Salaam just a curios sunni brother my questions have nothing to do with the vid i just want some ansewrs 1. The prophet said whoever figths ali is kafir does this mean his wife aisha is a kafir 2. If muawiyah is kafir why did HZ hassan give baiyah to him
Salaam just a curios sunni brother my questions have nothing to do with the vid i just want some ansewrs 1. The prophet said whoever figths ali is kafir does this mean his wife aisha is a kafir 2. If muawiyah is kafir why did HZ hassan give baiyah to him
Salam aleikum 1.The Prophet said in sunni source; whoever hurt Ali is like hurting me(Prophet). When she wage war against Imam Ali(as) was based on personal hatred and political interest, later on she express her joy when Imam Ali(as) died, so we can say she was a kafirah. 2. Who says Imam Hassan(as) gave bayah, proof it from shia sources, if you can?
He did not give bay3eh. But suluh. Yani peace. This was to minimize the blood shed of Muslims. And there were many rules like muawaya was not allowed to make his son yazid a khalif after him, and so on. But many of these promises were not fulfilled and that is why almost every single man of the prophets family got slaughtered in karbala. As of what aisha. There is a quran verse that is clear. Surat al buroj ayah 10. If she did tawbah after fighting imam ali then it is between her and Allah. The issue is that she also went out to fight imam al hassan. And if she did do another tawbah after that then that is between her and Allah. But then again one of imam hassans wills was to get buried next to his grandfather muhammed SAW. And she did not accept. Aisha might have done good after this and done tabwah and become a good human being. But having her as a rolemodel while there exist women like khadija fatima mariam um salamah um al baneen asia and so on. Women that fought for islam and offered everything without letting the Dunya affect them. I hope you understand iam not of the kind that hates aisha, she is the prophets wife and shall be respected and we don't have the right to curse or personally attack her as a women. But we have to question her motives and actions and criticise her for what she did. Both good and bad
We do not question our imams Whatever the hassan AS did he knows best The same goes with Hussein AS, he could've also made peace The imams know best That's how a true shia deal with it The entire army of Ali was from badris uhudis muhajereen and ansar Meanwhile, aisha had toleqaa and few badris
May الله bless and reward you guys and may the peace and blessings of الله be upon Sayyida Zainab❤️🩹
Mashallah brother
Salaam just a curios sunni brother my questions have nothing to do with the vid i just want some ansewrs
1. The prophet said whoever figths ali is kafir does this mean his wife aisha is a kafir
2. If muawiyah is kafir why did HZ hassan give baiyah to him
Salaam just a curios sunni brother my questions have nothing to do with the vid i just want some ansewrs
1. The prophet said whoever figths ali is kafir does this mean his wife aisha is a kafir
2. If muawiyah is kafir why did HZ hassan give baiyah to him
Salam aleikum
1.The Prophet said in sunni source; whoever hurt Ali is like hurting me(Prophet). When she wage war against Imam Ali(as) was based on personal hatred and political interest, later on she express her joy when Imam Ali(as) died, so we can say she was a kafirah.
2. Who says Imam Hassan(as) gave bayah, proof it from shia sources, if you can?
@Farzadsafarwandi jazakallah khairan ya akhi
He did not give bay3eh. But suluh. Yani peace.
This was to minimize the blood shed of Muslims. And there were many rules like muawaya was not allowed to make his son yazid a khalif after him, and so on. But many of these promises were not fulfilled and that is why almost every single man of the prophets family got slaughtered in karbala.
As of what aisha. There is a quran verse that is clear.
Surat al buroj ayah 10.
If she did tawbah after fighting imam ali then it is between her and Allah. The issue is that she also went out to fight imam al hassan. And if she did do another tawbah after that then that is between her and Allah.
But then again one of imam hassans wills was to get buried next to his grandfather muhammed SAW. And she did not accept.
Aisha might have done good after this and done tabwah and become a good human being. But having her as a rolemodel while there exist women like khadija fatima mariam um salamah um al baneen asia and so on. Women that fought for islam and offered everything without letting the Dunya affect them.
I hope you understand iam not of the kind that hates aisha, she is the prophets wife and shall be respected and we don't have the right to curse or personally attack her as a women. But we have to question her motives and actions and criticise her for what she did. Both good and bad
@hassanalsalim245 bro you have no.idea how gratefull i am to you. Tysm jazakallah kahyran habibi May Allah give you jannah
We do not question our imams
Whatever the hassan AS did he knows best
The same goes with Hussein AS, he could've also made peace
The imams know best
That's how a true shia deal with it
The entire army of Ali was from badris uhudis muhajereen and ansar
Meanwhile, aisha had toleqaa and few badris
That must be why Daniel Haqiqajew left Tashayu. He's really sexist and laughs at girls who want to go to school.
He is from Narnia ,. ie in the closet
Just like Andrew Tate,. 😅