Blaming the Policies of the dead is something else. Thatcher instigated playing one sector of society against another you could not get more inhuman 'disgusting' a policy.
@@zoon1543 Spot Oil or Contract, Thatcher killed that market paying for the wholesale destruction of the Mines. Of course direct tax only accounts for 28% to 32% of any western governments fiscal budget - everyone pays tax.
I cant wait for independence and yo get rid of Westminster government and the tories and labour and Liberal Democrats we want our own votes to count and our own democracy it's time Scotland 🏴 ruled itself we don't want what England votes for we want what we scots votes for and it certainly won't be the tories or keir starmer who is more tory than Labour we won't be any better of under keir starmer
@@barbaraurquhart2276you need to grow up and look what the SNP have done for Scotland and then blame Westminster on everything that the SNP have made, like the ferries that are well behind and over budget and money that is sent to other countries and not spent in Scotland. So no we don’t want independence. We would not survive and if you think that we can then you’re in a different planet
@@barbaraurquhart2276People like you don’t speak for Scotland any more than your claims for separation make sense. I mean, what numpties thought up the idea of keeping the Pound (which following separation would be the currency of a now foreign state). You wouldn’t even have your own ‘independent’ currency 😂
Fibber Swinney stated back in 2004 he would 'axe' the Council Tax. Instead his Govt. actively pursue those who are unable (not unwilling) to pay, by deducting at source from people's wages and benefits overdue Council Tax. People can lead healthier lives if they can afford decent food. His party also state they wish to eradicate child poverty, yet they demand those on benefits pay the highest percentage of their only income on this unfair Tax. They then use this income to promote agendas, while those in Council Tax debt go hungry.
Well the EEC started closing mines in many regions on the basis of a 40 year transition to new industries and regional rejuvenation not closing the entire industry within 2 years providing no support and killing all non service industries the length of the UK - pumping oil at 3m BBL/pd to pay for the policy. Interesting the Tories always run to the Energy sector for revenue when they have crashed out, 75% windfall tax on current UK oil production 550K BBL/pd is not sustainable. There may be a small flaw with the Tory 'Services' policy; like post Brexit there is now a €0.6T difference between the EU Trade balance and the UK trade deficit - it wasn't that great pre Brexit at least pre Brexit the BoP was not a black hole.
My god these people are nutters,going back to Margaret Thatcher is a measure of desperation, it tells me they are on the rails and barely hanging on, they are done for. 💪
As for the obsession with Brexit surely that is the remit of those who wouldn't accept the result of the biggest democratic vote that the UK has had. We might have had a better trade deal if when it was put to Parliament the SNP hadn't abstained as a result the deal that we now have was accepted with a majority of around 7 votes. If he thinks that the 9 years of austerity from 2010 to 2019 was bad, the austerity that would have to be experienced by Scotland if god forbid they ever gained independence would make those years look like a boom time. Particularly as they want to rid themselves of oil and gas revenues ( something that the 2014 indyref. was predicated upon.
The oven ready hard Brexit deal was soley the responsibility of BOJO the oligarch and the Tory junta. You have to live with the consequences, in effect all Brexiteers are remainers having to face the full effects of Economic failure and a massive drop in the standard of living. Austerity is only implemented to ensure the Rich remain rich at the cost if all other areas of society.
14 yrs of Tory austerity, nothing compared to the super charged austerity and utter mismanagement of Scotland at the hand of the tartan tory Natsi Party!
Why didnt the SNP appoint a minister for the "wellbeing" of men, when they established the same ministerial position to consider the wellbeing of women? Why didnt the SNP, or indeed Holyrood in unity, appoint a minister for men, as we have a minister for women? Why couldnt SNP, in its continuous game of political one upmanship with Westminster...... give scottish men a "mans day" in Holyrood? Because they dont care? or because until recently, the political misandry in Scotland, has been no better than in the rest of the UK. Would it be so far off the mark to claim 70% of the victims, in 70% of the areas that lead to socio economic disadvantage, are males? Address that, and watch life expectancy for men increase......... not to mention its knock on effect in society in general.
Love the IKEA themed furniture, wonder if the company could run Scotland for us? Might be better run! I know, dated comment! As to flapping seals, I commented on that ages ago, still applies!!
That was a huge list of SNP failings. Douglass Ross really exposed how they are bad for Scotland's health. Can't believe just how bad the Scottish health service has got. Sounds like the SNP really are bad for your health
Riss needs to go. Regardless of views on the SNP, his behaviour is turning the Scottish parliament init disrepute and a laughing stock to the rest of the world. It's childish, immature behaviour that should be left in the school yard. He is a true embarrassment to Scotland. The soon he is booted out, the better. And his back stabbing behaviour towards his own colleagues shows how indefensible his behaviour actually is.
I would have gladly stood by Douglas Ross but I’m a traveler.He and I both know that there are good and bad in any community 2:20 .He took a cheap shot at
Excellent reply by the Scots FM not only were all questions and assertions answered Dross was pushed into his usual box of changing the subject and his unrefined reply charged with anger. Small wonder the speaker had no choice and pulled DRoss's Breeks up.
@@Diana-007Not at all DRoss presents zero substance and fails to push his childish arguments. He fails to maintain composure and his reply is violent and antagonistic. One of the worst and least respected politicians in the UK
@@vincescotian8083 keep taking your tablets 😂 might help with reducing the nonsense your speaking. Oops forgot you’re an SNP supporter so that won’t happen.
@@Diana-007 these days there are no pills all replaced by red or blue brain chips. Red helps you see reality, blue keeps you in illusion. Pity there are no sales of the Red...
Swinney so desperate, he’s taking his blame game back to the Thatcher years !!! He’s running on empty.
Another word salad from Spinney .
The man is incompetent.
You’ll get more sense from a cabbage
What utter pish from Swinney.
SWINNEY GETS CONFUSED JUST TRYING TO TALK SENSE
@@jamesfindlay7186 He has to drop his trousers, and underpants to count to eleven.
@@grahamestrathern7924 I ONLY DO THAT WHEN COUNTING TO TWENTY ONE
@@grahamestrathern7924 lol 🤣
@jamesfindlay7186 👈 this is what delusional looks like.
Blaming a long dead woman is disgusting
Blaming the Policies of the dead is something else. Thatcher instigated playing one sector of society against another you could not get more inhuman 'disgusting' a policy.
@@vincescotian8083 Bit like SNP supporters and Taxpayers ?
@@zoon1543 Spot Oil or Contract, Thatcher killed that market paying for the wholesale destruction of the Mines. Of course direct tax only accounts for 28% to 32% of any western governments fiscal budget - everyone pays tax.
Snp we are all laughing at you good luck Scotland
Maybe we’re laughing at you 🏴🏴🏴🏴
Aye....clapping seals, and nodding dogs,
The HOC is full of them also.
Why does Shona Robison only say yep yep yep is that the only word she knows.
Get the snp out. We desperately need a change. Focusing on independence is a joke especially when scotland is in such dire condition.
Honest John blames Westminster again, how unusual. Useless individual, he is Krankie in a suit.
Thatcher to blame for drug deaths in Scotland
@@stephenford8775 @ 06.50..go see.
Thatcher's been dead for over 10 years
It's drug USERS that are responsible for drug deaths Simple
PM Blair, his Labour Executive
were elected in 1997 !
Thatcher was a nightmare the scots hated her the whole of Scotland celebrated the day she wasn't prime minister
Holyrood is a TROUGH, NO USE TO ANYONE EXCEPT THE KID ON POLITICIANS THAT KID ON THEY ACTUALLY DO ANYTHING.
Liar liar pants on fire
Sheeiiite
Blabbering Baffoon. SNP - vote them out. Still going on about Independence- F in shameful.🇬🇧🇬🇧
Honest John 🤣🤣🤣
He needs to hold his head up and speak properly - I know. A big ask for this apology for a man.
They’ve managed to save the jobs of 600 at Ferguson’s!!……….BRAVO!!
Swinney he’s so far up his own arse SNP vote them out the problem is a lot o the rest are as well completely out of touch
And , like Ruth Davidson, be kept by the taxpayer for the rest of his life.
Douglas Ross
Unlike Turdgeon, Hamas Useless and 'Honest' John, milk more for the tax payer then any MP!
Not much of a leg to stand on yourself Douglas 😂
Where about is the clapping from the snp party he’s way of the mark with that one Wee Ross is peeing his pants
Half the SNP missing In action already on hols
So what would that wee trumpet Ross do about it then?
A proper job, that’s what
Could not do worse. Any school debating society could do better than SNP.
Swinney should stop telling lies we do not believe a word that comes out of his meally mouth anymore .
John Swinning, who would they blame if they were independence. SNP, need to go and go now
I cant wait for independence and yo get rid of Westminster government and the tories and labour and Liberal Democrats we want our own votes to count and our own democracy it's time Scotland 🏴 ruled itself we don't want what England votes for we want what we scots votes for and it certainly won't be the tories or keir starmer who is more tory than Labour we won't be any better of under keir starmer
@@barbaraurquhart2276you need to grow up and look what the SNP have done for Scotland and then blame Westminster on everything that the SNP have made, like the ferries that are well behind and over budget and money that is sent to other countries and not spent in Scotland. So no we don’t want independence. We would not survive and if you think that we can then you’re in a different planet
@@barbaraurquhart2276independence under this bunch of amateurs? It is a death wish. Grow a brain!
@@barbaraurquhart2276People like you don’t speak for Scotland any more than your claims for separation make sense. I mean, what numpties thought up the idea of keeping the Pound (which following separation would be the currency of a now foreign state). You wouldn’t even have your own ‘independent’ currency 😂
@@johnfisher7587 aka Giovanne Prescatario
Fibber Swinney stated back in 2004 he would 'axe' the Council Tax. Instead his Govt. actively pursue those who are unable (not unwilling) to pay, by deducting at source from people's wages
and benefits overdue Council Tax. People can lead healthier lives if they can afford decent food. His party also state they wish to eradicate child poverty, yet they demand those on benefits
pay the highest percentage of their only income on this unfair Tax. They then use this income to promote agendas, while those in Council Tax debt go hungry.
So where is all the "ring fenced" missing money dunderheid?
Disgusting snp, as a Yorkshire farmer I’d love douggie Ross as on or first minister, he’d do a grand job
Stay in Yorkshire
Thatcher was in power 40years ago! It's all her fault 😂😂😂
Well the EEC started closing mines in many regions on the basis of a 40 year transition to new industries and regional rejuvenation not closing the entire industry within 2 years providing no support and killing all non service industries the length of the UK - pumping oil at 3m BBL/pd to pay for the policy. Interesting the Tories always run to the Energy sector for revenue when they have crashed out, 75% windfall tax on current UK oil production 550K BBL/pd is not sustainable. There may be a small flaw with the Tory 'Services' policy; like post Brexit there is now a €0.6T difference between the EU Trade balance and the UK trade deficit - it wasn't that great pre Brexit at least pre Brexit the BoP was not a black hole.
😂😂😂@@vincescotian8083
Why does the presiding officer always reprimand Douglas Ross and never the SNP,
My god these people are nutters,going back to Margaret Thatcher is a measure of desperation, it tells me they are on the rails and barely hanging on, they are done for. 💪
Obviously she is also a part of the Ali Baba party.
Douglas Ross would make a fine PM
No seat and in anycase for PM did not go to the right school. Reform would take him
Can we vote out the snidey Presiding Officer please?
Every snp are snide saint they
No
They will be losing their Westminster snouts in the trough soon, watch out they’ll be on the go to make up for that loss in other ways. 😱
wasn't GAZA on the 2nd page of the spn manifesto .i never knew GAZA WAS IN SCOTLAND.complete audit in a couple of weeks
As for the obsession with Brexit surely that is the remit of those who wouldn't accept the result of the biggest democratic vote that the UK has had. We might have had a better trade deal if when it was put to Parliament the SNP hadn't abstained as a result the deal that we now have was accepted with a majority of around 7 votes.
If he thinks that the 9 years of austerity from 2010 to 2019 was bad, the austerity that would have to be experienced by Scotland if god forbid they ever gained independence would make those years look like a boom time. Particularly as they want to rid themselves of oil and gas revenues ( something that the 2014 indyref. was predicated upon.
The oven ready hard Brexit deal was soley the responsibility of BOJO the oligarch and the Tory junta. You have to live with the consequences, in effect all Brexiteers are remainers having to face the full effects of Economic failure and a massive drop in the standard of living. Austerity is only implemented to ensure the Rich remain rich at the cost if all other areas of society.
Nothing wrong with calling them what they are
The hypocrisy of Swinney. He was the one that first raised objections to Ross having a seat at Holyrood and standing for Westminster.
Swinney has no answers for anything
They all treat each other like idiot's, AND RIGHTLY SO 😂
Parliament? It’s an assembly, at best
It's a glorified council.
Don’t agree with the politics of D Ross but agree with observation that the “SNP Government is bad for Scotland’s health”.
Blatant lies, blame someone else. You have financial control you are inept
They do not have financial control nor control over UK drug policies.
@@graemetimoney7002 Drug deaths are higher in Scotland than the other parts of the UK though.
I am voting tactically next Thursday to avoid having Ian Blackford’s SNP replacement.
John swindler.
God he’s a snide is swingy, and why can he say that while Doug gets shut down?
That would be sea lions. Seals don't have big enough flippers to clap.
14 yrs of Tory austerity, nothing compared to the super charged austerity and utter mismanagement of Scotland at the hand of the tartan tory Natsi Party!
Nothing to do with the 17 years of incompetent SNP governance
I notice Kate Forbes not clapping very much. She looks out of place in the SNP under their lack of principles
Don’t be fooled, she is a hard worn National Socialist.
She is another Sturgeon in waiting
@@Steviemacdonald6594 She is thick.
Why didnt the SNP appoint a minister for the "wellbeing" of men, when they established the same ministerial position to consider the wellbeing of women? Why didnt the SNP, or indeed Holyrood in unity, appoint a minister for men, as we have a minister for women? Why couldnt SNP, in its continuous game of political one upmanship with Westminster...... give scottish men a "mans day" in Holyrood?
Because they dont care? or because until recently, the political misandry in Scotland, has been no better than in the rest of the UK.
Would it be so far off the mark to claim 70% of the victims, in 70% of the areas that lead to socio economic disadvantage, are males?
Address that, and watch life expectancy for men increase......... not to mention its knock on effect in society in general.
Love the IKEA themed furniture, wonder if the company could run Scotland for us? Might be better run! I know, dated comment! As to flapping seals, I commented on that ages ago, still applies!!
SNP blaming Margaret Thatcher for drug deaths & the state of the Scottish NHS how embarrassing from the clapping seals 😂😂😂 John Swinney is desperate!
That was a huge list of SNP failings. Douglass Ross really exposed how they are bad for Scotland's health. Can't believe just how bad the Scottish health service has got. Sounds like the SNP really are bad for your health
Clapping for the nonsense PARTY. SNP are a bad joke again blaming everything except themselves.
SNP is only competent in being CLAPPING SEALS
His lot drumming the desk like excited school children.
The preciding officer is a disgrace ...Swiney can say what he likes but Ross is constantly cautioned.
Swinney you voted to leave the EU if Scotland got independence when you voted yes Scotland would have been out of the EU and UK for 10 years
SNP couldn't run a bath despite the fact they have been running Scotland for years and everyone here pays more tax
Says the thief
Beavis vs Butthead
Clapping seals douglas! Is that because they foresaw you getting booted out......lol
Riss needs to go. Regardless of views on the SNP, his behaviour is turning the Scottish parliament init disrepute and a laughing stock to the rest of the world. It's childish, immature behaviour that should be left in the school yard. He is a true embarrassment to Scotland. The soon he is booted out, the better. And his back stabbing behaviour towards his own colleagues shows how indefensible his behaviour actually is.
I would have gladly stood by Douglas Ross but I’m a traveler.He and I both know that there are good and bad in any community 2:20 .He took a cheap shot at
At my folk.Why would you do that.I am nearly 100percent British.He hurt my feelings.He acted like a snob.
He has to remember he will be the mp for evryone.
A saying Douglas Ross should take Heid ‘ people in glass hoses shouldn’t throw stones’
His Westminster Tory party say more than there prayers.
Excellent reply by the Scots FM not only were all questions and assertions answered Dross was pushed into his usual box of changing the subject and his unrefined reply charged with anger. Small wonder the speaker had no choice and pulled DRoss's Breeks up.
You having a laugh 😂
@@Diana-007Not at all DRoss presents zero substance and fails to push his childish arguments. He fails to maintain composure and his reply is violent and antagonistic. One of the worst and least respected politicians in the UK
@@vincescotian8083 keep taking your tablets 😂 might help with reducing the nonsense your speaking. Oops forgot you’re an SNP supporter so that won’t happen.
@@Diana-007 these days there are no pills all replaced by red or blue brain chips. Red helps you see reality, blue keeps you in illusion. Pity there are no sales of the Red...
Ross should be sent outside the Parliament building until he grows up.