To me, the last movement sounds mostly like the first movement of his piano concerto - like horse race. Instead of 'grandiose' I feel it's bombastic, and not so very listenable. Tiring in its mostly unrelenting harshness, I'm afraid. The first two parts are fine, sound like weeping if you like that. Although, what do I expect from a Ukrainian in the middle of Stalinist Soviet Union...
@@ufkbyfize Well, I know, but as far as the kind of regime it was, there wasn't much difference, wtsas there? All the basics had already been laid down properly by Vladimir Iljits Uljanov, even though he was reputed to have warned people about Yosip Visarionovits. I'd bet that by the time Vladimir Iljits died, Yosip had already been well on the way... to making sure everything would go on smoothly.
Дуже вдале виконання , з того , що переслухала , найкраще . Браво , видно розуміння стилістики та в цілому задуму композитора ¡
Чути таку чуттєву музику під час війни, це велике щастя. Вона дах життя.
Bravo bravo bravo fantastic brilliance grandiose genial music super wow wow wow
Шикарно!
Very listenable and relistenable.
Хто виконавець ¿
Who is performer?
Stefan Breit, cello
Fritz Walter, piano
Another hidden gem! Fun fact: Shostakovich actually donated the stalin-prize for his Piano Quintet to Kosenko's widow after his death
To me, the last movement sounds mostly like the first movement of his piano concerto - like horse race. Instead of 'grandiose' I feel it's bombastic, and not so very listenable. Tiring in its mostly unrelenting harshness, I'm afraid. The first two parts are fine, sound like weeping if you like that. Although, what do I expect from a Ukrainian in the middle of Stalinist Soviet Union...
в 1924 только умирает Ленин, произведение написано в 1923, какой сталинский режим? Учите историю
@@ufkbyfize Well, I know, but as far as the kind of regime it was, there wasn't much difference, wtsas there? All the basics had already been laid down properly by Vladimir Iljits Uljanov, even though he was reputed to have warned people about Yosip Visarionovits. I'd bet that by the time Vladimir Iljits died, Yosip had already been well on the way... to making sure everything would go on smoothly.