Which Cinematic AI Video Tool is Best?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 126

  • @ZYTHI
    @ZYTHI Місяць тому +2

    I loved the in-depth comparison of Luma and Kling - it's clear you've put a lot of effort into testing these tools. I have to say, I'm impressed with both, but Luma's attention to detail and Kling's ability to understand prompts are standouts. Your analysis is spot on, and I appreciate the honesty about each tool's strengths and limitations. I'm excited to try them out for myself! One thing that would be great to see in future videos is a deeper dive into the ethical considerations of using AI in filmmaking. As you mentioned, some of these services are under lawsuits for stealing data, and it's crucial we consider the implications of relying on these tools. Nonetheless, your content is invaluable, and I look forward to seeing more

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      Definitely consider the ethics behind all the creative decisions using these tools. Thanks for engaging with us!

  • @MichaelMarshall53
    @MichaelMarshall53 Місяць тому +5

    Kling is clip 1, 4 & 6
    Luma is clip 2, 3 & 5

  • @Sjaano
    @Sjaano Місяць тому +5

    1.luma
    2.kling
    3.luma
    4.kling
    5.kling
    6.luma
    Great video as always!

  • @suzannecarter445
    @suzannecarter445 Місяць тому +2

    Loved this video! I'm so glad you didn't drag Runway into the comparison this time - not in same league. Wish I had your eye for detail/nuance.

  • @dylan_curious
    @dylan_curious Місяць тому +4

    That was awesome to see the comparisons

  • @Silverhare01
    @Silverhare01 Місяць тому +1

    Awesome, love how Ai is evolving.

  • @punchtalestudio
    @punchtalestudio Місяць тому +1

    At this stage it is a mash up of different platforms. I use LTX for character consistency and get the polishing on Runway.

  • @AiTechRealm
    @AiTechRealm Місяць тому

    Thanks for doing that comparison. Both Luma & Kling are very comparable, who ever updates there model first will get ahead.

  • @Anusiri-r9s
    @Anusiri-r9s Місяць тому

    As a cinephile and AI enthusiast, I've been experimenting with various AI video tools lately. It's amazing how far the technology has come! While there are several great options out there, I've found that the best tool depends on your specific needs and skill level. Some are better for beginners, while others offer more advanced features for pros. Have you tried any AI video tools yourself?

  • @EasyHap
    @EasyHap Місяць тому +11

    AI is not going to take actors job. The actor who uses AI well might take your job )

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      Haha, perhaps!

    • @jessejames7074
      @jessejames7074 Місяць тому +1

      AI will have an effect on actors in the future. Most actors are concentrated in a small place in Hollywood. How many times have you heard of them talking about selling their soul. The man that played Wolverine all these years was under contract to where he couldn't even have his own haircut or style the way he liked. These actors date other actors, it's an inside cult in the deeper you dig the more sick satanic shit that you will find I honestly feel that AI taking actor's jobs is a good thing. We are paying people and exorbitant amount of money to work for corporate entities that do not care about the betterment of humanity but only their wallets.

    • @allhopeabandon7831
      @allhopeabandon7831 Місяць тому

      I have been saying for at least a decade, that the films of the future will not be live actors, but rather the likeness of the actors and actresses. It won't be long until we can have a 20 y/o Jack Nicholson, and a 20 year old Errol Flynn, competing for the love interest of a 20 year old Jennifer Lawrence. They, or their estates or the owner of the likeness (bc holding companies will buy all the rights to an actors likeness if possible) will be paid for their likeness. It will be really cool, but it will make it that much harder for new actors to beak into Hollyweird, bc they will have an entire catalogue of any actor who has ever been in the industry...

  • @chariots8x230
    @chariots8x230 Місяць тому

    I’d say the AI video tool that follows prompts accurately and gives the user the most control is the best tool for filmmaking.

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      Fair point that's incredibly important!

  • @AiTechRealm
    @AiTechRealm Місяць тому

    thank god they released that brush tool, will be very useful.

  • @NOPEFallacy
    @NOPEFallacy Місяць тому +1

    1)KLING
    2)LUMA
    3)KLING
    4)LUMA
    5)LUMA
    6)KLING
    Thanks♥♥

  • @thewebstylist
    @thewebstylist Місяць тому +3

    Great highlights!

  • @KEMET1971
    @KEMET1971 Місяць тому

    Thank you for the A.I. tool list. A wonderful resource.

  • @ufologistsguide
    @ufologistsguide Місяць тому

    Great video as always Caleb. Have a good weekend!

  • @suzannecarter445
    @suzannecarter445 Місяць тому

    Great video! Could the issues with HD quality and framerate by fixed by running it through Topaz?

  • @AndersJægerPerdersen
    @AndersJægerPerdersen Місяць тому

    1: Luma
    2: Kling
    3: Luma
    4: Kling
    5: Kling
    6: Luma

  • @theTapePlayer
    @theTapePlayer Місяць тому

    1. Luma
    2. Kling
    3. Luma
    4. Kling
    5. Kling
    6. Luma

  • @viaarmada
    @viaarmada Місяць тому

    1. luma 2. kling 3. kling 4. luma 5. luma 6. kling

  • @DanFrederiksen
    @DanFrederiksen Місяць тому +1

    luma kling luma kling kling luma
    It's strange that video gens haven't gone AV gens to get characters talking with the subtitle data connected because video generation really takes off when characters act and speak. seems so obvious.

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      True! We can't wait to see how it all evolves soon!

  • @LenaIyer
    @LenaIyer Місяць тому +1

    1)LUMA
    2)KLING
    3)LUMA
    4)KLING
    5)KLING
    6)LUMA

  • @kikibutterfly1137
    @kikibutterfly1137 Місяць тому

    I’m excited to learn more!

  • @user-yo9nn2pu2s
    @user-yo9nn2pu2s Місяць тому +1

    Thank you for the vid!

  • @dynamic_scenes
    @dynamic_scenes Місяць тому

    🌟 Amazing video! I always enjoy your content! 👏

  • @BarryMcBangerz
    @BarryMcBangerz Місяць тому

    1. Kling 2. Luma 3. Luma 4. Kling 5. Luma 6. Kling

  • @temiloluwaolatunde5463
    @temiloluwaolatunde5463 Місяць тому

    Swordswoman = clip1 - Luma, clip2- Kling/
    Waves rising = clip1 - Luma, clip2 - Kling/
    Boy driving = clip1 - Kling, clip 2 - Luma.

  • @xzamac
    @xzamac Місяць тому

    Luma: 1,3,6
    Kling: 2,4,5

  • @evgenika2013
    @evgenika2013 Місяць тому

    Luma 1,3,6
    Kling 2,4,5

  • @oxide5688
    @oxide5688 Місяць тому

    1-luma,3-luma,6-luma. 2-kling, 4-kling, 5-kling

  • @leandromarcelo7515
    @leandromarcelo7515 Місяць тому

    1,3,6-Luma 2,4,5-Kling

    • @leandromarcelo7515
      @leandromarcelo7515 Місяць тому

      I did this documentary short with several IA tools ua-cam.com/video/s3MlEY48JJk/v-deo.html

  • @Twizzforsberg
    @Twizzforsberg Місяць тому +1

    Luma have not nailed any of my videos. Now my 30 free videos are out

  • @makeguyver8596
    @makeguyver8596 Місяць тому

    I appreciate you wanting to cover the evolving Ai video industry as a whole. I would love to see a series or separate channel that covers just the open source and free to use/local versions of Ai video generation, which is where the real possibilities will lie. No serious filmmaker is going to run their ideas and prompts through China or a pay to use generator. Now that we are seeing open source models please consider pushing the industry in this direction by providing your followers with the real goods and not simply the not quite ready offerings. As they appear on the scene obviously. Hopefully by years end.
    Oh and
    1 Luma 2 kling 3 kling 4 luma 5 luma 6 kling

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      Intersting point! The big issue is that the level of effort, technical know-how, and computer troubleshooting with open source models is quite a stretch for most people.

  • @orangeismedia
    @orangeismedia Місяць тому

    It’s a new winner every week

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      New tools, new updates, new everything !

  • @jakehill6418
    @jakehill6418 Місяць тому

    1.luma 2.kling 3.luma 4.kling5.kling 6.luma

  • @JamesBray-qm8gr-q3w
    @JamesBray-qm8gr-q3w Місяць тому +2

    I have been using all the AI tools for a year, and was excited at first. I work on militaryh history and ALL of the AI image generators and video creaters CANNOT do accurate military history with proper uniforms, accoutrements and weapons correctly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! There is a MARKET for accurate and realist historical military or otherwise historical images for books, article, videos and film! BUT NOTHING does it and I cannot understand why when there is so much references on the internet to train the AI!
    I am working a Civil War project and need images from both sides. I asked Midjourney to give me an image of Confederate President Jefferson Davis and it gave me 4 images of ALL black men!!!!!!!! Don't get me wrong, if I want an image of the brave 54th Mass colored infantry, I want them to be black. But my point is ALL AI is not being taught create accurate history because of WOKE horse shit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! These developers need to learn the saying that those who refuse to learn from history are doomed to repeat it!!!!!!!!!!!
    The AI creaters who develop a Historically accurate AI will make money!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      Thanks for sharing your perspective!

  • @Stirfryfilm
    @Stirfryfilm Місяць тому

    1,3,5 kling, rest is luma

  • @jmik9556
    @jmik9556 Місяць тому

    1-L 2-K 3-L 4-K 5-K 6-L -- Love you guys!!

  • @bermainai
    @bermainai Місяць тому

    video 1 : LUma
    video 2 : Kling
    video 3 : Luma
    video 4 : Kling
    video 5 : Kling
    video 6 : Luma

  • @Guicastellanos_AI
    @Guicastellanos_AI Місяць тому

    1 Luma
    2 Kling
    3 Kling
    4 Luma
    5 Luma
    6 Kling

  • @RodsFromGod_26
    @RodsFromGod_26 Місяць тому +2

    I don't get it. Kling STILL requires a chinese phone number!

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому +1

      Not anymore! You can sign up with just your email.

    • @RodsFromGod_26
      @RodsFromGod_26 Місяць тому +1

      @@curiousrefuge I just went there. Still a chinese phone #. You have an updated link? I'd really like to try it. thanks.

  • @Ai-Art-42
    @Ai-Art-42 Місяць тому

    Very interesting

  • @HistoriaHaul
    @HistoriaHaul Місяць тому

    I used luma create my Ai trailer

  • @Justin.Q
    @Justin.Q Місяць тому

    1. LUMA
    2. KLING
    3. KLING
    4. LUMA
    5. KLING
    6. LUMA

  • @AmarjitSingh-po2bp
    @AmarjitSingh-po2bp Місяць тому

    1 luma
    2 kling
    3 luma
    4 kling
    5 kling
    6 luma

  • @neamedia
    @neamedia Місяць тому

    Kling-Luma, Luma-Kling, Luma-Kling

  • @PrinceVeganin
    @PrinceVeganin Місяць тому

    Kling, Luma, Luma, Kling, Kling, Luma

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      You got it right!! Feel free to email us here letting us know you won the webshow competition and we will get you your prize.
      hello@curiousrefuge.com

  • @Soundpaintmusic
    @Soundpaintmusic Місяць тому

    Some of the services mentioned are under lawsuits for stealing data. How do you feel about promoting such services?

    • @NoidoDev
      @NoidoDev Місяць тому

      😅 These lawsuits should be thrown out much faster.

    • @Soundpaintmusic
      @Soundpaintmusic Місяць тому

      @@NoidoDev Tell that to all the music makers of the world - whose materials have been trained upon without permission.

    • @NoidoDev
      @NoidoDev Місяць тому

      @@Soundpaintmusic
      Going to make some song on Suno about it.

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      These are tools. We tell people to use tools ethically.

    • @Soundpaintmusic
      @Soundpaintmusic Місяць тому

      @@curiousrefuge You can't use an illegal tool "ethically". The challenge is how those tools were made in the first place. Some of them is that they were illegally trained on music without permission - and are currently heading for lawsuits as a result thereof. Ultimately it means a couple of tech bros cash in on the work of millions - while destroying the respective industries they are taking from. So these aren't just "tools" - there are disruptive tools and destructive too, since the people creating the work never gets compensated.

  • @particlepanic
    @particlepanic Місяць тому

    For everyone who wants to get an impression, I made the AI movie trailer for "Riefenstahl" entirely using Luma AI's Dream Machine (image to video): ua-cam.com/video/BDHs8CJdKY0/v-deo.html

  • @RJay121
    @RJay121 Місяць тому

    Huh. I still dont see how Kling or Sora or Llama can change little things in a scene without redesigning the entire scene. AI can not reason. So AI imagery seems trapped in a gilded cage 😢

    • @bradloflin6776
      @bradloflin6776 Місяць тому +1

      Llama... scene...
      what are you referring to? must have meant Luma

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      We appreciate you watching and commenting!

  • @lane-t4u
    @lane-t4u Місяць тому

    Luma
    Kling
    Kling
    Luma
    Luma
    Kling

  • @rodentrider2
    @rodentrider2 Місяць тому

    8 bit ryan looking ahh

  • @HelamanGile
    @HelamanGile Місяць тому +1

    1 k
    2 l
    3 k
    4 l
    5 l
    6 k

  • @oxide5688
    @oxide5688 Місяць тому

    hi

  • @AiStudiosWithKyle
    @AiStudiosWithKyle Місяць тому

    hello

  • @NoidoDev
    @NoidoDev Місяць тому

    1:10 - So you don't think for yourself?

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      Thanks for watching! We do think for ourselves :)

  • @NeonCucumber
    @NeonCucumber Місяць тому

    Bro you look like ai in this cid

  • @AiMotionStudio
    @AiMotionStudio Місяць тому

    Made this AI Movie Teaser using Kling AI: ua-cam.com/video/-UDebQL2qb0/v-deo.html

  • @chrystal.spiezio
    @chrystal.spiezio Місяць тому

    omg, too much talking, why dpont you just give the list and what it does. i cant watch long videos just yapping on

  • @stevo728822
    @stevo728822 Місяць тому

    Please put your hands down. Stop waving them around. This is a mistake all young You Tubers make.

  • @CsokaErno
    @CsokaErno 23 дні тому

    Are you a real person?

  • @ai.ai.captain
    @ai.ai.captain Місяць тому

    8:07 most important deciding factor…❤🫡

  • @pablochea1554
    @pablochea1554 Місяць тому

    Clip 1 Luma - Clip 2 Kling / Clip 3 Kling - Clip 4 Luma / Clip 5 Kling - Clip 6 Luma

  • @oggy3D
    @oggy3D Місяць тому

    kling is paid u have to pay to generate anything shlt site

    • @curiousrefuge
      @curiousrefuge  Місяць тому

      You have some free credits that you can get through first.

  • @2beck
    @2beck Місяць тому

    1.luma 2.kling
    3.luma 4.kling
    5.kling 6.luma

  • @ExTern-nl4ov
    @ExTern-nl4ov Місяць тому

    Kling, Luma, Luma, Kling, Luma, Kling

  • @topherwinters
    @topherwinters Місяць тому

    1. Luma
    2. Kling
    3. Kling
    4. Luma
    5. Luma
    6. Kling

  • @TheBlessingReport
    @TheBlessingReport Місяць тому

    1. Luma 2. Luma 3. Kling 4. Luma 5. Kling 6. Kling

  • @kc-jm3cd
    @kc-jm3cd Місяць тому

    1. LUMA
    2. KLING
    3. LUMA
    4. KLING
    5. KLING
    6. LUMA