السلام عليكم الاخ شمسي انت واخوانك المجاهدين السلفيين واحذروا منهج الاخوان واتركوهم . واستشيروا اهل العلم في الدعوة وخذوا بنصيحتهم .ولا يهمكم ان رموكم بالمداخلة او الجامية او الوهابية فهو ديدنهم . ركزوا على دعوة التوحيد واسال الله ان يوفقكم ويزيدكم علما ويثبتكم على المنهج السلفي .
@DUS Dawah Timestamps 0:00 Introduction 0:36 Hadith: “Whoever sees an evil let him change it...” 2:10 This is not a personal issue it's a matter of Deen 3:03 Promoting misguided people 3:27 Shamsi requesting to speak off camera 4:03 We're not like the Christians who have major errors in their religion and they keep quiet about it 4:38 Ali needs Dawah comparing Shamsi to extremists 5:44 Ali needs Dawah making the issues public and requesting Black Dunya to send the video to Content Over Everything channel and spread it 7:40 Why we are making this video and spreading it openly 8:50 Types of misguided people Ali needs Dawah promotes 10:28 We protect our Deen before anyone else
Br shamsi has clearly been studying the deen for many years and he speaks humbly and directly in accordance to Quran and sunnah including clarifying the understanding according to the ways of the salaf. We have to be stern in the haqq of Islam, clarifying the truth is a fard! Love you shamsi
That dude called salafis a cult when in fact I've been learning more from them than everyone else. He became too emotional, and irrational to the point he even allied himself with the non muslims to gang up on Shamsi. May Allah (SWT) guide him.
Yonis Ali What a very ignorant thing to say. In no way did I say the world revolves around me. I stated my point of view. Salafis always showed me what made sense. They always go back to the Quran, and the Sunnah. I came from a Sufi background into true Islam. All Shamsi is saying is that we must always hold firm to the rope of Allah (SWT). You guys want us to unite with innovators like the sufis. That’s a big no no, and you fall into hypocrisy. May Allah (SWT) guide you. Ameen
@@traditionalistgeeljire5487 Salam alaykum Don't just claim that "majority of the ulema were sufis" ! PROVE IT Coz we DON'T even agree with you that they were "suFis" in the first place... And before all of this firstly we need to define it properly, take into account the various usages of this term during different time periods and ONLY then can we move on...
Just look how Shamsi spoke with 'Ilm, he spoke with knowledge, with principles, with consistency - not emotions & vague speech. Ali wanted the video spread, Shamsi didn't - and Shamsi is getting told that HE is causing the Fitnah???? الله المستعان
KingTempa Abu Abdullaah Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Mufarraj said, Abu Jafar Ahmad bin Awn illaah (d. 378H) would show rejection against the People and Innovation and call them to account, showing extreme harshness against them, utterly humiliating them, always seek to pick out their faults, rushing to damage them, vehemently oppressive against them, chasing them away whenever he was able to, not allowing them to remain. And every one of them (Ahl ul-Bid?ah) used to be frightened of him, and would seek to hide and protect himself from him. He (Abu Ja?far Ahmad) would never compromise with a single one of them, and nor would he allow any of them to remain safe. And if he came across evil and witnessed any deviation from the Sunnah, he would oppose it and would disgrace and humiliate (its perpetrator), and he would announce the affair of this person and declare his own disownment of him by mentioning the evil of such a one in the various public gatherings, and he would incite others against him such that he either destroyed him or caused him to abandon his evil and repugnant madhhab and his evil doctrine. And he would never cease to remain upon this habit, making Jihaad therein, seeking the Face of Allaah, up until he met Allaah. (Taareekh Dimashq 5/118). And he is the Muhaddith, Imaam, Ahmad bin Awn illaah bin Hudair Abu Ja?far al-Andalusee al-Qurtubee (d. 378H).
@@streetzboxa if those "muslim" you are talking about separated themselves from areas of aqeedah[areas of the most important part of the rope of ALLAH] by innovating in the areas of aqeedah and they practise and preaches these aqeedah's innovations publicly themselves' while indicating their permanent established position on these issues-- their own aqeedah's innovations by refusing to accept 4 years worth of private nacea to correct those big aqeedah blunders and currently they still preach and promote these blunders, now' common sense tells me that if shamsi is still holding on to the rope of ALLAH[Kitaab and Sunnah] regarding not making or promoting those who made democracy voting and riba halal, like what ali and others are doing on the contrary' which in result is what made them[ali] separated from areas of aqeedah on the rope of ALLAH' this means ali separated from me, shamsi and the three best generations and cannot separated from the rope of ALLAH to please ali and join with ali on this great mis-guidance, so therefore ali and his democratic scholars need to separate from their aqeedah bidah and our arms are already opening welcome to accept them joining us back on the rope' cause its not our rope we cant reject no one who wants to hold on to it[its ALLAH's Rope]
Abū Mūsa al-Atharī many of my friend and family went to madinah university. I have a question do you have any proof that asking the question how much hands Allah has is an innovation ? I believe the verse that Allah created Adam with hands, but asking and testing people aqida isn’t that innovation ? Did companions ask that question ?
Our brother Shamsi implementing the way of the Salaf: Ibn al-Qayyim رحمه الله said: “The one who remains silent in the face of falsehood is a tongueless devil.” [Ad-Da`u wad-Dawaa’]
Al Maghribi this should be super imposed on the comment sections wallaahi it hurts that so many people want others to stay quiet concerning the deen of Allaah because of feelings. We are Muslims may Allaah bless us all, and we should be grateful to the one who corrects our deen
@@BlueSkyblueseagreenland Wallaahi you are right akhi. The Sahaba and Imaams of the salaf have been killed and tortured for this Deen and yet some people want us to stay quit when people try to change the Deen of Allah. Never. Baarak Allahu feekum.
My Muslim brothers and sisters it is important for brother Shamsi to expose the misguidance of Ali Dawah publicly. This is because Ali dawah is doing such acts publicly therefore Shamsi needs to expose him publicly. If everyone kept quiet and didn’t say a word the Muslim laymen will believe that Ali Dawah is correct as no one is refuting him. Therefore. We must refute the misguided in order to prevent further misguidance. And Allah knows best.
Those affected by Ikhwani principles are always emotionally driven (instead of evidence driven) you see them fiercely attacking those who speak with the manhaj of the Salaf but never have the same energy when it comes to the people of innovation (like the Sufiyyah, modern day Mu’tazili Rationalists, and the Khawarij takfeeriyoon).
Truss me there’s a lot of people claim to be salafi who speak from emotions to, also we shouldn’t label br Ali as certain group we should act better than he is and be soft in Naseeha when musa as was going to firawn to speak to him Allah swt said speak to him gentle so he may understand and Allah had knowledge already that firawn was going to say I am the lord most high so imagine talking to a Muslim.
Yonis Ali Yh I agree with you tbh a lot of the people claim to be salafi giving themselves praise when they aren’t a predecessor to anything it’s fine to follow the Manhaj of the salaf but personally follow the way sheikh uthaymeen and sheikh Saleh al fawzan have their view on calling yourself a salafi.
Yonis Ali you are not a intellectual smart person we see, first we say salaf I Salih not just any salaf second we do call ourselves ahlul sunnah wal jammah but go further into detail so that people can get the SEALED NECTAR!
The truth always hurts and this guy speaks the truth. Shamsi is genuine he fights for the deen and by following the sunnah and Quran. Remember a person who speaks the truth he has so many enemies. Even our prophet SAW had so many enemies. So if you speak the truth and u hv haters that doesnt mean ur wrong. Keep up the great work shamsi and i pray may Allah always guide and protect u brother. Ameen.
Assalamu aleikum from Azerbaijan to all brothers and sisters. Assalamu aleikum to brother Shamsi. Salafi dawah is spreading everywhere, Alhamdulillah. This path is so clear and bright that it's enough for a person to open his or her mouth and you can immediately sense whether that person is upon salafiyyah or not. When I watch the videos of Ali Dawah (may Allah guide him to the right manhaj), I can sense that his videos lack the fragrance of salafiyyah. While watching the videos of salafis like Br. Shamsi, you can sense the fragrance of salafiyyah. May Allah help the brother and other salafi brothers.
Just a quick question is 'Salafiyyah' a new religion and the 'Salafis' it's followers???...as going by Taleh Karimov's comments, it seems to be a new trend which is gaining following...as far as I'm aware 'Islam' is our religion and 'Muslims' are it's followers... From my limited understanding and knowledge I thought the word 'Salafi' comes from the Arabic phrase, 'as-salaf as-saliheen', which refers to the first three generations of Muslims (starting with the Companions of the Prophet), otherwise known as the Pious Predecessors....I think we will NEVER be able to compare ourselves to the 'aa salaf as-saliheen'. So I think we should try to follow Islam and be Muslims....and unite upon lā ʾilāha ʾillā llāh muḥammadun rasūlu llāh ...
Salafiyyah is understanding and following Islam the way the righteous predecessors (salafus saleeh) understood and followed. It’s the pure Islam free from any type of shirk and bidah. There is nothing in salafiyyah except that its based on quran, sunnah and understanding of the companions. The reason why salafiyyah looks like a sect is because of the presense of the deviated sects. Imagine a white paper which is Islam, and I paint it with different colours and leave one space unpainted. Because that space is surrounded by other colors, it will look like painted with white color. That unpainted space is salafiyyah
@@talhakrim5975 Thank you for your clarification, but surely the scholars closer to the time of our beloved prophet (pbuh) had the best understanding, I don't know much about this Salafiyyah movement but it seems to be a new thing which is why I feel vary...the 'Saliffiyah' can't confidently say that their understanding is that of the true companions of the Prophet (pbuh) as we are far from being even close to how they were. From my limited knowledge and understanding I feel we shouldn't label ourselves and just try and be the best of people and better our characters, call ourselves 'Muslims' and followers of 'Islam'...there is only strength in unity and wanting for others what we desire for ourselves... And pray that we are on the 'siratal mustakeem' and not be arrogant to think we are on the right path or on the 'correct understanding' and everyone else is astray.
Edexcel IGCSE Science & Maths you mentioned correctly that the scholars closest to the prophet sallallahu aleihi wa sallam had the best understanding. This is what salafiyyah is: understanding islam the way they understood. As for labelling, the first person to label muslims was prophet himself sallallahu aleihi va sallam. He was the one who said my ummah will split into seventy three sects, all of them is in hellfire except one. The sahabah asked which one. He said the jamaah (he did not say muslims) . And you need to understand that calling ourselves salafi is out of necessity to distinguish pure Islam from the deviated sects
@@talhakrim5975 That's a big claim you're making, that you are on 'pure islam'...and to say that you are following Islam as the pious predecessors did...well, again that's an even bigger claim. And your interpretation of what the 'Jamaah' is, others may differ with... But one thing for sure I would never call myself a 'Salafi' as I'm far from being even close to what they were.
You guys in the comments are plain stupid or haven't watched the video. If someone promotes misguidance for years while being advised, then this video needs to be made just to show he is wrong because he has a big following. So, people need to know he promotes misguidance.
@@streetzboxa like the video states. It's not personal. He promotes people with deviant ideas, this doesn't mean they or Ali are bad, so I do disagree with the title. However, if you are advised privately for years and still promote the same people of whom are deviant a video must be made in order to protect his large following. Salaam
@@streetzboxa Listen. I didn't claim to follow Shamsi or SPUBS. I agree with Shamsi on many cases. Personally I follow those such as Asim Al Hakeem and Abu Usamah. Nevertheless, nobody is perfect including Yusuf Estes and Mufti Menk who do have some ideas that are not strictly from the sunnah. But I believe you shouldn't force people's beliefs like what SPUBS do, I just think if a Muslim advises another Muslim for 4 years they have the right to make a video on that Muslims mistake for the benefit of his followers. Please don't be emotional or insulting. Thank you
May Allah bless Bro Shamsi. The one thing I definitely agree with him on is Bro Ali, for as big of a platform that he has, he needs to gain more knowledge on Islam. May Allah guide us all! Amin.
Nabil Chennoufi audobillah I never made takfeer on him. Please put your emotions away. He is my brother and may Allaah have mercy on him We ask for guidance from Allaah everyday, doesn't mean we disbelieve don't get it twisted
@@BlueSkyblueseagreenland you litteraly said. May Allah guide Ali and soften his hart so he can accept THE TRUTH. What is someone who hasn't accepted the truth yet. A disbeliever.
Ba-rokAllahu feekum yeah u point out the right thing's. zajhakumullahu khairan for clarifying "Ali Dawah"'s falsehood. we should be aware who we take our dawah-knowledge.
The brave one and wise one is the one who accepts his mistake after being reminded or corrected by someone. We are all brothers. Sit together and look at the Reality the reality is and accept it . Shamsi bro. I send you my loves from Germany ! Wish u all the best !
@Darth Shadow i think he is one of those trolls who uses an Arabic names from the Christians or atheists , they are just an attention seekers and a waste of time, they have no life just ignore them brother.
@Darth Shadow how can i be a kafir. When i call a person who wants to unite with ahlul bid'ah a kafir. He is not a muslim. Did you even hear or see what his aqeedah is. Islam is not a game. Stop being emotional
Thank you brother Shamsi. I dropped Ali Dawah as soon as I saw your video even though I didn't know about you and was a subscriber to him. When someone entirely speaks and defends him/herself by using the Quran and sunnah, like you did, who am I to say they're a liar. Alhamdullilah.
Our brothers in Salafiyyah Shamsi and Anwar (and other than them) are striving to clarify and preserve the Deen of Allaah. May Allaah guide us all to what is pure and correct.
May Allah swt bring your hearts together. The holy month of Ramadan is ahead of us , we need to cleanse our hearts and forgive each other for the sake of Allah swt
Who is fighting for his ego?isn't it Ali?it is already long ago that I noticed mistakes in Ali Dawa and now I'm sure about it.my heart tells me brother Shamsi is right.may Allah forgive us and guide us. Amin
Well, this is a test from Allah, so If even in our deen we got confused, we ask Allah to guide and have mercy on us. let's do everything to the best of our knowledge and if there's disagreement, we keep openminded and patience. Allahu Akbar! Subhanallah! Alhamdulillah!
This is the problem, anyone who supports deviated people should be exposed. And the responses below are typical in responses we see the mental disconnect most muslims have is believable hence why we have sects. And they cant cope when someone stands and warns against someone who promotes misguided people. The proof in there look and listens to what Ali says. Shamsi keep up the good work. This is a massive problem and we need to expose innovators and misguided people.
I totally agree with you since I saw this video I have stopped watching Ali and in addition after watching Haji trying to attack you and releasing a video mocking you I have totally lost respect for both brothers. May Allah guide them. You stay on your dawah brother and do not let them get in your way Allah has blessed you with a great mind, May Allah always protect you and your family. Ameen
Allah will overlook the accidental, but not the intentional. May Allah forgive those who are in genuine error, for that may be their best attempt of understanding the deen. But becareful of sins from bad character, for that is something intentional. Knowledge is extremely important, but bad character destroys the fruit of it. Reminder to myself and to my brothers & sisters.
Ali needs dawah. I've been saying that for like 4 years. Shamsi you owe me brother... Love that one though. May Allah preserve shamsi... may Allah guide Ali as he is really washed up
May Allah guide us all and prevent us from dividing, some people are only looking for fame and nobility but honour belongs to allah and his messenger and the believers, so follow quran and sunnah
No matter how much knowledge Shamsi and Ali have, as Muslims our instincts are to be embarrassed and saddened by this feud. May Allah (swt) judge our intentions, and efforts, and bring us closer. We love you both, no doubt.
Ali Dawah is an embarrassment and immature promoting something he don’t study enough. Shamsi is far ahead of Ali Dawah in the Deen. I don’t know why Mohammad Hijab does not school Ali Dawah from embarrassing himself and attacking Muslim brothers who are far knowledgeable than him doing Dawah.
I watched the ali and shamsi thing being as objective as I could, shamsi was in the right, have to keep falsehood away truth and can’t mix them for “bringing everyone together” falsehood statement
Brother, you should fear Allah and stop labelling fellow muslims as misguided. May Allah guide us all to the correct manhaj and good conduct in dealing with Muslims, Amin.
يقول الله سبحانه : " فاتقوا الله وأصلحوا ذات بينكم " , قال البغوي في تفسيرها : أي : اتقوا الله بطاعته وأصلحوا الحال بينكم بترك المنازعة والمخالفة , أصلحوا ما بينكم وبين إخوانكم ، فما يكون لديكم تقاطع ، ولا تدابر ولابغضاء ، ولا شحناء ، ولاخصومات روى البخاري في كتاب المناقب عن أبي هريرة رضي الله عنه قول النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم : " إن الله يرضى لكم ثلاثا ويكره لكم ثلاثا , فيرضى لكم أن تعبدوه ولا تشركوا به شيئا وأن تعتصموا بحبل الله جميعا ولا تفرقوا ويكره لكم قيل وقال وكثرة السؤال وإضاعة المال " أخرجه البخاري , أما يكفي المتخاصمين مثل هذا الحديث ؟! إني أظن أن القلوب لو طهرت وتلقت توجيهات نبيها وآيات ربها بشفافية ونقاء لانتهت _ بمثل هذا الحديث وغيره من الأحاديث الكثيرة _ عما تفعل قال البيهقي : سمعت أبا عبد الرحمن السلافي يقول : المؤمن يطلب معاذير إخوانه والمنافق يطلب عثرات إخوانه . وقال البيهقي : إذا زل أخ من إخوانكم فاطلبوا له سبعين عذرا فإن لم تقبل قلوبكم فاعلموا أن المعيب أنفسكم وقال ذو النون : تناسوا مساوئ الإخوان يدم لكم ودهم , ولا تثقن بمودة من لا يحبك إلا معصوما أحبك أخى شمسى فى الله وأفتخر بكل من يدعو إلى آعلاء كلمه الله -- ربنا يوفقكم الى الحق ان شاء الله
لقد قدم الاخ شمسي لمدة 4 سنوات النصيحة لعلي في السر بالرفق واللين بل دعاه الى بيته و ما الى ذلك من الامور لكن للاسف الاخ علي لا زال مصرا على أخطائه و لم يتقبل النصيحة مما اضطر الاخ شمسي ان يتبرأ منه و من دعوته و يحذر الناس من اخطائه و خطورة اولئك المبتدعة الذين ينشر سمومهم في قناته و يعرض عامة المسلمين للشبهات و البدع. للاسف اصبحنا نرى بعض المسلمين اليوم يهتمون بالصداقة و المحبة و يحرصون عليها اكثر من حرصهم على الدين و يستسهلون خطورة الشبهات و البدع على انواعها سواءا في العقيدة او المنهج و الله المستعان.
Masha Allah for brother Shamsi. May Allah grant him a place in paradise with the prophet ﷺ. I noticed he never bends the truth or satisfy nonbelievers at the expense of deen like many people do in the Speakers’ Corner. He’s not there for followers nor for fame unlike Mohamed Hijab and Ali dawah. His UA-cam is educational and aimed to give dawah and teach the Ummah the Salafi way. Others like Mohammed Hijab are concerned about followers. Brother Shamsi is a good example Masha Allah. May Allah make his heart steadfast on religion 🤲🏾 As for the people who comment down below and say “this isn’t good and it should be done privately” my answer to you is this. قال الله تعالي: لُعِنَ الَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا مِن بَنِي إِسْرَائِيلَ عَلَىٰ لِسَانِ دَاوُودَ وَعِيسَى ابْنِ مَرْيَمَ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ بِمَا عَصَوا وَّكَانُوا يَعْتَدُونَ (78) كَانُوا لَا يَتَنَاهَوْنَ عَن مُّنكَرٍ فَعَلُوهُ ۚ لَبِئْسَ مَا كَانُوا يَفْعَلُونَ (79) Allah cursed those who used not to prevent one another from wrongdoing that they did. How wretched was that which they were doing. Correcting people like Mohammed Hijab and Ali Dawha is a form of enjoining good and forbidding wrong like sheik Salih Al-fawzan said. How can their followers learn if this was done privately?! O You Who makes hearts steadfast make our hearts steadfast in adhering to Your religion 🤲🏾
Muslims fights muslims in many countries. We as a whole now needed this on youtube and you two are doing great. You both talk about Islam, prophets, and sahabas. I wonder how sahabas had reacted when they had their differences.
Shamsi has the most knowledge in speakers corner. When you watch his videos he never ever uses his own desires always quoting from Quran and Hadith. If he says he tried to advice Brother Ali for four years I believe him may Allah help and guide brother Ali it’s okay to say I don’t know but having an answer out of your own desires in Islam this is unacceptable. Remember in the Fatiha we ask Allah to guide us to the straight path not the one with many turns.
Advice to Ali dawah and Mohamed hijab may Allah guide them “And if only the people of blameworthy opinion busied themselves with beneficial knowledge, and seeking the Sunnah of the Messenger of the Lord of Creation, and followed the way of the fuqahāʾ and muḥaddithūn - then they would find that this would be sufficient for them Shaykh Muḥammad ibn Jamīl Zaynū
Alhamdulillah our brother Shamsi is on the Haq. Sadly Ali Dawah is not a student of knowledge and follows those who are misguided and who have been warned against by the scholars of knowledge. Ali Dawah is a video an 'internet personality' who causes fitnah and misleads those who have little or no knowledge.
You guys are brothers in Islam why we fighting..? We should be spreading love and peace 😔setting an example it makes me so sad..😢come on akhi your a good man..may allaah swt reward you..🙏🏼
I know you might not take my comment seriously because i am a musician. But i am a big fan of you wallah. I hate to give you advice because you are a knowledgeable man. You always hit every point from the best angle. But if i was you, i would delete all the videos that has any comment about Ali. Eh wallah, And I copy this comment now and past it onto his videos. So he can do the same. Be the bigger man you have always been brother. May allah place guidance on all of us and make me at least half the person you are. As i will always be your fan wallah. Love you brother, wallah i wish i could meet you one day. Salam
I don't understand why Shamsi is labeling others with such harsh words. Do your preaching and stay in your lane. Both brothers are trying to do good in the park but all that will be in vain if you fight with each other. SubhanAllah how ironic? You are there to bring people to Islam but fight amongst each other. They are not no scholars. Go to people with knowledge and solve your disputes. Just remember this, every soul shall taste death. These two brothers should come together with the presence of an intermediary and solve this or face it on the Day of Judgment. All of those who are saying he's right and he's wrong are no different. They are both wrong. SIMPLE. Shame on the brothers who recorded this video
@@grahamgooch1938 I said that they were wrong and need to solve their issue by talking to each other privately. Sigh....Did you even read what I wrote brother?
@@grahamgooch1938 Advising him about what? Shamsi kept saying Ali and Hijab are lying to the people about our religion. I've watched a ton of their videos and haven't heard them lie. If he advises them that's good. But I don't agree with all this public stuff. Allah will judge each of them. I don't care if he advised him for 4 years. Talking bad about your fellow brother in Islam is wrong. I don't know why you're still on about this. Instead of promoting Islah and reconciliation you're out here choosing sides akhi.
Seems like young kids arguing without knowledge, but brother shamsi does sound much more knowledgeable than Ali, Allah knows best of course, may Allah's guide all Muslims on the right path
The backbiting from both sides is absolutely disgraceful. We have the deen of Allah being attacked left right and centre and yet we Muslims are continuously fighting amongst ourselves. When will we wake up and see the bigger picture! May Allah forgive us! Ameen
What burns them and causes them to resort insulting the salafis is the fact they can't rebut your points with Ilm (Quran and Sunnah upon the understanding of the Salaf.) It's all "my opinion this and my opinion that. "
Every person moves to different lengths to speak about Islam. I agree that Ali Dawah should try to become a proper aalim before giving dawah, but I also believe he has guided many people and defended Islam in the most important situations, for example when he debated Tommy Robinson. As for what you said about Mufti Menk, I’d say he is definitely more learned than any of us and one of the best scholars of today. Dr Zakir Naik is also self taught yet he preaches to millions of people; many have accepted Islam. I also believe that we should avoid this sectarianism. You could have highlighted all of the good stuff about Ali Dawah and clarify some of his mistakes. Whatever Ali does, he does it for the love of Islam. He may have changed the mind of many people aswell. I agree that there are some problems but also highlight the greater good. Ali is not a person working for personal interests. He is doing a great job trying to change wrong public perceptions.
Synadex I just watched a yusuf estes talk in the Quran and he said that “Allah recited the words to Gabriel, Gabriel to Muhammad (pbuh) and the Muhammad recited it to the sahabah.” Isn’t that right though and then humans wrote down the what was brought down? Or are we saying a physical book was brought down? I’m confused
Prophet Muhammad never named someone with his name because you can still deliver your naseeha and change munkar without naming as prophet Muhammad use to say " what is the matter with the people that they say such and such. this is the manhaj and the way prophet Muhammad use to change munkar if you people are following him but if you want to follow otherwise then Allah knows best.
Ali Dawah EXPOSED:
▶ ua-cam.com/video/PXZecuvGHrk/v-deo.html
Stop causing fitnah!
▶ ua-cam.com/video/weaLLptUTmw/v-deo.html
السلام عليكم اخي شمسي
أفضل النصيحة في الستر بلا تشهير
فالاعداء كثيرون و متربصون بنا
و جزاكم الله خيرا على مجهوداتكم
::
السلام عليكم الاخ شمسي انت واخوانك المجاهدين السلفيين واحذروا منهج الاخوان واتركوهم . واستشيروا اهل العلم في الدعوة وخذوا بنصيحتهم .ولا يهمكم ان رموكم بالمداخلة او الجامية او الوهابية فهو ديدنهم . ركزوا على دعوة التوحيد واسال الله ان يوفقكم ويزيدكم علما ويثبتكم على المنهج السلفي .
Pure knowledge based on Qur'an, Sunnah and salaf. May Allah guide me, Ali Dawah, Shamsi and other muslims to follow the right path.
Ameen
Adine jesi u londonu
Ameen ☝🏻☝🏻
@Marvin Alexander You sound like an edgy teenager wannabe from the Sam Harris cult.
Do we ever see Christian's arguing like this, no we don't because we have the truth
@DUS Dawah
Timestamps
0:00 Introduction
0:36 Hadith: “Whoever sees an evil let him change it...”
2:10 This is not a personal issue it's a matter of Deen
3:03 Promoting misguided people
3:27 Shamsi requesting to speak off camera
4:03 We're not like the Christians who have major errors in their religion and they keep quiet about it
4:38 Ali needs Dawah comparing Shamsi to extremists
5:44 Ali needs Dawah making the issues public and requesting Black Dunya to send the video to Content Over Everything channel and spread it
7:40 Why we are making this video and spreading it openly
8:50 Types of misguided people Ali needs Dawah promotes
10:28 We protect our Deen before anyone else
Br shamsi has clearly been studying the deen for many years and he speaks humbly and directly in accordance to Quran and sunnah including clarifying the understanding according to the ways of the salaf. We have to be stern in the haqq of Islam, clarifying the truth is a fard! Love you shamsi
That dude called salafis a cult when in fact I've been learning more from them than everyone else. He became too emotional, and irrational to the point he even allied himself with the non muslims to gang up on Shamsi. May Allah (SWT) guide him.
Yonis Ali What a very ignorant thing to say. In no way did I say the world revolves around me. I stated my point of view. Salafis always showed me what made sense. They always go back to the Quran, and the Sunnah. I came from a Sufi background into true Islam. All Shamsi is saying is that we must always hold firm to the rope of Allah (SWT). You guys want us to unite with innovators like the sufis. That’s a big no no, and you fall into hypocrisy. May Allah (SWT) guide you. Ameen
If Sufism is an innovation, why were the majority of Sunni Ulama throughout history, either Sufis or supporters of Sufis?
@@traditionalistgeeljire5487
Salam alaykum
Don't just claim that "majority of the ulema were sufis" !
PROVE IT
Coz we DON'T even agree with you that they were "suFis" in the first place...
And before all of this firstly we need to define it properly, take into account the various usages of this term during different time periods and ONLY then can we move on...
Why is your name Hassan the Salafi clearly they havent taught you enough about modesty lol
Just look how Shamsi spoke with 'Ilm, he spoke with knowledge, with principles, with consistency - not emotions & vague speech.
Ali wanted the video spread, Shamsi didn't - and Shamsi is getting told that HE is causing the Fitnah????
الله المستعان
KingTempa fear Allah and repent
KingTempa for lying 🤥
KingTempa
Abu Abdullaah Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Mufarraj said,
Abu Jafar Ahmad bin Awn illaah (d. 378H) would show rejection against the People and Innovation and call them to account, showing extreme harshness against them, utterly humiliating them, always seek to pick out their faults, rushing to damage them, vehemently oppressive against them, chasing them away whenever he was able to, not allowing them to remain. And every one of them (Ahl ul-Bid?ah) used to be frightened of him, and would seek to hide and protect himself from him. He (Abu Ja?far Ahmad) would never compromise with a single one of them, and nor would he allow any of them to remain safe. And if he came across evil and witnessed any deviation from the Sunnah, he would oppose it and would disgrace and humiliate (its perpetrator), and he would announce the affair of this person and declare his own disownment of him by mentioning the evil of such a one in the various public gatherings, and he would incite others against him such that he either destroyed him or caused him to abandon his evil and repugnant madhhab and his evil doctrine. And he would never cease to remain upon this habit, making Jihaad therein, seeking the Face of Allaah, up until he met Allaah.
(Taareekh Dimashq 5/118). And he is the Muhaddith, Imaam, Ahmad bin Awn illaah bin Hudair Abu Ja?far al-Andalusee al-Qurtubee (d. 378H).
@@streetzboxa if those "muslim" you are talking about separated themselves from areas of aqeedah[areas of the most important part of the rope of ALLAH] by innovating in the areas of aqeedah and they practise and preaches these aqeedah's innovations publicly themselves' while indicating their permanent established position on these issues-- their own aqeedah's innovations by refusing to accept 4 years worth of private nacea to correct those big aqeedah blunders and currently they still preach and promote these blunders, now' common sense tells me that if shamsi is still holding on to the rope of ALLAH[Kitaab and Sunnah] regarding not making or promoting those who made democracy voting and riba halal, like what ali and others are doing on the contrary' which in result is what made them[ali] separated from areas of aqeedah on the rope of ALLAH' this means ali separated from me, shamsi and the three best generations and cannot separated from the rope of ALLAH to please ali and join with ali on this great mis-guidance, so therefore ali and his democratic scholars need to separate from their aqeedah bidah and our arms are already opening welcome to accept them joining us back on the rope' cause its not our rope we cant reject no one who wants to hold on to it[its ALLAH's Rope]
Abū Mūsa al-Atharī many of my friend and family went to madinah university.
I have a question do you have any proof that asking the question how much hands Allah has is an innovation ? I believe the verse that Allah created Adam with hands, but asking and testing people aqida isn’t that innovation ? Did companions ask that question ?
I’m not Muslim but Shamsi makes sense and he’s humble..
Humble and honest talk free from emotion is sign of scholar
Br. Shamsi really uses authentic source for conversations....... He is really great guy. May Allah SWT protect you
Shamsi is speaking facts but not everybody is gonna like that!!
Best comment so far
Love you akhi for the sake of ALLAAH..
May ALLAAH preserve you..
Ameen
Shakil Ahmed Ameen
Ameen
2.5 Billion Christians
No, he loves him in the sake of Allah.
ʜᴏᴜsᴇ ᴘᴇᴏᴘʟᴇ
really?
Our brother Shamsi implementing the way of the Salaf:
Ibn al-Qayyim رحمه الله said:
“The one who remains silent in the face of falsehood is a tongueless devil.”
[Ad-Da`u wad-Dawaa’]
Al Maghribi this should be super imposed on the comment sections wallaahi it hurts that so many people want others to stay quiet concerning the deen of Allaah because of feelings. We are Muslims may Allaah bless us all, and we should be grateful to the one who corrects our deen
@@BlueSkyblueseagreenland Wallaahi you are right akhi. The Sahaba and Imaams of the salaf have been killed and tortured for this Deen and yet some people want us to stay quit when people try to change the Deen of Allah. Never. Baarak Allahu feekum.
My Muslim brothers and sisters it is important for brother Shamsi to expose the misguidance of Ali Dawah publicly. This is because Ali dawah is doing such acts publicly therefore Shamsi needs to expose him
publicly. If everyone kept quiet and didn’t say a word the Muslim laymen will believe that Ali Dawah is correct as no one is refuting him. Therefore. We must refute the misguided in order to prevent further misguidance.
And Allah knows best.
Asim Umar and this after Shamsi was advising privately for many years
We love all of our brothers, but it doesn't mean that we will not criticise them if they are misguided
May Allah rewards you effort brother Shamsi
May the almighty Allah bless and protect you brother Shamsi.
Those affected by Ikhwani principles are always emotionally driven (instead of evidence driven) you see them fiercely attacking those who speak with the manhaj of the Salaf but never have the same energy when it comes to the people of innovation (like the Sufiyyah, modern day Mu’tazili Rationalists, and the Khawarij takfeeriyoon).
Reminds me of something Shaykh Rabee said about Tahir Wyatt.
Mr Abdi خالد عبدالرحمن 💯 💯
Truss me there’s a lot of people claim to be salafi who speak from emotions to, also we shouldn’t label br Ali as certain group we should act better than he is and be soft in Naseeha when musa as was going to firawn to speak to him Allah swt said speak to him gentle so he may understand and Allah had knowledge already that firawn was going to say I am the lord most high so imagine talking to a Muslim.
Yonis Ali Yh I agree with you tbh a lot of the people claim to be salafi giving themselves praise when they aren’t a predecessor to anything it’s fine to follow the Manhaj of the salaf but personally follow the way sheikh uthaymeen and sheikh Saleh al fawzan have their view on calling yourself a salafi.
Yonis Ali you are not a intellectual smart person we see, first we say salaf I Salih not just any salaf second we do call ourselves ahlul sunnah wal jammah but go further into detail so that people can get the SEALED NECTAR!
Br Shamsi's explanation makes sense
May Allah bless you in this world and the hereafter.
The truth always hurts and this guy speaks the truth. Shamsi is genuine he fights for the deen and by following the sunnah and Quran. Remember a person who speaks the truth he has so many enemies. Even our prophet SAW had so many enemies. So if you speak the truth and u hv haters that doesnt mean ur wrong. Keep up the great work shamsi and i pray may Allah always guide and protect u brother. Ameen.
may Allah give correct understanding of salaf to Ali Dawah.Both are my brothers
Assalamu aleikum from Azerbaijan to all brothers and sisters. Assalamu aleikum to brother Shamsi. Salafi dawah is spreading everywhere, Alhamdulillah. This path is so clear and bright that it's enough for a person to open his or her mouth and you can immediately sense whether that person is upon salafiyyah or not. When I watch the videos of Ali Dawah (may Allah guide him to the right manhaj), I can sense that his videos lack the fragrance of salafiyyah. While watching the videos of salafis like Br. Shamsi, you can sense the fragrance of salafiyyah. May Allah help the brother and other salafi brothers.
Just a quick question is 'Salafiyyah' a new religion and the 'Salafis' it's followers???...as going by Taleh Karimov's comments, it seems to be a new trend which is gaining following...as far as I'm aware 'Islam' is our religion and 'Muslims' are it's followers...
From my limited understanding and knowledge I thought the word 'Salafi' comes from the Arabic phrase, 'as-salaf as-saliheen', which refers to the first three generations of Muslims (starting with the Companions of the Prophet), otherwise known as the Pious Predecessors....I think we will NEVER be able to compare ourselves to the 'aa salaf as-saliheen'.
So I think we should try to follow Islam and be Muslims....and unite upon lā ʾilāha ʾillā llāh muḥammadun rasūlu llāh ...
Salafiyyah is understanding and following Islam the way the righteous predecessors (salafus saleeh) understood and followed. It’s the pure Islam free from any type of shirk and bidah. There is nothing in salafiyyah except that its based on quran, sunnah and understanding of the companions. The reason why salafiyyah looks like a sect is because of the presense of the deviated sects. Imagine a white paper which is Islam, and I paint it with different colours and leave one space unpainted. Because that space is surrounded by other colors, it will look like painted with white color. That unpainted space is salafiyyah
@@talhakrim5975 Thank you for your clarification, but surely the scholars closer to the time of our beloved prophet (pbuh) had the best understanding, I don't know much about this Salafiyyah movement but it seems to be a new thing which is why I feel vary...the 'Saliffiyah' can't confidently say that their understanding is that of the true companions of the Prophet (pbuh) as we are far from being even close to how they were.
From my limited knowledge and understanding I feel we shouldn't label ourselves and just try and be the best of people and better our characters, call ourselves 'Muslims' and followers of 'Islam'...there is only strength in unity and wanting for others what we desire for ourselves...
And pray that we are on the 'siratal mustakeem' and not be arrogant to think we are on the right path or on the 'correct understanding' and everyone else is astray.
Edexcel IGCSE Science & Maths you mentioned correctly that the scholars closest to the prophet sallallahu aleihi wa sallam had the best understanding. This is what salafiyyah is: understanding islam the way they understood. As for labelling, the first person to label muslims was prophet himself sallallahu aleihi va sallam. He was the one who said my ummah will split into seventy three sects, all of them is in hellfire except one. The sahabah asked which one. He said the jamaah (he did not say muslims) . And you need to understand that calling ourselves salafi is out of necessity to distinguish pure Islam from the deviated sects
@@talhakrim5975 That's a big claim you're making, that you are on 'pure islam'...and to say that you are following Islam as the pious predecessors did...well, again that's an even bigger claim. And your interpretation of what the 'Jamaah' is, others may differ with...
But one thing for sure I would never call myself a 'Salafi' as I'm far from being even close to what they were.
You guys in the comments are plain stupid or haven't watched the video. If someone promotes misguidance for years while being advised, then this video needs to be made just to show he is wrong because he has a big following. So, people need to know he promotes misguidance.
@@streetzboxa like the video states. It's not personal. He promotes people with deviant ideas, this doesn't mean they or Ali are bad, so I do disagree with the title. However, if you are advised privately for years and still promote the same people of whom are deviant a video must be made in order to protect his large following. Salaam
@@muhammadchoudhury6818 But he's done that for 4 years!! What else do you expect when he could potentially be leading his followers in a negative way
@@streetzboxa For goodness sake brother it's in the video. Pay attention please man.
@@streetzboxa Listen. I didn't claim to follow Shamsi or SPUBS. I agree with Shamsi on many cases. Personally I follow those such as Asim Al Hakeem and Abu Usamah. Nevertheless, nobody is perfect including Yusuf Estes and Mufti Menk who do have some ideas that are not strictly from the sunnah. But I believe you shouldn't force people's beliefs like what SPUBS do, I just think if a Muslim advises another Muslim for 4 years they have the right to make a video on that Muslims mistake for the benefit of his followers. Please don't be emotional or insulting. Thank you
KingTempa give the citation of this in and in Arabic please.
Just keep a ear out and listen to the people Shamsi constantly quotes...... Scholar after scholar.
May Allah bless Bro Shamsi. The one thing I definitely agree with him on is Bro Ali, for as big of a platform that he has, he needs to gain more knowledge on Islam. May Allah guide us all! Amin.
May Allaah guide Ali and soften his heart so he can accept the truth
Fine. Now you do takfeer on Ali. That's actually unexpectee. Very good
Nabil Chennoufi audobillah I never made takfeer on him. Please put your emotions away. He is my brother and may Allaah have mercy on him
We ask for guidance from Allaah everyday, doesn't mean we disbelieve
don't get it twisted
@@BlueSkyblueseagreenland you litteraly said. May Allah guide Ali and soften his hart so he can accept THE TRUTH. What is someone who hasn't accepted the truth yet. A disbeliever.
Mufti menk Yusuf estas are bringing people into Islam.
Subhanallah.
Menk is a provocateur in the muslim scene ua-cam.com/video/v0LMD2X1NTo/v-deo.html
Ba-rokAllahu feekum
yeah u point out the right thing's.
zajhakumullahu khairan for clarifying "Ali Dawah"'s falsehood. we should be aware who we take our dawah-knowledge.
May Allah guide Ali dawah to true dawah...
The brave one and wise one is the one who accepts his mistake after being reminded or corrected by someone. We are all brothers. Sit together and look at the Reality the reality is and accept it .
Shamsi bro. I send you my loves from Germany ! Wish u all the best !
Very clear akhi Jazakallahu khair!
Very clear, we must defend our beloved religion from non-Muslims as well as misguided Muslim, not defending our dunya and we let our Deen behind
What's misguided muslims. There is not such a thing
@@nabilc1667 that just shows your lack of knowledge and you have no idea what's going on unfortunately.
@Darth Shadow i think he is one of those trolls who uses an Arabic names from the Christians or atheists , they are just an attention seekers and a waste of time, they have no life just ignore them brother.
@@AmineCasan0va i am muslim ya Amine not a troll.
@Darth Shadow how can i be a kafir. When i call a person who wants to unite with ahlul bid'ah a kafir. He is not a muslim. Did you even hear or see what his aqeedah is. Islam is not a game. Stop being emotional
May Allah guide us all!
Ameen
May Allah guide us all to the straight path inchaAllah brother
Thank you brother Shamsi. I dropped Ali Dawah as soon as I saw your video even though I didn't know about you and was a subscriber to him. When someone entirely speaks and defends him/herself by using the Quran and sunnah, like you did, who am I to say they're a liar. Alhamdullilah.
I have a dream, that in one day i will have a chance to speak to brother Shamsi ..May Allah give him Jannah.Amin
Our brothers in Salafiyyah Shamsi and Anwar (and other than them) are striving to clarify and preserve the Deen of Allaah.
May Allaah guide us all to what is pure and correct.
Allah humma Baarik Akhy. Beautiful message
Love you fot the sake of Allah.
May Allah swt bring your hearts together. The holy month of Ramadan is ahead of us , we need to cleanse our hearts and forgive each other for the sake of Allah swt
BarakAllahu feek for exposing the lies and deception of ali 'needs' dawah.
Ali Needs Dawah
Because he is not in islam
He is muslim
@Darth Shadow clearly not. How can he be a muslim by such claims and aqeedah. Islam is not a game.
@Darth Shadow that vermin creature, Nabil, is a kharijite.
Yes
Who is fighting for his ego?isn't it Ali?it is already long ago that I noticed mistakes in Ali Dawa and now I'm sure about it.my heart tells me brother Shamsi is right.may Allah forgive us and guide us. Amin
How can you know if your opinion is true ? I dont need daleel my heart just tells me 🙂🙂 what the F
Well, this is a test from Allah, so If even in our deen we got confused, we ask Allah to guide and have mercy on us. let's do everything to the best of our knowledge and if there's disagreement, we keep openminded and patience. Allahu Akbar! Subhanallah! Alhamdulillah!
Jazaakum Allahu khayran.
Dawah as-salafiyyah is too heavy for these ikhwani's. People should learn the deen.
brother why acusing when you no have avidence fear allah
You are who your friends are and his friends are ikhwani
The Legendary Outdoorsman
My brother, don't call someone ikhwani, even if he's ignorrant.
The irony, this is exactly what ali dawah was saying in the video lol. 5:04
Shamsi has a pure knowledge!
This is the problem, anyone who supports deviated people should be exposed. And the responses below are typical in responses we see the mental disconnect most muslims have is believable hence why we have sects. And they cant cope when someone stands and warns against someone who promotes misguided people. The proof in there look and listens to what Ali says. Shamsi keep up the good work. This is a massive problem and we need to expose innovators and misguided people.
I totally agree with you since I saw this video I have stopped watching Ali and in addition after watching Haji trying to attack you and releasing a video mocking you I have totally lost respect for both brothers. May Allah guide them.
You stay on your dawah brother and do not let them get in your way Allah has blessed you with a great mind, May Allah always protect you and your family. Ameen
I love brother ali dawah but he makes dawah like a show.. may allah bless you brother shamsi, keep doing your thing..
Allah will overlook the accidental, but not the intentional.
May Allah forgive those who are in genuine error, for that may be their best attempt of understanding the deen.
But becareful of sins from bad character, for that is something intentional.
Knowledge is extremely important, but bad character destroys the fruit of it.
Reminder to myself and to my brothers & sisters.
Jezklahu kayren my brother. May Allah help him and stop him from this ya rab.
Ali needs dawah. I've been saying that for like 4 years. Shamsi you owe me brother...
Love that one though. May Allah preserve shamsi... may Allah guide Ali as he is really washed up
Go giv him now why is it that he couldn't bring out the proof
replace with a new battery on the fire alarm it beeps in the background...
3:17 bro shamsi did u mention Mufti Menk mixes truth with Falsehood?? Subhanallah whats your proof for this slander??
Mufti menk is a human and he can.make mistake but people like shamsi treat them as kuffar. Stay away from shamsi
@@sddz6452 so are you making takfeer on deobandis??
Coming from the future have you seen the interview of Menk by the Danish radio station ??
hope his errors are crystal clear to everyone now.
We are one ummah
May Allah guide us all and prevent us from dividing, some people are only looking for fame and nobility but honour belongs to allah and his messenger and the believers, so follow quran and sunnah
No matter how much knowledge Shamsi and Ali have, as Muslims our instincts are to be embarrassed and saddened by this feud. May Allah (swt) judge our intentions, and efforts, and bring us closer. We love you both, no doubt.
Ali Dawah is an embarrassment and immature promoting something he don’t study enough. Shamsi is far ahead of Ali Dawah in the Deen. I don’t know why Mohammad Hijab does not school Ali Dawah from embarrassing himself and attacking Muslim brothers who are far knowledgeable than him doing Dawah.
Go see what ibn sireen said regarding this religion!
I agree with the brother, Ali dosnt know enough to give Dawah
So that was what was going on oooh okay.😐
شكر الله سعيكم وثبتكم الله على الحق.
I watched the ali and shamsi thing being as objective as I could, shamsi was in the right, have to keep falsehood away truth and can’t mix them for “bringing everyone together” falsehood statement
بارك الله فيك وجزاك الله جنة الفردوس الأعلى... والله اني أحبك ف الإسلام يا أخي.
Brother, you should fear Allah and stop labelling fellow muslims as misguided. May Allah guide us all to the correct manhaj and good conduct in dealing with Muslims, Amin.
يقول الله سبحانه : " فاتقوا الله وأصلحوا ذات بينكم " , قال البغوي في تفسيرها : أي : اتقوا الله بطاعته وأصلحوا الحال بينكم بترك المنازعة والمخالفة , أصلحوا ما بينكم وبين إخوانكم ، فما يكون لديكم تقاطع ، ولا تدابر ولابغضاء ، ولا شحناء ، ولاخصومات
روى البخاري في كتاب المناقب عن أبي هريرة رضي الله عنه قول النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم : " إن الله يرضى لكم ثلاثا ويكره لكم ثلاثا , فيرضى لكم أن تعبدوه ولا تشركوا به شيئا وأن تعتصموا بحبل الله جميعا ولا تفرقوا ويكره لكم قيل وقال وكثرة السؤال وإضاعة المال " أخرجه البخاري , أما يكفي المتخاصمين مثل هذا الحديث ؟! إني أظن أن القلوب لو طهرت وتلقت توجيهات نبيها وآيات ربها بشفافية ونقاء لانتهت _ بمثل هذا الحديث وغيره من الأحاديث الكثيرة _ عما تفعل
قال البيهقي : سمعت أبا عبد الرحمن السلافي يقول : المؤمن يطلب معاذير إخوانه والمنافق يطلب عثرات إخوانه . وقال البيهقي : إذا زل أخ من إخوانكم فاطلبوا له سبعين عذرا فإن لم تقبل قلوبكم فاعلموا أن المعيب أنفسكم وقال ذو النون : تناسوا مساوئ الإخوان يدم لكم ودهم , ولا تثقن بمودة من لا يحبك إلا معصوما
أحبك أخى شمسى فى الله وأفتخر بكل من يدعو إلى آعلاء كلمه الله -- ربنا يوفقكم الى الحق ان شاء الله
لقد قدم الاخ شمسي لمدة 4 سنوات النصيحة لعلي في السر بالرفق واللين بل دعاه الى بيته و ما الى ذلك من الامور لكن للاسف الاخ علي لا زال مصرا على أخطائه و لم يتقبل النصيحة مما اضطر الاخ شمسي ان يتبرأ منه و من دعوته و يحذر الناس من اخطائه و خطورة اولئك المبتدعة الذين ينشر سمومهم في قناته و يعرض عامة المسلمين للشبهات و البدع.
للاسف اصبحنا نرى بعض المسلمين اليوم يهتمون بالصداقة و المحبة و يحرصون عليها اكثر من حرصهم على الدين و يستسهلون خطورة الشبهات و البدع على انواعها سواءا في العقيدة او المنهج و الله المستعان.
Shamsi is From ALGERIA 🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿
The Truth is clear! Whenever you hear a person accuse a person of the sunnah of being in cult, know that this is a attack on the sunnah!
Slm bro Shamsi you speak the truth may Allah reward you and guide us all to the straight path
Ali (needs alot of) dawah.
Unite in the name of Allah SWT and Muhammed SAW. Unity is our strength.
Masha Allah for brother Shamsi. May Allah grant him a place in paradise with the prophet ﷺ. I noticed he never bends the truth or satisfy nonbelievers at the expense of deen like many people do in the Speakers’ Corner. He’s not there for followers nor for fame unlike Mohamed Hijab and Ali dawah. His UA-cam is educational and aimed to give dawah and teach the Ummah the Salafi way. Others like Mohammed Hijab are concerned about followers. Brother Shamsi is a good example Masha Allah. May Allah make his heart steadfast on religion 🤲🏾
As for the people who comment down below and say “this isn’t good and it should be done privately” my answer to you is this. قال الله تعالي: لُعِنَ الَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا مِن بَنِي إِسْرَائِيلَ عَلَىٰ لِسَانِ دَاوُودَ وَعِيسَى ابْنِ مَرْيَمَ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ بِمَا عَصَوا وَّكَانُوا يَعْتَدُونَ (78) كَانُوا لَا يَتَنَاهَوْنَ عَن مُّنكَرٍ فَعَلُوهُ ۚ لَبِئْسَ مَا كَانُوا يَفْعَلُونَ (79)
Allah cursed those who used not to prevent one another from wrongdoing that they did. How wretched was that which they were doing.
Correcting people like Mohammed Hijab and Ali Dawha is a form of enjoining good and forbidding wrong like sheik Salih Al-fawzan said. How can their followers learn if this was done privately?!
O You Who makes hearts steadfast make our hearts steadfast in adhering to Your religion 🤲🏾
Muslims fights muslims in many countries. We as a whole now needed this on youtube and you two are doing great. You both talk about Islam, prophets, and sahabas. I wonder how sahabas had reacted when they had their differences.
Shamsi has the most knowledge in speakers corner. When you watch his videos he never ever uses his own desires always quoting from Quran and Hadith. If he says he tried to advice Brother Ali for four years I believe him may Allah help and guide brother Ali it’s okay to say I don’t know but having an answer out of your own desires in Islam this is unacceptable. Remember in the Fatiha we ask Allah to guide us to the straight path not the one with many turns.
Jazakallahu khyran ustaad shamsi hafidahullah
Advice to Ali dawah and Mohamed hijab may Allah guide them
“And if only the people of blameworthy opinion busied themselves with beneficial knowledge, and seeking the Sunnah of the Messenger of the Lord of Creation, and followed the way of the fuqahāʾ and muḥaddithūn - then they would find that this would be sufficient for them
Shaykh Muḥammad ibn Jamīl Zaynū
Thank you so much because a lot of the stuff he posts I find confusing and not of love but anger
Alhamdulillah our brother Shamsi is on the Haq. Sadly Ali Dawah is not a student of knowledge and follows those who are misguided and who have been warned against by the scholars of knowledge.
Ali Dawah is a video an 'internet personality' who causes fitnah and misleads those who have little or no knowledge.
You guys are brothers in Islam why we fighting..? We should be spreading love and peace 😔setting an example it makes me so sad..😢come on akhi your a good man..may allaah swt reward you..🙏🏼
jazak allah kheir shamsi brother may allah guide you a,d bless you , thank you for what you are doing
I know you might not take my comment seriously because i am a musician. But i am a big fan of you wallah. I hate to give you advice because you are a knowledgeable man. You always hit every point from the best angle. But if i was you, i would delete all the videos that has any comment about Ali. Eh wallah, And I copy this comment now and past it onto his videos. So he can do the same. Be the bigger man you have always been brother. May allah place guidance on all of us and make me at least half the person you are. As i will always be your fan wallah. Love you brother, wallah i wish i could meet you one day. Salam
I hope in the future both brothers to have healthy friendly and private dialogue to advice one another. May Allah bless us all.
اسف اخي على التسرع انت على حق جزاك الله خيرا
I don't understand why Shamsi is labeling others with such harsh words. Do your preaching and stay in your lane. Both brothers are trying to do good in the park but all that will be in vain if you fight with each other. SubhanAllah how ironic? You are there to bring people to Islam but fight amongst each other. They are not no scholars. Go to people with knowledge and solve your disputes. Just remember this, every soul shall taste death. These two brothers should come together with the presence of an intermediary and solve this or face it on the Day of Judgment. All of those who are saying he's right and he's wrong are no different. They are both wrong. SIMPLE. Shame on the brothers who recorded this video
So then why are you speaking???
You’ve just done that which your telling Shamsi not to do!!!
@@grahamgooch1938 I said that they were wrong and need to solve their issue by talking to each other privately. Sigh....Did you even read what I wrote brother?
Ismail Ilmi
Shamsi has spent 4 years privately advising Ali dawah. Now what?
Ismail Ilmi
He said 4 years in the video did you even listen??? Once again you say what you don’t do yourself sigh !!!
@@grahamgooch1938 Advising him about what? Shamsi kept saying Ali and Hijab are lying to the people about our religion. I've watched a ton of their videos and haven't heard them lie. If he advises them that's good. But I don't agree with all this public stuff. Allah will judge each of them. I don't care if he advised him for 4 years. Talking bad about your fellow brother in Islam is wrong. I don't know why you're still on about this. Instead of promoting Islah and reconciliation you're out here choosing sides akhi.
Al Jarh wa taa'deel. You should do a video on this akh Shamsi. People need to know about these Usoolul Deen
Seems like young kids arguing without knowledge, but brother shamsi does sound much more knowledgeable than Ali, Allah knows best of course, may Allah's guide all Muslims on the right path
The backbiting from both sides is absolutely disgraceful. We have the deen of Allah being attacked left right and centre and yet we Muslims are continuously fighting amongst ourselves. When will we wake up and see the bigger picture! May Allah forgive us! Ameen
i can't wait to see you hit 100k subs 😃
Calm down and solve any problem in the name of Allah and let's help promote Peace and Unity within Islam
Dawah for Fame. This is what some Brothers in the Park are about.
Not true what you said, he just need to learn more.
Most of them do for fame... they will get more egos and Allah install TAKABBUR inside they heart... no manners (adab), humble and not lillahi taala...
Fame Who? Ali? or Shampsee?
Ali needs Dawah!
I unsubscribed from Ali dawah.
Jazak'Allah khair bro Shamsi. Barak'Allah feek
Baraka allah fika akhi Shamsi Islam has to be defended before any desires
May Allah guide ali
Alhamdulillah
.إِنَّ الَّذِينَ فَرَّقُوا دِينَهُمْ وَكَانُوا شِيَعًا لَّسْتَ مِنْهُمْ فِي شَيْءٍ ۚ إِنَّمَا أَمْرُهُمْ إِلَى اللَّهِ ثُمَّ يُنَبِّئُهُم بِمَا كَانُوا يَفْعَلُونَ
.وَأَنَّ هَٰذَا صِرَاطِي مُسْتَقِيمًا فَاتَّبِعُوهُ ۖ وَلَا تَتَّبِعُوا السُّبُلَ فَتَفَرَّقَ بِكُمْ عَن سَبِيلِهِ ۚ ذَٰلِكُمْ وَصَّاكُم بِهِ لَعَلَّكُمْ تَتَّقُونَ
Am I the only one who thinks Shamsi and Ali should talk things out?? Or not talk at all? Instead of having a public war...
Ali and hijab had to take it personally even accusing one person of rape. Shamsi only exposes their aqeedah.
What burns them and causes them to resort insulting the salafis is the fact they can't rebut your points with Ilm (Quran and Sunnah upon the understanding of the Salaf.) It's all "my opinion this and my opinion that. "
أحبك في الله أخي شمسي ..
اخوك من السعودية .
Every person moves to different lengths to speak about Islam. I agree that Ali Dawah should try to become a proper aalim before giving dawah, but I also believe he has guided many people and defended Islam in the most important situations, for example when he debated Tommy Robinson.
As for what you said about Mufti Menk, I’d say he is definitely more learned than any of us and one of the best scholars of today.
Dr Zakir Naik is also self taught yet he preaches to millions of people; many have accepted Islam.
I also believe that we should avoid this sectarianism. You could have highlighted all of the good stuff about Ali Dawah and clarify some of his mistakes. Whatever Ali does, he does it for the love of Islam. He may have changed the mind of many people aswell.
I agree that there are some problems but also highlight the greater good. Ali is not a person working for personal interests. He is doing a great job trying to change wrong public perceptions.
Mufti menk isn't a scholar in the Islamic sense (ie Aalim).he can be/is an imaam aa mufti or a student of knowledge but not an aalim.
What’s wrong with Yusuf Estes? Or Mufti Menk? I seriously want to know! Please advice me with proof too!
Synadex I just watched a yusuf estes talk in the Quran and he said that “Allah recited the words to Gabriel, Gabriel to Muhammad (pbuh) and the Muhammad recited it to the sahabah.” Isn’t that right though and then humans wrote down the what was brought down? Or are we saying a physical book was brought down? I’m confused
Coming from the future have you seen the interview of Menk by the Danish radio station ??
hope his errors are crystal clear to everyone now.
Prophet Muhammad never named someone with his name because you can still deliver your naseeha and change munkar without naming as prophet Muhammad use to say " what is the matter with the people that they say such and such. this is the manhaj and the way prophet Muhammad use to change munkar if you people are following him but if you want to follow otherwise then Allah knows best.
Jazak Allah Khair Bro.Shamsi
Books that cannot be changed can have a big design across the spines. How very impressive the man that cannot read says.