I'm so proud of f (3) & I'm proud to be an f (x) fan I just wish that the fandom would be more united as the relationship the girls have. First we have the haters who want Sulli to leave and then we have the people who bashed on Victoria for being sick and not attending the concert. I will always love f(x) and f (x) = f (5), people need to understand that. As I watched Sunyoung, Amber, & Soojung perform I will admit that I felt mixed emotions of sadness and being proud...so proud. I wish them the best of luck in promoting in Japan but SM needs to do a better job because last time I checked they didn't sell out on any merchandise like everyone else so how can they possibly do well for an album. Anyways, thank you to these three girls for staying strong and giving us a great performance & thank you to the real f (fans) who continue to believe in f (5), f (x) fighting ♡ UPDATE: the sandals sold out & thank you for the positive comments towards me and the girls
I love our fandom! So many understanding and real people! Even though some give up but still f(fan) is more stronger now! Thank you unnie! I appreciate your feelings ☺
Daisyar5 yes i know exactly what you feel. I felt the same too! It was sad and it feels weird to just watch 3 people when f(x) has 5 members. But still, i couldn't agree with you more, i'm so proud. They're always gave their fans their effort and hard-working and i'm proud to be their fans. I hope SM will look up for them more and give them more and better attention. I know, we know that f(x) is Worth.
Just wanne tell people who dont know what happened to Victoria: She had a surgery and had to stay in hospital for least one week. It's impossible for her to dance or performance like that on the stage. She's now at home and having a rest. This is her first time missing SMT. During those years, even when she was shooting a drama and got very tired, she was still hanging on and didn't miss any stage. So pls just wish her getting well soon and believe in her.
mecheel There was only a Japanese news saying she would not attend smt because of her health situation. That shocked lots of fans. So the biggest chinese fansite SongQianBar asked the company and got the information. They posted it out and told fans calm down. And sorry I dont have that news link, you may find it on twitter i guess.
It is a bit sad seeing f(x) performing as just 3 but they still killed it! Sulli and Victoria, we will wait for you. :) Major props to the 2 backup dancers! Luna looked gorgeous as always and slayed; Red Light was always her time to shine. Krystal did very well and I'm glad she was feeling better. Amber did great as well. F(x)!!! At first I thought them performing as 3 was a prelude to a future subunit, f(Amber+Krystal+Luna). XD
DJeane Actually, no. She's been on a HIATUS since last year, but she never quit being a member. There were rumors she left but SM said no. So for the time being she is not a past member and still a current member who is just on a break.
Not gonna lie, ever since Beautiful Stranger, I've wanted a f(Luna+Amber+Krystal) subunit, and seeing them perform here, I can see that it would be an amazing subunit. This is actually one of the best Red Light Performances I've seen. I really want f(x) to come back as 5, but I just have to give these three their props for doing such a great job.
xuandaidalat2010 this reminds me of a tts vibes like 3 strong vocals and the rest are dancers but the Vic and sulli are fine its just that these 3 got a lot of more training
OMG!! f(3) totally work so hard. I hope Vic get well soon. Sulli I wish you the best, you deserve to be happy. Luna+Amber+Krystal SLAYED . SM, you better prepare an awesome comeback for f(x)
GloriousGrande All f(x) songs were originally sung by the group.. aka 5, and were made for 5. What's your point? Lol they're just following the original not indicating Sulli's return
GloriousGrande Exactly what i'm saying. Exo dancing their original choreography doesn't mean their members will be coming back.. SM said there were no plans of Tao, Luhan & Kris leaving or similar things and look where they are now. Can you really trust SM's words anymore?
It's sad to see only f(3) BUT, I feel they did an awesome performance for Red Light! It's not easy for Amber, Luna and Krys to dance with the two dancers. At least, they did well! I'm proud of f(x) and I would like to give them MILLION 'likes'!! To overcome an obstacle is not easy yet f(3) did their best to rehearse and sing not only their parts but the other members' parts! f(x) fighting!! Never give up for the success!! U deserve a big applause! 👏 PS: Thank u so much for uploading!!
This is honestly an amazing performance. It's sad seeing Vic and Sulli not there, but these three really pulled their weight and made an awesome performance.
Our girls worked hard to give us this amazing performance! I'm speechless.... The vocals were on the point, the dance just perfect, the stage presence killed it. And yet we know it's not complete, yet we know something is missing, we still see it's f(x). This is the proof these women slay no matter what. And Vic please, we miss you and we are worried, please get well soon and take time to rest!
I do agree that amber, luna and krystal killed it as three in this song but without victoria and sulli it felt incomplete but i gotta give these girls major props because they pulled it off and that makes me really proud of them. Hope Victoria gets well soon and Sulli comes back but after seeing this performance i think it's safe to say that they totally got this!
it is heart breaking to see only the 3 of them performing but I'm still proud that despite everything that's happening..they stood in the stage for the fans.
AMBER STANDS HIGHEST AT THE CENTRE FOR ABOUT SECONDS!!! AND SHE HAS MORE THAN 5 SECONDS SINGING IN THE SONG!!!! OH MY GOSH I KNOW I CAN DIE HAPPILY NOW!!! AND DO YOU SEE THAT GODDAMN SEXY STARES????????? *KISS THE SCREEN*
ughhh i miss these galss so much.. im so happy i get to see them performing on stage again after like forever. thanks for uploading.. i can't wait for them to make a comeback. btw, f(3) slays the hell out of this perf.. im so proud to be their fan
This performance looks better I think because they practised hard for days right before the concert so they're still in high spirit. Also, since they performed with dancers with good moves, it boosted their dances as well. Plus, LunBer are getting so much attention these days, giving them more confidence. Luna is always hardworking but can you see girl is on fire here? Her gaze is different. She is becoming more beautiful these days too. As for Amber, she got most Vic's and Ssul'S lines and her deep alto voice is stronger, giving different vibes to the song. Also, since she got to sing more, I think Amber was happier and was more confident haha ❤ As for Krystal, she is just fine :) And well.. Since this is f(3) and some people underestimated them, I think they gave it all here and proved that people were wrong. My two cents :> I'm not f(x).
watching this video made me proud to be an f(x) stan NAMELESS/AFF(X)TION . with this performance of f(3),it shows how strong this group can be,though they are carrying a very heavy burden but still they put their "head" high and gave us a performance that is worth of a standing ovation. with the absence of the other two VICTORIA (get well soon) and SULLI (have a happy time their in GREECE) they have to re do everything the dance steps and their respective lines but still they delivered it with GRACE........
2 members missing. Victoria is recovering from a surgery. This is her first absent from smt; Sulli is on a vocation in Greece and this is her 2nd /3rd time missing. Victoria is different from sulli. She's indeed a very responsible leader.
Believe it or not I can't keep my eyes of the back up dancers. They are killing it. Like slaying so hard as if they been there since the comeback stage. Their body control and charisma is on point. Also Luna looks really good and different.
I'm crying right now. And the reason I am crying isn't because there are 2 members missing. I am crying because of your comments. You guys are so thoughtful and sweet. You guys did not give up on F(x) and stay by their side, cheering them on through a video. It is so beautiful to read, I wish the girls can read these comments. I love you all for being there. Thank you from an F(x) fan. Let us stay together and support our girls!
Im so proud and sad at the same time. These girls are really amazing. Remembering that f(x) always had a bad luck from the beginning. Hope this year and the next years they got the best luck. Ameen.
oh im felling so touching! even there just f(3) two dancer but they really working hard! this is a good preformance f(x) we proud of you all and wish victoria unnie get well soon and sulli comeback fast ~ f(3) smtown japan fighting❤❤❤
Damn, Luna is looking fierce! Good performance from f(3). I must admit though...I worry about them a lot. It's hard for me to believe that Soojung is only 21...
Am I the only one that felt happy and sad at the same time? It's sad that f(x) just perform with 3members. But happy as amber got more lines and their performance was superb. I mean yeah they hardworked. Somehow it felt better when they perform with ot5
Some of the comments are so inhumane! Victoria is sick people! She had a surgery and is too weak to dance. She never said she's leaving. Sulli is the one that is leaving fx. Krystal also said recently: unfortunately our member vic oennie's not here due to health problems...which means sulli is not their member anymore
I'm so proud of our f(x) girls! Amber, Luna and Krystal really did their best!!! Victoria get well soon! Looking forward to their come back on September! f(x) fighting!
They still killed it to be honest lol Im happy Amber got more lines,Luna never fails me and Krystal improved ^_^ Vic eomma and Ssul we will wait for you !! The back up dancers are great as well
I want them together... Some haters can be so annoying and have so much power to destroy one of the only groups that have difficult choreographies and great songs. YEEEES, we know that you don't like Sulli's legs or her relation with Choiza, but she has feelings and a life, let her live!!!
Seeing that they added 2 backup dancers just to make them 5 gets my hopes up that sulli wont leave. F(3) looks so empty... f(5) will always be the best👌
So this is what f(Amber + Luna + Krystal) would look like... I'm missing Victoria, but they do sound amazing. Lucky that they had the three strongest vocals for the concert, at least.
These 3 are what keep fx alive. They are good at performing. I love victoria and sulli but they aren't the most stable. fx has always been held back over the years since every year something happens making it difficult for the girls to have comebacks. SM puts makes conflicting schedules for them to promote during the year such as sulli, victoria and krystal having dramas or movies. Luna with her musicals and amber I'm variety shows or hosting. They legit do more individual activities as solos than as a group. Hopefully this year fx gets a clear start when the Sulli issue gets settled of whether she wants to stay or leave because the only thing she's doing is holding back the group and making a damage to their image with her scandals. I understand she needs a break but she needs to take into consideration her members. This perfomance was the most solid one they have done for Red Light, there is no denying they work extremely well as a trio and pulled it off effortlessly even though they had to rearrange their parts
Like the way they tweaked the choreography to keep f(3) front and center at all times. That must have been tricky for them, having to learn something almost but not quite what they're accustomed to doing.
This makes me sad u.u I hope víc omma gets well soon~ and well... If supposedly Sulli hasn't left Fx then she should have took one day off of her hiatus like they need you :( still F(3) was really amazing I love them so much...
Im so proud that f(3) performed without any mistake. Good jood Krystal Luna Amber. Love you, Krystal unnie Dear SM, let's look at my girls. They are so talents. And damn, why you combulsori they wait for their FIRST OWN FANDOM AND CONCERT. it's 6years, too long. Anyway, Im so happy to be your fan, always and forever. Get well soon, Victoria. ^^ and Ssul,watch this vid and think of what you've done, you make me very very disappointed. F(x) fighting, come back soon :>
f(3) in this performance did really good. And the vocal line(Luna+Krystal)Rap(Amber) Try their best. And the result of the performance was really amazing.!!! I'm so proud of them. f(x),fighting No matter f(4) or f(5),they are always the best.
Atleast they added 2 more dancers so i have hope that f(5) is still real. I hope my girls shine brighter than the stars this year and more years later ;;
If only they were complete in this performance, this would be the badass perf ever in my life!! It feels awkward seeing them three filling up the empty spaces of Vic and Ssul. f(5) fighting~
I just want f(x) to have a comeback now. I don't want Sulli leaving rumor to be true. I love f(x) and they are so underrated. People think that being under a big company gets special treatment, but not for f(x). I really wish f(x) would comeback as 5, if not 4 is fine too.
Back in the day, when an artist in a group was out, they wouldn't change much, just have a backup dancer with a mask on, take their "solo" parts with playback vocals from the original recording. I guess with two of them missing, you can't really do that. I think they did a great job adapting to it.
magicmike191v2 The only one I can think of at the moment is DBSK's first promotions of Rising Sun when it was 5 members. Jaejoong had injured his leg before promotions started and would have a backup dancer take his place on stage. In some instances the backup dancer (in a mask) would be there for everything, using a microphone to look like he was part of the group, "singing" with a backtrack that contained Jaejoong's voice in it, others, the backup dancer would be there to dance and Hero would just come on during his two solo parts and then walk off stage, and they have switched it so Changmin took his vocal roles while the backup dancer in the mask was just there to keep the same dance structure.
I hope I get to see the f(5) again .. But I really appreciate they still performed even though it was just the three of them but tbh I actually prefer this performance because (OO.. MAA. GAAD..) they were killing it💜💜 hope Victoria gets well soon and gets to perform with f(x) again ^_^ and I really hope that Sulli won't leave f(x)!!🙏 F(x) FIGHTING!!!
all the comments about haters that bashing Victoria were irritated my feelings :'). She didn't leave f(x) for god's sake she's just feeling unwell :'). She's sick. Oh gosh... I don't want to reply hate comments on your post thou, i'm being calm but please, she didn't do anything that harm all of you :')
SM tiene que ser serio con F(x) fans. Victoria ya tiene 28 y quiere trabajar en China mas q en Korea. Sulli tiene mas de un ano en hiatus y no quiere regresar. Vamos SM decidete, promueve a AMBER, KRYSTAL Y SULLI y hazle un comback pronto. En realidad Amber lider y 3 vocal, Krystal visual y 2 vocal, Luna main vocal.
it's sad that it's js f(3) BUT flawless performance as always. :3 HEY SM, Stop neglecting your groups.. =_= All yr groups are fabulous in their own way!
Sophie Meeoun f(x) usually sings live, but most of the SMTOWN concert performances are pre-recorded for some reason. Most SM groups sing live at their own concerts and music shows now
OiiOreo Because if the performers don't sound absolutely perfect, the people paying admission complain, and start saying "oh they can't sing, why are they making so much money?" and stop going to concerts. SM needs people to go to concerts, that's their bread-and-butter, not CD's or other stuff...
Got it! Thanks for the explanations. I hope I didn't sound too snarky. I love the group but I'm always disappointed that their live concerts are mostly lip-syncing... I suppose who isn't these days? Lol. Thanks again!
And really, they are _always_ singing when they perform live, even with the "backing track" - of their own voices - it just varies from site to site and event to event what the balance between the microphone and the playback is, anywhere from 50/50 to 80/20 in each direction :)
![[MPD직캠] 에프엑스 1위 앵콜 직캠 4 Walls Fancam No.1 Encore full ver. MNET MCOUNTDOWN 151105](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ETX-RyhbIO4/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm so proud of f (3) & I'm proud to be an f (x) fan I just wish that the fandom would be more united as the relationship the girls have. First we have the haters who want Sulli to leave and then we have the people who bashed on Victoria for being sick and not attending the concert. I will always love f(x) and f (x) = f (5), people need to understand that. As I watched Sunyoung, Amber, & Soojung perform I will admit that I felt mixed emotions of sadness and being proud...so proud. I wish them the best of luck in promoting in Japan but SM needs to do a better job because last time I checked they didn't sell out on any merchandise like everyone else so how can they possibly do well for an album. Anyways, thank you to these three girls for staying strong and giving us a great performance & thank you to the real f (fans) who continue to believe in f (5), f (x) fighting ♡
UPDATE: the sandals sold out & thank you for the positive comments towards me and the girls
I love our fandom! So many understanding and real people! Even though some give up but still f(fan) is more stronger now! Thank you unnie! I appreciate your feelings ☺
♡ OT5! another proud f(x) fan here. Fandom, let's unite. For them, for f(x)
Daisyar5 yes i know exactly what you feel. I felt the same too! It was sad and it feels weird to just watch 3 people when f(x) has 5 members. But still, i couldn't agree with you more, i'm so proud. They're always gave their fans their effort and hard-working and i'm proud to be their fans. I hope SM will look up for them more and give them more and better attention. I know, we know that f(x) is Worth.
Daisyar5 naduu!!!! i miss them and really anticipated for their comeback this year.
Just wanne tell people who dont know what happened to Victoria: She had a surgery and had to stay in hospital for least one week. It's impossible for her to dance or performance like that on the stage. She's now at home and having a rest. This is her first time missing SMT. During those years, even when she was shooting a drama and got very tired, she was still hanging on and didn't miss any stage. So pls just wish her getting well soon and believe in her.
Nele Yi Hi, I hope Vic recovers soon :) I was wondering how people knew she was sick, can you send me a link please?
mecheel her chinese fansites posted the news on weibo
AmberLiufangirl Thank you :)
mecheel There was only a Japanese news saying she would not attend smt because of her health situation. That shocked lots of fans. So the biggest chinese fansite SongQianBar asked the company and got the information. They posted it out and told fans calm down. And sorry I dont have that news link, you may find it on twitter i guess.
Nele Yi Thanks! And yes, I heard she was sick but I didn't knew anything else, I hope she gets well soon :)
It is a bit sad seeing f(x) performing as just 3 but they still killed it! Sulli and Victoria, we will wait for you. :) Major props to the 2 backup dancers! Luna looked gorgeous as always and slayed; Red Light was always her time to shine. Krystal did very well and I'm glad she was feeling better. Amber did great as well. F(x)!!!
At first I thought them performing as 3 was a prelude to a future subunit, f(Amber+Krystal+Luna). XD
You can wait for sulli anymore, she is no longer fx member. Sulli will b pursue her acting career
Nikita Michi lmao SM never announced she isn't a member anymore.
DelenaJemiFan it's been like weeks since they confirmed that Sulli is no longer part of f(x) but she's still under sm ent. :)
DJeane it was a haitus a break not leaving
DJeane Actually, no. She's been on a HIATUS since last year, but she never quit being a member. There were rumors she left but SM said no. So for the time being she is not a past member and still a current member who is just on a break.
Not gonna lie, ever since Beautiful Stranger, I've wanted a f(Luna+Amber+Krystal) subunit, and seeing them perform here, I can see that it would be an amazing subunit. This is actually one of the best Red Light Performances I've seen. I really want f(x) to come back as 5, but I just have to give these three their props for doing such a great job.
djChives95 well they are the main vocals in their group
what do you think :P
xuandaidalat2010 this reminds me of a tts vibes like 3 strong vocals and the rest are dancers but the Vic and sulli are fine its just that these 3 got a lot of more training
Same!!
OMG!! f(3) totally work so hard. I hope Vic get well soon. Sulli I wish you the best, you deserve to be happy. Luna+Amber+Krystal SLAYED . SM, you better prepare an awesome comeback for f(x)
^ lol it's because it's a dance for 5 and a song sung by 5 that doesn't mean sulli hasn't left
kelznhi they used the 2 dancers for all their songs not just this one
GloriousGrande All f(x) songs were originally sung by the group.. aka 5, and were made for 5. What's your point? Lol they're just following the original not indicating Sulli's return
GloriousGrande Exactly what i'm saying. Exo dancing their original choreography doesn't mean their members will be coming back..
SM said there were no plans of Tao, Luhan & Kris leaving or similar things and look where they are now. Can you really trust SM's words anymore?
Are u kidding me? You are damn right !!! But I doubt about Sulli's presence. Hope there's news that she went to SM building or sth
It's sad to see only f(3) BUT, I feel they did an awesome performance for Red Light! It's not easy for Amber, Luna and Krys to dance with the two dancers. At least, they did well! I'm proud of f(x) and I would like to give them MILLION 'likes'!! To overcome an obstacle is not easy yet f(3) did their best to rehearse and sing not only their parts but the other members' parts! f(x) fighting!! Never give up for the success!! U deserve a big applause! 👏 PS: Thank u so much for uploading!!
This is honestly an amazing performance. It's sad seeing Vic and Sulli not there, but these three really pulled their weight and made an awesome performance.
These girls slayed. Red Light has intricate dance moves and my girls did so well. f(3) just slayed, so proud.
Our girls worked hard to give us this amazing performance! I'm speechless....
The vocals were on the point, the dance just perfect, the stage presence killed it. And yet we know it's not complete, yet we know something is missing, we still see it's f(x). This is the proof these women slay no matter what.
And Vic please, we miss you and we are worried, please get well soon and take time to rest!
I do agree that amber, luna and krystal killed it as three in this song but without victoria and sulli it felt incomplete but i gotta give these girls major props because they pulled it off and that makes me really proud of them. Hope Victoria gets well soon and Sulli comes back but after seeing this performance i think it's safe to say that they totally got this!
amber and luna's voices are so great
it is heart breaking to see only the 3 of them performing but I'm still proud that despite everything that's happening..they stood in the stage for the fans.
I'm so proud of my girls, slayin'! Red light performance is really daebak.
I'm so proud to be f(x)'s fan! They performed really well!
AMBER STANDS HIGHEST AT THE CENTRE FOR ABOUT SECONDS!!! AND SHE HAS MORE THAN 5 SECONDS SINGING IN THE SONG!!!! OH MY GOSH I KNOW I CAN DIE HAPPILY NOW!!! AND DO YOU SEE THAT GODDAMN SEXY STARES????????? *KISS THE SCREEN*
Very trueeee love amber so much
riiiggggghhhhhttttt
ughhh i miss these galss so much.. im so happy i get to see them performing on stage again after like forever. thanks for uploading.. i can't wait for them to make a comeback. btw, f(3) slays the hell out of this perf.. im so proud to be their fan
Luna
Is only me that find this f(3) performance of Red LIght better then the f(5) one?
No me too
***** she doesnt leave. VALK are the biggest f(5) stans alive. you can dislike her as much as you want, but dont spread the untrue information
This performance looks better I think because they practised hard for days right before the concert so they're still in high spirit. Also, since they performed with dancers with good moves, it boosted their dances as well. Plus, LunBer are getting so much attention these days, giving them more confidence. Luna is always hardworking but can you see girl is on fire here? Her gaze is different. She is becoming more beautiful these days too. As for Amber, she got most Vic's and Ssul'S lines and her deep alto voice is stronger, giving different vibes to the song. Also, since she got to sing more, I think Amber was happier and was more confident haha ❤ As for Krystal, she is just fine :) And well.. Since this is f(3) and some people underestimated them, I think they gave it all here and proved that people were wrong.
My two cents :> I'm not f(x).
***** I understand your opinion but please don't generalize the fandom. Not all fans are like that.
***** Immature kid,grow up lah you
watching this video made me proud to be an f(x) stan NAMELESS/AFF(X)TION .
with this performance of f(3),it shows how strong this group can be,though they are carrying a very heavy burden but still they put their "head" high and gave us a performance that is worth of a standing ovation. with the absence of the other two VICTORIA (get well soon) and SULLI (have a happy time their in GREECE) they have to re do everything the dance steps and their respective lines but still they delivered it with GRACE........
2 members missing. Victoria is recovering from a surgery. This is her first absent from smt; Sulli is on a vocation in Greece and this is her 2nd /3rd time missing. Victoria is different from sulli. She's indeed a very responsible leader.
everything about this performance is perfect
Thank you... U don't know how much I miss them :((
Krystal is love ... She's so freaking beautiful
f(3) + 2 backup dancers.. i feel so sad watching these 3 trying their best :(
jeongmal kamsahabnida for uploading this video. they are AMAZING! fx fighting! love them. f(5) FOREVER
Believe it or not I can't keep my eyes of the back up dancers. They are killing it. Like slaying so hard as if they been there since the comeback stage. Their body control and charisma is on point. Also Luna looks really good and different.
Thank you so much for this awesome fancam! The girls did so so well considering the circumstances. :)
This was awesome and Amber is a great vocalist!!!!!! They deserve better than how SM is treating them
I'm crying right now. And the reason I am crying isn't because there are 2 members missing. I am crying because of your comments. You guys are so thoughtful and sweet. You guys did not give up on F(x) and stay by their side, cheering them on through a video. It is so beautiful to read, I wish the girls can read these comments. I love you all for being there. Thank you from an F(x) fan. Let us stay together and support our girls!
they were awesome , Amberr got a lot of lines !!! yay , still a little sad that sulli and vic didnt preform together . LOve Fx !!
Que orgulho das minhas meninas... Luna está... INCRÍVEL...
Im so proud and sad at the same time. These girls are really amazing. Remembering that f(x) always had a bad luck from the beginning. Hope this year and the next years they got the best luck. Ameen.
oh im felling so touching! even there just f(3) two dancer but they really working hard! this is a good preformance f(x) we proud of you all and wish victoria unnie get well soon and sulli comeback fast ~ f(3) smtown japan fighting❤❤❤
Damn, Luna is looking fierce! Good performance from f(3). I must admit though...I worry about them a lot. It's hard for me to believe that Soojung is only 21...
Am I the only one that felt happy and sad at the same time?
It's sad that f(x) just perform with 3members. But happy as amber got more lines and their performance was superb. I mean yeah they hardworked. Somehow it felt better when they perform with ot5
Some of the comments are so inhumane! Victoria is sick people! She had a surgery and is too weak to dance. She never said she's leaving. Sulli is the one that is leaving fx. Krystal also said recently: unfortunately our member vic oennie's not here due to health problems...which means sulli is not their member anymore
thank you so much so much sosososososo much for uploading!
Luna is freaking charming and sexy
F(3)are already done their best fighting!
I'm so proud of our f(x) girls! Amber, Luna and Krystal really did their best!!! Victoria get well soon! Looking forward to their come back on September! f(x) fighting!
They still killed it to be honest lol
Im happy Amber got more lines,Luna never fails me and Krystal improved ^_^
Vic eomma and Ssul we will wait for you !!
The back up dancers are great as well
+LiEll 엠버 Bitch, what do you mean Krystal improved? She always slayed.
She improved because remember their past red light perfs? She looked tired and weak but now she looks strong and fierce
Cant take my eyes off Luna
I want them together... Some haters can be so annoying and have so much power to destroy one of the only groups that have difficult choreographies and great songs. YEEEES, we know that you don't like Sulli's legs or her relation with Choiza, but she has feelings and a life, let her live!!!
LUNA IS FLAWLESS
Seeing that they added 2 backup dancers just to make them 5 gets my hopes up that sulli wont leave. F(3) looks so empty... f(5) will always be the best👌
So this is what f(Amber + Luna + Krystal) would look like... I'm missing Victoria, but they do sound amazing. Lucky that they had the three strongest vocals for the concert, at least.
you really nailed it girls!! but I still miss the times when you all perform in stage :(
Thank you!! Even as 3 they did really well.
These 3 are what keep fx alive.
They are good at performing. I love victoria and sulli but they aren't the most stable.
fx has always been held back over the years since every year something happens making it difficult for the girls to have comebacks.
SM puts makes conflicting schedules for them to promote during the year such as sulli, victoria and krystal having dramas or movies. Luna with her musicals and amber I'm variety shows or hosting. They legit do more individual activities as solos than as a group.
Hopefully this year fx gets a clear start when the Sulli issue gets settled of whether she wants to stay or leave because the only thing she's doing is holding back the group and making a damage to their image with her scandals. I understand she needs a break but she needs to take into consideration her members.
This perfomance was the most solid one they have done for Red Light, there is no denying they work extremely well as a trio and pulled it off effortlessly even though they had to rearrange their parts
This SM town was so bittersweet - no sulli no victoria no tao no yunho no jessica :'(
no luhan and no kris
i'am so sad and so happy well sad because i miss sulli and vic and happy because my babies are working so hard
I just wanna say thank you for uploading this video. The f(3) here are amazing. Thanks again
Like the way they tweaked the choreography to keep f(3) front and center at all times. That must have been tricky for them, having to learn something almost but not quite what they're accustomed to doing.
Amber is so damn gorgeous
Luna and Krys
Woah. These 3 just nailed the performance.
Krystal ♡
This makes me sad u.u I hope víc omma gets well soon~ and well... If supposedly Sulli hasn't left Fx then she should have took one day off of her hiatus like they need you :( still F(3) was really amazing I love them so much...
Im so proud that f(3) performed without any mistake. Good jood Krystal Luna Amber. Love you, Krystal unnie
Dear SM, let's look at my girls. They are so talents. And damn, why you combulsori they wait for their FIRST OWN FANDOM AND CONCERT. it's 6years, too long.
Anyway, Im so happy to be your fan, always and forever.
Get well soon, Victoria. ^^ and Ssul,watch this vid and think of what you've done, you make me very very disappointed.
F(x) fighting, come back soon :>
f(3) in this performance did really good.
And the vocal line(Luna+Krystal)Rap(Amber)
Try their best. And the result of the performance was really amazing.!!!
I'm so proud of them.
f(x),fighting
No matter f(4) or f(5),they are always the best.
Fx always in my heart..keep fighting!
It's sad seeing Vic gone, can't wait to see her again. On a random side note, Luna's hair is great. Lmao
I'm surprised how well did krystal, usually always about to faint on stage or do not mind.
Claudia Vargas Well she is well rested now, she only faints when she's being overworked
f(3) still killed it
Atleast they added 2 more dancers so i have hope that f(5) is still real. I hope my girls shine brighter than the stars this year and more years later ;;
If only they were complete in this performance, this would be the badass perf ever in my life!! It feels awkward seeing them three filling up the empty spaces of Vic and Ssul. f(5) fighting~
Did you film any of f(x)'s other performances? :)
I feel sad while watching this :(
but I hope that we can still see f(5) on the stage again💪🏻
f(5) forever!!!!
Good job kristal,amber &luna. Krystal chu....... 😘😘😘😘
Hope vic get well soon and join fx back
¡Genial!! Hermoso hermoso :)
I just want f(x) to have a comeback now. I don't want Sulli leaving rumor to be true. I love f(x) and they are so underrated. People think that being under a big company gets special treatment, but not for f(x). I really wish f(x) would comeback as 5, if not 4 is fine too.
f3 with 2 cool dancers!!!
fantastic!!!
I miss f(x)!
Thanks to f(3) & the dancers, it's an amazing performance
*GetWellSoonVictoria
Back in the day, when an artist in a group was out, they wouldn't change much, just have a backup dancer with a mask on, take their "solo" parts with playback vocals from the original recording. I guess with two of them missing, you can't really do that. I think they did a great job adapting to it.
Is there video on UA-cam of a backup dancer covering for a idol
magicmike191v2 The only one I can think of at the moment is DBSK's first promotions of Rising Sun when it was 5 members. Jaejoong had injured his leg before promotions started and would have a backup dancer take his place on stage. In some instances the backup dancer (in a mask) would be there for everything, using a microphone to look like he was part of the group, "singing" with a backtrack that contained Jaejoong's voice in it, others, the backup dancer would be there to dance and Hero would just come on during his two solo parts and then walk off stage, and they have switched it so Changmin took his vocal roles while the backup dancer in the mask was just there to keep the same dance structure.
Someone can explain to me waht's up to Victoria? Why is she inactive??
They should've performed the songs that don't have either Sulli or Victoria in them, like Beautiful Stranger and Goodbye Summer. I love those songs
I hope I get to see the f(5) again .. But I really appreciate they still performed even though it was just the three of them but tbh I actually prefer this performance because (OO.. MAA. GAAD..) they were killing it💜💜 hope Victoria gets well soon and gets to perform with f(x) again ^_^ and I really hope that Sulli won't leave f(x)!!🙏
F(x) FIGHTING!!!
SOOOOOOOO MAY PART FOR OUR LLAMA... OH MY GOSH
all the comments about haters that bashing Victoria were irritated my feelings :'). She didn't leave f(x) for god's sake she's just feeling unwell :'). She's sick. Oh gosh... I don't want to reply hate comments on your post thou, i'm being calm but please, she didn't do anything that harm all of you :')
only 3 but A,L,K can rule the stage!!!
And Victoria?
F(3) working so hard. AMAZING F(x) fighting !!!
💜💜💜
where's vic omma? :(
SM tiene que ser serio con F(x) fans. Victoria ya tiene 28 y quiere trabajar en China mas q en Korea. Sulli tiene mas de un ano en hiatus y no quiere regresar. Vamos SM decidete, promueve a AMBER, KRYSTAL Y SULLI y hazle un comback pronto. En realidad Amber lider y 3 vocal, Krystal visual y 2 vocal, Luna main vocal.
i wonder who the mystery dancers with masks are? amber, luna, krystal slayed!
wow...hope they can perform together soon again, fighting f(X)
I hope krystal don't get sick again and fainted like before..
f(x) Slay 💕
Krys's voice sounds like Jessica so much
Really cool dance
it's sad that it's js f(3) BUT flawless performance as always. :3 HEY SM, Stop neglecting your groups.. =_= All yr groups are fabulous in their own way!
those 2 dancers are so good???!
really really thank to u .we miss f(x) too much ^^ f(x) slayed ^^
Vic快回來!Sulli已經不期待了⋯⋯😭
Good job girls
OMFG omg 😱😱😱😱😱 my llama just kill dayunmmmmm aaahhhh im gonna die 😍😍😍😍 kystal and luna too but my llama just aaaaaahhhhhhhhh 💕❤💕❤💓💓💓
Soy yo o esta Luna cada vez se esta poniendo más buena¿?
Explain to me what happened to Victoria?
It can not be !!
***** I wonder which member will f(x)/krystal fandom drive away next hmmm bet it's Luna
Even with 3 - F(x) still slays! Luna of course, my goddess of F(x) you are absolutely gorgeous :) And Sulli, you will never be forgotten!
OMG where is victoria!!
Is there a K pop girl group that DOESN'T using a voice recording in a supposedly LIVE performance?
Sophie Meeoun f(x) usually sings live, but most of the SMTOWN concert performances are pre-recorded for some reason. Most SM groups sing live at their own concerts and music shows now
OiiOreo Because if the performers don't sound absolutely perfect, the people paying admission complain, and start saying "oh they can't sing, why are they making so much money?" and stop going to concerts. SM needs people to go to concerts, that's their bread-and-butter, not CD's or other stuff...
Got it! Thanks for the explanations. I hope I didn't sound too snarky. I love the group but I'm always disappointed that their live concerts are mostly lip-syncing... I suppose who isn't these days? Lol. Thanks again!
And really, they are _always_ singing when they perform live, even with the "backing track" - of their own voices - it just varies from site to site and event to event what the balance between the microphone and the playback is, anywhere from 50/50 to 80/20 in each direction :)
2NE1 and MAMAMOO
Lunaaa!!!!!!!