K-POP NEWBIE REACTS TO 진 (Jin) For The FIRST TIME! | 'The Astronaut' MV REACTION

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 98

  • @RUNXARMY
    @RUNXARMY 3 місяці тому +23

    Jin song EPIPHANY live ver !
    Yours , awake, Abbys, moon
    💜 Jin is amazing 💜 he is world world handsome 💜 Jin is my best singer 💜 he is BTS best high note singer 💜

  • @aprilmay4242
    @aprilmay4242 3 місяці тому +45

    That was Chris doing the harmonies throughout! Jin collaborated with Coldplay on this song as a goodbye prior to his enlistment and actually performed it live with them in Argentina- you should check out that performance! I'd also recommend his performance of "Epiphany"!

  • @tammarabg8174
    @tammarabg8174 3 місяці тому +57

    Yes, that was Chris Martin @2:01.
    Jin is the oldest BTS member, and the first to enter military service. He did not have time to make an album before he left, as the other members did. He was released from service June 12th, and is currently working on one now.

    • @psychosadie3138
      @psychosadie3138 3 місяці тому +3

      I had seen that video multiple times and it took my husband to notice Chris... and this guy gets it the first time 🤣

  • @katiemarie8580
    @katiemarie8580 3 місяці тому +39

    Thank you for reacting to Jin, our world wide handsome! He had never sang before joining BTS at 20 and learned everything from zero once he became a trainee. And what vocals he has now!! The Astronaut was a song he released right before enlisting in the military, as is mandatory is South Korea, and is a love song to ARMY saying goodbye for now. Jin actually just this month got discharged after serving his 18 months and is finally home!

  • @DinosaurBerriez
    @DinosaurBerriez 3 місяці тому +26

    I love all of the BTS members but Jin’s voice always makes me feel so emotional. I always feel like his voice is giving me a loving hug, warm and gentle. I love every BTS songs and their solo music but Jin’s music and vocals are very special to me. I’m so happy that he’s back, I can’t wait for more Jin’s music in the futures since he returned from the military and I can’t wait for the rest of the BTS members to return 💜💜💜💜
    BTW, there’s a live performance of "The Astronaut" with Coldplay!!! Chris Martin was a part of this song and it would mean everything if you could watch that performance!! Jin flew to Argentina to perform this song live for ARMY's at a Coldplay concert before he enlisted in the military!! (BTS and Coldplay have a lovely friendship especially Jin and Chris Martin) BTS has also made a song with Coldplay called “Our Universe” highly recommend that too!!😊💜

  • @walkofnails2923
    @walkofnails2923 3 місяці тому +39

    Jin was literally approached on the street by the talent scouts based on his looks. They brought him in and taught him to sing like a pro and he had to work very hard to learn dancing. The great thing is that Jin was going to school to be an actor and he is a natural comedian, so he has done very well on camera

  • @walkofnails2923
    @walkofnails2923 3 місяці тому +16

    Coldplay has been a great collaborator with BTS. Check out the video of My Universe. Very cool futuristic mv

  • @eyes17
    @eyes17 3 місяці тому +41

    Ephiphany is a must....
    Abyss...yours...awake...
    Bro this man gives u chillsss🤧

    • @nataliacoggins6769
      @nataliacoggins6769 3 місяці тому +4

      MOON!!!!!

    • @luisagabrielarodrguezovied5704
      @luisagabrielarodrguezovied5704 Місяць тому +1

      Tambien Moon y Tonight

    • @luisagabrielarodrguezovied5704
      @luisagabrielarodrguezovied5704 Місяць тому +1

      Y hasta Super Tuna ❤

    • @eyes17
      @eyes17 Місяць тому

      yes agreed guys. its so amazing .

    • @nataliacoggins6769
      @nataliacoggins6769 Місяць тому

      ​​@@eyes17 I 💕 all the BTS vocal line; however, the pure honesty of Jin's reason for writing and releasing this cute little personal ditty of a song, Super Tuna, is what made me go all in and state Jin is my vocal line bias!!!! If course, Suga is my rap line bias!!!! I guess I just like older men!!!! 😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂

  • @mawbast1
    @mawbast1 3 місяці тому +18

    FYI the little girl represents Army, she’s the same age. It was his comfort for us and the day after he was discharged he rode a bike onto the stage and sang it to us again💜

  • @이팝나무-z6h
    @이팝나무-z6h 3 місяці тому +13

    방탄소년단에서 jin이 보컬을 젤 잘한다고 생각해요.
    그의 보컬은 고평가 되어야합니다.

  • @catnight4947
    @catnight4947 3 місяці тому +18

    When Jin sings, you feel

  • @Люля-я2я
    @Люля-я2я 3 місяці тому +6

    Песни Джина лучше анализировать вживую когда поёт. Пожалуйста реагируйте на Астронавт на аргентинской сцене. Epiphany, Yours пожалуйста 🙏🏼

  • @Artfrg4
    @Artfrg4 3 місяці тому +13

    Epiphany live stage mix, from Jin! WWH! 💜

  • @이팝나무-z6h
    @이팝나무-z6h 3 місяці тому +9

    특히 jin의 노래가 리스펙 해야할 이유는, 가사내용.주제가 매우 철학적이고 인생을 관통하는 주제를 담았거나,
    초월적인 서사를 담았기 때문이고, 일관성있게 주제를 노래하고 있다는 것입니다

  • @mawbast1
    @mawbast1 3 місяці тому +9

    Jin has a song called Moon, BTS and ColdPlay did My Universe, BTS made a song about Pluto. Space is a thing here😁💜

  • @JeonJungkook-wr4yr
    @JeonJungkook-wr4yr 3 місяці тому +12

    Jin made this song for Army as a goodbye for now since he went into the military. He also sang this for festa as well. Also Jin os out of the military and so happy can't wait to see what he does next till the next member Jhope comes out in October 17th so I'm so excited and till the rest come back in 2025.

  • @bordeauxroze7375
    @bordeauxroze7375 3 місяці тому +21

    Jin did this live with Coldplay in Argentina four days before he left for the military. Iconic. Look it up! He also sang it one night after he was dismissed from military service.

    • @psychosadie3138
      @psychosadie3138 3 місяці тому +2

      My favorite part was when Jin choked up towards the end.. his friendship with Chris Martin is my all time favorite ❤

    • @bordeauxroze7375
      @bordeauxroze7375 3 місяці тому +2

      @@psychosadie3138 Oh, yes! Also the big hug when Jin ran to the main stage.💜

    • @psychosadie3138
      @psychosadie3138 3 місяці тому +1

      @@bordeauxroze7375 i admit I teared up 💜

  • @sonialynn572
    @sonialynn572 3 місяці тому +9

    Jin has the best high notes in BTS let go and crystal snow/ Jamais vu but solo epiphany/yours/and just for fun super tuna

  • @rjbirmingham
    @rjbirmingham 3 місяці тому +6

    if you watch again watch when he did it at the ColdPlay concert - he travel half way around the world to sing it one time to ARMY worldwide before he left for military, but you have to make sure you get the one with Chris's intro - so meaningful and it is a live version which you have not heard

  • @christchellebetil9911
    @christchellebetil9911 3 місяці тому +6

    Jin's solo songs always make us feel something.... We love his melodies... ❤ listen to epiphany, abyss, tonight and moon

  • @judyburgess3357
    @judyburgess3357 3 місяці тому +7

    Our beautiful and beloved World Wide Handsome weaves his spell with his wonderful voice. To think he learnt to sing after joining Bighit.
    Epiphany, a live stage performance would be best.
    Awake
    Abyss
    Moon
    Super Tuna.
    He is the eldest and had to leave BTS to do his mandatory military service back in dec 2022, he has just been released from the army to the joy of all BTS fans.

    • @nataliacoggins6769
      @nataliacoggins6769 3 місяці тому +1

      They added a second verse to Super Tuna for his return performance at Festa 2024!!!!

  • @anitaherbert1037
    @anitaherbert1037 3 місяці тому +4

    Jin has a classic light Rock pop voice but combines with the most gorgeous falsetto and head voice. His voice has great power and stability yet he did not sing before he was 19( western age) he only learned after joining BTS to sing and dance. He was studying acting. He has worked really really hard with coaches. Korean critics call him silver voice because of the clarity and stability.. He's an alien who learns about emotion and love from his interaction with his earth family. The little girl is yhe same age as BTS so as ARMY. About finding your place and family in the universe. EPIPHANY great song and MV

  • @esinedordaz
    @esinedordaz 3 місяці тому +4

    You should react to My Universe also a collab BTS x Coldplay. Coldplay & Jin did this song for us ARMY because Jin was leaving to do his mandatory Military Service(for 1year 1/2) it's like a goodbye letter & see you soon. Every time a hear this song makes me cry (even tho Jin got out from the Military June 11, a few days ago). It's a beautiful song. A special song. 💜💜💜💜

  • @catarinapaula9458
    @catarinapaula9458 3 місяці тому +7

    The track is completely a Coldplay sound... Cris Martin produced it... And it's a gem for army, this song was performed once and once only. Gin flew from Korea to Argentina to sing this song in a coldayplay show.. He said his good bye to army and flew back... Literally half of the world... It a was a very meaningful moment for us all... So it's a song that have a very special meaning to us!

    • @JLau-janbgobh
      @JLau-janbgobh 3 місяці тому +1

      Ah but he's now performed it a second time for us during his performance at the 2024 Festa the day after his discharge from military service. He said he was a bit nervous since he hadn't sung in a year and a half but he was perfect!
      💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

  • @mlynlim5337
    @mlynlim5337 3 місяці тому +4

    Jin ranks top for me. I love his voice, his visuals, his charm, his goofiness, his intelligence , his kindness and he is cool❤❤❤❤❤he is very skilled in voice techniques but is super humble. So proud of Jin❤❤❤ARMY is family, the little girl represents Army! His solos makes us feel something!

  • @asanmig
    @asanmig 3 місяці тому +3

    If you like jazzy R&B music, you should DEF watch V of BTS: Tiny desk korea. If you want more from Jin i recommend Awake, Moon, and Epiphany which i consider to have similar vibes of astronaut:)

  • @jgrubbs2251
    @jgrubbs2251 3 місяці тому +3

    JIN IS MY #1 ...LOVE ALL OF THE MEMBERS BUTBJIN WON MY HEART!!

  • @lainee1217
    @lainee1217 3 місяці тому +3

    Jin is my bias. Recommend:
    Epiphany
    Moon
    Super Tuna (just a fun short one)
    Awake
    Abyss

  • @sherymac5783
    @sherymac5783 3 місяці тому +4

    Thank you!!!!💜 Epiphany live

  • @stefaniekritzler6401
    @stefaniekritzler6401 3 місяці тому +4

    He’s my fav. The sweetest human

  • @DianeCarr-kv3xd
    @DianeCarr-kv3xd 3 місяці тому +2

    As many below have said, this song was written as a good bye song for ARMY before he entered into the Korean Military (mandatory). He did just finish his 18 months service and was released. This was written by Jin and Chris Martin. There is a live version where he performed it with Coldplay at their concert in Argentina. Watch the version with the full introduction by Chris Martin. It's so touching!

  • @thecopycatcustomvintage
    @thecopycatcustomvintage 3 місяці тому +2

    You should watch Taylor Mari's guide to BTS if you haven't already.

  • @elizabethbenson9019
    @elizabethbenson9019 3 місяці тому +2

    The Live of this at Coldplay concert is a MUST WATCH !!

  • @dariajaruszkiewicz4126
    @dariajaruszkiewicz4126 3 місяці тому +2

    I understand that you are new to K-pop , so let me tell you ...
    The best BTS is the Live BTS.
    Honestly I don't know how are the other groups, but live performances are always better.

  • @georgejavier8930
    @georgejavier8930 3 місяці тому +2

    That was chris martin and also him doing the harmonies!

  • @eyes17
    @eyes17 3 місяці тому +6

    Filmmmmm oouuuuttttttt

  • @jennymabelparrameneses829
    @jennymabelparrameneses829 3 місяці тому +2

    Gracias por la reacción te recomiendo Hepiphany de jin ojalá toda las reacciones fuesen en vivo no te arrepentirás superan a las de estudio también recomiendo house of cards en vivo es solo de Los 4 miembros de la línea vocal de bts sus voces son maravillosas y sus armonías grandiosas. Saludos 💜💜💜💜🇨🇱

  • @athelas5305
    @athelas5305 3 місяці тому +3

    Where do I rank Jin?
    Tied for first with Kim Namjoon, Min Yoongi, Jung Hoseok, Park Jimin, Kim Taehyung, and Jeon Jungkook.
    Jin flew 36 hrs each way to perform this one song live with Coldplay at one of their Argentina concerts. It's fun to see them play the instruments and sing along with him. It's also pretty emotional. This concert was aired live in theaters and you can find it on YT if you're interested.
    And he might have been singing it to you--it was made for ARMY. 💜

    • @이팝나무-z6h
      @이팝나무-z6h 3 місяці тому

      아주오랫동안,
      진을 디스하는 많은 악플들이
      진의 음악을 폄훼해왔는데,
      당신도 그중의 하나인가 보다. 보컬진이 가장 리스펙하다는걸 인정하세요.

    • @athelas5305
      @athelas5305 3 місяці тому

      @@이팝나무-z6h 😂I think there must be a language misunderstanding! Jin is my bias and it was his voice that reached into my heart, squeezed out emotions I didn't even know I had, and took hold of me. But I am ot7 forever. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

  • @kari111071110
    @kari111071110 3 місяці тому +4

    Please react to "set me free pt.2" by jimin

    • @이팝나무-z6h
      @이팝나무-z6h 3 місяці тому

      예의가 없는 지민팬들,
      진의 얘기를 하고있는데,
      웬 지민팔이?
      예의가 없는 무지성들

  • @elizaaparecidakmick6590
    @elizaaparecidakmick6590 3 місяці тому +1

    Jin and Cold Play made this song to say goodbye to Army, because Jin was going to serve his military service for 18 months.
    He was recently released from military, but the other six still serving.

  • @sharonmartin-hy5ne
    @sharonmartin-hy5ne 3 місяці тому +2

    Yours. It’s a song for a drama. (OST)You can watch the ost which shows clips from the drama

    • @이팝나무-z6h
      @이팝나무-z6h 3 місяці тому

      유어쓰,
      Yours 지리산 ost
      뷰티풀한 진의 목소리의 성찬이죠❤❤❤

  • @3k2jpm18
    @3k2jpm18 3 місяці тому +6

    This song is not KPOP it was written by Coldplay and some others with Jin also credited because he rewrote some verses in Korean. It wasn’t produced by Koreans either. Not every thing a Korean sings is “ Kpop”. lol

  • @mawbast1
    @mawbast1 3 місяці тому +1

    Jin has a song called Moon, BTS and ColdPlay did My Universe, BTS made a song about Pluto. Space is a thing here😁💜

  • @eileencritchley4630
    @eileencritchley4630 3 місяці тому +1

    Just so you know ARMY in general don't tend to be kpop fans we are BTS fans.

  • @JoobieLoobieSoobie
    @JoobieLoobieSoobie 3 місяці тому +1

    "Gomenasai" is Japanese, not Korean, bro. The Korean for "I'm sorry" is 죄송합니다 (pronounced 'chay-song hamnida'). Hope this helps!

  • @KarencitaCespedes
    @KarencitaCespedes 3 місяці тому +1

    Gracias por reaccionar a este tema de Jin, me encanto tus comentarios.
    Otras canciones de Jin que vale la pena reacciones seria: "Epiphany" tiene MV oficial , Awake y Moon solo hay presentaciones en vivo

  • @Lungette1
    @Lungette1 3 місяці тому +1

    Coldplay is one of Jin’s favourite artists. BTS covered “Fix You” for their MTV Unplugged concert and then Coldplay got word that BTS would love to do a song together.
    My Universe is a Coldplay x BTS song (banger!) and when Jin was leaving to go to the military, he asked Chris Martin to help him make a song as a “goodbye for now” for ARMY. And The Astronaut was born. 🥰
    You can hear Chris doing the backing vocals throughout.
    There are several interviews with Chris Martin talking about working with BTS and he has so many lovely things to say about them. There’s also a little documentary about them recording My Universe which I think you should check out. It’s about 12-15 mins long iirc.
    There is also a live performance of this song with Coldplay in Argentina. Jin flew out to join Coldplay for one night just to perform this once for ARMY before he went to the military. The day after he was released, he performed it again. It always makes me cry. 🥹
    Beautiful song. 💜
    Edited to add: It’s a song about the love Jin has for ARMY. He considers ARMY his family.
    The little girl represents ARMY. Jin is the astronaut. His spaceship crashed on Earth and is broken. He wanders around while waiting for it to go “home”. He befriends the little girl and she ends up making Earth feel like home. So he goes back to spaceship and then decides to stay. We see him walking away as it takes off.
    Then he goes back to his house and completes the crossword. We hear the bell from the girls bicycle which makes him smile. He’s finally HOME. 😁

  • @jacklyn208
    @jacklyn208 3 місяці тому +1

    Thank you for reacting to Jin's The Astronaut! I love that you love it. It's one of those songs you can listen to again and again, on repeat. I would love it if you would do reactions to some of The Rose's songs. They are an indie K-rock band with two incredible vocalists. I suggest Alive, Back to Me, and Sorry to start. Side note: One of their vocalists, Woosung, sang the vocal part on Agust D's song Snooze.

  • @emarsh55
    @emarsh55 3 місяці тому +1

    Garden State soundtrack is awesome, so is movie!

  • @lostitiarias2078
    @lostitiarias2078 10 днів тому

    Deberías ver la versión en vivo con cold play,,,

  • @malikrizwan1257
    @malikrizwan1257 3 місяці тому +1

    Please reaction tobts V singularity

    • @이팝나무-z6h
      @이팝나무-z6h 3 місяці тому

      주제가 진입니다.
      예의를 지키세요.

  • @manaal9044
    @manaal9044 18 днів тому

    We don't "rank" bts members sir !!!

  • @kaleighcoutermarsh4922
    @kaleighcoutermarsh4922 Місяць тому

    Jin's solo track with BTS called Moon is incredible. To me, it's his masterpiece. One of the best choruses I've ever heard.

  • @darylkho7854
    @darylkho7854 3 місяці тому

    Not a Jin solo song but a BTS vocal line song.. Can you please check out The Truth untold and a JK solo song Euphoria, Please check out JK performing Euphoria live at the Wembley stadium. Thank you

  • @eileencritchley4630
    @eileencritchley4630 3 місяці тому

    The Cure fan here but also Coldplay fan and it's Coldplay and Jin.

  • @ronaxo4654
    @ronaxo4654 Місяць тому

    Oh i love him too❤thanks for reacting💜💜💜jin is an emotional singer, the Silver Voice of Korea. Pls check his other songs you won't regret it

  • @gmasword0613
    @gmasword0613 2 місяці тому

    Love the Shins (and the Garden State) comparison, although it's Coldplay through and through. Chris and son Moses do much of the harmonies in this masterpiece.

  • @koya_joonie
    @koya_joonie 2 місяці тому

    yes it is a song about family, isnt it 🥹🥹🥹😭😭😭💜💜💜💜💜💜💜🫂

  • @ninimar-o1m
    @ninimar-o1m 2 місяці тому

    The first two things you will find as you listen to JIN is that 1: he has an incredible and rarely seen ability to transmit emotions when he sings, making each song an experience and 2: he sounds even much better in live performances. His live always go viral since his stability in his voice becomes evident and he sound more powerful and angelic. He is about to release his first solo album, I assure you, you won't want to miss it.
    fun fact for Chris' concert in Argentina JIN had little time left to enter the sm so he traveled 14 hours to sing just one song that was rehearsed only once the day before and the song was released to the public the morning of the concert , and Army found out that JIN would sing on that day shortly before, that is, the concert is mostly full of Coldplayers (that is, a great set up for the disaster but nothing is too big for JIN and it was beautiful). Links for The Astronaut Argentina & Epiphany live.
    ua-cam.com/video/FqmYc62HUec/v-deo.htmlsi=h3Da6sozlXqjQrwj
    ua-cam.com/video/IKqtyJReVVk/v-deo.htmlsi=eizlmgpJP5-k6yzM

  • @eileencritchley4630
    @eileencritchley4630 3 місяці тому

    Jin and Chris Martin of Coldplay wrote this song and Jin sung it live with Chris and Coldplay at a Coldplay concert. So you'll get the live performance of it with the funny mistake where Jin sung the wrong lyric and giggled. There's a lovely speech by Chris as his introduction for Jin to join them on stage.
    Yes that is Chris.

  • @MsJanoli
    @MsJanoli 3 місяці тому +1

    Yes his type of songs might reflect more of songs sang by bands…you could tell his musical influences are from there just like Coldplay, Goo Goo Dolls… for me the songs that has that vibe/melody is this song and epiphany. So this song was co-written by Coldplay. I do hope when he does his solo work that he will go to this route…he can hold a note well that band lead vocalists have.

    • @이팝나무-z6h
      @이팝나무-z6h 3 місяці тому +2

      진의 최애 가수가 콜드플레이입니다.
      그래서 마이 유니버쓰 협업도 가능했고,
      진이 콜플에게 디아스트로넛 곡을 부탁한것도 그 이유입니다.
      사실 하이브내 작곡자들보다
      진을 더 애정해주는게 크리스마틴입니다

    • @mlynlim5337
      @mlynlim5337 3 місяці тому

      @@이팝나무-z6htrue. They always prefer the rest and feels Jin is not talented. I feel so sad about this. Listen to the older songs like with Seoul, converse high, etc. his voice is so beautiful!

  • @eileencritchley4630
    @eileencritchley4630 3 місяці тому

    Jin has another song about the relationship between BTS and ARMY which is called 'Moon' where he's saying the moon needs the earth that there would be no moon with the earth and the earth needs the Moon ( the moon often gets hit so the earth still gets hit sometimes but it would be far more often if the moon wasn't there) He's saying BTS would exist without ARMY and ARMY wouldn't exist without BTS.
    He also has like all BTS members other solo's within BTS albums.

  • @valeriastefanyvilla6552
    @valeriastefanyvilla6552 2 місяці тому

    100% Epiphany by Jin, it’s definitely a ballad that helps you discover self love is a very meaningful song and it is also one of those that will become a lot of people’s anthem ,this song catches old rock and ballads, spirit. and shows a lot of feelings and he has a great voice. I hope that you can react to it.

  • @americasilva3900
    @americasilva3900 2 місяці тому

    “i think i love him too” hahaha I LOVE IT 😭😭🩷🩷🩷 thanks to react to jin, i can relate to the feeling that his voice is like a cure of soul 😭💜💜

  • @eileencritchley4630
    @eileencritchley4630 3 місяці тому

    Jin is the Astronaunt who crashed to earth was out of place but found a friend in a little girl Amy and decided his home was earth in the end.
    Amy represents ARMY and the song is saying he's going away for a while which of course he did 18months in the military and that he's returning. He's only just returned and the next day he did a fan concert and hugged a line 1,000 fans one at a time.

  • @jjonlysoda
    @jjonlysoda Місяць тому

    you should check the live version of this song

  • @danaalexa1704
    @danaalexa1704 3 місяці тому

    I love Jin the Astronaut too, so meaningfull and chill

  • @marybell4116
    @marybell4116 3 місяці тому

    this song was written as a love song for ARMY from Jin

  • @jhopeur7219
    @jhopeur7219 2 місяці тому

    Yeah, we don't rank our boys so don't ask us to or encourage others to, please.

  • @Vanessa-vns
    @Vanessa-vns 3 місяці тому

    Listen Epiphany, Moon and Abyss 💜🥹

  • @stougaard321
    @stougaard321 3 місяці тому

    Always stick to the end with these guys

  • @onefineday9266
    @onefineday9266 3 місяці тому +1

    All the members of BTS are extremely hard working with a work ethic that seems superhuman. But Jin, I feel, had to work even beyond that to keep up.
    He was recruited based on looks but he fought hard to show he is more than a beautiful face. And in the process he developled this hilarious persona as world wide handsome. And learned to love himself.
    He's my bias for those reasons and many more.

  • @AVidz-p8k
    @AVidz-p8k 3 місяці тому +1

    That's the kind of magic Jin's voice holds. He can make you feel all the emotions when he sings. So pleasing to the ears AND HEART! I love him!

  • @eileencritchley4630
    @eileencritchley4630 3 місяці тому

    Love song of Jin for ARMY

  • @andreacastellano8339
    @andreacastellano8339 3 місяці тому

    this song has so many beautiful messages for army i literally cry every single time i listen to it

  • @walkofnails2923
    @walkofnails2923 3 місяці тому +2

    My favorites of the group are V and Jungkook. My fave solo song has been V’s song Fri(end)s. He’s a great actor too. Loved V’s acting in the IU music video Love Wins All. She has a beautiful voice if you haven’t heard her before

    • @이팝나무-z6h
      @이팝나무-z6h 3 місяці тому

      뷔의노래는 흐느적..거리는거외에 감정을 못줍니다.그리고 지금은 진의 노래에 대해 얘기하는 중인데, 주제를 비켜가는 타멤버를 추천하는 불손함은 뷔를 꼭 닮아보이네요.
      그 노래취향은 당신이나 듣지 대중들의 마음을 움직이지 못해요.

    • @walkofnails2923
      @walkofnails2923 3 місяці тому

      ⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@이팝나무-z6h
      First, he asked for recommendations for any other BTS or solo songs we would like to see reactions to. So no, it isn’t rude or irreverent of me to recommend another member’s song here.
      Secondly, music is subjective to the listener, so if you don’t feel any emotion to the song Fri(end)s, that is your opinion. You don’t get to speak for me or anyone else about how a song makes them feel.
      Finally, you should focus on recommending songs by members you do like instead of being rude & negative to others here about their own recommendations.
      Have a nice day.