@@BlueWolfStudios117 it almost happened during Falklands war, apparently British submarine was able to locate Argentina submarine but failed to attack it, Argentino sub was a more quieter diesel electric and eluded the British submarine
@@BlueWolfStudios117 Technically it only happened once during WW2, every sub-to-sub engagement of the war involved one sub being on the surface, except one. A British sub skipper managed to compute a 4-dimensional firing solution on U-864 with minimal calculations and basic information as to speed, heading etc. He guessed where the sub would dive to and fired 4 shots, only one hit. It's the only successful sub-to-sub engagement ever recorded.
Thinking that when the countermeasure ammunition was launched - my thinking is this - the torpedos would either blow up at the countermeasures' ammo without hitting the sub directly as it hit the countermeasures, or the countermeasures would detonate and cause the torpedos to go off course before the tubes blew later. I guessed for no. 1 when I first watched this movie on HBO, and sadly, I should have guessed for no. 2. Also, if I were in that sub, and if I were the sub commander, I would launch the countermeasures to be released from the sub's stern, or back, to cut back on the torpedo's impact even more, assuming that a torpedo attack can be from behind my ship.
The depiction of countermeasures in this movie (and most submarine movies) is not very detailed, though it can be forgiven in that era of movies as many of these techniques were classified and it's hard to show audiences how these things work. The countermeasure does pull the torpedo off-course, but this is in combination with a technique called forming a 'knuckle'. When the submarine rapidly changes course, it forms a knot of turbulent water behind it which momentarily masks the submarine. This combined with the countermeasure is what pulls it off-course. Using a countermeasure earlier such that it simply sits far behind the submarine, directly astern does basically nothing. A torpedo will typically just pass through, recognize it was fooled by a noisemaker, and start a search pattern which will easily pick up the original target. The torpedo has it's own sonar to do such a search. Furthermore, if the torpedo is still on a wire, it will definitely not fool the parent submarine.
Yeah, it's hilarious when movies portray stuff like this where guys that are supposed to be experts in their field ask dumb questions on behalf of the audience.
Some subs boasted strong enough hulls to tank a torpedo hit, the SSBNs were the most likely candidates. The Typhoon-class was always the front-runner in that regard, even in the game Cold Waters 9/10 times you need to successful torpedo hits to sink it.
At least in a destroyer, you can jump into the water and wait for rescue, in a submarine, that's very unlikely, death is almost certain, I think only Russian submarines have escape pods, but you'll be lucky if you can get to one in a damaged submarine
@@bombarderoazul Especially if the bilch bay gets flooded so so bad on a torpedo hit, the only way out is to seal the bilch bay. Failure to do so means the sub goes down to depths dangerous enough to create a death-inducing hull crush implosion like what happened to the Titan submersible about 4 days prior.
Nah man, destroyers have very little armor. One torpedo from a sub against a destroyer would equal a dead destroyer as well. Not to say that subs aren't just as much if not more threatening than a surface ship to the crew. Just that one's armor is not a factor.
@@compmanio36 Ship armor is irrelevant when dealing with torpedoes. The torp explodes under the ship, forming an air bubble, which means that gravity breaks the ship in half. Armor is against artillery shells and rockets. Not torpedoes.
A little before the captain gives the command "All ahead standard", wich means go ahead to standard power, because he was at 'All ahead flank (that means full power)', the bell noise indicated the confirmation of power change, if i'm not mistaken :)
If I was skipper I'd remind the Sonar guy to get a grip and stop shouting. Somewhat similar to how Gerard Butler's character sorted out his sonar guy in Hunter Killer.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
An OSCAR award for the sonar-guy👍
THIS IS EXTENDED VERSION!
He was in titanic and the rock.
Booooo!
@@martinlutherking6550 and Eraser.
1 or 2?
0:58
The Akula looks so badass as she cuts hard to port while opening her tubes. Thanx 4 posting and have a 'like'!
Hunter> "how about we start a drill now sir?"
Hunter: Sir lets resurface to receive the EAM with an Akula above us
@@BurnedSpacesend one ping only
How nice of the sonar to draw out the shape of things on screen
loll
I almost died watching this. It was so intense
2:06 When you're in the middle of a clan battle and you Father asks you if you've done your homework...
Me 2:13
Submarine battles are awesome. They’re slow-no underwater dogfights.
They almost never happen actually or very rarely are both subs underwater
Sir Humphrey Appleby happened a lot during WW2, yet indeed there arent as many any more.
@@BlueWolfStudios117 it almost happened during Falklands war, apparently British submarine was able to locate Argentina submarine but failed to attack it, Argentino sub was a more quieter diesel electric and eluded the British submarine
A true game of marco polo
@@BlueWolfStudios117 Technically it only happened once during WW2, every sub-to-sub engagement of the war involved one sub being on the surface, except one. A British sub skipper managed to compute a 4-dimensional firing solution on U-864 with minimal calculations and basic information as to speed, heading etc. He guessed where the sub would dive to and fired 4 shots, only one hit. It's the only successful sub-to-sub engagement ever recorded.
Range gateing? I don't remember that exchange in the movie and I've watched it multiple times
I agree. Ican't see this scene on dvd. where's come from?
Probably a video version that includes deleted scenes.
There's a RARE DVD-Extended version - and that's where this is from. Small stuff. Nothing earth-shattering.
It's on an extended edition
Mandela effect😂😂
Amazing gene Hackman.
When you get a bounty and you in your sub and the whole lobby sends the players with subs after you in GTA😂
Is this extended version? Some scene here is not in the original movie.
Thinking that when the countermeasure ammunition was launched - my thinking is this - the torpedos would either blow up at the countermeasures' ammo without hitting the sub directly as it hit the countermeasures, or the countermeasures would detonate and cause the torpedos to go off course before the tubes blew later. I guessed for no. 1 when I first watched this movie on HBO, and sadly, I should have guessed for no. 2.
Also, if I were in that sub, and if I were the sub commander, I would launch the countermeasures to be released from the sub's stern, or back, to cut back on the torpedo's impact even more, assuming that a torpedo attack can be from behind my ship.
The depiction of countermeasures in this movie (and most submarine movies) is not very detailed, though it can be forgiven in that era of movies as many of these techniques were classified and it's hard to show audiences how these things work. The countermeasure does pull the torpedo off-course, but this is in combination with a technique called forming a 'knuckle'. When the submarine rapidly changes course, it forms a knot of turbulent water behind it which momentarily masks the submarine. This combined with the countermeasure is what pulls it off-course.
Using a countermeasure earlier such that it simply sits far behind the submarine, directly astern does basically nothing. A torpedo will typically just pass through, recognize it was fooled by a noisemaker, and start a search pattern which will easily pick up the original target. The torpedo has it's own sonar to do such a search. Furthermore, if the torpedo is still on a wire, it will definitely not fool the parent submarine.
@@NACLGames interesting stuff!
Star Wars cant hang with this. This is moviemaking at the highest level.
You watch the critical drinker too?
Modern movies in general can't compete with this. They are too obsessed with "woke" culture to actually make a good film.
I wouldn't mind if the movie just had a subtitle pop up explaining the military lingo instead of making a character ask a question they'd never ask.
Yeah, it's hilarious when movies portray stuff like this where guys that are supposed to be experts in their field ask dumb questions on behalf of the audience.
Top Gun under the sea
Best sub movie after Das Boot and Hunt for Red October.
So Popeye finally joined the Navy where he belongs.
1:45 he announced "10,000 yards". How did the torpedo go from 3,000 to 10,000 and then back to 1,000?
He clearly said, "2,000 yds."
Green vs blue
Galielio
Soviet Submarines such as the Akula/Typoon class Submarine are awesome.
Surface tablet
Jose Class 5 VS Matthew Class 4, who is the winner?
اندروميدا
Cold Waters and Sea Power combat in the missile age be like:
This is the most worthest nightmare ever!!!!! 😱😱😱😱
THAT DAMN WINCH!!! 😁😅🤫✌️
Yep that blew their stealth.
سوبر نبيل اسيل
Pull ahead flank, right full Rutter!
واش بيهه
2nd 1st renault
Akula2000, sudah 2021 at THN.
Sori
الدستور السلفية في الجائر
"What's range gating??" 🥴🥴 Was it bring your son to work day on the nuclear submarine?
A single active sonar ping to determine range.
Hackman at his BEST!!
i didnt steal my name from this movie shhh!
موحدون 30
موح
ماش كيف كيف
Great movie
War in the land, sky and sea....such cool! 😎😎😎
That’s why I never choose to be on a sub instead of a destroyer. One hit in a sub it dead in a destroyer ur not. 😂🤣😂👍
Some subs boasted strong enough hulls to tank a torpedo hit, the SSBNs were the most likely candidates. The Typhoon-class was always the front-runner in that regard, even in the game Cold Waters 9/10 times you need to successful torpedo hits to sink it.
At least in a destroyer, you can jump into the water and wait for rescue, in a submarine, that's very unlikely, death is almost certain, I think only Russian submarines have escape pods, but you'll be lucky if you can get to one in a damaged submarine
@@bombarderoazul Especially if the bilch bay gets flooded so so bad on a torpedo hit, the only way out is to seal the bilch bay. Failure to do so means the sub goes down to depths dangerous enough to create a death-inducing hull crush implosion like what happened to the Titan submersible about 4 days prior.
Nah man, destroyers have very little armor. One torpedo from a sub against a destroyer would equal a dead destroyer as well. Not to say that subs aren't just as much if not more threatening than a surface ship to the crew. Just that one's armor is not a factor.
@@compmanio36 Ship armor is irrelevant when dealing with torpedoes. The torp explodes under the ship, forming an air bubble, which means that gravity breaks the ship in half. Armor is against artillery shells and rockets. Not torpedoes.
adel
1:08 from range gating to 1000 yards torpedo activation, this guy knows nothing about their boat
بان
Ali
Patserie
سبحان الله العظيم
عادل جغلاف
3:21 whats that noice?
A little before the captain gives the command "All ahead standard", wich means go ahead to standard power, because he was at 'All ahead flank (that means full power)', the bell noise indicated the confirmation of power change, if i'm not mistaken :)
That noise you heard is a speed control system that control the submarine speed. It rings out bells when it changes.
سكول ماشي كيف
Metropoliten obtain
If I was skipper I'd remind the Sonar guy to get a grip and stop shouting. Somewhat similar to how Gerard Butler's character sorted out his sonar guy in Hunter Killer.
Cc
بولسار
Mein kumf haya
Supervook الحرب الداخلية
مغيب الشمس
8k
Sldt sk boss
امنيتي دنيا
31
Mining enfieering
الحوت الأزرق
Minus
ليونا
ماد
Dogfight time!
Jarb ummayd
مولد
fittest jamel inkiv
باسات سيسي
حكم
لهم الخزي
ماستر
بلو سفير
الحرب على الومن
Gabriel
كونترول
فسلية انت
يوفف فرنسا
Ji310
مصيبة مقنن
ATA
سيلبشيب
Reddit gta6
Ar15
بفور كريس
3
SAAB
مقو حم
The perfect movie for the times we are living in right now with Kamala Harris about to take over as president
ب
Subhuman robot
شنقريحة
A u.s sub would never escape an acula class
LMFAO
Bullshit Ivan!
@@ericmorang3903 Poor yankee, did the truth hurt your pussy?
Ofcourse it will easily escape