I'm apparently one of the few who liked the Iris release last year! I appreciate your review on this-- jasmine is a note that I find very hit or miss in perfumes, so I'm on the fence with this one.
Dear Mr Persolaise, you cannot imagine how much I like listening to you ... 5:25 would you please name the other two in your "Top Three femmine Perfumes"? Thank you 😊
Yes, soapy beginnings, and lovely drydown - though not the strongest nor longest lasting. Of the four Millesimes I’d put this at #2, behind Vanilla P. I did like M. Iris but not as an iris (didn’t smell any iris in fact); rather it was kind of an innocently sweet vanilla on my skin. Thanks for your review, was really looking forward to this one 🙏🏼
To me this works exactly the same like Tonka. You are right. The first note of Jasmine is quite heavy. But then after a while you will get this whiff of delicate Jasmine and it’s gorgeous. I’m definitely stocking this up.
Not from Milessime line, but Shalimar Souffle d'Oranger is the best flanker for me. I love jasmin as a note but i am in the fence any getting Millessime Jasmin because of the soapy beginning.
This is my favorite Shalimar Millesime. I found Tonka too heavy and Iris was just ok. This one is the most interesting. I haven’t been able to smell the Vanilla though so I can’t judge that one.
Always a joy to hear a royal we ;) RE the cultural appropriation idea, there's a fascinating interview with Benazir Bhutto (late Prime Minister of Pakistan) in which she describes visiting her father Zulfikar Ali Bhutto in prison prior to his execution, and she recounts fetching for him his own bottle of Shalimar which he wore right at the very end.
Had the same exact feeling !!! Opening was hmm was expecting way more better Jasmin expression and quality and then I literally followed the dry down like every 10 minutes .. and then the lovely Jasmine ,the better one the Indian more retro more indolique and interessant cames ,this construction is quite different from the other Shalimar and way more closer to Souffle de Parfums ,and then the warm Ambery vanilla leather makes it all more balanced ..I was so afraid after the « Iris Case » . on skin and after dry down it’s an other world ! Beautiful result and Shalimar DNA wasn’t betrayed (on the dry down ) but so much closer to Souffle de parfums structure ! Well done Deplhine ❤ ps : I’ve done my review one day before 😂 ahaha
@@Persolaise definitely and as we all know always better to get a nice ending despite any false promise at the first day 🤣. Did you find any souffle intense spirit ?
I expected Shalimar Millésime Jasmin to be very green in the opening and then transition to an overdose of fluffy white jasmine before settling down as a powdery white vanilla. But unfortunately it comes across as an overdose of sweet vanilla, much like last year’s Millésime Iris, rather than the celebration of jasmine I was hoping for. In the end, I suppose this version fits into the Shalimar family better than the one I had envisioned. SMJ carries the original Shalimar DNA, especially in the opening, along with the sweet vanilla we saw in SM Iris and even hints of tonka reminiscent of SM Tonka.
I have taken notice of this release, but it's not available to us in Australia yet. I absolutely love jasmine and I'm embarrassed to say I don't own Shalimar 'yet'. This could become my first version....
As I have predicted the millissime are running through the GUERLINADE (vanilla, Tonka, iris, jasmine.. then rose, bergamot and should be DONE. BTW I LOVED the Iris
SMJ really is a shapeshifter. Strangely I get something animalic directly from the OG Shalimar. Then the base is perfect for me. I struggle with the “baby sick & baby poop” notes in current Shalimar EdP. The base in SMJ is softly sophisticated. Turin might say “goes well with food”
Watched this on the edge of my seat as I've already got a bottle reserved for me at a Guerlain counter. 😂 Glad to hear it gets nicer in the dry down, floral leather sounds great to me!
@@Persolaise that is true i guess i just love natural jasmine too much to the point where cleaned up jasmine feels almost wasteful… but with that logic there wouldnt be any room for experimentation in perfumery
Thank you, i have waited for your Review. 🙏 My question has been answered. I love deep natural jasmin scents , maybe this one is not for me. I do love the original Shalimar for ever. The only millésime i have owned is the tonka one. I like it in a a cold season.
I haven't smelled this one, but all scents Delphine Jelk has created are flat structured, one dimensional, horrible stinkers. Her work isn't right for the house of Guerlain.
@@Persolaise , thank you so much. I thoroughly enjoy your reviews and always find them interesting and educating. I wholeheartedly agree that one shouldn't review today's new 'scentmaps' through a prism of the past. Even if many vintage masterpieces hold their own incredible power, today's scents might have interesting qualities, and you are always on point with this. New scents are most of all different, which goes for all of them. As for the various Jelk creations I find the attempts of new 'directions' and search for originality being scents which all lack deep, genuine harmony. But we are all different and I would be very happy if she created something so beautiful that it became a groundbreaking classic.
The Shalimar D’Iris is gorgeous
Ah, another fan. Excellent.
I agree
I think the iris leans more feminine romantic - it's also about body chemistry.
I'm apparently one of the few who liked the Iris release last year! I appreciate your review on this-- jasmine is a note that I find very hit or miss in perfumes, so I'm on the fence with this one.
Ah, good to know that you enjoyed the iris.
if they’re doing the full guerlinade with this line, god I CANNOT wait for the rose and bergamot versions
I suppose the bergamot would have to be like the 'light' Shalimar from many years ago.
Oh they’re definitely going full Guerlainade. I predict Millésime Rose next.
@@Persolaisethat Shalimar edc in the elongated bottle was absolutely amazing
Dear Mr Persolaise, you cannot imagine how much I like listening to you ... 5:25 would you please name the other two in your "Top Three femmine Perfumes"? Thank you 😊
Oh gosh, I can't think what they are now. Sorry!
Yes, soapy beginnings, and lovely drydown - though not the strongest nor longest lasting. Of the four Millesimes I’d put this at #2, behind Vanilla P.
I did like M. Iris but not as an iris (didn’t smell any iris in fact); rather it was kind of an innocently sweet vanilla on my skin.
Thanks for your review, was really looking forward to this one 🙏🏼
Thank YOU very much for watching.
To me this works exactly the same like Tonka. You are right. The first note of Jasmine is quite heavy. But then after a while you will get this whiff of delicate Jasmine and it’s gorgeous. I’m definitely stocking this up.
Good to know -- thanks for watching.
so glad you talked about this and Barenia! TY!!!! I was really interested in those two!
Thank YOU for watching.
Not from Milessime line, but
Shalimar Souffle d'Oranger is the best flanker for me. I love jasmin as a note but i am in the fence any getting Millessime Jasmin because of the soapy beginning.
Yes, it really is very soapy, right?
Thanks for watching.
Was waiting for this one
Wonderful.
This is my favorite Shalimar Millesime. I found Tonka too heavy and Iris was just ok. This one is the most interesting. I haven’t been able to smell the Vanilla though so I can’t judge that one.
Good to know. I think the Vanilla is probably my favourite.
Always a joy to hear a royal we ;) RE the cultural appropriation idea, there's a fascinating interview with Benazir Bhutto (late Prime Minister of Pakistan) in which she describes visiting her father Zulfikar Ali Bhutto in prison prior to his execution, and she recounts fetching for him his own bottle of Shalimar which he wore right at the very end.
Oh gosh, that's a superb story. Thanks for sharing.
Thierry Wasser is misssing !! Please come back for the next Millesime 🙏
I wonder if he'll do the next one.
I just got the shipping notification on my bottle. I can’t wait!!
Come back and let us know what you think of it.
Had the same exact feeling !!! Opening was hmm was expecting way more better Jasmin expression and quality and then I literally followed the dry down like every 10 minutes .. and then the lovely Jasmine ,the better one the Indian more retro more indolique and interessant cames ,this construction is quite different from the other Shalimar and way more closer to Souffle de Parfums ,and then the warm Ambery vanilla leather makes it all more balanced ..I was so afraid after the « Iris Case » . on skin and after dry down it’s an other world !
Beautiful result and Shalimar DNA wasn’t betrayed (on the dry down ) but so much closer to Souffle de parfums structure !
Well done Deplhine ❤ ps : I’ve done my review one day before 😂 ahaha
Ah, this is fascinating. I do think the opening should have been handled better, but thank goodness it improves as it goes along.
@@Persolaise definitely and as we all know always better to get a nice ending despite any false promise at the first day 🤣. Did you find any souffle intense spirit ?
@@Persolaise definitely Agree ✔️
Got my bottle coming tomorrow, worried/excited!
I hope you like it.
Good to know. On an unrelated topic. Have you tried and reviewed the amouage opus king blue??? ☮️🇺🇸
I haven’t reviewed it.
Thanks very much for watching.
I expected Shalimar Millésime Jasmin to be very green in the opening and then transition to an overdose of fluffy white jasmine before settling down as a powdery white vanilla.
But unfortunately it comes across as an overdose of sweet vanilla, much like last year’s Millésime Iris, rather than the celebration of jasmine I was hoping for.
In the end, I suppose this version fits into the Shalimar family better than the one I had envisioned. SMJ carries the original Shalimar DNA, especially in the opening, along with the sweet vanilla we saw in SM Iris and even hints of tonka reminiscent of SM Tonka.
An excellent summation.
Thanks for watching.
I have taken notice of this release, but it's not available to us in Australia yet. I absolutely love jasmine and I'm embarrassed to say I don't own Shalimar 'yet'. This could become my first version....
Well, if you get it, come back and let us know what you make of it.
As I have predicted the millissime are running through the GUERLINADE (vanilla, Tonka, iris, jasmine.. then rose, bergamot and should be DONE. BTW I LOVED the Iris
Ah, good to know. Thanks for watching.
SMJ really is a shapeshifter. Strangely I get something animalic directly from the OG Shalimar. Then the base is perfect for me. I struggle with the “baby sick & baby poop” notes in current Shalimar EdP.
The base in SMJ is softly sophisticated. Turin might say “goes well with food”
Yes, it certainly comes into its own in the drydown.
Purchased. Cannot wait
Please let me know what you think of it.
@@Persolaisedidn’t like it 🥲my mistake was to engrave the bottle can’t return it 🥲
I'm waiting for mine to arrive 💖
Please let me know what you think of it.
Watched this on the edge of my seat as I've already got a bottle reserved for me at a Guerlain counter. 😂 Glad to hear it gets nicer in the dry down, floral leather sounds great to me!
Let me know what you think of it when it arrives.
I never understood the need for making clean jasmine (and even tuberose) scents. Isnt the beauty of jasmine its indolic and heavy components?
Yes and no. It's an indolic flower, but it's also interesting to manipulate it and see what other facets it can offer.
Yes❤
@@Persolaise that is true i guess i just love natural jasmine too much to the point where cleaned up jasmine feels almost wasteful… but with that logic there wouldnt be any room for experimentation in perfumery
Not all jasmine is indolic. I collect jasmine and there are jasmine that are very soapy and green.
@@EduVonGomes true
I imagine a jasmine tea drank whilst wearing shalimar and that appeals rather than an overt jasmine led scent .
Great description.
Iris was not good but after it has sat it is lovely
Good to know.
Thanks for watching.
🌷
Thanks for watching.
I’m wearing bal a Versailles today as I watch this but had shalimar on yesterday at work .
Ooooh, wonderful.
Thank you, i have waited for your Review. 🙏 My question has been answered. I love deep natural jasmin scents , maybe this one is not for me. I do love the original Shalimar for ever. The only millésime i have owned is the tonka one. I like it in a a cold season.
Glad you found the review useful -- thanks for watching.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Thanks for watching.
I haven't smelled this one, but all scents Delphine Jelk has created are flat structured, one dimensional, horrible stinkers. Her work isn't right for the house of Guerlain.
Oh dear. Well, this channel is all about exchanging views and ideas, so I totally welcome your response to her work.
@@Persolaise , thank you so much. I thoroughly enjoy your reviews and always find them interesting and educating.
I wholeheartedly agree that one shouldn't review today's new 'scentmaps' through a prism of the past. Even if many vintage masterpieces hold their own incredible power, today's scents might have interesting qualities, and you are always on point with this. New scents are most of all different, which goes for all of them. As for the various Jelk creations I find the attempts of new 'directions' and search for originality being scents which all lack deep, genuine harmony. But we are all different and I would be very happy if she created something so beautiful that it became a groundbreaking classic.
I havevvll
Wonderful.
I dislike Shalimar.
It’s a masterpiece, but it’s definitely not everyone’s cup of tea!
That's okay -- we can't all like the same scents.
Have you tried the Shalimar cologne? It’s much lighter and quite lovely.
Hopefully soon in 🦘land..I’m a bit migraine sensitive with strong Jasmine; hopefully good for me🤞🏻
Thank you 🙋🏻♀️🇦🇺❤️🧡
It'll be interesting to know what you make of it.