Having Texas at 3 when Georgia beat them in Texas by more than 2 touchdowns is ridiculous. There should not be such a big difference in the ranking or seeding between Texas and Georgia. And if Texas is so great at 3 why not give Georgia credit for beating them when compared to Alabama and Ole Miss??
Why do you guys keep trying to cannibalize Texas? You have a shit ton of other programs to go after, but its always Texas. What I keep hearing is that Alabama or Georgia might have more losses that, say, BYU, but they play in the SEC where every team is better than a BYU.... Sound familiar? Then Texas plays the exact same schedule as Tennessee, the only deviation is Texas travels to A&M, where Alabama played at Tennessee. The Texas schedule isn't "The easiest schedule since Tulane was in the SEC", like Finebaum reported Georgia as having said. It has been an all out smear against Texas. Texas is beating the SEC teams they by an average of 14 points. Is that impressive? It seems to be when Georgia or Ole Miss wants to jump Texas. The double standard is obvious. One last point. If you calculate the over win% of the opponents each SEC team will face this season. Ole Miss is the lowest at 53%, meaning they will face teams that are around .500... Texas and Tennessee face identical win% at 54%. A&M and Missouri, 56% ..... Georgia, 60% .... Georgia also beat the SEC team they faced by 9 points in average. The margin of victory was a metric point used to rank teams until 2008ish. It was removed to encourage sportsmanship, however it took away a teams ability to be recognized as being quality even when their competition isn't in the top 25. I say that the SEC needs to make up their mind. Is it the number of top 20 victories, which is what they slam Texas for, or is the level of competition? If Georgia can benefit by saying the SEC teams are just way better and that fact should be considered when ranking teams, then Texas should benefit from that too.
Ward Manuel said his eyeballs test they had to watch all the games and see who played well. . That is absolutely ridiculous .. Not everybody plays the same competition. He should be impeached..
@@SilFord-o9f you’re 100% right. There’s no stand out elite teams. If Georgia and bama weren’t having an off year and Michigan was halfway decent then we wouldn’t even be talking about these big10 teams.
Let's not forget the big 10 is the only conference to represent goose eggs in the playoff era, not just 1 but 2 goose eggs with one of those 2 teams being the most glorified team in all of college football, never in my life have they earned their annual praise or top 3 ranking and I don't care what anyone says about it, Ohio St is trash.
Any 6-year old can add up wins and losses. We don't need a committee to do that. I'd rather have a computer with published SOS formulas than what we have now. The biggest lie in college football is that "you are what your record says you are." Yet here we are with a committee that effectively says all wins and losses are the same! I hope Greg Sankey blows up this CFP agreement ASAP so that the best teams are fairly rewarded for their efforts.
Dont think the committee likes Kirby saying he has no idea what they are looking for. But he's right. Schedule strength should matter. Big 10 with 4 of top 5 is a total joke. Texas at 3 is a joke as well. Who have they beaten?
It's so simple, yet we make it so difficult by using BIG words out of Webster's dictionary and allowing all these platforms to weigh in on who, what, when, where, and how college football should be, especially the playoffs. All you have to do is open the dictionary and find the word "GREED", and every member of the CFP committee picture will be stamped by the word. All you have to do is follow the money. Anything that goes on "behind closed doors" is not legit, it's "secretive", it's "we have the power, the say so and no one can do anything about it. Oh wait, the TV networks are standing in the corners of the room too clearing their throats when the "common sense" of who, what, where, how, and why starts speaking and is quickly shut down. Bottom line is they, the CFP committee, have been instructed to fanagle the list to sway towards more of the Big 10 because the SEC has dominated all these years and IT'S TIME FOR A CHANGE. Michigan got it started last year and why? What was in the news, what had everyone's attention? - (THE CHEATING). YOU WERE GLUED TO YOUR TV DURING THE NC GAME WATCHING TO SEE IF MICHIGAN CHEATED!!!! So, if you keep controversy going that's what will draw more viewers. Best way to sum it up - as a kid you thought wrestling was real!!!! And now you learn the physicality part is real, they train, they sweat, they get injured------BUT THE OUTCOME IS SCRIPTED SO AS TO KEEP THE AUDIENCE ENGAGED, INTRIGUED, TALKING, FIRED UP!!! WHAT WILL PUT PEOPLE IN THE SEATS, AND LASTLY---------HOW MUCH $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ CAN I (ESPN - THE MOTHERSHIP) GET SO I CAN HAVE ALL THE POWER!!!!!!!!!!! AND IT'S OCCURRING RIGHT IN FRONT OF US BY HOW THEY HAVE RANKED TEAMS IN THE CFP - THE EVIDENCE IS RIGHT THERE!!!!!!! SMH!!!! AGAIN, SO SIMPLE.....LIKE A KID GETTING CAUGHT WITH HIS HAND IN THE COOKIE JAR, THEN TRYING TO EXPLAIN AS TO WHY AND THE KID STARTS TELLING HIS SIDE AND HAS ALL THESE REASONS - SOUND FAMILIAR? CFP COMMITTEE MEMBERS TRYING TO EXPLAIN THE RANKINGS BASED OFF OF STRENGTH OF SCHEDULE, OH WAIT, STRENGTH OF SCHEDULE IS NOT WEIGHTED, OH WAIT, THIS WEEK IT IS, OH WAIT, NOW IT'S NOT!!!!! WHAT MORE DO YOU NEED TO SEE????? BILLIONS AND BILLIONS OF $$$$$$$$$$$$ AND YES, WE WILL CONTINUE PACKING THE STADIUMS ON SATURDAYS!!!!!!!! ALL IS GOOD :)
SEC flip-flops are interesting. In years when the top of the SEC is unbeaten, they say the record should matter most. This year, when the top of the SEC has multiple losses, they say SOS should matter most. What metric will they promote next year, best weather at kickoff?
To all of the B10 clan, PLEASE STOP IT, THE B10 STINKS! You can tell a B10 guy is running this thing with Indiana & Penn St high up qith they have done NOTHING! WARD MANUEL = MICHIGAN GUY B10 bias for a crappy league
We’re OK this is just a play spot for the playoffs. Just get your home-field advantage and keep winning. Nothing else matters none of these records matters it’s becoming an NFL week. Welcome baby.
Neither was Texas last year one of the best teams last year. 12 -O Georgia lost the SEC championship to an 11 -1 Alabama I believe. Alabama got in. A 10-2 Texas beat a 9-3 Oklahoma State and won the Big 12 championship and Texas got in over Georgia. I may be wrong on my numbers but that is my memory on last year.
Georgia has played a cupcake schedule for the last 5 years and they finally play a real schedule and now yall crying! The irony & how soft georgia folks are is pathetic Bama put the beats on ur head and ole miss stomped you out when are yall going to accept U ARE NO LONGER ELITE! GET OVER IT NOBODY SCARED OF GEORGIA! RTR 🏈🐘🏆
In 2022 UGA played 7 top 25 teams, won 7, lost 0, and played/beat 3 top 6 teams. No one else in the country came close to UGA's schedule that year. How many top 25 teams did your team beat in 2022? How many top 25 teams did your team play in 2022 and what was their record against those top 25 teams???
Well said Mike. You represent Georgia and the SEC very well 👏🏻
The agenda of the committee is to get an All Big 10 semifinal if they can
Great job, Mike. Any complete moron does not believe Penn State or Indiana could beat any of the top four SEC teams.
Penn State isn’t beating Tennessee.
who thought it was a good idea to have sitting/active ADs from any school on the committee???? dumbest thing ever
Having Texas at 3 when Georgia beat them in Texas by more than 2 touchdowns is ridiculous. There should not be such a big difference in the ranking or seeding between Texas and Georgia. And if Texas is so great at 3 why not give Georgia credit for beating them when compared to Alabama and Ole Miss??
THIS!!!
Why do you guys keep trying to cannibalize Texas? You have a shit ton of other programs to go after, but its always Texas.
What I keep hearing is that Alabama or Georgia might have more losses that, say, BYU, but they play in the SEC where every team is better than a BYU.... Sound familiar?
Then Texas plays the exact same schedule as Tennessee, the only deviation is Texas travels to A&M, where Alabama played at Tennessee. The Texas schedule isn't "The easiest schedule since Tulane was in the SEC", like Finebaum reported Georgia as having said. It has been an all out smear against Texas.
Texas is beating the SEC teams they by an average of 14 points. Is that impressive? It seems to be when Georgia or Ole Miss wants to jump Texas. The double standard is obvious.
One last point. If you calculate the over win% of the opponents each SEC team will face this season. Ole Miss is the lowest at 53%, meaning they will face teams that are around .500... Texas and Tennessee face identical win% at 54%. A&M and Missouri, 56% ..... Georgia, 60% .... Georgia also beat the SEC team they faced by 9 points in average.
The margin of victory was a metric point used to rank teams until 2008ish. It was removed to encourage sportsmanship, however it took away a teams ability to be recognized as being quality even when their competition isn't in the top 25.
I say that the SEC needs to make up their mind. Is it the number of top 20 victories, which is what they slam Texas for, or is the level of competition? If Georgia can benefit by saying the SEC teams are just way better and that fact should be considered when ranking teams, then Texas should benefit from that too.
Ward Manuel said his eyeballs test they had to watch all the games and see who played well. . That is absolutely ridiculous .. Not everybody plays the same competition. He should be impeached..
Word manual sounds like every car salesman I ever went to talk to. Absolutely ridiculous word Salad !!
Dude might still be angry UGA throttled Michigan in the semis in 2021.
There is no way the B10 have the Top 4 out 5 teams in the country,
The B10 is TERRIBLE THIS YEAR! its such a JOKE
You think just because over half of an entire conference has 5 wins or less makes them terrible? I do too 🤣big10 is a joke
@richboii6597 CFB overall is just NOT GOOD this year, a lot of OVERHYPED, OVERRATED, OVERVALUED teams
@@SilFord-o9f you’re 100% right. There’s no stand out elite teams. If Georgia and bama weren’t having an off year and Michigan was halfway decent then we wouldn’t even be talking about these big10 teams.
They should use the conference champions and then use the old BCS computer formula to fill it out.
You're right! That's the same thing I've been saying for years!
100% correct. These playoffs will be without the SEC in 2026 if it keeps going like this.
Televise the discussion,end of problem.
Miami, notre dame, penn state, and indiana are way over rated. If tiu lose at home to NIU you are not a playoff yeam
The committee needs to be transparent. This secrecy allows for rankings to look "cooked"
Everyone knows the SEC Is the best conference top to bottom in the country by far. big 10 is a joke every year
Send in the Feds!
Let's not forget the big 10 is the only conference to represent goose eggs in the playoff era, not just 1 but 2 goose eggs with one of those 2 teams being the most glorified team in all of college football, never in my life have they earned their annual praise or top 3 ranking and I don't care what anyone says about it, Ohio St is trash.
Exactly and Alabama and UGA almost never lose on neutral field.
Any 6-year old can add up wins and losses. We don't need a committee to do that. I'd rather have a computer with published SOS formulas than what we have now. The biggest lie in college football is that "you are what your record says you are." Yet here we are with a committee that effectively says all wins and losses are the same! I hope Greg Sankey blows up this CFP agreement ASAP so that the best teams are fairly rewarded for their efforts.
They keep this up they’ll find out.
Dont think the committee likes Kirby saying he has no idea what they are looking for. But he's right. Schedule strength should matter. Big 10 with 4 of top 5 is a total joke. Texas at 3 is a joke as well. Who have they beaten?
It's so simple, yet we make it so difficult by using BIG words out of Webster's dictionary and allowing all these platforms to weigh in on who, what, when, where, and how college football should be, especially the playoffs. All you have to do is open the dictionary and find the word "GREED", and every member of the CFP committee picture will be stamped by the word. All you have to do is follow the money. Anything that goes on "behind closed doors" is not legit, it's "secretive", it's "we have the power, the say so and no one can do anything about it. Oh wait, the TV networks are standing in the corners of the room too clearing their throats when the "common sense" of who, what, where, how, and why starts speaking and is quickly shut down. Bottom line is they, the CFP committee, have been instructed to fanagle the list to sway towards more of the Big 10 because the SEC has dominated all these years and IT'S TIME FOR A CHANGE. Michigan got it started last year and why? What was in the news, what had everyone's attention? - (THE CHEATING). YOU WERE GLUED TO YOUR TV DURING THE NC GAME WATCHING TO SEE IF MICHIGAN CHEATED!!!! So, if you keep controversy going that's what will draw more viewers. Best way to sum it up - as a kid you thought wrestling was real!!!! And now you learn the physicality part is real, they train, they sweat, they get injured------BUT THE OUTCOME IS SCRIPTED SO AS TO KEEP THE AUDIENCE ENGAGED, INTRIGUED, TALKING, FIRED UP!!! WHAT WILL PUT PEOPLE IN THE SEATS, AND LASTLY---------HOW MUCH $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ CAN I (ESPN - THE MOTHERSHIP) GET SO I CAN HAVE ALL THE POWER!!!!!!!!!!! AND IT'S OCCURRING RIGHT IN FRONT OF US BY HOW THEY HAVE RANKED TEAMS IN THE CFP - THE EVIDENCE IS RIGHT THERE!!!!!!! SMH!!!! AGAIN, SO SIMPLE.....LIKE A KID GETTING CAUGHT WITH HIS HAND IN THE COOKIE JAR, THEN TRYING TO EXPLAIN AS TO WHY AND THE KID STARTS TELLING HIS SIDE AND HAS ALL THESE REASONS - SOUND FAMILIAR? CFP COMMITTEE MEMBERS TRYING TO EXPLAIN THE RANKINGS BASED OFF OF STRENGTH OF SCHEDULE, OH WAIT, STRENGTH OF SCHEDULE IS NOT WEIGHTED, OH WAIT, THIS WEEK IT IS, OH WAIT, NOW IT'S NOT!!!!! WHAT MORE DO YOU NEED TO SEE????? BILLIONS AND BILLIONS OF $$$$$$$$$$$$ AND YES, WE WILL CONTINUE PACKING THE STADIUMS ON SATURDAYS!!!!!!!! ALL IS GOOD :)
SEC flip-flops are interesting. In years when the top of the SEC is unbeaten, they say the record should matter most. This year, when the top of the SEC has multiple losses, they say SOS should matter most. What metric will they promote next year, best weather at kickoff?
To all of the B10 clan, PLEASE STOP IT, THE B10 STINKS! You can tell a B10 guy is running this thing with Indiana & Penn St high up qith they have done NOTHING!
WARD MANUEL = MICHIGAN GUY B10 bias for a crappy league
💯 FTMF
We’re OK this is just a play spot for the playoffs. Just get your home-field advantage and keep winning. Nothing else matters none of these records matters it’s becoming an NFL week. Welcome baby.
It's not serious. It's a joke!
Neither was Texas last year one of the best teams last year. 12 -O Georgia lost the SEC championship to an 11 -1 Alabama I believe. Alabama got in. A 10-2 Texas beat a 9-3 Oklahoma State and won the Big 12 championship and Texas got in over Georgia. I may be wrong on my numbers but that is my memory on last year.
If strength of schedule don't matter then why is Indiana number 5 why not number 2 they are full of crap
really stupid process.......SMH
The want woke results in the NATTY because the SEC has dominated the finals for too many years
lol “national”
Georgia is playing a tough Massachusetts game this weekend.
Look at the ENTIRE schedule, MORON, NUMBSKULL
They deserve an easy game
Georgia is the biggest crybabies!
Pretty sure your team plays a team like this every week 😂
Which team had the toughest schedule this year?
Ifs and buts. Fact, good teams don't lose
Georgia has played a cupcake schedule for the last 5 years and they finally play a real schedule and now yall crying! The irony & how soft georgia folks are is pathetic Bama put the beats on ur head and ole miss stomped you out when are yall going to accept U ARE NO LONGER ELITE! GET OVER IT NOBODY SCARED OF GEORGIA! RTR 🏈🐘🏆
Hater. We got two chips in the last 5 years!!!! The strength of schedule for “this year” for UGA is insane. WHAT ROCK DO YOU LIVE UNDER?
What's wrong with you? Us SEC fans are trying to make 𝐚 point of Big Ten bias and here you are attacking Georgia. 🤡
In 2022 UGA played 7 top 25 teams, won 7, lost 0, and played/beat 3 top 6 teams. No one else in the country came close to UGA's schedule that year. How many top 25 teams did your team beat in 2022? How many top 25 teams did your team play in 2022 and what was their record against those top 25 teams???
@@reyb1649Alabama Fan, Reading Comprehension. You have to pick one haha
Ah yes. Like they didn't have to beat 2 top 4 teams to win both those Championships. Weak schedule. Got it.