Alex was quoted as saying, "Blah, blah, blah... Blah, BLAW, blaw, blaw". Haha, sorry, I just had to. I really like your post with that quote. I know what Neil is talking about, and I can solve easy equations and cannot run a marathon. Those 3 guys did all that for decades on end in the face of adversity and oceans of dimwits.
Any version of rush is the right version. Ageless classics. I like live too! im only 25 and lucky enough to see them 4 times. You can't go wrong either way with Rush
I remember when Rush came to Brazil for the second time. I couldn't go the first time because I was a fucked broken high school student and they played in São Paulo and Rio, which are, around 2000km from my city (Recife). So, I just got an internship and with the first salary of my life I bought tickets for a flight to São Paulo and for the concert. I will never forget that October 8th, 2010. It totally worth it. I went with some of my best friends to the date. Rush is the only thing which is an unanimity among us. :)
Remember Geddy’s playing bass , singing, playing the foot pedals and the keyboards , sometimes all of them at the same time!! There is no one like these 3 gentleman! and you will never see it again! Truly the best musicians and humans of all time!
As a fan since '79, I know everything they created was a miracle and I'm insanely grateful to have grown up and seen them live 32 times...to this day I still tear up 😢 listening and realizing their will never be another band like RUSH...A FAREWELL TO KINGS!
Yes, Geddy had chickens roasting back there. He started using the house amps and his side of the stage was empty so he had dryers, chicken roasters, popcorn makers, great fun 😂
With Rush, both studio and live versions are well worth it. Rush's studio production value is as extraordinary as their live proficiency. I feel hearing the studio version gives you a better perspective on their live performances and both are reaction worthy.
Geddy does at times play synth with his feet while singing and playing the bass. By Moving Pictures, he added the keyboards for his hands. Still has the foot moog, jumping back and forth. 3 genius virtuosos.
In the early and mid 1990's Neil Peart started taking lessons from 2 different Jazz drum teachers. This was after he had been voted the #1 rock drummer several years in a row. He felt his drumming was getting stagnant so he took lessons! He went through a phase after these lessons of playing primarily with a traditional grip instead of his usual matchstick grip. This was also after he had organized and played in Buddy Rich Tributes in the late 80's and early 90's. Buddy Rich's daughter asked Neil Peart to do this after Rich's death. Buddy Rich was one of Peart's idols. You should search UA-cam for Peart playing "Cotton Tail" at one of these tributes. He incorporates parts of his drum solo parts into this jazz tune. If you watch Peart's drum solos (especially the solo in Frankfurt, Germany) towards the end he incorporates "Big Band" samples and you can see video of Buddy Rich, Gene Kruppa and other jazz drumming legends on the screen behind him. So, yes you are correct - Peart had strong jazz influences in his drumming style.
9:21 "Ahhhhgggggg... this guy, this guy, jeez" That is the correct answer Church, for all three members. Just found your channel, love it so far, THANKS!!
The studio versions are the ones we listen to (mostly), but the live versions, while most of the time having some cool changes from show to show, are just insanely impressive. Like yeah I can see how you can play YYZ in the studio but like...on stage? Back to back to back and it sounds just as good every time? Come on now.
HOW🤯DO THEY DO THAT? Playing with such ferocity, tight, technically perfect to the album AND for THREE HOURS EVERY NIGHT! Next level musicianship.👌✌️🤘🥁🎸🎹🎤
Hearing you rave (correctly) about how these guys could put a concert in a single song reminds me of something to recommend to you. It's a video known as "Best Intro Ever," which consists of an instrumental medley of six of their older songs (from the first six albums) leading into one of their classics (which led off the seventh album), The Spirit of Radio. If I recall correctly, you already reacted to the studio version, but - perhaps obviously - this one isn't just worth it; it's a must see.
And just like that, this guy just became a better musician in whatever genre he is into. Rush has been doing that for millions musicians around the world for many decades.
To try and cover Geddy with all he does on stage live (singing, bass, keys, foot pedals etc) would be pretty close to impossible, he is truly one of a kind and in a class all by himself. In regards to the rotisserie chicken. Geddy plays through the PA system. Alex tours with his amps and speakers, (as a joke) Geddy uses props like washing machines and vending machines to balance the stage. Rush imo is the greatest or pretty darn close to the best live band on the planet. Their concerts run up to 3hrs long. With over 40 yrs of touring, there will be mistakes here or there , equiptment failures etc but for the most part, Rush is spot when it comes to live on stage. Neil was influence by jazz drummer Buddy Rich. Generally at every concert Neil will perform a drum solo for the fans. Try Neil Peart drum solo live in Frankfurt or Maligant Narcissism which is followed by a drum solo from snakes and arrows tour. I believe the YT video is about 10 to 11 mins long. I like the studio version of Digital Man vs live. It's not that the live is bad, I just find the mix a bit muddy and for Digital Man, I want to hear Geddy's bass cut through.
YEP!!! Just in the 'YYZ/Rio' version, the background SYNTH at the beginning is almost inaudible, the HARMONICS at the end of one of Geddy's 'Solo Riffs' is either pulled off, or just can't be heard, etc. Those little subleties......... There's a popular T.Sawyer Live version where the mix is too BASS-HEAVY. It's nice to hear Ged thumping like that, but the whole MIX is off from WHAT'S INTENDED!
Watch the drum cam version of Digital Man at that concert. Then ending and outro trumps are exceptional! I was lucky enough to see 6 RUSH concerts, including SnA.
Alex’s guitar is heavily modified. It has a piezoelectric pickup on the bridge which, when it’s switched on, gives it that acoustic sound. Gibson and Epiphone have an Alex Lifeson signature series with the piezo pickup and a Floyd rose tremolo.
Yea sir, those were Rotisserie Chickens out there! When Geddy started running his sound thru the board his side of the stage got empty! Since Alex wanted to keep his stacks, as a joke, Geddy acquired some washers and dryers! There is also vending machines and popcorn poppers! It started as a joke, but became a real thing!! Be well and God bless…from Texas!!
Yes, chicken. Why wouldn't a band have rotisserie chicken on stage with them? ;) It's an upgrade from the washers and dryers. Whatever equipment they need to make this amazing music! Check out Rush Best Intro Ever!!!!! (another amazing live performance)
Rush Neil Peart trained with Freddie Gruber As time passed, he began to emulate jazz and big band musicians Gene Krupa and Buddy Rich. In 1994, Peart became a friend and pupil of jazz instructor Freddie Gruber. It was during this time that Peart revamped his playing style by incorporating jazz and swing components.  en.m.wikipedia.org › wiki Neil Peart - Wikipedia
He's the only musician I've ever heard openly admit to taking lessons as a working musician - he said in his book Traveling Music that Freddy Gruber took him all the way down to rudiments - and that was after he was widely acclaimed as one of the best drummers in the world. 🤯🤯🤯
Church Boy, I can't thank you enough for reacting to my #1 Rush song Live. I saw Rush play this 5 times. I was blown away every time. You want to see a young Rush the song "Anthem" Live 1975. It's my favorite song on Fly by Night album. Neil's first album he wrote when he joined the band in June of 1974. Alex Liveson is a phenomenal guitarist. ❤🔥
Thank you for recognizing the immense talent of my favorite band and I love that you go to church. I love that you love God and rush. Can’t get much better than God and rush, strings and sticks baby.
Studio vs live - Why not Both? Studio first gives you a baseline for appreciating the creative changes and live reproduction of the original track in live performances. Please don't confine yourself to Live versions. I love Rush live performances, but the studio versions and studio production of songs are amazing in their own right. Really enjoying your reactions, on this Rush journey. Keep up the good work.
You never go wrong with Rush live.. true tallent shows when you are live... you can't hide. For me their most beautiful live performance after 20 abums is the last song of the last album.. Go watch it, it's called The Garden from clockwork angels tour... it's farewell song that capture the essence of life... Spoiler quote from the song «The measure of a life is a measure of love and respect, so hard to earn so easily burned» this gives me chills every time. I love your reactions, you know about musicianship and we can tell that you see right away what is special of this band.
The true energy of Rush often comes through best in the live tracks. With YYZ for example, the live in Rio track is BY FAR the best you will hear. Nothing like 60000 fans singing an instrumental song, LOL! Great reaction! Keep them coming!
Neil worked hard on his Jazz skills! He took time off shortly before the time frame to reinvent his technique with a famous Jazz instructor. That was after being widely considered the greatest rock drummer ever. He was a huge Buddy Rich fan, and used to host events in his honor.
Thanks for giving Alex his due, so under appreciated. The reason to listen to this song and others from the studio versions is to hone in on all three elements, especially the bass riffs. On this song they are unbelievable! Geddy, Alex, and Neal are playing their own riffs within riffs within their songs.
"a concert in one song" welcome to Prog. :D If you can make the time, please read Geddy's book, "My Effin' Life". He does a great job describing how their albums were made and how Alex just unconsciously came up with his riffs.
All the studio versions are great. The live versions are where it lives and breathes. Good all the way around. I know, I did both for decades. RUSH Night was always very special. It’s a huge vibe live!
2112... studio version also Headlong Flight with the video showing the flying dudes, and last but not least The Garden.... it was last song listed on their last album - "Clockwork Angels" Many felt it was Neil's way of saying goodbye as he passed on about years later. I can't listen to it without tearing up. For me he was in the same category of gifted songwriters like Bob Dylan, John, Paul, George, Neil Young & on the female side - like Melanie, Joni Mitchell
Another amazing reaction!👏!! This is one of my all-time favorite songs and this album (Permanent Waves), is my favorite. I really appreciate your analysis, especially since you are a musician. This band has always amazed me, how they showcase their individual talents, yet still manage to stay so cohesive. Three of the greatest musicians.....ever(RIP...NP)
Necromancer elements in Natural Science. You can listen to them back to back and realize how great Necromancer is. Caress of Steel is weird but amazingly fantastic.
CB - Seeing you geek out on RUSH reminds me of someone who recently found faith. Just a blown away excitement level. Like a little kid. I love playing this song on my Les Paul. Especially the chord progressions at the beginning. I’m a long way from Alex but the tones coming out of my amp always give me goosebumps. Check out “Camera Eye” sometime. There is an excellent repeating riff/groove in that song you’ll love. Lots of tempo changes.
If you want to see pure musicianship watch Rush the greatest opening ever. The way they move between songs seamlessly is amazing your mind will be blown.
Just saw an interview with Alex and when asked what Rush song was the most difficult to play he said "All of them" but then specifically mentioned this one as challenging.
My friend, a RUSH concert was a 3 hour long feast for your ears and eyes. Between 27 and 30 songs a night. RUSH Songs. And they make it look sooo easy.
Rush is great live but the studio sessions. The studio versions can be often more clear and concise. You don’t have to worry about crowd noise so I hope you’re gonna do the studio version of natural science. I really look forward to your reaction. OK ciao
There is only ONE LIVE VERSION of a Rush song that sounds better than the studio version, and that is the song Working Man from the live album recorded in ‘76 All The World’s A Stage, where you really hear the difference between Neil Peart and John Rutsey, their first drummer.
Red barchetta, subdivisions, entre nous, nobody´s hero, cut the chase, marathon, etc etc Rush catalog is just awesome; and yes live versions are great ALWAYS
Another awesome reaction! I just love that you pick up on the minutae from an instrumental standpoint: Alex’s delicate harmonics that set the stage for the attack of the guitar that would ensue, to bring home and echo the statement made by Neil’s lyrics- profound! Geddy playing and jumping while singing delicate yet high emotionally pitched words that speak to the grandeur of life(however it got here!), then ridding a killer pentatonic bass riff… oufff. Neil Peart, the professor in the drums and with pen…, What a miraculous trio to grace the stage while we were here with them to witness this grandeaur all along. RIP NEP, you were an amazing human being, and it’s my hope and prayer that you live in Light’s embrace🙏
I'm a fan of Rush since 1977, I've seen them live and the only criticism I have is that if you look at live performance of Rush don't if it's after 2000-2005 because Geddy's voice is broken and he can't hit the notes anymore. For decades he sang out of his range so in later years he paid for it. If you feel like listening to other bands that play a concert in one song try old Genesis, a song like Supper's Ready or The Battle of Epping Forest. Prog Rock for life.
Yep! OLD Rush was built on Ged's voice. Some of the APEX MOMENTS in some songs are lost. If you know Alex's 'VICTOR' album, you know Lisa Dalbello. At first, I thought she might be Geddy. For a time, I was wishing they got another singer but I understand.
Thank you for finally doing live! A lot of the magic of a live rush show (other than they are almost perfect to album when playing live) is the crowd... never been to other concerts where 50,000 people will sing every song perfectly.. it's like a giant family get together.
"Living in their pools, they soon forget about the sea." It's kinda like how people living in their bubbles today in the West when before there was a bigger sense of unity and of purpose.
Yes chickens! Geddy said in an interview that he runs direct line into the house, so he needed something to fill up the stage. One tour they had dryers that had shirts in them that they threw into the crowd. The chickens are real and get donated to local shelters after the show.
Welcome to the real Rush rabbit hole... You have entered the Rush zone that you should find a live version for your first listen if you can. Why? Because you need to feel how they play together. Studio versions are cleaner and better if you want to learn the lyrics. But Rush was always built as a live band. Any Rush fan can tell you, you can hear different things if you focus on each instrument. The reason we can listen to Rush over and over is because you discover new things everytime you listen. Listening to them live is always a treat. Not only does the rabbit hole go from studio vs. live.... It goes from LIVE vs LIVE.... and yes I can tell you which live version it is most of the time.
Man, I gotta get to your church if you’re pulling Rush riffs! Seriously, if you’re comfortable sharing, I’d love to swing by and hear you play. I know God has given you a special talent because you are picking up key sigs, time changes, modes, harmonics, etc. or if you guys live stream services, I for sure would tune in. For His Glory! Love your channel and your reactions.
Thanks for reacting to one of my favorite live Rush performances! (The 1997 version from the Molson Ampitheatre might be my favorite version). Also, while there are no synths in this song, when there are keyboard parts, Geddy plays those (as well as foot pedals when he is playing bass). Truly a musical multitasker! For a future reaction, I suggest the live version of 'Digital Man' from the Snakes and Arrows tour.
Don’t shun the studio versions because a lot of their earlier stuff wasn’t played live in the later years. RUSH is one of those rare bands that sounded good in the studio and live. I recommend you listen to the studio version of a song first, then check it out live, if available. Love your reactions, it’s fantastic to see a musician appreciate RUSH and totally get it! Keep ‘em coming!
Neil played in the Buddie Rich tribute concert....Deffinatly check that out!!!!!! You 'll see him play jazz with a big band!!!!!..Love the reaction and the channel, God Bless.
The reason you hear that acoustic guitar sound out of his electric is he has a piezo built into the bridge of his guitar with a separate output jack that goes into an acoustic amp. Also the craziest part to me is these guys DIDNT play to a click track, how they stayed in time so well is beyond insane
Thank you for another great reaction. I so appreciate your acknowledgement of Alex. Most reactors don't even mention him during his solos! Correction: Geddy also plays the synth and keys while singing and playing bass. He is using his feet and sometimes moves the mic with his oversized nose. Each of these musicians are aliens. Neil Peart's hero was Buddy Rich, so he learned jazz drumming from Freddie Gruber and ended up cutting a collaborative album called "Burning For Buddy" featuring other rock drummers who were also inspired by Rich.
Hey man, such sweet compositions from Rush that I've listened to for 35 plus years- to hear you pick up your bass and even though you say you're slaughtering it you're so freaking close it's awesome man! Your reactions are excellent, no other channels doing that- thank you, I really dig it. I picked up a used electric bass few months ago I've been plucking around but your ability and Ear inspire me to learn more. Thanks again! Song suggestions- The Camera Eye- The Enemy Within- Here Again- Jacobs ladder- as appetizers...
That's why you need to watch YYZ live in RIO - the crowd sings to the music. I prefer the live versions for most songs, but we'll let you know which song you should listen to live. Growing up, we heard the studio versions first, so I don't know which would be better for a newcomer. They are hilarious too. Loving your reactions to my favorite band!
I saw on your face, a couple of times during this, that sudden urge to just say, "F*** it!" and sell off all your instruments. Am I right??? These three Canadians are just riDICulous!!! What talent! What tightness! What invention!!
It's fun watching you experience them for the first time, and I'm a bit jealous! I was 12 when I first heard them (1980). Probably didn't appreciate them as much as I would have as a first-time adult listener.
Don't get too concerned about which version you listen to. It is just so much fun watching you discover Rush just as we did back in hte day. Keep doing what you're doing.
"Strings and sticks" plus Alex and Geddy both play Taurus pedals... Geddy, whilst singing and playing the bass! Neil also triggers some sounds, if the others are too busy.
Actually is good to hear studio first so you hear their perfected written version. Then hear the loose jamming version live where they have built off of it over the years.
I’m so excited that you were doing natural science this album is one of my favorites permanent waves never gets enough love loving that you’re listening to one of my all-time favorite Rush songs and God bless you. I’m loving your reactions. Keep up the good work.!!!
I think the studio recording is the best way to experience RUSH and then appreciate the live version later. Either way you can't go wrong. When it comes to live versions they will probably kill you in the comments saying this is the wrong version and so on. You can't make everyone happy so you gotta do what is good for you. I am here for your journey
You will pick up different things with each version. Live when you can that way you can see what they’re doing and it brings a whole new appreciation for their talents
Please don't forget studio versions. As great as they are live, you can miss some of the nuances and production quality without the studio cuts. Please finish the rest of the Moving Pictures album, or do the studio version of Spirit of Radio.
Totally agree about Studio! As for choices, I'm wanting Losing It, and then some Power Windows. There's some great BASS there! Territories, Middletown, Marathon... hell that whole album to me is their best all-around.
Amazing in person since 1980!!! AMAZZZZZZINGGGG :) “Now may the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace as you believe in Him so that you may overflow with hope by the power of the Holy Spirit.” ~ Romans 15:13
That 4:4 'MARCH BEAT' just Kills me. Such a great groove, mixing meters and then, to me, that 4:4 just destroys the whole mood. Drives me nuts about this song.
Neil Peart is quoted as saying, "Playing a three-hour Rush show is like running a marathon while solving equations." That's why he is the professor.
I've seen Rush live more than 20 times and I have NEVER heard him mess up any part of a song.
Alex was quoted as saying, "Blah, blah, blah... Blah, BLAW, blaw, blaw". Haha, sorry, I just had to. I really like your post with that quote. I know what Neil is talking about, and I can solve easy equations and cannot run a marathon. Those 3 guys did all that for decades on end in the face of adversity and oceans of dimwits.
Any version of rush is the right version. Ageless classics. I like live too! im only 25 and lucky enough to see them 4 times. You can't go wrong either way with Rush
I remember when Rush came to Brazil for the second time. I couldn't go the first time because I was a fucked broken high school student and they played in São Paulo and Rio, which are, around 2000km from my city (Recife). So, I just got an internship and with the first salary of my life I bought tickets for a flight to São Paulo and for the concert. I will never forget that October 8th, 2010. It totally worth it. I went with some of my best friends to the date. Rush is the only thing which is an unanimity among us. :)
Natural Science is one of the best from Permanent Waves album.
very timid take. But I understand, PW is loaded with timeless bangers.
Natural Science is in my top5 Rush songs.
@@vicenteraira it is true. That is all that matters.
Remember Geddy’s playing bass , singing, playing the foot pedals and the keyboards , sometimes all of them at the same time!! There is no one like these 3 gentleman! and you will never see it again! Truly the best musicians and humans of all time!
Live is good, but with Rush your first listen should be the studio version. Your channel rocks bro, I'm with you
100%!
Agreed! Live cuts are great and fun to watch put the original cut should be the first listen
Fan since '77 and I respectfully disagree. IMO their live versions are better than studio cuz they're playing LIVE, which is what it's all about.
@@johnandrews3568 - That's cool. As a writer, I go with the Studio. It's be BEST version they can produce - as NEAR PERFECT to the way they intended.
Best three piece rock band. Ever. Period.
Natural Science - deliver this message to a new generation! they need it now more than ever. Love your bass playing!
As a fan since '79, I know everything they created was a miracle and I'm insanely grateful to have grown up and seen them live 32 times...to this day I still tear up 😢 listening and realizing their will never be another band like RUSH...A FAREWELL TO KINGS!
Yes, Geddy had chickens roasting back there. He started using the house amps and his side of the stage was empty so he had dryers, chicken roasters, popcorn makers, great fun 😂
So the Roadies can eat? lol
"Time after time we lose sight of the way our causes can't see their effects"...I still wrap my mind around that.
Possibly the best of all the rabbit holes to go down.... three gifted musicians... 50 years of excelence.
I always recommend that you listen to the studio version and the live version to gain a whole new level of appreciation for their musical mastery 😁
Yes, BOTH is best ;-)
With Rush, both studio and live versions are well worth it. Rush's studio production value is as extraordinary as their live proficiency. I feel hearing the studio version gives you a better perspective on their live performances and both are reaction worthy.
😂 Don't mind us! 🤗 We'll take Rush any way we can get it! 🥰🐰
Okay you released this one late at night but I’m here for you, hun. RUSH ARMY here.
Geddy does at times play synth with his feet while singing and playing the bass. By Moving Pictures, he added the keyboards for his hands. Still has the foot moog, jumping back and forth.
3 genius virtuosos.
RUSH YYZ Live in Rio is a MUST Church Boy!!! You'll love it!!!
Xanadu live is a must watch🔥
In the early and mid 1990's Neil Peart started taking lessons from 2 different Jazz drum teachers.
This was after he had been voted the #1 rock drummer several years in a row. He felt his drumming was getting stagnant so he took lessons!
He went through a phase after these lessons of playing primarily with a traditional grip instead of his usual matchstick grip.
This was also after he had organized and played in Buddy Rich Tributes in the late 80's and early 90's.
Buddy Rich's daughter asked Neil Peart to do this after Rich's death. Buddy Rich was one of Peart's idols.
You should search UA-cam for Peart playing "Cotton Tail" at one of these tributes. He incorporates parts of his drum solo parts into this jazz tune.
If you watch Peart's drum solos (especially the solo in Frankfurt, Germany) towards the end he incorporates "Big Band" samples and you can see video of Buddy Rich, Gene Kruppa and other jazz drumming legends on the screen behind him.
So, yes you are correct - Peart had strong jazz influences in his drumming style.
9:21 "Ahhhhgggggg... this guy, this guy, jeez" That is the correct answer Church, for all three members.
Just found your channel, love it so far, THANKS!!
The studio versions are the ones we listen to (mostly), but the live versions, while most of the time having some cool changes from show to show, are just insanely impressive. Like yeah I can see how you can play YYZ in the studio but like...on stage? Back to back to back and it sounds just as good every time? Come on now.
HOW🤯DO THEY DO THAT? Playing with such ferocity, tight, technically perfect to the album AND for THREE HOURS EVERY NIGHT! Next level musicianship.👌✌️🤘🥁🎸🎹🎤
Rush Xanadu live Exit stage left
Hearing you rave (correctly) about how these guys could put a concert in a single song reminds me of something to recommend to you.
It's a video known as "Best Intro Ever," which consists of an instrumental medley of six of their older songs (from the first six albums) leading into one of their classics (which led off the seventh album), The Spirit of Radio. If I recall correctly, you already reacted to the studio version, but - perhaps obviously - this one isn't just worth it; it's a must see.
This song is in my opinion the zenith of Rush as prog rock.
And just like that, this guy just became a better musician in whatever genre he is into. Rush has been doing that for millions musicians around the world for many decades.
To try and cover Geddy with all he does on stage live (singing, bass, keys, foot pedals etc) would be pretty close to impossible, he is truly one of a kind and in a class all by himself. In regards to the rotisserie chicken. Geddy plays through the PA system. Alex tours with his amps and speakers, (as a joke) Geddy uses props like washing machines and vending machines to balance the stage.
Rush imo is the greatest or pretty darn close to the best live band on the planet. Their concerts run up to 3hrs long. With over 40 yrs of touring, there will be mistakes here or there , equiptment failures etc but for the most part, Rush is spot when it comes to live on stage.
Neil was influence by jazz drummer Buddy Rich. Generally at every concert Neil will perform a drum solo for the fans. Try Neil Peart drum solo live in Frankfurt or Maligant Narcissism which is followed by a drum solo from snakes and arrows tour. I believe the YT video is about 10 to 11 mins long.
I like the studio version of Digital Man vs live. It's not that the live is bad, I just find the mix a bit muddy and for Digital Man, I want to hear Geddy's bass cut through.
check out Neil with the Buddy Rich Orchestra for some jazz. Listen to Freewill
This is the song we named our Rush tribute after. It’s one of absolute favorites to play live on drums!
Studio version FIRST always WITH LYRICS always.
YEP!!! Just in the 'YYZ/Rio' version, the background SYNTH at the beginning is almost inaudible, the HARMONICS at the end of one of Geddy's 'Solo Riffs' is either pulled off, or just can't be heard, etc. Those little subleties......... There's a popular T.Sawyer Live version where the mix is too BASS-HEAVY. It's nice to hear Ged thumping like that, but the whole MIX is off from WHAT'S INTENDED!
I can play MOST of this song - It wears me out...
Try digital man live from snakes and arrows tour . killer bass up your alley.also red barchetta from same concert.,..
Watch the drum cam version of Digital Man at that concert. Then ending and outro trumps are exceptional! I was lucky enough to see 6 RUSH concerts, including SnA.
Alex’ solo is fire… one of my faves. He uses those harmonics like a second instrument. Awesome song.
Alex’s guitar is heavily modified. It has a piezoelectric pickup on the bridge which, when it’s switched on, gives it that acoustic sound. Gibson and Epiphone have an Alex Lifeson signature series with the piezo pickup and a Floyd rose tremolo.
Yea sir, those were Rotisserie Chickens out there! When Geddy started running his sound thru the board his side of the stage got empty! Since Alex wanted to keep his stacks, as a joke, Geddy acquired some washers and dryers! There is also vending machines and popcorn poppers! It started as a joke, but became a real thing!! Be well and God bless…from Texas!!
Yes, chicken. Why wouldn't a band have rotisserie chicken on stage with them? ;) It's an upgrade from the washers and dryers. Whatever equipment they need to make this amazing music! Check out Rush Best Intro Ever!!!!! (another amazing live performance)
You got to feed the crew. Rush is great live.
Rush Neil Peart trained with
Freddie Gruber
As time passed, he began to emulate jazz and big band musicians Gene Krupa and Buddy Rich. In 1994, Peart became a friend and pupil of jazz instructor Freddie Gruber. It was during this time that Peart revamped his playing style by incorporating jazz and swing components.

en.m.wikipedia.org › wiki
Neil Peart - Wikipedia
He's the only musician I've ever heard openly admit to taking lessons as a working musician - he said in his book Traveling Music that Freddy Gruber took him all the way down to rudiments - and that was after he was widely acclaimed as one of the best drummers in the world. 🤯🤯🤯
Church Boy, I can't thank you enough for reacting to my #1 Rush song Live. I saw Rush play this 5 times. I was blown away every time. You want to see a young Rush the song "Anthem" Live 1975. It's my favorite song on Fly by Night album. Neil's first album he wrote when he joined the band in June of 1974. Alex Liveson is a phenomenal guitarist. ❤🔥
Thank you for recognizing the immense talent of my favorite band and I love that you go to church. I love that you love God and rush. Can’t get much better than God and rush, strings and sticks baby.
Studio vs live - Why not Both?
Studio first gives you a baseline for appreciating the creative changes and live reproduction of the original track in live performances. Please don't confine yourself to Live versions. I love Rush live performances, but the studio versions and studio production of songs are amazing in their own right.
Really enjoying your reactions, on this Rush journey. Keep up the good work.
You never go wrong with Rush live.. true tallent shows when you are live... you can't hide. For me their most beautiful live performance after 20 abums is the last song of the last album.. Go watch it, it's called The Garden from clockwork angels tour... it's farewell song that capture the essence of life... Spoiler quote from the song «The measure of a life is a measure of love and respect, so hard to earn so easily burned» this gives me chills every time. I love your reactions, you know about musicianship and we can tell that you see right away what is special of this band.
The true energy of Rush often comes through best in the live tracks. With YYZ for example, the live in Rio track is BY FAR the best you will hear. Nothing like 60000 fans singing an instrumental song, LOL! Great reaction! Keep them coming!
Neil worked hard on his Jazz skills! He took time off shortly before the time frame to reinvent his technique with a famous Jazz instructor. That was after being widely considered the greatest rock drummer ever. He was a huge Buddy Rich fan, and used to host events in his honor.
Geddy Lee is playing the synth parts on Taurus foot pedals. Singing, bas, and synths, one guy.
Natural Science is the finest song ever written.
Thanks for giving Alex his due, so under appreciated. The reason to listen to this song and others from the studio versions is to hone in on all three elements, especially the bass riffs. On this song they are unbelievable! Geddy, Alex, and Neal are playing their own riffs within riffs within their songs.
"a concert in one song" welcome to Prog. :D If you can make the time, please read Geddy's book, "My Effin' Life". He does a great job describing how their albums were made and how Alex just unconsciously came up with his riffs.
I am so glad to see you give Alex props. He is an excellent player and incredible writer, Al is the man!
All the studio versions are great. The live versions are where it lives and breathes. Good all the way around. I know, I did both for decades. RUSH Night was always very special. It’s a huge vibe live!
2112... studio version also Headlong Flight with the video showing the flying dudes, and last but not least The Garden.... it was last song listed on their last album - "Clockwork Angels" Many felt it was Neil's way of saying goodbye as he passed on about years later. I can't listen to it without tearing up. For me he was in the same category of gifted songwriters like Bob Dylan, John, Paul, George, Neil Young & on the female side - like Melanie, Joni Mitchell
Another amazing reaction!👏!! This is one of my all-time favorite songs and this album (Permanent Waves), is my favorite. I really appreciate your analysis, especially since you are a musician. This band has always amazed me, how they showcase their individual talents, yet still manage to stay so cohesive. Three of the greatest musicians.....ever(RIP...NP)
I agree amazing group. Very special.
Necromancer elements in Natural Science. You can listen to them back to back and realize how great Necromancer is. Caress of Steel is weird but amazingly fantastic.
CB - Seeing you geek out on RUSH reminds me of someone who recently found faith. Just a blown away excitement level. Like a little kid. I love playing this song on my Les Paul. Especially the chord progressions at the beginning. I’m a long way from Alex but the tones coming out of my amp always give me goosebumps. Check out “Camera Eye” sometime. There is an excellent repeating riff/groove in that song you’ll love. Lots of tempo changes.
If you want to see pure musicianship watch Rush the greatest opening ever. The way they move between songs seamlessly is amazing your mind will be blown.
Just saw an interview with Alex and when asked what Rush song was the most difficult to play he said "All of them" but then specifically mentioned this one as challenging.
My friend, a RUSH concert was a 3 hour long feast for your ears and eyes. Between 27 and 30 songs a night. RUSH Songs. And they make it look sooo easy.
Rush is one of those rare bands that sound as good live as in the studio. You can’t really go wrong either way!
Rush is great live but the studio sessions. The studio versions can be often more clear and concise. You don’t have to worry about crowd noise so I hope you’re gonna do the studio version of natural science. I really look forward to your reaction. OK ciao
There is only ONE LIVE VERSION of a Rush song that sounds better than the studio version, and that is the song Working Man from the live album recorded in ‘76 All The World’s A Stage, where you really hear the difference between Neil Peart and John Rutsey, their first drummer.
SICK bass playing by this guy! Geddy was awesome, too.
In some of the live shows you can see him play the synthesizer pedals with his feet while playing bass and singing
Yeah, you hear the crowd singing they do that a lot at Rush concerts because the music is so beyond great
Red barchetta, subdivisions, entre nous, nobody´s hero, cut the chase, marathon, etc etc Rush catalog is just awesome; and yes live versions are great ALWAYS
Yes Church Boy....their skill and craftsmanship will leave you completely breathless
Points at the vid with a quizzical look ... "Is that chicken?"
best reaction moment!!!
Another awesome reaction! I just love that you pick up on the minutae from an instrumental standpoint: Alex’s delicate harmonics that set the stage for the attack of the guitar that would ensue, to bring home and echo the statement made by Neil’s lyrics- profound! Geddy playing and jumping while singing delicate yet high emotionally pitched words that speak to the grandeur of life(however it got here!), then ridding a killer pentatonic bass riff… oufff.
Neil Peart, the professor in the drums and with pen…,
What a miraculous trio to grace the stage while we were here with them to witness this grandeaur all along.
RIP NEP, you were an amazing human being, and it’s my hope and prayer that you live in Light’s embrace🙏
always enjoy a musician reacting to rush,,,, cool bassman,,,, next level,,,,🤘🤘🤘
I'm a fan of Rush since 1977, I've seen them live and the only criticism I have is that if you look at live performance of Rush don't if it's after 2000-2005 because Geddy's voice is broken and he can't hit the notes anymore. For decades he sang out of his range so in later years he paid for it. If you feel like listening to other bands that play a concert in one song try old Genesis, a song like Supper's Ready or The Battle of Epping Forest. Prog Rock for life.
Yep! OLD Rush was built on Ged's voice. Some of the APEX MOMENTS in some songs are lost. If you know Alex's 'VICTOR' album, you know Lisa Dalbello. At first, I thought she might be Geddy. For a time, I was wishing they got another singer but I understand.
I would love to see you react to Neil Peart’s drum solo live in Frankfurt.
If you're told you did the wrong version, which there are very few, just do another version. We'll be there. 😊
Thank you for finally doing live! A lot of the magic of a live rush show (other than they are almost perfect to album when playing live) is the crowd... never been to other concerts where 50,000 people will sing every song perfectly.. it's like a giant family get together.
"Living in their pools, they soon forget about the sea." It's kinda like how people living in their bubbles today in the West when before there was a bigger sense of unity and of purpose.
Yes chickens! Geddy said in an interview that he runs direct line into the house, so he needed something to fill up the stage. One tour they had dryers that had shirts in them that they threw into the crowd. The chickens are real and get donated to local shelters after the show.
Welcome to the real Rush rabbit hole... You have entered the Rush zone that you should find a live version for your first listen if you can. Why? Because you need to feel how they play together. Studio versions are cleaner and better if you want to learn the lyrics. But Rush was always built as a live band.
Any Rush fan can tell you, you can hear different things if you focus on each instrument. The reason we can listen to Rush over and over is because you discover new things everytime you listen. Listening to them live is always a treat. Not only does the rabbit hole go from studio vs. live.... It goes from LIVE vs LIVE.... and yes I can tell you which live version it is most of the time.
Man, I gotta get to your church if you’re pulling Rush riffs! Seriously, if you’re comfortable sharing, I’d love to swing by and hear you play. I know God has given you a special talent because you are picking up key sigs, time changes, modes, harmonics, etc. or if you guys live stream services, I for sure would tune in. For His Glory! Love your channel and your reactions.
Thanks for reacting to one of my favorite live Rush performances! (The 1997 version from the Molson Ampitheatre might be my favorite version). Also, while there are no synths in this song, when there are keyboard parts, Geddy plays those (as well as foot pedals when he is playing bass). Truly a musical multitasker! For a future reaction, I suggest the live version of 'Digital Man' from the Snakes and Arrows tour.
Don’t shun the studio versions because a lot of their earlier stuff wasn’t played live in the later years. RUSH is one of those rare bands that sounded good in the studio and live. I recommend you listen to the studio version of a song first, then check it out live, if available. Love your reactions, it’s fantastic to see a musician appreciate RUSH and totally get it! Keep ‘em coming!
Neil played in the Buddie Rich tribute concert....Deffinatly check that out!!!!!! You
'll see him play jazz with a big band!!!!!..Love the reaction and the channel, God Bless.
The reason you hear that acoustic guitar sound out of his electric is he has a piezo built into the bridge of his guitar with a separate output jack that goes into an acoustic amp. Also the craziest part to me is these guys DIDNT play to a click track, how they stayed in time so well is beyond insane
Thank you for another great reaction. I so appreciate your acknowledgement of Alex. Most reactors don't even mention him during his solos! Correction: Geddy also plays the synth and keys while singing and playing bass. He is using his feet and sometimes moves the mic with his oversized nose. Each of these musicians are aliens.
Neil Peart's hero was Buddy Rich, so he learned jazz drumming from Freddie Gruber and ended up cutting a collaborative album called "Burning For Buddy" featuring other rock drummers who were also inspired by Rich.
RUSH live all the time !!!
Hey man, such sweet compositions from Rush that I've listened to for 35 plus years- to hear you pick up your bass and even though you say you're slaughtering it you're so freaking close it's awesome man! Your reactions are excellent, no other channels doing that- thank you, I really dig it.
I picked up a used electric bass few months ago I've been plucking around but your ability and Ear inspire me to learn more.
Thanks again!
Song suggestions-
The Camera Eye-
The Enemy Within-
Here Again-
Jacobs ladder-
as appetizers...
That's why you need to watch YYZ live in RIO - the crowd sings to the music. I prefer the live versions for most songs, but we'll let you know which song you should listen to live. Growing up, we heard the studio versions first, so I don't know which would be better for a newcomer. They are hilarious too. Loving your reactions to my favorite band!
I saw on your face, a couple of times during this, that sudden urge to just say, "F*** it!" and sell off all your instruments. Am I right??? These three Canadians are just riDICulous!!! What talent! What tightness! What invention!!
It's fun watching you experience them for the first time, and I'm a bit jealous! I was 12 when I first heard them (1980). Probably didn't appreciate them as much as I would have as a first-time adult listener.
Don't get too concerned about which version you listen to. It is just so much fun watching you discover Rush just as we did back in hte day. Keep doing what you're doing.
"Strings and sticks" plus Alex and Geddy both play Taurus pedals... Geddy, whilst singing and playing the bass! Neil also triggers some sounds, if the others are too busy.
Actually is good to hear studio first so you hear their perfected written version. Then hear the loose jamming version live where they have built off of it over the years.
I’m so excited that you were doing natural science this album is one of my favorites permanent waves never gets enough love loving that you’re listening to one of my all-time favorite Rush songs and God bless you. I’m loving your reactions. Keep up the good work.!!!
RUSH= SIMPLY THE BEST!!
I think the studio recording is the best way to experience RUSH and then appreciate the live version later. Either way you can't go wrong. When it comes to live versions they will probably kill you in the comments saying this is the wrong version and so on. You can't make everyone happy so you gotta do what is good for you. I am here for your journey
You will pick up different things with each version. Live when you can that way you can see what they’re doing and it brings a whole new appreciation for their talents
Playing bass, talking, singing, and playing the foot pedals. Geddy.
Please don't forget studio versions. As great as they are live, you can miss some of the nuances and production quality without the studio cuts. Please finish the rest of the Moving Pictures album, or do the studio version of Spirit of Radio.
Totally agree about Studio! As for choices, I'm wanting Losing It, and then some Power Windows. There's some great BASS there! Territories, Middletown, Marathon... hell that whole album to me is their best all-around.
Xanadu live from exit stage left is a must
You should watch Neil Peart.Burning for Buddy tribute (Buddy Rich) Multiple drummers playing drums with big bands.
Amazing in person since 1980!!! AMAZZZZZZINGGGG :) “Now may the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace as you believe in Him so that you may overflow with hope by the power of the Holy Spirit.” ~ Romans 15:13
Alex is the most underrated guitar player in the history of guitar.
Neil appeared on the Buddy Rich tribute check it out and do a reaction.
That 4:4 'MARCH BEAT' just Kills me. Such a great groove, mixing meters and then, to me, that 4:4 just destroys the whole mood. Drives me nuts about this song.