You will realize that michael C's articles has lots and lots of hidden background messages. All anti China and pro America. Read carefully, and discerningly, you will be brainwashed by him.
Mr Chugani, please ignore those racist comments under your articles and videos, they're rubbish which try to seek your attention that they don't deserve. Thank you for spending effort writing and speaking up, it's an honour to have you in the old HK.
Standing up to tyranny as a well respected public figure is very very hard because it requires wisdom and courage, losing "friendships", being threatened, etc. you name it. Mr Chugani, you're a hero!
hi michael, I saw what you saw from my window as I lived in your next block, I feel what you feel as I'm a hongkonger, but I only could keep my fingers crossed every night, good luck to hk.
Actually, who's lost. It is the lost of China because Hong Kong is no longer the Pearl of Oriental. China losses the genuine value of Hong Kong. People of Hong Kong don't have any loss because they are not the ruling party to decide the future of Hong Kong. Thus, people can pick up their choices again.
The Hong Kong people may have "攬炒" successfully, but truly there is no winner here. Everybody loses unless there is someone sensible holding power. “土共” is going ruin China, HK and the whole Chinese race.
Not everyone has a choice. It is the easiest for rich people but still they have to give up lots of things such as their friends and relatives, not to mention those who do not have the economical privilege. If you see China as an entity, yes, it is their loss. But for the rulers? They do not give a shit about that. It is just a part of their job, a hobbit-like activity making other people suffer. Their life goes on with or without HKers. That is why everybody is looking forward to the sanctions.
Sad but true. It’s very depressing to see what’s happening in HK. The worst things are some Hk ppl actually don’t wanna wake up and rather blame those waken people interfering their life while it’s just a dream
褚簡寧代表了香港很大部分的開明精英的想法。他們不蠢，而且有很多都非常聰明。經歷了他們各自的奮鬥，在他們真正的收成期，期望平穩繁榮，是可以理解的。他們當中也有很不少的朋友，在意識形態上都支持社會公義及民主進步。然而由於他們已身處高位，在表達政見時，都變得螫手螫腳。但到了現在，就連褚簡寧這種溫和人士，都不得不說“不想再見到林鄭月娥的樣子”。香港昔日社會的包容性很大，不同立場，不同種族，不同膚色，不同宗教的人士，都可以隨心所欲的表達自己的意見，最多只是不歡而散而已，但哪用擔心會觸犯國安法？那些口中最喜歡說要和諧，要再出發的，卻在那邊廂設立篤灰熱線，將文革的那一套搬來香港。亞洲國際大都會？你說笑是吧？董建華。由這志大才疏的敗家子當上首屆特首開始，我們就知道，中共永遠不能好好運作一個國際大都會。他們最懂的，就是破壞。1949年赤化之後，首先破壞了東方巴黎－－上海；到1997年之後，就再將東方之珠－－香港，再破壞一次。
+1
其實中國 有名嘅所謂國際大都會都係西洋人建立嘅。包括上海，香港。而當中國用心胸狹窄嘅態度否定西方價值，就只有倒退到中國人本身能力可以經營嘅程度。 可以回到文革，大躍進。甚至可以回到封建王朝帝制社會！國際大都？！會什麼是國際大都會？！ 上面個皇帝話，中國人只需要懂得吃包子。
@@SilverSilence002 可能你喜欢吃洋火腿，不好意思那是你的事。你可选择留下或离开。至于中国的发展，不管是西方还是非洲各国都多少有一定贡献，但贡献最大的是中国人自己。至于香港包容性问题，我并不觉得香港有什么所谓地包容性。要是有，就不会有所谓的黄蓝分裂。即便说有，也是政府与制度上存在包容性，然而现在这种包容性随着你们的政治运动反而缩小了。有些人总搞不清自己的位置与角色
@@SilverSilence002 看眼前的事實吧。你講的歷史不錯，但有否回中國親眼看看今天的發展？人和國家都可以進步的，一個國家要繁榮，不一定只有一種模式。
@@schoy3330 毒你唔死算你夠运！
褚簡寧先生，我一直都有看他主持的時事節目，也一直收藏他寫的英語教學專欄。好開心見到褚先生喺一位為香港發聲的良心記者和評論員！支持褚簡寧！
You will realize that michael C's articles has lots and lots of hidden background messages. All anti China and pro America. Read carefully, and discerningly, you will be brainwashed by him.
222y5h
褚生在高壓打擊下不屈服係🈶️骨氣🈶️良知的傳媒人，香港人支持你。
Ken K 我有他親筆簽名的書
係我老闆朋友知道我係粉絲
送我的 🙂
多謝沈生訪問禇簡寧先生，對禇簡寧先生只有致敬和感激。
褚Sir！謝謝你！講出了大部份香港人的心底話，反映了我們的意念！願上帝祝福你，也憐憫我哋香港人😞黑暗盡頭見光明🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
在外20多年、仍❤️繫香港🇭🇰
這是我首次在媒體認識Michael
他雖是持有外國護照、但仍愛護以往的「香港🇭🇰」及🈶️勇氣現時「香港🇭🇰」政情的弊處、是值得我們尊敬的🈶️識、🈶️言論自由人仕
由衷尊敬所有本來身處安樂,但願意出來講真話但香港人。 每天面對內外壓力不容易。 保重,謝謝。
禇簡寧係真香港人!
完全講中晒重點! 睇完兩個字, 心寒! 多謝製作呢條片, 亦慶幸仲可以睇!
有~親切感~~最終~~都有機會~~訪問褚簡寧 (Michael Chugani)謝謝分享~
Michael 十分理智，倆位也是wise men
謝謝褚簡寧同沈教授.
Mr Chugani, 多謝你的分享
希望褚生曰後生活愉快。你是真香港人。
多謝沈博士提供如此優質節目。👍👍👍 可否提少少意見？可否將背景音樂取消或降低聲量？有時會聽唔到主持同嘉賓講嘢。
【海外香港 219 🇺🇸🇭🇰】褚簡寧 (Michael Chugani)：美國也有國安法，但與《港區國安法》有何不同？（二）
ua-cam.com/video/EVCpaiLmCUE/v-deo.html
Really proud of Michael Chugani...one genuine and brave Hong Konger.
支持，加油💪
好應同禇簡寧所講
堅定支持沈教授，加油。💪💪💪
句句中point ，謝謝褚簡寧先生。
感謝！
褚 Sir . Respect ! 🤛🏻🤛🏻🤛🏻
香港人加油💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪
Support 真港人發聲！
香港不單沒有了自由, 還沒有了公義！！！
Can't agree more. 👍
講得好,思路非常清晰,👍
Thank you Mr. Chugani!
光復香港！！時代革命！！！！💪💪💪💪
One of the best interviews I had seen in UA-cam. 👍
見到香港宜家變成咁真係好心up
物是人非事事休，欲語淚先流。
Mr Chugani, please ignore those racist comments under your articles and videos, they're rubbish which try to seek your attention that they don't deserve.
Thank you for spending effort writing and speaking up, it's an honour to have you in the old HK.
Thanks for the interview
香港人要好好教育自己下一代，做一個有獨立思考及明白民主，自由及良知的可貴
It’s time for Hongkongers to move where we will find freedom and democracy. No matter where we move to , stay United. God bless us all!
香港人真係要接受 去面對 以前的香港已經 返吾到轉頭
捱落去，堅持自己，唔好硬碰硬
@@zim-chan 鬥長命，捱下捱下咁又好快一世人喇。
以前值民地管治，你有投票選擇誰來管治香港嗎？
香港人加油💪🏻
Standing up to tyranny as a well respected public figure is very very hard because it requires wisdom and courage, losing "friendships", being threatened, etc. you name it. Mr Chugani, you're a hero!
完全感受到你的感覺，今日面書好多人不但封了咀，就算連like也不敢，有更多人連社交媒體也不看！
香港愈變愈差，回憶總是美好
昔日香港個page 冇左
@@shiumycheng5847 好似係版主過身了?rip
@@oneouts2702 😢
The more things change, the more people stay the same.
無論點變，將香港嘅歷史文化保留，承傳落去。話俾後代及外國人知。以前嘅香港係點，依家係點。
Yes ! Yes ! Yesssssssssssssssssssssss !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Respect Mr Chugani and good comment. Thanks
Thank you for your sharing
離港是唯一出路
共慘黨滅亡才是最好的結局
天朝的思想是我們難以理解（從來都是難以捉摸、難以相信。）。
沉着抗戰 抗爭地下化 堅守專業 消極不合作 積存財/實力 打好國際線
有良心既人一定會變黃的
褚生嘅心路歷程跟沈生大同小異
加油
Same feeling about HK's current state as Michael Chugani.
HK has die. So depressing!!!
Well said
中國係人治，肯定就唔會俾清晰嘅法律條文。
如果法律係由中文寫，而非英文寫嘅，我難以相信會可能有清晰法律條文。中華文化先天規限。
@@SilverSilence002 人治國家條法律寫得唔清楚方便佢哋搬龍門
@@clotholachesisatropos 100% Agreed !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
香港已不是香港
真係死左了
Support and thank you !!!!!
禇簡寧 一語中矢, 完全明白老共既想法, 所以年輕人不要再送頭了
講得好，人哋一年前已經安排好呢條法例而等你哋跌落嚟.
多謝Simon找褚簡寧先生做訪問，昔日的香港已經死了……今天的香港已經是共產黨控制，統冶～香港人要籬開就襯早！
The background music is too noise
講出好多人既"無奈"，香港人反抗既理由
"香港"還存在嗎?
女神利君雅、男神褚簡寧。
好想揾日有人訪問沈博士! 期待!
睇得出呢條片係當時啱啱過国安法嗰時錄嘅,
現在情況又繼續變差, 黃就死咬亂告, 藍就輕輕放生, DQ民主派繼而導致全體辭職, 日日捉教職員/學校/公務員釘牌, 好快到法院..
10:53 禇生, 有冇犯法唔係你話㗎! 有冇犯法係睇中國共產黨嘅喜好, 佢鍾意話你有就有, 佢鍾意話你冇就冇, 因為香港已經變咗一個人治嘅城市, 任何法律條例都祇係中共嘅遮醜布。😔😔😔
佢喺呢一方面 暫時仲未與時並進
某某一説甚麼，馬上就成了法律。真神奇！
中共面前人人含撚！！
@@edgarchan9429 含撚致軟！😁😁😁
香港人!!
Thanks 🙏
hi michael, I saw what you saw from my window as I lived in your next block, I feel what you feel as I'm a hongkonger, but I only could keep my fingers crossed every night, good luck to hk.
Actually, who's lost. It is the lost of China because Hong Kong is no longer the Pearl of Oriental. China losses the genuine value of Hong Kong. People of Hong Kong don't have any loss because they are not the ruling party to decide the future of Hong Kong. Thus, people can pick up their choices again.
The Hong Kong people may have "攬炒" successfully, but truly there is no winner here. Everybody loses unless there is someone sensible holding power. “土共” is going ruin China, HK and the whole Chinese race.
Not everyone has a choice. It is the easiest for rich people but still they have to give up lots of things such as their friends and relatives, not to mention those who do not have the economical privilege. If you see China as an entity, yes, it is their loss. But for the rulers? They do not give a shit about that. It is just a part of their job, a hobbit-like activity making other people suffer. Their life goes on with or without HKers. That is why everybody is looking forward to the sanctions.
原來這個訪問已經是去年的，今天褚簡寧又有所改變，何不再訪問他一次，應該很多人想看！
到呢一刻佢仍然係一個天真嬌。
香港根本由97嗰一刻已註定悲劇。
咁樣都可以講簽訂南京條約同北京條約時 嗰刻，香港已註定係悲劇
@@lamlam1338 唔係喎! 你諗清楚： 呢件事令到我哋有超過100年自由，能夠令很多人，包括我今生成為香港人，而不是大陸人，真係要感謝上天有呢段歷史喎！
👍👏🙏🏻💪
respect
褚生好代表到香港的中立人士
好多香港人(不單祇年青人)都唔了解中國共產黨, 要知道 :「人有人格、黨有黨格」, 睇翻歷史, 中共嘅統治手段就係「順佢者倡、逆佢者亡」, 愈係反對佢、愈同佢對抗, 佢就愈加打壓、迫害。就好似香港而家咁! 😔😔😔
謝謝兩位仍會在崗位裡發聲。少少意見，受訪嘉賓的部份語意內容較多重複，同一句重複了好幾次，後期剪接處理時 可以精簡些。
采访能力太有限了
講得啱
Thank you
洗腦下一代……老實講若果我有下一代的話，一定會選擇離開，最低限度唔會再比佢接受“香港”教育。走唔倒既父母就要醒目d喇，要比正確既價值觀比下一代，同時要教識佢地同老師講大話，韜光養晦係呢個變態既時代係必須既生存手段
最緊要令到下一代能夠明辨是非：不能同流合污，不能為利益不擇手段， 不能指鹿為馬，背棄良心做一隻狗！
推翻極權，結束專政係唯一出路
即使立了國安法，香港亦「要完成憲政責任，為 23 條立法」，呢個係 6 月嗰時嘅新聞
佢就係要 take all :(
🙏❤ 😇
香港返唔到轉頭，第一原因係重用一班無賴的執法者。
畫面好藍，內容好黃 :)
藍色水
🤣 你上曬腦啦。
Michael 加油
支持褚Sir
網絡監察都不遠矣！所以年輕人要用盡方法多接觸世界，接觸不同文化及多訓練自己的哲學思維。
愛香港先會出黎
香港年輕人係被迫上戰場面對殺人政權
法例係死、人係生！我90年代進入政府工作，今天公務員與港英時代轉變很大。董生上場後，政府運作走向私人機構模式，盲目追求冷冰冰的數字表現！忘記政府服務對象是香港市民，當你服務人就很難用數字衡量。服務人最重要係滿足人心，其次先係慾望。港英年代公務員係講理、情、法，今日公務員為自保，一定同你講法、理、情。任何法律，永遠由人的智慧去演繹，但今天公務員只會按本子辦事，甚少行使手上酌情權😢😢😢
簡單總結褚生，佢以前太簡單
我唔祗林鄭個樣連佢把聲都唔想聽到😡😤
Yes ! Yes ! Yessssssssssssssssssssssss !!!!
可能有d似49年後嘅上海，由遠東國際大都會，慢慢變回一個普通工業城市
係共黨強制利用工業取代消失既商業活動去消化當地既無業人口, 戰前堆英商係長三角有廠, 但上海係寫字樓
Sad but true. It’s very depressing to see what’s happening in HK. The worst things are some Hk ppl actually don’t wanna wake up and rather blame those waken people interfering their life while it’s just a dream
支持 micheal🙂🙂🙂
放背景音樂原意係製造輕鬆氣氛，現實效果就適得其反。
沈教授，唔哂再放背景音樂喇。
遲早會篩選過d網，先準你上。
宜家乜都係煽動煽惑，條紅線任移，
加埋前線 班X 少少唔鐘意就會 亂用條例，
無罪推論一早收工
正, 煮咖哩(個名陶生改)
香港已死，但香港人不能灰心
它用重手壓香港，其實最後會自斷手臂的！
來留言CLS