Asian virtual singers involve a lot of work, it is not like those AI synthesizers that steal the voice of a voice actor or celebrity, they involve the work of the voice provider, of all the technological team that creates the software, composers, musicians, illustrators, animators, it is useless to despise the work of such a large collective with excuses like "they have no soul" "they are cold" "they steal opportunities to humans", because there is a lot of HUMAN talent behind a single song And no, the fact that they are "perfect" because they are virtual does not mean success, it is the same as with the singers of flesh and blood, it is a roulette of chance where the virtual singer can be successful (harvested after years) or be a failure for their company
i hate that she is just hating for no reason. its take as much work as normal singer and vocaloid. idk why she take it so personally, also her voice suck as well, i hope she take taken away with miku and teto
@@vsingersubs cos it is. She cant b famous in her own country so she try to be more famous in china for some reason. Hating on vocaloid is bad enough. I sub to this channel but now i want to report any video
@@LinLP you are free to express yourself, just as she is to express herself. as someone who has been working in the industry all her life, the last thing she wants to see is AI replacing human singers, which is absolutely possible in the future. is that really hard to understand? or are you just a hater? in that case, go watch something else and stop wasting your time bud.
Lovely reaction and appreciate the honesty! It's the first time I hear of a singer's perspective, thank you. I listen to real life singers often (of course) and vocaloid songs as well. Some trivia about vocaloids that may better help Teacher Rozette's understanding about the community: vocaloids started as a computer program for music producers who were, well, not able to afford or had no connections with real singers. Most producers were in their teens and begin creating songs from their bedrooms! (Kinda like an indie genre.) Gradually, the popular songs on niconico had others covering the songs either vocally or as a dance. In fact, so many current popular Japanese singers, had their roots from creating/covering vocaloid songs. To name a few: Yonezu Kenshi (his famous song is "Lemon"), Yoasobi, Ado etc. Others focus their whole career on covering vocaloid songs and amassing a following from it. In short, as a vocaloid fan, I focus more on the person behind creating the vocaloid song because I like their style, and then also gradually supporting whoever who make good covers. I don't forsee vocaloids taking over real life singers. AI, on the other hand, is something I agree we should be concerned over but that's another topic. Thank you again for the sincere reaction!
lovely to hear rozette's beautiful singing and piano at the end and also what you guys feel and think about the ai "singers" topic. gong linna and the other musicians made the stage really interesting. it's a first for me, sitting through a vocaloid's performance till the end - they sound "flat" (not in the pitch sense) to me like plain machines and lack the juice and taste of flesh and blood vocals. it's a funny feeling knowing they're working on that, sampling real singers' behaviour and choices 😬
in the end as people we will still easily moved by a good human vocal, vocaloids still have a long way to go if their works want to move people the way Disturbed Sounds of Silence or Zhou Shen's Memory
Would you please make a video on Kalafina? It’s a Japanese group of three very great female vocalists, kind of rock mix operatic singing. Layers of voices very well blended. I’ve never heard anything like that from other groups. They’re amazing!
I think it might help to understand the whole vocaloid industry more. The technology has been around for a long time and one of the reasons it hasn't already taken over the entire industry is cost. While it's true the cartoon character doesn't need to eat or sleep but it takes people of various numbers and skills in the background to make that cartoon come to life. It's not as easy as it looks, just like being a singer isn't as easy as it looks to people outside the industry. Now the only thing to watch out for is for regulations to catch up when/before vocaloid singing becomes more widely accepted, income starts rolling and economies of scale make the industry blow up.
Maybe since Vtubers have been mentioned, you can react to them next. Not quite sure how that will fly from past controversies but it would be interesting to see.
Vocaloids will become really scary when their singing voices become indistinguishable from human singers, just like text to speech software voices now. And then the engineers tweak the algorithm to show convincing emotions and imperfections, plus Zhou Shen level of vocal artistry.
To be honest, I don't like her evaluation. She treats Vocaloid as a machine and ignores everyone's efforts. The reason we like Vocaloid·Utau is that there are many excellent creators here. We will pay attention to many painters, composers, arrangers, tuners, and lyricists. Even if it is equipped with a voice library trained by AI, without the efforts of the tuner, the virtual singer will not be able to sing at a level that matches that of normal people. Tuning is not an easy task. In fact, it also requires the tuner to have very high knowledge and level of music theory. I'm a little emotional right now, So if you think the tuner's job is easy, then you can try it yourself and use the vocaloid 3 editor.There is an English virtual singer named Oliver who has a voice library based on the vocaloid 3 engine. Are you ready for us to see your work?😅
I feel the East is more acceptable to AI tech than the West. This is not to say who is more or less right, it's just an observation. Perhaps it is due to the pop culture in the West? ie. Terminator. Or perhaps also due the pop culture in the East, ie. Anime; the vocaloids are always stylized in anime style.
Ini Hanyalah teknologi suka atau tidak hanya kenyataan yang bisa atau tidak harus disaksikan. Seperti dahulu Holywood membuat filem basket jordan dgn carakter cartun. Apa perbedaannya dgn ini. Kita tidak dapat berbalik kebelakang dgn terus melangkah, yang di belakang hanya kenangan baik manis atau pahit. Seperti waktu yang tidak dapat menunggu kita. Nikmati atau hiraukan itu hanya pilihan
Love your reactions BUT you are missing out on a real treat. You don't appear to have reviewed probably one of the best female vocalist out there from South Korea. Want to see a singer show TOTAL CONTROL? Try “Misty” by Sohyang. ua-cam.com/video/_ivvpK3UMlw/v-deo.html
我滿同意右邊男生的看法，我認為藝術有不同形式和受眾，我不討厭AI歌曲，但也不會因為AI表現得完美無瑕而不欣賞有瑕疵的人聲，對我來說他們是不同的藝術形式，就像老師說的，藝術是個獨特的主題，或許未來機器可以取代掉許多技術或勞動職業，但它不能取代真正的藝術家，就算AI成為一種藝術流派也不代表其他人會被取代
就像AI還沒出現時大家也都有自己喜歡的歌手和曲風，AI只是一種新的藝術形式，真人歌手有自己的價值，表演者們苦練的技巧，歌唱時的情感及背後付出的努力都是我們喜歡，甚至成為粉絲的原因，這是機器無法替代的
(下一支推薦影片竟然是Neuro-sama的歌QQ)
老师太可爱了 真性情 😢我好喜欢这个老师
其實可以跟老師說明，Vocaloid並不是完全無中生有，背後仍需要數十甚至上百小時的人聲錄音。像最早一版的初音的收音母帶數據就有50個小時，而且其實不需要覺得這會取代什麼，畢竟以現在來說，我認為Vocaloid也算是樂器的一種，是樂曲的一部分，是創作者表現的一種方法。君不見那些走向幕前的P以及翻唱歌手一樣有好的表現，同時也不影響Vocaloid的發展與應用
确实不是无中生有，但是之后技术会更成熟，需要的各种成本越来越少，挤压到活人艺术家是必然的。
@@wenpx3971 怎麼擠壓？IA問世這麼久，我不覺得Lia有被擠壓到啊？近十年的動畫oped也沒看有那家起用vocaloid？
@@justforacg 因為過去的硬體和素材還沒到爆發期，光是去年初到今年初MJ6的表現和還不夠嗎？AI不光是應用的範圍，用海量資料以假亂真的會是更大的問題(如新聞、歷史、資料庫……)
現在AI有長久記憶的技術越來越像人，
共存的方向不像老師去考慮現實面不可能，
我相信人本精神最重要的是去欣賞人當下的選擇、反應、表現，
這是生命，這是靠資料的機器跟AI所沒有的東西，
大眾會被行銷跟教育引導喜好，
未來的藝術家不能困在自己的小圈圈自HIGH，
應該多做一些大家接受、聽得懂、有審美的東西
😂我還想說怎麼沒人說初音！！初音團體在虛擬歌手裡絕絕子阿！
Asian virtual singers involve a lot of work, it is not like those AI synthesizers that steal the voice of a voice actor or celebrity, they involve the work of the voice provider, of all the technological team that creates the software, composers, musicians, illustrators, animators, it is useless to despise the work of such a large collective with excuses like "they have no soul" "they are cold" "they steal opportunities to humans", because there is a lot of HUMAN talent behind a single song
And no, the fact that they are "perfect" because they are virtual does not mean success, it is the same as with the singers of flesh and blood, it is a roulette of chance where the virtual singer can be successful (harvested after years) or be a failure for their company
I think it really depends, at this moment, yes your comment is absolutely correct. However, what about 5 years later when AGI becomes real?
i hate that she is just hating for no reason. its take as much work as normal singer and vocaloid. idk why she take it so personally, also her voice suck as well, i hope she take taken away with miku and teto
@@LinLP It even seems like a personal resentment, it's absurd
@@vsingersubs cos it is. She cant b famous in her own country so she try to be more famous in china for some reason. Hating on vocaloid is bad enough. I sub to this channel but now i want to report any video
@@LinLP you are free to express yourself, just as she is to express herself. as someone who has been working in the industry all her life, the last thing she wants to see is AI replacing human singers, which is absolutely possible in the future. is that really hard to understand? or are you just a hater? in that case, go watch something else and stop wasting your time bud.
you can relax, just like paintings will never be replaced by photos, nor will human vocalists ever be replaced by vocaloids.
其實看到影片有討論讓我蠻開心的，畢竟這是今後的問題之一。
我很喜歡為電子人聲所寫的歌，不代表我喜歡上電子人聲、
而是我喜歡上那些翻唱的唱者。
對我來說電子人聲是讓那些難以出名的作曲者、
無法自己唱出DEMO的作者們得到讓大家知道他們作品的機會。
回歸這個舞台，舞台做的很棒，龔琳娜也真的用強大聲壓控住整場，
其實沒太多會讓我排斥的地方；
真的讓我排斥的是歌唱類選秀節目上派出電子人聲上場。
那個節目最終選出了所有歌唱節目以來幾乎最強的素人冠軍，
但同時也讓大眾看到了一個無恥的笑話。
點評電子人聲唱歌音準跟技術，也不知道到底他是否真的知道自己在做啥。
I found that Tianyi Luo was the original signer of the song and Gong Linna covered it showing different interpretation of the song.
跪求周深深的“Unstoppable”🙏🙏
雖然全程背影，但仍能從深深的歌聲、視角中，感受到滿滿的力量❤❤❤
我也期望
後來只會越來越多 這是趨勢 只要會創作詞曲的人 都能用AI展現自己的才華 而不用經過繁雜的投稿 尋找歌手
很多人可以寫很好的詞曲 但本身五音不全 除非運氣特別好 不然通常都放棄夢想了
vocaloid跟ai一点关系都没有啊，纯手调拼接的，算最早期的语音合成软件了，十几年前初音未来就很火了，就相当于录好每个元音辅音，然后拼接起来，听起来很生硬，也有很特殊的电子味；可以对比的是现在比较新的cevio ai的语音合成软件，大概是用ai学习了一个发声模型，然后用模型直接跑出来想要的歌，这个还更接近ai一点，但是还是得手动调教（加个私货，cevio ai的比较火的一个声库“可不”，是以Vtuber花谱制作的，也想听听老师对这个的评价）；实际现在最ai的还是抖音ai配音，微软ai朗读这种，感觉还没怎么见到在歌唱领域的应用。
現在的vocaloid已經開始加入AI技術了.. 跟最開始早就不一樣了
@@selina-fu6vv 狭义上vocaloid还是指老的雅马哈那套用音节拼接的软件吧，新的软件像可不用的是cevio，这种是建立一个语音模型，然后再去模拟的，原理不一样了。（虽然现在v家曲排行榜，甚至官方的pjsk里都直接加了cevio做的曲子就是了，哈哈）
@@selina-fu6vv是的而且未来的趋势基本上就是会淘汰歌手 演员 模特的。这是不可避免的
这么说吧，你可以把它理解为乐器和电子音乐，这两者谁也替代不了谁，完全是不同路线的产物
很能理解老師對AI將取代歌手的傷感.去年AI繪圖軟體出來後。攝影師跟畫家也瞬間被取代，雖說ＡＩ的基礎是無數攝影師跟畫家的大量作品的數據生成，可是讓我震驚的是，ＡＩ竟然一夕之間取代的了專業的攝影師跟畫家。以前我總以為被機器人取代的工作，只是些無聊的工作，所以要求小孩一定要有一技之長，在工作中要成為不可替代的才不會被淘汱。
可是，現在歌手，攝影師，畫家，這三種都是需要長年不斷的練習累積的高專業職業，現在就這樣被AＩ取代，這真的真的很讓人傷感。
我完全可以理情老師的心情，我覺得我的心裡也還沒有調整到可以接受這個新AＩ統治的新世代。
只是不接受，不表示可以抵抗它們的到來，這才是可怕的，ＡＩ將大量統治引領這個新世界，它帶來好處，也帶來缺點。帶來方便，也帶來殘忍的淘汱。
其实艺术家不用太担心被AI取代工作。我试过AI制图 如果是重复性的工作 AI确实可以轻易取代，但AI是没有艺术作品的内核和表达的。这个不论是小说 绘画 还是音乐 都是一样的。Eventually AI是一个工具 但能创造出有灵魂有共鸣作品的 只有人类。
理解老师的情绪爆发。AI的发展必然对人类社会带来更深刻的变化。是福是祸尚未定论。
就好像做纯手工汽车的师傅，应该都不喜欢工厂流水线生产的汽车一样。
Lovely reaction and appreciate the honesty! It's the first time I hear of a singer's perspective, thank you. I listen to real life singers often (of course) and vocaloid songs as well.
Some trivia about vocaloids that may better help Teacher Rozette's understanding about the community: vocaloids started as a computer program for music producers who were, well, not able to afford or had no connections with real singers. Most producers were in their teens and begin creating songs from their bedrooms! (Kinda like an indie genre.) Gradually, the popular songs on niconico had others covering the songs either vocally or as a dance. In fact, so many current popular Japanese singers, had their roots from creating/covering vocaloid songs. To name a few: Yonezu Kenshi (his famous song is "Lemon"), Yoasobi, Ado etc. Others focus their whole career on covering vocaloid songs and amassing a following from it.
In short, as a vocaloid fan, I focus more on the person behind creating the vocaloid song because I like their style, and then also gradually supporting whoever who make good covers. I don't forsee vocaloids taking over real life singers. AI, on the other hand, is something I agree we should be concerned over but that's another topic. Thank you again for the sincere reaction!
彼阳的晚意，初生的东溪
可以和老師分享，周深唱的那首【搭拉蹦吧】的原唱就是洛天依。
非常理解和讚同Rozette，我不是很喜歡AI歌聲/歌手
還是re昨晚同在B站表演的周深唱的unstoppable吧
在目前來看，AI再厲害也取代不了“人生為人”這件事。
在電腦上聽一段大自然的鳥叫聲，跟到戶外聽到的，是很不一樣的體驗。絕不是一套完美的音響和錄音就能取代的。
孩子們在身旁隨口的哼唱，也絕不會輕易被AI所取代的。
希望老师也来赏析一下周深唱的《浮光》
非常好听
非常好听
非常好听！！！
重要的事情说三遍
Saya sedang menunggu tanggapan kepada Sah Dinding salah satu penyanyi dgn suara sangat indah.
把老師弄哭了，這大過年的😢😢
lovely to hear rozette's beautiful singing and piano at the end and also what you guys feel and think about the ai "singers" topic. gong linna and the other musicians made the stage really interesting. it's a first for me, sitting through a vocaloid's performance till the end - they sound "flat" (not in the pitch sense) to me like plain machines and lack the juice and taste of flesh and blood vocals. it's a funny feeling knowing they're working on that, sampling real singers' behaviour and choices 😬
許願點評日本歌手Ado所有的LIVE演出影片 , Ado都已經在日本NHK紅白歌唱大賽表演 , 演唱SHOW的LIVE演出 , 還是遲遲等不到老師的點評 ,
雖然Ado不露臉 , 相信以老師的音樂專業 , 要分辨出來是不是真唱沒問題 , 之前已經很多西方的歌唱老師和歌手以及音樂製作人都點評過Ado , 都給出很高的評價 ,
很難讓人相信Ado真的是LIVE唱出那些高難度歌曲 , 一直在研究Ado的歌唱技巧 , 越研究越發現Ado真的是自己演唱 , 都震驚了他們 !
歌手們（特別是女歌手）因初音未來洛天依都是針對女聲，應該以專業的態度投身歌唱，不要再假唱咪嘴才不會被淘汰；龔琳娜周深是其中表表者，龔琳娜老師跟安達組合合作的是如何投入便是最佳模範。
可以解釋一下你想表達什麼嗎？
我認為vocaloid的主題是製作人本身而不是歌手，卡通形象只是作為媒介，製作人的代表。vocaloid在日本的作品很多更像是拿vocaloid作為一種樂器，而不是傳統的音樂。至於傳入中國後，喜歡把卡通形象去和真人同台合作與較量，那是商業公司的考慮。而且我感覺這個視頻單純是抨擊ai，像ai畫不出人畫的東西一樣，然而vocaloid十來年的發展歷史中，ai只是這一兩年的一種新載體，所討論的東西也跟vocaloid關係不大。
外行人表达他们对某新生事物的第一印象而已，确实不太懂，有点杞人忧天，但他们的反应是真实的，这就跟原始部落的村民看见照相机以为灵魂会被那个黑盒子带走一样，外人看着也许觉得可笑，但是确实是他们的真实反应啊
in the end as people we will still easily moved by a good human vocal, vocaloids still have a long way to go if their works want to move people the way Disturbed Sounds of Silence or Zhou Shen's Memory
放心，所有创作类艺术类的工作都会是最后一批被AI取代的工作，if it ever happens，现在还有很多几乎没什么创造性的很routine的工作还在用着要喝水吃饭，会生病会发脾气的人，那些人担心自己被取代的紧迫性才更高。
把這集和陶喆搞壞自己聲音那集放在一起能哭瞎我的眼睛...
不用过于担心，虚拟歌姬出现也有20年左右了吧。但至今也没有表现出要取代真人歌手的势头
Would you please make a video on Kalafina? It’s a Japanese group of three very great female vocalists, kind of rock mix operatic singing. Layers of voices very well blended. I’ve never heard anything like that from other groups. They’re amazing!
有利有弊，AI人物尤其是动漫人物，需要一个团队，从就业人数来讲比一个经纪人带一个歌手更多。而且成本和产出也有利润差距。
我觉得现在是技术还没有成熟到足以能够完全模仿人声以及完全模仿人类形象的境地，不过再过可能3年，5年，技术已经发展到可以完全模仿人声，并且完美模仿人物形象时，真实人类的歌手受到的威胁更大。有可能一个让人完全看不出是AI还是真人的人类形象在网络上不断的推出自己的音乐。
I think it might help to understand the whole vocaloid industry more. The technology has been around for a long time and one of the reasons it hasn't already taken over the entire industry is cost. While it's true the cartoon character doesn't need to eat or sleep but it takes people of various numbers and skills in the background to make that cartoon come to life. It's not as easy as it looks, just like being a singer isn't as easy as it looks to people outside the industry. Now the only thing to watch out for is for regulations to catch up when/before vocaloid singing becomes more widely accepted, income starts rolling and economies of scale make the industry blow up.
Agree! Her disdain for vocaloids is evident in her words even though she knows nothing about it, which is why this video is so disgusting.
真的被伤到了😂10-20年后再考古这个视频，会很有意思😊😊😊
完全贊同！這一集探討的問題既嚴肅又感傷！
我的觀後感是，使用ai代替真人時，知識版權和引用資源方面可能要公開透明，或為ai歌手設定一定限制，引用資源要合乎知識版權，不然可能導致行業秩序混亂，可能也會出現原本那真人被ai代替這種的被侵犯的意味。
好想聽Rozette老師點評大老師, 還有她聽到那些歌的反應😫求求了, 我是小學生
洛天依在现在的 10 后中非常受欢迎，也许这就是代代相传而已
站在時代巨輪面前，任何人，事，物都必定會變遷，老師或許還是太年青，並未深深感受到變幻原是永恆的道理，雖然我也不懂欣賞Al歌手，但不能否定AI出現的必要，這是人力資源的問題！正如老師經常強調不喜歡古舊深沉而長厚的震音，現在也不喜歡AI,這些都是時代下的某一些元素，任何事我們總不能停在自己感覺最良好的時代，用感覺最良好的元素一成不變地幹下去，時代終將首先淘汰這類別的人！還有，藝術發展這產物，本身就是因為社會發展富裕起來的副產品，受眾者本身不需有指定品位才能欣賞藝術，變相可以百花齊放的發展，尤其對於音樂，音樂本來就是在不同心態，情緒，年齡下都有不同的感受，當然，太劣質的作品，自然會淘汰，所以别太介懷於某些元素的出現，這是必然也是必需的！
認同並尊重你的看法
但懷舊復古近年又流行起來，正因為科技不斷推陳出新，有些歷久彌新的經典反而更顯珍貴
@@thomasvr4 一般所謂流行的新東西，新事物，其實多是用以前的流行的再加少許改變而產生，很少有一樣東西是沒涉及舊有元素！如果真有這麼一種東西出現，那肯定能夠改變世界的！
Maybe since Vtubers have been mentioned, you can react to them next. Not quite sure how that will fly from past controversies but it would be interesting to see.
Vocaloids will become really scary when their singing voices become indistinguishable from human singers, just like text to speech software voices now. And then the engineers tweak the algorithm to show convincing emotions and imperfections, plus Zhou Shen level of vocal artistry.
反正我也是沒辦法接受AI歌手的，一方面是因為很假，讓我耳朵不舒服，一方面是就像老師說的，若AI音樂可以取代人聲成為主流音樂，那這些練習vocal的人感覺就像小丑一樣，練習這些還有什麼意義？至少我會有這種感覺。
对于AI的完美无瑕，我觉得这反而是它最大的瑕疵……
To be honest, I don't like her evaluation. She treats Vocaloid as a machine and ignores everyone's efforts. The reason we like Vocaloid·Utau is that there are many excellent creators here. We will pay attention to many painters, composers, arrangers, tuners, and lyricists. Even if it is equipped with a voice library trained by AI, without the efforts of the tuner, the virtual singer will not be able to sing at a level that matches that of normal people.
Tuning is not an easy task. In fact, it also requires the tuner to have very high knowledge and level of music theory.
I'm a little emotional right now, So if you think the tuner's job is easy, then you can try it yourself and use the vocaloid 3 editor.There is an English virtual singer named Oliver who has a voice library based on the vocaloid 3 engine. Are you ready for us to see your work?😅
洛天依是vocaloid，不是AI，vocaloid的初衷是为了让作曲家更容易创作作品，这跟AI演唱的初衷完全不同，也完全没有掩盖任何艺术家的才华
個人不是太喜歡 AI歌手 沒感情的歌 是感動不到人 讓我想起明日之子那個卡通形象參賽的歌手
洛天依不是ai....ai和vocaloid不一样
@@tamakomika7145都一樣很難聽😂
@@ThomasLeung-j6z 比你唱的好听
@@ThomasLeung-j6z油饼？
老师你想想只要没有电那个虚拟就不存在了，而人任何时候都可以唱歌。不要难过，我虽然和你一样不能接受，ai唱歌一点感情都没有。
我看到影片裡老師哭我也快哭了
但是我看到卡通人物哭不會跟著哭
所以AI暫時不會完全取代人類
未聞花名弄哭超多人🤣
跪求react周深B站跨年晚会上的unstopabled的神级现场！
我也期望
AI人聲能夠幫助不擅長唱歌的作曲家出聲，比如VOCALOID，我不認為這是壞事，因為真人歌手不可能會被替代
作曲家是找不到人来唱吗？
我在想其实老戏骨们看流量明星 或者更早些年戏剧演员看流行歌手也可以有一样的感慨吧 身在其中很难判断我们是在对抗时代的堕落还是艺术的发展
歸根VOCAL並不是工具價值 就算機械唱出一模一樣的聲音 對我們來說並不是相同意義 我們是欣賞歌手的技術和創作 展現出人類的可能性 例如AI棋手再強也不會影響我們欣賞真人棋手 , 另外是歌手跟觀眾的互動 由真人來傳遞情緒感受給我們是最真實的。但同樣我可以想像像配音員這些行業更有可能被取代 因為我們並不需要跟背後這個人進行互動 例如一個遊戲的人聲由Ai還是真人錄製我們應該普遍不太重視。
I feel the East is more acceptable to AI tech than the West. This is not to say who is more or less right, it's just an observation. Perhaps it is due to the pop culture in the West? ie. Terminator. Or perhaps also due the pop culture in the East, ie. Anime; the vocaloids are always stylized in anime style.
你可以試著給老師聽 周深 跟 鄧麗君 的合唱 鄧麗君是人工生成的 但是背後有真人唱
不赞同乐器的部分 乐器虽然没有生命 但是演奏家有呀 同一具小提琴在不同人手中呈现出来的效果也是不一样的
Ini Hanyalah teknologi suka atau tidak hanya kenyataan yang bisa atau tidak harus disaksikan.
Seperti dahulu Holywood membuat filem basket jordan dgn carakter cartun. Apa perbedaannya dgn ini.
Kita tidak dapat berbalik kebelakang dgn terus melangkah, yang di belakang hanya kenangan baik manis atau pahit.
Seperti waktu yang tidak dapat menunggu kita.
Nikmati atau hiraukan itu hanya pilihan
感覺老師看到miku live concert的反應應該會很有趣
@CZ Media
周深安达组合唱
對！超好聽的
敲碗張雨生！！
我是看了这首表演的现场的，不得不说我的现场感受就是非常不适。现有的视频是舞台上已经有一位虚拟形象，而现场舞台是没有的，可以看到导播仍然把大量龚琳娜演唱时的镜头给了虚拟形象，而实际上在现场虚拟形象的演唱只是一段背景录音，这让觉得对龚琳娜非常不公平。一位是有好好利用自己的天赋，经过并坚持长年累月练习才得到的接近完美演唱的歌手，另一位是没有人格存在的只是编辑出来的一段声音，而现场导播甚至把这位歌手演唱时的镜头交给一个空的舞台，让我非常难过。
我并不是不能接受虚拟形象歌手，但我不能接受真人歌手与虚拟形象同台把大量镜头（甚至是真人歌手演唱的镜头交给虚拟形象。
可以听听孙燕姿AI, 99％ 感觉像真人唱似的。。
還是希望多分享周深視頻
老师是不是Michael Jackson粉丝？要是可以Review下 MJ就好了❤
動作挺快!
我覺得大家對於人類本身特殊性過分低估了。
vocoloid 及其他定位相似的技術與其說是「歌手」，不如說是擔當樂曲中vocal角色的「樂器」，和真實的歌手根本是完全不同的領域，不可能出現誰取代誰的問題。
而AI又是完全不同的東西，從其運作方式和發展方向來看，要媲美人類還要好幾十年，更不用說強調情感的藝術領域😅
老师多虑了，AI技术确实在各行各业中发挥作用也许还会取代某些行业!但是我相信表演行业AI是无法取代的，因为大多数观众还是喜欢看、喜欢听有血有肉真人表演和演唱的，也许会有一少部分年轻人会喜欢AI表演，就像有些人就喜欢看动漫也不看真人电影或演唱，所以AI表演是取代不了真人表演的，老师不必太担心!
Really thought provoking and fair points you bring up about AI
BUT THE TURTH IS THAT virtual singers are not AI😅shes nobody but a clown
其实老师不必多虑，ai代替不了真正的人声，这个洛天依出道好多年了，现在依然只有她一个还在表演，并没有见更多AI声音出现在舞台上，说明只能浅尝即止。
can teacher do ADOＰＬＳＳＳＳＳ
I definitely prefer human … I don’t care how good or great the vocoloid 100% object on tht …
下结论之前是不是应该完全了解你所评论的事物？ACE/Synthv/Cevio这类ai声库之中ai起的作用是让调教更加方便 起决定作用的主体 让虚拟歌手真正唱出旋律的还是幕后的调教师，天依也好，miku也好，他们的歌声背后是无数人的努力 歌行四方从游学记企划公开再到制作完成再到登上跨晚中间无数的staff为之付出了心血 这首歌就是创作者们为天依而做的 你连最基本的什么是vocaloid 什么是ace ai 什么是洛天依都没搞清楚 就开始评头论足了？😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
外行人表达他们对某新生事物的第一印象而已，确实不太懂，有点杞人忧天，但他们的反应是真实的，这就跟原始部落的村民看见照相机以为灵魂会被那个黑盒子带走一样，外人看着也许觉得可笑，但是确实是他们的真实反应，有必要上纲上线吗？
Love your reactions BUT you are missing out on a real treat.
You don't appear to have reviewed probably one of the best female vocalist out there from South Korea.
Want to see a singer show TOTAL CONTROL? Try “Misty” by Sohyang.
ua-cam.com/video/_ivvpK3UMlw/v-deo.html
取代不會，但人力會變少而貴吧
为啥我总感觉老师不太喜欢龚琳娜那种民族唱法挤压发出的尖锐音呢？😂之前看一个国内乐评对比的视频宋祖英和席琳迪翁合唱《茉莉花》的对比里也有相同的观点
白人的傲慢罢了
不熟悉而已，也没有说过任何贬低的话吧？
周深的unstopprable， ua-cam.com/video/brARi-8UgTU/v-deo.html
現在國外已開始用AI去製作音樂，有些作詞作曲者，拿Adele的聲音加入AI編成一首歌，聽上去就像是Adele再唱一首新歌
未來可能沒有真人歌手這個職業，有的只是專業配音員!! 幫AI機器人配音
未來也不再需要討論歌手假唱這件事情，因為舞台上沒有真人再唱歌
不懂欣賞Vocaloid
老實說沒有龔老師的聲音墊著,我沒有辦法對洛天依的部分有共鳴,龔老師的聲音他在跟我傾訴山川,在跟我傾訴草原上的風,但是洛天依的聲音,好聽,但是我甚麼都感受不到...
零興致
电子音真心难听得很
聲音較尖銳，耳朵不是很舒服。
我不混二次元，对洛天依不讨厌也不喜欢，不管是她的声音还是她唱歌的曲风对我来说都没有太大的吸引力，我猜测很多年轻人喜欢洛天依是因为她的形象和她虚拟的身份，洛天依的二次元属性本身就足够吸引他们了，而不是因为喜欢她那种合成的声音？
龚琳娜跟着德国老公竟唱一些光怪陆离的小众歌 包括这首和AI合唱 和一只狗和唱更吸引眼球。
如果能接受AI歌手/藝術家，那是否也該接受演唱會假唱？接受AI運動員/球隊…機器人國民/領導人？我想看生也有涯的人類在有生之年努力突破人類在體力/想像力/創造力的極限，要是想看機器突破人類極限，去看無人機飛行或核彈彈爆破可也
先搞清楚如今的vocaloid•utau的虚拟歌手（此处泛指）是不是AI，先问是不是，再看有没有。😅
偷换概念有一手
不是同一个事，爱看动画片也爱看真人电影，不冲突啊，听听AI歌手，也听听真人唱歌，都可以啊。
看动画片的时候可以接受配音演员配音和动画角色嘴对不上的那些人，在看真人电影的时候，就算是后期配音，也会要求演员要有基本的敬业，念台词的时候不能是数12345对不对？
接受AI歌手，怎么就等于真人唱歌可以对嘴了？完全不同的事物啊
彼阳的晚意，初升的东曦