"Meinst du die Russen wollen Krieg?" - Soviet Anti-war Song in German (Хотят ли русские войны)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 тра 2023
- UA-cam striked my channel for promoting terrorism because of an IRA video (Come out ye black and tans), so they blocked me from uploading anything for a few days, thats why I haven't uploaded since May 1st
My channel is dedicated to anthems, hymns and patriotic songs, here is the link to our discord server: / discord
Not gonna lie, this is very beautiful version of original!
Meinst du, die russen wollen die spezielle Kriegoperation ??
Hello Ingen,
in the first stanza of the song Busch sings "Im weiten Feld im Pappelhain" (Which is a light forest full of poplars) "Befrag die Birken an dem RAIN" not Rhine. The Rhine is a river very far in the west of Germany, where in all probability no Russian soldier is buried (referring to the line "dort wo er liegt in seinem Grab, den russischen Soldaten frag"). Meant is a Rain, which means as much as field edge or wayside. This could be misleading. If it is possible, please change it so that no one here misunderstands. Thank you very much. Thats one of the most beautyful Songs of UdSSR.
Greetings from East Germany.
There are russian soldiers near the Rhine. POW were held in whole Germany. But you are right with the rest.
Sachse?
Many Russian soldiers also died in the Rhine area. The text is already correct.
The only germany I can respect. All the best, comrade.
@@jakubb700 It's true that Russian soldiers were trapped on the Rhine during the war, but in the context of the song it's sung about the many who met their end on the battlefield (at least that's how I understood the song). But you are right, there were russian soldiers 👍
Beautiful song, thank you for the upload.
Reading these comments, it is clear people don't understand that this is an anti-war song. In the lyrics he is asking Russian citizens if they wont war, something they don't, but their government says the contrary. This is actually how the situation in Russia is and people are instead poking fun of Russia without even understanding the lyrics themselves
It says the government doesn't either. "Russia" wasn't a thing when this song was written.
If that was an anti government song then it would not have been allowed in the USSR. What they are meant to imply is that both the government and the people don't want war.
The Russians want war. Clearly. 60% of the Russian population supports a war of aggression.
It was not an anti-war song, it was a patriotic song adressed to enemy's citizens: Do you think that russians want war?
@michal Russian Socialist Federative Soviet Republic*
Three uploads in a day??? We have been plessed
Ingen going to new heights
I only see two?
Edit: Nevermind
0:25 This isn't about the river Rhine (Rhein), it's about either a Feldrain (some sort of border: de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feldrain ) or a Rain, which in some German regions is a word for slope/hillside, althoung the standard German word would be Hang.
But both Rain and Feldrain are pronounced exactly the same as the river Rhein.
Welcome back Ingen!
Прекрасный стих, прекрасное пение и на русском и на немецком.
The Russians want war. Clearly. 60% of the Russian population supports a war of aggression.
@@DrHydro-mq7sw laut Regierungsumfragen?)
TNO???
@@stadtrepublikmulhausen4121 именно
Nein das russische Volk will so wenig Krieg wie wir Deutsche.
Ein sehr schönes Lied in Text und Melodie!
One of my favorite songs
Least communist north Italian vs least fascist south italian
@@randomgoat3886 tell me you know sh*t about my country without actually saying it.
Bravo, viva il comunismo!🚩🇮🇹
@@kothbegemoth84 grazie compagno
@@itacom2199 Ha vinto Giorgia Meloni. Hai perso, comunista.
❤❤❤ОЧЕНЬ КРАСИВО ЗВУЧИТ НА НЕМЕЦКОМ ЯЗЫКЕ!!!❤❤❤
Danke!
Earliste ive ever been for a video
Hard times create strong Slavs.
Strong Slavs create hard times.
Hard times create strong Slavs.
🔁
germans arent slavs
@SlonzokzeSlonska 👍👍. The people who this song is about are Slavs. Hence, my comment about Slavs.
@@FirstName-kd4nv i thought this is just antiwar song but ok
Чтобы понять кто на стороне добра, а кто зла, надо просто вспомнить:
- кто шутил про кондиционеры
- кто называл детей личинками жуков
- кто на телевидении показывал как женщина режет горло пленному
- кто называет блюда в ресторане именами погибших людей
- кто в рекламе заменяет жертвам теракта лица на фарш
- кто радуется расстрелу мирных людей в концертом зале
И сразу все становится на свои места
Русские никогда не хотели войны. Нас этому учили и советы, нас этому учили предки. Украина, к сожалению, это понятие предало и полезло на своего же брата.
@@BlackLeague249 you violated the budapest memorandum and attacked ukraine, do not cower behind faked victimhood
This aged like fine milk
Danke
I think in deepest thoughts most of Russian people really don't want war. I, as a citizen of Russia, don't want this war and I hope it'll end soon with (hopefully) new government in here
Wer will schon Krieg. Aber wer will schon Untertan sein oder werden? 🤷🏻♂️ deshalb empfehle ich zu kämpfen sonst geht Russland kaputt wie Germany. 😢
@@wertuntgewinnt7517 also willst du, dass die faschistische Putin-Regiment noch lebt?
It might unfortunately take a long time for government reforms in your country. The current governmental system's style goes way back in history and it may take a long time to get rid of those roots that were the main thing that started the corruption in the first place.
@@AlreadyTakenTag at First look in you Country and your goverment and corruptions. 😂 sklaven händler
almost the same, if in kiew is a new government... a nation will be born, if the ukrainian people let the fuck them out all his oligarchs and set a free democratic government in instead of Selensky and his patron oligarch. same result, just this is probably, not like the government change in moscow. Peace and God bless you all, ukrainian and russian people.
This edit is better than original Russian song. I really like both ngl, but German is better for this song
🖤❤️💛
Согласен.
yeah you indoctrinated ukrainians in general like leaning more towards german stuff.
You could make a video for the Chilean version of this song, sung by Rolando alarcon
Wow, double video !
Triple videos
Interesting. Sounds nice.
Is this because of the close relationship to the soviets?
Yes probably. But i wouldn't call it a "close relationship". It was a military occupation and a puppet regime
listening to this while playing stellaris, the galaxy wide War is going great with this song
Russian songs sound best in German.
a lot of songs sound good in German, a good question why...
History repeats itself, but at this time the "Stars" hit first
No, thats wrong..first strike was from nato in 2008, georgia, than 2014 ukrain
@@pkkaussrGeorgia isnt even close to being nato affliated you mong
@@pkkaussr This is bullshit. Moscow has a tradition of invading its neighbours and they just keep doing it.
(That does not make the all these bullshit anti terror wars right, but saying the US + allies also do evil stuff, does not make it less bad.)
As a Pole i have to say that hits me hard.
A slight correction 'Weltenbrand' ought to have been translated as 'world-fire' or 'world conflagration', meaning a worldwide disaster or conflict
And I thought it means a revolution, not a disaster
Also, at 0:25, I am pretty certain that there has been a phonetic confusion. It just so happens hat "der Rhein" (the river Rhine) and "der Rain" (a baulk, meaning a strip of vegetation bordering a field) sound exactly the same in German. I can see where the confusion is coming from as "der Rain" is not at all a commonly used word, but "der Rhein" would make no sense as the Soviets never reached the river Rhine during WW2. Moreover, birches being pioneer trees commonly grow on the transitional zone between forests and the open landscape, so it would make perfect sense for them to be found at a "Rain".
"Do you think the Russians want war?"
Aged like fine milk.
Yes, they want
@@valentyn7739No Putin wants war.
Нет.
No.
They don't want war
@@LebaneseOrthodox then come to Russia and listen how they will be very happy that everyone who speaks English and lives in the west will be destroyed.
2 videos in less than a minute?
Actual Content
Strange times and these people are still alive. Run, run away!
My friend (a German communist) will like this, I am sure.
Do you think the Russians want war?
Ask Prague Spring!
And the elderly Finn will remember,
A young Georgian will tell
Lithuania, Estonians, Latvians
Chechnya, Moldova, Ingushy
And a citizen of any country!
Do the Russians want
Do the Russians want
Do Russians want war?
Vadim Dubovsky
u dont want to play this game dude
Georgia was invaded cuz georgian armed forces striked at russian peacekeeping forces at their own border.
Ichkeria - islamic extremists same to ISIS and Taliban(google about Beslan school)
Go and ask a Russian off the street if he wants war. Start using atleast 1% of your brain to comprehend that Russian government =/= Every Russian in Russia. Jesus Christ
@@RH_5152Why are Russian peace keeping forces in Georgia afterall?!!?
@@RH_5152 Yeah sure, and Poland attacked Nazigermany first...
Now we know the answer.
Уже раз 5 переслушал
На немецком хорошо звучит👍
русский акцент конечно лютый.
@@CMEPT_PUTINSKIM_OKKUPANTAM звучит ещё грозней и чувственней
@@CMEPT_PUTINSKIM_OKKUPANTAM Это поёт коммунист Эрнст Буш, и он немец. Какой русский акцент?
В немецком нет твёрдого Л.
В целом он неплохо справляется со звуком Эль, как в слове Soldaten.
Но он явно спалился на слове Vaterland.
Но самое палевное это звук Р.
Такой звук Р резонирующий как здесь можно поставить только в одном месте.
У логопеда в советском детском садике.
Это железобетонно.
например во фразе Kämpfer Rat.
Вы можете эту фразу тупо в гугле вствить и послушать звучание.
Это русский поёт 95 % даю.
Die Antwort kennen wir ja nun.
Те русские, которые не хотят войны, очень тихие. Даже те, кто находится за пределами России.
Нихера себе тихие - все нервы нам истрепали.
@@user-jx9lp1jc7j Почему раздражают российские нервы? А что ты такой непристойный?
Can you do "siammanusati"? plzz :)
is the come out ye black and tans video completely gone now
"Claimed its Anti-Semitism"
Typical UA-cam
RIP to all Russian and German soldiers who sacrificed everything for their motherlands. May we embrace peace and righteousness 🇩🇪 🇷🇺 🕯☦
no
Жаль только, что немцы тогда посчитали своей родиной весь мир
I love how my two replies to this are a German and Russian respectively. Remember saints of German origin like Prokop von Ustjug and the Romanov martyrs guys!
@@seronymus russia will always be the enemy of the Germans. I will never forgive them what they did.
@@user-bb5xu6wr9u Германия смогла избавиться от этого заблуждения. Россия все еще должна последовать их примеру.
Did UA-cam get rid of “Wo alle Straßen Enden”? I couldn’t find it on your channel.
@@SwePol I’m literally 24 I swear bro
@@Volkermann wdym?
I’m East Germany and I approve this message
You support socialistic system ?
@@elmanazimov1385 yes and im coming for your toothbrush and your rundown shotgun house in Mississippi
@@elmanazimov1385 Yes
Weg wit den spitzeln
@@elmanazimov1385 Yes
Eines der besten Antikriegsgedichte von Jewgeni Jewtuschenko! Kann es heute noch auswendig aufsagen. Gruß
First i hope
Yes
Man, this German version lacked any Bundesheer combat footage to have a montage... because of song composition
Bundesheer is austrian, Bundeswehr is german
@@nemotastic86 this is now like the 2nd time this has happened to me
So tell me why the Federal German Military retains the term wehr? And Austria makes more sense with that more than their lowlander counterparts
@@shinsenshogun900 wehr means defense
@@shinsenshogun900 East Germany had the "NVA".
The "Nationale Volks Armee"
@@shinsenshogun900I can't tell you why, why don't you ask a German? They won't know either. That's just how it is
🎉❤❤❤
This one didn't age quite well
Do you think the Russians want war?
Ask the mothers whose son are dying in Ukraine.
Do they want war? No they don’t.
This is a war of the bourgeoisie, not the people.
Yes, however it seems their leader wants war, not the Russian
Isn't that normal for Propaganda songs
Но некоторые русские до сих пор не хотят войны, это факт
@@WhatShould_I_WriteHere I don't get people like you. The whole comment section is english, I do a comment in english and you reply to it in russian(?) or whatever language that is. Few people are going to undertand it.
100 тысяч просмотров!
bro rlly went to future
2022/2023 Edition: Do you think the Russians want Special Military Operation?
The Russians want war. Clearly. 60% of the Russian population supports a war of aggression.
as a russian citizen, I was waiting for it since 2014 when ukrainian government fell under rebels.
@@RH_5152 I said it before. The majority of Russians are warmongering fascists
@@RH_5152 that was a rough year for you guys 😖 Удачи, брат
@@RH_5152 💯💯
❤❤❤❤❤!!!!❤❤❤❤❤!!!!!
Aged like milk
How?
@@user-jf5qw6vg3h Because Russia literally started the war against Ukraine. Don't even try to deny it. Russia wants war.
Dang.
First comment, congratulations!
Bro is fast asf.
Not again, Ivan's gonna kill me
Peace please 🕊️
Says the one with the terrorists flag
@@moisuomi yes, all Arabs are "terrorists" definitely
+he's not even an Arab???
@@moisuomi his flag isn't even that of palestine
Why would they strike you for come out ye black and tans? It isn't even an Ira song, it's a republican song (which are just Irish nationalist songs)
Nicht nur die 💪💪💪
All i can comment to this song is.....IRONIC
and it's sad
Unbanned moment
what happened to the song „Wo alle Straßen enden“ ?
Think it got age restricted and then removed
Some of them do.
Jetzt wissen wir, was sie wollen
2 in 1?
First
Ja, Sie wollen.
Nein! Wir wollen nicht diesen sinnlose Krieg
This is not Ernst busch - an erst busch admirer from germany
אני אוהב את זה
Yes they do
Ja...ja wollen sie.
They dont but you want
@@BdbdNaoThats why they always start them.
Is this Ernst Busch?
Unironically fitting to the current time
I just started learning German, but... Doesn't "Meint ihr" (2:48) mean "Does he think" and not "Do you think" ?
Do you think is correct. Meint ihr is plural.
@@wertzui1926 Thank you!
@@OmegaTaishu What you meant is "Meint er" and that‘s indeed "Does he think".
@@hdbrot So it is, thank you for the correction!
I come up with the lyrics of 'ich bin soldat' that lyrics are 'every people love the peace' ' only tyrants must wage a war'
German people are good at composing and writing lyrics
As a German, thank you on behalf of my Vaterland and Volk 🙂
2nd
Russia be like: War is bad.
But,
US be like: war is bad, but....
War isn't bad or good. It's simply something that must be done, but not many people understand this. We think we can all be friends. If we cannot make peace with our past and forgive the millennia of slaughter between our nations, then war is inevitable
It is bad but when your people are getting killed then it may be needed to start one to stop the situation.
@@EinDeutscherPatriot620 That‘s just why we need to forgive these millennia of slaughter. I could easily do that. And hence, this also does not invalidate the claim that war is bad.
@@hdbrot You could easily do that, yes? If you haven't seen war then everyone could easily forgive it. But for those who live it, it's much harder and most people don't understand how horrible war can be at its worst. Photos and videos certainly don't do it justice. Forgiveness of death, rape, destruction, and murder isn't something anyone could easily forgive and saying you can is a lie. And war isn't bad or good. It's a tool people use for a reason. Wars are inevitable and they can be extremely complex, far more complex than just being able to talk your way out of it like everyone wants to do. If someone breaks into your home with one purpose in mind, you won't be able to talk your way out of it.
Bro literally posted 3 vids at the same time
While writing the comment i literally had to update it from 2 to 3 because he posted a new one
Yes,i think that. See Ukraine,Georgia,the list goes on…
Georgia started a Genocide against its own people, God knows why, and the inhabitants asked for international help, while Democratic West was shut, great Russia saved Abkhazia from Stalinist Georgian government. And about Ukraine, are you really blind, deaf or maybe both? Because Ukraine tried to join NATO and NATO surrounds Russia's borders, Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Poland, Lithuania, Georgia, Japan, South Korea, Ukraine...all have US military bases ready to invade Russia.
Look at the context, dummy 😂
Chechnya, Afghan, Hungary, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania
@@user-jf5qw6vg3h Nay then you lie. ichGive proof. Furthermore,Russia saber rattles,so of course countries want to join NATo…
@@stephe4721 Chechnya is a modern Invention, a terrorist state like the Ukrainian Reich. Afghanistan was invade by Soviets not Russians. Hungary wasn't invaded by Russia until it joined the Axis, and Russia never invaded the Baltics we just took them once from Poland, then from Germany, Russia never directly engaged with Baltics.
Hi
Ja
hello
Who sang this?
A German person.
They do in fact want war
act of self-defense to protect the people of Donbas & other regions that are near ukrainian border.
ruskies were not the ones that started shelling civs.
just because the government does doesn't mean that the russian workers do.
@@comradeLucienne most of russians waited for this war to happen since 2014, ukrainians couldn't just massacre people without getting f'd
@@RH_5152 They started the war in the Donbas by supporting the separatists, then started crying like little children and screaming genocide because the Ukrainian military came to do their job.
@@RH_5152Same excuse as nazi germany. Always protecting its people but not in their own country where cannibals are freed and people drink themselves to death.
❤️ ¡Viva Alemania del Este! 🇩🇪❤️
Vive Allemagne libre et indépendente ! USA go homme! La fine de ľ occupation américaine !!
Yes, yes I do think so.
then watch what your "heroic" ukrainian "warriors" did to Donbas since 2014.
NO NO AND NO
@@RH_5152 You heard what Prigozhin said yesterday? 😁
3. OKT. 1990 - Ich nabe meine Heimat verloren und nicht wiedergefunden.
Ja wollen sie🤔😂
Ingen gone crazy
Русские не хотят войны. Каждый из нас знает цену войны. Но наша власть ее забыла, и мы, к сожалению, ничего не можем с этим сделать... Нет войне.
Можем.Взять вилы
😢❤
Hey, es gibt in Deutschland klare Regeln, was YT machen darf und was nicht. DU bist hier nicht so ausgeliefert wie die Amerikaner. Ich empfehle dir eine Rechtsschutzversicherung abzuschließen. Denn sonst wirst du dich ja doch nicht gegen YT wehren.
Apparently they do
Who wouldn't
there is a Spanish version
Wo findet man die Version ?
@@MrPuhvogel "querrían los rusos las guerra" from a republican spanish singer
And so began, yet another ingen spam…
Das hat mir Gänsehaut gegeben. Deutschland und Russland ❤. Friede für immer
☮️🇷🇺🤝🇺🇦
Ah, such a based comment!👍
@@Better_Clean_Than_GreenCompletely agree with you
not possible at the moment, at all.
Finally, a sensible comment.
More portuguese songs pls
Sim por favor🇵🇹💪
@@Volkermann Angola é nossa has already a video, I would like to see more 25 de Abril songs.