Usually, the first time you hear a song, that is the version you will prefer (think Downtown Train by Rod Stewart and the original Tom Waits song). But I think with this comparison, it does not matter. The Bee Gees wins hands down!
I had never heard the first cover, I really enjoyed it. But, the original, Bee Gees can't be beat. It still gives me goose bumps after all theses years.
The BeeGee's hands down.Its pronounced Bee(as in bumblebee)and Gee(as in gosh,or golly,gee I'm not sure)It stands for Brothers Gibb.Barry is the tallest one(all the teeth And hair)then the twins, Maurice (pronounced Morris)with the receeding hairline and his twin brother Robin.They had another brother named Andy who died first,then Maurice,then his twin, Robin.The only one still alive is the oldest brother.
There is nothing like the Brother’s Gibb, Bee Gees, in the top five trio of all time. You will love reacting to so many more of their songs. Nights on Broadway,Fanny, Lonely Days,How Can You Mend A Broken Heart,You Should Be Dancing and more!
I am 64 years old . I danced under the disco globe light, to this song with the love of my life who later became my ex. Looking back I feel so fortunate. But at this age I found the remake remarkable however the Bee Gees hands down . Your sweet reaction is honest comes across as heartfelt. And I would surmise that the two Bee Gees who are now in heaven are smiling as well at your reaction. That their music lives on. Thank you so much
The Beatles Twist and Shout is a cover so I’m not sure that’s a valid criticism. The problem is it wasn’t a good cover lol. In the end we agree, Bed Gees win in a walkover
HOW CAN YOU COMPARE????? BEEEE JEEEEZZ!!! LOL .. 200 MILLION RECORDS SOLD. THE BEST TRIO HARMONY OF THE 20TH CENTURY. PERIOD. NOT SHOUTING. JUST LOVE AND FACTS. SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER SOUNDTRACK SONG. WORLD FAMOUS. ❤❤❤
Went on a date to the movies 1978 to see Saturday Night Fever the girl that was with me cried so much I got emotional too, then after the movie we went and made love, great memories love the movie, love the song "HOW DEEP IS YOUR LOVE"...RIP Bee Gee brothers #3...Only one left...
This is Bee Gees and it isn't even close for me. They wrote the song, performed it first and performed it the best. The Bee Gees version peaked at #1 in the US on Xmas 1977 and stayed in the top 10 for a then-record 17 straight weeks! And it is just pronounced 'Bee Jeez' (not Bees and Gees); Bee Gees stands for the "brothers Gibb" as the group was made up of brothers Barry, Robin and Maurice Gibb. Barry, the one with the high falsetto, is the only surviving member.
The BeeGee's. Back in the 70's they were a closet group. In public you hated them. I mean it was rock against disco. But at home in private you would throw on the Saturday night Fever soundtrack and jam out
I am an older person and was raised on the B-Gs. I like YABBA because I could feel the love they put into it. They are clearly fans and that is a good thing. Not a competition, but if the B-Gs music is going to survive more people need to discover it, interpret it , and do their own spin on it. Everything moves on.
Bee Gees....Hits the emotive strings and the memories come flooding back!!! They are towards the top, if not at the top of the Premier League when it comes to music. The PJ Morton version was nice, but doesn't compare....it's almost unfair to pit artists against the BEE GEES when it comes to their material, because that brotherly connection and harmonies that had be honed since they were kids will always win out!!
Bee Gees is my favorite, I used to listen to this song over and over again way back in the day lol. Okay, India, their name is pronounced B Geez... readeal
The Bee Gees are the authors, the originals. the hit makers. I'm not sure who those others were but they get a trophy for participating. No go sit down and let The Brothers Gibb show how they made it a hit. BTW, when younger people mispronounce the names of legendary bands/groups it makes me feel............... so OLD! lol
First of all I want to say love the shirt the greatest Band ever. But back to the video this is one beautiful songs though they're did a great version. The Bee Gees hands down. One of the all time greats. Nobody can do a Bee Gees song like the original singer
I loved India’s reaction here, and the song was taken from 2 different angles, one more soul inspired, one as ballad pop rock. So it may be a tough choice for some. All in what you like. As for India’s pronouncing the band’s name is not Jeep at all. She kept saying Bee n Gees. Remove the “n”... it’s just Bee (like don’t get stung by that bee) Gees. That’s all Bee Gees. But it made me chuckle.
Bees and Gees. Lord have mercy🤣🤣🤣🤣
Pray for me 😩😭😭
@@OhMyGoshIndia 🙏
@@OhMyGoshIndia You are forgiven my child!!!....Just don't make a habit of it!!
That made my day!!!
@@OhMyGoshIndia we did. You’re good now. 👍
Whenever you have a question of Bee Gees vs ??, the answer is always the Bee Gees.
Louise Flintoff love this. Exactly how I feel!
exactly!
Louise Flintoff
NO DOUBT ✌️😎
Agreed
Agree
Bee Gees handsdown! Also, the Bee Gees wrote this song! MORE Bee Gees PLEASE!
Right on brother, yes definitely the Bee Gees!!! Wish she'd react to The Nights on Broadway, one of the best songs they, as far as I'm concerned 😃😃😃
Without a doubt--The Bee Gees.
Bee Gees. NO question about it.
💯😁
👍
💯
Definitely Bee Gees.
BeeGees. No contest. And it's Bee Gees, not bees and gees.
Bee Gees all day every day 💯 often imitated, never duplicated.
The Bee Gees were iconic and when you reach that pinnacle, others covering their songs are simply a compliment.
Hands down The Brothers Gibb!🎶🎧
The Bee Gees wrote the song so the others are just covers.
I liked both ,but i would have to vote for the BeeGees it is their song originally.
So many copy cats why.play.not the.originals so irritating
Can't beat the Bee Gees...SO BEAUTIFUL!!! 😍😇😍😇😍😇
You can't beat an original. Bee Gees had a unique sound.
I disagree. You absolutely CAN beat an original. Of course it did not happen here ;)
Bee Gees always 😊
Definitely Bee Geee's!!!!!!
Bee Gees, they ended up selling 120 million albums. Someone liked them
For billboard 250 million records
I heard is more than 220 millions albums...
I love jazz. But, this felt like they were just singing around the notes. Bee Gees hands down.
They are both great but, Bee Gees for me
The Bee Gees Hands Down, all others are just paying tribute.
Bee gees.... that is all
Pure masterpiece
Barry Gibb’s voice from The Bee Gees is one of a kind.
True but those harmonies with his brothers are extraordinary
@@Michelle-pc6gp everything about the Bee Gees was extraordinary including Barry.
I LOVE the PJ Morton/Yebba version. But the Bee Gees wrote the song, their harmonies are so so beautiful ... that says it all!
The Bee Gees!!
Usually, the first time you hear a song, that is the version you will prefer (think Downtown Train by Rod Stewart and the original Tom Waits song). But I think with this comparison, it does not matter. The Bee Gees wins hands down!
I had never heard the first cover, I really enjoyed it. But, the original, Bee Gees can't be beat. It still gives me goose bumps after all theses years.
Bee Gees all the way! The Bee Gees also wrote EMOTION, classic song!
Bee Gees, all day and all night...🤟🏿😎
COME ON IS THIS A JOKE.
The BeeGee's hands down.Its pronounced Bee(as in bumblebee)and Gee(as in gosh,or golly,gee I'm not sure)It stands for Brothers Gibb.Barry is the tallest one(all the teeth And hair)then the twins, Maurice (pronounced Morris)with the receeding hairline and his twin brother Robin.They had another brother named Andy who died first,then Maurice,then his twin, Robin.The only one still alive is the oldest brother.
Bee Gee one thousand percent.. You should check out Too much heaven.
There is nothing like the Brother’s Gibb, Bee Gees, in the top five trio of all time. You will love reacting to so many more of their songs. Nights on Broadway,Fanny, Lonely Days,How Can You Mend A Broken Heart,You Should Be Dancing and more!
Just get the whole soundtrack of Saturday Night Fever. Their songwriting is phenomenal.
Bee Gees 💯 3 Gibb brothers vs an orchestra and still won❣
The Bee Gees, baby. They wrote the song and felt it the most, bless their beautiful hearts.
The problem with covering this song is that the original (Bee Gees) is perfect.
I am 64 years old . I danced under the disco globe light, to this song with the love of my life who later became my ex. Looking back I feel so fortunate. But at this age I found the remake remarkable however the Bee Gees hands down . Your sweet reaction is honest comes across as heartfelt. And I would surmise that the two Bee Gees who are now in heaven are smiling as well at your reaction. That their music lives on. Thank you so much
Bee Gee's by a mile! Aint nothin' like the real thing!
The Bee Gees hands down! They were the original writers and singers of this song. The other stuff is just a cover.
The Beatles Twist and Shout is a cover so I’m not sure that’s a valid criticism. The problem is it wasn’t a good cover lol. In the end we agree, Bed Gees win in a walkover
Bee Gees 100% ❤️❤️❤️❤️ Their voices are out of this world 💞
No doubts...!!!
Bee Gees.
BeeGees. No doubt. I have listened to them since I was in my teens.
BG's (short for Brothers Gibb) version definitely!!!
I always thought they should be called the Bees Gee.
Bee Gee's 💯 Not even close
The Bee Gees have stood the test of time...a timeless classic. Hard to beat their harmonizing. One word...smoooooth.
Bee Gees.... Hands down
Bee Gees for sure
PJ Morton & Yebba won a grammy for that cover!
That first cover was shocking, no one can better the original, your reaction says it all
HOW CAN YOU COMPARE????? BEEEE JEEEEZZ!!! LOL .. 200 MILLION RECORDS SOLD. THE BEST TRIO HARMONY OF THE 20TH CENTURY. PERIOD. NOT SHOUTING. JUST LOVE AND FACTS. SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER SOUNDTRACK SONG. WORLD FAMOUS. ❤❤❤
Went on a date to the movies 1978 to see Saturday Night Fever the girl that was with me cried so much I got emotional too, then after the movie we went and made love, great memories love the movie, love the song "HOW DEEP IS YOUR LOVE"...RIP Bee Gee brothers #3...Only one left...
This is Bee Gees and it isn't even close for me. They wrote the song, performed it first and performed it the best. The Bee Gees version peaked at #1 in the US on Xmas 1977 and stayed in the top 10 for a then-record 17 straight weeks! And it is just pronounced 'Bee Jeez' (not Bees and Gees); Bee Gees stands for the "brothers Gibb" as the group was made up of brothers Barry, Robin and Maurice Gibb. Barry, the one with the high falsetto, is the only surviving member.
Bee Gees baby!!!
You can't compare them, one being live and a different take on the song. But to choose, Bee Gee's all the way.
Bee Gees for sure!!!!!
As most everyone has stated, the PJ Morton version is okay, but there is not any comparing it to the B-G's version. In any fashion.
The original are the best!!! BEE GEES No.1 Forever!!!
PLEASE do more reaction of Bee Gees
without even listening to anyone else .... BeeGees all the wayyyyyyyyy
Bee Gees. The cover was really good, but the Bee Gees were on another level
Bee gees..sounds like bee Jees...wrote so many songs ..Very talented.
it is Jees but spelt Gees
The first was a worthy effort, but you know the classic is the best.
Bee Gees,
Hands down.
Not even close.sorry
Bee Gees best male vocals, falsetto, writers, performers, Hair!!
Bee Gees by far, they are and always will be the greatest group ever!!
The bee gees there’s no match against them the best trio EVER 😍👌
Bee gees hands down
Rest In Peace Robin and Maurice Gibb 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽 thanks for the memories
Who sang it better?! REALLY?! The Bee Gees without question!!
The BeeGee's. Back in the 70's they were a closet group. In public you hated them. I mean it was rock against disco. But at home in private you would throw on the Saturday night Fever soundtrack and jam out
Bee Gees all the way. They're untouchable. Yebba is really good but the Bee Gees were great.
I am an older person and was raised on the B-Gs. I like YABBA because I could feel the love they put into it. They are clearly fans and that is a good thing. Not a competition, but if the B-Gs music is going to survive more people need to discover it, interpret it , and do their own spin on it.
Everything moves on.
The Bee Gees' music of love soars into clouds and beyond, while reaching deep into the depths
The girl takes it to another level .
No contest. The Bee Gees original is the best.
Bee Gees....Hits the emotive strings and the memories come flooding back!!! They are towards the top, if not at the top of the Premier League when it comes to music. The PJ Morton version was nice, but doesn't compare....it's almost unfair to pit artists against the BEE GEES when it comes to their material, because that brotherly connection and harmonies that had be honed since they were kids will always win out!!
Not doubt.. the Bee Gees. And it is pronounced the "B G's"( Bee Gees)
The Bee Gee's owned the last part of the 70's with 6 #1's in a row and this tune was the first of those 6 #1's.
Yebba reaches in and makes this song more than a song of love between two people, it almost has the feel of a spiritual, it is soulful.
Bee Gees is my favorite, I used to listen to this song over and over again way back in the day lol. Okay, India, their name is pronounced B Geez...
readeal
2 words describe the Bee Gees. Awesome harmonies! 👌
You should react to "To much heaven ",by the Bee Gees, it's a great song
Bee Gees easily. No one had that much soul and feel in their voice like the Bee Gees. The epitome of pure sounding music.
bee gees all the way
No school like old school....Bee Gees every day and twice on Sunday
The Bee Gees are the authors, the originals. the hit makers. I'm not sure who those others were but they get a trophy for participating. No go sit down and let The Brothers Gibb show how they made it a hit. BTW, when younger people mispronounce the names of legendary bands/groups it makes me feel............... so OLD! lol
they did actually get a ‘trophy for participating’ , it was the grammy for best traditional r&b record
@@nicktomato7 We'll aren't they special.
@@sirslice it’s just funny that you said they get a trophy lol
The Bee Gees by far !
Bee Gees, of course
It was a great cover. I prefer The Bee Gees, but they did a good job, too.
That girl could really SING!!!!!
It was touch and go with your comparison, however my dear India the bee gees are beyond legendary
Always get the tingles when I hear this song 🎵
There is no contest. Bee Gees are in a different league. They are one of the worlds greatest bands.
Bee Gees love them.
Bee Gees of course
Bee Gees reaction: I'm melting....I'm melting.
Some songs should not be covered..... This is one of them
Yes this is TRUE!
Jed Keelan Agreed!
First of all I want to say love the shirt the greatest Band ever. But back to the video this is one beautiful songs though they're did a great version. The Bee Gees hands down. One of the all time greats. Nobody can do a Bee Gees song like the original singer
HAVE YOU DONE "TOO MUCH HEAVEN" BY THE BEE GEES??? GET ON IT
Yes!!
yes yes yes
Definitely!
ABSOLUTELY!
The Fatman
Could you ask in a nice tone??
Get right on that!! ✌️😎
The Bee Gees , beautiful like a rainbow !
Bee Gees. If you're going to do more of the Brothers Gibb, it *has* to be Stayin' Alive.
no question,,,BEE GEES for sure!!
Bee Gees but I am 58 and was a teenager when the Bee Gees did it. So I might have some bias.
BeeGees ... Hands Down!! no question. BeeGees just transport you somewhere else
There's a reason why the Bee Gees are so famous. Btw "Gees" rhymes with "Jeep." Or like "Gee Whiz." 😉
I loved India’s reaction here, and the song was taken from 2 different angles, one more soul inspired, one as ballad pop rock. So it may be a tough choice for some. All in what you like.
As for India’s pronouncing the band’s name is not Jeep at all. She kept saying Bee n Gees. Remove the “n”... it’s just Bee (like don’t get stung by that bee) Gees. That’s all Bee Gees. But it made me chuckle.
@@jtpencils Bee Gees is spoken like Bee Jees
Pye Ltd. yeah, she just needs to drop the N in between.
India, the Bee Gees hands down. And it's not Bee and Gees, just Bee Gees. Thanks for your reactions, they're wonderful.
BeeGees.. Better.. Pronounced BG's good songs girl..
The BEEGEES Album, Children of the World album was spectacular! Every song was great! Especially "Subway" and "Lovers".
Damn! I didn't know that