I really commend you on your stance with the ethics of insta360 and everything that you did. I know that that wasn't an easy decision and insta360 does make some decent cameras but me personally I stay away from for the same exact reason. It's just not good for us. I did want to get a hold of an ace Pro 2. To compare it with the DJI pocket. 3. And then I found out that you can't buy them on Amazon. You can't buy them at Best Buy. They never released it to any big box stores and I found out that the return policy stated that had to be within 15 days and you couldn't take it out of the box and the fact that you still can't get it at any big box stores seems a little sketchy to me
Gotta say the stabilization on AP2 really shines in low light... GP tends to get a bit jittery when the lighting isn’t great, but AP2 stays stable and clear
I'll give Insta360 credit where it's due, their highlight control in low light is impressive. It balances bright streetlights and headlights really well without losing too much detail in the dark. One of those features you don't notice until you need it
From all the videos i’ve seen, Go Pro has by far the best colors and quality in good lighting. The Ace Pro 2 has the best low light. The Action 5 pro is decent middle ground that looks more ‘digital’ than go pro in good lighting and can handle low light. I wish Go Pro could do low light, it’d be near perfect then. It has the best magnetic mounting system now and built in gps. Hoping their next camera has a larger sensor, 4:2:2 10 bit, and higher bitrate.
are you serious? I show how crappy the dynamic range of the AP2 is compared to the other ones lol. it is terrible unless you shoot in the HDR mode which then look very artificial
Agreed. AP2 and GP13 seem to handle highlights and shadows better, esp the snow's texture and contrast in darker areas. 06:47 I hate to say it but OA5 appears to lose some detail... The image feels a bit flat and fake...
It’s funny how he talks like the action 5 doesn’t have HDR turned on indefinitely. Lol. I can only imagine how muddy the image will become once a toggle is added to turn it off. It’s on by default. I guess biases will keep you blind.
In terms of color science and contrast GoPro 13 is in another league. The others 2 don't come even close in this field. However, I do think Action 5 Pro is much better to use indoors due to its higher dynamic range and less warping of the edges.
I wonder if the color science for Action 5 in the snow, trees, and distant mountains could be sharper and stand out from each other to achieve results comparable to other cameras. I'm not a fan of the Action 5's blue tones and HDR look.
I'm not a face shooter so I prefer the Ace Pro 2 image. Landscape image colors look fine to me especially clouds. The flip screen convenience alone for my style of shooting(point and shoot straight out of camera, hiking, boating and travel) is the winning feature and the zoom on the Ace Pro 2 is outstanding. Always value your reviews 🙂
@@AbelVlogsRD Gopro performs phenomenally well in bright snow conditions in many ways than the other cameras. However, you should see comparisons from other content creators in different variety of conditions depending on the surrounding landscapes and environment. I would suggest the GoPro for snow sports if that's your priority, however, their sensor is outdated producing a darker image, narrower field of view, and higher distortion. Non of the cameras are perfect.
@@AbelVlogsRD that’s what I said exactly on my comment. But hey, if they send you a paycheck, no matter how muddy the image is, it will look clear as day. Lol.
Close focus is bad on the ace pro 2? 2:02 I can read your beany brand on both the gopro and ace pro 2 but not on the oa5. So it’s in focus and action 5 isnt? Less detail? 3:43 i can see tire tracks on both ace pro 2 and gopro, as there is almost none on the action 5. Same goes for the background. I see details for both gopro and ace pro 2 and almost none existent on the action 5 pro. Also for this to be fair, both gopro and ace pro 2 has to be on HDR, cause the action 5 pro has this turned on indefinitely. Also, I really do believe the ace pro 2 is on a different color profile and not the normal color profile. Of all the videos I’ve watched, and I watched a ton of them. None had that sky color on the normal color profile. That’s way too blue.
I show HDR on and off examples with the ace pro 2 and it's not so much close focus issues (which it does have) as it is over sharpened look no matter the sharpness settings and this was all filmed in normal color on the cameras
So pleased with your review Jake as I am tired of all the negative reviews about GoPro it’s like everyone wants to see them fail. I’m very much an amateur photographer but in my eyes the image on GoPros are just more pleasing to the eye. Not only that but as someone who doesn’t want to spend too much time on colour grading, for me it looks great straight out of the camera. What so many people don’t accept is that an action camera is built for action in predominantly bright conditions. They are not designed to replace a video camera or stills camera or to perform well in low light. Use action cameras for ACTION and accept their limitations.
Exactly right. I have been critical of GoPro in the past when they made dumb design choices or had problematic software but their image quality is still excellent
Looking at the difference at 1:33 and 4:25 I don't think you're using the same color among the 3, the ace pro 2 is clearly using a different color profile. I am sorry but this does not look like a fair comparison
Hello, thank you for this helpful video. I considered the Action 5 Pro for POV skiing videos, as sharpness and clarity in snow footage are crucial for capturing a broader perspective of the surrounding landscapes and environment. However, I wasn’t entirely impressed with the Action 5 Pro's clarity and sharpness in expansive scenes like mountains and snow, as the footage often has a blueish tint and struggles with rougher textures, especially over larger ranges. I wanted to ask if you’ve noticed a loss of detail with Action 5 on certain textures during the recording. While some suggest the Action 5 Pro appears oversharpened, I find it lacks clarity and depth on rough surfaces like gravel, snow, concrete roads, structures, and even vegetation, whereas other cameras seem to preserve sharper detail, especially in snow, maintaining the realistic snow tone color. Do you think these issues, such as the blueish tint and lack of depth, can be fixed through settings adjustments, color grading, or a firmware update to enhance clarity and improve texture highlights? My priority is the best image quality for snow and mountain ranges similar to your footage in Alaska.
@@JakeSloan Pardon my persistence with these questions. I mainly wanted to ask if there’s potential for the Action 5 Pro to achieve results comparable to other cameras by adjusting sharpness and color grading to enhance clarity and improve texture highlights in expansive scenes like mountains and snow. Please share your insight and experience about this camera Action 5.
You should've paid good attention to the details in this video. You can see that the GoPro has by far the best clarity and contrast when you look at the mountains/trees in the background. For me it's a no brainer that in good lighting condition the other 2 cameras don't come even close to the GoPro.
@@gabrielavastye7208 Gopro performs phenomenally well in bright snow conditions in many ways than the other cameras. However, you should see comparisons from other content creators in different variety of conditions depending on the surrounding landscapes and environment. GoPro might be a great option for snow sports in capturing detail if that's the priority, however, their sensor is outdated producing a darker image, narrower field of view, and higher distortion. None of the cameras are perfect. that's just my opinion and the primary reason why I'm interested in the action 5.
@@Untied_Shoelace agreed. I think that different cameras perform differently in different environments. For example I’m an fpv pilot and would use the GoPro for daylight outdoor shooting. For indoor fpv I’d always use the action 5 due to its better lowlight performance and dynamic range. Also less warping of the edges when you pan on the action 5 compared to the GoPro
Here’s my take: Since I’m using the GP10, my options are to either upgrade to the GP12 (to save on battery costs) or choose between the GP13 and the OA5-AP2 is off the table for me now. We’ll be filming outdoor adventures in Alaska all winter, including overnight tent camping and stays in public-use cabins. Come spring, we’re heading to Southeast Asia for a few weeks to explore day and night street food markets. I was hoping the GP would be the obvious choice, but since I’ll need to buy new batteries anyway, the OA5 is becoming a serious contender.
I had gopro 10 before and it would not record longer than around 30 minutes in -10c while my Action 3 (back then) would record for an hour with still a lot of battery left.
there is also one thing which I can see - pink'ish skin tones from both Action and Insta. Gopro colours are more neutral. Sure you can take a bit of the tint off in the postprocessing but it won't sort the issue 100%
Greetings from Belarus. Bought DJI Action 5. Bigger sensor = less noise. I finished with GoPro on the sixth version. 13 GoPro looks decent, but the sensor is small. For those who shoot their face, this is a decisive factor, but there is Pocket 3 for such purposes. Thanks for the comparison.
Great Video and very helpful. I will buy a new action cam and i think i will go for the dji action 5. had many gopro and it's time for a switch. i enjoyed your 1:1 comparison. looking for focus i think the action 5 is not bad at short distance but does it have some issues with long distance? at 7:03 or 7:30 there is not much detail or how do you rate this? it looked better (for me) in your comparison video between GP13 and DA5Pro
The action 5 has a lot of flexibility in the footage to edit it how you like for contrast and colors. This was in normal mode but if you film and set it to expose at -0.3 you will get more detail in the highlights like what you see in the background behind me
Jake, thank you for the great video and detailed comparison! At mark 2:57, the GoPro’s clarity is incredible you can even see the details in your facial hairs, which really shows its sharpness. I was curious about the Insta360’s performance during the day shot in the snow, why does it look so washed out compared to the others? The wrinkles around your eyes also stand out prominently with the GoPro, which highlights its ability to capture fine details. The low-light test was what I was most curious about, and you answered all my questions perfectly-thank you for that!
Thanks much Jake. I ordered the Action 5. The background in the GoPro footage looked detailed but also over sharpened. I like the size and utility of the Action 5.
What do you think about these action cameras? while each one does have their strengths I definitely feel like the weakest overall is the Insta360 Ace Pro 2...
Thanks for the video Jake. Please pin your comment (click three dots, then 'pin comment') so your 'author' comment doesn't get buried in all the comments, it'll keep it at the top for everyone to see. Keep up the good work!
I have fogging issue on my ace pro 2 i use it as a motovlov and my speed is only 30-kmph normal days I'm from Philippines. Video recording 2.7k frms video duration less than an hour every time the camera heat and there's a wind only mild wind the lens has fog. What should i do?
Good fair review. I've had GoPro's for many years, and tried the Action 3, but still favor the GoPro despite the lower battery time. One thing I think would be a good test review is to do some multicam videos and compare how GoPro sync vs Action's 5 sync would work out in the real world if using 3+ cameras. I've also installed the GoProLabs firmware for multicam LTC syncing. If your outdoors, the GPS sync is another option, but I found inconsistent. The easiest way to sync multiple GoPro's is using the QRcode with the QRControl app, which makes post-production much faster.
Hey Jake, been watching your videos since I bought an Action 5 pro, very helpful stuff especially on extreme scenarios that I can't test myself. I did test it out riding my motorcycle and it did not disappoint. Love from the Philippines!
Question, Jake; did you have the Action 5 in high bit mode? I’m curious because there is virtually no detail in the snow or mountains behind you on the Action 5.
yes but the lack of detail is more due to the camera exposing for the face not the overall image, that detail can be recovered in post with some basic adjustments or using D-log M
Very nice real world comparison. I just bought the Hero 13 and I think I made the right choice, given that I rarely shoot in low light. It's no surprise that Action5 and Ace Pro 2 struggle focusing at close distance, since they both have a large sensor. Large sensor makes it impossibile to focus at close distance, - it's just optics, there's no way around it - but helps a lot with low light performance. So... it depends on what you want to prioritize. With good light the Gopro looks great (color riproduction/sharpness/contrast) and that's what I I want the most.
I do think you're being honest but I have a similar but different take. I'm just about to finalize a very detailed comparison between the Ace Pro 2 and the action 5 and I'd be curious to discuss further. I'm 100% non-sponsored and I'm just looking to seek the truth.
@JakeSloan it's a tough decision and side by side comparisons are time consuming summing to edit and make an honest, definitive general recommendation. I had 11 categories and they tied in two so it's head to head in that regard.
Man this was helpful. I was all in on the AcePro2 because of low light but seeing the images its clear the GoPro is the look I want. And telling me about the lack of 10-bit was huge. Thanks. Great review.
Jake, I've watched a ton of videos on these cameras. I also purchased all three and have struggled to frame how they all compare to crown a winner. Need something for a wide range of uses. While I really love the screen on the Ace Pro 2 the images from the Action 5 Pro are also looking better overall. So NICE job and BEST I've seen for a round-up of all three. Stay warm. -JB
Love your videos!! I'm curious to know, out of the GoPro & Action 5, which camera looks more closer to what you actually see with your eyes. You mentioned your jacket looked more natural with the Action 5. But how about the sky and the color of the snow? Btw, is it me or did the Action 5 have a lot less detail in the snow? Is that something that could be fixed if shooting in D Log M instead? Thanks for your work!
AMAZING VIDEO! It made me subscribe! i got the Action 5 yesterday. ¿Do you think you can do a high bitrate + color graded 10bit+ -0.3ev stops to see if it can retain better detail on the snow behind you? I´m just really wondering why it looks so much better contrast and detail on the gopro.
yes if you expose -0.3 or even -0.7 in conditions like these you will get better detail as well as when you shoot in D-log M the HDR look goes away which also helps
Hmmm... agree about the focus on your face from the AP2, but look at 4:25 and look how bland the background is on the OA5. The GoPro and AP2 have so much more detail on the mountain, snow, etc. I just think the OA5 does a better job on the vlogger but a worse job on backgrounds (not enough contrast or sharpness = very bland).
This is the best comparision I have seen and I totally agree (not sponsored by AcePro, miracle!). The best details and colors are for GoPro (here, in Spain, is a sunny country so... GoPro wins). In low light conditions I use my DJI Osmo Pocket 3 (I watch glittering at night in all actions cameras). I like ski and diving.... Ski at night, surf at night, BMX at night...???? It looks ridiculous to me. Action cameras are made for action sports.... in the daytime! P.D. I have watched your video in a PHILLIPS OLED 65 inches... it is easier to see the details. Congratulations!
Personally, looks to me the images on: -DJI Action 5 Pro is well balanced camera. - GoPro looks the best as long there is light. - Insta360 Ace Pro just not on par, but it has an attractive punch.
I need one for skiing but don’t want to deal with go pro powering off from the coldness and I don’t like dji. Think I might have to get insta 360 what do you thing? How cold can the go pro get?
Nice comparison. For someone who wants to get one for things like family vlogging which would you recommend? I want something with a simple interface since I need to learn more about the editing process.
I wish I could find this solid of a comparison based around using them for scuba diving. I wasn't happy with my GoPro12 in some instances while diving, I'm assuming due to lack of light. Really having trouble deciding between the Ace Pro 2 and Action 5 for that use case.
yeah I don't dive unfortunately. but off hand I would say the action 5 is the better of the 3, it has better low light performance and tru color underwater video mode as well as depth sensors etc
Good to see comparison. I’m GoPro user and to lazy to switch to another system. GoPro is closing the Quick app on Mac OS at end of year and going only phone 📱 I do wonder if they will be around for the long haul.
Great video mate. I currently have the gopro hero 9 and was considering upgrading to the hero 13 but i mostly film travel content which can be in low light so was swaying towards dji action 5 but i have quite alot of gopro accessories like the media mod and other mounts so it would be cheaper to upgrade to the gopro overall but i feel i would miss out on an opportunity to get the dji action 5 which is overall better. Any suggestions?
I agree man, In many cases, Action 5 performs well. However, I wasn’t entirely impressed with the Action 5 Pro's clarity and sharpness in expansive scenes like mountains and snow, as the footage often has a blueish tone and struggles with rougher bright textures, especially over larger ranges. Maybe the biggest cause of it is the HDR look. Additionally, I noticed that the forest is less sharpened with the snow and fog. I really hope there's an update to sharpen the image in already bright conditions and d-log m will achieve a comparable result to other cameras by adjusting sharpness and color grading to enhance clarity and improve texture highlights in expansive scenes like mountains and snow. I'm struggling with this decision as well.
unfortunately the weak point of gopro is lowlight. if you have a lot of accessories and a small light for low light filming then the gopro can do ok, otherwise the action 5 is where it's at especially if you add the DJI mic 2 in for clean audio anywhere
I am really liking the DJI 5 Pro, since I am the proud owner of the Action 1 an the Action 4, I think I will wait for a good sale on the 5 pro. Love this comparison, thanks for taking the time.
Decided to go wirh Action 5 over Gopro this time around. GoPro footage in this video, minus low light does look so good, but i have been diggin the action 5 as well. Excited to see battery life this winter when snowboarding and temps below 20 F
Hate to say it but the GP looks the best in most of this video, the details in the snow and the mountains stand out more. However, I've owned several GoPro's and they all eventually fail whether is freezing, recording without audio or randomly shutting of so I just can't trust them anymore. I would have bought the AP2 if it was actually available anywhere but ended up with the Action 5 and a DJI Mic 2 transmitter as my new POV setup.
Pardon for my persistence with these questions. I mainly wanted to ask if there’s potential for the Action 5 Pro to achieve results comparable to other cameras by adjusting sharpness and color grading to enhance clarity and improve texture highlights in expansive scenes like mountains and snow. Please share your insight and experience about this camera Action 5.
I agree, I like the GP image in perfect conditions, however overall the DJI A5P is the best. I have taken the Action 5 Pro out on the snow machine up here in Fairbanks in the white mountain rec area in temps from 5 to 15 F and it performed flawlessly and I am always blown away by how long it records for. After a couple hours I'll think "oh I need to check the camera" and yep, its still recording. DJI has to many add on features and the best price compared to the competition to not be labeled the "best".
I think DJI action 5 Pro is the new king of the action cameras only because they have an actual ecosystem meaning that you can match different cameras. You can match it with the pocket. 3. The pocket 3 also does a better job and low light than the ace Pro 2. Plus it has the 10-pick color grading. I don't think the ace Pro 2 is a bad camera but having cameras is more about video. You have to have good audio as well. The the action 5 Pro has two mic capability. The color grading time code. It has everything that a real Pro Camera should have. You can even do cinematic filming with it. The other thing is is that they are doing a firmware updates. It came off on a rocky start but they're starting to make the tweaks that it needs and they are listening to the people that bought the cameras and making the improvements accordingly. There's when you buy an expensive action camera you want support like that so that if you are having difficulties, you know that the manufacturer is trying to solve the issue. I agree with what you were saying about the ace Pro 2. The first generation had focusing issues. This one is better but it still has focusing issues. Nobody was talking about that. They're trying to make it like a vlogging camera, but they're saying well it can't you know don't put it up against the pocket 3 because that's not a fair fight. However, if you're going to promote it as a login camera, well, it is a fair fight between that and the pocket 3 fair is fair. Don't promote it as a login camera and then say well. Don't put it up against the pocket. 3. I seen the footage the pocket 3. Went out on the low light footage. I think the best combination is the pocket 3. The action 5. Pro or the action 4. The only thing I really don't like about the auction 5. Pro is the lens flare issue is a bit bothersome, but I own a three and a four and the three had virtually no lens flare because it doesn't have that low light sensitivity. So it's the coating on the lens that's causing this flare
I’ve been researching a new action camera. Flip flopping between all of them. GoPro not really being at the top but after seeing these images from the three I’m definitely more interested in the GoPro. To my eyes it looks a lot better than the other two.
I have the same view.. I shoot in daylight and the aftermarket for GP is vast and I expansive... GP color wins me Everytime... If I start shooting in batcaves .. I will consider the other 2... Specifically the DJI
The Acepro looks like there is a "softening" effect on your skin, it's kind of weird. The Action 5, just seems 'brighter' than the rest...GoPro seems to have more contrast and is a little sharper close up. If you weren't looking at them side by side, most people would probably be happy with any of them.
yeah it's just strange what the ace pro is doing to the image but you are right without showing them side by side people would be happy with any of them
Settings matched when one camera can record at a higher resolution than another doesn’t seem like fair comparison to me. That’s like not letting a basketball player dunk because another basketball player can’t dunk. Idk 🤷♂️
*I noticed in Low Light the GoPro seemed to Struggle but I had the Hero12. But I'm Comparing the Ace Pro to the Action5 to see which is the better between the 2 of those, but the GoPro to me stopped being the Best IMP after the Hero9*
Unfortunately GoPro has stopped innovation and just added iterative changes. They need to do something good in the next version or they are probably done for
@@JakeSloan yeah but because GoPro is such a Mass Produced Name almost anyone lookin for an Action Camera especially here at Costco will Buy it because it's all we sale.
Great analysis. I prefer the DJI although I still use the GoPro 10 to record my UA-cam videos, along with the iPhone 15. But I will move to DJI since in my opinion it has a better dynamic range.
Great Review! I was wanting to get a new Action 5. I'm kind of on the fence now. Probably still go with the action 5. My old GoPro 10 is ok (other than overheating) but I'm upset with the new battery design GoPro went with.
Great video comparison. I purchased the DJI A5P after previously going back & forth between GoPro & then the Ace Pro (1). I think GoPro will always be strong but I do like the ecosystem of the DJI especially if owning the DJI OP3. In the end, all have great picture & decision tends to really lean on individual preference & use case.
I have two GoPros - a 7 and a 10 - and I bought an Ace Pro (not the 2) but returned it as the video quality was very bad especially once you enabled horizon levelling which is a must for me. I then bought the DJI Action 5 and, as with your video, the quality of the images still doesn't come close to the GoPros but there are some "usability" features that mean I'm keeping it - namely the ability to connect two wireless mics in reasonable quality as many cameras will support connecting a wireless mic but only in very low quality. So pretty much my experiences are similar to yours - if you want decent video then the GoPro is the one to beat except for the very specific case where you need to shoot in low light in towns.
I prefer the Action 5 and the GoPro. But man, its me or the auto exposure on the DJI is completly lost when there is scene with high contrast. 1:20 If you look at the sky its like it is constaly searching how to expose the scene.:O It's the same on the Ace Pro, but less aggressive (and the darker image helps hide these changes).
Love this even comparison for the GoPro, I just bought the A5 but I prefer the day light look of the GoPro. I just can’t get over how the shadows on the GoPro makes everyone look 10 years older with wrinkly skin.
Nice work on the review Jake. I was torn between the A5 and AP2 so I bought both. Almost 4 weeks now and I still don’t have the AP2. There is a lot I like about both cameras but in the end the A5 wins for me. I have requested a refund from insta360 and I’ll keep the A5.
I have been using latest firmware of Osmo Action 5 Pro in super night. They introduced 60fps for 4k in SuperNight. To be honest - no diffs. I assume, that it might improve slightly videos from the deep dives, when you need to slow-mo a bit. But in general - I didn't notice any improvements.
Kinda different story for IRL streamers (webcam mode)... - GoPro is nice overall, but useless in low light so a big no go anyways. Even the Osmo Action 4 beats it. - DJI webcam mode is broken, stutters and Supernight is not available at all. Even if it suddenly was available in webcam mode it looks much worse than Pure Video on the Insta360. And whats up with the traffic cone shaped lens flare?! (All modes) -Insta360 struggles with some details and the focusing, but it works and you can use it in low light. They may not be able to fix the focusing with firmware update because its probably the physical lens, however they may be able to fix the details in the shadows etc. 3 biggest action cam manufacturers release something and they all fail, but Insta360 fails the least for IRL in my opinion. Would be very interesting to see your take on this matter, all of the cams recording to OBS as webcams (since almost all IRL streamers use encoders with SRTLA etc. and do not use their specific apps streaming modes because its mostly garbage) on a normal evening stroll down the streets or even outdoor up in Alaska (should get dark pretty early there now). All of them set to 4k30, with benefits like Pure Video/Supernight used to counter what you have alot of now, darkness. (Keep in mind they all just output 1080p30 in Webcam Mode because they have all failed with that too once again) Does not matter that much because of bandwidth usage at 4k destroys the image even more at bad reception. When it comes to 10 bit, its kinda irrelevant too since its live and no post production benefits from it. Even if you stream 10 bit, once its has been compressed for transmission its not post editing friendly anymore anyways in for example UA-cam DVR function.
Ace Pro 1 had a really bad close in focus problem that eliminated it from my list. I was hoping the Pro 2 would fix it! But they just never learn that not everyone is going to blog with a 3 foot selfie stick.
@@JakeSloan Thank you for covering this fact. Its something that almost ALL other reviews didnt say anything about, and one of the biggest factors on if you want to buy the thing for Vlogging. It seemed odd that nobody said anything about its close focus when it was such a huge blight on the first generation. Even the same reviewers that made big video's on how bad the close focus was on the Ace Pro, were mute this time around.
Thank you for review. I am upgrading from hero 7 black. Watched lots of comparisons and beginning to think it must be my 55 y old eyes. The Gopro videos just look better. You are the first to agree with me 😝. I use an action camera…. well for filming outdoor action such as motocross and mtb. Not interested in vlogging at night- seems like my iPhone 16 pro would do that job. The action 5 too bright- not realistic, the AP 2 videos just look weird. My issue with Gopro are their standard problems that I hope they have mostly fixed after 6 generations. Costco package on sale 329$ now- 2 batteries, case,128gb card.
I am still using aco pri 1 and is great, as focus distance, when I ski cycle or holiday the camera is always filming at more than 1 m away. So no probs. I had action 5 pro but send it back as the sky was all purple and no clarity in the clouds
I don’t consider any of them to be photo camera but you can take decent ones. 27mp for GoPro, 48mp for the action 5 and 50mp for the ace pro. Low light is what it is on GoPro or any action camera for that matter. Just not great.
@@JakeSloan Some people have had leaking battery doors with the Action 5. Those doors could be moved without pushing the release button. Not all units seemed to be affected though. After DJI first denied the issue, I believe they're now sending out replacement doors.
Nice comparison. There are a lot of comparison videos on these cameras. Interesting to see the cameras in a different setting of snow. Even with similar settings, I can’t believe how washed out the DJI is in the snow. Totally lose the details of the terrain, shadows, brush, rocks, and tracks compared to the others. Maybe you could play with the setting, but not even close to the other two.
At 7:50 I will say that Action 5 have most realistic colors since snow should have blue tint from the blue sky (its reflective). Gopro tend to show red closer to orange and that I have seen from other videos aswell. Ace Pro 2 looks more like a cheaper brand with its lack of close focus. I do like all 3 brands but from your test it seems like Action 5 is softer than mine is when I have mine at -2 Texture. But I will not say either is a winner here, they all do well. My choose is still Action 5, batterylife and no major issues.
Thank you for the review! This is really helpful for me, as I'm new to the world of action cameras. I was initially leaning towards the DJI Action 5, but I don't like how it seems to be... missing a lot of details in the image, for example the footprints on the ground and all the small fissures/snowdrifts in the background at 1:36 and 11:13. So now I'm leaning more towards the GoPro, despite the inferior performance w.r.t. overheating and battery life.
it comes close but you end up with better image quality since you have more control over noise reduction in post. I almost exclusively use D-log m when I shoot stuff with the action just because I can lower the sharpening and noise reduction and then use my programs to adjust it in post
@ awesome, that’s what i was hoping, looking at moving from hero 12’s to the action 5 for all my cinematic rigs, will be really nice to benable to fly deeper into blue hour
What was the temp when gopro shutdown due to the cold? we get -25c or even -30c here in Finland. I was about to go for Ace pro 2 since we have lot of darkness in winter, but after this video I have to seriously reconsider my options 😅
Thanks for the review! Insta360 has its advantages, but the problem with it - impossible to buy it (bummer). The delivery time of Insta360 Ace Pro 2 now is more than a month, and no guarantee, that it is true. So, among those 3 cameras - my favorite remains DJI Action 5 Pro. I use it almost every day, when I'm running or hiking.
interesting, I ordered mine on launch day from insta360 and got it a week or so later (if I remember right) it is interesting that no stores have it in stock yet.
@@JakeSloan return it for a swap if I was you. Insta360 stopped selling them because the lens fogging issue, if it's not today maybe it will happen in the future.... Even a seller on Ali confirmed this, but Insta360 ignored it publicly! "Hello, there are some issues with the lenses of the first batch of Insta360 Ace Pro 2, and the manufacturer is urgently recaling and repairing them." I am still waiting for my preorder from a local shop.
You left out the shake test. I recently watched a video that that did a shake test with these 3 cameras and there were some significant variations in performance. The gopro did do very well. It makes me think you are skewing your review in favour of gopro.
Why the hell would I shake a camera? also I don't give a rip what camera you buy or don't buy. everything in this video is here to inform, make up your own mind
@JakeSloan I believe unbiased reviewers do the shake test to demonstrate an action cameras stabilization ability. Get on your mountain bike with an action camera and do a downhill run. Then tell me the shake test is irrelevant.
I liked the Action 5 Pro overall, GoPro is good in daylight, but contrasty, insta360 has an image processing problem. But the last part of the video was the best - Pocket 3 👑 .
Nice comparison. And yes, 8 bit color is consumer grade and 10 bit color is considered professional grade. If you ever want to color grade those 1 billion colors are going to give you a lot more to work with than 16.7 million. Should be called the Ace 2, not the Ace Pro 2.
Personally I love my Action 5 Pro. GoPro 13 is not bad. Insta360 is 💩 as expected... The AcePro cameras are so mushy feeling and the colors are off.
agreed!
I really commend you on your stance with the ethics of insta360 and everything that you did. I know that that wasn't an easy decision and insta360 does make some decent cameras but me personally I stay away from for the same exact reason. It's just not good for us. I did want to get a hold of an ace Pro 2. To compare it with the DJI pocket. 3. And then I found out that you can't buy them on Amazon. You can't buy them at Best Buy. They never released it to any big box stores and I found out that the return policy stated that had to be within 15 days and you couldn't take it out of the box and the fact that you still can't get it at any big box stores seems a little sketchy to me
The color of ACEPRO2 is always wrong, see 1:13, purple snow and sky?
@@blueCollarGuyCostco carries the Insta360x4 and Apple also. So they do have them in the 🇺🇸.
@CubamusPrime Ace pro 2 not in Canada Amazon or Best buy. Only older model
Gotta say the stabilization on AP2 really shines in low light... GP tends to get a bit jittery when the lighting isn’t great, but AP2 stays stable and clear
yep thats true
The background on the acepro 2 looks way sharper to me... You can actually see more texture and detail in the distance compared to the other cameras
There is more detail when you film in 8k mode but in all modes it looks artificially sharpened
I'll give Insta360 credit where it's due, their highlight control in low light is impressive. It balances bright streetlights and headlights really well without losing too much detail in the dark. One of those features you don't notice until you need it
Yep and one thing I called out and gave them credit for in this video
From all the videos i’ve seen, Go Pro has by far the best colors and quality in good lighting. The Ace Pro 2 has the best low light. The Action 5 pro is decent middle ground that looks more ‘digital’ than go pro in good lighting and can handle low light.
I wish Go Pro could do low light, it’d be near perfect then. It has the best magnetic mounting system now and built in gps. Hoping their next camera has a larger sensor, 4:2:2 10 bit, and higher bitrate.
I agree!
The dynamic range on the ap2 looks a lot better tho, especially in scenes with strong contrast...
Don’t tell him that. Lol. AP2 is lacking details he said.
are you serious? I show how crappy the dynamic range of the AP2 is compared to the other ones lol. it is terrible unless you shoot in the HDR mode which then look very artificial
Agreed. AP2 and GP13 seem to handle highlights and shadows better, esp the snow's texture and contrast in darker areas. 06:47 I hate to say it but OA5 appears to lose some detail... The image feels a bit flat and fake...
It’s funny how he talks like the action 5 doesn’t have HDR turned on indefinitely. Lol. I can only imagine how muddy the image will become once a toggle is added to turn it off. It’s on by default. I guess biases will keep you blind.
One of the best comparison videos I’ve seen about these 3 cameras. Because I film occasionally in low light, I went with the DJI. Thanks!
Thank you very much
In terms of color science and contrast GoPro 13 is in another league. The others 2 don't come even close in this field. However, I do think Action 5 Pro is much better to use indoors due to its higher dynamic range and less warping of the edges.
Agreed
Agreed, big time
I wonder if the color science for Action 5 in the snow, trees, and distant mountains could be sharper and stand out from each other to achieve results comparable to other cameras. I'm not a fan of the Action 5's blue tones and HDR look.
I'm not a face shooter so I prefer the Ace Pro 2 image. Landscape image colors look fine to me especially clouds. The flip screen convenience alone for my style of shooting(point and shoot straight out of camera, hiking, boating and travel) is the winning feature and the zoom on the Ace Pro 2 is outstanding. Always value your reviews 🙂
thank you!
Details at 2:02 are the reason why I chose GoPro over DJI. I thought the Action5 would solve the focus problem but no
Not quite but better than the ace pro
@ Better? Can you read the beanie brand there? Come on Bruh
@@AbelVlogsRD Gopro performs phenomenally well in bright snow conditions in many ways than the other cameras. However, you should see comparisons from other content creators in different variety of conditions depending on the surrounding landscapes and environment. I would suggest the GoPro for snow sports if that's your priority, however, their sensor is outdated producing a darker image, narrower field of view, and higher distortion. Non of the cameras are perfect.
@@AbelVlogsRD that’s what I said exactly on my comment. But hey, if they send you a paycheck, no matter how muddy the image is, it will look clear as day. Lol.
Close focus is bad on the ace pro 2? 2:02 I can read your beany brand on both the gopro and ace pro 2 but not on the oa5. So it’s in focus and action 5 isnt?
Less detail? 3:43 i can see tire tracks on both ace pro 2 and gopro, as there is almost none on the action 5. Same goes for the background. I see details for both gopro and ace pro 2 and almost none existent on the action 5 pro.
Also for this to be fair, both gopro and ace pro 2 has to be on HDR, cause the action 5 pro has this turned on indefinitely.
Also, I really do believe the ace pro 2 is on a different color profile and not the normal color profile. Of all the videos I’ve watched, and I watched a ton of them. None had that sky color on the normal color profile. That’s way too blue.
I show HDR on and off examples with the ace pro 2 and it's not so much close focus issues (which it does have) as it is over sharpened look no matter the sharpness settings and this was all filmed in normal color on the cameras
GoPro has much more detail in regards to the Action 5 and better colors, the AcePro2 is way too much artificially over shapen and colors are off.
100% agree
So pleased with your review Jake as I am tired of all the negative reviews about GoPro it’s like everyone wants to see them fail. I’m very much an amateur photographer but in my eyes the image on GoPros are just more pleasing to the eye. Not only that but as someone who doesn’t want to spend too much time on colour grading, for me it looks great straight out of the camera.
What so many people don’t accept is that an action camera is built for action in predominantly bright conditions. They are not designed to replace a video camera or stills camera or to perform well in low light. Use action cameras for ACTION and accept their limitations.
Exactly right. I have been critical of GoPro in the past when they made dumb design choices or had problematic software but their image quality is still excellent
16:12 The footage from DJI Pocket 3 looks amazing. Thats the real winner here!
agreed!!
Looking at the difference at 1:33 and 4:25 I don't think you're using the same color among the 3, the ace pro 2 is clearly using a different color profile. I am sorry but this does not look like a fair comparison
It was using the same profile through out. This isn’t some grand conspiracy to do an unfair review. Some modes on the ace pro just look like garbage
Hello, thank you for this helpful video. I considered the Action 5 Pro for POV skiing videos, as sharpness and clarity in snow footage are crucial for capturing a broader perspective of the surrounding landscapes and environment. However, I wasn’t entirely impressed with the Action 5 Pro's clarity and sharpness in expansive scenes like mountains and snow, as the footage often has a blueish tint and struggles with rougher textures, especially over larger ranges. I wanted to ask if you’ve noticed a loss of detail with Action 5 on certain textures during the recording. While some suggest the Action 5 Pro appears oversharpened, I find it lacks clarity and depth on rough surfaces like gravel, snow, concrete roads, structures, and even vegetation, whereas other cameras seem to preserve sharper detail, especially in snow, maintaining the realistic snow tone color. Do you think these issues, such as the blueish tint and lack of depth, can be fixed through settings adjustments, color grading, or a firmware update to enhance clarity and improve texture highlights? My priority is the best image quality for snow and mountain ranges similar to your footage in Alaska.
I find for better sharpness and contrast straight out of camera I prefer the action 4 which is excellent
@@JakeSloan Pardon my persistence with these questions. I mainly wanted to ask if there’s potential for the Action 5 Pro to achieve results comparable to other cameras by adjusting sharpness and color grading to enhance clarity and improve texture highlights in expansive scenes like mountains and snow. Please share your insight and experience about this camera Action 5.
You should've paid good attention to the details in this video. You can see that the GoPro has by far the best clarity and contrast when you look at the mountains/trees in the background. For me it's a no brainer that in good lighting condition the other 2 cameras don't come even close to the GoPro.
@@gabrielavastye7208 Gopro performs phenomenally well in bright snow conditions in many ways than the other cameras. However, you should see comparisons from other content creators in different variety of conditions depending on the surrounding landscapes and environment. GoPro might be a great option for snow sports in capturing detail if that's the priority, however, their sensor is outdated producing a darker image, narrower field of view, and higher distortion. None of the cameras are perfect. that's just my opinion and the primary reason why I'm interested in the action 5.
@@Untied_Shoelace agreed. I think that different cameras perform differently in different environments. For example I’m an fpv pilot and would use the GoPro for daylight outdoor shooting. For indoor fpv I’d always use the action 5 due to its better lowlight performance and dynamic range. Also less warping of the edges when you pan on the action 5 compared to the GoPro
Here’s my take: Since I’m using the GP10, my options are to either upgrade to the GP12 (to save on battery costs) or choose between the GP13 and the OA5-AP2 is off the table for me now. We’ll be filming outdoor adventures in Alaska all winter, including overnight tent camping and stays in public-use cabins. Come spring, we’re heading to Southeast Asia for a few weeks to explore day and night street food markets. I was hoping the GP would be the obvious choice, but since I’ll need to buy new batteries anyway, the OA5 is becoming a serious contender.
Definitely deserves consideration
1st it's bettery life and 2nd - internal storage.
I had gopro 10 before and it would not record longer than around 30 minutes in -10c while my Action 3 (back then) would record for an hour with still a lot of battery left.
@@rjfotovideo what camera are you using now?
The best review of these 3 I've seen so far! Thank you Jake!
Wow, thanks!
there is also one thing which I can see - pink'ish skin tones from both Action and Insta. Gopro colours are more neutral. Sure you can take a bit of the tint off in the postprocessing but it won't sort the issue 100%
You can shoot in log on the action 5 and match it to whatever you like but straight out of colors from GoPro are pretty good
@@JakeSloan log could sort it I guess
Greetings from Belarus. Bought DJI Action 5. Bigger sensor = less noise. I finished with GoPro on the sixth version. 13 GoPro looks decent, but the sensor is small. For those who shoot their face, this is a decisive factor, but there is Pocket 3 for such purposes. Thanks for the comparison.
Agreed
Great Video and very helpful. I will buy a new action cam and i think i will go for the dji action 5. had many gopro and it's time for a switch. i enjoyed your 1:1 comparison. looking for focus i think the action 5 is not bad at short distance but does it have some issues with long distance? at 7:03 or 7:30 there is not much detail or how do you rate this? it looked better (for me) in your comparison video between GP13 and DA5Pro
The action 5 has a lot of flexibility in the footage to edit it how you like for contrast and colors. This was in normal mode but if you film and set it to expose at -0.3 you will get more detail in the highlights like what you see in the background behind me
Problem with DJI is having to side load a spyware heavy app to activate it
Same with insta360
@@JakeSloan insta360 are both in the app store and Google play store. DJI isn’t. I wonder why that is. Lol.
Jake, thank you for the great video and detailed comparison! At mark 2:57, the GoPro’s clarity is incredible you can even see the details in your facial hairs, which really shows its sharpness. I was curious about the Insta360’s performance during the day shot in the snow, why does it look so washed out compared to the others? The wrinkles around your eyes also stand out prominently with the GoPro, which highlights its ability to capture fine details. The low-light test was what I was most curious about, and you answered all my questions perfectly-thank you for that!
so glad I was able to hit all those points for you!
Thanks much Jake. I ordered the Action 5. The background in the GoPro footage looked detailed but also over sharpened. I like the size and utility of the Action 5.
Awesome!
What do you think about these action cameras? while each one does have their strengths I definitely feel like the weakest overall is the Insta360 Ace Pro 2...
Why the sky and snow of ACEPRO 2 in 1:13 is purple?
Thanks for the video Jake. Please pin your comment (click three dots, then 'pin comment') so your 'author' comment doesn't get buried in all the comments, it'll keep it at the top for everyone to see. Keep up the good work!
I have fogging issue on my ace pro 2 i use it as a motovlov and my speed is only 30-kmph normal days I'm from Philippines. Video recording 2.7k frms video duration less than an hour every time the camera heat and there's a wind only mild wind the lens has fog. What should i do?
Interesting I have heard of this from a few other people as well
@JakeSloan I bought it online not in insta36p website should i return this?
Good fair review. I've had GoPro's for many years, and tried the Action 3, but still favor the GoPro despite the lower battery time. One thing I think would be a good test review is to do some multicam videos and compare how GoPro sync vs Action's 5 sync would work out in the real world if using 3+ cameras. I've also installed the GoProLabs firmware for multicam LTC syncing. If your outdoors, the GPS sync is another option, but I found inconsistent. The easiest way to sync multiple GoPro's is using the QRcode with the QRControl app, which makes post-production much faster.
yeah thats a huge win for sure
Hey Jake, been watching your videos since I bought an Action 5 pro, very helpful stuff especially on extreme scenarios that I can't test myself. I did test it out riding my motorcycle and it did not disappoint. Love from the Philippines!
Great to hear and thank you.
Great comparison Jake. One of the best and most unbiased I’ve seen so far!
Appreciate that!
Question, Jake; did you have the Action 5 in high bit mode? I’m curious because there is virtually no detail in the snow or mountains behind you on the Action 5.
yes but the lack of detail is more due to the camera exposing for the face not the overall image, that detail can be recovered in post with some basic adjustments or using D-log M
Like the sharpness of Gopro, Like the Dynamic range of Ace pro2, but overall the image quality of Action 5 look nicer and cinematic to my eyes
interesting, I definitely prefer the dynamic range of the action 5 or gopro
@@JakeSloan This year definitely The Action 5 is winner
where can you find the dynamic range of Acepro 2?
Very nice real world comparison. I just bought the Hero 13 and I think I made the right choice, given that I rarely shoot in low light.
It's no surprise that Action5 and Ace Pro 2 struggle focusing at close distance, since they both have a large sensor. Large sensor makes it impossibile to focus at close distance, - it's just optics, there's no way around it - but helps a lot with low light performance.
So... it depends on what you want to prioritize.
With good light the Gopro looks great (color riproduction/sharpness/contrast) and that's what I I want the most.
Exactly right and you made a great choice
I do think you're being honest but I have a similar but different take. I'm just about to finalize a very detailed comparison between the Ace Pro 2 and the action 5 and I'd be curious to discuss further. I'm 100% non-sponsored and I'm just looking to seek the truth.
interesting how has your experience been?
@JakeSloan it's a tough decision and side by side comparisons are time consuming summing to edit and make an honest, definitive general recommendation. I had 11 categories and they tied in two so it's head to head in that regard.
This is the first non biased review between all 3 cameras, and GoPro is still top, not everyone lucky enough to have footage in arctic.
Thanks!
Man this was helpful. I was all in on the AcePro2 because of low light but seeing the images its clear the GoPro is the look I want. And telling me about the lack of 10-bit was huge. Thanks. Great review.
Glad I could help!
Jake, I've watched a ton of videos on these cameras. I also purchased all three and have struggled to frame how they all compare to crown a winner. Need something for a wide range of uses. While I really love the screen on the Ace Pro 2 the images from the Action 5 Pro are also looking better overall. So NICE job and BEST I've seen for a round-up of all three. Stay warm. -JB
thank you very much!
In Jake we trust....the gopro is much better than other youtubers give it credit...you look like you shaved with the AP2
ROFL. That’s a great take on it 😂
Hi Jake, as always excellent test of these cameras. Did you film in flat on all cameras
In most cases I filmed in normal except where I was talking about log. Those clips were filmed in each cameras log profile
Love your videos!! I'm curious to know, out of the GoPro & Action 5, which camera looks more closer to what you actually see with your eyes. You mentioned your jacket looked more natural with the Action 5. But how about the sky and the color of the snow? Btw, is it me or did the Action 5 have a lot less detail in the snow? Is that something that could be fixed if shooting in D Log M instead? Thanks for your work!
To me the action usually looks the closest. If you want a more contrasty image (detail in the snow etc) get an action 4! Still great image
@@JakeSloan Thanks for the advice!
AMAZING VIDEO! It made me subscribe! i got the Action 5 yesterday. ¿Do you think you can do a high bitrate + color graded 10bit+ -0.3ev stops to see if it can retain better detail on the snow behind you? I´m just really wondering why it looks so much better contrast and detail on the gopro.
yes if you expose -0.3 or even -0.7 in conditions like these you will get better detail as well as when you shoot in D-log M the HDR look goes away which also helps
@JakeSloan thank you for the quick answer! :D love this camera. Its sooo small.
Hmmm... agree about the focus on your face from the AP2, but look at 4:25 and look how bland the background is on the OA5. The GoPro and AP2 have so much more detail on the mountain, snow, etc. I just think the OA5 does a better job on the vlogger but a worse job on backgrounds (not enough contrast or sharpness = very bland).
Good point
This is the best comparision I have seen and I totally agree (not sponsored by AcePro, miracle!). The best details and colors are for GoPro (here, in Spain, is a sunny country so... GoPro wins).
In low light conditions I use my DJI Osmo Pocket 3 (I watch glittering at night in all actions cameras). I like ski and diving.... Ski at night, surf at night, BMX at night...???? It looks ridiculous to me. Action cameras are made for action sports.... in the daytime!
P.D. I have watched your video in a PHILLIPS OLED 65 inches... it is easier to see the details.
Congratulations!
Couldn't agree more!
Personally, looks to me the images on:
-DJI Action 5 Pro is well balanced camera.
- GoPro looks the best as long there is light.
- Insta360 Ace Pro just not on par, but it has an attractive punch.
agreed
I need one for skiing but don’t want to deal with go pro powering off from the coldness and I don’t like dji. Think I might have to get insta 360 what do you thing? How cold can the go pro get?
Idk for sure but the action series has been by far the best in cold temps for me.
Dude is the only guy on the internet trashing the Ace Pro 😂😂
well I call it like I see it but I also wasn't given one for review...
Nice comparison. For someone who wants to get one for things like family vlogging which would you recommend? I want something with a simple interface since I need to learn more about the editing process.
I’d recommend the action 4 or 5 honestly.
I wish I could find this solid of a comparison based around using them for scuba diving. I wasn't happy with my GoPro12 in some instances while diving, I'm assuming due to lack of light. Really having trouble deciding between the Ace Pro 2 and Action 5 for that use case.
yeah I don't dive unfortunately. but off hand I would say the action 5 is the better of the 3, it has better low light performance and tru color underwater video mode as well as depth sensors etc
Good to see comparison. I’m GoPro user and to lazy to switch to another system. GoPro is closing the Quick app on Mac OS at end of year and going only phone 📱 I do wonder if they will be around for the long haul.
honestly no big reason to switch. anything that has come out in the last few years has been great
Great video mate.
I currently have the gopro hero 9 and was considering upgrading to the hero 13 but i mostly film travel content which can be in low light so was swaying towards dji action 5 but i have quite alot of gopro accessories like the media mod and other mounts so it would be cheaper to upgrade to the gopro overall but i feel i would miss out on an opportunity to get the dji action 5 which is overall better. Any suggestions?
I agree man, In many cases, Action 5 performs well. However, I wasn’t entirely impressed with the Action 5 Pro's clarity and sharpness in expansive scenes like mountains and snow, as the footage often has a blueish tone and struggles with rougher bright textures, especially over larger ranges. Maybe the biggest cause of it is the HDR look. Additionally, I noticed that the forest is less sharpened with the snow and fog. I really hope there's an update to sharpen the image in already bright conditions and d-log m will achieve a comparable result to other cameras by adjusting sharpness and color grading to enhance clarity and improve texture highlights in expansive scenes like mountains and snow. I'm struggling with this decision as well.
unfortunately the weak point of gopro is lowlight. if you have a lot of accessories and a small light for low light filming then the gopro can do ok, otherwise the action 5 is where it's at especially if you add the DJI mic 2 in for clean audio anywhere
I am really liking the DJI 5 Pro, since I am the proud owner of the Action 1 an the Action 4, I think I will wait for a good sale on the 5 pro. Love this comparison, thanks for taking the time.
Good choice!
Decided to go wirh Action 5 over Gopro this time around. GoPro footage in this video, minus low light does look so good, but i have been diggin the action 5 as well. Excited to see battery life this winter when snowboarding and temps below 20 F
Nice you definitely picked the right one for cold weather.
Hate to say it but the GP looks the best in most of this video, the details in the snow and the mountains stand out more. However, I've owned several GoPro's and they all eventually fail whether is freezing, recording without audio or randomly shutting of so I just can't trust them anymore. I would have bought the AP2 if it was actually available anywhere but ended up with the Action 5 and a DJI Mic 2 transmitter as my new POV setup.
nice setup!
Great video! This really helped me when looking at the three.
Are any of them capable of getting a decent video or photo of the Aurora Borealis?
No not really. Of the three the action 5 or ace pro would be best but only in night Timelapse mode
Pardon for my persistence with these questions. I mainly wanted to ask if there’s potential for the Action 5 Pro to achieve results comparable to other cameras by adjusting sharpness and color grading to enhance clarity and improve texture highlights in expansive scenes like mountains and snow. Please share your insight and experience about this camera Action 5.
yes there is, film in D-log M with sharpness and noise reduction set to -2 then you can make it look like you wish with color grading etc
Hi my insta 360 ace pro 2 doesn't have the problems she had... in the snow I made excellent videos, yours will have a problem, send it for assistance
I have seen similar problems in a lot of other videos on UA-cam as well so it’s not limited to mine.
What cor profile did you use on rhe AP2? Leica standard is nice and you can up the sharpening in rhe menu
this was Leica standard
@@JakeSloanknew it! It was leica natural or vivid and not the actual standard color profile. That’s why it’s darker! Come on now.
I agree, I like the GP image in perfect conditions, however overall the DJI A5P is the best. I have taken the Action 5 Pro out on the snow machine up here in Fairbanks in the white mountain rec area in temps from 5 to 15 F and it performed flawlessly and I am always blown away by how long it records for. After a couple hours I'll think "oh I need to check the camera" and yep, its still recording. DJI has to many add on features and the best price compared to the competition to not be labeled the "best".
100% the best performance in cold temps has been the action for me too
I think DJI action 5 Pro is the new king of the action cameras only because they have an actual ecosystem meaning that you can match different cameras. You can match it with the pocket. 3. The pocket 3 also does a better job and low light than the ace Pro 2. Plus it has the 10-pick color grading. I don't think the ace Pro 2 is a bad camera but having cameras is more about video. You have to have good audio as well. The the action 5 Pro has two mic capability. The color grading time code. It has everything that a real Pro Camera should have. You can even do cinematic filming with it. The other thing is is that they are doing a firmware updates. It came off on a rocky start but they're starting to make the tweaks that it needs and they are listening to the people that bought the cameras and making the improvements accordingly. There's when you buy an expensive action camera you want support like that so that if you are having difficulties, you know that the manufacturer is trying to solve the issue. I agree with what you were saying about the ace Pro 2. The first generation had focusing issues. This one is better but it still has focusing issues. Nobody was talking about that. They're trying to make it like a vlogging camera, but they're saying well it can't you know don't put it up against the pocket 3 because that's not a fair fight. However, if you're going to promote it as a login camera, well, it is a fair fight between that and the pocket 3 fair is fair. Don't promote it as a login camera and then say well. Don't put it up against the pocket. 3. I seen the footage the pocket 3. Went out on the low light footage. I think the best combination is the pocket 3. The action 5. Pro or the action 4. The only thing I really don't like about the auction 5. Pro is the lens flare issue is a bit bothersome, but I own a three and a four and the three had virtually no lens flare because it doesn't have that low light sensitivity. So it's the coating on the lens that's causing this flare
Great take on it!
I’ve been researching a new action camera. Flip flopping between all of them. GoPro not really being at the top but after seeing these images from the three I’m definitely more interested in the GoPro. To my eyes it looks a lot better than the other two.
I have the same view.. I shoot in daylight and the aftermarket for GP is vast and I expansive...
GP color wins me Everytime... If I start shooting in batcaves .. I will consider the other 2... Specifically the DJI
gopro has fantastic image quality overall
The Acepro looks like there is a "softening" effect on your skin, it's kind of weird. The Action 5, just seems 'brighter' than the rest...GoPro seems to have more contrast and is a little sharper close up.
If you weren't looking at them side by side, most people would probably be happy with any of them.
yeah it's just strange what the ace pro is doing to the image but you are right without showing them side by side people would be happy with any of them
Settings matched when one camera can record at a higher resolution than another doesn’t seem like fair comparison to me. That’s like not letting a basketball player dunk because another basketball player can’t dunk. Idk 🤷♂️
settings like wb sharpness noise reduction shutter speed etc...
@ Thanks for the reply! I understand. I guess I thought that meant all cameras set to 4k
there are examples where all cameras where set to 4k as well...
*I noticed in Low Light the GoPro seemed to Struggle but I had the Hero12. But I'm Comparing the Ace Pro to the Action5 to see which is the better between the 2 of those, but the GoPro to me stopped being the Best IMP after the Hero9*
Unfortunately GoPro has stopped innovation and just added iterative changes. They need to do something good in the next version or they are probably done for
@@JakeSloan yeah but because GoPro is such a Mass Produced Name almost anyone lookin for an Action Camera especially here at Costco will Buy it because it's all we sale.
Really appreciate your review I was this close to pull trigger on AP2.
Thanks and I am glad to hear it helped
Great analysis. I prefer the DJI although I still use the GoPro 10 to record my UA-cam videos, along with the iPhone 15. But I will move to DJI since in my opinion it has a better dynamic range.
nice!
I went from the GoPro 10 to the DJI Action 4 and it was a HUGE upgrade! You’ll love it!
Switched from GoPro 9 (still around since 2019) to Action 5 Pro recently. DJI nailed it with Action 5 Pro and probably edged out GoPro from the Crown.
yeah DJI really delivered on the action 5
Fantastic review as always. Thanks.
Thanks
Great Review! I was wanting to get a new Action 5. I'm kind of on the fence now. Probably still go with the action 5. My old GoPro 10 is ok (other than overheating) but I'm upset with the new battery design GoPro went with.
yep
Great video comparison. I purchased the DJI A5P after previously going back & forth between GoPro & then the Ace Pro (1). I think GoPro will always be strong but I do like the ecosystem of the DJI especially if owning the DJI OP3. In the end, all have great picture & decision tends to really lean on individual preference & use case.
Good choice!
I have two GoPros - a 7 and a 10 - and I bought an Ace Pro (not the 2) but returned it as the video quality was very bad especially once you enabled horizon levelling which is a must for me. I then bought the DJI Action 5 and, as with your video, the quality of the images still doesn't come close to the GoPros but there are some "usability" features that mean I'm keeping it - namely the ability to connect two wireless mics in reasonable quality as many cameras will support connecting a wireless mic but only in very low quality. So pretty much my experiences are similar to yours - if you want decent video then the GoPro is the one to beat except for the very specific case where you need to shoot in low light in towns.
couldn't agree more. I tested the ace pro (original) and it was really not great.
This was very helpful. Color grading with different sources can be hard enough and it’s easier with more data.
Glad it was helpful!
I prefer the Action 5 and the GoPro. But man, its me or the auto exposure on the DJI is completly lost when there is scene with high contrast. 1:20 If you look at the sky its like it is constaly searching how to expose the scene.:O
It's the same on the Ace Pro, but less aggressive (and the darker image helps hide these changes).
you can always lock exposure and DJI did release a firmware update a few days ago that might help with this
Love this even comparison for the GoPro, I just bought the A5 but I prefer the day light look of the GoPro. I just can’t get over how the shadows on the GoPro makes everyone look 10 years older with wrinkly skin.
hahahahahaha OUCH... but yeah not wrong
Nice work on the review Jake. I was torn between the A5 and AP2 so I bought both. Almost 4 weeks now and I still don’t have the AP2. There is a lot I like about both cameras but in the end the A5 wins for me. I have requested a refund from insta360 and I’ll keep the A5.
wow thats unfortunate to hear about the AP2 delays. I like the A5 so much I bought another one when my first one broke
Im on the same boat!! Ive been waiting for my AP2 for weeks. I really want to like it but if I can't use it whats the point. Im gonna request a refund
Hey - what firmware are you shooting on the action 5 pro? The lates one (v01.02.03.30) claimes to improve the super night mode.
I have been using latest firmware of Osmo Action 5 Pro in super night. They introduced 60fps for 4k in SuperNight. To be honest - no diffs. I assume, that it might improve slightly videos from the deep dives, when you need to slow-mo a bit. But in general - I didn't notice any improvements.
@@SupersonicTraveller all right thank you for your fast response! Take care and greetings from germany
@@t0pa thanks! Cheers!
This video was all shot and edited before the most recent firmware so I didn't have a chance to test that out unfortunately. It looks promising though
Kinda different story for IRL streamers (webcam mode)...
- GoPro is nice overall, but useless in low light so a big no go anyways. Even the Osmo Action 4 beats it.
- DJI webcam mode is broken, stutters and Supernight is not available at all. Even if it suddenly was available in webcam mode it looks much worse than Pure Video on the Insta360. And whats up with the traffic cone shaped lens flare?! (All modes)
-Insta360 struggles with some details and the focusing, but it works and you can use it in low light. They may not be able to fix the focusing with firmware update because its probably the physical lens, however they may be able to fix the details in the shadows etc.
3 biggest action cam manufacturers release something and they all fail, but Insta360 fails the least for IRL in my opinion.
Would be very interesting to see your take on this matter, all of the cams recording to OBS as webcams (since almost all IRL streamers use encoders with SRTLA etc. and do not use their specific apps streaming modes because its mostly garbage) on a normal evening stroll down the streets or even outdoor up in Alaska (should get dark pretty early there now). All of them set to 4k30, with benefits like Pure Video/Supernight used to counter what you have alot of now, darkness. (Keep in mind they all just output 1080p30 in Webcam Mode because they have all failed with that too once again) Does not matter that much because of bandwidth usage at 4k destroys the image even more at bad reception.
When it comes to 10 bit, its kinda irrelevant too since its live and no post production benefits from it. Even if you stream 10 bit, once its has been compressed for transmission its not post editing friendly anymore anyways in for example UA-cam DVR function.
Hmm interesting thoughts on live-streaming
Ace Pro 1 had a really bad close in focus problem that eliminated it from my list. I was hoping the Pro 2 would fix it! But they just never learn that not everyone is going to blog with a 3 foot selfie stick.
I was hoping too but nope
@@JakeSloan Thank you for covering this fact. Its something that almost ALL other reviews didnt say anything about, and one of the biggest factors on if you want to buy the thing for Vlogging. It seemed odd that nobody said anything about its close focus when it was such a huge blight on the first generation. Even the same reviewers that made big video's on how bad the close focus was on the Ace Pro, were mute this time around.
Thank you for review. I am upgrading from hero 7 black. Watched lots of comparisons and beginning to think it must be my 55 y old eyes. The Gopro videos just look better. You are the first to agree with me 😝. I use an action camera…. well for filming outdoor action such as motocross and mtb. Not interested in vlogging at night- seems like my iPhone 16 pro would do that job. The action 5 too bright- not realistic, the AP 2 videos just look weird. My issue with Gopro are their standard problems that I hope they have mostly fixed after 6 generations. Costco package on sale 329$ now- 2 batteries, case,128gb card.
gopro still has some magic in it
Yes u right! Ace pro should have 10bit. But for now it's only suitable for low light and as a second camera only if the main one is failed ....
Agreed
Turn face priority on the ace pro 2
I did in some cases but I did not like it
I am still using aco pri 1 and is great, as focus distance, when I ski cycle or holiday the camera is always filming at more than 1 m away. So no probs. I had action 5 pro but send it back as the sky was all purple and no clarity in the clouds
Interesting thanks for sharing
Are there any advanced settings you can use to rescue the GoPro's night video? And what about photos from each?
I don’t consider any of them to be photo camera but you can take decent ones. 27mp for GoPro, 48mp for the action 5 and 50mp for the ace pro. Low light is what it is on GoPro or any action camera for that matter. Just not great.
Only things that keep me from buying action 5 is the low light performance and the usb door issue.
usb door issue?
@@JakeSloan Some people have had leaking battery doors with the Action 5. Those doors could be moved without pushing the release button. Not all units seemed to be affected though.
After DJI first denied the issue, I believe they're now sending out replacement doors.
Nice comparison. There are a lot of comparison videos on these cameras. Interesting to see the cameras in a different setting of snow. Even with similar settings, I can’t believe how washed out the DJI is in the snow. Totally lose the details of the terrain, shadows, brush, rocks, and tracks compared to the others. Maybe you could play with the setting, but not even close to the other two.
You definitely can adjust it and get different results.
nothing beats gopro video quality in all action camera
it's still the original
At 7:50 I will say that Action 5 have most realistic colors since snow should have blue tint from the blue sky (its reflective). Gopro tend to show red closer to orange and that I have seen from other videos aswell. Ace Pro 2 looks more like a cheaper brand with its lack of close focus.
I do like all 3 brands but from your test it seems like Action 5 is softer than mine is when I have mine at -2 Texture. But I will not say either is a winner here, they all do well. My choose is still Action 5, batterylife and no major issues.
nice
Thank you for the review! This is really helpful for me, as I'm new to the world of action cameras. I was initially leaning towards the DJI Action 5, but I don't like how it seems to be... missing a lot of details in the image, for example the footprints on the ground and all the small fissures/snowdrifts in the background at 1:36 and 11:13. So now I'm leaning more towards the GoPro, despite the inferior performance w.r.t. overheating and battery life.
i have gp 13 i get more 1hour 30 minutes in 5.3k 30 no overheating and no freezing
yeah that mostly is just how it is exposed you can recover much of that detail in post with some adjustments or exposing at -0.3 to -0.7 in camera
Nice comparison thanks Jake👍
Thanks!
Very useful comparison. Well done! Thanks.
Thanks for watching!
How's the DJI Super Night Mode compare to shooting it in log and then boosting the shadows in post?
it comes close but you end up with better image quality since you have more control over noise reduction in post. I almost exclusively use D-log m when I shoot stuff with the action just because I can lower the sharpening and noise reduction and then use my programs to adjust it in post
@ awesome, that’s what i was hoping, looking at moving from hero 12’s to the action 5 for all my cinematic rigs, will be really nice to benable to fly deeper into blue hour
Dji all the way
Yep
Which one you suggest for mountain biking and road cycling? I don’t ride at night, but some trails might have shadows…
Action 4 or action 5 for sure
Very good comparison video Jake
Thanks Lyn I appreciate that!
What was the temp when gopro shutdown due to the cold? we get -25c or even -30c here in Finland. I was about to go for Ace pro 2 since we have lot of darkness in winter, but after this video I have to seriously reconsider my options 😅
I would seriously consider an action 4 or 5 as they do substantially better in cold temps (alaska is quite similar to you)
Thanks for the review! Insta360 has its advantages, but the problem with it - impossible to buy it (bummer). The delivery time of Insta360 Ace Pro 2 now is more than a month, and no guarantee, that it is true. So, among those 3 cameras - my favorite remains DJI Action 5 Pro. I use it almost every day, when I'm running or hiking.
Just checked your latest D-LOG review. Educative, and I would like to see also HLG test under different condition.
Your reviews of DJI OA5 Pro convinced me to buy one!
interesting, I ordered mine on launch day from insta360 and got it a week or so later (if I remember right) it is interesting that no stores have it in stock yet.
@@JakeSloan return it for a swap if I was you. Insta360 stopped selling them because the lens fogging issue, if it's not today maybe it will happen in the future.... Even a seller on Ali confirmed this, but Insta360 ignored it publicly!
"Hello, there are some issues with the lenses of the first batch of Insta360 Ace Pro 2, and the manufacturer is urgently recaling and repairing them."
I am still waiting for my preorder from a local shop.
@@sokarim Oh, interesting! That's must why impossible to buy this camera anywhere. Thanks!
You left out the shake test. I recently watched a video that that did a shake test with these 3 cameras and there were some significant variations in performance. The gopro did do very well. It makes me think you are skewing your review in favour of gopro.
Why the hell would I shake a camera? also I don't give a rip what camera you buy or don't buy. everything in this video is here to inform, make up your own mind
@JakeSloan I believe unbiased reviewers do the shake test to demonstrate an action cameras stabilization ability. Get on your mountain bike with an action camera and do a downhill run. Then tell me the shake test is irrelevant.
I liked the Action 5 Pro overall, GoPro is good in daylight, but contrasty, insta360 has an image processing problem. But the last part of the video was the best - Pocket 3 👑 .
I LOVE using the pocket 3, the image out of it is just so damn good
Whaa! How did you notice when looking on the small screen beside it's too bright unbelievable! 😅
lol. Test first then go and film the video
Amazing comparison. Thank you!
My pleasure!
What is true about ace pro 2 fogging issues and focus issues? Also lots of low light jittering which for me even the old ace pro does a better job....
I haven’t messed with the original ace pro so I can’t comment on it but I was surprised how poorly the new one did
Nice comparison. And yes, 8 bit color is consumer grade and 10 bit color is considered professional grade. If you ever want to color grade those 1 billion colors are going to give you a lot more to work with than 16.7 million. Should be called the Ace 2, not the Ace Pro 2.
exactly