This is my opinion: Lows - D3: Rihanna (much more solid and audible) Eb3: Rihanna (especially since she was pregnant, her lower register was all the more audible) E3: Tie (Sia's E3 was actually quite good) F3: Tie (ooh love Rihanna's low larynx on both F3s) G3: Sia G#3: Tie A3: Tie Belts - G#4: Sia (far more resonant) A4: Tie Bb4: Sia Bb4: Tie B4: Rihanna B4: Tie C5: Sia C5: Tie C5: Rihanna C#5: Tie C#5: Sia C#5: Sia D5: Tie D5: Sia D5: Rihanna (one of my favourite D5s EVER 😍😍😍) Eb5: Sia Eb5: Sia Eb5: Sia E5: Sia E5: Sia E5: Sia F5: Sia F5: Sia G5: Sia Upper Register - C5: Sia C#5: Sia D5: Sia E5: Tie F5: Sia F#5: Sia G5: Tie G#5: Tie Bb5: Sia B5: Sia C6: Rihanna Lows - Rihanna Belts - Sia Upper Register - Sia Sia wins!
I really like both singers! Rihanna in her vocal prime was sooo good omg🤩 Her vibrato is so underrated. Unfortunately after 2015 or so, she regressed vocally (especially when she is belting).
Why are people still wasting their time , saying that Rihanna is a better vocalist thanSia. Sia is and will always be a better vocalist than Rihanna. I'm not biased(I love Rihanna) , I'm just factual. Rihanna has a beautiful voice and so on. But Sia's vocal range is wider , more skilled and emotional. So Sia wins.
@addictedtovocals I understand. And I love the content btw. But some "special" people who place Rihanna over Sia , vocally , aren't it. I just can't 🤣🤣
@@aymenakabusiness631 dude, her midbelts is technically perfect for modern standart even she can outshine some sopranos outthere with her volume output. Not bad is an undertstatement
My opinion : Low notes : rihanna win Belts notes : tie Head voice : sia win You can do the best notes of adele on munich concerts , i think it’s the vicals here are the best above all the high notes like on set fire to the rain and when we were young and i’ll be waiting and all i ask …… and thank you
And its all wrong actually. Rihannas low notes are airy uncontrolled and Unsupported untill A3. Sia has support down to G#3 which gives her a win easily.Also she is less airy and her passagio is better. Belts:Rihanna is again worse than Sia.Rihannas belts tend to be screamy and light approached.Starting from Bb4 she is losing her support,but she has a good amount of support till B4. Sia on the other hand is a god of mid belts with no throat tension and high larynx up to C#5/D5,she also has a bright resonance.She takes the win easily. Head Voice:I dont think rihanna has that much of material in her head voice though she had some good F5's ill give it to her. Sia has a well supported, rounded and connected head voice up to C6 and higher.Idk about their head voices much but i dont like the technique of both.So they both will get it
@@vocalsbycyrus Her lowest note live (that I know of) is B2 in Wild Thoughts India, but it might be lower due to the audio quality. But in her most recent FENTY Beauty video, her speaking voice has consistently gone down to around G#2 - A2 (not vocal fry).
Before I do all the notes by notes thing can I just say yes to all the research and time you took to find all these notes no one knew they had. You ate that ❤️ D3 - Rihanna Eb3 - Sia E3 - Sia F3 - Sia F#3 - Rihanna (guessing Sia’s was copyright issues) G3 - Rihanna G#3 - Tie A3 - Rihanna G#4 - Sia A4 - Rihanna Bb4 - Rihanna Bb4 - Sia B4 - Rihanna B4 - Sia C5 - Rihanna C5 - Sia C5 - Sia C#5 - Sia C#5 - Rihanna C#5 - Sia (one of my fav songs of all time) D5 - Rihanna D5 - Sia D5 - Rihanna Eb5 - Sia Eb5 - Sia Eb5 - Sia E5 - Sia E5 - Rihanna F5 - Sia F5 - Rihanna F#5 - Rihanna G5 - Rihanna (surprised they both have that high live tbh) C5 - Rihanna C#5 - Rihanna D5 - Sia Eb5 - Rihanna E5 - Rihanna F5 - Sia F#5 - Sia G5 - Rihanna G#5 - Sia (Rihanna’s was a sharp G) A5 - Rihanna Bb5 - Sia B5 - Rihanna C6 - Sia
People are so biased in this comment section rihanna ate sia up, i love sia and she is great but when it comes to vocal and technique rihanna has edge rihanna has stronger lows, mids and head voice and agility also im kinda surprised by rihanna high notes here too you picked some great clips ❤❤ Ps : rihanna tone is gold no one can do impersonation of it (sia tone sometimes sounds annoying)
@@missfentybeauty Sia on the other hand, has a voice made to convey emotions, she doesn’t need technique. Her emotiveness, raw belting power and vocal range is what make her shine.
@@addictedtovocals yup as i said she is great and yeah like u said she sings with so much emotion but rih has characteristics in her voice too love them boths but we r talking about vocal battle so its always rihanna above her
@@aymenakabusiness631That is emotion. If you know what Chandelier was about , then you would feel her pain. Btw Chandelier is one of the hardest songs to sing
@@aymenakabusiness631 That's actually more raw and emotional. But you wouldn't understand. Because you don't know the ART , that is Sia. S-Sia I-Is A-Art
At 9:04 could you please tell me what song that was from Sia & what performance that was, because that alone won it for me. I wasn't ready. The power, the emotion, the control, the melisma, it was all on point and precise.
EDIT: SIA's A5 is NOT live.
I love both. But sia is somewhat higher in my list ❤
This is my opinion:
Lows -
D3: Rihanna (much more solid and audible)
Eb3: Rihanna (especially since she was pregnant, her lower register was all the more audible)
E3: Tie (Sia's E3 was actually quite good)
F3: Tie (ooh love Rihanna's low larynx on both F3s)
G3: Sia
G#3: Tie
A3: Tie
Belts -
G#4: Sia (far more resonant)
A4: Tie
Bb4: Sia
Bb4: Tie
B4: Rihanna
B4: Tie
C5: Sia
C5: Tie
C5: Rihanna
C#5: Tie
C#5: Sia
C#5: Sia
D5: Tie
D5: Sia
D5: Rihanna (one of my favourite D5s EVER 😍😍😍)
Eb5: Sia
Eb5: Sia
Eb5: Sia
E5: Sia
E5: Sia
E5: Sia
F5: Sia
F5: Sia
G5: Sia
Upper Register -
C5: Sia
C#5: Sia
D5: Sia
E5: Tie
F5: Sia
F#5: Sia
G5: Tie
G#5: Tie
Bb5: Sia
B5: Sia
C6: Rihanna
Lows - Rihanna
Belts - Sia
Upper Register - Sia
Sia wins!
Love Sia's Voice 💖💖
Sia's headvoices are so Angelic
Besides her headvoices her voice is so powerful....Sia is powerhouse❤❤❤❤
I really like both singers! Rihanna in her vocal prime was sooo good omg🤩 Her vibrato is so underrated. Unfortunately after 2015 or so, she regressed vocally (especially when she is belting).
Why are people still wasting their time , saying that Rihanna is a better vocalist thanSia. Sia is and will always be a better vocalist than Rihanna. I'm not biased(I love Rihanna) , I'm just factual. Rihanna has a beautiful voice and so on. But Sia's vocal range is wider , more skilled and emotional. So Sia wins.
@@NANYADAMBUZNIS we still make these because it’s content and that’s our job as vocal content creators. Facts remain the same although.
@addictedtovocals I understand. And I love the content btw. But some "special" people who place Rihanna over Sia , vocally , aren't it. I just can't 🤣🤣
Also remember, sia voice was destroyed by drugs, so one person whit that register is also something
@@JorikDz Couldn't have said it any better🙌❤️
Sia is so amazing
Oh wow rihanna is really not that bad vocally damn
Yea I didn’t know she could hit half these notes I was very impressed!
@@aymenakabusiness631 dude, her midbelts is technically perfect for modern standart even she can outshine some sopranos outthere with her volume output. Not bad is an undertstatement
Sia wins
My opinion :
Low notes : rihanna win
Belts notes : tie
Head voice : sia win
You can do the best notes of adele on munich concerts , i think it’s the vicals here are the best above all the high notes like on set fire to the rain and when we were young and i’ll be waiting and all i ask …… and thank you
And its all wrong actually.
Rihannas low notes are airy uncontrolled and Unsupported untill A3.
Sia has support down to G#3 which gives her a win easily.Also she is less airy and her passagio is better.
Belts:Rihanna is again worse than Sia.Rihannas belts tend to be screamy and light approached.Starting from Bb4 she is losing her support,but she has a good amount of support till B4.
Sia on the other hand is a god of mid belts with no throat tension and high larynx up to C#5/D5,she also has a bright resonance.She takes the win easily.
Head Voice:I dont think rihanna has that much of material in her head voice though she had some good F5's ill give it to her.
Sia has a well supported, rounded and connected head voice up to C6 and higher.Idk about their head voices much but i dont like the technique of both.So they both will get it
@@GarikArakelyan-ne3pv Factual
My opinion
Lows: Rihanna>>>> Sia
Belt/Chest Notes: Tie
Head voice/Falsetto: You choose
Actually they voice sound pretty similar sometimes.
❤
Sia >>>
sia>>>
Rihanna Lows are so much better😍 in new lives she has a lot of G#2s... but the way they two belt is not healthy.
Link to G#2?
@@vocalsbycyrus when she sing Wild Thoughts in India 2024. The video was block on UA-cam
@@vocalsbycyrus Her lowest note live (that I know of) is B2 in Wild Thoughts India, but it might be lower due to the audio quality.
But in her most recent FENTY Beauty video, her speaking voice has consistently gone down to around G#2 - A2 (not vocal fry).
no battle here, Sia is a vocalist, Rihanna is not.
@@lovers_cult debatable, Sia’s a vocalist, but Rihanna is a vocalist too, just not on the big picture.
Before I do all the notes by notes thing can I just say yes to all the research and time you took to find all these notes no one knew they had. You ate that ❤️
D3 - Rihanna
Eb3 - Sia
E3 - Sia
F3 - Sia
F#3 - Rihanna (guessing Sia’s was copyright issues)
G3 - Rihanna
G#3 - Tie
A3 - Rihanna
G#4 - Sia
A4 - Rihanna
Bb4 - Rihanna
Bb4 - Sia
B4 - Rihanna
B4 - Sia
C5 - Rihanna
C5 - Sia
C5 - Sia
C#5 - Sia
C#5 - Rihanna
C#5 - Sia (one of my fav songs of all time)
D5 - Rihanna
D5 - Sia
D5 - Rihanna
Eb5 - Sia
Eb5 - Sia
Eb5 - Sia
E5 - Sia
E5 - Rihanna
F5 - Sia
F5 - Rihanna
F#5 - Rihanna
G5 - Rihanna (surprised they both have that high live tbh)
C5 - Rihanna
C#5 - Rihanna
D5 - Sia
Eb5 - Rihanna
E5 - Rihanna
F5 - Sia
F#5 - Sia
G5 - Rihanna
G#5 - Sia (Rihanna’s was a sharp G)
A5 - Rihanna
Bb5 - Sia
B5 - Rihanna
C6 - Sia
TYSM!!!
@@vocalsbycyrus ty🫶
I have no problem with your rating. But that C5 and C#5 was definitely in Sia's favor
That G5 and B5 is also in Sia's favor. That B5 is heavenly
And to show that I'm not biased. That C6 from Rihanna was better
People are so biased in this comment section rihanna ate sia up, i love sia and she is great but when it comes to vocal and technique rihanna has edge rihanna has stronger lows, mids and head voice and agility also im kinda surprised by rihanna high notes here too you picked some great clips ❤❤
Ps : rihanna tone is gold no one can do impersonation of it (sia tone sometimes sounds annoying)
@@missfentybeauty Sia on the other hand, has a voice made to convey emotions, she doesn’t need technique. Her emotiveness, raw belting power and vocal range is what make her shine.
@@addictedtovocals yup as i said she is great and yeah like u said she sings with so much emotion but rih has characteristics in her voice too love them boths but we r talking about vocal battle so its always rihanna above her
Sia 👑
It irritares me so much that you were just too lazy to search properly Sia’s vocals 🙄
Sia
Sia ❤
I thought it will be easy to choose the better signer, but it is really really hard, both of them are very good 👏👏
SIA
Sia 👑
Rihanna is a better belter
In your dreams😂😂
@@Zeth-x8q I agree, but Sia has more vulnerability and emotion in her belts. Technique wise Rihanna wins, but Sia wins for rawness and power
@@addictedtovocals definetly
LOL
Lol what's up with sia cracks i thought she's a skilled singer
@@aymenakabusiness631 Sia’s cracks are for emotion. She does that a lot and she actually has a lot of skill with it
@@addictedtovocals well the one on your F5 clip surely wasn't intentional girlie was hurt
@@aymenakabusiness631That is emotion. If you know what Chandelier was about , then you would feel her pain. Btw Chandelier is one of the hardest songs to sing
@@NANYADAMBUZNIS lol that performance shows she's that struggling unlike her other performances wih her beautiful intentional breals
@@aymenakabusiness631 That's actually more raw and emotional. But you wouldn't understand. Because you don't know the ART , that is Sia.
S-Sia
I-Is
A-Art
Why I thought Faouzia was Rihanna in the thumbnail😭
mommy
Rihanna's C6s are actually B5s
Nope, she went sharp on the ones that were labelled and hit C6. Hence why I didn't label one of the B5s because it was on pitch.
6:54 tell me what sia song?
Breathe me
@@gardapamungkas5583 Breathe Me
At 9:04 could you please tell me what song that was from Sia & what performance that was, because that alone won it for me. I wasn't ready. The power, the emotion, the control, the melisma, it was all on point and precise.
lentil