it is really really like REALLY cool how no matter how much fame or attention as an artist Hayden gets, she stays very true to herself and the creative influences and collaborators around her. Collaborating with really amazing bands and artists and uplifting them with her larger audience really warms my heart. punish is beautiful and this performance was truly unreal. thank you for all you do Hayden 🖤
I feel like the demo sounds a lot like the sadness that comes with shame, whereas the released version focuses more on the pure disgust of shame, the kind that makes you unable to look at yourself in the mirror. Either way, I'm obsessed with both versions. Love it sm!!
thank you for creating and releasing this masterpiece, i’ve been listening to it on repeat since its release, and never forget, it’s happening to everybody.
You know what, I think I've heard a Good Night & Good Morning song a long time ago and liked it, but I didn't dive any deeper than that. This performance is making me go, "...Damn. I think I need to give these guys a proper shot." So thanks a bunch for reintroducing me to this group, Hayden! 🙏
sounds like distant rain.. i’m just outside the city, but it’s lights so bright, i still can’t see any stars & i don’t care, because it feels good to be gone 🖤
I heard that demo with Vyva Melinkolya on tumblr and fell in love with it. I also really wish this vid was on Spotify. Or SoundCloud. Everything you put your hands on turns golden, thank you.
"Key Studies" Lyrics: [Verse 1] Press down the keys to sing for her Studies of keys that open her door And the studies will show [Refrain] I'll turn up in Boston I'll turn up in Brooklyn I'll turn up in Boston I'll turn up in good time [Verse 2] Time on my knees to beg for her Studies of "please" to take more And the studies will show You got your start (I'll turn up in Boston) When you were too young to know that (I'll turn up in Brooklyn) The world looked better (I'll turn up in Boston) Through a haze (I'll turn up in good time)
"Punish" Demo Lyrics: each time that i think of you i push another through and recall how the bullet flew each time that i think of you i barricade the room one more wound i was an angel, though plummeting i watched it get dark i’m playing it tough the worst that could happen is happening to me another round of shots for the boys on tv i was an angel, but they made me leave with stars in my eyes crying as i wheel as i hit the lake i prayed it’d be green it’s all that i need i deserve it, i think i loved an angel, and it made me weak i am punished by love i am punished by love i am punished by love i am punished by love i loved an angel, and it made me weak i loved an angel, and it made me weak
All this stuff brings to mind a lot of what was going on in my day during the 90s with so much of the shoegaze bands. Her voice is much more interesting and soulful than most of those bands though.
@@eggplantbearI’d do anything for that footage. Also thanks for recording that other gig, that performance of Median II has meant the world to me since this gig finished.
I love how the audience was so respectful and stayed quiet during the preformance, this videotape is very relaxing
in the club, it happening to every-body
What is happening?
@@orionsshoe2424 what's happening to you and me.
Clurb*
Omg this comment 👌🏽
this era’s gonna be everything
it is really really like REALLY cool how no matter how much fame or attention as an artist Hayden gets, she stays very true to herself and the creative influences and collaborators around her. Collaborating with really amazing bands and artists and uplifting them with her larger audience really warms my heart. punish is beautiful and this performance was truly unreal. thank you for all you do Hayden 🖤
"i deserve it, i think" might just be one of my favorite lines ever. it's so mournful, i adore it.
I love watching my favorite legend of Zelda player singing and making music
This performance reminded me of early Low (never a bad thing). Wonderfully absorbing.
Iirc they actually played a show with Low back in the day!
@@JenRipsVinyl That would be a good double bill.
I feel like the demo sounds a lot like the sadness that comes with shame, whereas the released version focuses more on the pure disgust of shame, the kind that makes you unable to look at yourself in the mirror. Either way, I'm obsessed with both versions. Love it sm!!
If we don’t get this demo released somewhere, I will rally the daughters. (With love)
thank you for creating and releasing this masterpiece, i’ve been listening to it on repeat since its release, and never forget, it’s happening to everybody.
have we all been punished?
being punished as i write these words
yas
@@minamur uboa reference?
it's happening to everybody
more like saved FROM BEING punished. she cleanses my soul
This is gonna be song of the year/album of the year.
love it when artist take their time
You know what, I think I've heard a Good Night & Good Morning song a long time ago and liked it, but I didn't dive any deeper than that. This performance is making me go, "...Damn. I think I need to give these guys a proper shot." So thanks a bunch for reintroducing me to this group, Hayden! 🙏
you need to listen to narrowing type it’s lifechanging
Goodnight and Good morning x Punish is all I’ve ever needed
"i deserve it, i think" . . . Wow hayden, just wow
there’s something so indescribable about live performances
I love how you can hear the slow midwestern emo inspiration in this demo, such a cool take. I can’t wait for this albumm🙏
hearing key studies and punish back to back was incredible...
loving the soft edges, like its forming, slipping to the surface in clay , pulling through , having the best fun taking your time together
i get that she changed the finished version to match the perverts project mood, but i need this one released 😢
Gosh, this made time stand still
i heard it first through tumblr, it was so beautiful.
hearing the demo version is so beautiful its amazing to see how much process goes into the music
sounds like distant rain..
i’m just outside the city, but it’s lights so bright, i still can’t see any stars & i don’t care, because it feels good to be gone 🖤
PRAISE THE LORD
you guys should release a studio version of key studies!!
song is key studies by good night & good morning / punish (demo) by ethel cain for those who are asking
thank you
I am punished by this song. I love this to death and listen to it at least 10 times a day/night.
punish starts at 6:40 if anyone was wondering 🤍
this sounds so good right now
heavenly sounds
I heard that demo with Vyva Melinkolya on tumblr and fell in love with it. I also really wish this vid was on Spotify. Or SoundCloud. Everything you put your hands on turns golden, thank you.
You have the best band
this is good night & good morning
@@eggplantbearGNGM are the best band tho they’re right
it was a dream watching this live!!!!!! hope you come back to town again!!
i need a studio version of the punish demo ASAP
dang i live near there and missed an ethel performance and a jack white performance. I must start going more often i guess.
Ya'll sound like early Low, and that is fantastic!!
i need this version of the song so bad 🥲
SHE WAS IN MILWAUKEE AND I MISSED IT
such a wonderful and gorgeous demo, she should release it but if she doesn’t we have this amazing live performance for sure 🖤
The best album of the year
Its finally happening to everybody
So cool to hear Punish in this conceptualization. Love the repetition of the “angel” line
Lo que me hace sentir esta mujeeer dioooos, te amo tanto
"Key Studies" Lyrics:
[Verse 1]
Press down the keys to sing for her
Studies of keys that open her door
And the studies will show
[Refrain]
I'll turn up in Boston
I'll turn up in Brooklyn
I'll turn up in Boston
I'll turn up in good time
[Verse 2]
Time on my knees to beg for her
Studies of "please" to take more
And the studies will show
You got your start
(I'll turn up in Boston)
When you were too young to know that
(I'll turn up in Brooklyn)
The world looked better
(I'll turn up in Boston)
Through a haze
(I'll turn up in good time)
this is incredibly beautiful, very touching. thank you for creating and sharing art with us. it means the world. I love you forever Hayden♡
i love gnagm so much, cant believe i missed this
This looks incredible live
beautiful
I am so glad I found your music when I did. Your music has helped me so much. Your voice is stunning!
Ethereal Cain 🎉
Ohhhhhh I love this vibe on the guitar and live. Gives the song a whole different feel that I equally love!
Okay seriously, we need that demo
love them much
this is so beautiful
So beautiful and effortless 🥲
I can't wait to see you perform live!!!
i could so see her working with Akira Yamaoka in the future... the demo version is glorious
this is how i find out Good Night & Good Morning are back??!? and performing with you????
we all live in different cities now but we’re slowly doing stuff again!
Amazing 🖤
I CANNOT wait for Perverts to drop
absolutely incredible. Thank you
Being punished is my new high
The vibe is amazing, i know i would be crying in a random corner by myself
you are a revolutionary istg
i had been waiting for this to be posted ty! i love this punish version
Stunningly beautiful as always
"Punish" Demo Lyrics:
each time that i think of you
i push another through
and recall how the bullet flew
each time that i think of you
i barricade the room
one more wound
i was an angel, though plummeting
i watched it get dark
i’m playing it tough
the worst that could happen
is happening to me
another round of shots
for the boys on tv
i was an angel, but they made me leave
with stars in my eyes
crying as i wheel
as i hit the lake
i prayed it’d be green
it’s all that i need
i deserve it, i think
i loved an angel, and it made me weak
i am punished by love
i am punished by love
i am punished by love
i am punished by love
i loved an angel, and it made me weak
i loved an angel, and it made me weak
the demo is sooo calming
Thank you mother
Best band in the world
"i loved an angel, and it made me weak" oh :((
Love Hayden's mind so much
tysmmmmm
This is glorious
All this stuff brings to mind a lot of what was going on in my day during the 90s with so much of the shoegaze bands. Her voice is much more interesting and soulful than most of those bands though.
Thanks meemaw🎉
I love the sound of this demo :0
Someday I will see her perform live..
oh my god
Surreal.
🌊
Imagine being ethel cain and be like: wtf im ethel cain
Could never be me bcs i'm not Ethel Cain 😭
Gives the same vibes as "IM FUCKING MARKIPLIER BITCH"
@@Kirb171don’t let your dreams be dreams
i think listening to your voice is the closest i’ll ever be to heaven… something about it vibrates through my very soul
Love you 🖤
YES LAWDDDDDD YES
The demo 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
we love you Ethel
it’s happening to every-body ♡
God I can't wait for the album to come out so I can lay on my bed and stare at the ceiling in the dark listening for an hour and a half
Love u 😭😭😭 u changed my life girl
🖤🖤
thank you for this, angel
I'm so so so excited for this new music dude
❤❤❤
what I would give to see this live.
it was amazing, i recorded on my ps vita
@@eggplantbearI’d do anything for that footage.
Also thanks for recording that other gig, that performance of Median II has meant the world to me since this gig finished.
@@Grouchator luckily for you it will be on my youtube soon
@ oh God bless you
i’m begging pls come perform in toronto i wanna see u live so badd
❤ you should do a tour with Chelsea Wolf - don’t forget to come to Europe 👏
Beautiful gorgeous mama
Hello very much