I kinda think that there needs to be a inbetween of the two, 2019 sounds way to old, even though he is supposed to be a teenager but 90's sound like he's like 8 even though he is preteen.
I like both Snufkin VA's but I prefer the Moominvalley one more for two reasons. 1) It's a clever way to show that Snufkin is a traveller to give him a slight accent, especially a Nordic one. 2) His voice is smooth melted butter on my warm golden toast.
I can’t stand the old Little My her voice is so whiny and shrill That’s one reason why Snufkin going “you’ll soon find out” and menacingly snapping a twig is such a big mood for me lol
i love both audios so much! the original just has a cheerful feel to it that i adore and the new one has made such great choices with voice actors! i especially love snufkin’s new voice
Proof that family is family Its estonishing how the characters from both adaptations fit each other so well despite having slight differences (especially with Snufkin)
God I forget how much more tolerable Little My's voice is in Moominvalley. As much as I like how cheerful the old voices sound, the much more mature new ones ring out to me way more. Maybe because it was built for English instead of dubbed!
Little My is super abnoxious in the 90s version for sure and basically in every dub, but that's kinda her character. Though i agree new one is more tolerable and doesn't make your ears bleed after an episode.
i must say the 90s dub has its charm but the moominvalley voice actors just fit their roles so perfectly and really add to the serenity of the whole show
@@foamyj9028 since the voice actor is swedish it is pretty easy to just add a slight accent if we feel like doing so :0 I think that’s the case for the actor? Idk? Maybe?
What are these people on about under your comment? Snufkin’s voice actor has an accent. It’s a Swedish accent. Literally everyone in this world has an accent. I’m so confused. I really do love Snufkin’s accent, it’s so cute!
You know, when Moomin sounds younger it changes the dynamic between the two of them by making him seem like a kid that looks up to a reassuring adult instead of guy that wants to impress his friend.
Snufkin has never once sounded like the kid he's most likely meant to be. And if they're meant to be adults together, since they're the same age, Moomintroll has always sounded very chibi. Which is bizarre.
@@rappingbeaniedog347 Snufkin happens to have a low voice, and Snufkin also happens to be an orphan as far as he knows. We don't know what he was doing before meeting the Moomins, but with the way he lives it's not hard to assume he was alone. And a child left alone to raise himself in the wild will talk and act a bit more 'adult' than the average kid for obvious reasons. I'm surprised I saw no one point it out yet, everyone seems confused by Snufkin's gap between age and overall vibe, when the answer is right here
I love both of the 90s and the remake and many people are having a debate whether what Moomin show has the best voice actors. All I can gladly say is that I love the voice actors in both shows. Everyone has its own charm and cuteness to it and both deserve all the love and praise :> So please don't argue over who has the best voice actors, it is a little sad how many people are starting to argue over a nonexistent problem :(
I love Taron's voice for Moomin, it fits him a lot better than the 90's even though I like the 90s Moomins better. But for Snufkin I actually REALLY love the Polish voice actor, idk
Both if snufkin's voices are great! And I can easily see the 2019 voice being the older version of 90 moonins voice its really cute Thank you for putting so much time into this it came out wonderful
19 snufkin sounds very awkward to me. And Moomin as well. They wanted to make him sound more mature but now he acts like a big baby. They could have done a better job in my opinion
3:36 “Yes, you might be very handsome but that dosen’t mean I want you around all the time.” I think im understanding this sentence differently than how it’s supposed to be-
The cast for Moominvalley has outdone themselves; Their voices fit perfectly with the characters. However, I would love to see New Snufkin with Old Snufkin's voice. Both are lovely, however I do have some bias towards his old voice.
I feel like the voice acting for Moominvalley is perfect, and almost made for the show and atmosphere it has. However Edvin Endre fits 90s Snufkin alot somehow.
I love the 2019 voice acting! To me, the 90s version is like theyre still children and the 2019 seemed like theyre already adults (even though both have the characters at a ambiguous age)
It’s so weird that if they swapped voices where how the shows actually were I wouldn’t have liked either show anywhere near as much. (Except moominvalley’s snufkin’s voice is perfect for him in any version imo lol) I wasn’t sure about the moominvalley voices when I first heard them, but now I feel like there perfect for the show where they look older. Also, great editing on this!!
They fits soooooo good even when they are swapped!! I forgot what i was watching few times. I especially love old Little My with new voice. Snufkin is too good and feels right in any version, but i personally prefer 90s one.
Am I the only one who actually prefers the 90s voice acting? I just think that it gives each character more personality with different accents and ways of speaking. When everyone speaks the same way it's harder to tell who's talking and makes the dialogue so bland.
The thing about the 90's voicework is that it's a dub, which makes some of the English translation and even the acting somewhat forced. However, the voices themselves are very good and appropriate. If there was no translation or rewriting of the script, i.e. the script and animation were made from scratch in English, then it would be perfect.
i love all the new voices. not only are they generally very pleasing to the ear, they fit the characters too. and i like that snufkin, moomin, and little my all sound similar in age, whereas moomin's high pitched 90's voice made him seem much younger. the 2019 adaptation still plays with the idea that moomin is still growing up but not in the way where he sounds like a prepubescent child lol and i think that matches moomin's character from the novel as well. as for snufkin i just love his new voice. i like that that he has a different accent than those in the valley too, it's a good way to characterize him as someone who traveled there from afar. the voice acting is one of the strongest parts of the newest adaptation in my personal opinion. maybe an unpopular opinion but i struggled to get past most of the english dub of the 90s anime
"yes you might be very handsome but that doesn't mean I want you around all the time don't you see there's Moomintroll to think of, what am I going to do with you" w h a t ARE WE GONNA IGNORE THAT?
Mumintroll's 2019 voice in the 1990's version is like watching the Swedish or Finnish versions of it. It's weird how much younger he sounds in English. I guess it's cuz he's voiced by a woman in the Japanese version...but that's true of even fully grown adult men so long as they're immature (28-year-old Kenshin Himura from Rurōni Kenshin, 17-year-old Luffy from One Piece), so it's hard to say how old he's supposed to sound in that. Also, thank you for this. You must've put a lot of effort into it. Good job!
LOVE THIS! I need more!! I think the vocies work well for snufkin but not so much for moomin, but I think mainly because moomins 90's voice is very chidlike whereas 2019 moominvalley everyone seems to be a little older. I love both versions, and in fact was really surprised at how much I enjoyed the 2019 moominvalley; it's different and I think thats what I like about it, especially the soundtrack! I love the 90's music but it feels very dated. x
@@jocelynecupcake I have to disagree, I'm my opinion it doesn't sound older it's just sounds different because of his accent. I think both versions of snufkin sound fairly young but I think if they made his voice more childish it would get irritating quickly, I'm not 100% sure but I think snufkin is suppose to be older than Moomin anyway. I think his voice suits his personality very well.
I'm going to have to be real with you, seeing 90's Snufkin with the 2019 voice made me pause. I got so used to deep voice that when I was expecting the soft voice I still was shook.
2019 Little My: I find out what you're hiding you tricksy old bean bag _glares_ 90s Little My: *I SEE IT MOOMIN DONT LIE TO ME! WHY ARE YOU HIDING IT DAMMIT!!!!*
Taron Egerton is excellent as Moomin. Makes him sound like still a teenager, but I slightly older one than how he sounds in the 90s version. His accent is also 👌👌👌
Okay like the voice actors are doing a great job, but I just wish y'all knew what you were missing; Moomin is just *meant* to be in Fennoswedish. The best I can explain it is that they all sound like philosophers and Snufkin especially is just completely different. The language and their rhythm completely changes the context hh
Dragon: completely and clearly visible
Moomintroll: show urself
Issa dragon :DD
“sHow YourSEEEEEELf”
@@melodytheatre2887 retch frozen 2
1:09
The way he says it and his eyes narrow gives it a little malicious quality to it
90’s Moomin: everyone babie except snufkin
Moominvalley: no one babie except snufkin
You've summed it up perfectly
Exactly !! But in the _original_ japanese version snufkin's slightly more babie ua-cam.com/play/PLiX-gswuFBSd3qnawcqlRyqhnu_FRKLkC.html
The old voice of snufkin on the new snufkin is like seeing a toddler with a 40-year old man’s voice
Brooke it I love his voice but its kinda true
Exactly. 90s Snufkin feels like a grown man, while 19 Snufkin seems a lot younger.
Which is funny considering the fact that thr characters in Moominvalley are canonly older than in the 90s series
But they look the same age to me...
@@Schwarzorn me too LMAO
i love how goblin-y little my’s 90’s voice is. but damn, “tricksy old beanbag” is one of the best insults i’ve ever heard.
I will be adding that to my insult list
Also your pfp makes me soft
*trickthy*
agreed
*_"In your room, you say?"_*
i’m sad there’s no equivalent of the ‘in your room you say’ face in the original animated version
There is
"I'll TeLl YoU laTer~"
I love how you can say "in your room you say face" and everyone knows what you mean this fandom is gold
Streifen Demon love that one
@@streifendemon1089 YAS
@@vampireactually yes Imao
to be fair, i think taron has the perfect voice for moomintroll it just fits so well. i still love the old one though!
I totally agree!
I hate the new voice, I don't think it fits at all. Definitely prefer the 90s voices
I like both :)
Dude I never even knew Taron voiced MOOMINTROLL?! Its my favourite actor and my favourite show but I never put two and two togeyher
I kinda think that there needs to be a inbetween of the two, 2019 sounds way to old, even though he is supposed to be a teenager but 90's sound like he's like 8 even though he is preteen.
I feel like snufkin’s voice works switched but moomintroll’s is so weird switched lmao
I agree
I actually feel like snufkin's respective voices actually fit _better_ this way round, somehow?
Lexi Lala , I could see that
Moomin’s new voice makes him sound a older and more mature which I quite like. Makes him and Snufkin feel closer in age.
Totally agree!
Snufkin’s voice is perfect no matter what
I like both Snufkin VA's but I prefer the Moominvalley one more for two reasons.
1) It's a clever way to show that Snufkin is a traveller to give him a slight accent, especially a Nordic one.
2) His voice is smooth melted butter on my warm golden toast.
I totally agree
Best description I ever heard
On your toast, you say?
Hehe yes
@@CadetHedo Matt Berry: "YES"
Why did the voice actor for 90s little my decide just screaming louder and louder was a suitable emotion for her to have at all times
it isn't?
I think it was like a joke about little kids being loud? Especially mischevious angsty ones
It's too much like real life
I can’t stand the old Little My her voice is so whiny and shrill
That’s one reason why Snufkin going “you’ll soon find out” and menacingly snapping a twig is such a big mood for me lol
Silver Shadow which makes no sense because little my is older than snufkin lmao
Snufkin's voice works switched. moomintroll's....not so much xD
aside from the accents, they're practically interchangeable.
eh, 2019 moomin actually has a deep voice, just like the finnish version i grew up with haha
Mags I think they were trying to make Moomintroll sound more like a little kid in the anime dub
No I think snufkins voice doesn't work switched
@@danjoredd It's perfect 😾
i love both audios so much! the original just has a cheerful feel to it that i adore and the new one has made such great choices with voice actors! i especially love snufkin’s new voice
Same, moomin sounds a lot more mature now
Proof that family is family
Its estonishing how the characters from both adaptations fit each other so well despite having slight differences (especially with Snufkin)
Dragons, they do as they like. They see a fat fly somewhere and they forget everything else. That's dragons for you. Not very loyal.
Thank you for you wisdom, ancient dragon whisperer.
Why do I feel like you know this from experience.
Snufkin be like these hoes ain't loyal 😤
God I forget how much more tolerable Little My's voice is in Moominvalley. As much as I like how cheerful the old voices sound, the much more mature new ones ring out to me way more. Maybe because it was built for English instead of dubbed!
I was really surprised the first time I heard 90's Little My's voice. She was so loud! >_< But I miss it now. Both voices suit her in different ways.
Both. Both is good.
Little My is super abnoxious in the 90s version for sure and basically in every dub, but that's kinda her character. Though i agree new one is more tolerable and doesn't make your ears bleed after an episode.
'I'll find you out, you tricksy old beanbag' really sold the new voice actor for me, it was still sassy and cute but not intolerable
The English dub's script is so good, tho, that' it's impossible to even know it wasn't originally in English. That script wowwed me constantly.
i must say the 90s dub has its charm but the moominvalley voice actors just fit their roles so perfectly and really add to the serenity of the whole show
KEDAMONO
90s: BABY
2019's: Intellectual BBy
Zephyrus_anim8 wouldn’t that be like late 2010’s
The editing is honestly really great. Good job :)
Also, while i really like the 2019 voices, especially Snufkin's, i would say i like the 1990's more
Thank you! :3
me too I also love the Japanese voice more
me too perkele
same! i feel like they fit the characters better. not that the 2019 ones don't though
hailey coppock I honestly felt the opposite. I feel like the 2019 voices fit more than the 90s ones and sound more natural when they’re talking.
snufkin: *slight accent*
me: 😭😭❤️❤️👏👏👏👏👏😔😔❤️❤️👶👶👶👶
Rebecca Majik _THE BIGGEST MOOD_
Kinda strange bc his voice actor doesn’t seem to have an accent at all?
Snufkin’s accent seems to change a bit.
Finally, someone other than me has pointed it out. I always wondered how that worked since his voice actor doesn’t even have one lol
@@foamyj9028 since the voice actor is swedish it is pretty easy to just add a slight accent if we feel like doing so :0
I think that’s the case for the actor? Idk? Maybe?
What are these people on about under your comment? Snufkin’s voice actor has an accent. It’s a Swedish accent. Literally everyone in this world has an accent. I’m so confused. I really do love Snufkin’s accent, it’s so cute!
i love both of snufkin’s voices. the 2019 one’s accent gets my heart. 90s moomin will always be my favorite
I DIDNT REALIZE HOW SIMILAR THESE SCENES WERE TILL NOW! Also this is awesome editing it lines up well!
You know, when Moomin sounds younger it changes the dynamic between the two of them by making him seem like a kid that looks up to a reassuring adult instead of guy that wants to impress his friend.
"friend" ahem, boyfriend
@@WylieMyers1007 nah, Bfriend
Snufkin has never once sounded like the kid he's most likely meant to be. And if they're meant to be adults together, since they're the same age, Moomintroll has always sounded very chibi. Which is bizarre.
@@rappingbeaniedog347 Snufkin happens to have a low voice, and Snufkin also happens to be an orphan as far as he knows. We don't know what he was doing before meeting the Moomins, but with the way he lives it's not hard to assume he was alone. And a child left alone to raise himself in the wild will talk and act a bit more 'adult' than the average kid for obvious reasons.
I'm surprised I saw no one point it out yet, everyone seems confused by Snufkin's gap between age and overall vibe, when the answer is right here
I like the 90s show much more but i think the moomin valley voices fit more
I think the 90s voice fit them better and I do like the 90's one best
Me too cause its a total mood
I agree
i didnt know i needed this until now
Same
Feels strange and at the same time perfect
That’s actually really cool you’ve got some cool skills there
Thank you! C:
I love both of the 90s and the remake and many people are having a debate whether what Moomin show has the best voice actors. All I can gladly say is that I love the voice actors in both shows. Everyone has its own charm and cuteness to it and both deserve all the love and praise :>
So please don't argue over who has the best voice actors, it is a little sad how many people are starting to argue over a nonexistent problem :(
Thank you!! I agree c:
I personally prefer the older moomin, it just had its own charm. But the newer one isnt bad at all :)
The 90’s Snufkin is 100% an extrovert playing an introvert character.
I love Taron's voice for Moomin, it fits him a lot better than the 90's even though I like the 90s Moomins better. But for Snufkin I actually REALLY love the Polish voice actor, idk
Honestly i like both, they fit in so well the cartoon style even if they are so different. It's hard to choose a favorite
The 2019 opening reminds me of sims music
Wtf no
It kind of does!
omg yeah... but i rlly like it
Hear 90's snufkin voice in 2019 snufkin is WHOOSSH!
Both if snufkin's voices are great!
And I can easily see the 2019 voice being the older version of 90 moonins voice its really cute
Thank you for putting so much time into this it came out wonderful
Gotta say that I do like the 2019 voices better but the 90’s voice acting has its own charm.😊
Edit: How the hell did this get 1,000 likes?!
Agreed
Yup
I agree. The characters- especially Snufkin- seem to have way more personality. That's my opinion, atleast.
I like the 2019 Moomintroll more because they made him sound more mature
19 snufkin sounds very awkward to me. And Moomin as well. They wanted to make him sound more mature but now he acts like a big baby. They could have done a better job in my opinion
3:36 “Yes, you might be very handsome but that dosen’t mean I want you around all the time.”
I think im understanding this sentence differently than how it’s supposed to be-
The cast for Moominvalley has outdone themselves; Their voices fit perfectly with the characters.
However, I would love to see New Snufkin with Old Snufkin's voice. Both are lovely, however I do have some bias towards his old voice.
Omg I love this so much!!!! The editing is so good!!
Thank you so much! C:
I like snufkin’s old voice better, but I enjoy them both
I feel like the voice acting for Moominvalley is perfect, and almost made for the show and atmosphere it has. However Edvin Endre fits 90s Snufkin alot somehow.
I love the 2019 voice acting! To me, the 90s version is like theyre still children and the 2019 seemed like theyre already adults (even though both have the characters at a ambiguous age)
It’s so weird that if they swapped voices where how the shows actually were I wouldn’t have liked either show anywhere near as much. (Except moominvalley’s snufkin’s voice is perfect for him in any version imo lol)
I wasn’t sure about the moominvalley voices when I first heard them, but now I feel like there perfect for the show where they look older.
Also, great editing on this!!
Thank you! C:
Perfect! All I need to be completely satisfied is 2019 voice Moomintroll in 90's animation asking Snufkin where is his hat.
all snufkin's voices sound comfy in their own way
1990S ANIMATION WITH 2019 VOICES MAKES ME GO YIP YIP
Personally I love the 90's voices, they're very cute lmao
3:20 to 3:47 fits SO SO WELL its satisfying i love it
Combining the 1990's title screen and the 2019's theme was beautifuly merged.
Thank you! C:
I personally like it
They fits soooooo good even when they are swapped!! I forgot what i was watching few times. I especially love old Little My with new voice. Snufkin is too good and feels right in any version, but i personally prefer 90s one.
Am I the only one who actually prefers the 90s voice acting?
I just think that it gives each character more personality with different accents and ways of speaking. When everyone speaks the same way it's harder to tell who's talking and makes the dialogue so bland.
The thing about the 90's voicework is that it's a dub, which makes some of the English translation and even the acting somewhat forced. However, the voices themselves are very good and appropriate. If there was no translation or rewriting of the script, i.e. the script and animation were made from scratch in English, then it would be perfect.
I agree
I think the 2019 voices are alright, but I just love 90's Snufkin's voice so much!
I love both shows, but I prefer the dialogue and voices a bit more in Moomin Valley.
Omg the new voice of Snufkin with the 90s Moomin animation is somehow SO CUTE?!
I adore Snufkin's new voice sooooo muchh (even though I love the old one too)❤❤❤
I laughed so hard when moomintroll say i gottem i gottem, its just funny! My brain didn't expected that
90’s Snufkin: *Anything or anyone harms MoominTroll* So you have chosen death.
* *thouroughly confused* *
90's Snufkin with 2019 Snufkin's voice is a whole aesthetic
Little My has two distinctly different voices yet I love them equally
i love all the new voices. not only are they generally very pleasing to the ear, they fit the characters too. and i like that snufkin, moomin, and little my all sound similar in age, whereas moomin's high pitched 90's voice made him seem much younger. the 2019 adaptation still plays with the idea that moomin is still growing up but not in the way where he sounds like a prepubescent child lol and i think that matches moomin's character from the novel as well. as for snufkin i just love his new voice. i like that that he has a different accent than those in the valley too, it's a good way to characterize him as someone who traveled there from afar. the voice acting is one of the strongest parts of the newest adaptation in my personal opinion. maybe an unpopular opinion but i struggled to get past most of the english dub of the 90s anime
I LOVE THIS SO MUCH. This is perfect ahhhh
1:02 funny to see him jumping around and WHISPERING
90's snufkin with 2019 snufkin's voice was something i never knew i needed
I just love the fact that snufkin passed up the opportunity to have a dragon with him all because it made moomin upset
"yes you might be very handsome but that doesn't mean I want you around all the time don't you see there's Moomintroll to think of, what am I going to do with you"
w h a t
ARE WE GONNA IGNORE THAT?
Little My popping out of a tea pot is a mood
Mumintroll's 2019 voice in the 1990's version is like watching the Swedish or Finnish versions of it. It's weird how much younger he sounds in English. I guess it's cuz he's voiced by a woman in the Japanese version...but that's true of even fully grown adult men so long as they're immature (28-year-old Kenshin Himura from Rurōni Kenshin, 17-year-old Luffy from One Piece), so it's hard to say how old he's supposed to sound in that.
Also, thank you for this. You must've put a lot of effort into it. Good job!
LOVE THIS! I need more!! I think the vocies work well for snufkin but not so much for moomin, but I think mainly because moomins 90's voice is very chidlike whereas 2019 moominvalley everyone seems to be a little older. I love both versions, and in fact was really surprised at how much I enjoyed the 2019 moominvalley; it's different and I think thats what I like about it, especially the soundtrack! I love the 90's music but it feels very dated. x
Little older? LOL He sounds older than 90's Snufkin! 90's Moomin, Moomin sounds like a kid and Snufkin sounds 30! And in Moominvalley it's vise versa
@@jocelynecupcake I have to disagree, I'm my opinion it doesn't sound older it's just sounds different because of his accent. I think both versions of snufkin sound fairly young but I think if they made his voice more childish it would get irritating quickly, I'm not 100% sure but I think snufkin is suppose to be older than Moomin anyway. I think his voice suits his personality very well.
Never have I ever seen something so blessed yet so cursed.
Love this! It would be cool to see an audio swap of the Snufkin vs. the Park Keeper moments
I'm going to have to be real with you, seeing 90's Snufkin with the 2019 voice made me pause. I got so used to deep voice that when I was expecting the soft voice I still was shook.
I. LOVE. THIS!
What a great idea, and a sweet li'l video! ♡
i feel like 2019 snufkin’s voice fits his character way better, but 90’s snufkin is iconic
i love snufkin’s 90’s voice so much
2019 Little My: I find out what you're hiding you tricksy old bean bag _glares_
90s Little My: *I SEE IT MOOMIN DONT LIE TO ME! WHY ARE YOU HIDING IT DAMMIT!!!!*
Why am I getting recommended Moonmin Valley?
And why the hell is Snufkin's voice so smooth?
I'm questioning everything
omggg it's so weird to hear their voices being swapped like this! you start to see that voice casting for each version was done the right way :D
What if Snufkin’s old voice actor comes back to voice Joxter in the reboot?
0:02 The soundtrack is @-@;;;♡
Oh wow the editing is amazing!
Very e pi c
Thank you! C:
I love the new opening song so much! This was a great video
I miss old Little My's voice~ she's so iconic. She just brings this smile to my face every time she opens her mouth lol.
Let's be real, Snufkin is the reason to watch either show.
Taron Egerton is excellent as Moomin. Makes him sound like still a teenager, but I slightly older one than how he sounds in the 90s version. His accent is also 👌👌👌
“in yOur RoOm yOu sAy???”
Aww! 90s Snufkin with 19 Snufkin's voice is so cute!!!
I prefer Snufkin’s old voice. I feel like it fits his chill but snarky personality a lot more.
I THOUGHT IT WAS A COMPARISON AND FREAKED OUT WHEN I HEARD IT SHS
I think the new voice actor for Moomin is better. Mostly because I’m a Swede and more used to Moomin a voice being darker and more mature.
It's official... i love them both!
I must be old and stubborn. I like the older series better in every way, but this was a really fun comparison!
this is trippy
I prefer the 90s since I grew watching it
Especially Snufkin and Moomin's voice
Okay like the voice actors are doing a great job, but I just wish y'all knew what you were missing; Moomin is just *meant* to be in Fennoswedish. The best I can explain it is that they all sound like philosophers and Snufkin especially is just completely different. The language and their rhythm completely changes the context hh
Somehow, I feel like 90s Moomin has the superior.... Everything.
This makes me realize 90’s mooning is so much better
Moomin's new voice is weird because I saw the old one first. Idk haha. Nice editing though, you did a great job.
i watched s1 and im used to it now
The Snufkins sound good either way, but the Moomintroll voices oughta stay in their own version