The Daily Muppet | Talking Tactics W/Dharnish, Progress? | Manchester United Transfer News

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 83

  • @kse7en496
    @kse7en496 Місяць тому +3

    James, if you want overlapping fb, then you have to change the manager and get a tactically flexible manager.

  • @AyuenAguto
    @AyuenAguto Місяць тому +2

    I agree we have not had a complete 90-minute yet and that is concerning, but I was not expecting my team to go from who they were to completely controlling games right away! also if we were converting our chances, none of this would be a topic of discussion at all because we made enough chances to kill games while we were on top. My concern at this moment is how we gonna score goals when Marcus is not doing it and when Bruno is not doing it because both strikers are so inexperienced in that department.

  • @AntonyR_Golf
    @AntonyR_Golf Місяць тому +3

    Looking forward to listening. Question - from what you are being told, is Jason Wilcox forensically analysing our performances? With the positive noises about his football intelligence my only hope is that we have the right people analysing our performances inside the club

  • @cornthdl
    @cornthdl Місяць тому +3

    October is huge for Ten Hag…if he makes it.

    • @playedout148
      @playedout148 Місяць тому +1

      Can't wait to see Ruud on the hot seat, then Southgate then Nagelsmen then Carrick. 😂

    • @ilariopastori6927
      @ilariopastori6927 Місяць тому +1

      Can't see him alive in a month, would love to... Would love to start winning games by 2/3 goals but this hasn't happened in the last 2 years so.... We can try to stay positive find positives in controlling the ball against lower sides, but the harsh truth is coming, and saying that spurs villa fenerbache and porto are tough teams makes me even more realize that we are middle table team😢

  • @edzibit27
    @edzibit27 Місяць тому +4

    Wow, how is James not an elite manager?? Sounds like he has *all* the answers! Ineos need to put him in the hotseat asap so that we can finally win the treble again

  • @coombs9328
    @coombs9328 Місяць тому

    Great vid guys👍

  • @patrickmullins7981
    @patrickmullins7981 Місяць тому +1

    I think our midfield would look alot better with Ugarte along side an athletic progreesive passer, and Kobbie Mainoo as a ball carrying 10.

  • @Boylo2492
    @Boylo2492 Місяць тому +1

    It feels like everything we do is a "Lets try this and see if it works" kind of idea. What is going on in training? All other teams in the league have a clear idea of how to defend, build up, progress the ball and attack the box. We don't. So the question has to be asked does the manager AND coaching staff not have a plan to get us scoring and winning games, or are the players just unable to execute?
    Or is it a mixture of both. Ive backed Ten Hag and I still am, but hes on borrowed time now and I dont see him sticking round past December.

    • @andrewtroester5737
      @andrewtroester5737 Місяць тому

      I think this is a good point. The fanbase love to live week to week. And there is a narrative that bounces back and forth. even on this channel. "We have to be tactically flexible to win games" then followed up weeks later with "we have to have a specific style of play". Some of the nuance is lost. To be fair to ETH he inherited a dumpster fire and dealt with Ronaldo/Sancho...whe went practical and results followed. Season two he tried to fully implement his system and then half the squad was out. Now he is continuing to implement but has 6 new players where everyone expects immediate challenge for Champions league. Its all been pretty unstable.
      It helps to stop and ask yourself "do you really think ETH, RVN, and HACKE are not sitting down and trying to put ideas in place to BOTH win games practically as well as satisfy the clamoring fanbase who want GAME MODEL" not likely. they are professionals. you u could argue if they have ideas but we don't know what those are and they are not going to say it in press conferences

    • @yoshuaduyols
      @yoshuaduyols Місяць тому

      @@andrewtroester5737 Again with the fucking stupid excuses for Ten Hag.

  • @AyuenAguto
    @AyuenAguto Місяць тому +2

    James is trying his absolute best to paint as Eric Ten Hag's problem and not the fact that we do not have a proven scorer in our squad

    • @yoshuaduyols
      @yoshuaduyols Місяць тому +1

      Because Ten Hag is the problem.

    • @AyuenAguto
      @AyuenAguto Місяць тому +3

      @@yoshuaduyols We had the same problems for 11 years ten hag has only been here 2 1/2 so yeah I don’t think he’s the problem

    • @playedout148
      @playedout148 Місяць тому

      ​@@AyuenAgutoWill Ruud make it 3 years?

    • @Muppetiers
      @Muppetiers  Місяць тому +1

      Can you show me all of tottenhams proven scorers they needed to beat a Europa league team?

    • @AyuenAguto
      @AyuenAguto Місяць тому

      Oh, do mean like Son and Solanke? Don't get me wrong we should have beaten FC Twente however unlike you I believe that was more on the players and not the manager

  • @RunnaNo1
    @RunnaNo1 Місяць тому

    It doesn’t feel like a team in year 3 because it isn’t. It’s a manager in year 3. Doesn’t make it better, but that’s the reality. Yeah there are a number of players that are the same but it’s not the same settled team

  • @kse7en496
    @kse7en496 Місяць тому

    James, Ten Hag's latest interview he admitted that he's impatient and I think he has to accept this is the way forward. Because he is not making proper tactical solutions at the end of games.

  • @OserojiemenKing
    @OserojiemenKing Місяць тому +1

    Bruno literally plays for another team that is not United. How does he play for them stylistically? That tells you all you need to know.

  • @manuty.4
    @manuty.4 Місяць тому

    Liverpool were having the same problems we are having with the defence
    and.they went and bought fast,quick,scary and towering center backs
    Nobody is really scared of our center backs😂😂

    • @playedout148
      @playedout148 Місяць тому +1

      That striker went through maggie like a hot knife through butter.

  • @darkestearth6599
    @darkestearth6599 Місяць тому

    The big problem with this channel is the people you bring on often just agree with you, it would be nice to have someone that has an opposing view. I know that SOMETIMES happens on the podcast but even here, you are saying things like the subs at Palace and everybody is just agreeing. It's clear that Zirkzee was brought off because Rashford had started scoring and allowing to see if Garnacho-Rashford-Amad can work. Then Amad is brought off for Hojlund because that's the front three that can normally score? As well as Erikson isn't 'the plan' he is just having a good run of form? Not everything is a way for the manager to be wrong to fit the agenda

  • @FFXJO
    @FFXJO Місяць тому

    It will all be over on Sunday 🎉🎉🎉

  • @playedout148
    @playedout148 Місяць тому

    Ruud is officially on the hot seat. 😂

  • @morampragnan5556
    @morampragnan5556 Місяць тому +7

    Pls let the other person complete his sentence before u make u r point .. like guest can't even open his mouth while ur talking , u just barge suddenly while darnish is making a point he has to stare at screen for 15 mins while u go on a rant/monologue.. or just let him 1st show the tatics breakdown and then the video can transition into a discussion video..

    • @bryanwin
      @bryanwin Місяць тому +1

      Exactly my feel.
      James. Love the content. But don’t be like Piers Morgan.
      Let your guest talk, not just wait for your turn to talk.

  • @darshildholakia6346
    @darshildholakia6346 Місяць тому

    Lmao James seems to think players stay in a rigid position and formation throughout the whole 90 mins. Cos Dalots inverting that means he’s defo not overlapping when that’s just not true. We’ve seen Dalot be the inverted winger and the winger holding the width, it just depends on if the team has managed to progress the ball to the final 3rd. Completely not true that we’re not having ‘overlapping full backs’

  • @amarvijh4504
    @amarvijh4504 Місяць тому +1

    This Ole talk is funny because no matter any way you slice it United were the best for longer periods under him. Media killed him, titter followed suit and then the smear campaign started. Now ego has fans not wanting to see the good, who cares about style?! WE CAME 2ND!!!

  • @bf1716
    @bf1716 Місяць тому +1

    MU leadership has stated they want the league by 2028.
    City, Arsenal and Liverpool are 1,2,3. So that leaves one spot to be divided by all sub top teams in PL.
    I'm sure most fan channels expect MU to compete for PL by next season, which is not in line with the realistic MU leadership goal and agenda.
    EtH has had 1 good window, under the new leadership. Now everybody expects all new players to immediately perform at their best, like Scholes 😂 they want new players to be dropped into this team as if they are like car parts you simply exchange 1 on 1. It's almost laughable, no team sports works like that. It seems that many people are simply insane and have insane expectations. Players are people and training takes time.
    There's a lot of criticism of EtH which is based on a lot of speculation, but the reality is that the Ajax under EtH would destroy MU any time. MU is NOT a top team, to become a top team is the goal, not a reality already.
    Not enough attention is paid to highly overrated and overhyped players like Rashford and Bruno.
    Ajax had a real captain under EtH, Tadic, a real leader. Bruno is a joke of a captain, a petulant boy. So, if Bruno is the best option for captain then that says a great deal about this club and team. If one compares for example KdB with Bruno, then the differences are obvious and huge. It's comparing a real leader with a petulant boy. That's simply an observation. Bruno may have good statistics, but he is NOT a good leader. Good statistics don't make good leaders. But he's the "best" option 😂.
    The Ajax players under EtH were paid only a small fraction of what average players at MU are paid. Their performances on the pitch are not in comparison in a negative sense. The Ajax team was hungry under EtH, this team is hungry sometimes.
    Maybe the last 10 years show that manager's influence on players at MU is by default not very high, because they are paid too much for doing too little for too long. It will take time to hammer that sick mentality out of the club, it's not done with one good window. Probably at least two more good windows are needed to weed out the rotten apples and replace them with decent players. This was also stated last season, but suddenly fans talk as if this one window is going to change everything immediately, competing for top 4 with teams that are already competing with players playing together at least a whole season while MU is in a huge transition.
    On top of all that, my experience is that this club's fan base is extremely toxic. I see flipflopping opinions every game. Last year fans complained about the lack of rotation while there were often not even 11 players available 😂 this year they are complaining about too much rotation 😂😭
    This club has been a circus for over a decade, maybe that explains all the clowns.

    • @andrewtroester5737
      @andrewtroester5737 Місяць тому +1

      AJAX: clear culture and direction built over time. MU: has been chaos with no direction and club culture since SAF. All the manager who have been hired since SAF weren't trash managers. club culture and resource has a lot to do with it.
      Fanbase point is spot on. Its getting to Arsenal levels. There are so many deep seeded issues at the club that need to be fixed and those things are moving forward under INEOS but the timeframe some folks have (including James) is laughable. The idea that this team routinely walks out and plays and functions like CIty or Arsenal or Liverpool is the expectation. Champions League is the expectation. We cant "waste another season". That short termism is how we hasted a decade.

    • @yoshuaduyols
      @yoshuaduyols Місяць тому

      @@andrewtroester5737 He is here 3years no clear cut vision from his playing style. Stop defending a manager that came in 8th with a minus gd and shows he isn't changing.

  • @kse7en496
    @kse7en496 Місяць тому

    ETH LoL is cooked 😂😂

  • @markloughran4827
    @markloughran4827 Місяць тому +1

    Cheer up James, it’ll be ok. This obsession with tactics is so reductive. Even within seasons Ferguson used different tactics against different teams. Some games he’d just tell his team to do their thing. He’d look at the Spurs game and tweak the team slightly to nullify their strengths and exploit their weaknesses. To be honest I think Ten Hag’s issue isn’t tactics, it’s player management. Getting them to stick to the script, motivating good performances out of them. And he definitely has a Fernandes issue. The guy needs a rest, he has no long term future in this team otherwise. Maybe none in any case.

    • @andrewtroester5737
      @andrewtroester5737 Місяць тому +1

      people like the tactics discussion because they believe that its quantitative and "controllable" They hate the idea that sometimes individual moments and performances make a difference (often). Mistakes and moments change games more than tactics. Sometimes it is a lot about individuals. But then that doesn't make people listen to multiple podcasts a week

    • @markloughran4827
      @markloughran4827 Місяць тому +1

      @@andrewtroester5737 yeah,it’s not like effort, skill, pace, spatial awareness, shooting, passing, attitude, motivation and team harmony actually have any importance, right?

    • @yoshuaduyols
      @yoshuaduyols Місяць тому

      But that management getting the best out individuals to play the best in a team setting and Ten Hag is failing badly at that.

    • @yoshuaduyols
      @yoshuaduyols Місяць тому

      And in all those areas Ten Hag is subpar at coaching those things so what does he do then to stay?

    • @andrewtroester5737
      @andrewtroester5737 Місяць тому

      @@yoshuaduyols sure I think you make that argument and you can back that with examples or data. I think "the best out of individuals and systems" is a tough recipe. Tuchel is great example. Can get a tune but is toxic and short term. Sometimes personnel matters. Man I is a toxic soup and environment. That was there before ETH arrived

  • @JamesMIrby
    @JamesMIrby Місяць тому

    Tottenham is playing twice in a week.

  • @JamesMIrby
    @JamesMIrby Місяць тому +1

    We are where are. The tables dont lie. No excuses please!!

  • @yoshuaduyols
    @yoshuaduyols Місяць тому

    Selling Fernandes is really biting the club in the ass.
    Ineos not making a decision on the manager last year is a real failure of the best in class people.
    Sorry we can't go further with ten hag in my eyes for this season. not making a decision on this puts Ineos on fraud watch.
    SJR can sack people behind the scenes at ease, put can't pull the trigger on the manager because he doesn't have the balls.
    We could have won the EUL this season and it would give us UCL football next season.

  • @mucool328
    @mucool328 Місяць тому

    I don’t get why people say 3 years, it is 2 years plus 8 games this season , community shield , 5(2W2L1D) , 1 league cup win, 1 Europa league draw.

  • @manuty.4
    @manuty.4 Місяць тому +5

    I really think after 13 years of being shit and having no identity or style of play whatsoever,James expect it to click as simple has like 5 months ineos of have been here... and that's just an impatient act,Again this is our first season under a new regime and I can even confidently say this is rashfords (been here for 8 years)hes getting to play under a consistent sorta tactic...
    So my point is rome wasn't built in a year regardless of whether ten hag has been here for 3 years or not this is first season in my opinion cause this is the only season he has been given the circumstances to succeed

    • @menamegaza7201
      @menamegaza7201 Місяць тому +2

      And he's been shit so far

    • @manuty.4
      @manuty.4 Місяць тому

      ​@@menamegaza7201if.ineos think like you I'll be genuinely worried mate😂

    • @Isaac-q7i6b
      @Isaac-q7i6b Місяць тому +3

      rashford played under LVG, way more consistent tactics than ETH

    • @manuty.4
      @manuty.4 Місяць тому +1

      @@Isaac-q7i6b and where did it get lvg? fucken sacked innit 😂

    • @Isaac-q7i6b
      @Isaac-q7i6b Місяць тому

      @@manuty.4 like ten hag should have been

  • @RDJM90
    @RDJM90 Місяць тому +1

    Utd will never ever be a cohesive unit that can control games until Bruno is no longer at Utd James. He vacates too much space. His positional discipline isn't good enough and he isn't cute enough with the ball and what I mean by that is he doesn't play the nice one-twos and isn't a dribbler.

  • @febian1529
    @febian1529 Місяць тому

    The narrative about Ten hag need player magic to score i think is stupid. This season we are the top 5 of chance creation and also missed chance, we create chance against Fulham, Liverpool, palace, Brighton. The problem is our player arent clinical enough to score, player need more repetition to be clinical and thats need time. We also need to admit that most our attacker still young and adapting to EPL (garnacho, Amad, hojlund, zirkzee). While the other 2 (Antony, rashford) really flop last season and still try to regain confidence.
    The issue about Dalot inverting and not overlapping i think thats smart from Ten hag. Rather than using Dalot with his weaker left foot, ITS better using him to invert and to carry the ball. The problem with that is rashford doesnt get overlapping fullback and rashford looks very limited (maybe James really like rashford and doesnt want to expose his weakness)

    • @andrewtroester5737
      @andrewtroester5737 Місяць тому

      SPOT ON! If we convert some of the big chances we missed then we aren't having this ETH out conversation. We are creating a lot of chances and missing them. Thats personnell/luck. The forward line is young and inconsistent. Or old and inconsistent in the case of rashford.
      Playing overlapping fullbacks to get the best tout of rashford is a choice you could go. Or you leverage another attacking pattern. that's up to the coaches but Dalot helps with control an area everyone like jame was mad about a couple days ago

    • @febian1529
      @febian1529 Місяць тому

      @@andrewtroester5737 we have many senior player who are inconsistent (rashford, Bruno, Casemiro, Eriksen, maguire, Lindelof). Compare them to Liverpool or city senior player and they are miles behind for consistency.
      And also comparing Chelsea to United is really not Apple to Apple. Chelsea really clear out the deadwoods in short period (Sterling, chilwell, havertz, Tiago Silva) and totally overhaul the squad. While INEOS prefer the long game and still keep some deadwoods. So expecting us to make drastis change is really silly

    • @andrewtroester5737
      @andrewtroester5737 Місяць тому

      @@febian1529 i agree. people can question whether all of those players are inconsistent BECAUSE of ETH. I think that is fair, but like Maguire got absolutely sat down for the twente goal and James wont mention it ever. Maguire is his hill to die on which is weird. But full stop Casemiro, eriksen, maguire, lindelof SHOULDNT need to be consistent for us to win. they should be on the bench. If you look at our first team we are asking for players like Hojland, zirkzee, amad etc to be consistently like Liverpool or city's attack? come on.
      For the Chelsea point....they cleared out immediately and were horrifically...like comically bad as they threw a bunch of randoms onto their field together. they will improve but go ask a chelsea fan how they have appreciated the aggressive "deadwood" clear out.

    • @yoshuaduyols
      @yoshuaduyols Місяць тому

      @@andrewtroester5737 living in a hypothetical. It's not good enough and after last season it's clear he isn't good enough.
      Having your best goalscorer huging the touchline is just stupid.

    • @febian1529
      @febian1529 Місяць тому +1

      @@yoshuaduyols be real no manager Will build something if you have as many injury as United last season. Dont forget to add the drop performance from senior player (Casemiro, rashford, Eriksen, varane) and also disciplinary problem (rashford Sancho). When Liverpool lost Van djik the whole year because of ACL suddenly Liverpool drop from treble winner to Europe league team.
      If rashford play consistent and improve his work rate, surely Ten hag Will play him more as inside forward to score. The problem is rashford isnt consistent and cant be trust to be main goalscorer. So if you arent good enough then you need to follow the system. So don't tell me that rashford is very good like mbappe or Vinicius so he could be trusted as main goal scorer