getchoo and holiday being only 7 is actually criminal. holiday is the most underrated song on blue, and getchoo is just a good song, even with its dark theme
Holiday is an amazing song, and almost made to be done by high school jazz choirs for the next decades. I feel the only thing that even slightly brings it down is how well it blends into Only in Dreams, so it almost feels like a small intro or interlude until the real meat of the ender.
Why are all the *good* videos on Weezer so hidden by the algorithm?? This is one of the best rankings I've seen! You make your rankings well justified and explain it all well, even if you aren't Weezer based, this video is still a gem in the community 🙌
Holiday at 7 was a punch to the gut, it’s one of my favorite songs from blue 😭 Same with American Gigolo’s rating, it’s my favorite maladroit song. Also why is tired of sex a 10? The good life deserved that instead.
My favorite thing about Weezer fans is how vastly different their opinions on songs are... like a 10/10 Foolish Father is absolutely diabolical to me lol
The fact that teal goes above anything else is insane. When you got to make believe I thought you didn't even include teal which is what I would've expected. Edit: RUN RAVEN RUN IS A 9 OMG IM CRYYYIIINGGGG Edit 2 LA GIRLZ IS BETTER THAN ONLY IN DREAMS UR I CANT BREATHE
i unironically love raditude like everysong maybe im crazy but i dont think any able ot bad i love everything...except for love is the answear that song is ok..
Pretty good rating, Autumn was kinda robbed by gestalt rating tho, it's a great EP and Get Off to the Pain is an absolute banger Iambic Pentameter = 10, btw
for my part (rounded up ranking): 1- Pinkerton : 10 2- Blue: 10 3- Maladroit: 8.5 4- Green: 8 5- Everything will be alright in the end: 7 6- all the rest is subpar (for my taste)
White Album is tops on my Weezer list. I can't understand how anyone without the nostalgia factor (being in Junior High or High school when it came out) would think Pinkerton is even in Weezer to 5. Not even in my top Weezer 10. But then...lol...I love Pacific Daydream
@@Slyfier155 But you loved it in junior high or high school, right? The lyrics on Pinkerton aren't good for me...I much prefer say even the lyrics on Pacific Daydream...and love those songs. Peace, Love andWeezer.
I think if Weezer would have made Everything into a double album and keep the really good Everything tracks and adding the best of the Ecce Homo era tracks and you would have the best Weezer album. Also, I think you missed False Metal, arguably the worst Weezer LP ever!
Death To False Metal is a compilation album, and I think the worst is more like Raditude, The White Album, The Black Album, or Pacific Daydream. Also, good take with EWBAITE.
White over Blue is criminal. I appreciate your system, but some of the Gestalt ratings don’t make sense to me. Ranking LA Girls a 10 is laughable, especially after you attack Raditude for being cheesy. Don’t Let Go at 6.5 is robbery. I could go on, but all of these are subjective and personal preference anyway. At least you’ve got Pinkerton on top.
No, I used to hold this opinion as well. While the red album shows Weezer willingness to experiment and move out of their comfort zone while having a lot of fun songs it lacks the perfectly crafted styles & emotion of Weezer's masterpieces.
@SpellisUwU I disagree, The Angel and the One, The Greatest Man That Ever Lived, Pig, Heart Songs, and King are masterpieces imo. ESPECIALLY The Angel and the One which is the best weezer song imo. The only songs I'm not a huge fan of are Everybody Get Dangerous and Cold Dark World.
You aren't gonna bait me into watching this. Because every time someone does a weezer album ranking, its some completely braindead bs like ranking make believe as last. Despite the fact that Hurley exists. Despite the fact that MB is one of the most relevant and relatable albums they've done. This only became an opinion once zoomers started to infest their fanbase. Before this, people liked make believe
Nah Make Believe was always shit. Every Weezer Fan hated and was embaressed for Beverly Hills, the Rick Rubin production is trash, and the songs can't save this as they are medium at best. Hurley on the other hand has a lot of quirky charm.
@@trashbockmist9077 haunt you every day is one of their best songs imo but i agree, hurley has a lot of charm and personality plus actually interesting lyrics and make believe is boring and joyless
Factually incorrect statement. Make Believe has always gotten clowned on especially when it came out. In my opinion, Make Believe in last is totally valid because it is not relevant (???) or relatable unless you’re a 14 year old who’s e-girlfriend just dumped them. It is weak songwriting from a typically strong songwriting in Rivers aside from a few pretty good songs.
Currently I am obsessed with seeing other people’s opinions on Weezer. I don’t know why.
Hahahah same here 😅. Usually looking for Make Believe and Maladroit love es
@@panchojd Maladroit is very underrated. And I’m glad that someone else likes make believe. I always thought that it doesn’t deserve the hate it gets.
Seezing💀
Same, I don’t even like Weezer THAT much
@@panchojd Make Believe is my favourite weezer album honestly
only in dreams not getting 10 is the only punishable offence here
White over Blue is just fucking funny, i'm sorry.
Justice for The World Has Turned (My favourite Weezer Song)
Holiday and In the Garage in the 7s is criminal
Idk about holiday but in the garage should be 10
Finally someone who appreciates Fall Together
getchoo and holiday being only 7 is actually criminal. holiday is the most underrated song on blue, and getchoo is just a good song, even with its dark theme
Holiday is an amazing song, and almost made to be done by high school jazz choirs for the next decades. I feel the only thing that even slightly brings it down is how well it blends into Only in Dreams, so it almost feels like a small intro or interlude until the real meat of the ender.
Why are all the *good* videos on Weezer so hidden by the algorithm?? This is one of the best rankings I've seen! You make your rankings well justified and explain it all well, even if you aren't Weezer based, this video is still a gem in the community 🙌
This needs more views ❤
you're so real for this, love to see this rating systems and analysis. also pinkerton number 1, big w
Holiday at 7 was a punch to the gut, it’s one of my favorite songs from blue 😭
Same with American Gigolo’s rating, it’s my favorite maladroit song.
Also why is tired of sex a 10? The good life deserved that instead.
pink triangle and falling for you are probably my favorite of their works
The red album is so underrated on nearly every Weezer ranking video on this platform
Except for Billy Cobb, ig
y sinn delay@@honeycomblord9384
I know I love red , also why does everyone hate cold dark world so badly
My favorite thing about Weezer fans is how vastly different their opinions on songs are... like a 10/10 Foolish Father is absolutely diabolical to me lol
This video is so damn good, I love the ranking system. Subbed.
Excellent Video. Completely agree with most of this. Pinkerton also has some outstanding bonus tracks on the deluxe edition
Why the actual heck is the blue album flipped in the intro
The fact that teal goes above anything else is insane. When you got to make believe I thought you didn't even include teal which is what I would've expected.
Edit:
RUN RAVEN RUN IS A 9 OMG IM CRYYYIIINGGGG
Edit 2
LA GIRLZ IS BETTER THAN ONLY IN DREAMS UR I CANT BREATHE
The White Album is like a fusion between The Blue album and Pinkerton
i cant get over that the members are flipped on the blue album cover
Haunt you everyday should have been rated better
slave at a 6.5 hurts my soul. good list
I will not tolerate the Happy hour slander, I subscribed so I could unsubscribe
i unironically love raditude like everysong maybe im crazy but i dont think any able ot bad i love everything...except for love is the answear that song is ok..
him not including turn me round in the ranking was unfair (or is it not in the standard albums?)
Wait what’s turn me round haven’t heard of it
Great video 👍 I love averages. Also you should do Radiohead
this is a great video! I really enjoyed it. but why did you use a flipped version of the cover for the blue album?
Wow, didn’t even notice until you mentioned it. Not even sure how I stumbled upon that cover art
@@rivratesstuff5799it is generally difficult to find a high quality of the original blue album cover
i genuinely love you for putting white album over blue and giving la girlz 10/10
maladroit is my favourite album at a 9.65
Okay, but how is holiday at the bottom of the blue album
holiday isnt my favorite but isnt that bad to be honest i think no one else is the most mid track on blue
My Top 5: Pinkerton > Blue > OK Human > Make Believe > Maldroit
My top 5: White> ok human > SZNZ > Blue > Pinkerton
I like the black album and I think Byzantine and Too many thoughts in my head are underappreciated
I must be weird. I love the Black album. Don’t understand the hate for it. It’s my 5th favorite weezer album. 🤷🏻♂️
Pretty good rating, Autumn was kinda robbed by gestalt rating tho, it's a great EP and Get Off to the Pain is an absolute banger
Iambic Pentameter = 10, btw
la mancha screwjob at 3 and feels like summer at 6.5 is fucking ludicrous
I still have nightmares about raditude
Great job mate !
This is so in depth I love it! I love love white, but not sure about it being #2
Excellent video
for my part (rounded up ranking):
1- Pinkerton : 10
2- Blue: 10
3- Maladroit: 8.5
4- Green: 8
5- Everything will be alright in the end: 7
6- all the rest is subpar (for my taste)
great ratings for the albums, i agree with the placement of the top 5
White Album is tops on my Weezer list. I can't understand how anyone without the nostalgia factor (being in Junior High or High school when it came out) would think Pinkerton is even in Weezer to 5. Not even in my top Weezer 10. But then...lol...I love Pacific Daydream
It's my personal favourite, because it's just so raw and honest unlike a lot of their attempts at pop music
@@Slyfier155 But you loved it in junior high or high school, right? The lyrics on Pinkerton aren't good for me...I much prefer say even the lyrics on Pacific Daydream...and love those songs. Peace, Love andWeezer.
What about death to false metal???
its a b sides
And yet another person ranking Pinkerton at #1. What a surprise 🤓.
What's your #1?
where would you put death to false metal, if it were considered an album and not a compilation?
BUTTERFLY ISN'T ATLEAST A 9?!?!
hell yeah
ye
back to the shack being a 6.5 and other bad takes made me unlike the vid
Pinkerton is the best album. Plain and simple… BUT TIRED OF SEX IS NOT THE BEST SONG ON IT, IT’S GENUINELY THE WORSE (great video 👍)
The Best Is Across The Sea Imo
My Top 5: Pinkerton > Blue > OK Human > Make Believe > Maldroit
you should do one on jeff rosenstock
You should do this with Radiohead
I think if Weezer would have made Everything into a double album and keep the really good Everything tracks and adding the best of the Ecce Homo era tracks and you would have the best Weezer album. Also, I think you missed False Metal, arguably the worst Weezer LP ever!
Death To False Metal is a compilation album, and I think the worst is more like Raditude, The White Album, The Black Album, or Pacific Daydream. Also, good take with EWBAITE.
here comes the rain being rated so low hurts lol
you act like all my friends are insects wasn't a banger bruh
thank god for girls is about four points too low but otherwise you cooked
If Maladroit is their most underrated (and I agree), the White album has to be their most overrated.
I agree
Cant agree more with you
White over Blue is criminal. I appreciate your system, but some of the Gestalt ratings don’t make sense to me. Ranking LA Girls a 10 is laughable, especially after you attack Raditude for being cheesy. Don’t Let Go at 6.5 is robbery. I could go on, but all of these are subjective and personal preference anyway. At least you’ve got Pinkerton on top.
Teal album is bottom of the list for me
Hot Take: Red Album is tied for being their best album along with Blue
🥓&🫘
No, I used to hold this opinion as well. While the red album shows Weezer willingness to experiment and move out of their comfort zone while having a lot of fun songs it lacks the perfectly crafted styles & emotion of Weezer's masterpieces.
@SpellisUwU I disagree, The Angel and the One, The Greatest Man That Ever Lived, Pig, Heart Songs, and King are masterpieces imo. ESPECIALLY The Angel and the One which is the best weezer song imo. The only songs I'm not a huge fan of are Everybody Get Dangerous and Cold Dark World.
make believe*
1. Blue
2. Pinkerton
true they are untouchable but i do think pinkerton is betyer
in the mall is unironically fire
personally, i skip tastes like pain every chance i get. it’s honestly unlistenable
now do Twenty One Pilots
nice
1. Hurley
Everything else
Hurley is their worst album, tf you on about
@@TheAbandonedAccount7nothing can beat raditude in how garbage it is
you do it to yourself
You aren't gonna bait me into watching this. Because every time someone does a weezer album ranking, its some completely braindead bs like ranking make believe as last. Despite the fact that Hurley exists. Despite the fact that MB is one of the most relevant and relatable albums they've done. This only became an opinion once zoomers started to infest their fanbase. Before this, people liked make believe
i am a hurley defender and you hurt me deeply. pacific daydream should be last tho.
Nah Make Believe was always shit. Every Weezer Fan hated and was embaressed for Beverly Hills, the Rick Rubin production is trash, and the songs can't save this as they are medium at best. Hurley on the other hand has a lot of quirky charm.
@@trashbockmist9077 haunt you every day is one of their best songs imo but i agree, hurley has a lot of charm and personality plus actually interesting lyrics and make believe is boring and joyless
@@Luesverse Yeah that song is great especially the demo version. (Lets say Top Tier medium to save my argument ;) )
Factually incorrect statement. Make Believe has always gotten clowned on especially when it came out. In my opinion, Make Believe in last is totally valid because it is not relevant (???) or relatable unless you’re a 14 year old who’s e-girlfriend just dumped them. It is weak songwriting from a typically strong songwriting in Rivers aside from a few pretty good songs.
Do NOT let bro cook again 😂