Юля прекрасна, как всегда. Влюбилась за 2014 год в ее катание, до этого не знала, что такая звездочка у нас в России есть. Любуюсь каждым элементом, вращения просто шикарны, особенно ее коренное в вертикальном шпагате! Какая же гибкость, пластичность и женственность! Юля все это в себе сочетает, продолжаю восхищаться ее растяжкой! От Юлиных программ глаз оторвать нельзя, а список Шиндлера - это просто шедевр'
Спасибо за ролик. Никто после нее ничего лучшего не показал. Все только повторяли. Какая пластика, какие руки и какие вращения. Надо было переждать пубертат. 2020
shes amazing! one of the most talented skaters these days, and her flexibility is as great as zhang in the past. she skates w some flaws, but still great to watch! well done!
She is amazing! Her flexibility sets her apart - in a good way. The comment abt holding the spirals longer -I'm sure the timing of her program does not allow for that - I agree it would be nice. She is very young and so so talented. As she matures, so will her skating. There is nothing negative to say in my opinion.
Нравится когда комментаторы иностранцы, культурно комментируют. Но наши иногда комментаторы, слушать не охота, как с улицы. Юлию любят, не равнодушны к её катанию. Эта маленькая девочка покорила сердца многих.
I see the comparison. They have marvelous flexibility that only they two could master. If Julia can match Cohen's artistry and flexibility with her consistency, she's unstoppable. What I don't want to see is another situation like Elizaveta, be picked to win and then crumble particularly next years Olympic season! I have my own hopes for the podium but if the Russians don't make it on Sochi, I can see a considerable chance for a sweep in PyeongChang.
The Nutcracker pas de deux is one of the most rousing and moving moments in the ballet so she needs to really push the presentation and connect to the music to match the power. That will come in time with her, I hope. I also hope she's able to keep her immense back flexibility as she gets older.
Great comment! Her flexibility does not merge with her skating skills and makes her looks like a circus act. This is figure skating, not contorsionism skating.
I heard her interview and she told when music start playing she couldn’t feel her legs and arms…Basically that were her 1-st Big competitions! She needs more practice and experience as well. WELL COME JULIA to the REAL figure skating World!!! And Good Like!!!
Julia and her coach should also work on Julia's axel technique because she doesn't get a lot of knee bend on the take-off (as Tuktamysheva does, for instance) so it doesn't get a lot of height and that can be a problem in the future when she grows!
Anybody can’t compete to her. They are not simply flexible…this is a reason why many people don’t like her. And she is brave girl and her performance much better than Sasha’s Kohen((
Thank you! Sometime my comments get hammered because of the diversity of opinions. I try to stick to the facts and Julia is not as polished as the rest of the field. Some of her positions look ugly such as the Sasha Spin and her needle scales. When Sasha Cohen first did them in the early 2000's many people complained about this as well. Hope Julia gets better.
Okay let me put this into..Do you u have an idea about how special a skater is no matter how good jumper or nice presentation could have??...in last 15 years I saw that special thing in Michelle Kwan..Sasha Cohen Yuna Kim Mao Asada..and even Shizuka Arakawa...watch their vids and I hope u can undestand what I´m talking about...
Excuse me but there's no comparison with Sasha Cohen..agreed about her flexibility and spins but at age of 15 Sasha had such an artistry and amazing musicality in contrast to Julia, however I think this young russian lady will mature in that part of her skating maybe in a couple of years..
says who ? Julia has good technique aside from her 2A, she has good edges and rotates fast in the air that makes up for ther critcisms of her smaller jumps
Julia should've been the Sochi gold medalist, but she fell twice. So Russians gave it to the other Russian. haha. It was Julia, NOT Sotnikova, who could beat Yuna Kim or Mao Asada. Again, sadly she fell hard twice. But then again, Russians cheated and generously gave the gold to Sotnikova. Such dirty way to 'win'. No dignity.
I think that The Nutcracker was a bad choice to skate to because it makes you want to compare it to other skaters that had amazing and artistic programs to The Nutcracker (e.g: Sasha Cohen). Plus, she is 14 and I think that she is still a little too immature to skate to music like this. I agree, she does need a better choreographer because it does get quite annoying when she lifts her leg and think that she is always slightly overscored on the artistic mark.
Really? Like Sasha, this girl needs to learn how to jump. Everyone's talking about her flexibility & spirals. What about her jumps?. She landed practically all of her jumps off balance & with 2 footing.
She can be gorgeous but there are too many ugly positions there beacuse her spirals are not held longer, her head positions look awkward, the stroking is poor and I'm sorry but I don't like prepubescent skaters. Remember all the fuzz that surrounded Zhang and MIrai 5 years ago?
Юля прекрасна, как всегда. Влюбилась за 2014 год в ее катание, до этого не знала, что такая звездочка у нас в России есть. Любуюсь каждым элементом, вращения просто шикарны, особенно ее коренное в вертикальном шпагате! Какая же гибкость, пластичность и женственность! Юля все это в себе сочетает, продолжаю восхищаться ее растяжкой! От Юлиных программ глаз оторвать нельзя, а список Шиндлера - это просто шедевр'
Julia Lipnitskaya= total package! Textbook spirals and skating! Sasha and Irina morphed into one! What's not to love!
Спасибо за ролик. Никто после нее ничего лучшего не показал. Все только повторяли. Какая пластика, какие руки и какие вращения. Надо было переждать пубертат. 2020
shes amazing! one of the most talented skaters these days, and her flexibility is as great as zhang in the past. she skates w some flaws, but still great to watch! well done!
She is very good!!!! Big enjoy watch to her performance!!!!
She is amazing! Her flexibility sets her apart - in a good way. The comment abt holding the spirals longer -I'm sure the timing of her program does not allow for that - I agree it would be nice. She is very young and so so talented. As she matures, so will her skating. There is nothing negative to say in my opinion.
Ну нет ей равных! Виртуознейшая вращения. Руки шикарные, гибкость изумительная. Моя любимая фигуристка.
Юлия Липницкая-королева вращений.Рядом с ней могу поставить только Денизе Бильманн.
Чайковский ей очень подходит. И Да! Таких вращений нет ни у кого. Даже только за них она всегда на первом месте
Нравится когда комментаторы иностранцы, культурно комментируют. Но наши иногда комментаторы, слушать не охота, как с улицы. Юлию любят, не равнодушны к её катанию. Эта маленькая девочка покорила сердца многих.
I see the comparison. They have marvelous flexibility that only they two could master. If Julia can match Cohen's artistry and flexibility with her consistency, she's unstoppable. What I don't want to see is another situation like Elizaveta, be picked to win and then crumble particularly next years Olympic season! I have my own hopes for the podium but if the Russians don't make it on Sochi, I can see a considerable chance for a sweep in PyeongChang.
She is the transfiguring power of the Eternal Feminine. Heavenly!
Just remember she's 14 in this video, still has a lot time to mature and grow into the lyricism.
The Nutcracker pas de deux is one of the most rousing and moving moments in the ballet so she needs to really push the presentation and connect to the music to match the power. That will come in time with her, I hope. I also hope she's able to keep her immense back flexibility as she gets older.
Great comment! Her flexibility does not merge with her skating skills and makes her looks like a circus act. This is figure skating, not contorsionism skating.
she did well, Julia is a fighter !
I hope her ankle feels better soon :)
I heard her interview and she told when music start playing she couldn’t feel her legs and arms…Basically that were her 1-st Big competitions! She needs more practice and experience as well.
WELL COME JULIA to the REAL figure skating World!!! And Good Like!!!
season's best yet she's third, this shows the level. The last three skaters were just great!
OMG Ive been saying for forever that she doesnt hold her spirals long enough at all! Glad to see im not the only one who thinks that!
And she will, like Sasha, Julia's a fast learner. I think she generally has a more contemporary form of artistry.
Julia and her coach should also work on Julia's axel technique because she doesn't get a lot of knee bend on the take-off (as Tuktamysheva does, for instance) so it doesn't get a lot of height and that can be a problem in the future when she grows!
In a year or two she will probably be quite the contender.
she's great :) more practice for jumps.. please don't judge this young girl she did her best.. mybe she can be kim yuna someday :)
Anybody can’t compete to her. They are not simply flexible…this is a reason why many people don’t like her. And she is brave girl and her performance much better than Sasha’s Kohen((
if she could get a better choreographer she'd be unstoppable, her programs unfortunately are very junior-ish but she has so much potential :)
Everybody shut up she is 14 she won the short program and then she skated bad the lond but she knows how to jump
What's the name of the music pls???
The Nutcracker Pas De Deux by Pyotr Illych Tchaikovsky
Thank you! Sometime my comments get hammered because of the diversity of opinions. I try to stick to the facts and Julia is not as polished as the rest of the field. Some of her positions look ugly such as the Sasha Spin and her needle scales. When Sasha Cohen first did them in the early 2000's many people complained about this as well. Hope Julia gets better.
Okay let me put this into..Do you u have an idea about how special a skater is no matter how good jumper or nice presentation could have??...in last 15 years I saw that special thing in Michelle Kwan..Sasha Cohen Yuna Kim Mao Asada..and even Shizuka Arakawa...watch their vids and I hope u can undestand what I´m talking about...
Excuse me but there's no comparison with Sasha Cohen..agreed about her flexibility and spins but at age of 15 Sasha had such an artistry and amazing musicality in contrast to Julia, however I think this young russian lady will mature in that part of her skating maybe in a couple of years..
says who ? Julia has good technique aside from her 2A, she has good edges and rotates fast in the air that makes up for ther critcisms of her smaller jumps
The other ladies better be glad that she's still learning how to master the free skate. Thats all i'm saying.
Don't forget she is only 14.
Julia should've been the Sochi gold medalist, but she fell twice. So Russians gave it to the other Russian. haha. It was Julia, NOT Sotnikova, who could beat Yuna Kim or Mao Asada. Again, sadly she fell hard twice. But then again, Russians cheated and generously gave the gold to Sotnikova. Such dirty way to 'win'. No dignity.
gorgeous girl, i hate her double axel
Such a beautiful piece of music for such a furious, determined brat.....definitely the wrong choice of music!!!
2010Saoirse brat?
I think that The Nutcracker was a bad choice to skate to because it makes you want to compare it to other skaters that had amazing and artistic programs to The Nutcracker (e.g: Sasha Cohen). Plus, she is 14 and I think that she is still a little too immature to skate to music like this.
I agree, she does need a better choreographer because it does get quite annoying when she lifts her leg and think that she is always slightly overscored on the artistic mark.
Really? Like Sasha, this girl needs to learn how to jump. Everyone's talking about her flexibility & spirals. What about her jumps?. She landed practically all of her jumps off balance & with 2 footing.
Flexibility is very important in womens figure skating. I don't like to watch the jump machine))).
115 is way too high. all the jumps should have been (-)
Her artistry is improving but her face... doesnt tell the story of the music! she doesnt look like she enjoys it :(
мне кажется эта композиция её просто "съела"
but she was not better than yuna
She can be gorgeous but there are too many ugly positions there beacuse her spirals are not held longer, her head positions look awkward, the stroking is poor and I'm sorry but I don't like prepubescent skaters. Remember all the fuzz that surrounded Zhang and MIrai 5 years ago?