted, Brahmin -hate infested and the negative polluted Music Academy altogether and start a good parallel institution to nurture,patronise and develop the Carnatic music rich culture and traditions.. I am sure Rasikas from all over the world will support this noble initiative.. Cheers and God bless.. ..
What Dushyanth says is right. No one is telling don't learn or I will not teach you classical music if you are not a Brahmin. What about Yesudas Sir who learned and performed karnatic music with immense appreciation. Vinayam is necessery where there is Vidya. I didn't know TMK until this controversy. So. TMK pl work hard for the betterment of Karnatic music and any sort of music especially.
Why are you taking Yesudas example... How many kacheris has done alongside so called bragmins..... You should only ask him what discrimination he faced ... So. Shut up
Thank you Dushyanth, for staying true to our values. Proud of you.
TMK's achievements are corrupting Carnatic style music and bringing discredit to many doyens and Vaaggeyakaras. He must be having his own larger political ambitions and hopes to achieve them in his own style ably supported by such awards.
Completely agree with Dushyanth ji. Carnatic music with just focus on musicality without any devotion is like a decorated dead body without life.
You are absolutely correct 🙏
I fully agree with the sentiments expressed by Dushyanth Sridhar.
I am an atheist and not his fan/follower.
I am of the firm view that Ramaswamy Naicker was a third rate person who thought that the only way to destroy Sanatana Dharma was by destroying the Brahmin community.
Nobody has the right to INSULT the Religious beliefs of others.
Carnatic fraternity has been insulted. It is not Music Academy anymore. It is Periyar Thidal. Let all Carnatic vidwans and rasikas boycott events in the Music Academy.
Exactly 💯
The divine music fraternity should ignore music academy en masse.
Best u... pls leave Tamilnadu too...
Very good
Sangita Karunanidhi TMK 😂
Boycott all events happening at Music academy. Hindus should not goto music academy during December Margazhi
Sandhula sindhu
Best speech by Dushyant with very valid points! 👍🙏
Well expressed, Vid. Dushyanth Sridhar🙏🏼
There was a time TMK was my favorite, listening over and over for instance to his rendering of the Simhendramadhyamam composition 'Ninne Nammithi' by Vid. Mys. Vasudevacharya. But over time, TMK seems to have mysteriously turned full circle, from being a Bhakta once, now to mud slinging Carnatic Sahityas of great composers. In Kaliyuga, it's said devotional singing is the route to reach God Himself.
The music academy would do well to know one cannot reward Peter for robbing to pay Paul!
What reforms did he accomplish just like a typical leftist just talking about and do nothing he just demonise Brahmins and call Brahmins all kinds of names is not justified. I totally agree with you Dushyant ji.
What intelligence.. what clarity… what a grounded stance.
This is what real Bhakti and knowledge brings… that’s who we term a Brahmin. Padavandanas sir!!🙏🙏🙏🙏
T M Krishna may be talented but he is a negative force for the society.
For Brag. Mins yes 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Well said Dushyant ji.Boycott Music Academy
Music academy is a Rogue organization and hence chose to honour a Rogue
Super
Finally, a fit reply
Dushyantha shridar sir is highly knowledge and unafraid to speak the truth.
It is good to know that atleast few people are unafraid and have guts. A
As a true reforner, not just boasting of reformity or inclusiveness in words, i am.asking if TMK in these 10.years of such mere talking, has brought onto his stage atleast 2 tambura artists from oorrur kuppam???? Leave alone accompaniments . When he has not even done that successfully , doesnt it show that he is speaking with political ahenda and not true to his conscience?
You are absolutely correct, we fully support on your stand
I really appreciate Dushyanth Shridhar for taking this bold, responsible and sensible stand.
Iam sure if more and more people come together for the noble cause of boycotting T M Krishna, he will soon be erased from public memory.
Getting fame through the great vagyekarakas of carnatic music and conveniently villifying them to get a magsaysay and playing to the gallery and N Ram is what he is all about.
A person with hardly any integrity or dignity should be shown the door.
T.m.krissh has chosen a short cut for recognition...And that is to abuse Hindu Gods. There are many of this kind, enemies within.
That guy was /is against the construction of Ram mandir at Ayodhya.
Most pathetic part some /few / Brahmins with a political bias supporting him. It is hard to understand the logic.
Is everything boils down to money?
One doubt. Do they announce the Sangita Kalanidhi Award so early every year. Or the "secular" "The Hindu" group wants to create a nuisance before elections. Giving an opprtunity to TN govt to interfere
I wish he should be respected with Chappal Garland. He deserves only thst as honour. TMK sold out to DMK. Shame on him to to shamelessly receive award. In fact he should decently withdraw or will be put to shame. Our Hinduism cumture heritage, it's discipline us utmost important.
As a matter of fact he himself looks like a perfect villen as he has proved it several times.
But in kaliyuga all these things are bound to happen. persons who don't deserve will adorn the chairs & people who don't deserve will get the
awards & rewards. Parodox of life....! What to do....shame,.,.
I suspect nexus between DMK government and MMA to confer the title on this hypocrite TMK.
100 % it is political pressure for this ,
a institution,,,built on righteous,,ethic,,principle,,
decency,,decorum,,,has buckled,,by political power.
Come on M/s Murali & co ,,answer ,,logically
ethically,,,consciously ( if U have) for cranky,,lunatic
half baked,,with the attributes of ‘ mental ‘
not performed for @ 8 years in season,,,
how he is selected .?????
Is there some competent ,,strong good
Advocate to move a appropriate case
against this controversy ????
Many comments are made without fully listening to the points being made by the speaker. Music has various genres. Classical CARNATIC MUSIC is about DIVINITY . It's sacred to Indians just like compositions of Vach, Beethoven...in Western classical.
BTW: Why no one dare attempt reforms on various practices of Abhamic faiths.
Oh! I made the same point too, trying to explain carnatic music's nature and hertiage value. We are being called names for the same.
Who stopped anyone from protecting villu pattu, nagaswaram and so forth?
These so called TMK and EVR supporters, just find an opportunity to hurt Brahmins, hindu sentiments, its cultural value in any form and paint caste to the issue to politicize it.
But I'm glad that atleast now, we don't sit back and look for someone else to speak for us. Its time we RAISE.
😢 0:15 0:15 sir it is my strong guss that it is due to political pressure they had decided to give this award to periyarist
Why is Krishna awarded now. It is evident. Such singers if they want to sing Periyars song let them but not on a stage where the singers praise the Gods.
Why can't he sing the way he wants? Are you a prophet or a messenger for the gods like the Brahmins think they are?
@@sandeep15299nobody is asking him to sing in another way..but just the place where he sings matters ..nobody wants to hear about a person who insulted their sentiments..u may not be believing Hinduism or it’s gods,but u have no rights to insult others beliefs
@@sandeep15299Brahmins never feel that way may be u do😂😂😂 may be u have a complex that makes u feel inferior to them...
@@nandhinin9263 So you all powerful people will decide what, where and how he sings? Can you show me where there is no God? Just because someone does not agree with such conceited and arrogant behavior does not mean they don't believe in Hinduism. The fact that you are all so obsessed with Gods shows that you do not know much about Hinduism. Your behavior is more in line with Abrahamic thinking.
@@sandeep15299 ha ha..here the powerful ppl r the ones who are affiliated to some party ..just like how TMK who had disrespected the whole meaning of Carnatic music got through his influence..and it’s high time he s shown the right place..he insulted lord Rama and that’s hurting the sentiments of ppl who follow ..not the seculars like you who dt even know what it means when ur beliefs are mocked …u always connect everything with Brahmins..tats how u r all trained ..if u talk the same way abt Islam or Christianity everyone will oppose together,unfortunately tat unity is not there as among Hindus there is secular ones who r brainwashed
You have every right to peacefully protest. TMK is a stupid hater of Dharma, that's why Vidhya should be given to Eligible people. otherwise this would happen,
The award has already been tarnished when they do not consider whoever has a raised a voice against their decision. There is a lot of favoritism and lacks objectivity . Now it is all the more evident that they are political. Personally I don't wish to listen to anyone singing or performing on their stage
To all those who are witch hunting one particular community :I would request you to remember that what they have achieved in the realm of classical arts is the result of a lot of sacrifice, dedication and endless hard work. Nowhere has anybody from any other community, who is willing to put in the hard work required to gain such acumen ,been barred from doing so.
By the way, I am a non- Brahmin!😊
People, be fair! Use your good sense. It is so easy to get carried away by mob fury!
MMA is Hindu Ram’s coterie. Sane music lovers should boycott MMA with immediate effect. There are umpteen honest and orthodox sabhas to perform at and get recognised by. Don’t need MMA at all.
Very well articulated and conveyed the collective feelings of all of us.
Everyone has a right to music and sing what they want. Would be super interesting to see these ppl tolerate TM singing in other places while insulting their religion. When water gets under their own butts - then they become victims!
Same crappy drama since 75 yrs.
kudos to ppl who are now voicing their displeasure.
TMK=DMK .. Ignore them to proceed to positive life..
TMK earned money and fame by singing mummoorthigal keerthana, all Brahmins, and the people who have patronised his concerts in India, USA, other countries are mostly Brahmins
Classic Sanatan Dharma!
What are you trying to convey? He has taken money from bhramins, so better he not speak anything but praise about them??
TMKrishna is a compassionate person. His compassion is evident... he reached out to so many under privileged people to understand their views. All those speaking against him need to think a little. The privileged people are so hurt because of TMKrishna's views. Think of the underprivileged who could not enter the temples they labored to build. TMK's views hurt you so much; but the people he's referring to were hurt physically, mentally, subconsciously for centuries and the effect that created in them is still impacting their life.
TMK is a reformer in the musical field as Aadi Sankarar and Ramanajur were in the realm of religion, who were equally despised by similar retrograde crowd that existed then and feels uneasy now.
TMK will also be respected in the future for reforming this form of music that has become, in their own words, brahmin music, only to be learnt, sung by this crowd which is hopelessly lost in their backwardness of thought and existence, change and adapt if you want to survive. You have everything to lose, choice is yours.
This problem is prevalent only amongst the the tamil brahmin community, not so with the brahmin community of other languages who encourage others also to take up carnatic and classical music.
This guy harps about TMK boycotting the December music season for the past several years. I only have one simple question - is there a written rule somewhere in the rulebook that says that participating in the December season is a mandatory requirement for the artiste to be considered for the award?
If that is not an eligibility requirement, this guy should just shut up. There is no need to lecture us about sanatana dharma etc. Whoever this character is, he just comes across as a bitter and angry young man. God bless him.
This is about an award. If the candidate meets the eligibility criteria, he/she will be considered. If the person wins, he/she wins. Plain and simple. We may disagree with a person's views/opinions. That is irrelevant. We should be able to hold our emotions in check.
TMK boycotted every December past 10 years by villainizing the whole Brahmin community as door keepers of k music which is not true. And his hatred is coming from so called periyar who put cheppal on lord Srirams Murthi. That expains his sick secular mind. Period.
@@ayahuascaa9455 Hmmm....'sick secular mind'? Really? You are suggesting that it is 'sick' to be 'secular'? I feel sorry for you. Take care.
It is a very shameful act by the academy for awarding this rogue, indecent, anti Hindu and anti sanatani with academy award. If music academy doesn't rescind its decision, the music lovers will not only boycott it but we will look for establishing a new academy.
Well saidji. Music academy has lost its good respect due to this act. Never expect such action from music academy.
TMK always chooses dirty steps to gain cheap popularity. This is not the first time.
Well said Dushtant ji. God bless.
Very well said Dhushyantji.
Academy is now controlled by Periarists….that’s why they gave to TMK
Fully agree. TMK should dedicate himself to music than to cheap politics based On Religion😂 we have great vocalist , Legend Yesudas👏 who was always devoted to music. Ppl love to listen music than focusing on religion. I hate TMK😂
He is working towards democratising the beautiful art form we have towards non Brahmins. Ruikang Devi Arundale brought about similar changes making Bharatnatyam not just accessible for the Devadasi but for the Brahmins and other castes as well. Somehow when it’s done the other way there’s something wrong with it.
Tq, now i understand the controversy better, and i think the award is undeserved.
Finally, one person to understand what the controversy is about. The moment they take periyar's name or Rama's name they associate that this because of brahmins and caste and sanatana.
TM krishna is a sold soul.
Despicable.
Very bad. Academy award lost its dignity after conferring accademy award to TM Krishna who is aligned with enemies of Sanathana Dharma. Dushyant and other are doing good thing by boycotting future program.
There is one rule followed accross the globe and more so visibly in Bharat , if any one resorts to Brahmin Bashing and Hindu bashing, they generally are showered with awards and Schalarships. Its sad that Academy also joined the same vagan. As such , the standards are any way coming down. If academy did not confer to the Great MDR, where do the contemporary musians stand?
What kind of cinema oriented concerts have sprung up? As such diminishing this rich culture is not enough on the screens it is now taken towards concerts!
It is like giving Nobel peace prize to Osama bin ladan postumously.
Krishna should be taught a lesson
😂😂 who's stopping you from teaching him lesson,go teach him
Why TMK engage Brahmins as accompaniments.We all expect is Practice what you PREACH
You are absolutely right! Even the great saint arumagitinadhar is not from this community .
When they have nothing to defend they politize the issue by blaming it on brahmins/hindus. That's all!
TM Krishan stated his opinion that Carnatic music is dominated by Brahmins. I don't think he should be vilified and cancelled for stating his opinion. According to this gentleman reform needs to be done in a subtle manner so as not to offend his sensibilities. Most reform movements are only successful because some one calls out as loudly as possible about the injustices. Why are these people not being subtle about their boycott and instead shouting all over the social media. ng And who are these people do decide how and what songs he can sing or not? This boycott, cancelling, vilifying is exactly what dominant groups do and actually makes TM Krishna's point. A mature and empathetic community will actually start a dialogue to self examine and see if there is something that can be improved.
Did u see how TM Krishna responds ?? How he disrespects all stalwarts of Carnatic ..?he deserves all these for all those actions of his …
@@nandhinin9263I guess you expect complete obeisance and compliance to your dogma. Fortunately, those days are long gone. I gather he does not respect them because of their arrogance and their domineering, casteist behavior. Good for him.
We can say the same about EVR followers as they want to dominate with EVR theories which are extremely disgusting and devastating. We simply say, Shri. TMK can have his ideologies but presenting it in the carnatic music platform is not the one, for it. End of the day, it is the choice of audience as what they want to listen to but imagine a baby consuming poison served with payasam. As an adult, we just want one to be responsible because babies will never willingly consume poison. Hope you understand the metaphors.
@@sandeep15299 have U even seen them??so why shd he be respected..how much respect has evr given ??did u even know MS amma dominated anyone?If so share the proof..do you even know anybody was denied musical knowledge as they were not Brahmins?the days u had told stories and bashed Brahmins are gone..
Of course, whoever has talent will dominate and it’s obvious Brahmins dominate this field- don’t need TMK to tell that. The reasons he gives and vilifying the whole community are absurd. Non Brahmin musicians know how they got their art and are not supporting TMK. Caste prejudices are there in every community and they are slowly going away in their own due to changing times. No need to link art to caste. This fellow is just enjoying the attention of anti Brahmin hate mongering toolkit gang and feeling morally superior. An arrogant but useful idiot for the leftists.
Who is Jesudas?😊 Did Chembai sir stop him? MLV amma, MS amma?
Yes you are spot on Dushyant Sir.
Well mentioned Sri Dushyanth Sridhar swami🙏🏼👌🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Dushyant is too junior to comment. Several seniors are keeping quiet since this is an unwanted and unnecessary controversy.
But u r a baby to say that.
@@vedavallirajagopalan9652My sincere submission to you is that, he is atleast voicing the unjust that others consider not worthy due to various reasons.
A bold decision by Swami. Namaskaram
Both DMK=TMK
Second T sounds more harsh than D
Kanimozhi support to TMK show how he got
His qualification DMK likes "speak against brahman and create friction among hindu"
this is one of the “” tell tale indicators “
that Dravidian,,political,,,quid pro quo “
anti “” freedom for India “ group.
Irony is when whole…nation was fighting for
freedom,,even at the cost of their life..
irrespective,,of cast creed,,religion.
Following the foot steps of the so called
reformer,,but after learning from great
“” Semmangudi “ this lunatic ,,with all
unethical,,traits,,makes exceptions as
“ head lines” out of arrogance,,imbibed
by ignorance. ,,wants to be in “ lime light”
by hurting humiliating,,,even the Guru
& others,,including his parents,,perhaps
repenting for such a cranky ,,crack pot.
Let all have their full from of ,,,their opinion
bla bla but why so called institutions,,,built
by ethics,,principles,,values,,laid down by
guidances,,bye - laws ,,etc be vitiated
& award a wrong ,,person embodiment
of Negative,,Pessimistic,,,attitude to
the fine art of Carnatic music,,which is
breathed,,,worshipped as “ Divine by
millions of Music lovers. More for their
ultimate,,surrender,,mental solace…l
The so called select,,expert committee
even now take a recourse,,correct the
wrongs.
n
well said, Dushyant Sir
Hari Om. Music Academy has gone out of its principle of flourishing music. Now it has gone into the hands of DMK . Music Academy can now change its name as DMK Stage and start engaging for DMK meeting only and not to Indian Arts and Culture.
That has been long gone, Sir!
Excellent...the questions asked by Swamy as regards Thyagaraja Kritis @ 1.33 and EVR's past deeds should be answered definitely by Academy
Right from the 2000 season onwards, these awards have been issued based on popularizing the carnatic music abroad, which was used as a trump card for gaining that title. Everyone knows that this is a big lobby, partly uncovered by mee too movement. I have witnessed the musicians from the days of chembai vaidyanatha bhavatar etc., and now a days honestly the award is not even worth its paper weight. This fellow shouldn't even be allowed sing carnatic song in the first place, let alone him receiving an award. This just reinforces only one point , the dilution of standards. Nothing else.
Pl give the award to Dushyanthji
A million thanks to Dushyanth ji
The value of award is degraded!
😂
Nonsense
Yes no value for that award
Is he a good Carnatic singer? If yes, he is eligible to receive that award. Just because he sang about Periyar, he should not be opposed.
Carnatic music lovers should boycot the entire felicitation event of t.m.krishna.
Stalin says don't bring politics into Music in the TM Krishna matter. But let Stalin think who is bringing politics into Music by this accolade to a Periyar follower. Boycott Music Academy.
TMK is from famous family of first corrupted politician of india ttk.
TTk Was charged by non other than Feros and he is joining hands with feros grandson great combination
Namaskaram Sir, You have pointed out strong reasons for the boycott and we as Rasikas would also boycott the ceremony.
Dynasty Congress has a history of anti Sanatani narrative and their actions show it time and again ❤
Does that mean brahmins are only sanatanis rest of other people aren't sanatanis 🤣🤣🤣lol
TMKrishna is a shame on to himself.
Learned luminary like Dushyant screaming about him Is a victory for TMKrishna who is a spoilt bored rich kid.
My heart goes out for Dushyant.
May his harbinger ring like a death knell on the adversaries.
Well Done Sir you have done great Job to boycott
Your decision is welcome
Great🇮🇳👍
Ombu 😂
@@sureshkumarm1153 you are a bully
Very clearly explained. 🙏🙏
Bhakthi is the essence of carnatic music. Carnatic music is not like rock and roll thingie with just beats. So not just Brahmins, even the conservative or god loving non Brahmins Hindus are upset with the act of MA..
It appears TMK was awarded to ridicule carnatic music's great composers and carnatic music lovers by academy members. When award is proposed it is necessary to look for voting from carnatic music lovers too and not just the academy committee.
Better you all avoid to perform in the Academy for a year and let TMK alone perform.
சரியே.ஆனால் பக்க வாத்தியக் காரர்கள் இவருக்கு வாசிக்க க்கூடாது.அப்படி இருந்தால் தான் சரியான பாடம் கற்பிக்க முடியும் இந்த மாதிரி பேர்வழி களுக்கு.அழிவு ஆரம்பம்.
I support you sir 🙏❤🙏
None of mummurthis or saint composers sang for us they only sang for theit beloved lord to show their bhakti through their spontaneous compositions. All the musicians who are making a career in this field had to study this music for years practising and come to platform level once you get fame and name they are lost in it and become egoist. These days even carnatic musicans have fallen with values and it has become glamourised. Need to see which direction it goes
Already heading in the wrong direction...
The problem with TMK is that he wants to have the cake and eat it too. I am shocked to hear that he has accepted this award. He should know that the title Sangita Kalanidhi will never collocation with him.
Shame on him....if he has boycotted the academy for 10 years then he should have declined the award.....
Super. Arumi. Music academy thinks they are coming from heaven. The same murali do for in paper Hindu paper for several years for academy this time. What We boygott paper, not going academy. It's my humble request to music lovers
T M Krishna belongs to the family of TTK, so some influence would have been there
Music Academy wants to buy peace with TMKrishna
Not to forget that he belongs to the ttk family
Oh now got it 😂😂@@AkhilaVenkat
Happy to know that atleast few have the Gutts to express the truth!
Support DS whole heartedly - I like TM Krishna's rendition but I cannot fathom any servings or rendition from a ill hearted person. sorry -
Bhakthi and purity within one's soul is prime. then comes bhavam and Shruti.
It is self defeating when artists demonise other artists just because they are Brahmins. Rather, they should learn the dedication and devoutness of Brahmins.
Its dividing musicians based on cast lines, when eveeyone is free to learn music from anybody. Please be professional not parichial, Mr. Krishna. Very sad.
He is given the Award on the basis of his Talent in Carnatic Music ...Period
😂
@@nithyapalanisamy633 you couldn't deny the fact he is talented ...Shamelessly showing your teeth ...
Most of the comments from the TMK-haters is nothing but a case of 'sour grapes'.
Absolute clarity Dushyantji.
DMK pressures to award TMK ?
I strongly agree
In today's world anyone who is interested in a particular vocal or instrument can learn it and master it. Music has no language, no religion, no country or boundaries. It is universal. It is like AIR.
Yet the privileged and oppressor classes always forget their privilege
DMK might have used influence for TMK to bring down the fame of Music Academy and music standards. Shame to the jury for recommending the award to the so called rebel of karnatik music
Maybe Duyshanth should be awarded
TM Krishna roasted 😂
Instead of withdrawing from Music academy for the season, He should be expelled from the Academy for his discriminatory behaviour..
TMKrishna has not taught carnatic music to Lower class people and produced a good stage performer. All his students are brahmins and foeigioner.
If he wished. I the last ten years he must have produced ten scheduled cast stage performers.
We must ask, what happened to the beautiful Nagaswaram that will precide every auspicious ceremonies and temple festivals. Why never fight for those artistes and help them retain their lineage. Its very saddening to see temple festivals or the temples per se not having our divine nagaswara vidwans.
Besh Dushyant good explanation
MOst Amazing Presentation with the Most Convincing reasons.
And in continuation...
It would be a good idea for all the top Carnatic music artists to boycott the much corrupted, Brahmin -hate infested and the negative polluted Music Academy altogether and start a good parallel institution to nurture,patronise and develop the Carnatic music rich culture and traditions..
I am sure Rasikas from all over the world will support this noble initiative..
Cheers and God bless..
..
Agree with you Sir…
Well said Dushyant Ji.