American Reacts Christmas Truce - December 1914 - Sabaton History 107 [Official]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 55

  • @James-wp3jq
    @James-wp3jq Рік тому +18

    Watch the sainsburys ad about the Christmas truce .

  • @stevenlowe3026
    @stevenlowe3026 Рік тому +9

    Those battlefields were so bare because all trees and buildings had been destroyed by huge artillery barrages. What had been farms and crops and forests had been turned into a wasteland.

  • @mosthaunted2
    @mosthaunted2 Рік тому +4

    You should watch the 2014 Sainsbury's Christmas advert, it's literally about this event .

  • @damonbryan7232
    @damonbryan7232 Рік тому +3

    My great grandfather was a major in the German Army. He lived long enough to tell us about WW1. This reminds me about him. He told us. He ordered his men to never fire on Christmas Day. As he said. It was the only order he gave. He never regretted.

  • @sarablack2547
    @sarablack2547 Рік тому +3

    Paul McCartney and his band wings did a song that's played at Xmas called pipes of peace.the video shows this truce with him playing character on both sides.

  • @samnemeth-smyth6109
    @samnemeth-smyth6109 Рік тому +8

    Being in the trenches in summer would have been FAR better.
    Winter usually brings far more rain/snow which would turn the ground at the bottom into acres of mud and freezing cold puddles of water, which in turn would cause soldiers boots to become waterlogged.
    Those boots would be unable to dry properly because of the constant presence of water on the ground, which would lead to even higher numbers of trench foot and similar problems.
    Not too mention the increase in things like frostbite and frost nip due to the cold.
    Also a latrine is a toilet.

    • @the98themperoroftheholybri33
      @the98themperoroftheholybri33 Рік тому +1

      Tolkien served in ww1 and he's said that perhaps the inspiration he subconsciously made with the dead marshes were from the dead bodies in the bomb craters in no man's land

  • @TheSlyngel
    @TheSlyngel Рік тому +4

    Små grodorna the song indy sings is indeed about frogs and we Swedes sing it at midsummer when dancing around the midsummer pole (sometimes at chrismas too dancing around the christmas tree), its origins are a mystery but its a french melody and its quite possible that its a mocking song angainst the French army from the napoleonic wars. The Brittish mock the french and call them frogg eaters and we were part of that war on the Brittish side so maybe thats were the song comes from. But no one knows for sure. Its from the right era though.

  • @whitefox2336
    @whitefox2336 Рік тому +1

    The Royal Guardsmen brought out "Snoopy's Christmas" which relates to the 1914 Christmas truce, in the late 1960s. I play it every Christmas.

  • @angelabushby1891
    @angelabushby1891 Рік тому

    You want to watch Saisburys Christmas advert about the truce, very touching and makes you think.

  • @AlmosttheGoodlife
    @AlmosttheGoodlife Рік тому +1

    The video to THE PIPES OF PIECE by Paul McCartney tells this story.
    There was also a Christmas advert by Sainsbury’s which also told this story, it brings a tear to the eye.

  • @anthonykarlsson5166
    @anthonykarlsson5166 Рік тому +2

    The tradition of indoor trees comes from Germany and the first known dressed tree in Sweden is from 1741 and was dressed with apples, saffron pretzels and wax candles. From manors, vicarages and school teachers' residences, the Christmas tree spread into the countryside, and by the end of the 19th century it was common throughout the country.

  • @mats7492
    @mats7492 Рік тому

    Sabaton put it best..
    "War.. whats so fucking great about it?"

  • @blondkatze3547
    @blondkatze3547 Рік тому

    In Liverpool , england , there is a statue commemorating the 1914 Christmas peace.

  • @JonathanH1253
    @JonathanH1253 Рік тому

    The latrine is the bathroom, well more like an outhouse or just a hole for them to shit in.

  • @pabmusic1
    @pabmusic1 Рік тому

    Two things from the British pov - first there were no helmets yet in 1914, and (more important) no conscripts . Conscription didn't begin till 1916. Also, almost none on the volunteers ('Kitchener's Army') were yet engaged. They were mostly regulars and Territorials (that is, reserves).

  • @samuel10125
    @samuel10125 Рік тому +1

    It's important to remember this truce only primarily happened to between British and German troops the French for obvious reasons really didn't take part some did but the majority didn't same for the Belgians.

  • @stephwaite2700
    @stephwaite2700 Рік тому +1

    My father always believed that the terrible loss of so many young men in such dreadful conditions in WWI used, in his words, as "cannon fodder by inept leaders", was the point that so many people in the UK started to drift away from the Church..
    I've no idea if that is true or not, but certainly we are a far less religious country than we once were..

  • @CouncilOfWolves
    @CouncilOfWolves Рік тому

    Those young men were used as cannon fodder by warmongers. It was no-stop slaughter of the innocents in a war to end all wars. In 2014 the supermarket chain Sainsburys launched a Christmas advertising campaign to commemorate the centenary of this moment. The result is a moving account of one moment in time and well worth watching.

  • @karenblackadder1183
    @karenblackadder1183 Рік тому +2

    What's a latrine?! Give me strength!!!

  • @lynette.
    @lynette. Рік тому

    Men standing against those in charge. Just for a while but so important. Never the soldiers fault.

  • @Steve-gc5nt
    @Steve-gc5nt Рік тому +2

    What a shame they didn't just all drop their weapons and go home.

  • @AndrewwarrenAndrew
    @AndrewwarrenAndrew Рік тому

    The football is in a regimental museum in the UK. I forget which one though.

  • @einarthormodster95
    @einarthormodster95 Рік тому +1

    If not already, you should check out Sabaton, No bullets fly, the animated version 🙂

  • @almamater9566
    @almamater9566 Рік тому

    There is a fantastic French movie on this : Joyeux Noël (Merry Christmas) from 2005 by Christian Carion with Diane Kruger and Guillaume Canet, among many other obviously.

  • @KimForsberg
    @KimForsberg Рік тому +4

    The trenches and the battlefield you see in this video is basically what the battlefields look like in Ukraine now. No cover at all, especially in the south. It's all muddied farm fields, for miles upon miles, a front 70 miles or more deep (Ukrainian side) and 400 miles wide, and it's basically all flat. There's some cover in the east, but not much, especially around Bakhmut.
    The soldiers at the front all in tranches, every once in a while making a push. But this is a modern trench battle. There's no escaping the watchful eye of the drones or their bombs.
    Don't expect any repeat of the Christmas Truce though, as the ground freezes over after this mud season, it's again time for tanks and infantry fighting vehicles to make a showing again, hoping to push through the lines. Russia to try to make a rush to take Donbass as they have tried for the last 9 months, and Ukraine to liberate the areas occupied by Russia.
    The few weeks of lull from mud season in the south will be broken in not too long.

    • @markmorris7123
      @markmorris7123 Рік тому +2

      Errrrr,, no.. its completely different.. Dont listen to the mainstream garbage

    • @dirtystarlight
      @dirtystarlight Рік тому +1

      I'm on r/europe a lot (it's amazing, talking about things happening now then countries bringing up arguments with things other countries did things 200 years ago). Last week someone posted a photo of a Ukrainian trench, the mud everywhere, the landscape nothing but mud and mangled trees. Someone posted colourised photos of ww1 trenches and black and white photos of current Ukrainian trenches. It was hard to tell them apart, only way was some shots Ukrainian armour etc obviously modern. It's appalling the worst of ww1 trenches with drones, modern missiles etc to cope with on top.

    • @markmorris7123
      @markmorris7123 Рік тому +2

      @@dirtystarlight dont talk rubbish.. WW1 trenches were piled high with dead bodies, soldiers ravaged with dysentery, and they lacked any sort of consistent supply line.. The Ukranian trenches are very very very muddy.. That's true... But they are not filled with disease and countless dead bodies.. And they also have a constant supply line.

    • @markmorris7123
      @markmorris7123 Рік тому +1

      Ww1 1000s of men were dying in the trenches every day.. Very different

    • @jonashansson2320
      @jonashansson2320 Рік тому +1

      @@markmorris7123 Nobody said it was exactly the same or equally bad. "... basically what the battlefields look like.." And yes. In many places it is.

  • @lynette.
    @lynette. Рік тому

    It is why after both world wars we were able to live in peace it was those in charge not the ordinary man.

  • @ratowey
    @ratowey Рік тому

    To this day some of the battlefields are still scared, I`ve visited the battlefields of Belguim and France many times and its still shocking to see.

  • @billy2rivers1
    @billy2rivers1 Рік тому

    Yes mate it was called a war of attrition.

  • @andrebrodbeck384
    @andrebrodbeck384 Рік тому

    3:00 look at this guy, he is propably siting on a latrine. It is basicly a hole in the ground you can sit on to do your "business".
    Ok after having a second look it also could be the entry to the underground section. Not sure.
    29:16 to answer your question.
    Nope the ortodox x-mas is at the 7. January, so this also could happen around the x-mas time.
    Also, i guess the reason that germany is the first country that comes into your mind when it comes to x-mas. It is because x-mas is basicly a german invention as far as i know. Even if the traditions have changed a lot, the basic tradition of a x-mas tree comes from the germanic tribes, to celebrate their pre chritianic traditions. I think they celebrated the starting Winter, especialy the fact that the days become longer around this time in the year.

  • @DaxRaider
    @DaxRaider Рік тому

    All brothers of my grandfather died in the trenches in WW1 he later survived fighting in WW2 fighting in Russia

  • @MikeGill87
    @MikeGill87 Рік тому

    Easter in Russia is just like Christmas in Russia. Currently 13 days behind all the other countries who use the Gregorian calendar instead of the Julian one.

  • @RaceSimCentral
    @RaceSimCentral Рік тому

    I'm British but I think I have heard k pronounced as G or J when people speak Swedish. Both a k and gu sound are formed really similarly with the tongue on the top of the mouth.

  • @ericg5791
    @ericg5791 Рік тому

    @TimelineChannel Are you familiar with this YT channel? Full history documentaries

  • @kaylucas51
    @kaylucas51 Рік тому

    It’s Christmas goodwill to all men good on them leaders are the worst

  • @johnlewis734
    @johnlewis734 Рік тому

    This gentleman is a knob 🤔

  • @agnieszkazuk
    @agnieszkazuk Рік тому

    Decorated Christmas Tree originated in Germany 🙂

  • @DaxRaider
    @DaxRaider Рік тому

    You should try to fix back to how ur settings was before it's rly bad now

  • @Ander01SE
    @Ander01SE Рік тому

    Damnit man, you have a PC with notepad, why are you running off to grab pens? :P

  • @anthonykarlsson5166
    @anthonykarlsson5166 Рік тому

    Russian Christmas is around January 7th

  • @sjbict
    @sjbict Рік тому

    Latrine = Toilet

  • @supriyadiadi8148
    @supriyadiadi8148 Рік тому

    Next reaction (VOICE OF BACEPROT)" SABOTAGE"( Beastie BOYS cover.VOB
    Band Rock heavy metal 3 HIJABERS 🇮🇩 LIVE FULL SET At PASIWALI FESTIVAL in TAIWAN 10 23 2022 👍 AMAZING SUPER TALENTED 🤟🤟🤟

  • @jacklomas7773
    @jacklomas7773 Рік тому

    No French in these trenches.

  • @supriyadiadi8148
    @supriyadiadi8148 Рік тому

    Next reaction ( VOICE OF BACEPROT)"Enter Sandman" (Metalica cover )(VOB) Band Rock heavy metal 3 HIJABERS 🇮🇩 LIVE FULL SET At TRANS MUSICALES DE RENNES 👍 AMAZING SUPER TALENTED 🤟🤟🤟

  • @Krokmaniak
    @Krokmaniak Рік тому

    Christmas for Orthodox Christians is January 6th

  • @jonashansson2320
    @jonashansson2320 Рік тому

    Nope. No "dj" sound in swedish, so everytime you see a J or something that should be a similar sound, it's a lot like your Y sound.
    And also.. A big difference in WW2 and many of the wars you have fought after that. In WW2 you were on the defending side, the good side. That's not so certain after that. There's a reason many of the countries you have been fighting in hates you..