Hjalmar Söderberg - Doctor Glas BOOK REVIEW

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 95

  • @kristenkirk25
    @kristenkirk25 6 років тому +29

    Hey Cliff, I’m glad you liked the book. Thank you for a great ‘show’ with real contents. Hope you’ll have a smooth relocation.

  • @gustavturefeldt3938
    @gustavturefeldt3938 6 років тому +21

    As a swede, I read Doktor Glas in school, and it's truly a wonderful book! Happy to see it available in english as well

    • @Al-KA1mist
      @Al-KA1mist 3 роки тому +3

      What... you liked it?

    • @lineb98
      @lineb98 2 роки тому +1

      Verkligen?
      Jag läste den för liten tid sedan och det är den värsta boken jag har läst någonsin. Det är jobbigt att bli konfronterad med huvudkaraktärens depressiva tankar under den hela handlingen.

    • @francisdec1615
      @francisdec1615 2 роки тому

      @@lineb98 Han tänker ju inget som inte är sant, men visst, folk i allmänhet försöker förtränga sådant.

  • @MuzakFavo
    @MuzakFavo 3 роки тому +4

    I was in Stockholm yesterday (a rare occasion for me, as I live hours and hours away)! And my business happened to take me to the neighborhood of the fictional Dr. Glas. By chance I came across several of the landmarks/places that Söderberg describes so beautifully in his book. It was a glorious day too (one of the first warm days of summer), so Stockholm was really at its peak yesterday! I am sure many of those beauty spots that Söderberg takes us to visit through the doctor, still look and feel much the same today. And I so loved my impromptu "dr. Glas sightseeing" tour, that now I just have to re-read this masterpiece of a book, for the umpteenth time! :) Thanks for your video, I agree with a lot with a lot of what you are saying. DO read Ibsen, if you have the time and the inclination! Again you may be surprised, I think, at the freshness of the language and the topics of his plays. Ibsen was before his time too, for sure!

  • @MyHollycow
    @MyHollycow 6 років тому +6

    I love your book review series. They are so refreshing and straight into the point with a touch of your own personality. You are honestly one of my favourite youtubers now and congrats on the 30k subscribers. Keep it going!

  • @Blaizerous
    @Blaizerous 6 років тому +7

    If you want to read more dark swedish literature from 20th century, I highly recommend Pär Lagerqvists novels The Dwarf (1944) and Barabbas (1950). The Dwarf is definitely one of my favourite books of all time.

  • @francisdec1615
    @francisdec1615 2 роки тому +2

    The novel plays before 1897, because the priest mentions that they are going to build the Riksdag building "on that tiny little islet", and the building was constructed 1897-1905.

  • @gudulla
    @gudulla 6 років тому +14

    Protestant ‘priests’ never did not marry. In Scandinavia, we almost only had Lutheran protestantism for such a long time that we did not think it necessary to have different titles for priests and all that. Great review

    • @asdasd-be5ww
      @asdasd-be5ww 6 років тому

      Different titles for priest have very much always been a thing, and still is.

  • @m4lice960
    @m4lice960 5 років тому +11

    As someone who has only read the Swedish version the translation seems really good and true to the feeling of the book

  • @GWCoetzee
    @GWCoetzee 6 років тому +1

    Congrats with the 30,000 subscribers! Continue doing what you're doing and introducing us all to books that are better than food

  • @damir9206
    @damir9206 11 місяців тому +1

    One of the best books ever ! Greetings from Bosnia 🇧🇦

  • @ahaykal9357
    @ahaykal9357 6 років тому +2

    Fan from Indonesia here, keep it up man, I think you're the best book reviewer on youtube, straight to the point. Maybe you want to try some Indonesian literatures, someday, would be really appreciated!

  • @magnuskarlsson8655
    @magnuskarlsson8655 6 років тому +11

    You said it reminded you of the films of Carl Dreyer - perhaps Gertrude? Gertrude was written by Hjalmar Söderberg and adapted by Dreyer in 1965.

  • @EudaemonicGirl
    @EudaemonicGirl 5 років тому +4

    This is one of my favourite books of all time and makes me weep like a little baby.

  • @katferments
    @katferments 5 років тому +3

    Glad to see a Swedish author's book reviewed! And man, you should check out Henrik Ibsen and also Knut Hamsun. Great writers from the European North :) I'm sure you'd like them. Hamsun is also often compared to Dostoyevsky and Nietzsche.

  • @CedricV77
    @CedricV77 6 років тому

    Congrats on the 30k man! Been watching your videos for about two years and you get better every video. Keep up the amazing work. Got hooked after watching your review for The Rum Diary. Miss your movie reviews.

  • @brandongacer1850
    @brandongacer1850 6 років тому +4

    I think you would love Lav Diaz's films. I recommend Norte the End of History. It's a loose adaptation of Crime and Punishment. Hypnotic long takes and operates like a Tarkovsky film set in the Philippines.

  • @nesarjalili8554
    @nesarjalili8554 Рік тому

    Read this for school a couple weeks ago in swedish and it blew me away. the english translation seems awesome, i might need to read it in english too. Great review!

  • @laurasalo6160
    @laurasalo6160 6 років тому

    I happened upon your channel and I have to tell you that I am completely taken by you. Thank you for what you do. You are enchanting and magnetic. I consume your insights and guzzle your voluminous range of passions. I am replete and yet desirous and wanting. I return for replenishment, resignedly insatiable.

  • @topkek_
    @topkek_ 6 років тому +9

    hey, this might be a bit of a weird suggestion, but I'm quite hampered in reading by my dyslexia and I have a really cognitively demanding desk job. I was wondering if you could make a list of shorter books at some point to help get into reading a bit easier? keep up the awesome channel! :)

    • @ОлегОленев-я3о
      @ОлегОленев-я3о 6 років тому +5

      Presuming you won't mind the recommendation of a stranger, I really recommend Submission by Michel Houellebecq. It's contemporary, very short (One could read it in a day), and a it name drops a lot of other interesting authors. It's the book that got me back into reading about a year and a half ago. Plus, it's just a good book.

    • @greggoat6570
      @greggoat6570 6 років тому +4

      If you don’t mind more advice from strangers, here are some more excellent novels, mostly under 250 pages:
      -Less Than Zero - Bret Easton Ellis
      -Mother Night - Kurt Vonnegut JR
      -Bright Lights, Big City - Jay McInerney
      -South of the Border, West of the Sun - Haruki Murakami
      - Ubik - Phillip K Dick
      - The Orchard Keeper - Cormac McCarthy
      - Siddartha - Herman Hesse
      - Diary - Chuck Palahniuk
      - One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest - Ken Kesey
      - Different Seasons - Stephen King ( Four excellent novellas, all around 100 pages or less)

    • @crippleized
      @crippleized 6 років тому

      EU is Cancer hunger by Knut Hamsun is a good one.

    • @BetterThanFoodBookReviews
      @BetterThanFoodBookReviews  6 років тому +2

      Yes I certainly could, thanks for the suggestion.

    • @crippleized
      @crippleized 6 років тому

      EU is Cancer he has a playlist on his channel called "one day reads". You should check those out :)

  • @RamboRylan
    @RamboRylan 6 років тому +2

    Congrats on the 30k! Well deserved. If you've not read it, you should read The Shadow of the Wind by Carlos Ruiz Zafon. A beautiful and profound book

  • @logografia
    @logografia 3 роки тому +1

    One of my favourite books. Great review.

  • @ОлегОленев-я3о
    @ОлегОленев-я3о 6 років тому +7

    Have you ever read anything by Laszlo Krasznahorkai? I just finish Satantango a few days ago; good stuff.

    • @heksail
      @heksail 6 років тому +2

      Олег Оленев I second this, there can be no discussion of modern experimentation in literature without speaking of Krasznahorkai. it makes sense to work chronologically through his oeuvre, and Satantango is the best starting point. A review of one of his works would definitely fit this channel

  • @asdasd-be5ww
    @asdasd-be5ww 6 років тому +44

    The 'ö' in Söderberg is pronounced like the 'i' in bird.

    • @miorio2645
      @miorio2645 5 років тому

      asd asd ehh? No? Ö is just ö, no sound in english that match

    • @kuhj278
      @kuhj278 4 роки тому +7

      @@miorio2645 nänä, han har rätt

    • @krille6690
      @krille6690 4 роки тому +2

      Mio Rio not really, the i in bird is quite similar

    • @Herodollus
      @Herodollus 4 роки тому

      Mio Rio Well not in english

    • @mitralize
      @mitralize 4 роки тому

      depends on your English accent

  • @Laughinglostsaint
    @Laughinglostsaint 6 років тому +2

    Hey , been following your channel for a while , there are many channels here regarding book reading but the reason that distinguishes you is that you read some "real" stuff not stupid teenagers novel with colour binding . keep uploading buddy , more happiness and strength to you ..

  • @callumsutherland2954
    @callumsutherland2954 6 років тому +7

    Have you read Hunger, by Knut Hamsun? It was one of the first novels of literary modernism, and a thrilling, twisted, disturbing read. It's from the end of the 19th century, and it's Norwegian -- the Scandinavian darkness you speak of is right there in Hunger.

    • @kuhj278
      @kuhj278 4 роки тому

      He's reviewed it.

  • @cosmin9950
    @cosmin9950 6 років тому +2

    Hey Cliff, greetings from Italy and my congratulations for the achievement. I was wondering if you ever heard of The Leopard by Tomasi di Lampedusa ?
    I feel like it might be a novel of your liking.

  • @flippedyflopp3831
    @flippedyflopp3831 4 роки тому

    This review helped me so much with my book analysis. I really wish I'd read this book out of my own volition instead of just skimming through it for school since I didn't realise how good the book actually was before watching this video.

    • @MuzakFavo
      @MuzakFavo 3 роки тому

      Don't worry! You can re-read Dr Glas again some time in the future! I pick it up every few years, when my mood takes me there, and it's always enjoyable (in a dark way!)

  • @buthwywho7438
    @buthwywho7438 6 років тому +6

    You should check out The Death of Ivan Ilyich by Leo Tolstoy

  • @asderc1
    @asderc1 6 років тому

    Looking pretty stylish today Sgt. Off topic but have you ever ventured into the music of John Zorn's Naked City. An experimental band that sounds like the noise inside the heads Dostoevsky and Sade.

  • @Ryan_Ek2
    @Ryan_Ek2 6 років тому

    Hey Cliff, is Persona your favourite? Winter Light has to be mine and it was Bergman's own favourite of his films.

  • @BlueRonin2015
    @BlueRonin2015 6 років тому

    I watched the Bergman film you mentioned, Through a Glass Darkly, a while ago. It's a good film but its a seriously outdated representation of mental illness. And if a great artist like Bergman can date so badly over 50 years, it shows what a talent this Soderberg must of have been, if he was writing convincing psychological novels 60 years earlier! I'll have to check it out.

  • @joshc6569
    @joshc6569 6 років тому

    Strangely the second time over the years you've mentioned a musician Ive only just discovered, Eric Satie. The other time you mentioned Avo Part and Tim Hecker.

  • @pandaredemption
    @pandaredemption 6 років тому

    Hell yeah! Finally hit 30K. Good job all y’all funky love cats.

  • @Malik-ji3mz
    @Malik-ji3mz 6 років тому

    I caught up with all your videos as of today. RIP me but good job you!

  • @adamh9579
    @adamh9579 6 років тому +1

    Thank you/tack :) en av sveriges största författare, min personliga favorit. / One of the best Swedish authors of all time, not to mention my personal favorite.

    • @akosp932
      @akosp932 6 років тому

      adam H En av mina favoritförfattare också, jag gillar särskilt hans noveller :) (en kille från Ungern som studerar svenska på uni)

    • @adamh9579
      @adamh9579 6 років тому

      Intressant, add me on Goodreads if you want : www.goodreads.com/user/show/6352793-adam-hermansson

  • @solovief
    @solovief 6 років тому +1

    Hope you have a smooth move. You are going to the opposite peninsula on 75. From the sock to the mitten.

  • @dashbustour3647
    @dashbustour3647 6 років тому

    Good man, good show. Enjoy Detroit. Did you know Louis Ferdinand Celine's wife is still alive?

  • @linakily9892
    @linakily9892 5 років тому

    There is a Swedish author named Bengt Ohlsson that wrote a book named Gregorius that tells the story from the Reverends perspective. You really should check it out if you liked Doctor Glas :)

    • @MuzakFavo
      @MuzakFavo 3 роки тому

      I agree! It's surprisingly good.

  • @whitmancynical9711
    @whitmancynical9711 6 років тому

    Oh wow cool UA-cam unsubscribed me from you, thankfully the algorithm suggested your review otherwise I would have missed this.

  • @rahimveron
    @rahimveron 2 роки тому

    I am reading this after To The Lighthouse.

  • @asderc1
    @asderc1 6 років тому

    I need a shorter book now I've finished the Brothers K so this is on the list.

  •  6 років тому +3

    As a heavy consumer and collector of wines (primarily vintage varietals from the Burgundy region), it pains me to see someone drink from a stemless glass. I hope that stuff you're drinking is something cheap and forgettable... Hehe.

    • @1m2a3t4t5
      @1m2a3t4t5 6 років тому

      stems are gay

    •  6 років тому +6

      Gay or not, they maintain the important function of keeping the temperature of the wine intact. Which is quite important, if you are appreciate the sort of attributes, that one usually enjoys when drinking wine i.e flavor, and the aromas. Wine should be served at a proper temperature, that's too obvious to even mention... Of course, if it's an 8€ bottle of some mass produced crap wine, then you might as well chug that thing from a pint for all I care. Everyone who understands wines even on a modest level, should know that you drink wine from a wine glass for a reason. And lastly; I think the adjective gay is a preferable trait; one should have a gay old time when enjoying the nice things in life.

    • @1m2a3t4t5
      @1m2a3t4t5 6 років тому +1

      True, well spoken.

    • @BetterThanFoodBookReviews
      @BetterThanFoodBookReviews  6 років тому +3

      it was dirt cheap ;)

  • @TJ-kk5zf
    @TJ-kk5zf Рік тому +1

    great book

  • @aboodradi220
    @aboodradi220 6 років тому

    Why do not show the books on the camera to see it

  • @Dontevenaskmebro
    @Dontevenaskmebro 6 років тому

    What are the titles of the books you use in your intro?

  • @neda2279
    @neda2279 4 роки тому

    Hejj! Kan någon snälla hjälpa mig med doktor glas jag har fått en läxa om det???

  • @jebb671
    @jebb671 6 років тому

    Do a review of Catcher in the Rye

  • @liamshope2838
    @liamshope2838 6 років тому

    Hey Cliff, long time fan here. I've been wondering, since your channel has grown so much since I subscribed and your fans have gotten more and more dedicated, are you afraid of developing a cult of personality? In other words, have you ever worried that, the more fans you get, it becoming less about the books and more about you?
    I only ask because I watched something similar happen to theneedledrop and his fans.

  • @krille6690
    @krille6690 4 роки тому

    Ceo of good vibes

  • @xcabc123
    @xcabc123 6 років тому

    Pastor Cliff Sargent!!!

  • @freeri87
    @freeri87 5 років тому

    Weary Men by Arne Garborg

  • @esticaandres3169
    @esticaandres3169 Рік тому

    Did you say he becomes obsessed with his patient Gregorious? comn, he is obsessed with sex.. and he focused that obsession on his wife

  • @fritzkuhne2055
    @fritzkuhne2055 5 років тому

    his girl died when he was still a child? reminds me of lolita

  • @sanderallstar6765
    @sanderallstar6765 6 років тому +1

    Jalmarr Suderburg lmao

  • @walterclaeton9715
    @walterclaeton9715 6 років тому

    This is just like that movie by Woody allen 🤔
    Irrational man

  • @OtherSideOfTheVoid
    @OtherSideOfTheVoid 6 років тому

    doctor glas? more like doctor varg vikernes!

  • @eyeofsauron2812
    @eyeofsauron2812 10 місяців тому

    Had to read this in school, it was awful

  • @Jonmad17
    @Jonmad17 6 років тому +8

    I just wanna say that your mannerisms have gotten way less obnoxious over the years. I guess reading does turn you into a better person.

    • @lulu-ug7hg
      @lulu-ug7hg 6 років тому +1

      thats so shady but i know exactly what you mean :p

    • @kylej.whitehead-music309
      @kylej.whitehead-music309 6 років тому +2

      Life itself seems to do a hell of a lot to subdue a person. I'm a bit of a spastic but despite my young age I already find myself mellowing. Life'll do that to you quicker than you expect.

    • @bigfat4172
      @bigfat4172 5 років тому +1

      Lol, this is hard to disagree with. I remember watching one of his early vids and thinking "Yeah,this dude probably had a neitzchez phase and probably listens to Joe Rogan and Jordan Peterson". Nowadays he's definitely a lot more interesting I think.