the vocals, rap, visuals… everything is perfect! a masterpiece 💯 karina, giselle, winter and ningning, i love you. im so proud of you my four amazing and talented girls 🥹
All of them looked more confident, happy, and energetic today. And Giselle is doing well! Her body seems more comfortable with the choreo now. So proud of her. She's really hardworking
Winter is such a good performer, Everytime she performs she adds more details to her movements which makes people replay her performance again and again till they find all those little details She knows how to grab everyone's attention which is a Talent in itself
agreed.. she improved a LOT.. LIKE A LOTT... though at some point in this performance her she is a bit wary and it shows in her facial expression... i hope MYs can tell her that shes doing great and she should feel confident in her improvements... i just worry that she isnt enjoy performing in stage... Giselle YOU ARE DOING GREAT
Definitely not live at all. Just accept the fact that they have never performed live for GIRLS performance, also the stage performances, not a live version. I would understand if they put some backtrack to support their live vocals, but this one, and other performances of GIRLS on other music shows are not live too. Not all people that pinpoint aespa lip-synching are haters. That is because these people were expecting something from aespa as the GG from SM who is known as the warehouse of powerful voacalists throughout the years.
@@imadoes9220 Lol talk much? I know they don’t sing live most of the time and I never said that those people who pinpoint that they don’t sing live are haters. So talk much when I just literally commented one line lol 🤣
Giselle improved since last week, I can feel her energy! Yeah she did mess up dance break a little bit but she tried her best. Really looking forward her improvements in future.
she didn't mess up. it's just that specific part of the choreo doesn't really suit her since she has yet to improve her angles and add more power but in terms of accuracy, she did everything correctly today.
@@sarangfied everday? i don't even talk about giselle a lot bc there's nothing much there to comment aside from her controversies sigh anyway, my comment here is from a performer's perspective. i started commenting about her bc she's so frustrating to watch.
WINTER dance moves are more on being smooth, sharp, and clean. She does not overpower her dancing that is why she is so satisfying to watch. Keep coming back to watch all her fancams, she's born to be a star
Winter is a main Slayer, she can sing, rap, dance, and she even has good stage presence, what can this all rounder not do, she use to be my bias wrecker and now she's my bias, I don't think that will ever change, love winter cause she's a perfect little angel
I am very proud of GISELLE. Look how tough he has improved since the nasty comments last week.GISELLE is the best rapper SM has!! Let's grow together for a better future AESPA!!!
agreed.. she improved a LOT.. LIKE A LOTT... though at some point in this performance her she is a bit wary and it shows in her facial expression... i hope MYs can tell her that shes doing great and she should feel confident in her improvements... i just worry that she isnt enjoy performing in stage... Giselle YOU ARE DOING GREAT
the four talented Girls showing the caliber performance that will carry them on top of the world..great stage presence from karina, giselle, winter and ningning...way up Girls
a MY to AESPA: LIFE'S TOO SHORT and full of BLACK MAMBAS,but you GIRLS are only making it better. Your songs gives us AENERGY for pushing forward to NEXT LEVEL. They makes us SAVAGE to fight all negativity. Your ILLUSION gives us the much needed escape from our reality,to the ICU for our bleeding heart. I,a MY among millions,will remember you gals FOREVER. May all of our DREAMS COME TRUE. :) For a better day,catch the train of KWANGYA with Aespa. Hwating!
Ning Ning have an asome stage presence shes really getting better and better, I hope people around the word support her, because shes really talent, koreans not apreciate her properly
why nobody talk’s bout Karina, the real main slayer, her voice, her rap, her dance, her visual, his scenic and natural presence. everything so powerful, she’s just perfect without effort, the real goddess my queen
![[K-Choreo 8K] 에스파 직캠 'Savage' (aespa Choreography) l @MusicBank 211022](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Z_0s7UP9Wy8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[K-Choreo 8K] 에스파 직캠 'Savage' (aespa Choreography) l @MusicBank 211022](/img/tr.png)
who else notice that giselle’s energy has improved a lot? i’m so proud
Yesss
So proud of Giselle❤️
right!
ikr So proud of her💜💜😝
yes yesss especially in this stage SHES KILLING IT
짱스파 무대 찢었다ㅠ 마이와 함께하는 뮤뱅 무대 넘 좋다🥺💖헤메코 라이브 춤선 미쳤다💜💙중간중간 하트 해주는 거 넘 귀엽다💕💕
라이브는 다음주부터 할거같아요
라이브는 아닌거 같고 이번엔 아예 AR튼게 아니라 사전녹음으로 녹음먼저따고 무대한듯. 라이브AR
@@castlename 이거 어떻게 알아요? 본방보니까 라이브소리 잘들려요 라이브맞는데..
직캠도 라이브맞대..
립싱크예요?
@@kim-mh8fd 립싱크인대
카리나 진짜 춤 개멋지게 춤.. 하
Winter always perfect!
the vocals, rap, visuals… everything is perfect! a masterpiece 💯 karina, giselle, winter and ningning, i love you. im so proud of you my four amazing and talented girls 🥹
Love you Winter ♥️ you did a good job!
All of them looked more confident, happy, and energetic today. And Giselle is doing well! Her body seems more comfortable with the choreo now. So proud of her. She's really hardworking
Winter is such a good performer, Everytime she performs she adds more details to her movements which makes people replay her performance again and again till they find all those little details She knows how to grab everyone's attention which is a Talent in itself
에스파 노래는 뭐랄까…전반적으로 웅장한 비트?라서 첨에는 그냥 그런데 나중에 보면 계속 듣게 되는 그런 중독성이 있어서 너무 좋아❤️
요번 Girls도 역시 넘 좋아ㅏㅏ
아 그리고 댄브 진짜 미친거 아니냐고오
그냥 에스파 아니 갓스파는 완-벽
카리나빼고 너무 일반인들이 춤추는거 같음
I think this might be my fave performance of aespa
Lot’s of energy, I love it🫶🏻
💯 agree
Agree, even when only 4 of them in the stage (no backup dancers) it doesnt feel empty cuz their moves are busy
Same!!
i'm glad giselle seemed to practice a lot for this, she's finally on the same wavelength as the other three 💯 i hope she maintains this energy
Queen G always slayin💯🌙🔥 always room for progress 👏
agreed.. she improved a LOT.. LIKE A LOTT... though at some point in this performance her she is a bit wary and it shows in her facial expression... i hope MYs can tell her that shes doing great and she should feel confident in her improvements... i just worry that she isnt enjoy performing in stage... Giselle YOU ARE DOING GREAT
Ningning so beautiful 😍 🤩
I think they're live, specialy when I saw how Winter singing
에스파는 전설이다...
winter im glad you're okay now. slayed as always.
와… 춤선 너무 이쁘다, 4명 다 밸런스 너무 잘맞고.. 춤 깔끔하고 강약조절 장난 아니네 와….
0:09, 0:19 Winter adding spice to her dancing by doing a new move for her intro! And look at those sharp movements!
진짜 에스파 비주얼 미쳤다 다들 너무 이뻐 옷도 너무 이쁘고 반짝반짝 빛나💗💗
예빈님 레즈?
chiness빼고
@@댕댕이와마루 그냥 같은 여자로써 동경이지 뭔 레즈..
여기 팬들 대다수가 레즈라서 저렇게 물어볼수있음 ㅋㅋ
닝닝 너무 잘한다
Their live performance really on the next level.
THIS IS LIVE PEOPLE AND THE STYLIST DESERVES A RAISE!!!!!!
Definitely not live at all. Just accept the fact that they have never performed live for GIRLS performance, also the stage performances, not a live version. I would understand if they put some backtrack to support their live vocals, but this one, and other performances of GIRLS on other music shows are not live too. Not all people that pinpoint aespa lip-synching are haters. That is because these people were expecting something from aespa as the GG from SM who is known as the warehouse of powerful voacalists throughout the years.
@@imadoes9220 Lol talk much? I know they don’t sing live most of the time and I never said that those people who pinpoint that they don’t sing live are haters. So talk much when I just literally commented one line lol 🤣
진짜 걸스 안무는 볼 때 마다 감탄할 수밖에 없음. 디테일이 전부 녹아있고, 걸리시 함을 잃지 않으면서 SMP의 파워풀함을 살리는 절묘한 줄타기를 보여줌. 댄브부터 터지는 쾌감은 진짜 예술임💛
와 HDR 진짜 끝내준다...
Giselle improved since last week, I can feel her energy! Yeah she did mess up dance break a little bit but she tried her best. Really looking forward her improvements in future.
i don’t think she messed up the dance break? better than last week
she didn't mess up. it's just that specific part of the choreo doesn't really suit her since she has yet to improve her angles and add more power but in terms of accuracy, she did everything correctly today.
She didn't mess up though
@@staychaeyoung4801 you dont have to look at every move she does everyday and complain about it , that’s really creepy
@@sarangfied everday? i don't even talk about giselle a lot bc there's nothing much there to comment aside from her controversies sigh anyway, my comment here is from a performer's perspective. i started commenting about her bc she's so frustrating to watch.
오늘 우리 에스파 또 무대를 찢었다🔥
ningning's stage presence and charisma on stage really shines through!
Ningning is so attractive
Ningning ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
WINTER dance moves are more on being smooth, sharp, and clean. She does not overpower her dancing that is why she is so satisfying to watch. Keep coming back to watch all her fancams, she's born to be a star
Winter is perfect. another level of visual, dance and vocal. She's literally ACE
NINGNING ALWAYS SERVE!!!! 🔥🔥🔥❤️😘🦋🦋🦋🦋
giselle looks very cute💗💗💗
I love Giselle's energy here~
They look so good today even their costumes are so pretty. Aespa you guys are cool
Who's here for Giselle and ended up feeling emotional because our girl is trying her best to improve? 🥹🥹🥹🥹
BEST GIRL AERI💜💜
Winter is a main Slayer, she can sing, rap, dance, and she even has good stage presence, what can this all rounder not do, she use to be my bias wrecker and now she's my bias, I don't think that will ever change, love winter cause she's a perfect little angel
Call them who said winter have no stage presence ,look at this she ate it 🔥🔥🔥🔥
compare her to Ningning she still has long way to go.
just let people praise her why u sound so bitter???
@@danissegomez7953 stay bitter lol
I am very proud of GISELLE. Look how tough he has improved since the nasty comments last week.GISELLE is the best rapper SM has!! Let's grow together for a better future AESPA!!!
LOUDERRRR💯🔥🌙😎 GISELLE GOT IT AND I ALWAYS FEEL LIKE THIS ISN'T ALL SHE GOT IN STORE FOR US👀❤️
agreed.. she improved a LOT.. LIKE A LOTT... though at some point in this performance her she is a bit wary and it shows in her facial expression... i hope MYs can tell her that shes doing great and she should feel confident in her improvements... i just worry that she isnt enjoy performing in stage... Giselle YOU ARE DOING GREAT
지젤 힘 빡빡주고 춤 추네. 지난주 첫방보다 전체적으로 싱크도 잘 맞구 짱스파 남은 활동도 화이팅
그때 표정이 아파보이던데 아팠던건 아닐까용...개인추측🥺
@@yogurt2315 민정이도 빡센 스케쥴로 아팠는데... 나머지 멤버들이 멀쩡할 수가 없긴하죠... 아팠던 것 같아요
일주일만에 힘이 생긴거보면 확실히 컨디션 문제였던거 같네요 ㅠ
안피곤한게 이상해요.. 미국 활동 끝나고 와서
단 하루도 못쉼..
@@yogurt2315 ㅁㅈ요ㅠㅠ 아파보여서..
GISELLE HAS SUCH A BEAUTIFUL LEGS
Winter never fails to impress me, her stage presence and facial expression is out of this world!! She consistently owns the stage
Why lying so much hhhh
No one can change my mind, when it comes to facial expressions during the choreo Giselle's got it down 💯
Winter so pretty
the four talented Girls showing the caliber performance that will carry them on top of the world..great stage presence from karina, giselle, winter and ningning...way up Girls
Winter hitting every beats..
아니 나 요즘 이 언니들 때매 미치겠네,,💗💗 다들 왤캐 멋있는거냐구우ㅜ우우 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
동혁님 레즈?
@@댕댕이와마루 땡!
Winter so pretty !!!
에스파 이렇게 무대 잘해버리면 더 사랑받을 일밖에 없어...넷다 오늘 헤메코 ㄹㅈㄷ 짱스파 흥해라
카리나빼고 나머지는 많이 더 잘해야될듯
카리나 저 권총인지 천년돌인지 그 안무마저도 잘살림 목이 앞으로 빠져서 상체 구부정하고 다리를 그냥 깽깽이처럼 들면 어정쩡해보이기 쉬운 안무인데 코어힘 써서 최대한 상체를 목까지 1자로 고정시키고 다리 각도까지 신경써서 올림 안무를 예쁘게 소화함
지젤 이번 헤메코 너무 잘어울린다👏🏻❤️
ningning never misses a beat I love to see it
Imo THIS IS ONE THE BEST GIRLS PERFORMANCE till now
i'm so proud of giselle. this era proves how hardworking she is.
에스파 너무 이쁘다 노래도 잘한다💗💗
a MY to AESPA:
LIFE'S TOO SHORT and full of BLACK MAMBAS,but you GIRLS are only making it better. Your songs gives us AENERGY for pushing forward to NEXT LEVEL. They makes us SAVAGE to fight all negativity. Your ILLUSION gives us the much needed escape from our reality,to the ICU for our bleeding heart.
I,a MY among millions,will remember you gals FOREVER. May all of our DREAMS COME TRUE. :)
For a better day,catch the train of KWANGYA with Aespa. Hwating!
This is really live. I can hear them breathing. They sing so good
Karina always make me amazed, never dissapointed! so prouddd giselle improved a lot~ aespa keren bangetttt
1:18-1:22, 1:34-1:39 Really love how Winter dances these parts! The choreography suits her dancing style so much.
I'm so proud of Giselle💐💐
Ningning is always energetic on stage~ lovely ningning~❤️❤️❤️
aespa deserved first place, they should have won.
Is aespa win?
@@forlucky8115 today itzy win
@@aininsofiya9781 aespa comeback first, hopefully aespa will gain many awards
@@forlucky8115 they already get 2 wins for their song GIRLS 👍
요새 그룹들이 다 귀염, 상큼 이런 컨셉밖에 없어서 지루한데.. 너무나 좋은 컨셉, 노래와 춤
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ저도요
윈터 이번에도 너무 귀여워 영원히 사랑합니다❤❤❤
I just realized the choreography has a lot of small details making it hard to synchronize properly, the girls did a very good job!
지젤 진짜 예쁘다 !!
GISELLE IS SLAYINGGGGG🔥👑💜
ningning with tied hair, bun and hair down! we got all of these hairstyles in different stages, thank you hair stylist-nim! 👏
GISELLE!!!
Is it just me or is this video like SUPER clear😭like wow the quality is extra amazing here haha
YESS music bank giving us 8k full cams now !!
The outfit looks so good and also their performance on fire!! 😍
와 오늘 무대 레전드다,,
오늘 헤메코 미쳤고, 무대는 더욱 농익었고, 춤이 점점 더 파워풀 해지고 너무 좋다🥰
세비지 때보다 걸스 의상들 다양하고 그 나이대에 맞는 예쁜 옷들이라 너무 예쁘다,,
오늘 의상이랑 코디한 악세사리들 정말 예뻐😭
4 visuals, 4 vocalists, 4 dancers, 4 all rounders, aespa superstars 💘
오늘 헤메코 너무너무 이쁨ㅠㅠㅠ 애들 무대도 점점더 잘하는것 같애 남은 활동 화이팅💓💓
ㄹㅇ
역시 에스파들 실력제대로 보여주는군~~역시 짱이당!!이게 바로 sm가수들에 실력이지 아무도 못따라오지 더이상 말못하게허하짱!❤️
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ
NING NING AND WINTER OOOOWWWNNNN THE DANCE BREAK
에스파 사랑해!!!💙🖤💜💜
ningning is the princess🦋
닝닝 반묶음한 거 너무 인어공주 같음.. 완전 예뻐
이번 헤메코 ㄹㅇ 진짜 다 무난하면서도 부담 없이 너무 다 잘 어울려서 갠적으로 넘 취향~!에스파 사랑해~!😍💙🌙⭐️🦋
진짜 오늘은 FPS게임 여캐처럼 의상을 입혀뒀어... 다들 너무 잘어울리고 너무 예쁘다
그런가......
에스파와 마이는 언제라도 우린 Together💜💙
the mic is on?!?!??!!? they are so talented
they are😭💖
Winter ❤️
aespa never disappoint
I love them all
so proud of giselle, gurl you got me!!!!!
you are all so beautiful, a masterpiece, giselle keep it up you dance so well, i'm so proud of you AESPA!!
Ningning’s makeup suits her so much~ our little 🐯 ~ so sassy ~🦋🦋🦋❤️❤️❤️
짱스파 무대 찢었다💜💙
ningning the main slayer never misses, she wil always ✨ serve and deliver ✨
아 누나들 이번 뮤뱅 헤매코 역시나 이쁘다 ㅠㅠ 민정이누나 베레모뭐야 ㅠㅠ 오랜만이야 너무 잘 어울려 ㅠㅠ 다들 아침부터 수고했어 민정이누나 링거자국 맘찢이다 ㅠㅠ 빨리 완벽하게 다 나았으면 좋겠다 다들 너무 잘 췄다 ㅠㅠ 완벽하다 사랑해 누나들 ㅠㅠ 💙❄️🖤❤️
GISELLE!!! THE ENERGY ♥️
I will never get over this dance break
ジゼルちゃんだんだんダンス上手くなってる😭
自信持って踊ってると最高に可愛いよ💕
Ning Ning have an asome stage presence shes really getting better and better, I hope people around the word support her, because shes really talent, koreans not apreciate her properly
Giselle slayyyyy🌙💘💘
NINGNING POWER IS REALLYYYY GOOD
why nobody talk’s bout Karina, the real main slayer, her voice, her rap, her dance, her visual, his scenic and natural presence. everything so powerful, she’s just perfect without effort, the real goddess my queen
Winter is so talented, pretty and all rounder. She deserve what she is getting now. She is successful and will grow more
Giselle slaying so hard on this stage it's amazing to watch.
진짜 오지게 예쁘다 다들 피지컬 비율도 오져서 더 인형 같음 ㅠㅠ ❤️