How BJP is using 2024 Lok Sabha polls to lay groundwork for PM Modi's succession
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 кві 2024
- Denial of tickets to politically entrenched MPs, lightweights as CMs, ministers and in key party positions, promotion of select detractors-- battle of succession in BJP has begun, ThePrint's Political Editor DK Singh analyses in this episode of #PoliticallyCorrect
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read DK Singh's column here : theprint.in/opinion/political...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
You can interpret all you want. BJP is 10 steps ahead of you 😅
Overconfidence like this will be the downfall of BJP.
Hitler thought the same
This video is by far the worst political analysis by the Print. Completely ignoring powerful upcoming leaders like Annamalai and ignoring the fact that Fadnavis and Yogi both have a strong voter base in their respective states.
@@nakulmohan115Pl continue dreaming and moaning
@@akshayagrawal5114Pl stop ranting
Clear bjp is not a family party.....it pains print...bjp is still different from most of the parties
Well said! This is an anti BJP channel
Exactly, print sets the tone and direction as how to view these situations
BJP is an unjust rude arrogant party, dosen't want to see anyone grow, sympathize with victim de facto, paint Modi like dictator
What print doesn't realize, there's another POV that you mentioned
BJP dosen't bow down to family pressure, puts checks and balances, and take decisions according to their judgement
Hutiye at print thinks, they'll push the former narrative, and it'll work in social media.
While some gullible people might fall into this, it makes certainly more people staunchly support a party who's facing such vile and evil L E F T I S T S
Who is BJP Karnataka State unit President? What are his achievements that got him this achievement?
I don't like INC and now BJP is becoming the same as INC
No. It promotes people who are chelas in the name of "common man" getting ticket. Talent , ability and own base is a problem for Modi.
@@sukantpanigrahi76 I agree. I still will vote BJP..... bjp has few families...congress is family has a party
1. Vishnu Dev Soy was Minster of State in Modi Govt from 2014-19. He was denied ticket in 2019 elections but showed no resentment & continued to work for the party vigorously. Subsequently he was made President of Chatisgarh BJP. He was removed from this post after one term but he remained fully commited to the party. Now he has been made CM of Chhatisgarh.
2. Vinod Tawade was Minister in Fadnawis Govt, Maharastra from 2014- 19 but denied Assembly ticket in 2019. Without showing resentment he continued to remain commited to the party and even said that he would have committed some mistake and will introspect to come up to the expectation of the party. Subsequently he was made National Secretary and thereafter elevated as National General Secretary. Today he is considered very powerful in BJP organisation.
There are many such examples in BJP which prove that committed workers donot remain in wilderness for long. Ajay Nishad, Rahul Kaswan, Bijender Singh are not grass root workers of the party and believe in entitlement being dynasts and their leaving BJP will not harm the party in the long run.
Funding ke karan he log ye nahin boltey
thats a very valid point
In democracy, non democracy countries all are controlled by Power ful people, top business man people.
There is no denial of that.
But I laugh when they says America democracy is more good than India democracy here modi promoting private players 😂.
Is American govt not controlled by private company?
It is inevitable in this materialistic world.
But still modi doing things to support poor section of society without discrimination - toilet, gas, house, health cover, loan to start self business and now solar panel at roof scheme (all are given only for first time in free, others are just support them in 50% funding, etc.
Free ration is to give them free hand for some yrs to move out poverty line perfectly)
Also -
Like deep state, private player control govt.
Still Indian democracy is alive and vibrant that a poor people can become pm of india😊.
Here above dk Singh just telling previous winning record is enough reason to get him ticket 😂.
Some people who denied ticket already winning 2-3 times , and also son of another winning candidate.
Now to provide his point, dk Singh eliminate Dynasty in politics 😂😂
These people leave party also shows how much they were loyal to bjp😂.
Also yes I am agree - modi is creating a army of loyal supporter in party to let succession plan done peacefully😂.
But still like whole bjp unit was against modi in 2013 but cadre support him, so no leader in bjp could successful in stopping him.
Modi knew this so may be modi preparing for that.
But still you can't control bjp cadre. Already resentment in bjp cadres is increasing on modi over no action against internal enemies 😅.
So if bjp cadres will decide Yogi as pm in future then I think no one can stop him.
Modi also shows other bjp leader that you have to snatch what you deserve😅.
People says modi Shah gave cm to Yogi.
Yes it is one component in many of them but one was this also that Yogi shows his strength to high command with mla and most mla supported him.
So Yogi also know this well.
I also want him to pm because he only carry legacy of pm modi.
He is most honest politician in history of India.
You can do allegation on modi being close to business man.
But this you can't do with yogi😂.
When modi model failing in controlling radical elements.
All bjp cm following pseudo secularism of congress model.
After 2017, Yogi changed all things. Yogi is hindutva politician (development+ no appeasement, + action against anti nationals)
Modi still not changed Ahmedabad name but popular it through invitation of various leader at that place.
But Yogi changed name quickly.
Yogi gave bulldozer model.
Yogi also can do many things but he is forced not to do this because of anti Yogi camp in Lucknow and in delhi😢.
Despite this Yogi won in 2022 after corona.
There was plan to let bjp come at 210-220😢.
In 2004 when bjp crushed against Congress.
Bjp done development work but not any ideology work.
In contrary , central leadership were against the cm of bjp in uttarpradesh Kalyan Singh at that time.
Due to which, insulting the Kalyan Singh, uttarpradesh which played crucial role always in making bjp a biggest party before 2004 election not play crucial role and sp, bsp,even congress started to grow.
So I hope they will not insult again cm of uttarpradesh again. Infact he is most powerful who changing uttarpradesh completely - Yogi adityanath.😊
When there is nehru like people who rule India then eventually system will become corruption, anti Hindu . People will have less ability to do anything.
Same in political analysis we can't do easily define Dynasty.
In running a party there is always need of president who himself control the party or who controlled by high command.
It is very very important to control party.😅
But problem comes when high command is always one people or one family.
Liberandu says that jp nadda is not rubber stamp ?
I says yes but still bjp is cadre based party, democratic party.
Why ??
Because previously bjp were controlled by advani bajpayee, suhma , Arun, pramod, nitin etc
Now controlled by modi shah, their loyalist.
In future, bjp would be controlled by another people (not from modi family or modi son or Shah family, Shah son)
If any party running like this then already it is closest to ideal internal democratic parameter.
Ideal internal democratic, not rubber stamp president is not possible in this world. It is inevitable.😂
But also bjp like party when bjp was not in power with majority - president of bjp was high command.
This rubber stamp president also started when bjp come in power with majority (it is important in this world it is inevitable)😂
So bjp was even more closest to ideal internal democratic parameter when it was not in power 😂.
Just do analysis of bjp with Cong, DMK, rjd,sp, tmc, bsp, aap, jds, jdu,ncp, pdp etc all other parties.
You will see bjp changing of leadership is more good than others and is closest to ideal point.
This is very important, if you are doing this only for party structure then your party will not vanish and will keep increasing.😅
There is not need of perfectly ideal (it is not impossible in this world)
and you can select rubber stamp president.
Important is change of leadership at high command level. If your high command change over a period of time then it very good because other dynasties party even not doing this😂.
I hope you understand.
@@Learner_being nice lines
I enjoyed reading
@@Learner_beingbrilliant point
Modi ji must be respected & has completely changed Indian politics to Center right & awakened hindus & shown zero tolerance to Terr0r
Terr0r
But as power comes people to becomes selfish a bit modi ji is in that phase where he wants people to recognise him as greatest PM
So wants his successors to be weak or in his control
As we know BJP is cader based party by RSS when supporters want change they will bring in YOGI we may go through Cong rule for 1 term
But Yogi has huge task to make UP number 1 state & show that as role model & I believe in him
But Modi ji is now making big mistakes by allowing opposition leaders come to party & get direct MP ticket & many are corrupt
& Interesting is who will be his successor I think Amit Shah may be or some very weak
& Well said BJP is not family control party from Atal advani to Modi Shah
Next Yogi himanta is build of hardcore leaders
From Muzaffarpur, when BJP says to Ajay Nishad that he won the 2019 election because of "upar waale", there is no questioning that assessment. Me and all the people I know here voted to him just because of Modi's face. Heck many didn't even vote because he was the candidate. He did absolutely nothing for the improvement of this place. You come here and see, every BJP supporter wanted him removed, not that the new guy would do something better than him, but just so people get back faith in BJP that they listen to the people, and there is also a notion in the people's mind that removing Ajay will also send a message to the new guy, if you don't work, you'll be removed also...
Wonder how they didnt run a similar survey in Begusarai where people want Giriraj Singh removed as BJP's choice. I wont be very surprised if CPI wins Begusarai.
I am form muzaffarpur bihar, no doubt bjp will win this seat easily
He spoke of political dynasty as a privilege but did not speak about BJP walking the talk of not promoting dynasty politics
its has not 1 family controlling the party !
BJP & RSS is putting the ground work for the next 30 yrs , 50 yrs , 75 yrs or even 100 yrs
Don't worry Print..RSS is still there. When the right time comes, a leader will emerge fir BJP. RSS is there to ensure the right leader comes up.
Bro Annamalai , Tejasvi Surya and many others are next generation leaders , they are educated and very down to earth . They spend time with common people . I think these young BJP leaders combined with RSS young seedlings we will have very competent leaders in future .
gorakhpur mla was sent to rajya sabha after his assembly seat was given to cm yogi
Tejas suryavi is brahmin and bjp wont select upper caste leaders.@@shivamji1234
@@shivamji1234tejasvi Surya 🤮
@The Print needs to drop it's media business facade and work as PR house for INDI alliance & Congress Dynastic crooks!!
The very fact that the Mps who were denied tickets jumped to Congress shows BJP was spot on...what is this video talking about
He is saying Amit Shah is planning to takeover after Modi
what should the MPs who were denied tickets do ? its like being kicked out of your job because you were too good at it and were a risk to the managers job
There are a number of jobs a person can do within a party... the current cm of Chattisgarh was also denied a mp ticket..looks where he is now
Clearly DK wishes bad for the Bjp...but he should know (and probably knows) that in the bjp the cadre matters most...hence DK is bringing up issues of particular leaders within bjp/ but will make no impact
@@VishKrish1you said "they were too good at their job" 😂 what constituency you come from?
@@shreyanschordia2496 in the video it is mentioned and is a fact that they won with a big margin in 2014 and a bigger margin in 2019 .
BJP has always been like this - how much work these guys have done for their constituency is not even talked about this analysis. BJP is very serious of development and MPs working for their own constituency. Also, pls remember when NaMo was General Secretary of BJP, everyone expected he will get cabinet seat. However, he was sent to a tough state where anti-incumbency was a ragung topic. He was embroiled in 2002 and everyone blamed him even some from his own party. He emerged victorious. Same strength and actions are expected from each party member.
BJP was aware that Kaswan, Nishad, & Singh were not trustworthy, their loyalty to BJP ideology was suspect and would jump to CONgress if denied a Lok Sabha seat. If you Mr. D. K. Singh, as 'The Print commentator' is unaware of it, and not even comprehend it, it only exhibits your incompetence.
Don't criticise Mr Singh. He's only bringing you his point of view. If you think you know better then you please put out your opinion independently on social media, _without 'killing the messenger_!'
Indeed. Loyalty in difficult times is a true test of character. Work hard even without a ticket and party will notice. However many people have big ego.
D. K. Singh has said the same thing what you have written in your own words and own way. It's all about empowering loyalists of Mo D for comming successor game to be played in the third term of Mo D.
What is the bjp ideology? 😂
Then why was Ashok Tawar, a known congressman given the Sirsa seat?
The Print, please note that BJP is not any Pariwarwadi party. You can day dream about political infighting in BJP but it will not materialise.
This is one of the basic laws of politics.
Never let anyone become too powerful
to be accepted , keep them below your shoulders, hail to the 'Prince'. 😂😂😂.
It seems that atleast one way or another BJP is following the VIP culture removal as there is no guarantee that when you can be axed. Also this stand would catapult the karyakartas thinking that they might get chance too. Superb research DK. Awesome and hit the Bulls eye. Bravo Sir and I may add that exemplary reporting. Reading between the lines is sometimes DK has gained expertise. Big fan sir
Same here. I too am a big fan.👍
Do you want a dynasty ther😢
Bjp from TN💯
I liked your closing statement.
Absolutely.😂 While showing a telling picture.🤪
@@shyambajekal8084 Forgetting who is the chanakya ?
This is leftist journalist who is shocked how modi is coming to power
They learnt it harder way in Karnataka , today Yeddiyurappa 's son is BJP chief and this is already causing just too much dissent within party. r. A leader should be unpredictable. That is the only thing that gives him the cut to be a leader. If you are too open and answering it definitely defies the quality of being leader . Even your boss SG is like that only as far as he talks. He is so unpredictable in slandering that he goes brutal on RaGa , apart from regular ruling dispensation. He does not end up being in company of Ravish Kumar or Rana Ayyub...although covertly he does concur with them.
Yeah truly it can't be jp nadda 😂😂😂
Forgetting who is the orginal chanakya ?
All the examples you have sighted are dynasts from generations and have little to no connect on the ground. The real karyakartas committed to the sangh ideaology never get resentful and will continue to work with same vigour irrespective of tickets. These are the type of people who will make their place on top within the organization, sooner or later. I am surprised that one of the very few astute analysts like DK havent been able to see through this.
Nothing can be taken for granted in a party not run by a family and always working for the nation as the prime motto. Position holders in the party have to be on their toes and constantly keep performing. Family run parties where going on vacations is the norm, running the party from jail or from bed is the norm - such parties will never understand what BJP is. GOD bless our Prime Minister.
Good analysis. However do not agree with all interpretations. Loyalty to the party is the most important factor for BJP Karyakarthas. There are so many in the waiting list. Party need to balance expectations by considering many other factors also. Those wants only power will be exposed.
A very good strategy...fresh talent is important ❤
❤For BJP.politics is not for power but a chance for service to the people.That is the simple reason, but not as simple to the media men
Are you really a Muslim or using a fake name?
A Muslim supporting bjp?
The great ever presstitute in the world....is the priint....the is much for you
it is all fine, but still better than Nehru dynasty cloning to the zamindari practices last 75 years- and not half smart and good as PM Modi. That is the choice for Indians . Most of the new faces from grass roots , no family ties. I thought that was good for democracy unlike Congress, Yadavs, DMK, BRS , Uddav faction , Abdullah's-the list goes on.
But then why tickets given to Congress detectors ?
Your views about BJP is highly skewed because of your leniency towards left of center. Be professional in your approach sir 😢
May be bjp want to show that they are not family party .
Classic closure!! No wonder DK is one of the best ...
Where Print's political experts including SG wisdom and thinking ends , RSS and BJP chanakya's starts !
😄😄😄😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Bjp best hopes is k Annamalai if he deliver with victory in coimbatore will increase his political profile, he already academic CV compared to none across any party in India, amit shah mighttry these tricks but he will never be pm simply don't have charisma of a pm, yogi aditynath is far more popular than him, also he is upper caste, with so much focus on obc and sc/st their won't be any upper caste cm now in India,
Mr. Singh I think you are the only free, unbiased journalist round the corner. All others seem to be either with or against the ruling party.
It's very good that you don't see everything good or bad in any political dispensation. You just present an insight into something most people probably miss to see or understand.
This is an excellent piece, pls keep the good work on.
Yes....don't associate with or against the ruling party.....try to be natural....
Thank you so much for appreciating my work...very encouraging
Good analysis DK
@The Print needs to drop it's media business facade and work as PR house for INDI alliance & Congress Dynastic crooks!!
At 10:18, DK smartly used a picture and his words to express his opinion.
This gentleman clearly doesn’t like bjp. Looks like cherry-picking.
Thank you Dksingh sir for bringing on Bjp politics.
Good reporting ❤
Your analysis is way better and crisp than 90 percent mainstream media.
Thank you.
oh really !!
Jayalalithaa, when CM of Tamil Nadu kept the party in power by changing her Cabinet Ministers often, still was very popular with the cadre as well as public
Fadnavis theory doesn't make sense. The only reason shivsena went to Congress was because bjp wanted fadnavis to be CM in 2019, and not give CM position to shivsena. Fadnavis was even CM in 2019 for a while
I really love your analysis. A little biased towards Modi or BJP. BJP is OK.
Very good analysis
Amit is shooting Narendra in the foot.
This joker from Print always looking for something wrong with BJP or Modi ji... Fuffer none of your efforts will success... And pls focus at least a little bit in your pronunciation
Glad to see DK ji engaging in something other than congress bashing. A good piece after long. Someone is clearly installing loyalists at all key positions and its obvious enough if one pays good attention .
I almost started to believe in what you are saying until Listening your analysis about Devendra. I must say your view about current situation is far from facts. On the contrary Devendra's stature is at its peak in the party in state politics in the given situation. Thanks.
Propaganda karta hai with some fact to disguise the main thrust.
DK is anti BJP and anti hindu.
True
Nowadays DK analysis is up to the mark. It’s becoming more a propaganda that an analysis.
After all, political positions are not because of individual ability.
Good observation, but who is going to be the next PM candidate from BJP ?
Amit shah.....will meet the same fate as lal Krishna Advani........
Did Advani join CONgress? Even if Amit Shah does not get what he expects Will he Join CONgress ?
Well articulated.. one bit of advice: use data, tables, graphics to make it more incisive and impactful
It is called good management. It is a stark contrast to the lack of good governance in Congress.
What do you expect from dropped MPs!
I am from Muzaffarpur, it is 100% true that Ajay Nishad won because of Upar Wale log, this time BJP would have lost for sure with Nishad.
BJP and RSS had their internal mechanism and they do not worry about win or loss. They are not allowing anybody to create any kingdom within party. You people in print will not understand as you are graduated in politics with subject Congress where all such things exists. Typically print have people who think that god has bestowed all wiseness on them and others were sleeping when god was distributing wiseness.
Rahul kaswan might win churu.. im from jhunjhunu and the momentum at the ground level is there because here it has become jaat vs rajput battle because people feel kaswan was dropped because of rajyavardhan singh rathore's intervention.. will be fun to see how things unfold.. also the bjp top brass knows this because amit shah himself has made atleast 5 rounds of churu and nagaur in the last 3 months not to mention modiji' s massive rally just last week
Congress leader Jyotiraditya Scindia today conceded defeat in Guna in Madhya Pradesh, his constituency for four terms and a stronghold of of his family.
Mr Scindia won Guna for three terms. Before that, his father Madhavrao Scindia had won in 1999. His grandmother Vijayaraje Scindia, a BJP leader, had also held the seat for four terms.
I don't know anything anywhere else, but for Muzaffarpur, Ajay Nishad neither have people's support nor he was ever winable, he doesn't even live in muzaffarpur. These so called 'experts' know nothing about ground reality.
Planning for 2047- no one other than the planners will know the moves - no random move being done -
I loved the final punch with photo of Mota Bhai and JP Nadda and saying that JP Nadda is not the person behind all these.
Wow..
What an analysis..
Hats off for to you DK Sir..!!
Thank you
Party as big as BJP can't run to keep few people happy. They have removed people like Ravi Shankar Prasad in the middle and again he is contesting. This election has thrown some outstanding leaders for future. Annamalai, Himanta biswa Sharma, Subhendu Adhikari, Tejasvi and there are few more. Yogi is a classic example.
I don't think Rahul Kaswan would have opposed Amit Shah😅
Print is fast seeming to be one of the media houses who think that they know it all.
This is making sure Amit Shah has a clear path
And these Dropped MPs will return in 2029 with seats increased
Generally, DK's Analysis is always spot on. In general elections, Modi's cult will sail through, but after annoying some, BJP may suffer some setbacks,
saying that, I do think the BJP is running several plans at a time few as follows,
1. Because you won with big margins, does not mean you are a good administrator, in long-term performance matters, switching candidates will keep others in check and anti-incumbency does matter,
2. BJP want to circulate the message that your seat is not yours, it is parties,
3. With big or small margins, BJP will sail through this general election, hence this is the right time to take risks and keep things in check,
4. The first sign of impending defeat is when a party and its strategies are predictable, this is not Modi and AS style,
5. The last question is about who will be PM after Modi? I do think, we are asking this question too early, definitely, RG will not be the next PM, that is assured, in politics a week is a long time, anything can happen, and predicting who will be PM after 10 years is not what I will be doing for next 5 years.
Good Anylasis...👏👏👏
BJP under the leadership of Modi can think where the intellectuals of Print or Wire or Guardian can't even imagine . BJP under Modi has clear cut plans and road map for the country and also Modi has a macro world view and how to move and position this country and himself for a transformational Vishwa Guru position although it may take more than a decade to crystalize his views but that is what I believe he is working at and to allign to such a guru position the future leaders below him also need to match his steps so he that is Modi is right in choosing his general and his army because he has a vision and he has also the purusharth to manifest his vision
I know Mr. Ajay Nishad from Muzaffarpur, he didn't done any work nor was very active in his area. So there is no wrong is replacing him. After all they get party cadre votes and also because of PM Modi charisma.
It's good. Everyone should get chance. Let others come and prove themselves. If BJP thinks they should not allow the ground level leaders to be in power for long... it's only good for them in the long term.
Don't give example of Pashupatinath Singh, he did nothing and physically unfit to represent Dhanbad Loksabha constituency
One of the best analysis I've come across
Now I get it it makes all sense
Very astute analysis but let me tell you, just as Advani failed with Modi, Modi Shah will fail with Yogi. Or else loose power.
In democracy, non democracy countries all are controlled by Power ful people, top business man people.
There is no denial of that.
But I laugh when they says America democracy is more good than India democracy here modi promoting private players 😂.
Is American govt not controlled by private company?
It is inevitable in this materialistic world.
But still modi doing things to support poor section of society without discrimination - toilet, gas, house, health cover, loan to start self business and now solar panel at roof scheme (all are given only for first time in free, others are just support them in 50% funding, etc.
Free ration is to give them free hand for some yrs to move out poverty line perfectly)
Also -
Like deep state, private player control govt.
Still Indian democracy is alive and vibrant that a poor people can become pm of india😊.
Here above dk Singh just telling previous winning record is enough reason to get him ticket 😂.
Some people who denied ticket already winning 2-3 times , and also son of another winning candidate.
Now to provide his point, dk Singh eliminate Dynasty in politics 😂😂
These people leave party also shows how much they were loyal to bjp😂.
Also yes I am agree - modi is creating a army of loyal supporter in party to let succession plan done peacefully😂.
But still like whole bjp unit was against modi in 2013 but cadre support him, so no leader in bjp could successful in stopping him.
Modi knew this so may be modi preparing for that.
But still you can't control bjp cadre. Already resentment in bjp cadres is increasing on modi over no action against internal enemies 😅.
So if bjp cadres will decide Yogi as pm in future then I think no one can stop him.
Modi also shows other bjp leader that you have to snatch what you deserve😅.
People says modi Shah gave cm to Yogi.
Yes it is one component in many of them but one was this also that Yogi shows his strength to high command with mla and most mla supported him.
So Yogi also know this well.
I also want him to pm because he only carry legacy of pm modi.
He is most honest politician in history of India.
You can do allegation on modi being close to business man.
But this you can't do with yogi😂.
When modi model failing in controlling radical elements.
All bjp cm following pseudo secularism of congress model.
After 2017, Yogi changed all things. Yogi is hindutva politician (development+ no appeasement, + action against anti nationals)
Modi still not changed Ahmedabad name but popular it through invitation of various leader at that place.
But Yogi changed name quickly.
Yogi gave bulldozer model.
Yogi also can do many things but he is forced not to do this because of anti Yogi camp in Lucknow and in delhi😢.
Despite this Yogi won in 2022 after corona.
There was plan to let bjp come at 210-220😢.
In 2004 when bjp crushed against Congress.
Bjp done development work but not any ideology work.
In contrary , central leadership were against the cm of bjp in uttarpradesh Kalyan Singh at that time.
Due to which, insulting the Kalyan Singh, uttarpradesh which played crucial role always in making bjp a biggest party before 2004 election not play crucial role and sp, bsp,even congress started to grow.
So I hope they will not insult again cm of uttarpradesh again. Infact he is most powerful who changing uttarpradesh completely - Yogi adityanath.😊
When there is nehru like people who rule India then eventually system will become corruption, anti Hindu . People will have less ability to do anything.
Same in political analysis we can't do easily define Dynasty.
In running a party there is always need of president who himself control the party or who controlled by high command.
It is very very important to control party.😅
But problem comes when high command is always one people or one family.
Liberandu says that jp nadda is not rubber stamp ?
I says yes but still bjp is cadre based party, democratic party.
Why ??
Because previously bjp were controlled by advani bajpayee, suhma , Arun, pramod, nitin etc
Now controlled by modi shah, their loyalist.
In future, bjp would be controlled by another people (not from modi family or modi son or Shah family, Shah son)
If any party running like this then already it is closest to ideal internal democratic parameter.
Ideal internal democratic, not rubber stamp president is not possible in this world. It is inevitable.😂
But also bjp like party when bjp was not in power with majority - president of bjp was high command.
This rubber stamp president also started when bjp come in power with majority (it is important in this world it is inevitable)😂
So bjp was even more closest to ideal internal democratic parameter when it was not in power 😂.
Just do analysis of bjp with Cong, DMK, rjd,sp, tmc, bsp, aap, jds, jdu,ncp, pdp etc all other parties.
You will see bjp changing of leadership is more good than others and is closest to ideal point.
This is very important, if you are doing this only for party structure then your party will not vanish and will keep increasing.😅
There is not need of perfectly ideal (it is not impossible in this world)
and you can select rubber stamp president.
Important is change of leadership at high command level. If your high command change over a period of time then it very good because other dynasties party even not doing this😂.
I hope you understand.
I didn't read the long comment but i will like the comment as you took so much effort to write it
In the obsession to get 400 seats, Modi is actually doing more harm than good for BJP.
The party discarding many of their loyal members and giving seats to defectors from other parties just to win a seat.
BJP also doing alliances with many parties that hates it but now joining just to survive politically and most probably will discard it in 2-3 years time.
All these illogical decisions will come back to bite BJP by the time next election comes.
BJP looks heading to be same like Congress where a few control the party with iron fist and make decisions at their whims and fancies.
Maybe only a resounding defeat in 2029 will make the leaders realise their mistakes and correct them .
If no corrections done, BJP will go back being a small party in another 5-10 years from now.
Unfortunately, analysts like DK Singh think they are smarter than the people making the decisions. This is similar to Analyst sitting at home suggesting how a top-class cricketer should play or anticipating the thought-process that goes into playing a particular shot. His whole analysis is pointing towards Amit Shah making himself ready to be the next PM position. What he fails to understand is that, there are many more things at play here. Fadnavis was denied the ticket, it was power play to break Shiv Sena by giving CM position to Eknath Shinde.
I recollect a cricket commentator some decades ago, stating that "If Sachin Tendulkar had hit the ball at 64-degree angle, it would have crossed the boundary instead of getting caught". Ironically, the baller was either Malcolm Marshall, Michael Holding or Joel Garner at their fastest blowing speed. 😁😅😀
BJP's internal machinery is run and operated via RSS, and in RSS, you are taught at the very initial level that when the time comes, you shall be stepped up if deemed appropriate or expunged without heistation and you'll have to accept it without dissend. That's perhaps the strongest reason why internal matter of BJP never comes to the fore.
"How do these developments relate to the BJP’s ticket distribution? Well, what the candidates’ list shows is an attempt to use PM Modi’s popularity to promote new faces or loyal MPs, who would owe their position entirely to whoever got them the party tickets.
The BJP is bringing up a whole new set of MPs, CMs, ministers, MLAs, and office-bearers of the organisation at the Centre and in states. They will play a crucial role if and when PM Modi hangs up his boots and there is a battle for succession. Whoever commands their loyalty is likely to have an upper hand if Modi decides to remain neutral. That should explain this thrust on promoting new faces at every level. You must be curious about the brain behind these changes, someone with the ability and clout to carry them out. All I can say is that it can’t be JP Nadda.."
So beautifully written. I am not saying this is true or not. Time will tell. But Mr Singh has floated a theory here. And it couldn't have been articulated in a better way. Amazing work..👌👌🙏🙏
Brilliant truely brilliant analysis! You are an asset to theprint!
Thank you
It is with every powerful leader and in fight for der legacy.
Amit Shah is trying to be the next PM from BJP.
But one thing is for sure.
Anyone can become PM from BJP but Amit Shah.
Yogi, Shivaraj, Gadkari and even Rajnath but Amit Shah cannot become PM of India and it will be the BJP which will not allow this.
interesting
I think Modi, Shah & Rajnath could be having S Jaishankar, Yogi & Hemanta as successors
@bmmilind4333 - this is not bollywood movie to have such fantasies
Its just groundwork for Amit Shah to succeed. There is only one challenger left to "deal with" now and he will be dealt with in 2027.
No brother amith shah is always behind Yogi in the PM race... people will definitely vote for Yogi as PM...he will replicate Modi...but Amit Shah as PM candidate not a good idea..but Amit ji as party president he will be more powerful...so after modi RSS definitely inclined towards Yogi or Nithin gadkari as PM candidate...
Brain behind all this is one and only Amit shah
Amit Shah is afraid of yogi,fadnavis
Okay, they want fresh faces. Atleast, BJP can give some consolation prize to the guys who did good work, and give them a sendoff. That way, they won't feel bad.
Looks like the 'Congressification' (as per Francois Guatiere's satirical observation during Vajpayee's time) is well on track.😅
I think BJP is in a right path. For any reason no one must think a constituency,
ministership etc is a personal property.
Time being we can see some temporary compromises. For example Yadiyurappa in Karnataka, who wants his son to be next CM. .....
We may recall the fight between Keshu bhai Patel and Shankar Singh waghela in Gujarat ....
Modiji ain’t hanging up his boots anytime soon. His life’s mission is to build *“Viksit Bharat by 2047”* , and I don’t think he would voluntarily give up the high political office that enables him to achieve this goal.
Fadnavis meesed up big time in Maharashtra even so that Mr. Modi had to compromise with Ajith Pawar, Khattar would have faced such a defeat no one ever faced in haryana. Shivraj Won for his freebies and not governance. Vasundhara was in nexus with Ashok Gehlot. If Mr. Adityanath messes up he would also be cut to his size. Nothing is more important than victory.
You have stated 3 instances to make a point. What about the overall scenario with 100+ replacements? Shouldn’t the trend be determined by the big picture than exceptions?
"Congress"ification of BJP 🎉
👏
Salute your unbiased and sharp analysis of BJP Strategy ❤
Thank you
Discussing Politics does make Humanities passouts feel like they are scientists of some sort..
It seems that Amit Shah is doing this so that when PM Modi steps down, there are so many feeble contenders for PMs job that Shah himself becomes the obvious choice. Shah has been quietly trying to clip Yogi's wings for the same reason. These two Gujaratis don't trust anyone but another Gujarati.
Who is orchestrating all this - setting up himself as a successor? Very sharp observation by DK Singh. He does not drop the name but says it all - the currently 2nd in command in the party and government to Modi and from the same state of Gujarat. Do one sti needs to calm out aloud - Amit Shah? 😅
Not sure what Mr. DK is trying to stoke, a MP winning a seat multiple times doesn’t means they have a first right of refusal. The party needs to bring new blood and that can be done by relieving the incumbents
👌
Yes, Its not JP Nadda. 😂
It's the Chanakya!
Never can understand DK Singh's comments . He appears to be a Congress stooge.
0:42 PRATAP SIMHA
same happened in Karnataka
Denied ticket for working so hard
So of the most sharp videos ever