The Beauty of Limitations (GM Tips with Satine Phoenix)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 51

  • @Peclo444
    @Peclo444 7 років тому +50

    I once GM'd a game where we just used a d4:
    1: Total failure
    2: Failure
    3: Success
    4: Total Success
    The setting was inspired by Akira and a PS1 fighting game we were playing earlier that night. I don't know how, but I was able to just come up with all this story line off the cuff, and it was probably the best role playing experiences I ever had.

    • @RPanda3S
      @RPanda3S 7 років тому

      Noah Pechal Nice.

    • @finaloctober2301
      @finaloctober2301 7 років тому

      the problem i see with that is that all players have equal strengths and weaknesses, discouraging introverts from participation

  • @mikegould6590
    @mikegould6590 7 років тому +12

    A very good friend and I once built a custom bike together from salvage. When I asked him “why salvage?”, he said back “the greatest limitation to creativity is the lack of limitations”. Odd, but true.
    Limitations allow for hyperfocus and the ability to calm those who get overwhelmed easily.
    Then, from those limitations, you can build as freely as you want, building new borders as you push the envelope slowly.
    I also encourage collaboration. When I wanted to start my last campaign, I told the players I had an idea for an island-hopping steampunk setting.
    Two players made two new races from scratch, and one used an established race but took it in a new direction.
    When they knew water would be a challenge, one built an aquatic race, one built a race that invents, and another focused on island to island trade.
    This worry about water and travelling it’s expanse meant they needed to adapt, and they did through creation.
    And I loved it.
    My youngest daughter is big on collaborative story, so although she started with little story at first, we built a family, island, culture, race, and economy collaborating.
    It was amazing.
    All because I told them their races had to deal with water or be trapped.
    My best friend made an amazing race with me called the Thullings, which were tentacle-haired aquatic “Teiflings” whose curse could be traced back to a Cthulhu like Kraken elder god.
    Restrictions sparked the story. Collaboration built it.
    And I’ll always treasure Jinx the Copper Gnome Barbarian mechanic, and Illandria the Thulling “Ceph” (Warlock) of this Elder Goddess.
    Awesome.

    • @tylerh2548
      @tylerh2548 6 років тому

      Mike Gould the Thullings remind me of the medusa (i think) pirate from the recent New World inspired Magic: the Gathering setting. Awesome idea to have "tieflings" tied to extraplanar forces that occupy the same place as devils but are, well, not devilish. I will definitely steal this thought process from your friend through your comment. Awesome stuff.

  • @SleeJeroen
    @SleeJeroen 7 років тому +3

    "i'm Building epic stories, for the bar after the game" Yes man!

  • @STEEVEWES
    @STEEVEWES 7 років тому +8

    Great! I always try To pass the ball as much as I can, I don't want to be the DM who do a lots of monologue and then Boom, combat. I had a DM like these, it was not fun at all. I really like the in between fight where all the players are just role playing and getting more and more roots in the world I've built for them.

    • @bryanwilmarth1435
      @bryanwilmarth1435 6 років тому

      I hear you, Steevewes. It's easy, as a GM, to get lost in the rules, lore, etc. and forget that the PCs need to have voices as well. I, too, have played with sort of GM. BORING. I love my players who REALLY get into their characters' heads and determine WHO they are which hopefully will increase their roleplay and have discussions amongst themselves forgetting I'm even there!

  • @NightSwift271
    @NightSwift271 7 років тому

    THANK YOU for this! With the limitations I am a strong advocate for more limitations story and world-wise (especially because I play pathfinder), because I think there are so many options and it is so open that you will often face writers block or dm paralyses if you dont have a centered focus and narrative. As for rules they should be flexible and in the end rulings can drastically differ between who is interpreting them, but having rules to base everything on is still very nice. Again many thanks for posting this, it really helps to explain my thinking to my players.

  • @lionskull1
    @lionskull1 7 років тому +7

    It would be awesome if you can link to some of the things spoken of in the video in the description. like the roll for shoes, or dread, or anything else like that.

  • @snowlio117
    @snowlio117 7 років тому +20

    i would like to see her bring on a DM who is a rules lawyer. cause they are not all bad, for me if i succeed within the confines of the system it means more, and feels like i earned the victory/success. If my DM just says "cool it works" it feels fake. I would be interested to see that side of rpg's on here. The rules heavy dm who is not a dick.

  • @jeffco5237
    @jeffco5237 7 років тому

    Best GM Tips yet! Thank you Satine & Sax.

  • @serfington3137
    @serfington3137 7 років тому +1

    I fucking love this series, thank you for continuing to host an amazing show Satine! Because of yours and Matt Mercer's work and dialogue I'm finally hosting my own games and couldn't be happier!

  • @MemphiStig
    @MemphiStig 6 років тому +1

    80s flashback. the game was called TWERPS (the world's easiset role-playing system). every character had one stat, and there was only one die to roll. there were several versions of the game, one for sci-fi, one for martial arts, etc., but it was all the same simple idea. i'm glad to see this "less is more" concept/style lives on. cuz, really, who needs 30 500-page rulebooks?

  • @BigPhatPandaGaming
    @BigPhatPandaGaming 7 років тому +2

    This is a ton helpful. Thanks so much for the tips! :)

  • @shallendor
    @shallendor 7 років тому +1

    Honey Heist is such a fun game, i ran it for our 5E group and had so much fun! I wonder if Sax would allow Wil Wheaton to touch his lucky dice?

  • @InitiallyDirty
    @InitiallyDirty 7 років тому +1

    These videos are so great - I would love for you guys to do a topic of things to add to your DM prep like "Rory Story Cubes", such a great tool!!

    • @RPanda3S
      @RPanda3S 7 років тому

      BJ. Hall Have much experience with them yourself? Seems like a fun novelty but I'm afraid that they would out-stay their usefulness quickly.

    • @InitiallyDirty
      @InitiallyDirty 7 років тому

      R_Panda they are great, use them for plot books or random quests, aids in creation of quests, and even enables you too improv on the fly with small details.

  • @jdooley1982
    @jdooley1982 7 років тому

    Great episode! Totally going to play Honey Heist at Thanksgiving (Canadian) this weekend.

  • @garoutail
    @garoutail 7 років тому +3

    So happy to hear someone mention RIFTS. And I would love to try Tactical Waifu if you can go full anime.

  • @meakimon
    @meakimon 7 років тому +1

    This reminds me of when my DM had to go get take out, and I just got into the DM seat and started making up an adventure where the other players where fighting against a stale pizza that wanted to kill them. I had them roll some dice, but I basically just made up the rules as I went along. 10 minute silly story with many laughs. XD

  • @vazak11
    @vazak11 5 років тому

    This was fun!

  • @cavepilled
    @cavepilled 7 років тому +1

    My first ever D&D game will have me as a DM. Wish me luck, guys.

  • @WaltRBuck
    @WaltRBuck 7 років тому +7

    I'm going to role my percentile dice. The amount rolled is the percentage that I absolutely love the tips and adore Satine. HOLY COW! 1000% on a 100 percentile dice set! AMAZING!

  • @NeiroAtOpelCC
    @NeiroAtOpelCC 7 років тому +3

    Is there a link to that show on the twitch channel mentioned near the end?

    • @Trokotof
      @Trokotof 7 років тому

      go.twitch.tv/videos/147352763 (for subscribers only of corse)

  • @danmenard6917
    @danmenard6917 6 років тому

    Kinda reminds me of the game "Kobolds Ate My Baby" which is also a Beer and Pretzels style game.

  • @PurpleAlzir
    @PurpleAlzir 7 років тому +3

    So what are your opinions on the Fate/Fate Accelerated system? It seems like one Sax might enjoy from how he seemed in this video.

    • @chrisvalentine3122
      @chrisvalentine3122 7 років тому

      Yea, I was thinking to myself "Sooooo, basically the fate system?"

  • @lordbiscuitthetossable5352
    @lordbiscuitthetossable5352 6 років тому

    This vid wasn't quite what I expected, but give me food for thought regarding rules usage with my colleagues.

  • @Sasqmo
    @Sasqmo 7 років тому

    Query... does the Mobile Feat effect a character's mount?

  • @dirtriderxr
    @dirtriderxr 7 років тому +1

    I don't suppose anyone can help me out by giving me a link to the twitch video he mentioned in her "favorite DM moment" question.

    • @Trokotof
      @Trokotof 7 років тому

      go.twitch.tv/videos/147352763 (for subscribers only of corse)

    • @dirtriderxr
      @dirtriderxr 7 років тому

      Christophe Alonso thank you very much.

  • @bryanwilmarth1435
    @bryanwilmarth1435 6 років тому

    "What are you expecting to see in the room?" LOVE IT!

  • @pooka573
    @pooka573 7 років тому +1

    10 six packs? wow @6:48 hehe

  • @Athril
    @Athril 7 років тому

    I died when I saw "tactical waifu"

  • @khodexus4963
    @khodexus4963 4 роки тому +1

    Funny coincidence, I also started DMing in sixth grade playing AD&D 2nd edition. But I actually DID understand the rules. And yes, I know that's one of the most complicated versions of D&D.

  • @brendanloriogara2071
    @brendanloriogara2071 7 років тому +1

    Gravity Dice rather high-end dice cost like 20$ for two die..Limitations are nice I agree, however in every rendition of gaming, I have played, and I started back in Chain-Mail, there can be found at least one sentence, that says something, to the effect that if any of the rules do not work, toss it. So limitations work and some do not, now nice to see you however I have to go get back to my Pathfinder game , 8 players every Friday with 2 alternate players on alternate weekends....Out.

  • @Troommate
    @Troommate 7 років тому +1

    I'm more than happy to Colour between the Lines :D

  • @daemonskycloak6818
    @daemonskycloak6818 7 років тому

    I love learning about DnD stuff but this channel has lost the variety it used to have. It's not LARP and gm tips and that's about as much variety we get.

  • @son0fgrim
    @son0fgrim 7 років тому +1

    Well if last weeks video was anything to go by, This weeks game is about too be a fucking shit show.

  • @Phoenix_
    @Phoenix_ 7 років тому +3

    I’m first, but nobody cares.

    • @obstgarteninnot9340
      @obstgarteninnot9340 7 років тому +2

      PhoenixFire42 True

    • @tntjperic
      @tntjperic 7 років тому +2

      very true

    • @WaltRBuck
      @WaltRBuck 7 років тому +3

      I would reply but it would show that I cared enough... oh crap.

  • @starcrafter13terran
    @starcrafter13terran 7 років тому

    Can she do a tip without some guest? Matt didn't seem to need any help doing them.