@@chinmayshetye3don't jump the guns. It's a UA-cam policy. They catch some keywords out of what is being talked about in video and flag the video if deemed necessary. If you go to around 20:00 min in the video, he is talking about sections related to suicide and UA-cam only catches the words suicide, flags the video. It is done because UA-cam interprets that if someone is watching a video related to suicide, he might need help. For you guys, even if your wives get pregnant it is BJP trolls' work 😅
THESE LAW MAKERS ARE NO5 THINKING THAT, THEY ARE IN THE SAME BOAT OF WITH SAME LAWS.. THEY THINK THAT, THEY ARE FROM HEAVENS , AND GET AWAY FROM CRUME CHARGES IF PARALLELLED AT THEM
Several spelling mistakes noticed- “MARRING” (MARRYING) ,GROUND (GROUNDS) …if this is in the actual book, calls for immediate amends. Overall, a commendable set of reforms and relevant nomenclature.
Two things I can never understand, for years I have been reading editorials about criminal laws reform, legal reforms when govt finally come up with it become controversial, huh
So its rape if a married man lies that he has not married but has sex with woman, but its not rape when married woman lies saying that she is not married?? Thats dumb..
Even I am from the south...can you please tell me the word for Indian, Penal and code in your language? Afaik Bharatiya Nyaya samhita stands correct for Malayalam, kannada, Tulu, and telagu.
Every thing in this country is controversial. What is not controversial tell me. If I use bathroom in my home it turns into a big controversial discussion in parliament
Actually one part of getting rid of unnatural sex law could unwittingly decriminalize animal sex which is certainly a bad thing! Hopefully it's covered under protection of animals section of the law!
Undiscussed bill cannot become legitimate law. Mainly a criminal law. For giving a judgment the discussions of Parliament are the base. Hence there is no discussion there is no base.
My personal opinion is the Supreme Court should strike down these 3 new law as there were many draconian laws. What old and irrelevant laws need is an amendments. The BJP government is trying to fool the Indian people but not everybody can be fool by BJP. Secondly, there is a hidden agenda behind these new laws.
Please make a CTC on India win. You had said a young team can win the World Cup as T20 is a young man’s game. But, India’s average age was quite high. So want to know how India won according to you.
UP has the highest number of custodial deaths in police stations, but no measures have been taken to address such type of issues here. Additionally, UP has the highest number of cases where victims are wrongly charged with crimes (FIRs get filed against them in a State where police often refuse to file FIRs) instead of the actual perpetrators. The Chief Justice has called for improving the judge-to-population ratio, but this has been ignored. The new changes are: 1. The definition of treason is very vague & ambiguous. 2. Introducing duplicated offences like attempt, abetment, & conspiracy (applies to not just organised crime, but to legitimate peacefully voice disagreements on social media). 3. Increasing punishment to death sentences! for such non-homicidal acts for simply voicing their frustrations, under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. 4. Removing the min safeguards from the UAPA. 5. Muslim lynching due to cow vigilantes is a crime, but is punishable only if courts possesses the ability to read the thoughts of vigilantes. Instead, why don't govt make laws to remove fake babas who cause 100s of Hindu devotees to stampede? RTI activists like R@njeet s0ni in Bhopal & 20 others in Bihar were finished for seeking truth. Where was rule of law & order during the lakhimpur incident where a Union Minister's son ran over farmer, or the rewarding of UP gundas like Bhush@n who molested female wrestlers? There are so many journalists jailed, I can think of many names on top of my head, like ashutosh negi arrested by cops, abhsar sharma, aritry das, disha ravi, bhasha singh, amit malviya, some more journalists names I am forgetting, etc.
What kind of pre-judgemental headline - "Controversial new criminal laws" ? Anything can be made controversial, by merely having someone shout against it. That doesn't make it wrong yo begin with. Judgement should be made afterwards. Atmost you write - critical analysis of new laws, ot problems with the new laws. But what do you mean controversial?
Did he say that no. And yes, when you do not deliberate on cornerstone acts sufficiently, and even the final draft bills having mentions of the old IPC chapters, shows the bang up job. No eminent jurists were consulted. I recommend you take BNS and IPC side-by-side and compare them. The controversy comes from that all lawyers, clerks, judges in criminal proceedings will have to memorise new section numbers for no productive reasons. Only increasing the backlog of cases.
13.00 Hats off people like Shekharji in the parliament from past 75 years nurtured this type of people. More people are there to get seperated and become the beacon holders for the peaceful faith but not to stay as sanathani.
Has anything ever happened in India without controversies (media’s halwa). Fed up. For Christs sake it is not controversy…it is some people who disagree with parts of a law…. There is a difference
Just because time has passed or been given has no bearing on the controversial aspect. Apart from minor changes, the criminal laws are only ammendment worthy, and not repealing the act, just because it is old. Plus, not enough deliberation have taken in replacing for such cornerstone acts.Even in countries such as USA and UK (who have similar laws), replacing laws is a massive excercise. BJP has done this in a summary manner. All the changes done could have been easily been encompassed in an ammendment. These reforms are a marketing excercise.
@@Jun_kid First calm down. I am living with it, but it is controversial, vain and deserves heavy criticism. In a democracy it is imperative to voice dissatisfaction, unless you want to be a mere subject. Clearly, you can not control your emotions. If you were to practice what you preach, then you would have not engaged in the comments section
@@Jun_kid I don't care if it is yt. I have manners. I don't require consequences to act properly. You suffer from something, that only you can figure out. Godspeed. And Who is Abdul. I don't get the reference.
What is the urgency to scrap the old crpc ipc rather implementing them. दो सालो में तो रट पाया हूं, अब फिर से नया रट्टा मारो। इन्हे राजनीति बस करनी है युवाओं के मानसिक उत्पीड़न का कोई खयाल है नही। पहले पेपर कैंसल करो फिर नए नए कानून बनाओ।
People need to take responsibility. Government should not be in the business of baby sitting. Our governments pay for marriages, girl children, education, healthcare, jobs without having any access to your bedroom. It’s shameful.
This is the warning that came up when viewing from Canada "Viewer discretion is advised The following content may contain suicide or self-harm topics."
Haha Mr. Gandhi told off the violent Hindus in first session of Parliament. Now Hindutwa will be stopped. Start counting your days SG, this govt will not survive long.
He told that to "BJP/RSS" leaders who claim to be "flagbearers of hinduism" and do violence in the name of religion, he specifically didn't said "all hindus"
Law was refined since british... All refinement is gone for toss.. This drastic change just because it was from british was unwanted... And not allowing it for debate was nondemocratic
Don't worry, there is no way Rahul Gandhi will allow them to pass these laws. In the first session itself he has shown mirror to Hindus. No more Sanghi propaganda will run in the country. Jai Constitution.
@@diyar8161 Ok...he can mention anything about hindus..but can't utter a single word about muslims , owaisi whose gangs are rioters (ex. CAA , NRC protest.)
@@missalberta5838 wo Kam to bjp kar rahi hai na. And nrc is a very sensitive issue. In assam, tripura they are against nrc saying Bengali Hindus and Bangladeshi muslims are eroding their culture so they wanted everyone out. So they are nrc . So it's a handle with care topic
Laws are no use for people if you don't have justice. Uttar Pradesh has the highest number of custodial deaths in police stations, but no measures have been taken to address such type of issues here. Additionally, UP has the highest number of cases where victims are wrongly charged with crimes (FIRs get filed against them in a State where police often refuse to file FIRs) instead of the actual perpetrators.
Hope you are not worried..since these will ensure all anti-nationals are behind bars...Anyways there is always Sugar and othet health conditions which can be used like furziwal...
UP has the highest number of custodial deaths in police stations, but no measures have been taken to address such type of issues here. Additionally, UP has the highest number of cases where victims are wrongly charged with crimes (FIRs get filed against them in a State where police often refuse to file FIRs) instead of the actual perpetrators. The Chief Justice has called for improving the judge-to-population ratio, but this has been ignored. The new changes are: 1. The definition of treason is very vague & ambiguous. 2. Introducing duplicated offences like attempt, abetment, & conspiracy (applies to not just organised crime, but to legitimate peacefully voice disagreements on social media). 3. Increasing punishment to death sentences! for such non-homicidal acts for simply voicing their frustrations, under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. 4. Removing the min safeguards from the UAPA. 5. Muslim lynching due to cow vigilantes is a crime, but is punishable only if courts possesses the ability to read the thoughts of vigilantes. Instead, why don't govt make laws to remove fake babas who cause 100s of Hindu devotees to stampede? RTI activists like R@njeet s0ni in Bhopal & 20 others in Bihar were finished for seeking truth. Where was rule of law & order during the lakhimpur incident where a Union Minister's son ran over farmer, or the rewarding of UP gundas like Bhush@n who molested female wrestlers? There are so many journalists jailed, I can think of many names on top of my head, like ashutosh negi arrested by cops, abhsar sharma, aritry das, disha ravi, bhasha singh, amit malviya, some more journalists names I am forgetting, etc.
Mr SG , Why your titles related some new initiatives or Indian interests is always controversial , skeptic , rhetoric , maligned rather than giving a positive image of India .. became old .. old habits die hard ..sorry about it
This video is being flagged by UA-cam for suicide and violence related content
Why?
BJP trolls at work
@@chinmayshetye3It's UA-cam being an idiot platform.Lol BJP UA-cam is if anything anti bjp or at least is not pro bjp.
@@chinmayshetye3don't jump the guns. It's a UA-cam policy. They catch some keywords out of what is being talked about in video and flag the video if deemed necessary. If you go to around 20:00 min in the video, he is talking about sections related to suicide and UA-cam only catches the words suicide, flags the video. It is done because UA-cam interprets that if someone is watching a video related to suicide, he might need help.
For you guys, even if your wives get pregnant it is BJP trolls' work 😅
that's just coz they speak about a suicide laws modified. The AI must have detected those words in the video transcript...
@@pulipakasrikiran9307watching the print video can make people depressed😂😂😂😂
Whoever did the Franklin Templeton ad must be a kid.
Correct. No clarity.
I don't know why, I received a User discretion alert message to confirm before watching this video? Please check
No point of any laws if the policing is so bad and judiciary is so slow.
These laws are made to Fast track judiciary and make police more responsible to their actions
Still lacks self defence and absolutely lacks laws against false cases like 498A, dowry and posco.
A new video on any fresh perspective gained after the elections?
Why in hindi ...why not in tamil or bengali marathi. Kannada Etc ?
What's the translation for Indian penal code in any of the southern languages? Afaik in kannada it's Bharatiya Nyaya samhita itself
It's sanskritise Hindi.
THESE LAW MAKERS ARE NO5 THINKING THAT, THEY ARE IN THE SAME BOAT OF WITH SAME LAWS..
THEY THINK THAT, THEY ARE FROM HEAVENS , AND GET AWAY FROM CRUME CHARGES IF PARALLELLED AT THEM
I wonder why i get a pop up for viewer discretion based on sucide and self half harm when the video content is no where based on in?
Crime minister rolls out new criminal laws😂😂🎉
Several spelling mistakes noticed- “MARRING” (MARRYING) ,GROUND (GROUNDS) …if this is in the actual book, calls for immediate amends.
Overall, a commendable set of reforms and relevant nomenclature.
Two things I can never understand, for years I have been reading editorials about criminal laws reform, legal reforms when govt finally come up with it become controversial, huh
The leftists and Congress don't want any reforms bottom line. They just shout slogans
Shekhar because of old loose laws things git miss used now we have proper laws. Look appreciate modi they are building a nation.
So its rape if a married man lies that he has not married but has sex with woman, but its not rape when married woman lies saying that she is not married??
Thats dumb..
Someone was taking notes about doublespeak while reading 1984
Sharjeel imam deserves jail. No one can say anything on sovereignty
I feel it so difficult to prounce these laws .. as a from South india
Even I am from the south...can you please tell me the word for Indian, Penal and code in your language? Afaik Bharatiya Nyaya samhita stands correct for Malayalam, kannada, Tulu, and telagu.
Liar
I don't think you are from South India, because South Indian pronunciations tend to be tougher than North Indian ones.
@@sandeepdesai3255 prove that he's a liar, if you can't then you are certainly a liar who defames people
Every thing in this country is controversial.
What is not controversial tell me.
If I use bathroom in my home it turns into a big controversial discussion in parliament
Thanks Shekharji for putting light on these important subject.
Laws well crafted to put all those opposing the ruling political party in Jail.
the print laundry 🧺
Please make a program on Bengals taliban like treatment of a Muslim woman. This is utterly disgusting
You got proof?
@@SushmaVivek-xq4nvso u have not seen any videos😂
Very good and positive analysis. 👍👍
Thanks for resharing… please make it a series and cover more aspects
Actually one part of getting rid of unnatural sex law could unwittingly decriminalize animal sex which is certainly a bad thing! Hopefully it's covered under protection of animals section of the law!
Thanks! Good coverage as always
Dear viewer,
Glad to know you liked our coverage. Thank you for your generous contribution.
But why don’t you highlight the amendments made in past years
Why is this video being flagged as having inappropriate content for some age groups ?!
Justice is " Blind " but it is not " deaf " or " dumb "
Eventually the perfect Law will shape in ... Jai. Hind 👊
Lol
Undiscussed bill cannot become legitimate law. Mainly a criminal law. For giving a judgment the discussions of Parliament are the base. Hence there is no discussion there is no base.
Point less. Once passed by Parliament, it becomes law.
So if someone says he is 6 ft and then the woman finds he is actually 5'11 is a case of deceitful identity and hence a crime?
Once a guy told me he was 6’1 but turned out he was around 5’7. I should have gone to the cops. 🙂
Birla's reaction shots are priceless.
Old episode …. Why repeats are being shown ?
Nice
None of the media is discussing the Lokpal Bill, it's rules were supposed to be framed
Nice
My personal opinion is the Supreme Court should strike down these 3 new law as there were many draconian laws. What old and irrelevant laws need is an amendments. The BJP government is trying to fool the Indian people but not everybody can be fool by BJP. Secondly, there is a hidden agenda behind these new laws.
Why is UA-cam flagging this for suicide/violence risk?
Please make a CTC on India win. You had said a young team can win the World Cup as T20 is a young man’s game. But, India’s average age was quite high. So want to know how India won according to you.
Most stupid to call it " controversial", SG's soft corner for criminals and terrorists notwithstanding.
UP has the highest number of custodial deaths in police stations, but no measures have been taken to address such type of issues here. Additionally, UP has the highest number of cases where victims are wrongly charged with crimes (FIRs get filed against them in a State where police often refuse to file FIRs) instead of the actual perpetrators.
The Chief Justice has called for improving the judge-to-population ratio, but this has been ignored. The new changes are:
1. The definition of treason is very vague & ambiguous.
2. Introducing duplicated offences like attempt, abetment, & conspiracy (applies to not just organised crime, but to legitimate peacefully voice disagreements on social media).
3. Increasing punishment to death sentences! for such non-homicidal acts for simply voicing their frustrations, under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.
4. Removing the min safeguards from the UAPA.
5. Muslim lynching due to cow vigilantes is a crime, but is punishable only if courts possesses the ability to read the thoughts of vigilantes.
Instead, why don't govt make laws to remove fake babas who cause 100s of Hindu devotees to stampede? RTI activists like R@njeet s0ni in Bhopal & 20 others in Bihar were finished for seeking truth. Where was rule of law & order during the lakhimpur incident where a Union Minister's son ran over farmer, or the rewarding of UP gundas like Bhush@n who molested female wrestlers? There are so many journalists jailed, I can think of many names on top of my head, like ashutosh negi arrested by cops, abhsar sharma, aritry das, disha ravi, bhasha singh, amit malviya, some more journalists names I am forgetting, etc.
Awaiting your Book on National Interest - Anticipating India - Vol-II , thanks & regards 🙏
What kind of pre-judgemental headline - "Controversial new criminal laws" ? Anything can be made controversial, by merely having someone shout against it. That doesn't make it wrong yo begin with. Judgement should be made afterwards. Atmost you write - critical analysis of new laws, ot problems with the new laws. But what do you mean controversial?
Did he say that no. And yes, when you do not deliberate on cornerstone acts sufficiently, and even the final draft bills having mentions of the old IPC chapters, shows the bang up job. No eminent jurists were consulted. I recommend you take BNS and IPC side-by-side and compare them. The controversy comes from that all lawyers, clerks, judges in criminal proceedings will have to memorise new section numbers for no productive reasons. Only increasing the backlog of cases.
13.00 Hats off people like Shekharji in the parliament from past 75 years nurtured this type of people. More people are there to get seperated and become the beacon holders for the peaceful faith but not to stay as sanathani.
Interesting episode.
I found most of changes r needed for the changed community 👍
Has anything ever happened in India without controversies (media’s halwa). Fed up. For Christs sake it is not controversy…it is some people who disagree with parts of a law…. There is a difference
Exactly….. every thing is melodramatic in India! The same people who protest now will happily use these laws if they are in power.
We were expecting new fresh episode on new laws
One step in the right direction
I don't think people know the meaning of the word controversial anymore.
People had ample time to read and understand the laws.
Just because time has passed or been given has no bearing on the controversial aspect. Apart from minor changes, the criminal laws are only ammendment worthy, and not repealing the act, just because it is old. Plus, not enough deliberation have taken in replacing for such cornerstone acts.Even in countries such as USA and UK (who have similar laws), replacing laws is a massive excercise. BJP has done this in a summary manner. All the changes done could have been easily been encompassed in an ammendment. These reforms are a marketing excercise.
@@Jun_kid First calm down. I am living with it, but it is controversial, vain and deserves heavy criticism. In a democracy it is imperative to voice dissatisfaction, unless you want to be a mere subject. Clearly, you can not control your emotions. If you were to practice what you preach, then you would have not engaged in the comments section
@@Jun_kid I don't care if it is yt. I have manners. I don't require consequences to act properly. You suffer from something, that only you can figure out. Godspeed. And Who is Abdul. I don't get the reference.
@Jun_kiThe second part of your username checks out.
Thanks for the analysis!
What is the urgency to scrap the old crpc ipc rather implementing them. दो सालो में तो रट पाया हूं, अब फिर से नया रट्टा मारो। इन्हे राजनीति बस करनी है युवाओं के मानसिक उत्पीड़न का कोई खयाल है नही। पहले पेपर कैंसल करो फिर नए नए कानून बनाओ।
Will this stop what is happening in manipur. Complete eyewash.
People need to take responsibility. Government should not be in the business of baby sitting. Our governments pay for marriages, girl children, education, healthcare, jobs without having any access to your bedroom. It’s shameful.
Not here for old shows
This is the warning that came up when viewing from Canada
"Viewer discretion is advised
The following content may contain suicide or self-harm topics."
I received the same message from Chennai as well .
At 20:00 mark he talks abt decriminalising suicide. Its just using the word multiple time triggers
Haha Mr. Gandhi told off the violent Hindus in first session of Parliament. Now Hindutwa will be stopped. Start counting your days SG, this govt will not survive long.
He told that to "BJP/RSS" leaders who claim to be "flagbearers of hinduism" and do violence in the name of religion, he specifically didn't said "all hindus"
Print and BBC Lallontop pained to read new laws of Modi Government
Lefties are obsessed with keeping failed Nehru's legacy
Congress kept everything in India the same from what the British left....brown sahib's
Kangana was correct in calling protesting farmers "terrorist" coz they all were repeatedly "obstructing supplies "
Bharath needs to build new mega prisons to accommodate traitors. We have many in our country
Only stupid citizens are fine with giving arbitrary power to the government to prosecute it's citizens.
Criminal and traitor spotted . U people Want lawlessness in your society .
Law was refined since british... All refinement is gone for toss.. This drastic change just because it was from british was unwanted... And not allowing it for debate was nondemocratic
Don't worry, there is no way Rahul Gandhi will allow them to pass these laws. In the first session itself he has shown mirror to Hindus. No more Sanghi propaganda will run in the country. Jai Constitution.
Get lost. All British laws should be scrapped
@@Nmax British made you civilized, don't forget. Before British you were just slaving under manu-smariti and burning your women.
Forget about New law. Rahul should be jailed for calling all hindus "Himsa karte hai"
Wtf, He said it to "violent BJP/RSS hindus" not "all hindus", are you deaf ? rewatch his speech and then comment
He said to modi ,rss and bjp not hindu as a whole
@@diyar8161 Ok...he can mention anything about hindus..but can't utter a single word about muslims , owaisi whose gangs are rioters (ex. CAA , NRC protest.)
@@missalberta5838 wo Kam to bjp kar rahi hai na. And nrc is a very sensitive issue. In assam, tripura they are against nrc saying Bengali Hindus and Bangladeshi muslims are eroding their culture so they wanted everyone out. So they are nrc . So it's a handle with care topic
@@diyar8161go listen to what he says again. He says Hindus…. He is just playing up to his vote bank, the Islamists.
Whats controversial...so you want 100 year old law for modern day world...this itself is a late reform ..atleast bjp has guts
Good analysis
Love the new stricter laws
Laws are no use for people if you don't have justice. Uttar Pradesh has the highest number of custodial deaths in police stations, but no measures have been taken to address such type of issues here. Additionally, UP has the highest number of cases where victims are wrongly charged with crimes (FIRs get filed against them in a State where police often refuse to file FIRs) instead of the actual perpetrators.
Very important changes to update the laws to actually work in the 21st century.
No problem. It won't get simply passed
Hope you are not worried..since these will ensure all anti-nationals are behind bars...Anyways there is always Sugar and othet health conditions which can be used like furziwal...
UP has the highest number of custodial deaths in police stations, but no measures have been taken to address such type of issues here. Additionally, UP has the highest number of cases where victims are wrongly charged with crimes (FIRs get filed against them in a State where police often refuse to file FIRs) instead of the actual perpetrators.
The Chief Justice has called for improving the judge-to-population ratio, but this has been ignored. The new changes are:
1. The definition of treason is very vague & ambiguous.
2. Introducing duplicated offences like attempt, abetment, & conspiracy (applies to not just organised crime, but to legitimate peacefully voice disagreements on social media).
3. Increasing punishment to death sentences! for such non-homicidal acts for simply voicing their frustrations, under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.
4. Removing the min safeguards from the UAPA.
5. Muslim lynching due to cow vigilantes is a crime, but is punishable only if courts possesses the ability to read the thoughts of vigilantes.
Instead, why don't govt make laws to remove fake babas who cause 100s of Hindu devotees to stampede? RTI activists like R@njeet s0ni in Bhopal & 20 others in Bihar were finished for seeking truth. Where was rule of law & order during the lakhimpur incident where a Union Minister's son ran over farmer, or the rewarding of UP gundas like Bhush@n who molested female wrestlers? There are so many journalists jailed, I can think of many names on top of my head, like ashutosh negi arrested by cops, abhsar sharma, aritry das, disha ravi, bhasha singh, amit malviya, some more journalists names I am forgetting, etc.
Cringe sense of humour
Mr SG , Why your titles related some new initiatives or Indian interests is always controversial , skeptic , rhetoric , maligned rather than giving a positive image of India .. became old .. old habits die hard ..sorry about it