No other girl groups can touch pink tape, red light and 4 walls album. The most remarkable album in KPOP. If anyone will not agree to me then it's time to tell you, without these albums your Idol will not exist in KPOP
I was crying over this beautiful stage and all the memories then I realized what Victoria’s shirt said lmaooo 😭 Even when I’m emotional, f(x) finds a way to make me smile. I love you guys!! ❤
Honestly, I do not find it elegant. It looks really lazy/uncaring personally. Sulli defenders will likely say that I am a "hater" but I think any outsider/casual fan would likely say the same if unbias.
Everything about this performance is magic, the setting, the choreo, the live vocals, THE SONG. I come back from time to time to remember why i fell in love with K-pop in the first place. We don't see magic like this very often now😢
Am I the only one that got quite emotional here..? i really like Fx but I've never been a SUPER fan but this.. I dont know it just made me wanna cry ..the song, the glitters or whatever is it that was falling , the dance .. literally the whole thing made me wanna cry .. Ah, no matter how many girls group there are out there FX definitely stand out. I dont think SM realise what they made.
All of you hating on Sulli, I would say put yourself in her shoes but I have no idea what goes on in her life besides the fact that she sings, dances, acts, and is the visual of the group. SHE HAS A LOT OF STUFF ON HER MIND GUYS. She needs to Practice singing, then practice dancing, then she has all her dramas and then has so many advertisements, commercials, and a bunch of CF's. And I know all of you use the comeback "Oh well she put herself into this situation." I'm sure she understands that! I don't think it's that she just "doesn't care anymore." I just think shes exhausted because of her overbooked schedule and her overworked and underrested body. Please give Sulli a break. Some say "The band would be just as good or even better with out Sulli she gives nothing toward the group." I honestly think Sulli's voice in this song is amazing and without her voice in future albums(if she were to leave.) I would honestly really miss it. You guys do know that f(x) isn't just like every other Girl Group right? They act like a family. They ARE a family! They call Vic "Omma" and Vic calls the rest of the members her babies. You know that Sulli, Soojung, and Amber are really good friends! Not only just them 3 but all 5 of them have an amazing bond that not every girl/boy band creates. I honestly do think that a lot would change if Sulli were to leave. Not just the performances, but the fact that the rest of f(x) members would dearly miss their 2nd maknae(after Krystal.) And knowing Sment they would probably replace Sulli with another singer/rookie and that would be really hard for f(x) to deal with. Losing one of their close members/friend/and most of all a close loved one part of their family. You guys have to realize that hating on Sulli isn't just hurting her but it's hurting f(x) as a whole. And not only that but Sulli's fans are getting hurt too because of all the hate Sulli is getting. And seeing their role model slowly get more more exhausted honestly hurts. I know this because it's hurting me. Please just rethink before you guys make a million articles on how Sulli is "emotionless' and maybe be more worried about it because you never know, That old smile everyone misses on stage could've been fake all these years and after hiding all of her emotions she finally decided not to hide them anymore. Thanks for your time.
great performance! love this! so glad they're all smiling now :) and Vic is singing! She has more lines too! ahhh!! so nice. such a sweet voice she has ^^ one of my favorites from their album!
I remember having chills when watching this performance for the first time. So thoughtful of them to change the lyrics in memory of those who suffered from that dreadful accident.
![[F (x)]] red light red light @ popular Inkigayo 140713](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vdnB00ogSD0/mqdefault.jpg)
이 노래만 들으면 그때의 에프엑스와 어렸던 옛날의 내가 생각나서 울컥함
고2때 였는데 아련하다 ㅜ
@@유현-s9zawww 😢
캬 이거도 진짜 띵곡이다...에어플레인, 러브, 컴윗미? 이부분 뭔가...뭔가 아련함
에어플레인 좋아하는 곡이라서 "어? 무대에서 부른게 있네"하고 봤는데 예상치도 못한 곳에서 설리 레전드 봐버림 ㄷㄷ 진짜 천상천하유아독존이네 ㅋㅋㅋ 존예다
NAVITIMOR THE 엌ㅋㅋㅋ 노래들르어로았는데 보자마자 설리봄 .. 이쁜건 핵인정 진짜
One of the best albums in kpop history, I'm willing to fight anyone who says it's not. Miss you Sulli, you'll always be my favorite peach.
"Willing to fight", like enforcing your opinion on people? What will you do, Caps Lock them to death? LMAO
No other girl groups can touch pink tape, red light and 4 walls album. The most remarkable album in KPOP. If anyone will not agree to me then it's time to tell you, without these albums your Idol will not exist in KPOP
와 설리진짜 예쁘구나......설리 호감도 아니였고 지금 까지 설리예쁘단말들을때마다 나는 공감못했는데 42초보고 단박에 이해했어.....말이안나온다.......예쁘다 아니 청초하다
근데 춤은 대충추는듯
박수아 ㅇㅈㅇㅈ
박수아 설리가 최고지
Christoper Dumdom 설리가 최고지
뭔가 이쁜데 춤을 느슨하게 춰서 뭐가 진짜 몽환적 분위기 대박적...
Who's listening to this in 2024?
mee
나ㅜㅜ
💜
🤍🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽
Meee
몇년전 영상인데... 설리 옷이랑 머리 화장 촌스럽지가않다... 하늘위로 훨훨 날아가서 너가 좋아하는 곳에 여행다니면서 살길바래
갓띵곡 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이때 아시아나인가 사고 있어서 바꿔 불렀었는데 마음씨도 참 예뻐... ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
이 노래 진짜 개좋음ㅠㅠㅠ 비오는 날 들어도 바로 푸른 하늘 밑에 있는 느낌을 받을 수 있는 찐명곡ㅠㅠㅠ
이 앨범으로 컴백하기 한달 전에 아시아나 추락 사고 있어서 가사 바꿔 부름
루나 파트 추락 -> 착륙
설리 파트 falling -> feeling
샤이니가 좋아하는 노래ㅋㅋㅋ 어제 올라온 리얼리티에서 봤는데 추천 영상에 이게 뜨네요 신기하다ㅋㅋ
라 라 오 저두요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그러고보니 샤이니 노래랑 느낌이 비슷하네요
10년이 지났어도 여전히 세련됀 노래 🎵 🎶
앨범의 수록곡들은 버릴게 없어요
하.. ㅠ 이것도 알고보면 명곡이였는데....
그냥듣자마자 띵곡임
언제들어도 좋다
ㅇㅈ
생각나서 보러 왔는데 넘 그리울 거 같다...
krystal's smile at 2:08 is priceless
I know, she looks so much like her sister there! ^^
SHINee loOver maybe it was because she starts dating kay! :)
Moody She wasn't even dating Kai during this.......
Irwin T. we don't know! it's her life. She may just smile because she enjoy this song x)
I couldn't help smiling as well.. she's too cute!
내 마음속 영원한..최고의 무대...
이거 군대생활관에서 라이브로 봤었지.
처음듣는 곡인데 너무좋아서 전역한지 5년이 지나도 듣는중ㅎㅎ
I was crying over this beautiful stage and all the memories then I realized what Victoria’s shirt said lmaooo 😭 Even when I’m emotional, f(x) finds a way to make me smile. I love you guys!! ❤
I'm having one of those aff(x)tionate moments when I can only cry to how perfect they are... Oh my f(x)! TTvTT
Diana Laura love u fx ❤❤❤❤😍😍😍😍😘😘😘🤩🤩🤩
2:09 Jung Soojung so cute
7 years later this is still a bop
9 years later…😢
@@MM-ex5kz 10 years later
Almost 11 years later
F(x) sings so well live ;w;
Throwback to the days when K-Pop groups STILL sang live, unlike groups these days ://
Throwback to Second Generation when groups sung live
i love the way luna smile at singing
luna's smile is one of the most beautiful and genuine i have ever seen. she's absolutely gorgeous ;~;
I feel sorry for Amber. It must be exhausting to be that awesome *all the time*.
She rules.
Ikr
이때 앨범 타이틀부터 수록곡까지 다 너무 좋아서 여름부터 다음년도 봄까지 들음 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
I love the way Sulli dances... Looks so elegant lol
And Now shes dead...rip 😖😭😢😢😷😷😷
xXyumi _u_w_u oh shut up
Honestly, I do not find it elegant. It looks really lazy/uncaring personally. Sulli defenders will likely say that I am a "hater" but I think any outsider/casual fan would likely say the same if unbias.
@@Batman1084CK oh yea? Good for you
@@darkedangel Good to know you're just another person in the world who can't hear something they disagree with. :) But yes, "good for me."
언니들 보고싶을때마다 온다
Luna's smile is adorable and I'm so glad she got a good amount of parts in this song :)
핑크테이프 앨범 명반이지,, 알고리즘 떠서 오랜만에 듣네
지금들어도 띵곡이다 ㅠ
its been more than 10 years and im still here.
I would have preferred f(x) using this as a title track
I feel so melancholic watching this
슬프다
그 때 그 시절도
지나간 그 시간도
Omg!!! Yay Victoria got more lines!!! She's so gorgeous and sang so well! I love her ♡♡♡
지금 들어도 세련됐음 ㄹㅇ
그때는 몰랐는데, 지금 가사를 다시 보니 이 곡 자체가 fx지 싶다...
OMG Krystal is so beautiful.
She looks so happy at the end
Miss all of them. F(x)'s music is amazing. This whole album is the best.
this song fills me with nostalgia - that sudden feeling of nostalgia when you're out during the golden hour during late summer afternoons.
너무 띵곡이라 가끔 생각날때마다 성지순례온다구…🫶🏻
이 당시의 걸그룹 노래는 아련해서 눈물날거같은데 미치도록 신난 노래 많았는데 그립당
Luna's hair style and look is so simple but it looks so amazing.
설리 진짜 개이쁘다
Victoria's hair was so pretty!!
her shirt too XD
This song gives me such catharsis. The epitome of kpop. I love Pink Tape, I love f(x)
언젠가 꼭 다시 이 노래를 들었을때와 같이 행동할 수 있기를 ..
지금 들어도 참 세련된노래..설리 이때 진짜 엄청 이뻣네요..보고싶습니다 천국에서 행복하길..
Airplane is all you need to know about f(x), doing what no one else is in KPop.
Everything about this performance is magic, the setting, the choreo, the live vocals, THE SONG. I come back from time to time to remember why i fell in love with K-pop in the first place. We don't see magic like this very often now😢
waaaaaaaaah!!! goosebumps when sulli sings with an angelic voice!!! love her!!! Love f(x)
:)
luna’s stable vocals are amazing
이거진짜 명곡ㅠ
Am I the only one that got quite emotional here..? i really like Fx but I've never been a SUPER fan but this.. I dont know it just made me wanna cry ..the song, the glitters or whatever is it that was falling , the dance .. literally the whole thing made me wanna cry .. Ah, no matter how many girls group there are out there FX definitely stand out. I dont think SM realise what they made.
좋아했던 추억들 아직도 현재진행형
Can we appreciate Luna's dancing? Like her isolations in this are like 💯
Among all kpop groups, f(x) have the best stages! I mean, they sound really good, the dance is perfectly synced, and they have such a charisma!
Krystal has been looking and sounding like Sica so much lately! I love this song its pretty and the dance is nice
내가 엠카 에어플레인 사랑하는 이유 수천가지... 하 함수니들 사랑해
love sulli voice so sweet..n luna is amazing
All of you hating on Sulli, I would say put yourself in her shoes but I have no idea what goes on in her life besides the fact that she sings, dances, acts, and is the visual of the group. SHE HAS A LOT OF STUFF ON HER MIND GUYS. She needs to Practice singing, then practice dancing, then she has all her dramas and then has so many advertisements, commercials, and a bunch of CF's. And I know all of you use the comeback "Oh well she put herself into this situation." I'm sure she understands that! I don't think it's that she just "doesn't care anymore." I just think shes exhausted because of her overbooked schedule and her overworked and underrested body. Please give Sulli a break. Some say "The band would be just as good or even better with out Sulli she gives nothing toward the group." I honestly think Sulli's voice in this song is amazing and without her voice in future albums(if she were to leave.) I would honestly really miss it. You guys do know that f(x) isn't just like every other Girl Group right? They act like a family. They ARE a family! They call Vic "Omma" and Vic calls the rest of the members her babies. You know that Sulli, Soojung, and Amber are really good friends! Not only just them 3 but all 5 of them have an amazing bond that not every girl/boy band creates. I honestly do think that a lot would change if Sulli were to leave. Not just the performances, but the fact that the rest of f(x) members would dearly miss their 2nd maknae(after Krystal.) And knowing Sment they would probably replace Sulli with another singer/rookie and that would be really hard for f(x) to deal with. Losing one of their close members/friend/and most of all a close loved one part of their family. You guys have to realize that hating on Sulli isn't just hurting her but it's hurting f(x) as a whole. And not only that but Sulli's fans are getting hurt too because of all the hate Sulli is getting. And seeing their role model slowly get more more exhausted honestly hurts. I know this because it's hurting me. Please just rethink before you guys make a million articles on how Sulli is "emotionless' and maybe be more worried about it because you never know, That old smile everyone misses on stage could've been fake all these years and after hiding all of her emotions she finally decided not to hide them anymore. Thanks for your time.
I like her no matter what :) Sulli
That's why Sulli is my bias..I have a ton of respect for her.
EXACTLY god
Xiuchen and sulli really left. I miss her so freakin much
When I miss Sulli so much. :(
If they release this song in 2019 or 2020 it would still be a bop and maybb even more success. F(x) is really ahead of their time.
가사가 더 인상깊다. 아차하면 떨어지고 있었을 너에게, 위태로운 여정에 손을 내밀어주지 못해 미안해 설리야. 이때의 너는 떠오르고 있었을까
I just love how Luna feels the song, she smiles and sings so happily, also she dances perfectly
아 저 후렴구만 되면 저시절 추억도 떠오름 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
여기서 설리 진짜 예쁘다... 말도안되게
This is one of their best b-sides!
Sulli is so perfect. I love f(x)!
이제는 아픔없는 곳에서 편히 쉬세요 ㅠㅠ
still one of b-side that I like and love
this stage is my favorite, and i will always miss you .
This song is so captivating.. makes you wanna listen to it more. Great choreography too! f(x) jjang! ♥
krystal looks gorgeous
One of my favourite b-side track in this Album😊
이무대 더 보고싶다ㅠㅠ
Victoria: 0:52, 1:30, 1:42.
Amber: 1:13, 1:44.
Luna: 0:08, 0:13, 1:20, 1:51.
Sulli: 0:04, 0:43, 1:36.
Krystal: 0:06, 0:28, 1:05, 2:07.
I really wish they'd sing the entire song live :) Luna
한국 100대 명반임거 보고 앨범 다 돌렸었는데 이곡이 제일 쩔어줬어요..
I’m Japanese.
I like this song.
I like f(x).
I like K-POP.
이 때 에프엑스 진짜 좋아했는데ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 돌아가고싶다
0:03 how beautiful 😭❣️
why they keeping skipping half of the song, that's not the full version.. I wanted to hear ambers part.
At least we get to hear her "you you you" part :)
Kailee Broadway it could be worse, for nugu groups even their title tracks get cut :/
great performance! love this! so glad they're all smiling now :) and Vic is singing! She has more lines too! ahhh!! so nice. such a sweet voice she has ^^ one of my favorites from their album!
OMG sulli voice so sweet sulliah
Luna so pretty omg
설리는 매 순간이 레전드
Luna so cuteee!!
No....all f(x) are cuteee >
f(x) my loves.
설리 너무 이쁘다.
아직도 듣는다
luna and krystal look sooooo goood with their hair. and this song is very beautiful. make me feel energised to start my monday tomorrow
요즘에 내가 좋아하는 노래 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
i want them to preform step or kick as well.. who am i kidding i want them to preform every song this album is f(lawless)
I remember having chills when watching this performance for the first time. So thoughtful of them to change the lyrics in memory of those who suffered from that dreadful accident.
I love Luna's new hair color and her eye makeup makes her look like a doll :) Really pretty unnie
Victoria has beautiful voice!
and a beautiful shirt
I miss them. SM please give F(X) comeback 💔😭
Sulli looks pretty when they are dancing in Sulli's part. She looks like a DOLL.... I Really Love Her.