Mannar Wind Power Scam

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 69

  • @srimalsepala5322
    @srimalsepala5322 8 місяців тому +8

    I am so sad that such a valuable channel only subscribe by so few. This is the tragity of Sri Lankan society.

  • @MiaDiwya
    @MiaDiwya 8 місяців тому +10

    Yes, of course, This is another daylight robbery by both Adani & our corrupted politician. However, it's better if you can create both Sinhala & Tamil versions of this video! It would help to bring more awareness to people. We will stand with you!!

  • @samv2777
    @samv2777 8 місяців тому +12

    Don’t ever trust Adani empire, there environmental records aren’t good enough to take such massive project on Manner shore. A responsible government should always consider the environmental impact which can cause irreparable and irreversible damage thus damaging such a beautiful bird sanctuary which belongs to whole nation, Buddhists, Hindus, Christians and Muslims. I hope current environmental minister take responsible measures to ensure well being of such wonderful creatures enable more ecotourism to showcase diversity

    • @angelsilva3727
      @angelsilva3727 8 місяців тому

      Then dont take to streets when there are energy cuts or give a solution for more cheap energy.

  • @mrknesiah
    @mrknesiah 8 місяців тому +6

    For the cost of this Ambani deal alone, Sri Lanka could have built it’s own photovoltaic and battery factories and become energy independent in 10 years.

    • @sajadabdulcader5337
      @sajadabdulcader5337 8 місяців тому

      But buds should allow it without asking for 10% commissions. U have seen the singhale lead political parties been corrupt all the way.

    • @angelsilva3727
      @angelsilva3727 8 місяців тому

      and our other ethnicities are pure and clean hahahahaha@@sajadabdulcader5337

    • @angelsilva3727
      @angelsilva3727 8 місяців тому

      O yeah sure you going to place them on your head?

  • @ayomawijesundere3166
    @ayomawijesundere3166 8 місяців тому +5

    Rohan P is a recognised authority on environment issues and a very patriotic citizen. We can encourage Solar Power instead. Knowing Adani and our Politician s there is nothing Patriotic about this issue. We are again robbed by them..please read into this and comprehend what's taking place..A.W.

    • @warsil3735
      @warsil3735 8 місяців тому +1

      Well that doesn't m an people talk rubbish..those turbines are not in the conserved area

    • @wikihoohoo
      @wikihoohoo 8 місяців тому +1

      ​@@warsil3735 Rohan is highlighting the overhead power cables and the corruption involved in the whole project. Do you approve of corruption and deliberate acts against the environment?

    • @warsil3735
      @warsil3735 8 місяців тому

      Go by the substance not the person, els you will be fooled by the persona with hidden agenda .

    • @warsil3735
      @warsil3735 8 місяців тому

      @@wikihoohoo these guys will never allow any power project renewable, nuclear or fossil and live and earn their bread and butter by condemning anything. Birds have learnt behavior and after many thousand deaths the next flock will find ways to circumnavigate the turbine blades . People will go hungry is cheap power is not generated as no factories will ever come. These NGO guys will get their dolls s for make ng mountains out of molehills 🤣 but the rest expecting a reduction in their bills to get at least two square meals will always be affected. Corruption is different but merely stopping a renewable energy program becaus of migratory be rds is rubbish look at the economic , loss of opportunity via and reduction of quality of life compared to a few bird watchers who bring champika in.a thousand times less revenue then the alternative fuel costs to drive the energy grid with fossil or on renewable energy..🤣

    • @wikihoohoo
      @wikihoohoo 8 місяців тому

      @@warsil3735 Even if we remove Rohan out the equation we are left out with corruption and deliberate acts against the environment. Isn't it?

  • @sunilsoysa2496
    @sunilsoysa2496 8 місяців тому

    Thanks for high lighting the hidden factors .

  • @nirojayasekera7055
    @nirojayasekera7055 8 місяців тому

    Thank you Sir for speaking on behalf of our environment and the creatures who will have to pay the ultimate price . Learned people on the subject please join hands with this gentleman to stop this hidden project 💔.

  • @RS-vp1iq
    @RS-vp1iq 8 місяців тому +1

    පරිසර පද්දතියට මෙයින් වන විනාශයත්, අපට වන අලාභයත් ගැන මෙසේ පෙන්වා දීම ගැන ඔබතුමාට පින්. අප රටට වන පරිසර හානිය නිසා අනාගත අනතුරු ඇඟවීමක් ආචාර්ය ඊ ඩබ්ලිව් අදිකාරම්තුමා පෙන්වා දුන් බවත්, ආචාර්ය රනිල් සේනානායක වැනි ප්‍රායෝගික වියතුන්ගෙන් හිටපු ජනපති අවවාද ගත්තනම් ඔබ තුමා මේ වීඩියෝවේ අවසාන විනාඩියේ සඳහන් කරණ විපත්තිය සිදුවීම-කෘතිම පෝර වලට ඇබ්බැහි වීමේ විෂම චක්‍රයෙන් ක්‍රම ක්‍රමයෙන් අවුරුදු 3 කින් මිදීම නිසා-අභව්‍යයක් බවත්, ඇමෙරිකාවේ සිදුවෙමින් පවතින පරිසර විනාශයෙන් අප පාඩම් උගත යුතු බවත් පහත උපුටනයන් මගින් ඔබතුමාගේ අවධානයට යොමු කරමි.
    නිස්සරණාද්ධ්යාශයෙන් කරණ මේ උත්සාහ බීරි අලින්ට වීණා වැයීමක් නොවේවාය කියා පතමි.
    (1)
    කෘමිනාශක බෙහෙත් නිසා මැරී යන්නේ ඇසට පෙනෙන ගැඩවිල් පණුවන්, කෘමි සතුන් පමණක් නොවේ. ඊට වඩා ලක්ෂ වාර ගණනකින් සිටින ඇසට නොපෙනෙන ක්ෂුද්‍ර ජීවිහු ද මැරී යති. නුගත් ගොවියා මේ බව දන්නේ නැත. තාවකාලික පහසුවක් තාවකාලික ලාභයක් සලකා කෘමිනාශක බෙහෙත් යෙදීමෙන් ගොවියා තම බිම විනාශ කර ගනියි. මේ හේතුවෙන් ලංකාව ගොවිතැනට නුසුදුසු කාන්තාරයක් වන දවස එතරම් ඈත විය නොහැකියි. Sithivili Volume 6, page 255 (Hard cover, 2003 Edition)
    (2)
    18 වන විනාඩියේ සිට විනාඩි 4ක් සහ 29වන විනාඩියේ ඊට විනාඩි 7ක්
    ua-cam.com/video/-fCIWfI9OSM/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared
    (3)
    42වන විනාඩියේ සිට විනාඩි 4ක්
    ua-cam.com/video/h3c_D0s391Q/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared

  • @dulminiperera-clinicalpsyc9965
    @dulminiperera-clinicalpsyc9965 8 місяців тому +2

    Hats off sir,

  • @M.Perera
    @M.Perera 3 місяці тому

    Respect to you gentleman.

  • @Sl_king213
    @Sl_king213 8 місяців тому +1

    Mannar Is already tilted by the mining industry already

  • @ruhunayake
    @ruhunayake 8 місяців тому +1

    Who conducted the faunal surveys for the EIA that's mentioned here? If it's such a faulty report, why are the authors of it not mentioned about? Which scientists from which university conducted the faunal surveys, especially the bird surveys that's specifically mentioned here?

  • @costengineeringsolutions5239
    @costengineeringsolutions5239 8 місяців тому +4

    Be it Indian, Chinese or any other, what we as citizens must see is the cost factor, price we are to pay and the impact it is going to cause to the environment of the locality. We get wind and sun light free and a foreigner is going to reap colosal benefits out of that. The greatest concern in this project is the location and the costing factor.

    • @Deelo999
      @Deelo999 8 місяців тому

      ua-cam.com/video/Lq1SueObDvQ/v-deo.htmlsi=i6O6yeC4PZ1jYQkG

  • @ravirajapaksha4500
    @ravirajapaksha4500 8 місяців тому

    Can you source better location for this project???

  • @brendansosa7078
    @brendansosa7078 8 місяців тому

    A classic statement by an academic who is clueless on economics. He is the type who led Gota to his doom!
    He has no suggestions for a viable alternative.🎉🎉

  • @mandawalapannawansa8991
    @mandawalapannawansa8991 8 місяців тому +1

    Unfortunately the man still thinks he is the master! With his ignorance he is digging his own grave by destroying environment !
    Nature has warned enough man to be attentive to his environment !
    Everybody should thank this important expose !
    Mandawala hamuduruvo

  • @ChannaGun
    @ChannaGun 8 місяців тому +1

    Given how attractive such a project could be to local investors, and your understanding of what an ideal site would be from an environmental impact perspective, can you please name one or more suitable sites for an alternative installation, in the comment thread or as a follow up video, Mr. Pethiyagoda? No reason why a suitable local enterpreneur would not step up to take the challenge, and SL would not end up cancelling this one, and then having to take up bird watching during power cuts.

    • @rohan.pethiyagoda
      @rohan.pethiyagoda  8 місяців тому +4

      You can download the EIA report from the link pasted here. Page 60 of the EIA has a wind resources map of Sri Lanka and you can visualize from that where similar sites exist: 203.115.26.10/2023/EIA/Mannar%20Wind%20Power%20Project%20Phase%20II%20EIA%20Final%20-%20English.pdf

    • @rohan.pethiyagoda
      @rohan.pethiyagoda  8 місяців тому +3

      And an even better map here: www.nrel.gov/docs/fy03osti/34518.pdf

    • @ChannaGun
      @ChannaGun 8 місяців тому

      @@rohan.pethiyagoda thank you!

  • @liuupson8593
    @liuupson8593 8 місяців тому

    Do you really believe that the older generation who have been voting UNP/SJB, SLFP/Pohottuwa, who contributed to our nation's financial bankrupt and celebrated during Premadasa's era when young people faced severe oppression under mass tire graves, have empathy towards birds?

  • @dhanapalagodage6920
    @dhanapalagodage6920 4 місяці тому

    Disgraceful. Greed override.

  • @andyprem
    @andyprem 8 місяців тому +3

    These Environmental mental cases have prevented every power generation project in Sri Lanka. Screw them .

    • @natalievh424
      @natalievh424 8 місяців тому

      But they still use power made by coal power plant

  • @randimasilva6598
    @randimasilva6598 8 місяців тому

    😥

  • @warsil3735
    @warsil3735 8 місяців тому +1

    Birds will show a learned ng behavior and go around the turbines after a few months 😂

  • @fahimmeerasahib4820
    @fahimmeerasahib4820 8 місяців тому +5

    Where were you when the project was under discussion. You people wait till the projects kick starts, some one sponsor you guys and starts critices.

    • @andyprem
      @andyprem 8 місяців тому +1

      exactly.

  • @balasubramaniamsivarasamm5036
    @balasubramaniamsivarasamm5036 8 місяців тому

    Don't blame Adwani.Srilankans and ADB are.responsible.

  • @athulahaputantri5072
    @athulahaputantri5072 8 місяців тому +2

    Let’s go back to the Stone Age, even telecommunication is harmful as per some so called experts.

    • @WarunaTennakoon
      @WarunaTennakoon 8 місяців тому +1

      apparently, you haven't watched the full video

  • @warsil3735
    @warsil3735 8 місяців тому +1

    Q have to live.before birds

  • @angelsilva3727
    @angelsilva3727 8 місяців тому

    What you say about the environmental impact is true but please tell the public what solution do we have to generate the necessary power that we need in our everyday life. We cant afford to buy oil and our water reservoirs cannot sustain the power supply we need. We saw the situation when we had energy cuts how our gotrikayas behaved. Lets go nuke ? Its easy for you to make a video talking anything against the system and thousands of baboons will follow you. Dont we have the same problem with elephants, monkeys, peacocks and almost every other fauna . More than 30% of our crops been destroyed and farmers taking heinous methods to protect their crops. Tell a damn solution without criticizing and what does economy and gains of ambani got to do with your birds?

  • @shakthianjanananayakkara6528
    @shakthianjanananayakkara6528 8 місяців тому

    This is the last reason this project should not be built. No body should give a single fuck about stupid birds.

  • @forwheniamgonefor
    @forwheniamgonefor 8 місяців тому

    Nice Sponsor - China. Great teleprompter - Made in China ;-) we should be ware of propagandist spreading false information. BTW are you vegetarian?

  • @srilankamoor7781
    @srilankamoor7781 8 місяців тому +4

    This is Chinese propaganda. We need power grids. Can’t go for another 12 hour power cuts

    • @AyalFernando2004
      @AyalFernando2004 8 місяців тому

      Exactly

    • @ravinathweerasooriya8937
      @ravinathweerasooriya8937 8 місяців тому +6

      How is this Chinese propaganda? Citizens have a responsibility to oppose disadvantageous projects.

    • @danhan7869
      @danhan7869 8 місяців тому

      We are not a competitor to China. This is nothing but JVP and aragala terrorists trying to sabotage the economy.

    • @Deelo999
      @Deelo999 8 місяців тому

      @@ravinathweerasooriya8937 consider cost effectiveness vs lack of economic growth . EG this is less than 1 %. We need year round unbroken energy supply for investors settles in SL. due to nature of our harbours, all we need good infrastructure to manufacture in international scale.

    • @wikihoohoo
      @wikihoohoo 8 місяців тому

      Explain the connection between not opting to underground cables and Chinese propaganda

  • @warsil3735
    @warsil3735 8 місяців тому

    Bloody hell, first half mans should live . Birds will have an adaptive changes 😂😂